Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Bioscience 0115091. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. AGENDA Bioscience Land Protection Advisory Board January I 5,2009 city of Palm Beach Gardens 10500 N. Military Trail 1:3o p.m. Roll Call Approval of September 18,2008 Minutes comprehensive Plan status - City of Riviera Beach Town of Lake Park Scripps, Max Planck and Briger updates (by Shannon LaROCClUe-BaaS) BrandinglMarketing SUbCOrYImittee update (Lisa De La Rionda) update from BDB (Kelly Smallridge) update State Funding corp. (Jenni Garrison) New Business scripps Dedication FebrUarV 26-28,2009 Public comment Next Meeting - March 19,2009, Town of Lake Park 2009 Meeting schedule attached Adjournment FINAL AGENDA AND MINUTES BIOSCIENCE LAND PROTECTION ADVISORY BOARD TOWN OF JUPITER COMMUNITY CENTER THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 18,2008 CALL TO ORDER: September 18,2008, at 1:30 pm., in the Town of Jupiter Community Center - 210 Military Trail, Jupiter, FL 33458. 1. Roll Call: Present: Karen Marcus, Palm Beach County Commission (Chair); Karen Golonka, Mayor, Town of Jupiter (Vice-Chair); Desca DuBois, Mayor, Town of Lake Park; Dawn Pardo, City of Riviera Beach; William Albury, Mayor, Town of Mangonia Park; Robert Friedman, Town of Jupiter; David Levy, Vice Mayor, City of Palm Beach Gardens; John R. Smith & Jenni Garrison, Governor's Appointees; Joe Russo, City of Palm Beach Gardens arrived approximately at 1 :40 p.m. Absent: Addie Greene, Palm Beach Commission; Ed Daly. Vice Mayor, Town of Lake Park; Cedrick Thomas, Chair, City of Riviera Beach; Peggy Cook, Town of Mangonia Park. Staff and others present: Robert Banks, Assistant County Attorney; Andrew Duffell, Senior Vice President, Business Development Board; Jeff Gagnon, City of Riviera Beach; Shannon LaRocque-Baas, Assistant County Administrator; Stephen Mayer, Senior Planner, City of Palm Beach Gardens; Patrick Sullivan, Town of Lake Park; Trish Weaver, Senior County Commission Administrative Assistant; Wendy Harrison, Vice-Mayor, Town of Jupiter; John Sickler, Town of Jupiter; Dann Bird, Town of Jupiter; Stephanie Thobum, Town of Jupiter, Janet Murphy, Town of Jupiter. 2. Approval of Minutes: MOTION to approve the May 15, 2008 advisory board meeting minutes. Motion by Mayor Golonka, seconded by Councilwomen DuBois, and carried unanimously. Bioscience Advisoly Board September 18,2008 Page 1 3. Comprehensive Plan Status - City of Riviera Beach Town of Lake Park City Councilwomen Dawn Pardo, City of Riviera Beach presented an update to the City’s comprehensive plan and noted they would be transmitting in November. Lake Park advised they transmitted and were adopting on October 15,2008. (CLERK NOTE: Councilman Joseph Russo, City of Palm Beach Gardens joined the meeting.) 4. Scnpps Update Ms. Shannon LaRocque-Baas, Assistant County Administrator updated the Board on the Florida Atlantic University (FAU) Scripps campus construction; the Max Planck lease; the Briger property and the overall plan for the JupitedPalm Beach Gardens area. 5. BrandinglMarketing Subcommittee Update Ms. Lisa De La Rionda was not present at the meeting. Chair Marcus suggested continuing the update to the next meeting. 6. Update from BDB Mr. Andrew Duffell. Senior Vice President, Business Development Board highlighted the June - San Diego meeting; the Life science newsletter; the BioFlorida meeting and the Southeast Bio conference. Mr. Duffell explained TyraTech, Inc. would not be making any decisions regarding funding or relocation until December 2008. He mentioned that the Economic Development Fund Advisory Board had made a recommendation to fund an incubator/internship program with Palm Beach Community College. Chair Marcus felt the Economic Development Fund Advisory Board was doing a great job. Mayor Karen Golonka, Town of Jupiter, asked Mr. Duffell if the effects of the market were being felt in the bioscience field regarding venture capital. Mr. Duffell felt the flow of committed money had slowed. Mr. Duffell mentioned the Max Planck Science Tunnel coming to the Palm Beach Science Museum for January -March 2009 exhibition. Bioscience Advisory Board September 18.2008 Page 2 6. 7. a. 9. 10. 11. Update from BDB Chair Karen Marcus, Palm Beach County Commission discussed the First Industrial - Florida Research Park. She said the research park was entertaining the idea of having a metal car smashing firm in residence. She felt this would limit the potential for bioscience firms in the area. She suggested the Board write the new owners regarding this issue. MOTION to approve drafting a letter to reflect the views of the Board with concerns regarding bioscience firms and heavy metal firms in the First Industrial - Florida Research Park. Motion by Councilor Friedman, seconded by Mayor William Albury, and carried unanimously. Update State Funding Corporation Ms. Jenni Garrison gave an update on Torrey Pines and Scripps. She distributed three documents to the Board regarding Scripps annual report; Florida 2008 Summer Student Teacher Interns pamphlet and the Scripps Discovers newsletter for Fall 2008. New Business Mayor Karen Golonka recognized Vice-Mayor Wendy Harrison, Town of Jupiter as an attendee for this Board meeting. Public Comment - None Next Meeting Commissioner Marcus suggested not having a meeting in December as the meeting conflicted with the FAC Legislative Conference but plan on the next regular scheduled meeting on January 75,2008 at Palm Beach Gardens. Consensus of Board agreed. Adjournment At 225 p.m., the meeting adjourned. Bioscience Advisory Board September 18,2008 Page 3 Scripps Ribbon Cutting Plan Draft as of 12/18/08 Event Dates: Thursday, February 26; Friday, February 27; Saturday, February 28 Location: 130 Scripps Way, Jupiter 800 people sent Save The Date, including members of PBC Commission, business, local government leaders (PBG, Jupiter, staff of Scripps Florida (290 people + 1 guest each), State delegation from the region, community leaders, Scripps Florida Funding, FAU Frank Brogan, Chancellor of Jupiter campus, heads of PBCC, Miami, FSU, UCF, Enterprise Florida, BioFlorida, Torrey Pines, Burnham, biotech firms, members of CA faculty, Max Planck, heads of pharmaceuticals, officials from School District and Scripps interns. Thursday 10 AM until noon - Ribbon cutting and official opening at FAU Presentations to be held under a tent Bottled water will be available Jupiter High School Band to provide anthem Program speakers: Dr. Richard Lerner John Moores, Chairman of the Board Trustees Governor Charlie Crist Governor Jeb Bush PBC Commission Chairman Jeff Koons Ribbon cutting photo op with these 5 people, private lab tour for 5 VIPs, followed by PBC Commissioners tour. (Keith to arrange) Following ribbon cutting, luncheon at PGA National -organized by Philanthropy Department. lnvitees are separate. All Commissioners to be invited. Friday - Scientific conference at facility, Scripps board meeting at Breakers Scientific presentation -by Scripps invitation in the auditorium Saturday 10 AM - 2 PM; Education day for students and families -working with PBC School District Interactive videos and exhibits for middle school students, passes for the day to be distributed to middle school students. Lawn displays to be available; this is not an open house. AS OF SEPTEMBER 30,2008: Scripps Florida employed 262 people and has received over $109 million in research support from non- state sources. Over 70 patent applications have been filed by Scripps Florida and over 45 license agreements have been entered into. Scripps Florida Funding Corporation disbursed 5203,871,213.37 to Scripps Florida since 2004. Of that amount, $189,292,750 is principal amount and $14,578,463.37 is interest earned, minus SFFCs annual operating budget. A FEW INSTITUTIONAL MILESTONES: On September 2,2008, TSRl announced that it has been awarded more than $80 million by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) to expand the work of The Scripps Research Molecular Screening Center. TSRl will direct nearly $52 million of this grant to Scripps Florida, which will use high throughput screening robotics to screen discoveries from laboratories in both La Jolla and Jupiter. The goal is to uncover 'proof of concept' molecules that could be useful in developing new treatments for a large number of human diseases. The Scripps Center is one of only four such large centers nationwide. In February 2008, the National Institutes of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (NINDS) awarded a $7.6 million multi-year grant to Scripps Florida scientists to develop the next generation of kinase inhibitors to treat Parkinson's disease. Philip LoGrasso, Scripps Research associate professor and senior director for drug discovery at Scripps Florida, is leading the project as principal investigator. Miami physician, businessman and philanthropist Phillip Frost and his wife, Patricia Frost, an ardent supporter of education and the arts, have donated $1 million to Scripps Florida. In recognition of the Frosts' donation, the foyer of the drug discovery building will be named the Frost Lobby. In 2008, a record number of new graduate students selected Scripps Florida as their school of choice to pursue their doctoral degrees. Of the eight new students, four came from Florida universities and colleges - the University of Miami; Florida State University; the University of Florida; and the New College of Florida. Scripps Florida established the Department of Metabolism and Aging and named Dr. Roy Smith as chair of the new department and in May 2008, Scripps Florida established the Environmental Health and Safety (EH&S) Department. Scripps Florida was awarded a $110,000 grant to provide Palm Beach County middle and high school teachers with a summer program of instruction in basic science and advanced laboratory-based techniques and give them special portable teaching units for future classroom use. A FEW SCIENTIFIC HIGHLIGHTS Scripps Florida Scientists Find New Clue to Alzheimer's Disease Progression: Scientists from Scripps Florida showed for the first time that a specialized form of RNA is directly linked to increased levels of amyloid plaque in the brains of Alzheimer's patients. Bicoastal Collaboration at Scripps Research Uncovers Novel Activators of Key Cell Receptors: Working in close collaboration, scientists at The Scripps Research Institute in La Jolla, California, and in Jupiter, Florida, identified several new molecules that activate cell receptors responsible for the regulation of a number of key physiological processes. The molecules have the potential to advance drug development. Scripps Florida Scientists Find New Clue to Alzheimer's Disease Progression: Scientists from Scripps Florida showed for the first time that a specialized form of RNA is directly linked to increased levels of amyloid plaque in the brains of Alzheimer's patients. Scripps Florida Scientists Discover New Gene Linked to Fragile X Syndrome: Scientists at Scripps Florida discovered a new gene involved in Fragile X syndrome, a condition that often shares many symptoms of autism. The discovery may lead to new tests or treatments for several neurological disorders, including autism. Highlights?om the Scripps Florida Funding Corporation annual report, dated 9/30/2008. The Economic Impacts of Scripps Florida on Florida's Economy October 1,2007 - September 30,2008 Prepared by the Business Development Board of Palm Beach County, Inc. for the Scripps Florida Funding Corporation Business Development Board of Palm Beach County, Inc. November 2008 The Economic Impacts of Scripps Florida on Florida's Economy October 1,2007 - September 30,2008 Introduction This analysis is designed to fulfill the requirements of Subsection 14(e) of the 2008 Scripps Florida Funding Corporation Annual Report to the State of Florida Governor and Legislature. Purpose: Estimate the economic impacts of the activities of the Scripps Florida facility on the State of Florida during its fieh fiscal year of operation that covers the period October 1, 2007 to September 30,2008. The analyses for the previous four fiscal years were conducted by Enterprise Florida, Inc. (EFI) and this analysis will follow a similar format as that established by EFI to address Subsection 14(e) of the Scripps Florida Funding Corporation's (SFFC) Annual Report to the Florida Governor and Legislature. This analysis was conducted by the staff of the Business Development Board of Palm Beach County, Inc. (BDB) at the request of SFFC. It is based on information and data provided to the BDB from SFFC and uses the IMPIAN economic impact model, as was used in prior analyses by EFI. The purpose of this analysis was to estimate the quantifiable economic impacts of Scripps Florida's activities in the State of Florida during its fifth fiscal year in operation, based on the expenditures made by Scripps Florida or its partners, Palm Beach County and Florida Atlantic University. This analysis makes no attempt to project future economic impacts or benefits on the State of Florida or Palm Beach County, nor does it attempt to estimate or project non-quantifiable benefits or impacts to Florida or Palm Beach County. As previously stated, this report follows a similar format as the one established by EFI in the previous four analyses. As such, this report will include sections that provide information on economic impact analysis and the model, IMPIAN, used to estimate impacts, the methodology used to conduct this analysis, results of the IMPIAN model, and a brief description of the impacts that this analysis does not attempt to estimate. Economic Impact Analysis Using IMPLAN Economic impact analysis estimates the changes in economic output (gross domestic product), employment, personal income (labor compensation and proprietors' income), property income (rents), and tax revenues that result from changes in demand for products or services in a given study area (referred to as an event). Impacts can be measured for zip codes, counties, states, or the entire country. Page 2 Business Development Board of Palm Beach County, Inc. November 2008 Due to the importance of Scripps Florida to the State of Florida, as being a world class research institute that has positioned Florida as an emerging focal point for the life sciences, this analysis will estimate the economic impacts to the entire State of Florida resulting from Scripps Florida operations. However, the majority of the benefits from Scripps Florida are likely concentrated in Palm Beach County and the surrounding region. The IMPlAN model is a recognized industry leader in the United States and is used by many organizations from federal agencies to private consultants for economic impact analysis. This analysis uses many of the default settings and features of the standard IMPIAN model, In accordance with the circumstances stipulated by Scripps Florida and in keeping with the format of prior analyses by EFI, this analysis reports the economic impacts of Scripps Florida in three different categories. First, the IMPIAN model quantities four categories of impacts: employment; personal income; economic output (gross domestic product); and tax revenues. Employment refers to the number of full-time jobs created in the study area due to the presence of Scripps Florida. Personal lncome includes all forms of labor compensation and proprietors' income that are injected into the economy of the study area as a result of Scripps Florida. Economic Output (Gross Domestic Product) is the increased amount of total economic output in the study area that results from the change in employment and value added created by the presence of Scripps. Lastly, tax revenues refer to the additional fiscal revenues generated by state and local governments (such as sales taxes, property taxes, and other excise taxes and fees) resulting from the increased economic activity due to Scripps. Second, there are three rounds of effects that are analyzed. Each round is classified as a separate category or effect. The first round produces the direct effects, which include the economic impacts to the four categories stated above that result from the set up and operations of Scripps Florida itself, such as the number of jobs created by Scripps to work in the new facility or the change in employment by the companies hired by Scripps to provide goods or services, such as construction of the site. Next come the indirect effects, which include interindustry changes in demand resulting from the construction and operation of Scripps or the goods and services required by companies hired by Scripps for design and construction. Lastly, the induced effects are measured, which are the increases in economic activity stemming from the expenditures by the households of the employees hired by Scripps or the companies used for designing and construction of the Scripps facility or businesses indirectly influenced by the presence of Scripps. Page 3 . Business Development Board of Palm Beach County, Inc. November 2008 The presence of direct effects, indirect effects, and induced effects result from what is referred to as the multiplier effect. The multiplier effect occurs, because every time a purchase is made in any sector of the economy, additional spending is created through direct, indirect, and induced effects. This happens over and over many times. Essentially, when one person or company spends money, it enables another person or company to spend money and so on, creating a chain of new spending by other people or companies. The third and last category will distinguish between the Scripps Florida's Operational Impacts and Facility-Related Impacts. Scripps FIoridak Operational Impacts. These impacts result from the operations of Scripps Florida during its fifth fiscal year. The operational impacts include Scripps payroll expenditures (for scientists and professional and support staff), expenditures for laboratory equipment, office supplies, information technology, utilities, and various other business services and operational expenses. Facility-Related Impacts. These impacts include all the economic activity due to expenditures on designing and constructing the facilities housing Scripps Florida. Those expenditures are made by Scripps Florida or by partners on behalf of Scripps Florida. The partners of Scripps Florida include Palm Beach County, Florida Atlantic University, and the State of Florida. Numerous activities are accounted for by the expenditures in this category, including: land surveys; environmental impact studies; site preparation; construction; architectural services; and various other professional and support services. Facility-Related impacts are included in this analysis because they are a result of Scripps' presence. However, once Scripps Florida has completed its permanent facility, these impacts will most likely diminish. Methodology The results of an economic impact analysis are reliant upon the primary data and assumptions used in the model. In this analysis, the BDB has relied on data provided by the Scripps Florida Funding Corporation. The data provided include all known expenditures by Scripps Florida and its partners (Palm Beach County and Florida Atlantic University) during the fiscal year October 1, 2007 to September 30,2008. All expenditures data obtained were input into the IMPLAN model, with the appropriate NAICS- based IMPLAN industry codes for each line item expenditure. The line items were then aggregated based on their features to achieve the quantifiable impacts mentioned in the previous section. Page 4 Business Development Board of Palm Beach County, Inc. November 2008 No data on actual job creation by Scripps Florida's activities were provided, and therefore no employment data were input into the IMPLAN model. However, expenditures for salaries and benefits were provided by Scripps, and these were included in the model using the IMPLAN industry code for payroll compensation, which allowed the model to estimate direct employment levels throughout the fiscal year. Therefore the estimated employment impacts generated by IMPLAN should be interpreted as the average annual full-time employment, and may in fact not be the actual employment of Scripps Florida or any other entity affected by the presence of Scripps at any time during the fiscal year analyzed. Since this analysis is focused on the single fiscal year of October 1, 2007 to September 30, 2008, the IMPLAN model does not attempt to differentiate between recurring and one-time impacts. As stated previously, any jobs or other impacts associated with the construction and design of Scripps permanent facility will likely diminish or disappear entirely once the facility is completed and Scripps moves into the facilities. Additionally, impacts associated with the operations of the Scripps facility can recur each year. However, this study is only concerned with impacts in fiscal year 2007-08. This analysis relied upon the default assumptions built into the IMPLAN model. This analysis used the assumptions in the IMPLAN model to determine the amount of expenditures and activity that affected the State of Florida due to the presence of Scripps Florida by estimating the amount of goods and sewices that are demanded from domestic sources versus sources in other states. The data used for the IMPLAN model's assumptions are derived from US Federal Government databases. Fiscal impacts were also estimated by the IMPLAN model, which differentiates between federal and state and local tax revenues. This analysis maintains the state and local tax revenue impacts established in the previous four analyses by EFI. In previous analyses, EFI assumed that all tax revenues obtained through vehicle licensing fees go to the State of Florida, whereas property taxes are paid to local governments. The sales tax receipts are split between the state and local governments, where the State of Florida receives six percent and the local governments receive anything above that due to local options. The IMPLAN model does not differentiate the split in sales tax, so it is possible that the amount of sales tax collected is overstated for the State of Florida and understated for the counties and municipalities. Page 5 Business Development Board of Palm Beach County, Inc. November 2008 The primary expenditures data provided by Scripps Florida Funding Corporation (SFFC) for use in the IMPIAN model are provided in the table below. FAU Site Work $10,590 FAU Construction $77,404,719 FAU Sofl Costs $5,755,230 FPL Relocation $1 05,620 Subtotal Facilities-Related $83,276,159 Owrational: Scientist Salaries 8 Benefits Supplies Scientific Equipment External Services Salaries 8 Benefits (non-scientist) Professional Services Supplies Purchased Services Business Meetings Subscriptions Other Allocations from California Facilities (Insurance, Utilities, Maintenance) Other Capital Expenditures Administrative ExDenSeS Recovered from Third Parties (IDC) 58,908,630 54219,760 52,905,851 51,101,640 $4,956,547 5592,630 $282,013 5591,730 $265,110 $82.770 $7,888 $1,705,630 $4,920,099 $76,826 44,375,878 .. btotal Operational I $26,241,246 tal Scripps-Related Expenditures in FY 2007-2008 $1 09,517.405 I Source Scnpps F!onda iuodmg Corporalion IMPLAN Model Results The table below summarizes the results of the IMPLAN economic impact model that was run for impacts to the State of Florida due to the presence of Scripps Florida in Palm Beach County, I Scripps Florida, SFFCs fiscal year 2007-2008. The results that follow illustrate the total economic based on the data provided by the SFFC. , I Page 6 . Business Development Board of Palm Beach County, Inc. November 2008 Type of Impact Employment Impact Facility- Related Operational Facility-Related Operational Facility-Related Operational Tax Revenues Facility-Related Operational State of Florida Local Governments (County 8 Municipal) PsfsonaI Income Impan Ou(put(Gnuu Domestic ProdUctJ Breakdown of Tax Revenues Behveen State 8 Local GovY Note: The estimated totals may not add up exactly due to rounding off IC 692 75 237,825,837 $34,237,406 $3,588.431 51W.063.815 $83,276,162 $16,787,853 $1,692,825 $757.441 $935.383 223 31 $12,830,161 $1 1,387,800 $1,462,561 133,237,596 $29,221,514 $4,016,081 51,338,691 $1,182.424 $156.287 276 30 $11,716,171 $10,553,313 $1,162,858 535,194,603 $31,701,458 $3,493,145 $2,31f,923 $2,082,275 $229,442 1.191 137 S62,372,1rO $56,158,319 $6,213,850 sisa,r~s,or4 $144,199,134 $24,296,880 $5.343,438 $4,022,140 $1.321.092 $630.391 I $547,4501 $980,1231 $2,157,964 I the nearest whole dollar or employee. Each of the impact types are summarized below. fmp/oyment Impact. The presence of Scripps Florida assisted in sustaining an estimated 1,327 jobs statewide. It is important to note that those jobs were not necessarily created during the PI 2007-2008, where some may have carried over from previous fiscal years, while some were also created during the fiscal year of the study. Therefore, it would not be correct to add results from previous fiscal years' analyses to this one. Direct. This analysis reports the total direct impacts, and also differentiates between the facility-related impacts and the operational impacts. During the SFFC's Fiscal Year 2007-2008, Scripps Florida had a total direct employment impact of 767 full-time jobs, 692 of which were due to the facility-related activities (construction, planning, design, etc.) and 75 were due to the operations of Scripps Florida. Indirect and Induced. An additional 561 jobs were supported throughout Florida as a result of indirect and induced effects, of which 499 were from facility-related activities and 61 were from Scripps Florida's operations. Income Impact. The total personal income impact of Scripps in the SFFC's fifth fiscal year was $62,372,170. Direct. The activities of Scripps Florida and the companies it hired to design and construct their facility were directly responsible for contributing to an influx of $37,825,837 of personal income into Florida's economy. Indirect and Induced. The multiplier effect led to an additional $24,546,332 in personal income in the Florida economy. Page 7 . Business Development Board of Palm Beach County, Inc. November 2008 Output (Gross Domestic Product) Impact. Scripps Florida added $168,496,014 to Florida's gross domestic product (GDP). Direct. The operational activities of Scripps Florida and the companies utilized by Scripps for construction and design of their facility directly contributed to adding $100,063,815 to Florida's GDP. Indirect and Induced. The multiplier effect led to the addition of $68,432,199 to Florida's GDP. Fiscal Impact. The total estimated fiscal revenues to State and local governments due to the presence of Scripps Florida in its fifth fiscal year amounted to $5,343,438. Direct. The operational activities of Scripps Florida and the companies utilized by Scripps for construction and design of their facility directly contributed to an estimated $1,692,825 in tax revenues to state and local governments. Indirect andinduced. The multiplier effect from the activities of Scripps Florida and the companies hired by Scripps led to an additional $3,650,614 in estimated tax revenues for state and local governments. The approximate breakdown between estimated tax revenues for the State of Florida and the local governments was: State Taxes. The estimated tax revenues that went to the State of Florida as a result of Scripps Florida were $3,185,473. Local Taxes. The estimated tax revenues that went to the local governments (county and municipal) in Florida as a result of Scripps Florida were $2,157,964. Economic Impacts Outside of the Model This analysis has focused on the economic impacts of Scripps Florida on the economy of the State of Florida during SFFC's fifth fiscal year of activities, October 1, 2007 - September 30, 2008. It is important to note that the IMPLAN model can only estimate the quantifiable economic impacts, such as employment, personal income, output, and tax revenues, to a geographical area based on changes in demand for goods or services caused by an event. Therefore, the model is not capable of measuring the qualitative economic benefits of an event, such as the presence of Scripps Florida, that could positively affect the economy of Florida. While the qualitative benefits are important, they may only become evident after a number of years or may influence quantifiable impacts in future analyses. Page 6 Bioscience Land Protection Advisory Board 2009 Meeting Schedule January 15, 2009 March 19, 2009 'May 22, 2009 Re-organizational Meeting July 16, 2009 September 17,2009 Palm Beach County November 19,2009 Town of Jupiter City of Palm Beach Gardens Town of Lake Park Town of Mangonia Park City of Riviera Beach Lunch starts at 1:00 PM Meetings start at 1:30 PM Revised Lk. 2008 BIOSCIENCE LAND PROTECTION ADVISORY BOARD MEETING JANUARY 15.2009 DATE SIGN-IN SHEET PLEASE PRINT MUNlClPALl7Y NAME TITLE ClTy OF PALM BEACH GARDENS BIOSCIENCE LAND PROTECTION ADVISORY BOARD MEETING JANUARY 15,2009 DATE SIGN-IN SHEET PLEASE PRINT A NAME n MUNICIPALITY TITLE GIN OF PALM BEACH GARDENS