Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda AIPP 042010AGENDA CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD TUESDAY, APRIL 20, 2010 AT 5:30 P.M. COUNCIL CHAMBERS I. CALL TO ORDER II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE III. ROLL CALL: ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD Regular Members Alternates Diane Cappella Meriel "Honey" Bryan 15t Alternate Jennifer O'Brien Paul Kaufman 2nd Alternate David Porter (Vice Chair) Cable Neuhaus (Chair) Dianne Sacchetti Susan Tornabene Mark Giuliani Also in attendance: Allyson Black, Resource Manager /Staff Liaison IV. ADDITIONS, DELETIONS, MODIFICATIONS V. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. February 16, 2010 AIPP Meeting 2. March 15, 2010 AIPP /RAB Joint Meeting 3. March 16, 2010 AIPP Meeting VI. ITEMS BY COUNCIL LIAISON VII. ITEMS BY STAFF LIAISON VIII. OLD BUSINESS IX. NEW BUSINESS 1. DOWNTOWN AT THE GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES - AIPP- 10 -03- 000026 RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL X. COMMENTS BY THE PUBLIC XI. COMMENTS BY THE BOARD XII. ADJOURNMENT 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD REGULAR MEETING FEBRUARY 16, 2010 The regular meeting was called to order at 5:32 p.m. by Chair Cable Neuhaus. I. CALL TO ORDER II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE III. ROLL CALL PRESENT: Chair Cable Neuhaus, Vice Chair David Porter, Diane ,Cappella (arrived 5:36 p.m.), Jennifer O'Brien, Dianne Sacchetti, Meriel Bryan (1st alternate sitting for Susan Tornabene). ABSENT: Susan Tornabene, Mark Giuliani. "r ALSO PRESENT: City Attorney R. Max Lohman; Growth`'Managemept Administrator, Staff Liaison Kara Irwin; Resource Manager, Alternate Staff I iaison °��Allyson BTaw Planner Kathryn Wilson. IV. ADDITIONS, DELETIONS, MODIFICATIONS None. V. APPROVAL OF MINUTES' David Porter made a motion for approval of the October 20, 2009 and November 17, 2009 minutes. VI. ITEMS BY COUNCIL LIAISON None. VII. ITEMS BY STAFF'TIAISON Growth Management °Administrator, Staff Liaison Kara Irwin reported that City Attorney R. Max Lohman will tie advising the Art in Public _Places Advisory Board regarding the Bus Shelter Selection Committed recorrimendations due 'io the passing of Attorney Robert Rosillo. s F VIII. OLD BUSINESS Lake Catherine RFP r Growt Management Admistra h' m tor, Staff Liaison Kara Irwin reported that a joint public workshop of the Art in Publik Places Advisory Board and Parks and Recreation Advisory Board will be held pp,March 15, 201. and described the public workshop process. Public Comm -Ont: None. ' 6 IX. NEW BUSINESS PUBLIC WORKSHOPS 1. DOWNTOWN AT"THE GARDENS Presented by: Donaldson Hearing, Cotleur and Hearing; Kevin Berman, Downtown at the Gardens; Kate Blakeley, Carousel Works, Inc. Discussion ensued. Public Comment: None. 2. 9/11 MEMORIAL ART PLAZA Staff Presentation: Planner Kathryn Wilson. Presented bv: Artist Mark Fuller. Public Comment: Pat Hughey, 9120 Reed Drive, Palm Beach Gardens. ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD PAGE 1 02 °16 °10 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 David Porter made a motion designating Chair Cable Neuhaus to be the contact person for artist Mark Fuller. Diane Cappella seconded. Motion passed 6 -0. RFP 2009 -010 ARTISTIC BUS SHELTERS Staff Presentation: Growth Management Administrator, Staff Liaison Kara Irwin. Discussion ensued. David Porter made a motion to accept the Bus Shelter Selection Committee recommendation to the Art in Public Places Advisory Board to reject all proposals and that the same recommendation be made to City Council. .; Diane Cappella seconded. Motion passed 6 -0. David Porter made a motion to enter into direct negotiati highest ranking artist, Mark Fuller, to go forward with designs for both PGA Boul Trail. Dianne Sacchetti seconded. Motion passed 6 -0. David Porter made a motion in favor of Chair Cable Neuhaus presenting theA_postion of the Art in Public Places Advisory Board to City Council Diane Cappella seconded. Motion passed 6 -0. X. COMMENTS BY THE PUBLIC'' Alissa Waite, 522 Sunset Road, West Pala} XI. COMMENTS BY THE BOARD Cable Newhaus, David Porter. ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD 02.16.10 of this page intentionally left blank.) PAGE 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 XII. ADJOURNMENT David Porter made a motion for adjournment. Meriel Bryan seconded. Motion passed, 6 -0. The meeting adjourned at 7:05 p.m. The next regular meeting will be held March 16, 2010. APPROVED AT' Donna M. Cannon Municipal Services Coordinator NOTE: These minutes are prepared in compliance with 286.011 F.S. and are not verbatim transcripts of the meeting. A verbatim audio recording is available from the Office of the City Clerk. All referenced attachments on file in the Office of the City Clerk. ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD 02.16 °10 PAGE 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD REGULAR MEETING MARCH 16, 2010 The regular meeting was called to order at 5:43 p.m. by Chair Cable Neuhaus. I. CALL TO ORDER II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE III. ROLL CALL PRESENT: Chair Cable Neuhaus, Vice Chair David Porter, Jennifer O'Brien, Dianne Sacchetti, Susan Tornabene. ABSENT: Diane Cappella, Mark Giuliani. ALSO PRESENT: Resource Manager, Alternate Staff Liaison Allyson Black; Planner Kathryn Wilson. IV. ADDITIONS, DELETIONS, MODIFICATIONS None. V. APPROVAL OF MINUTES None. VI. ITEMS BY COUNCIL LIAISON None. VII. ITEMS BY STAFF LIAISON Alternate Staff Liaison Allyson Black Downtown at the Gardens planned car, Thursday, March 18, 2010 City Council r. VIII. OLD BUSINESS None. IX. NEW BUSINESS 1. THE POINTE Public Comment: N 2. CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS 9/1 AIPP- 10- 02- 000025 Staff Presentation: Planner Kathrvn Wilson. on Legends of the Gardens art lighting and Bus Shelters project will be heard at the Kyle Jones, Project Manager, Stiles. Presented by: Artist Mark Fuller. Discussion ensued. David Porter made a motion to accept the design as presented with comments to City Council. Dianne Sacchetti seconded. Motion passed 5 -0. X. COMMENTS BY THE PUBLIC None. XI. COMMENTS BY THE BOARD None. ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD 03.1610 PAGE 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 X11. ADJOURNMENT David Porter made a motion for adjournment. Dianne Sacchetti seconded. Motion passed, 5 -0. The meeting adjourned at 6:45 p.m. The next regular meeting will be held April 20, 2010. APPROVED AT' Donna M. Cannon Municipal Services Coordinator NOTE: These minutes are prepared in compliance with 286.011 F.S. and are not verbatim transcripts of the meeting. A verbatim audio recording is available from the Office of the City Clerk. All referenced attachments on file in the Office of the City Clerk. ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD 03.16.10 PAGE 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD AND PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD JOINT MEETING MARCH 15, 2010 The joint meeting was called to order at 6:10 p.m. by City Clerk Patricia Snider. I. CALL TO ORDER II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE III. ROLL CALL PRESENT: Art in Public Places Advisory Board (AIPP) David Porter, Jennifer O'Brien, Susan Tornabene, Meriel Br5 Cappella). Parks and Recreation Advisor Board (RAB) Chair Tory Buc Jim Amsler, William Sonnenreich. ABSENT: Diane Cappella (AIPP), Mark Giuliani (AIPP) Nass (RAB), Arnie Schneider (RAB), Ernest Volonte (RAB). ALSO PRESENT: Growth Management Administrator, Division Director, Staff Liaison Mike Kelly. IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Timothy Frohling made a motion to approve the December' William Sonnenreich seconded. Motion passed 9 -0. V. PUBLIC WORKSHOP — LAKE CATHERINE;HIS' Cable Neuhaus and Tory Buckley introduced the project, f and goals. Cable Neuhaus explained the funding for Art in P VI. COMMENTS BY THE PUBLIC kley, Vice Chz Dianne Saccl Staff Liaison Uhaus, Vice Chair to sitting for Diane Timothy Frohling, Ai (AIPP), Howard Sara Irwin; Parks meeting minutes. ned the history, current status Places. Louis Satriano, 4703 Lakemont Court, Palm Beach Gardens; Mary Gillespie, 9900 Daphne Avenue, Palm Beach Gardens, Lorian Brownlee, 302 Balsam Street, Palm Beach Gardens; Jerry Brownlee, 302 Balsam Street, Palm Beach Gardens; Rochelle Satriano, 4703 Lakemont Court, Palm Beach Gardens. VII. COMMENTS BY THE BOARD None. (The remainder of this page intentionally left blank.) ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD AND PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD JOINT MEETING PAGE 1 03.15.10 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 VIII. ADJOURNMENT William Sonnenreich made a motion for adjournment. Timothy Frohling seconded. Motion passed 9 -0. The meeting adjourned at 6:40 p.m. A nvn n171Wn Art in Public Places Advisory Board Cable Neuhaus, Chair Parks and Recreation Advisory Board David Porter, Vice Chair Timothy Diane Cappella Amie Sc Jennifer O'Brien Ernest V Dianne Sacchetti William S Susan Tornabene Jim Amsler Mark Giuliani Howard Nass ATTEST Donna M. Cannon Municipal Services Coordinator 9 Vice NOTE: These minutes are prepared in compliance with 286.011 F.S. and are not verbatim transcripts of the meeting. A verbatim audio recording is available from the Office of the City Clerk. All referenced attachments on file in the Office of the City Clerk. ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD AND PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD JOINT MEETING PAGE 2 03.15.10 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD Agenda Cover Memorandum Meeting Date: April 20, 2010 Petition No. AIPP- 10 -03- 000026 Subject / Agenda Item: Petition AIPP- 10 -03- 000026: Art in Public Places — Downtown at the Gardens Recommendation to City Council: A request by Kevin Berman of Berman Enterprises and Donaldson Hearing of Cotleur and Hearing, Inc., on behalf of Downtown at the Gardens Associates, Ltd, for approval of art in public places for Downtown at the Gardens, generally located north of Kyoto Gardens Drive and east of Alternate A1A at 11701 Lake Victoria Gardens Avenue. [ X ] Recommendation to APPROVE [ ] Recommendation to deny Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: FINANCE: NA AIPP Board Action: Growth Management: [ ] Rec. approval Development Compliance Project ,� Costs: $ NA [ ] Rec. app. w/ conds. Mana er: Manager Total [ ] Rec. Denial _ Allyson Black $ NA [ ] Continued to: Bahareh Wolfs, AICP Current FY Interim Growth Mana ement Funding Source: Ad i tat [ ] Operating [X ] Other NA ata ie Wo CP Growth Mana ement Advertised: N/A Attachments: Date: • Application Budget Acct. #: • Applicant's Paper: Narrative • Site Plan [X] Not Required • Carousel Works Artistic information Approved by: City Manager: • Carousel Work Affected parties: Reference List N/A [ ] Notified • Proposed artistic Ronald M. Ferris [X] Not Required renderings • Budget breakdown Meeting Date: April 20, 2010 Petition AIPP- 10 -03- 000026 BACKGROUND Resolution 19, 2005 approved three (3) pieces of art work for the Downtown at the Gardens commercial development. The three pieces were "Palace" which was approved to be placed by the east valet, the "Pool" which was approved by the south valet and "The Water Bridge" which was placed in middle of the south court. Over the years, "The Water Bridge" was a continual maintenance issue and was constantly under repair. When Downtown at the Gardens changed ownership and Berman Enterprises became the owners, "The Water Bridge" was perceived as a liability issue. The piece was removed without notifying the City. Code Enforcement was informed of this incident and issued a Correction Request. DISCUSSION Don Hearing, Cotleur & Hearing, Inc., and Kevin Berman, Berman Enterprises, appeared before the Art in Public Places Advisory Board for a workshop on February 16, 2010, to discuss with the Board the proposed art and location on the site. A representative of Carousel Works described the process and uniqueness of each Carousel. The Board encouraged the applicant to move forward with the selection of the Carousel with Carousel Works, the location, in the southern courtyard, and to come back with a theme and design. BUDGET In accordance with Section 78- 261(d) of the Land Development Regulations entitled Requirements for art or fee in lieu of art, all budgets for new construction of private and public developments shall include one percent (1%) of the total budget for vertical construction as a fee for art in public places. The subject fee shall be utilized by the developer for the provision of artwork on the project site, or the developer may choose to contribute one percent (1 %) of the total vertical construction costs directly to the City for the provision of art on public property. The 1 % art requirement for Downtown at the Gardens was $320,000. Downtown at the Gardens, under Menin Development, spent a total of $360,000 for the three (3) art pieces. "The Water Bridge" was estimated to cost $105,000 but since they spent $40,000 over the requirement, the deficit Downtown at the Gardens faces in order to comply with the 1% art requirement is $65,000. Downtown at the Gardens has posted the $65,000 in escrow in order to meet the 1 % art requirement. The public art allocation breaks out as follows: $350,000 for the actual Carousel, and $47,750 for the sound system, lighting, electric service, permits and costs associated with installation for a total cost of $405,750 (Please see budget 2 Meeting Date: April 20, 2010 Petition AIPP- 10 -03- 000026 breakdown attached). PROPOSED ART IN PUBLIC PLACES Proposed Art The artwork will be commissioned by Carousel Works (please see attached artistic portfolio and reference list). Carousel Works is the world's largest manufacturer of wooden Carousels and they are well known for their talent at restoring antique Carousels. The proposed thirty six (36) foot Carousel has a total diameter of forty two (42) feet. There is an approximate five (5) foot walkway between the deck and safety fence. The carousel stands approximately seventeen (17) feet high. The applicant stated that the Carousel was inspired by four goals: (1) create a fun and whimsical atmosphere for both children and adults to play and discover art in an exciting and educational way, (2) create a nostalgic feeling for the young at heart, (3) create a Carousel which feels contextually at home within the modern architecture framework of Downtown at the Gardens, and (4) create a Carousel that is truly unique to Downtown at the Gardens inspired by the local history and environment of the City of Palm Beach Gardens, Palm Beach County, and the State of Florida. Figures The proposed figures will be unique hand - carved and painted animals inspired by a `horses in the garden' theme. They depict horses and animals found in their natural habitat. There will be a total of twenty -seven (27) animal figures on the Carousel, with the most common figure being variations of the horse. The other figures, yet to be determined, will be a variety of fun and lively animals native to the South Florida region, such as the Loggerhead Sea Turtle, Sandhill Crane, Wood Stork, Manatee, and Blue Heron (Please see attached proposed artistic renderings). There will also be two (2) spinning chariots and one (1) ADA compliant chariot on the Carousel. Center Surround The Center Surround consists of panels that cover the vertical components holding up the Carousel. The top half of these panels will contain a mirror within a frame. The middle section will alternate between a replicated carving of the Banyan Tree and a colorful painted arrangement of local flora and fauna. The lower section will contain framed painting of coastal colors. Internal Mural and radiating Beams Above the Center Surround is proposed as a hand painted Internal Mural, which would wrap around in the inside of the Carousel depicting scenes and names of local marine life. The beams radiating out from the internal painting are red with stenciling. 3 Meeting Date: April 20, 2010 Petition AIPP- 10 -03- 000026 Rounding Boards The Rounding Boards surround the outer canopy of the Carousel. They are proposed as boldly painted alternating panels with native South Florida birds in flight and local history. The bird scenes would be set in larger panels with blue background framed in gold, while scenes of the local history would be smaller oval panels with oranges and orange blossoms cascading from the top (Please see attached artistic renderings). Carousel Base The base of the Carousel would be made of Ipe Wood, which is an environmentally sustainable wood with a strong non -slip base. The wood contains slight gaps between the panels to prevent the water from gathering on the deck. Educational Material The applicant is proposing to include educational material on the perimeter fence of the Carousel. The materials are to educate the public about the various components of the Carousel such as the artist's process of building the Carousel, the historical elements located on the Carousel, as well as the plants and animals depicted on the Carousel. Proposed Location The applicant is proposing to locate the Carousel within the south circular courtyard, just east of Whole Foods Market. This is the exact location if the art being replaced, "The Water Bridge" (Please see attached site plan). This location allows for visibility from four (4) different access points; Victoria Gardens, south valet, Whole Foods and north shops. Proposed Liphting The applicant has stated that the Carousel will be lit from dusk until dawn with from bulbs attached to the structure. The Carousel contains 270 -300 60 -volt LED bulbs with an E14 base. The bulbs are attached to the underside of the Carousel canopy in order to minimize light pollution. The bulbs are LEDs, which are 75% more efficient than incandescent with equal light output. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff is recommending approval of the subject petition with the following conditions of approval: 1. The Applicant shall submit digital photographs of the installed artwork within sixty (60) days of completion. (Planning and Zoning) 2. Prior to the acceptance of the art for Downtown at the Gardens, the Applicant shall submit a copy of its logo and any mission statement of its organization, with authorization for the City to use such information in 11 Meeting Date: April 20, 2010 Petition AIPP- 10 -03- 000026 future publications. The artist name, title of artwork, and description shall be included. (Planning & Zoning) 3. The Applicant shall be responsible for the maintenance of the work of art. (Planning & Zoning) CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION Planning and Zoning Division Growth Management Department CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS 10500 North Military Trail Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410 (561) 799 -4243 Fax (561) 799 -4281 Request: 0 Planned Community Development (PCD) QPlanned Unit Development (PUD) DAmendment to PCD, PUD or Site Plan QConditional Use Amendment to the Comprehensive Plan Administrative Approval aAdministrative Appeal Project Name: Downtown at the Gardens Owner: Downtown at the Gardens Associates Ltd Applicant (if not Owner): Owner Applicant's Address: 5410 Edson Ln Suite 220 []Annexation QRezoning OSite Plan Review ElConcurrency Certificate Time Extension EZ]Miscellaneous E:]DtherArts in Public Places Date Submitted: 3/2/10 Telephone No. 301 -816 -1555 Agent: Kevin Berman / Donaldson Hearing of Cotleur & Hearing Inc. Contact Person: Kevin Berman E -Mail: kberman @bermanenterp rises. cor Agent's Mailing Address: 11701 Lake Victoria Gardens Ave, Suite 2203, Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33, Agent's Telephone Number: 301 - 520 -3900 Petition Number: Application $ Receipt Number: FOR OFFICE USE ONLY Date & Time Received: Engineering $ ,a woo Architect: N/A Engineer: N/A Planner: Don Hearing, Cotleur and Hearing 1934 Commerce Lane, Suite 1, Jupiter, FL 33458 Landscape Architect: N/A Site Information: Note: Petitioners shall submit electronic digital files of approved projects. See attachment for details. General Location: Downtown at the Gardens Address: 11701 Lake Victoria Gardens Ave. Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410 Section: 06 Township: 42 Range: 43 Property Control Number(s): 52- 43- 42- 06 -14- 001 -0000 48.76 PCD PCD Acreage: Current Zoning: Requested Zoning: Flood Zone Base Flood Elevation (BFE) — to be indicated on site plan Current Comprehensive Plan Land Use Designation: Professional Office (PO) Shopping Center Shopping Center Existing Land Use: Requested Land Use: Proposed Use(s) i.e. hotel, single family residence, etc.: Carousel Proposed Square Footage by Use: N/A Proposed Number and Type of Dwelling Unit(s) i.e. single family, multifamily, etc. (if applicable): N/A Justification 2 MAR 3 2010 lily; Information concerning all requests (attach additional sheets if needed.) {Section 78 -46, Application Procedures, Land Development Regulations} 1. Explain the nature of the request: Art in Public Places Misc. Petition We are proposing a new piece of art to fulfill the project art in public places requirement. We propose building a custom built carousel in place of the previously existing art bridge. 2. What will be the impact of the proposed change on the surrounding area? The carousel will be located internal to the project and will not impact any of the surrounding area. 3. Describe how the rezoning request complies with the City's Vision Plan and the following elements of the City's Comprehensive Plan — Future Land Use, Transportation, Housing, Infrastructure, Coastal Management, Conservation, Recreation and Open space, Intergovernmental Coordination and Capital Improvement. Not applicable. 4. How does the proposed project comply with City requirements for preservation of natural resources and native vegetation (Section 78 -301, Land Development Regulations)? Not applicable. 5. How will the proposed project comply with City requirements for Art in Public Places (Chapter 78- 261, Land Development Regulations)? This petition is to adhere to the AIPP requirement. An art piece has been removed that was approved as part of the original AIPP for the project. This petition is to request to replace that art piece with a new art piece. The applicant is proposing to provide a custom designed and constructed carousel. 6. Has project received concurrency certification? Yes Date received: 2003 Legal Description of the Subject Property (Attach additional sheets if needed) Or see attached deed for legal description. Location The subject property is located approximately 0 mile(s) from the intersection of Alternate Al A , on the[:]northF.-/Iast,3outhaest side of (street /road). Statement of Ownership and Designation of Authorized Agent Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Kevin Berman who, being by me first duly sworn, on oath deposed and says: 4 1. That he /she is the fee simple title owner of the property described in the attached Legal Description. 2. That he /she is requesting M i s ce I l a n e o u s Petition in the City of Palm Beach Gardens, Florida. 3. That he /she has appointed Kevin Berman/ Cotleur & Hearing, Inc. to act as authorized agent on his/her behalf to accomplish the above project. D Name of0 er: wntown at the Gardens Associates Ltd k atur Owner By: Name /Title 5410 Edson Ln Suite 220 Rockville, MD 20852 Street Address City, State, Zip Code P. O. Box City, State, Zip Code 301 - 816 -1555 301- 816 -1556 Telephone Number Fax Number kberman @bermanenterprises.com E -mail Address Sworn and subscribed before me this Y� day of Al d ((M 2010 Notary Public My Commission expires: ' �" -t CARLA DAVIS `• '4: `' MY COMMISSION # DD921746 EXPIRES August 31, 2013 (407)398.0153 Florida Nota ryS e. ry ice. com 5 Applicant's Certification I/We affirm and certify that I /we understand and will comply with the land development regulations of the City of Palm Beach Gardens, Florida. I/WE further certify that the statements or diagrams made on any paper or plans submitted herewith are true to the best of my /our knowledge and belief. Further, I /we understand that this application,_a tachments, and application filing fees become a part of the official records of the City o PaYm Beach ens, FFI d nd are not returnable. Applicant is: Signature of Applicant Zwner ❑Optionee OLessee Fl Agent Econtract Purchaser Kevin Berman Print Name of Applicant 5410 EDSON LN STE 220 Street Address ROCKVILLE MD 20852 3195 City, State, Zip Code 301- 816 -1555 Telephone Number 301- 816 -1556 Fax Number kberman @bermanenterprises.com E -Mail Address e t Permit # Palm Beach Gardens Growth Management Department 10500 North Military Trail, Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410 561 - 799 -4230 Financial Responsibility Form The owner understands that all City- incurred professional fees and expenses associated with the processing of this application request are ultimately the responsibility of the owner. A security deposit shall be deposited in an interest - bearing account with any accrued interest to be retained by the City of Palm Beach Gardens. The owner and /or designee shall be invoiced on a monthly basis for professional fees such as, but not limited to, consultant engineering services, legal services, advertising costs, and /or any other costs attributable to the processing of the permit for which the City incurred during the previous month. The owner and /or designee shall reimburse the City within thirty (30) days from date of invoice. If payment is not received, the City may utilize the security deposit for re- imbursement purposes. All activities related to the pending permit(s) will cease until any outstanding invoices are paid. The owner /designee further understands that transfer of this responsibility shall require a completed form, signed and notarized by the responsible party, and delivered to the City Growth Management Department if the name and /or address of the responsible party changes at anytime duri -tts li i�ri roces s. d ner si nafure Date Kevin Berman Owner printed name DESIGNEE /BILL TO: Downtown at the Gardens Associates LTD 5410 EDSON LN STE 220 ROCKVILLE, MD 20852 3195 52- 43-42- 06 -14- 001 -0000 Property Control Number Designee Acceptance Signature f i NOTARY ACKNOWLEDGEMENT STATE OF I [9(IGI G COUNTY OF ic7 ) `o rJe-� 6- i-4 YGI I hereby certify that the foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this — day of VV1 /Ire M 201!x, by IeeVi(1 F3crvyief r He or sh "'personally knowx�_ to me or has produced as Identificatiol� Notary public signature W16 )MV(S Printed name CARLA DAVIS y r MY COMMISSION # DD921746 9f EXPIRES August 31, 2013 (407) 398.0153 F1oridallolary3erv".com State of FL at -large My Commission expires: 3, 3 i , 13 Cotleur& HearingLandscape Architects I Land Planners I Environmental Consultants 1934 Commerce Lane • Suite 1 • Jupiter, Florida • 33458 • Ph 561.747.6336 • Fax 561.747.1377 - www.cotleurhearing.com • Lic # LC- C000239 Downtown at the Gardens Miscellaneous Petition Art in Public Places Replacement Request Introduction On behalf of Downtown at the Gardens, we are pleased to submit an application for Art in Public Places. The Downtown at the Gardens project was completed in 2005, along with the required art work for the Art in Public Places (AIPP) requirement of the code. The project has changed ownership since 2005 twice. The current owner of the property has been assessing all aspects of the project in effort to revive the center. In their assessment they noticed that one of the approved artworks needed replacement due to previous lack of maintenance in combination with a lack of appreciation by the centers patrons. Section 78 261 of the City of Palm Beach Gardens Code of Ordinances requires that all art used towards the Art in Public Places requirement must be reviewed and approved by the City. Request Downtown at the Gardens is seeking approval for an interactive art piece that will assist in the revival of the Downtown center. The applicant is proposing to construct a carousel with hand - carved figures and chariots. The art is proposed to be located within the south circular courtyard, just east of Whole Foods Market. This is the exact location of the art being replaced, the water bridge. The water bridge was not well maintained for several years by the previous owners and became a significant liability issue for the current property owner. The art was removed for this reason. The current owner has placed funds in escrow with the city to keep in compliance of the Arts in Public Places requirement. The proposed art was presented to the AIPP board as a workshop item on the 16th of February, last month. Per Section 78 261 "in making its recommendation to the city council, the AIPP board shall consider the quality of the artwork; the exhibition and sales history of the artist; the artist's works in public collections and previous public art purchases or commissions; the ability of the artist to complete the project within a specified schedule; and the compliance with the standards of this division." The artwork will be commissioned by Carousel Works. Carousel Works is the world's largest manufacturer of wooden carousels and they are also very well known for their talent at restoring antique carousels. Their facility is located in Mansfield Ohio and it houses b, -the design and construction aspects of the carousel. Their facility employs designers, and woodworkers, pattern makers, casting specialists, engineers, artistic painters, Downtown at the Gardens CH 00- 1003.03 Miscellanous Petition —AIPP Statement of Use March 5, 2010 the management team. Their work has appeared in architectural digest and many other design related publications and television shows such as Extreme Makeover: Home Edition. The company was the first to revive wooden carousel construction in 1991 after a construction freeze that dated back to the early 1930's. The owners of the company have been in the woodcarving and carpentry disciplines for 75 -years combined. They are known for their innovative designs and their true accuracy for antique restoration and replication. They have constructed carousels and installed them all over the country since 1994 in Virginia, California, New York, Ohio, Michigan, Missouri, Utah, Illinois, Connecticut, Wisconsin, Tennessee, Texas, Mississippi, Pennsylvania, Alabama, Colorado, Oklahoma, Georgia, Iowa, South Carolina, Indiana, Kentucky, and Florida. Design Overview The carousel will consist of three components; the frame, facade and the figures and chariots. The fagade and the figures and chariots are the art where as the frame is what supports the art. The facades are the decorative panels that actually hide the inner workings of the carousel (mechanical and electrical). The facades are uniquely designed and hand - painted to fit the theme of the carousel. The figures and chariots are represented by the well -known animals or carriages that signify a true carousel. They are hand - carved and hand - painted to ensure uniqueness for each carousel and each figure. Code Criteria Section 78 -262 lists the standards for artwork being requested. The proposed art meets the standards as discussed below: (a) Artwork shall be displayed in a visually accessible location, which shall be suitable to the design of the site, in order for the public to receive the most enjoyment and benefit from the a rt. The carousel will be displayed in the south circular courtyard where access is possible from four different points; Victoria Gardens, the south valet, Whole Foods, and north shops. (b) Artwork shall be integrated into the overall planning and design for a structure or project, and shall be compatible with the intent and purpose of the structure at which the work or works are located. Considering that Downtown has completed construction since 2005, the current property owner has suggested the most compatible location within the fabric of the center. The circular carousel is consistent with the circular courtyard and will fit seamlessly into the project. (c) Artwork shall be integrated into the overall landscaping plan, and landscaping shall be utilized to enhance the visibility of such works. Downtown at the Gardens CH 00- 1003.03 Miscellanous Petition — AIPP Statement of Use March 5, 2010 The landscape for the courtyard will be reevaluated to be consistent with the new artwork in the south courtyard. The landscape surrounding the previous art was ill maintained and needed replacing. (d) Artwork shall be lighted at a minimum from dusk until midnight. The lighting shall be designed and located in order to prevent excessive lighting, energy waste, glare, light trespass, and sky glow. The artwork will be lighted through midnight at minimum inside the carousel and from the courtyard. The lighting will be sustainably designed. (e) Artwork installed pursuant to the division cannot be altered or removed from the site without approval of the city council. The property owner will guarantee the artworks existence on site unless approval to remove it has been issued by the city council. (f) Maintenance. Artwork shall be maintained in good condition at all times, including any associated landscaping or related improvements. The property owner will be fully responsible for maintaining this new artwork to ensure the highest quality condition at all times, including the surrounding landscape improvements. (g) All artwork purchased from the art impact fund shall be displayed on city -owned land, a city -owned building, or a city - leased or - rented facility. Not applicable. (h) Zoning and building consideration. Consideration shall be given to project zoning. Permits and building approval shall be obtained, when necessary, and shall be in compliance with the Florida Building Code, the National Electric Code, and the previously- approved plans by city council. The applicant will comply. Conclusion The applicant looks forward to continue to work with City staff and the AIPP board to incorporate the new carousel into the Downtown at the Gardens approved art. The carousel will be a great attribute for the center and for the city. Carousels have been part of culture for thousands of years, dating back to 500 A.D. in the Byzantine Empire. They were developed for French Kings in the 16th century and brought to the United States in the mid 1800's as a landmark for Coney Island. Downtown at the Gardens is very excited to add this integral part of the urban culture to the City of Palm Beach Gardens. 3 Design Narrative for the Carousel Design Vision The carousel designed for Downtown at the Gardens was inspired by 4 goals: 1. Create a fun and whimsical atmosphere for both children and adults to play and discover art in an exciting and educational way. 2. Create a nostalgic feeling for the young at heart 3. Create a Carousel which feels contextually at home within the modern architecture framework of Downtown at the Gardens 4. Create a Carousel that is truly unique to Downtown at the Gardens inspired by the local history and environment of the City Palm Beach Gardens, Palm Beach County and the state of Florida. Figures The figures will be unique hand - carved and painted animals inspired by a 'horses in the garden' theme. They are whimsical, fanciful, natural creations and are adorned with trappings found in nature, such as native birds and flowers to our local region. As a child sits upon a figure, they will discover beautiful subtleties integrated into the figure, like a small hidden butterfly or a bird perched on a nose. These are reminiscent of horses and animals found in their natural habitat. The most common figure is the horse, but there is a menagerie of other animals. These other figures are a fun and lively smattering of animals native to the South Florida area, such as the Loggerhead Sea Turtle, Sandhill Crane, Wood Stork, Manatee, and Blue Heron. Each figure will be painted to allow the natural wood to "show through." There will be a total of (27) figures, (2) spinning chariots, and (I) chariot which will be ADA compliant. Center Surround The Center Surround are the panels that cover the vertical components holding up the carousel. The top half of these panels contains a mirror within a frame. These mirrors reflect light and brighten the carousel from the inside out. The middle section alternates between a replicated carving of the signature Palm Beach Gardens Banyan Tree and a colorful painted arrangement of local flora and fauna. The bottom of the center surround panels contains a framed painting of coastal colors. Internal Mural Above the Center Surround is the Internal Mural, which wraps around the inside of the carousel, and is hand painted, depicting scenes of local marine life. The top band has been stenciled with names of the different marine life. Radiating Beams There are beams radiating out from the mural: these are painted red on the underside with beautiful stenciling on the face. Rounding Boards The Rounding Boards surround the outer canopy of the carousel. These are boldly painted, alternating panels depicting native South Floridian birds in flight, and highlighting local history. The bird scenes are set in larger panels with a blue background and framed in gold, while the scenes of local history are smaller panels, and are set in beautifully carved Edwardian era type oval frames with oranges and orange blossoms cascading from the top. Carousel Base The base of the Carousel will be built of Ipe wood. This is an environmentally sustainable wood with a strong non -slip base with slight gaps between panel to prevent puddleing of water on the deck. The construction is solid and functional. For the children who ride it, however, the experience will be unforgettable. B" �a.r Education Material Education material will be attached to the perimeter fence of the carousel. The materials will educate people about various components of the carousel such as the artist's process of building the carousel, the historical elements used in the rounding boards, and the plants and animals depicted in the scenes and figures. Light Plan The Carousel will be lit from dust until dawn from bulbs attached to its structure. The Carousel contains 270- 300 60 volts LED bulbs with an E14 base. The bulbs are attached to the underside of Carousel canopy so they should not produce any unnecessary light pollution. The bulbs are LEDs, which are 75% more efficient than incandescent with equal light output. W m co C) 0 =i > 0 M 50 m 0 L<. r oc: & m -n 0 < P z M m Z r- 0 a) 0 0 m x a . z -1 cn T w M 71 ^ / � \zz < .� \\ C4 0) 0 CA 0 r_ 0 co f- j ,Q. 0 SOUTH ED COURTYARD ' X67' WAIVER SAFETY FENCE Ap YR V. ,, .UTH 1OVE �a s �' • Q" j9 195 P't 7"' EAST % CAROUSEL RIDE NOT TO SCALE Pl, %7ZA C.R,'ANDE 1.990 .1[0.14• .16 1160Y 1 ?-6M I 966 NORTH COURTYARD 93.1' q- ® 9�1i0 /. �V ((TTTT��ff)) �* TOOIAY'S ORIGINAL ' - � HILOA FLACK DES"S JP 63010 ,_w DOuRNET DELI � a •10.91' 111,11' a W 1. UR&W OVTFITTERS A z 1 u I syan R 9. 9' moo, e.r 19]3'b 71.51' 78'9A' a 71.73' 19.11' I6 1609' IOA' 1 g 9' { {{ 3 x °o R VACMI t.7J60 > B36S0 �tT5� . SOUTH ED COURTYARD ' X67' WAIVER SAFETY FENCE Ap YR V. ,, .UTH 1OVE �a s �' • Q" j9 195 P't 7"' EAST % CAROUSEL RIDE NOT TO SCALE Pl, %7ZA C.R,'ANDE 1.990 .1[0.14• .16 1160Y 1 ?-6M I 966 NORTH COURTYARD Cthe,sel s Artistic 1285 Jack Pollock Pkwy Mansfield, OH 44905 Ph 800.785.8283 Fax 419.524.9603 Email: info @carouselworks.com Website: www.carouselworks.com /.our Mpg Carousel Design Overview A Carousel Works carousel consists of three components the Frame, Fagade & Figures /Chariots. We work with each of these elements to create a one -of -a -kind carousel for each client. Frame The carousel Frame consists of the inner working of the carousel that supports the figures and creates the movement on the carousel. Facade The fagade consists of the decorative panels that are used to hide the Frame components. These panels are created for aesthetics, so our designers can be extremely creative in their design to create a one -of- a -kind carousel for each client. The components are uniquely designed for each project based on the overall theme and design concepts including the structural shape, decorative details and hand - painted artwork: • Rounding Boards — structure shape, decorative details as well as hand - painted artwork. • Center Surround — decorative details, mirrors, may also be designed to host hand - painted artwork. • Lower Surround Mural— original 56' hand - painted sprawling mural or the mural may be broken up into smaller sections if the client prefers. • Upper Surround —structural shape and decorative details. • Shields — these elements are customized to put the finishing touches of theme on each individual carousel design and may also be designed to host hand - painted artwork. Figures & Chariots Figure Design - Each and every figure /chariot is hand - carved and hand - painted so the design and creation of each figure is original. Our carvers begin with a basic figure silhouette and can create elaborately designed trappings (the harness, saddle, straps, blankets, etc.) or create a simple design depending on each individual client's wishes for their project. Next our artists hand -paint each figure uniquely to work with the overall color scheme to bring them to life. a�usel Carousel Works is the world's largest manufacturer of wooden carousels as well as being the premier choice for the restoration of antique carousels. Our 22,000 square foot facility in Mansfield, Ohio, encompasses all aspects of carousel construction, design, and restoration in- house. Our twenty -eight experienced and talented employees specialize in all aspects of carousel manufacturing ranging from design, hand - carving, woodworking, pattern making, casting, engineering, machine shop techniques, artistic painting, sculpture and management under one roof. This has allowed us to develop into the type of carousel manufacturing facility that hasn't existed for over sixty years. Our work has appeared in numerous articles and publications, including Architectural Digest. In addition, the Carousel Works has been featured on various television shows including Mister Rogers Neighborhood and Extreme Makeover: Home Edition. Odg' i ns Art Ritchie and Daniel Jones began Carousel Works in 1986 with one goal —to revive one of America's valuable treasures, a tribute to both craftsmanship and artistic innovation — the art of making wooden carousels. The company began by completing full carousel restorations and carving new individual figures for private owners, but always with the goal of building a new wooden carousel. At that time, the last wooden carousel to be built was in the depression -era early 1930s. In 1991, they reached their goal when they installed the first new hand - carved wooden carousel since that time with the Richland Carousel Park in Mansfield, Ohio. Art Ritchie — Co -Owner Art Ritchie is a Master Carver and has been a professional woodcarver for over thirty -five years. He began in the mid -1970s specializing in hand - carved wooden signs, furniture, relief carvings and individual carousel figures and is now one of the world's most renowned wooden carousel artists. Art's current focus is on the overall design of the new carousels, he is constantly creating new and innovative designs to make each carousel project uniquely its own. Daniel Jones — Co -Owner Daniel Jones has been a Master Carpenter for over forty years. He also began his career in the 1970s specializing in the architectural restoration of antique homes. Dan now oversees the entire Restoration Department and also creates the structural facades for the new carousel projects. Carousel Works Page 2 Carving & Woodworking Department Key StaffMembers: Don Blakley — Carving Department Supervisor Don began as an apprentice carver at the Carousel Works twenty years ago under Master Carver, Art Ritchie, when he was still in high school. Now himself a Master Carver, he is in charge of supervising the Carving Department, training new apprentice carvers while also carving the new figure patterns and also focusing on carving the most ornate, detailed figures. Donna Grantham - Lead Carver Donna has been specializing in carousel figure carving at the Carousel Works for fifteen years. She also has a background in Commercial Art & Design. Tim Gorka - Lead Carver Tim has been a professional woodcarver for twenty -eight years and joined our staff full -time in 2006. In addition to figure carving, Tim also focuses on the design and carving of the carousels' stationary chariots. In addition to his extensive woodworking background, he also has extensive qualifications in sculpture and painting. Aaron Schroeder — Carver /Metal Sculpture Aaron holds a Master of Fine Arts in Sculpture and in addition to an expansive background in wood working, has created numerous kinetic metal sculptures throughout the country. In addition to carving, Aaron's skills have allowed us to expand our designs to incorporate more kinetic sculpture movement into our overall carousel designs. Tonya Johnson — Carver Tonya specializes in carousel figure carving and has been with Carousel Works for fourteen years. Rick Beam — Carver Rick has been with Carousel Works for over twenty years, the majority of which he spent specializing in antique figure restoration. He has now transferred into the carving department where he is using his years of expertise and talent to carve new figures. Ryan Jones — Figure Fabrication Ryan specializes in fabricating the figure blocks so that the carver can create the desired design. He has over ten years of experience with the company and does an excellent job of creating the medium for the figure sculptures. Carousel Works Page 3 Art Department Key Staff Members: Marilyn Ritchie —Art Department Supervisor Marilyn is one of the most premier carousel artists in the world. She has been with Carousel Works for over twenty -three years. In addition to overseeing the Art department, she is also responsible for the coordination of all the artwork on the carousel, working with each client to determine an overall color scheme for the project as well as training new artists in the nuances of carousel art. Leslie Chaffin —Mural Artist Leslie was trained at the Otis Art Institute and has been a professional artist for thirty -two years, eighteen of those years have been with Carousel Works. She designs and creates original hand - painted artwork for the carousels. Martha Fort — Mural Artist Martha also uses her vast experience and skills to design and creates original hand - painted artwork for our carousels. She holds a BFA specializing in watercolor and has also taught art at the college level. Karen Beck — Figure & Facade Artist Karen has a degree and extensive background in Interior Design and in addition to working in our art department, also owns a private interior design /faux painting business for over fifteen years. She specializes in laying out the color design and finishes for the carousel fagade as well as figure painting. Eric Tomlinson — Figure & Facade Artist Eric is one of our newest artists. He holds a BFA in Sculpture and previously worked for the Columbus Museum of Art upon graduation before joining our staff in the art department. Jason Kaufman — Figure Artist & Sculpture Molds Jason specializes in figure art as well as the creating of our various sculpture casting that are used as additional decorative pieces on the carousel fagade. He has a BFA in Sculpture & Glassblowing and also recently opened his own gallery, Kenosis Gallery for Experimental Art. Carousel Works Page 4 Artistryin Wood.. m " / ~~^ ' ` ` � 73 Carousel Works Page 5 Carousel Works Page 6 Carousel Works Page 7 Artistic Painting - Bringing the Figures to Carousel Works Page 8 m Carousel Works Page 9 Fine Art - Original Artwork to Enhance the Beauty..... CA f4zy Carousel Works Page 10 - .-. , 01111 woo Al Mimi, - W-� -4-Vkr'-rA"- Ti Carousel Works Page 11 Carousel Works Page 12 Carousel Works Page 13 e voaks 1285 Jack Pollock Pkwy Mansfield, OH 44905 Ph 800 - 785 -8283 or 419 -522 -7558 Email: sales @carouselworks.com www.carouselworks.com REFERENCE LIST Complete project reference list — projects over $100,000.00 �0*00��s ', 11111 Carousel Works, Inc. New Carousels in progress ....0 Carousel: Royal Caribbean Contact: Denise Key- Tielebein - Project Analyst New Building & Fleet Design (786) 264 -0858 Miami, FL Project: (2) 24' Carousels Traditional Themed CWI is creating 2 traditional - themed carousels for Royal Caribbean's new Genesis class of ships - the Oasis of the Seas (Spring 2009) and the Allure of the Seas (Spring 2010) Carousel: Bay Creek Carousel Contact: Dick Foster - President (757) 491 -1240 Virginia Beach, VA Project: 52' Carousel Coastal /Golf Resort Themed (Fall 2009) Carousel: Los Angeles Zoo Carousel Contact: Connie Morgan -President (323) 644 -4701 Los Angeles, CA Project: 54' Carousel Conservation Themed (Winter 2010) Carousel: Hudson River Pier 62 Carousel Contact: Mark Boddewynn (917) 661 -8740 New York, NY Project: 36' Carousel Traditional Themed (Spring 2010) Carousel: Calgary Zoo Contact: Don Peterkin (403) 232 -9344 Calgary, Alberta, Canada Project: 36' Carousel Conservation Themed (Spring 2010) Carousel: Akron Zoo Carousel Contact: Linda Criss (330) 375 -2550, ext. 8964 Akron, OH Project: 36' Carousel Conservation Themed (Summer 2010) Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 2 Carousel Works, Inc. New Wooden Carousels Year Installed: 2009 Carousel: Silver Beach Carousel Contact: Suz Schalon - President (616) 318 -9555 St. Joseph, MI Project: 52' Carousel Traditional Themed Carousel: Kansas City Royals Carousel Contact: Jill Mitchell - Sr. Project Manager (816) 924 -6763 Kansas City, MO Project: 24' Carousel Kansas City Royals Baseball Themed Carousel: Sacramento Zoo Carousel Contact: Jim Schnormeier -Asst, Director (916) 808 -7381 Sacramento, CA Project: 36' Carousel Endangered Species Themed Year Installed: 2008 Carousel: Utah's Hogle Zoo Conservation Carousel Contact: Doug Lund - Asst. Director (801) 584 -1709 Salt Lake City, UT Project: 46' Carousel Conservation Themed Year Installed: 2007 Carousel: Binder Park Zoo Conservation Carousel Contact: Gregory Geise - Director (269) 979 -1351, ext. 130 Battle Creek, MI Project: 42' Carousel Endangered Species Themed Carousel: Kansas City Zoo Carousel Contact: Randy Wisthoff - Director (816) 513 -5702 Kansas City, MO Project: 42' Carousel Endangered Species Themed Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 3 Carousel Works, Inc. Year Installed: 2006 Carousel: Brookfield Zoo Carousel Contact: Stuart Strahl, PhD — Director (708) 485 -0263 Brookfield, IL Project: 62' Carousel Endangered Species Themed Year Installed: 2005 Carousel: Beardsley Zoo Carousel Contact: Greg Dancho - Director (203) 394 -6565 Bridgeport, CT Project: 36' Carousel jungle Themed Carousel: Henry Vilas Zoo Conservation Carousel Contact: Jim Hubing - Director (608) 266 -4733 Madison, WI Project: 36' Carousel Conservation Themed Carousel: Bronx Zoo Insect Carousel Contact: Sean McAllister (718) 741 -8295 Bronx, NY Project: 54' Carousel The first and only all insect carousel Carousel: Nashville Zoo Conservation Carousel Contact: Cindy Stitely (615) 833 -1534, ext. 129 Nashville, TN Project: 42' Carousel Conservation Themed Year Installed: 2004 Carousel: Houston Zoo Carousel Contact: Rick Barongi - Director (715) 513 -6500 Houston, TX Project: 54' Carousel Endangered Species Themed Carousel: Jackson Zoo Carousel Contact: Susan Dobbs (601) 352 -2582 Jackson, MS Project: 36' Carousel Endangered Species Themed Carousel Works — Complete Reference List Page 4 Carousel Works, Inc. Year Installed: 2003 Carousel: Toledo Zoo Carousel Contact: Dave DiCola (419)385 -5721 Toledo, OH Project: 52' Carousel African Jungle Themed Carousel: Erie Zoo Carousel Contact: Cynthia Kreider - Director (814) 864 -4091, ext. 226 Erie, PA Project: 36' Carousel Conservation Themed Carousel: St. Louis Zoo Carousel Contact: Joan Sisco (314) 781 -0900 St. Louis, MO Project: 54' Carousel Conservation Themed Carousel: Miami Metrozoo Carousel Contact: Carol Kruse - Asst. Director Miami, FL Project: 36' Carousel Jungle Themed Year Installed: 2002 Carousel: Memphis Zoo Carousel Contact: Connie Bellett (901) 725 -3458 Memphis, TN Project: 36' Carousel Asian Themed Carousel: Birmingham Zoo Carousel Contact: Jeff Cook (205) 879 -0409 Birmingham, AL Project: 42' Carousel Endangered Species Themed Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 5 Carousel Works, Inc. Year Installed: 2001 Carousel: Denver Zoo Carousel Contact: Craig Piper - President (303) 376 -4816 Denver, CO Project: 52' Carousel Conservation Themed Carousel: Lincoln Park Zoo Carousel Contact: Neal David (312) 742 -2315 Chicago, IL Project: 52' Carousel Conservation Themed Carousel: Bear Mountain State Park Carousel Contact: Carol Ash — NYState Park Commissioner (518) 474 -0443 Bear Mountain, NY Project: 42' Carousel Rustic Themed Year Installed: 1999 Carousel: Willowbrook Park Carousel Contact: Jona Carmona -Graf (708) 760 -6666 Staten Island, NY Project: 46' Carousel Traditional Themed Carousel: Oklahoma City Zoo Carousel Contact: Mark Campbell - Director (405) 424 -3344 Oklahoma City, OK Project: 46' Carousel Conservation Themed Year Installed: 1998 Carousel: Zoo Atlanta Carousel Contact: Dennis Kelly - CEO (404)624 -5864 Atlanta, GA Project: 42' Carousel Endangered Species Themed Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 6 Carousel Works, Inc. Carousel: Milhous Group Carousel Contact: Robert or Paul Milhous (561) 988 -2114 Boca Raton, FL Project: 52' Carousel Traditional Themed Carousel: The Heritage Carousel Contact: J. C. Brenton (515) 237 -5121 Des Moines, IA Project: 36' Carousel Traditional Themed Year Installed: 1997 Carousel: Riverbanks Zoo Carousel Contact: Satch Krantz - Director (803) 779 -8707 Columbia, SC Project: 42' Carousel Conservation Themed Year Installed: 1994 Carousel: Ft. Wayne Children's Zoo Carousel Contact: Jim Anderson - Director (260) 427 -6805 Ft. Wayne, IN Project: 42' Carousel Conservation Themed Carousel: Kentucky Horse Park Carousel Contact: Robert Hinkle (859) 259 -6805 Lexington, KY Project: 42' Carousel Equine Themed Carousel: Chapel Hill Mall Carousel Contact: Bryan Lutz (330) 633 -7100 Akron, OH Project: 36' Carousel Traditional Themed Carousel: Richland Carousel Park Contact: Mayor Lydia Reid (419) 755 -9626 Mansfield, OH Project: 52' Carousel Traditional Themed Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 7 Carousel Works, Inc. Restoration Projects Carousel: Nunley's Carousel Year: 2007-2009 Contact: Gary Grasso, R.A. (516) 571 -6888 Kevin Mulligan, P.E. (516) 571 -9611 County of Nassau Dept. of Public Works 1194 Prospect Avenue Westbury, NY 11590 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works 100% of band organ restoration by Stinson Band Organ Company Nunley's Carousel consists of the complete rehabilitation of the Stein and Goldstein Carousel. The carousel is a 16- section machine, with three (3) figures abreast and a 42- foot diameter platform. The restoration requirements for both the figures and facade, and the frame and mechanism are stringent with respect to maintaining the period look and design of the artistic pieces. In addition to restoring the entire carousel frame, we will also be bringing the drive unit and electrical systems up to code, as well as updating the carousel to meet with the Americans with Disability Act and Code standards. Included in restoring the existing facade, this carousel restoration also involves seventy -two (72) new original murals and scenery panel paintings to be created by our in -house artistic muralist that will depict the history of the carousel and the Nassau County area where the carousel will be located. A complete rehabilitation of all the figures and chariots, including full documentation of the original color scheme and a complete new suggested color palette for each figure is also part of the restoration plan. All original pieces not used on the carousel will be returned to the client for their historic value. This carousel was re- installed in April 2009. Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 8 Carousel Works, Inc. Carousel: Central Park Carousel Year: 1994 - present Contact: Sal Napolitano (212) 879 -0244 (Carousel) (718) 822 -8094 (Office) Central Park Carousel 830 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10018 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Central Park Carousel is the rehabilitation of a Stein and Goldstein Carousel originally built in 1908. This restoration project was completed in three (3) phases. 1994 - We completed a restoration of the carousel frame (complete mechanism), which included the Top Bearing, Cheese Bearing, and Jumper System. 1999 - During this phase, we replaced the existing drive system with a new Drive Unit. 2004 - Present - Since the carousel was operational at the time of restoration, the Central Park Carousel Conservancy decided to approach the figure and chariot restoration by restoring a few of the figures at a time so the carousel can remain open to riders. For this stage of the restoration, we are restoring eight (8) of the figures at a time and returning them to the carousel and then obtaining eight (8) additional figures to be restored. We have completed and returned thirty -six (36) of the figures to date, and are currently in the process of restoring eight (8) additional figure at our facility. This carousel is a 16- section machine, with four (4) figures abreast and two (2) chariots. Carousel: George Schott Year: 2000 - present Contact: George Schott (207) 754 -3630 Lewiston, ME Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works Mr. Schott is a collector of antique figures created by masters M.C. Illions, Carmel and Looff. Mr. Schott has entrusted Carousel Works, Inc. to faithfully restore and paint all of the eighteen antique figures he has acquired over the past several years. Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 9 Carousel Works, Inc. Carousel: Hempstead Lake State Park Carousel Year: 2004 Contact: Jack Heinlein (631) 669 -1000 New York State Office of Parks, Recreation & Historic Preservation Empire State Plaza - Agency Building 1 Albany, NY 12238 Gary Grasso, R.A. (516) 571 -6888 (Gary is now employed with the County of Nassau Dept of Public Works, but he was also involved with this carousel restoration.) Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Hempstead Lake State Park Carousel Restoration project consisted of the complete disassembly, storage, transportation, and restoration of the mechanism, facade, and figures and re- assembly of an antique, portable carousel. The thirty -two (32) wooden figures and two (2) chariots were carved by M.C. Illions & Sons, and the mechanism and frame were built by William F. Mangles. In addition to the wooden Illions figures, this carousel also contained eight (8) cast aluminum figures manufactured by Allen Herschell Co. The carousel is a 14- section machine, with three (3) figures abreast and a 36 -foot diameter platform. The restoration requirements for both the figures and fagade, and the frame and mechanism were stringent with respect to maintaining the period look and design of the artistic pieces. In addition to bringing the drive unit and electrical systems up to code, this carousel restoration also required the construction of replica pieces for almost all of the fagade work due to the extremely poor condition of the original pieces. We also converted one (1) of the chariots to meet with ADA standards. All original pieces not used on the carousel were returned to owner for their historic value. This restoration was completed and the carousel installed in the early part of 2004. Carousel: The Columbus Zoo Carousel (originally the Scioto Ranch park carousel) Year: 2000 Contact: Wayne Rogers (614) 645 -3438 Maintenance Supervisor, Columbus Zoo 9990 Riverside Drive Powell, OH 43065 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works 100% of band organ restoration by Stinson Band Organ Company Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 10 Carousel Works, Inc. The Columbus Zoo Carousel Restoration project consisted of the complete disassembly, storage, transportation, and restoration of the mechanism, facade, and figures and re- assembly of an antique carousel. This classic 1914 Mangels- Illions carousel consists of fifty -two (52) horses and two (2) chariots. The figures were originally painted in the "Coney Island" style. The frame and mechanism were built by William F. Mangles. In addition to the carousel figures and frame, this project also contained the restoration of a Wurlitzer 153 band organ. While the Stinson Organ Company of Bellefontaine, OH restored the band organ mechanism; Carousel Works, Inc. provided the paint and restoration for the band organ facade. The carousel is an 18- section machine, with (3) figures abreast and a 48 -foot diameter platform. In addition to bringing the drive unit and electrical systems up to code, this carousel restoration also required the construction of replica pieces for almost all of the facade work due to the extremely poor condition of the original pieces. All original pieces not used on the carousel were returned to owner for their historic value. This restoration was completed and the carousel installed in the summer of 2000. Carousel: Eden Palais Carousel (World's Largest Carousel) Year: 1994 -2001 Contact: Robert Ridgeway (708) 639 -3769 789 Plum Tree Road Barrington, IL 60010 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works This carousel restoration project for a private owner, Mr. Jasper Sanfilippo, encompassed the rehabilitation of part of the Eden Palais Carousel that was built in France during the 1890's. This restoration consisted of the rehabilitation to the primer stage of twenty -four (24) horses, five (5) gondolas, and the show front facade (94ft X 30ft dimension). Carousel Works — Complete Reference List Page 11 Carousel Works, Inc. Carousel: Cass County Carousel Year: 1994 -1995 Contact: Bridgette Eberhardt (269) 574 -8725 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Cass County Carousel located at Riverside Park is a Dentzel Carousel with all standing figures. This project consisted in the complete restoration of the figures, facade and frame. Carousel: Public Museum of Grand Rapids Carousel Year: 1993 Contact: Gary Fraser (616) 456 -3764 Grand Rapids, MI Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Public Museum of Grand Rapids Carousel project included the installation of a new Drive Unit and bringing the electrical components up to code. Carousel: Henry Ford Museum Carousel Year: 1993-1994 Contact: Mary Fahey (313) 271 -1620, ext. 600 Dearborn, MI Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Henry Ford Museum Carousel Project consisted of the complete restoration of fifteen (15) figures, including full documentation of original color. This Herschell- Spillman Carousel is a 12- section machine, with three (3) figures abreast - the carousel hosts thirty (30) figures and two (2) chariots. Carousel: Indianapolis Children's Museum Year: 1992 Contact: Bob Sutton (317) 334 -3618 The Children's Museum PO Box 3000 Indianapolis, IN 46206 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Indianapolis Children's Museum Carousel restoration project consisted of transporting a previously disassembled carousel to our facilities, the total restoration of the frame and mechanism, and the re- assembly of the carousel at the museum. Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 12 Carousel Works, Inc. Carousel: The Battleship Cove Carousel Year: 1990 -1991 Contact: Steve Parr (508) 324 -2000 Fall River Office of Economic Development One Government Center Fall River, MA 02722 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Battleship Cove Carousel restoration project consisted of transporting a previously disassembled carousel to our facilities, the total restoration of the mechanism, facade, and figures and the re- assembly of the carousel into a new facility, which happened to be the second floor of an existing building. This carousel was the Philadelphia Toboggan Company Carousel No. 54, originally installed at Lincoln Park in North Dartmouth in the 1920s. It consisted of forty -eight (48) horses, the twenty -eight (28) inner and middle row horses are jumpers, and two (2) chariots. This restoration also included the oil paintings, glass shields, rounding boards, ceiling panels, step -ups, the remainder of the decorative enclosure, and bringing all the electrical components and drive system up to code. This carousel is an 18- section machine, with three (3) figures abreast and a 48 -foot diameter platform. This frame consists of a wooden center pole supported and braced by wood mudsills and braces. Carousel: Santa Monica Pier Carousel Year: 1990 -1991 Contact: Elaine Mutchnik (310) 656 -1698 Santa Monica Pier Restoration Corporation 201 Santa Monica Pier Santa Monica, CA 90401 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Santa Monica Pier Carousel was built by the Philadelphia Toboggan Company (PTC #62) in 1922. In 1990 -1991 we completed a total restoration of all the forty -three (43) figures and two (2) chariots. Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 13 Carousel Works, Inc. Carousel: Bushnell Park Carousel Year: 1989 Contact: Bushnell Park Foundation (860) 232 -6710 31 Pratt St, 3rd Floor Hartford, CT 06103 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Bushnell Carousel Restoration project consisted of the complete disassembly, storage, transportation, and restoration of the mechanism, facade, and figures and re- assembly of the carousel. This classic 1914 Stein and Goldstein is an 18 section carousel consisting of forty -eight (48) horses and two (2) chariots. The frame and mechanism were built by William F. Mangles. In addition to the carousel figures and frame, this project also contained the restoration of a Wurlitzer 153 band organ facade. This restoration was completed and the carousel installed in 1989. Carousel: Ross Park Zoo Carousel Year: 1988 -1989 Contact: Dee Janis (607) 724 -5461 Ross Park Zoo 185 Park Avenue Binghamton, NY 13903 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Ross Park Zoo Carousel restoration project consisted of the complete disassembly, storage, transportation, and restoration of the mechanism, facade, and figures and re- assembly of the carousel. The facade restoration included 16 scenery panels (with new paintings), 16 Rounding Boards, 16 Rounding Board Shields. The figure restoration included sixty (60) figures and two (2) chariots. This restoration of this classic Allen Herschell carousel was completed and the carousel installed in 1989. Carousel: Conneaut Lake Park Carousel Year: 1987 Contact: Kris Wilson (330) 549 -5589 Conneaut Lake Park R.D. 4, Box 283 Conneaut Lake, PA 16316 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 14 Carousel Works, Inc. The Conneaut Lake Carousel Restoration project consisted of the restoration of the carousel frame, center surround, and scenery panels. The project also included restoration of twenty -six (26) horses and eight (8) new wooden horses that were carved in the Mueller style to fit the theme of the carousel. Carousel: City of Bridgeport Year: 1998 -1999 Contact: Greg Dancho (203) 394 -6575 Connecticut's Beardsley Zoo 1875 Noble Avenue Bridgeport, CT 06610 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The carousel restoration project for the City of Bridgeport, CT consisted of the rehabilitation of thirty -seven (37) horses, two (2) chariots, and twenty (20) top scenery panels for the carousel located at the Beardsley Zoo. Carousel: Bland's Park Carousel (Now DelGrossos Amusement Park) Year: 1987 Contact: Peter Gardella (814) 684 -3538 DelGrosso's Amusement Park Old Route 220 Tipton, PA 16684 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Blands Park Carousel Restoration project consisted of the restoration and painting of Bland's Park's thirty -six (36) Herschell- Spillman carousel horses and two (2) chariots. Carousel: Riverside Park Carousel Year: 1986 -1987 Contact: Unknown (The park has been sold to Six Flags) Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The Riverside Park Carousel restoration consisted of the rehabilitation of the Illions figures and chariots up to the primer stage. This project required us to strip the figures, document the original colors, repair broken joints and cracks and seal the figures in primer. Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 15 Carousel Works, Inc. Carousel: Lake Compounce Carousel Year: 1985 -1986 Contact: Paul S. Serff - President (512) 4 76 -44 72 (During this restoration project, Mr. Serff was the President of Hershey Entertainment Co. and our contact for the entire project.) Texas Travel Industry Association 812 San Antonio St. - Suite 401 Austin, TX 78701 Project: 100% of project completed by Carousel Works The restoration of the Lake Compounce Carousel consisted of the complete restoration of the figures, facade, and frame of the Looff & Carmel carousel originally built in 1912. No mechanical restoration was needed. Carousel Works - Complete Reference List Page 16 1 • F h - -APA 82(110 PV�t�B , r r ri F 4 s� F h - -APA 82(110 PV�t�B R WNI,� ��s n ' �a S .+Ks MAj y' Ack 41 MIA y 'F. . AV L PLANNING & ,,, ZONIN�� a wt oft . R o� 4,k i` A, , 4 k6l ,;` �r r �r?: .. 4. .� _ `�. — .,_ __ __ � '""� w _. e ' -.,, �. Cotleur& HearingLandscape Architects 1 Land Planners I Environmental Consultants 1934 Commerce Lane • Suite 1 • Jupiter, Florida • 33458 • Ph 561.747.6336 • Fax 561.747.1377 • www.cotleurhearing.com • Lic # LC- C000239 Downtown at the Gardens Carousel Miscellaneous Petition for Art in Public Places Project Budget • Per section 78 -261 the cost is based on 1 % of vertical construction for a new development. • In 2005 Downtown at the Gardens was completed and was required to provide artwork equivalent to the amount of $320,000 (1 % of vertical construction cost). • Three artworks were provided that were valued at more than the required 1 % at $360,000. • Today the applicant is requesting to replace one of the three artworks which was valued at $105,000. • Since the applicant had originally provided $40,000 over the requirement, the deficit for Downtown to comply with the requirement is $65,000. • Estimated budget for new AIPP = $405,750 Cost of Carousel Unit $350,000 Sound System $3,000 Safety Rail $15,000 Concrete Pad for unit $6,000 Electric Service $2,500 ADA Ramp to unit $250 Ticket Booth $4,000 Token Machine $2,000 Benches $6,000 Demolition and Excavation $10,000 Lighting $7,000 TOTAL 1$405,750 v' o Downtown at the Gardens Proposed Carousel O 'rs Art in Public Places - Background • Resolution 19 - 2005 approved 3 pieces of Art for DATG — Palace at East Valet — Pool at South Valet — The Water Bridge at the South Courtyard • The Berman's took ownership and deemed the The Water Bridge a safety liability. • The Berman's placed $65,000 in escrow with the City after the removal of The Water Bridge to bring them in compliance for their AIPP requirement until a new piece of art is installed. Proposed Art in Public Places • Downtown at the Gardens is seeking approval for a custom carousel. • The proposed artwork will be commissioned by Carousel Works the world's largest manufacturer and restorer of wooden carousels. The artwork will be located in the Small Courtyard. (former location of The Water Bridge.) Carousel Works (abbreviated) Biography • Leading Manufacturer and Restorer of Wooden Carousel in the World • Started by Art Richie a master carver and Daniel Jones a master carpenter in 1986 • Resume Highlights — Royal Caribbean —Oasis of the Sea — Bronx Zoo Carourel — Central Park Carousel (Restoration) Carousel Location Carousel Location NE1N SHOP NFOLE FOODS / / j 1i;�lt5• Czia:i�y fi7�na �'� : \�\ 1``,� • �j `` . /i � `, 7, f� 36' Carousel SafM/ Fence ��� —Cx aGip C�umrr. 1 III —JA I II i I I DOWNTOWN AT THE GARDENS 6t;$ It 1 G \OOURFI LII SITE PLAN li I I RERNIAN ENTERPRISES II H I"I .wa _m0—gcn :r4cas Design Vision for Downtown Carousel • Create a fun and whimsical atmosphere for both children and adults to play and discover art in an exciting and educational way. • Create a nostalgic feeling for the young at heart • Create a Carousel which feels contextually at home within the modern architecture of Downtown at the Gardens • Create a Carousel that is truly unique to Downtown at the Gardens inspired by the local history and environment of the City Palm Beach Gardens, Palm Beach County and the state of Florida. Carousel Components - Figures Carousel Facade Component Locations Sample Figure Sample Figure Figures • "Horses in a Garden" - Whimsical, fanciful, natural creations • 27 figures, 2 spinning and 1 ADA chariot • Majority Horses with a variety of other animals native to South Florida such as, Loggerhead Sea Turtle, Sandhill Crane, Wood Stork and Blue Heron • Figures will be adorned with trappings found in nature - native Birds and Flowers • Create subtleties, so a child will "discover" things intergraded in the carving • The figures will be painted so the underlying wood shows through Carousel Components - Center Surround Carousel Facade Component Locations Center Surround I, s_ , 1 �j Center Surround • Top half of the panels will contain mirrors within a frame The middle section will alternate between a replicated carving of The Gardens Banyan tree and colorful painted arrangement of local flora and fauna. • Lower section will contain framed painting of coastal colors. Carousel Components Internal Mural and Radiating Beams Carousel Facade Component Locations Internal Mural and Radiating Beams 31 VAL \ Internal Mural and Radiating Beams • Internal Mural will be hand painted scenes of local marine life. Beams radiating out from the internal painting will be stenciled in red. Carousel Components Rounding Boards Carousel Facade Component Locations Rounding Boards i 1. Rounding Boards The larger panels will be South Florida bird scenes with a gold frame and a blue background The smaller frames will depict local history within a oval shape with orange and orange blossoms cascading from the top. Carousel Components Carousel Base Carousel Facade Component Locations Carousel Base • The carousel base will be built of Ipe wood. I pe wood — Environmentally Sustainable — Strong Non -Slip surface — Contains slight gaps between boards to prevent water from puddling on the deck. Carousel Components Education Material Carousel Facade Component Locations Education Materials • Attached to the perimeter safety fence, materials /plakes will be provides to teach people about the carousel and its design componets. — Carousel as Art — Historical Elements — Plants and Animals Used Carousel Components Lighting System Carousel Facade Component Locations Lighting System • The carousel will be lit with 270 -300 60 Volt LED bulbs with an E14 base. The bulbs are attached to the underside of the f carousel canopy • The LED bulbs are 75% more efficient than incandescent bulbs. Downtown at the Gardens Proposed Carousel