Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Council Agenda 101112 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS COUNCIL AGENDA October 11, 2012 7:00 P.M. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL III. ADDITIONS, DELETIONS, MODIFICATIONS: IV ANNOUNCEMENTS / PRESENTATIONS: a. PRESENTATION OF THE GFOA – GOVERNMENT FINANCE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION BUDGET AWARD. V. ITEMS OF RESIDENT INTEREST AND BOARD/COMMITTEE REPORTS: VI. CITY MANAGER REPORT: VII. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC: (For Items Not on the Agenda, please submit request form to the City Clerk prior to this Item) VIII. CONSENT AGENDA: a. (Page 3) APPROVE MINUTES FROM SEPTEMBER 13, 2012 CITY COUNCIL MEETING. b. (Page 10) APPROVE MINUTES FROM SEPTEMBER 20, 2012 CITY COUNCIL MEETING c. (Staff Report on Page 13, Resolution on Page 19) RESOLUTION 84, 2012 - APPROVING AN AGREEMENT FOR ECONOMIC EVELOPMENT INCENTIVES WITH TBC CORPORATION. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE AN ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT INCENTIVES AGREEMENT WITH TBC-TIRE & BATTERY CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. IX. PUBLIC HEARINGS: (* Designates Quasi-Judicial Hearing) a. *(Staff Report on Page 31, Resolution on Page 63) RESOLUTION 78, 2012 - PGA COMMONS PARCEL 2 PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT AMENDMENT. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING AN AMENDMENT TO THE PGA COMMONS PARCEL 2 PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT (PUD) TO ALLOW MODIFICATIONS TO THE APPROVED SITE PLAN, SPECIFICALLY RELATED TO ACCENT LIGHTING, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN; PROVIDING WAIVERS; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. Mayor Levy Vice Mayor Premuroso Council Member Tinsley Council Member Russo Council Member Jablin X. RESOLUTIONS: a. (Staff Report on Page 67, Resolution on Page 69) RESOLUTION 89, 2012 – APPOINT MEMBERS TO THE ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING THE APPOINTMENT OF REGULAR AND ALTERNATE MEMBERS TO THE ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. b. (Staff Report on Page 84, Resolution on Page 86) RESOLUTION 90, 2012 – APPOINT MEMBERS TO THE RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING THE APPOINTMENT OF REGULAR AND ALTERNATE MEMBERS TO THE PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. c. (Staff Report on Page 113, Resolution on Page 116) RESOLUTION 91, 2012 – APPOINT MEMBERS TO THE PLANNING ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING THE APPOINTMENT OF REGULAR AND ALTERNATE MEMBERS TO THE PLANNING, ZONING, AND APPEALS BOARD; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. d. (Memo on Page 167, Resolution on Page 178) RESOLUTION 93, 2012 – AMENDMENT 4 TO THE FLORIDA CONSTITUTION. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA CONCERNING AMENDMENT 4 TO THE FLORIDA CONSTITUTION WHICH, IF ADOPTED, WOULD CREATE ADDITIONAL INEQUITIES IN FLORIDA’S TAX SYSTEM BY GRANTING CERTAIN TAX BREAKS TO SOME TAXPAYERS AT THE EXPENSE OF OTHER TAXPAYERS; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. XI. ITEMS FOR COUNCIL ACTION/DISCUSSION: XII. CITY ATTORNEY REPORT: XIII. ADJOURNMENT PLEASE TAKE NOTICE AND BE ADVISED that if any interested party wishes to appeal any decision made by the City Council with respect to any matter considered at this public hearing, such interested persons will need a record of the proceedings and may need to ensure that a verbatim record is made, including the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and Section 286.26, Florida Statutes, persons with disabilities needing special accommodations in order to participate in this proceeding are entitled to the provision of certain assistance at no cost. Please call the City Clerk’s Office at 561-799-4122 no later than 5 days prior to the hearing if this assistance is required. For hearing impaired assistance, please call the Florida Relay Service Numbers: 800-955-8771 (TDD) or 800-955-8770 (VOICE). NOTE: All presentation materials must be received by the City Clerk prior to the presentation to the Council. CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING PAGE 1 09-13-12 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS 1 CITY COUNCIL 2 REGULAR MEETING 3 September 13, 2012 4 5 The regular meeting was called to order at 7:02 p.m. by Mayor Levy. 6 I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 7 II. ROLL CALL 8 PRESENT: Mayor Levy, Vice Mayor Premuroso, Council Member Tinsley, Council Member 9 Russo, Council Member Jablin. 10 ABSENT: None. 11 III. ADDITIONS, DELETIONS, MODIFICATIONS 12 None. 13 IV. ANNOUNCEMENTS AND PRESENTATIONS 14 None. 15 V. ITEMS OF RESIDENT INTEREST AND BOARD/COMMITTEE REPORTS 16 Council Member Marcie Tinsley: Attended the funeral of Officer St. Laurent and expressed 17 condolences to his family; the League of Cities conference; PGA Corridor Executive Board 18 Meeting; announced the upcoming County Commission Public Hearing; Mayor’s Literacy 19 Luncheon; Police Explorers Golf Tournament; Chamber of Commerce Mayor’s Breakfast; 20 expressed wishes for a Happy New Year to the Jewish Community. 21 Council Member Joe Russo: Expressed condolences to Officer St. Laurent’s family; attended 22 the North County Economic Development Advisory Board Meeting; expressed wishes for a 23 Happy New Year to the Jewish Community. 24 Vice Mayor Bert Premuroso: Attended the PBGYAA annual meeting. 25 Council Member Eric Jablin: Expressed condolences to Officer St. Laurent’s family; attended 26 the 9/11 countywide remembrance at Christ Fellowship. 27 Mayor David Levy: Thanked the parents of the PBGYAA; attended the 9/11 countywide 28 remembrance at Christ Fellowship; announced the upcoming soccer opening. 29 VI. CITY MANAGER REPORT Discussed Tropical Storm Isaac and the City’s drainage 30 system; Pavement Management Program; thanked the Code & Building Department for their 31 volunteer services as part of the Community Action Support Team (CAST); announced that 32 David Reyes and Michael Morrow received National Public Works Association awards. 33 VII. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC 34 Irish Scheibl, 1029 Siena Oaks Circle West, Palm Beach Gardens; Kevin Easton, 8511 40th 35 Terrace North, Palm Beach Gardens. 36 VIII. CONSENT AGENDA 37 a. APPROVE MINUTES FROM AUGUST 9, 2012 CITY COUNCIL MEETING. 38 b. RESOLUTION 76, 2012 - APPOINTING THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS AS 39 ADDITIONAL MEMBER OF THE CANVASSING BOARD. A RESOLUTION OF THE 40 CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPOINTING 41 THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS, OR DESIGNEE, AS AN ADDITIONAL MEMBER OF 42 THE CITY’S CANVASSING BOARD; REQUESTING THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS, 43 OR DESIGNEE, TO CANVASS ALL ABSENTEE BALLOTS, TO CONDUCT THE LOGIC 44 AND ACCURACY TESTING OF THE ELECTRONIC ELECTION MACHINERY AND 45 TABULATION EQUIPMENT FOR THE CITY; CERTIFY THE RESULTS OF THE 46 GENERAL ELECTION; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER 47 PURPOSES. 48 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING PAGE 2 09-13-12 c. RESOLUTION 82, 2012 - INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT WITH JUPITER INLET 1 COLONY. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH 2 GARDENS, FLORIDA BETWEEN THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS AND 3 JUPITER INLET COLONY TO PROVIDE DISPATCH AND COMMUNICATIONS 4 OPERATIONS; AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE THE AGREEMENT; 5 PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 6 d. RESOLUTION 83, 2012 - APPROVE THE COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT. 7 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, 8 FLORIDA APPROVING AND RATIFYING ARTICLE 28, SALARY PLAN, OF THE 9 COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT WITH THE SERVICE EMPLOYEES 10 INTERNATIONAL UNION/FLORIDA PUBLIC SERVICES UNION FOR THE FISCAL 11 YEAR 2012-2013; AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE 12 SAID AGREEMENT; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 13 e. RESOLUTION 85, 2012 – AUDITING SERVICES. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY 14 COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING 15 ADDENDUM I TO THE AGREEMENT FOR INDEPENDENT AUDIT SERVICES WITH 16 RAMPELL & RAMPELL, P.A.; AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE 17 ADDENDUM I TO THE AGREEMENT; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR 18 OTHER PURPOSES. 19 f. RESOLUTION 88, 2012 – SUPPORT PROTECT OUR BEACHES, INC. A RESOLUTION 20 OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA 21 SUPPORTING PROTECT OUR BEACHES, INC., A COALITION TO FINDING A 22 PERMANENT, ECOLOGICALLY SOUND SOLUTION TO PROTECTING OUR BEACHES 23 AND DUNES FROM EROSION; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER 24 PURPOSES. 25 g. TENNIS CONTRACTORS – DUE TO THE SUCCESS OF THE TENNIS PROGRAM, 26 PATRICK MUNROE, AND HUY NGUYEN EXPECT TO EXCEED THE CONTRACT 27 THRESHOLD OF $65,000.00 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2012-2013. MR. MUNROE AND MR. 28 NGUYEN HAVE MADE IT POSSIBLE FOR THE CITY TO EARN ADDITIONAL 29 REVENUE DUE TO THEIR PROFESSIONAL EXPERTISE AND POPULARITY WITH 30 PATRONS. 31 h. LOCAL COURIER SERVICES – THE CONTRACT WITH ZAP LOGISTICS, LLC, WILL 32 ALLOW THE CITY TO PURCHASE LOCAL COURIER SERVICES FOR THE DELIVERY 33 OF MAIL AND DEPOSITS TO THE BANK FOR VARIOUS CITY DEPARTMENTS. THIS 34 AGREEMENT IS A PIGGYBACK OF A COMPETITIVELY BID AND AWARDED MIAMI-35 DADE COUNTY CONTRACT. EXTENSIVE MARKET RESEARCH WAS CONDUCTED 36 TO LOCATE A CONTRACT TO PIGGYBACK FOR COURIER SERVICES. 37 i. POOL CHEMICALS AND SUPPLIES – THE CONTRACT WITH GOMEZ CHEMICALS, 38 INC DBA BEACH-O-RAMA WILL ALLOW THE CITY TO PURCHASE POOL 39 CHEMICALS, SUPPLIES, AND RELATED ITEMS FOR THE RECREATION DIVISION 40 AND TO MAINTAIN THE SWIMMING POOLS IN A HEALTHY AND SAFE CONDITION 41 FOR USE BY CITY RESIDENTS AND OTHER PARTICIPANTS. 42 j. JANITORIAL SUPPLIES AND CHEMICALS – RENEWAL OF AN AGREEMENT WITH 43 INTERLINE BRANDS, INC. DBA AMSAN TO PIGGYBACK A CITY OF SUNRISE 44 CONTRACT TO PURCHASE JANITORIAL SUPPLIES AND CHEMICALS. THE VARIOUS 45 SUPPLIES AND CHEMICALS AVAILABLE ON THE CONTRACT WERE 46 COMPETITIVELY SOLICITED AND MEET THE NEEDS AND REQUIREMENTS OF THE 47 PARKS AND PUBLIC FACILITIES DEPARTMENT. 48 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING PAGE 3 09-13-12 k. CANAL LONG-LINE MOWING SERVICES – THE CONTRACT WITH THE GRASS 1 ROOTS CORP. WILL ALLOW THE CITY TO PURCHASE CANAL LO NG-LINE MOWING 2 SERVICES FOR VARIOUS CITY PROPERTIES FOR A PERIOD OF FIVE YEARS. THE 3 NEW CONTRACT PRICES ARE LESS THAN THE CURRENT PRICES BEING PAID TO 4 THE INCUMBENT VENDOR AND THE CITY WILL REALIZE SAVINGS OF $78,818 5 OVER THE FIVE-YEAR TERM OF THE CONTRACT. THE PURCHASE OF CANAL 6 LONG-LINE MOWING SERVICES IS NECESSARY FOR THE HEALTH, SAFETY, AND 7 WELFARE OF CITY RESIDENTS AND MAINTAINS AN AESTHETIC OF CLEANLINESS 8 AND ORDER FOR THE CITY. 9 l. SUPPLEMENTAL AGREEMENT WITH BALLARD AND PARTNERS FOR CITY 10 LOBBYING SERVICES –THE CITY AWARDED A CONTRACT TO BALLARD 11 PARTNERS, INC. FOR PROVISION OF APPROPRIATIONS LOBBYIST SERVICES, WITH 12 AN EXPIRATION DATE OF SEPTEMBER 30, 2014. PURSUANT TO THE PROVISIONS 13 OF THE AGREEMENT, THE CITY AND CONTRACTOR ARE REQUIRED TO AGREE ON 14 A NEW PRICE FOR FISCAL YEARS 2012-2013 AND 2013-2014. THE CONTRACTOR 15 HAS PROPOSED A FIXED AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY 16 THOUSAND DOLLARS ($120,000) (SIXTY THOUSAND DOLLARS - $60,000 PER YEAR) 17 FOR THE REMAINDER OF THE CONTRACT TERM. 18 Council Member Jablin made a motion for approval of the Consent Agenda. 19 Council Member Tinsley seconded. 20 Motion passed 5-0. 21 IX. PUBLIC HEARINGS: (*Designates Quasi-Judicial Hearing) 22 Those preparing to give testimony were sworn in. 23 a. PRESENTATION OF THE FISCAL YEAR 2012/2013 BUDGET. 24 Mayor Levy opened the Public Hearing. 25 Staff presentation: Finance Administrator, Allan Owens. 26 Budget Oversight Committee Annual Report, presented by Chairman, Phillip Woodall. 27 Public Comment: Marilyn Jacobs, 16 Bermuda Lake Drive, Palm Beach Gardens. 28 Mayor Levy closed the Public Hearing. 29 Council Member Jablin made a motion to adopt a proposed operating millage rate of 5.7404 30 mills and debt millage rate of .1790 for a total tentative rate of 5.9194 mills for fiscal year 31 2012/2013. Staff recommends an announcement be made declaring that the proposed rate 32 exceeds the roll-back rate by 1.19%. 33 Council Member Tinsley seconded. 34 Motion passed 5-0. 35 The City Clerk read Ordinance 26, 2012 by title. 36 b. ORDINANCE 26, 2012 – (1ST READING) ADOPTING FISCAL YEAR 2012/2013 37 BUDGET. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH 38 GARDENS, FLORIDA ADOPTING THE BUDGET FOR THE CITY OF PALM BEACH 39 GARDENS FOR THE FISCAL YEAR COMMENCING OCTOBER 1, 2012, AND ENDING 40 SEPTEMBER 30, 2013; PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE AND A SEVERABILITY 41 CLAUSE; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 42 Mayor Levy opened the Public Hearing. 43 Staff presentation: Finance Adminisrator, Allan Owens. 44 Public comment: None. 45 Mayor Levy closed the Public Hearing. 46 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING PAGE 4 09-13-12 Council Member Jablin made a motion to approve Ordinance 26, 2012 on first reading, 1 adopting a tentative budget for fiscal year 2012/2013 and setting the second and final reading for 2 September 20, 2012 at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers. 3 Council Member Tinsley seconded. 4 Motion passed 5-0. 5 The City Clerk read Ordinance 22, 2012 by title. 6 c. ORDINANCE 22, 2012 – (2ND READING AND ADOPTION) BUSINESS TAX LAW 7 CHANGES. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH 8 GARDENS, FLORIDA AMENDING CHAPTER 66. TAXATION. AT ARTICLE II. 9 BUSINESS TAX AND REGISTRATION. BY CREATING AN ENTIRELY NEW SECTION 10 66-65 TO PROVIDE A NEW STATUTORILY MANDATED EXEMPTION FOR REAL 11 ESTATE BROKER ASSOCIATES AND SALES ASSOCIATES; BY RE-NUMBERING THE 12 EXISTING SECTION 66-65 AND ALL FOLLOWING SECTIONS IN THIS ARTICLE 13 ACCORDINGLY; AND BY AMENDING THE EXISTING FEE SCHEDULE TO CONFORM 14 WITH THE NEW EXEMPTION AND ELIMINATE THE BUSINESS TAX FOR 15 INDIVIDUAL REAL ESTATE SALES AGENTS AND BROKERS; PROVIDING THAT 16 EACH AND EVERY OTHER SECTION AND SUBSECTION OF CHAPTER 66. 17 TAXATION. SHALL REMAIN THE SAME AS PREVIOUSLY ADOPTED; PROVIDING A 18 CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY; 19 PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 20 Mayor Levy opened the Public Hearing. 21 Staff presentation: Business Services Coordinator, Kenthia White. 22 Public comment: None. 23 Mayor Levy closed the Public Hearing. 24 Council Member Jablin made a motion to approve Ordinance 22, 2012 on 2nd reading and 25 adoption. 26 Vice Mayor Premuroso seconded. 27 Motion passed 5-0. 28 The City Clerk read Ordinance 23, 2012 by title. 29 d. ORDINANCE 23, 2012 – (2nd READING AND ADOPTION) FIRE PENSION. AN 30 ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, 31 FLORIDA AMENDING CHAPTER 38. FIRE PREVENTION AND PROTECTION. OF THE 32 CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, AT 33 ARTICLE II. FIREFIGHTERS’ PENSION FUND. IN ORDER TO IMPLEMENT 34 PROVISIONS OF THE 2012-2015 COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT BETWEEN 35 THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS AND THE PROFESSIONAL FIREFIGHTERS 36 AND PARAMEDICS OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, LOCAL 2928, IAFF, INC.; AMENDING 37 SECTION 38-51. DEFINITIONS. BY REVISING THE DEFINITION OF “SALARY”; 38 AMENDING SECTION 38-55. CONTRIBUTIONS. PROVIDING FOR AN INCREASE IN 39 MEMBER CONTRIBUTIONS AND PROVIDING FOR A DECREASE IN MEMBER 40 CONTRIBUTIONS TO BE FUNDED BY EXCESS PREMIUM TAX REVENUES; 41 AMENDING SECTION 38-56. BENEFIT AMOUNTS AND ELIGIBILITY. REVISING THE 42 NORMAL RETIREMENT BENEFIT AND REVISING THE COST OF LIVING 43 ADJUSTMENT; PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND 44 AUTHORITY TO CODIFY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER 45 PURPOSES. 46 Mayor Levy opened the Public Hearing. 47 Staff presentation: Finance Adminisrator, Allan Owens. 48 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING PAGE 5 09-13-12 Public comment: None. 1 Mayor Levy closed the Public Hearing. 2 Council Member Jablin made a motion to approve Ordinance 23, 2012 on 2nd reading and 3 adoption. 4 Vice Mayor Premuroso seconded. 5 Motion passed 5-0. 6 The City Clerk read Ordinance 24, 2012 by title. 7 e. ORDINANCE 24, 2012 – (2ND READING AND ADOPTION) AMENDMENTS TO THE 8 POLICE PENSION. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM 9 BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA AMENDING CHAPTER 50-POLICE OF THE CODE OF 10 ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA, AT ARTICLE III, 11 POLICE OFFICERS’ RETIREMENT TRUST FUND. IN ORDER TO IMPLEMENT THE 12 CITY COUNCIL’S ACTON RESOLVING THE IMPASSE IN COLLECTIVE BARGAINING 13 NEGOTIATIONS BETWEEN THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS AND THE PALM 14 BEACH COUNTY POLICE BENEVOLENT ASSOCIATION; AMENDING SECTION 50-61. 15 DEFINITIONS., BY REPEALING THE DEFINITION OF “SALARY” AND READOPTING 16 SAME, AS REVISED; BY REPEALING SECTION 50-116. NORMAL RETIREMENT. AND 17 READOPTING SAME, AS REVISED IN ORDER TO AMEND THE NORMAL 18 RETIREMENT DATE AND BENEFITS; BY REPEALING SECTION 50 -135. ANNUAL 19 ADJUSTMENTS. AND READOPTING SAME, AS REVISED IN ORDER TO AMEND THE 20 COST OF LIVING ADJUSTMENT; PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A 21 SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE 22 DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 23 Mayor Levy opened the Public Hearing. 24 Staff presentation: Finance Adminisrator, Allan Owens. 25 Public comment: None. 26 Mayor Levy closed the Public Hearing. 27 Council Member Jablin made a motion to approve Ordinance 24, 2012 on 2nd reading and 28 adoption. 29 Vice Mayor Premuroso seconded. 30 Motion passed 5-0. 31 The City Clerk read Ordinance 25, 2012 by title. 32 f. ORDINANCE 25, 2012 - (2nd READING AND ADOPTION) CLARIFY LANGUAGE FOR 33 CANVASSING BOARD. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF 34 PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA AMENDING CHAPTER 26. ELECTIONS. OF THE 35 CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA BY 36 REPEALING SECTIONS 26-2 AND 26-17 AND READOPTING SAME, AS REVISED, IN 37 ORDER TO REVISE AND CLARIFY THE CITY CLERK’S ELECTION DUTIES AND TO 38 REVISE THE COMPOSITION OF THE CITY’S CANVASSING BOARD; PROVIDING A 39 CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY; 40 PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 41 Mayor Levy opened the Public Hearing. 42 Staff presentation: None. 43 Public comment: None. 44 Mayor Levy closed the Public Hearing. 45 Council Member Jablin made a motion to approve Ordinance 25, 2012 on 2nd reading and 46 adoption. 47 Vice Mayor Premuroso seconded. 48 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING PAGE 6 09-13-12 Motion passed 5-0. 1 The City Clerk read Resolution 81, 2012 by title. 2 g. *RESOLUTION 81, 2012 - DOWNTOWN AT THE GARDENS SHARED PARKING. A 3 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNC IL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, 4 FLORIDA APPROVING AN AMENDMENT TO THE DOWNTOWN AT THE GARDENS 5 SITE PLAN TO APPROVE A SHARED PARKING STUDY AND MODIFY CONDITIONS 6 OF APPROVAL RELATED TO LIGHTING, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED 7 HEREIN; PROVIDING CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL; PROVIDING WAIVERS; 8 PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 9 Mayor Levy opened the Public Hearing. 10 Petitioner Presentation: Donaldson Hearing, Cotleur and Hearing. 11 Staff presentation: Director of Planning & Zoning, Natalie Crowley. 12 Public comment: None. 13 Mayor Levy closed the Public Hearing. 14 Council Member Jablin made a motion to approve Resolution 81, 2012. 15 Council Member Tinsley seconded. 16 Motion passed 5-0. 17 X. RESOLUTIONS 18 The City Clerk read Resolution 86, 2012 by title. 19 a. RESOLUTION 86, 2012 – PROPERTY AND CASUALTY INSURANCE. A RESOLUTION 20 OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA 21 APPROVING AN AGREEMENT WITH FLORIDA LEAGUE OF CITIES, INC. (SPONSOR 22 OF THE FLORIDA MUNICIPAL INSURANCE TRUST (FMIT)) FOR PROP ERTY AND 23 CASUALTY INSURANCE COVERAGE; AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE 24 SUCH AGREEMENT; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER 25 PURPOSES. 26 Staff presentation: Finance Adminisrator, Allan Owens. 27 Public comment: Rob Grand and Sharleen O’Toole, Wells Fargo, 2054 Vista Parkway, West 28 Palm Beach. 29 Council Member Jablin made a motion to approve Resolution 86, 2012. 30 Council Member Russo seconded. 31 Motion passed 5-0. 32 XI. ITEMS FOR COUNCIL ACTION/DISCUSSION 33 Mayor Levy requested a status of the Inspector General Law Suit. 34 Council Member Tinsley announced e-blasts and paperless technology for weekly updates. 35 XII. CITY ATTORNEY REPORT 36 None. 37 (The remainder of this page intentionally left blank.) 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING PAGE 7 09-13-12 XIII. ADJOURNMENT 1 Councilmember Jablin made a motion to adjourn. 2 Councilmember Tinsley seconded. 3 Motion passed 5-0. 4 The meeting adjourned at 9:00 p.m. 5 The next regularly scheduled City Council meeting will be held September 20, 2012. 6 APPROVED: 7 8 9 10 David Levy, Mayor 11 12 13 14 Robert G. Premuroso, Vice Mayor 15 16 17 18 Marcie Tinsley, Councilmember 19 20 21 22 Joseph R. Russo, Councilmember 23 24 25 26 Eric Jablin, Councilmember 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 ATTEST: 35 36 37 38 39 Patricia Snider, CMC 40 City Clerk 41 42 43 44 Note: These minutes are prepared in compliance with 286.011 F.S. and are not verbatim transcripts of the 45 meeting. A verbatim audio record is available from the Office of the City Clerk. 46 All referenced attachments are on file in the Office of the City Clerk. 47 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING PAGE 1 09-20-12 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS 1 CITY COUNCIL 2 REGULAR MEETING 3 September 20, 2012 4 5 The regular meeting was called to order at 7:01 p.m. by Mayor Levy. 6 I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 7 II. ROLL CALL 8 PRESENT: Mayor Levy, Vice Mayor Premuroso, Council Member Tinsley, Council Member 9 Russo, Council Member Jablin. 10 ABSENT: None. 11 III. ADDITIONS, DELETIONS, MODIFICATIONS 12 None. 13 IV. ANNOUNCEMENTS AND PRESENTATIONS 14 None. 15 V. ITEMS OF RESIDENT INTEREST AND BOARD/COMMITTEE REPORTS 16 Council Member Marcie Tinsley: attended the Mayors Breakfast, Literacy Coalition 17 Luncheon, encouraged residents to sign up for the City’s weekly updates via the web-site e-18 blasts, suggested residents review the budget presentation posted on the website. 19 Council Member Joe Russo: made a recommendation to name the Sand Hill Crane Park after 20 Commissioner Karen Marcus and add a brick paver at City Hall. 21 Vice Mayor Bert Premuroso: agreed with Council Member Russo’s recommendation, 22 attended the North County Governmental Meeting. 23 Council Member Eric Jablin: attended the Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council; meeting 24 with the City Manager regarding PGA Boulevard and referenced letter from the Department of 25 Transportation, agreed with Council Member Russo’s recommendation, announced the Green 26 Market will open October 14th. 27 Mayor David Levy: attended the Business Development Board Meeting, Water Resource Task 28 Force Meeting, Lower East Coast Water Supply Meeting, announced Post Doctorate Week. 29 VI. CITY MANAGER REPORT Update on the referendum. 30 Staff Presentation: Assistant to the City Manager, Jamie Voss. 31 VII. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC 32 None. 33 VIII. CONSENT AGENDA 34 a. PURCHASE AWARD FOR CCNA CONTRACT RENEWALS. 35 b. LEASE OF GOLF CARTS – THIS CONTRACT WILL ALLOW THE CITY TO LEASE 36 GOLF CARTS FOR USE AT THE CITY’S MUNICIPAL GOLF COURSE. THIS NEW 37 CONTRACT IS A PIGGYBACK OF A COMPETITIVELY SOLICITED LEASE WITH 38 YAMAHA CORPORATION AWARDED BY THE CITY OF PENSACOLA, FLORIDA. THE 39 PRICES OFFERED BY YAMAHA ARE LOWER THAN THE CURRENT VENDOR, AND 40 LOWER THAN PRICES OFFERED BY ADVANTAGE GOLF CARS, EZ GO, AND CLUB 41 CAR. THE PRICES ARE FIXED FOR THE 48-MONTHS TERM OF THE LEASE 42 AGREEMENT. 43 c. PROCLAMATION – NATIONAL SICKLE CELL MONTH. 44 Council Member Jablin made a motion to approve the Consent Agenda. 45 Council Member Tinsley seconded. 46 Motion passed 5-0. 47 IX. PUBLIC HEARINGS: (*Designates Quasi-Judicial Hearing) 48 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING PAGE 2 09-20-12 a. PRESENTATION OF THE FISCAL YEAR 2012/2013 BUDGET. 1 Mayor Levy opened the Public Hearing. 2 Staff presentation: Finance Administrator, Allan Owens. 3 Public comment: John Chaplik, 715 Hudson Bay Drive, Palm Beach Gardens. 4 Mayor Levy closed the Public Hearing. 5 The City Clerk read Resolution 79, 2012 by title. 6 b. RESOLUTION 79, 2012 - ADOPTING A TAX LEVY AND MILLAGE RATE. A 7 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, 8 FLORIDA ADOPTING A TAX LEVY AND MILLAGE RATE FOR THE CITY OF PALM 9 BEACH GARDENS FOR THE FISCAL YEAR COMMENCING OCTOBER 1, 2012, AND 10 ENDING SEPTEMBER 30, 2013; DIRECTING THE CITY CLERK TO FORWARD A 11 CERTIFIED COPY OF THIS RESOLUTION TO THE PROPERTY APPRAISER AND TAX 12 COLLECTOR WITHIN THREE (3) DAYS AFTER ITS ADOPTION; PROVIDING AN 13 EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 14 Mayor Levy opened the Public Hearing. 15 Public comment: John Chaplik, 715 Hudson Bay Drive, Palm Beach Gardens. 16 Mayor Levy closed the Public Hearing. 17 Council Member Jablin – The City of Palm Beach Gardens is proposing to adopt a final 18 millage rate of 5.9194 mills, which includes a debt millage of .1790 and an operating rate of 19 5.7404 mills, which is greater than the rolled-back rate of 5.6729 by 1.19%. 20 Council Member Jablin made a motion to approve Resolution 79, 2012, setting the final 21 millage rate for fiscal year 2012/2013 at 5.9194 mills. 22 Council Member Russo seconded. 23 Motion passed 5-0. 24 The City Clerk read Ordinance 26, 2012 by title. 25 ORDINANCE 26, 2012 – (2ND READING AND ADOPTION) FISCAL YEAR 2012/2013 26 BUDGET. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH 27 GARDENS, FLORIDA ADOPTING THE BUDGET FOR THE CITY OF PALM BEACH 28 GARDENS FOR THE FISCAL YEAR COMMENCING OCTOBER 1, 2012, AND ENDING 29 SEPTEMBER 30, 2013; PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE AND A SEVERABILITY 30 CLAUSE; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 31 Mayor Levy opened the Public Hearing. 32 Public Comment: None. 33 Mayor Levy closed the Public Hearing. 34 Council Member Jablin made a motion to approve Ordinance 26, 2012 on second and final 35 reading, adopting a final budget for fiscal year 2012/2013. . 36 Council MemberRusso seconded. 37 Motion passed 5-0. 38 X. RESOLUTIONS 39 None. 40 XI. ITEMS FOR COUNCIL ACTION/DISCUSSION 41 Council Member Tinsley discussed the idea of increased literacy, suggested adding additional 42 educational components to our summer programs, story-time, word recognition, access to books 43 and read for the record, made a recommendation for a book drive. 44 Council Member Russo discussed changes to the budget this year. 45 XII. CITY ATTORNEY REPORT 46 None. 47 48 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING PAGE 3 09-20-12 XIII. ADJOURNMENT 1 Councilmember Jablin made a motion to adjourn. 2 Councilmember Tinsley seconded. 3 Motion passed 5-0. 4 The meeting adjourned at 7:42 p.m. 5 The next regularly scheduled City Council meeting will be held October 11, 2012. 6 APPROVED: 7 8 9 10 David Levy, Mayor 11 12 13 14 Robert G. Premuroso, Vice Mayor 15 16 17 18 Marcie Tinsley, Councilmember 19 20 21 22 Joseph R. Russo, Councilmember 23 24 25 26 Eric Jablin, Councilmember 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 ATTEST: 35 36 37 38 39 Patricia Snider, CMC 40 City Clerk 41 42 43 44 Note: These minutes are prepared in compliance with 286.011 F.S. and are not verbatim transcripts of the 45 meeting. A verbatim audio record is available from the Office of t he City Clerk. 46 All referenced attachments are on file in the Office of the City Clerk. 47 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS CITY COUNCIL Agenda Cover Memorandum Meeting Date: October 11, 2012 Resolution 84, 2012 Subject/Agenda Item: Approve an Agreement for Economic Development Incentives with TBC Corporation. [X] Recommendation to APPROVE [ ] Recommendation to DENY Reviewed by: PuCJ;;), 4 Km! Ra Approved By: Originating Dept.: Planning & Zoning: Project Manager QQ~r&eiL_ Allyson'Biack Allan Owens, Finance Administrator 1------------1 Funding Source: Advertised: [ ] Required [X] Not Required [ ] Operating [X] Other Budget Acct.#: 001.0900.519.9928 Contract/Agreement: Effective Date: f-------------1 October 11.2012 / Affected parties: [X] Notified [ ] Not Required Expiration Date: September 30, 2022 or earlier if terms and conditions are met. City Council Action: [ ] Approval [ ] Approved w/ Conditions ] Denial ] Continued to: __ Attachments: • Resolution 63, 2012 • Resolution 84, 2012 • Agreement for Economic Development Incentives with TBC Meeting Date: October 11, 2012 Resolution 84, 2012 Page 2 of2 BACKGROUND: On June 7, 2012, the City Council unanimously approved Resolution 63, 2012, acknowledging to provide "Project Gold" $105,000 for the Qualified Target Industry Tax Refund Program as the required local match under the provisions of Section 288.106, Florida Statutes. and the Resolution also included the approval of an additional $398,000 as local support for the Governor's Quick Action Closing Fund per Section 288.1088, Florida Statutes, with conditions of approval regarding the disbursement of the funds. In August 2012, TBC announced it is expanding its headquarters in Palm Beach Gardens. The expansion follows the company's recent acquisition of Midas Inc., a long- time worldwide leader in the automotive services industry. The approved economic development incentive funds from the City assisted in retaining 120 existing local jobs with an average wage of $87,000. The economic impact projection of retaining these employees, as provided by the Business Development Board, has a total output of $45,261,761 (includes direct, indirect, and induced economic factors). The company has also committed to $12 million in capital investment and the creation of at least 175 new jobs with an average salary of $81,110 in the City of Palm Beach Gardens. This creation of new jobs has a total economic impact projection output of $55,909,167 (includes direct, indirect, and induced economic factors). At this time, the City wishes to enter into an Economic Development Incentives Agreement with TBC Corporation consistent with the terms of the Agreement included in Resolution 63, 2012. ' STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of Resolution 84, 2012 as presented. '· 1 RESOLUTION 63, 2012 2 3 4 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM 5 BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA RECOMMENDING "PROJECT 6 GOLD" BE APPROVED AS A QUALIFIED TARGET INDUSTRY 7 BUSINESS PURSUANT TO SECTION 288.106, FLORIDA 8 STATUTES; PROVIDING CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL FOR THE 9 FUNDING OF THE GRANTS; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; 10 AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 11 12 13 WHEREAS, "Project Gold", the business under consideration, is the nation's 14 largest vertically integrated marketer of tires for the automotive replacement market; 15 and 16 17 WHEREAS, the company is currently headquartered in Palm Beach Gardens, 18 and currently has an estimated 2,532 employees in the State of Florida; and 19 20 WHEREAS, the company is also considering one (1) other location for this new 21 facility, which would eliminate jobs in the City of Palm Beach Gardens and move them 22 out of state; and 23 24 WHEREAS, "Project Gold", under Section 288.108, Florida Statutes, is eligible 25 to apply for the Qualified Target Industry Tax Refund Program; and 26 27 WHEREAS, "Project Gold" plans to consolidate its international and national 28 headquarters into a single location; and 29 30 WHEREAS, "Project Gold" is relocating its training center to Palm Beach 31 Gardens, which is used by 1 ,500 US franchisees and franchisees from 13 other 32 countries; and 33 34 WHEREAS, "Project Gold" will commit to create 175 new jobs with an average 35 wage of $81,110, which is 200% of the Florida statewide average wage for 201 0; and 36 37 WHEREAS, the City of Palm Beach Gardens hereby acknowledges that local 38 financial support of 20% of the total tax refund of $525,000 is required under the 39 provisions of Section 288.106, Florida Statutes, governing the State's Qualified Target 40 Industry Tax Refund Program; and 41 42 WHEREAS, the City of Palm Beach Gardens has committed to provide $105,000 43 for the Qualified Target Industry Tax Refund Program as the required local match; and 44 45 46 Page 1 of 4 Resolution 63, 2012 1 WHEREAS, "Project Gold" is requesting an additional $398,000 as local support 2 for the Quick Action Closing Fund per Section 288.1088, Florida Statutes; and 3 4 WHEREAS, the City currently has funds for the purposes of economic 5 development opportunities; and 6 7 WHEREAS, the City Council deems approval of this Resolution to be in the best 8 interests of the health, safety, and welfare of the residents and citizens of the City of 9 Palm Beach Gardens and the public at large. 10 11 12 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY 13 OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA that: 14 15 SECTION 1. The foregoing recitals are hereby affirmed and ratified. 16 17 SECTION 2. The City Council hereby recommends "Project Gold" be approved 18 as a Qualified Target Industry Business pursuant to Section 288.106, Florida Statutes. 19 The necessary cash commitment of local financial support for the Qualified Target 20 Industry Tax Refund Program exists for "Project Gold" in the amount of $105,000, which 21 constitutes the entire 20% of the required local financial support 22 23 SECTION 3. The City Council hereby recommends "Project Gold" be approved 24 for the Quick Action Closing Fund pursuant to Section 288.1088, Florida Statutes. The 25 necessary cash commitment of local support for the Quick Action Closing Fund exists 26 for "Project Gold" in the amount of $398,000. 27 28 SECTION 4. This approval is subject to the following conditions, which shall be 29 the responsibility of "Project Gold": 30 31 1. The $105,000 local match funding will be made available in accordance with 32 the guidelines set forth by the Department of Economic Opportunity with the 33 stipulation that these funds are intended to represent the "local financial 34 support" required by Section 288.106, Florida Statutes. 35 36 2. The initial installment of the Quick Action Fund of $199,000 will be 37 disbursed when evidence is provided to the City that it has a signed, 38 executed agreement of the Closing Fund Agreement with the Department of 39 Economic Opportunity; the initial 50 new employees are in place; there has 40 been public announcement of the project's location to the City of Palm 41 Beach Gardens; and an investment of at least $4,000,000 in facility 42 purchase, renovations, and/or equipment purchases. 43 44 45 46 Page 2 of 4 -----------··--------·-- Resolution 63. 2012 1 3. The final installment of the Quick Action Fund of $199,000 will be disbursed 2 when evidence is provided to the City that a grand total of 175 new 3 employees with an average salary of $81,11 0; there is evidence provided to 4 the City for the retention of 120 IT positions; and capital investment of at 5 least $12,000,000 by December 31, 2014. 6 7 SECTION 5. This approval shall be consistent with all representations made at 8 any workshop or public hearing. 9 10 SECTION 6. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon adoption. 11 12 13 (The remainder of this page intentionally left blank) 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 Page 3 of 4 Resolution 63, 2012 1 2 3 PASSED AND ADOPTED this 7·r>t-day ot_-:f_v.JJ_-{., _____ , 2012. "4 5 6 ~ 7 "t;f"'. \ . 9 1b 1\U}!)T:. 11·--------- CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA 12 ·--:-- 13 . BY: 14 --~~~~~--------~---- 15 16 17 APPROVED AS TO FO 18 LEGAL SUFFICIENCY 19 20 D 21 BY: 22 ~~~~~~~------------- 23 24 25 26 27 VOTE: 28 29 MAYOR LEVY 30 31 VICE MAYOR PREMUROSO 32 33 COUNCILMEMBER TINSLEY 34 35 COUNCILMEMBER RUSSO 36 37 COUNCILMEMBER JABLIN 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 AYE NAY ABSENT / / / / / 46 47 G:\attorney_share\RESOLUTIONS\2012\Resolution 63 2012-project gold-FINAL.docx Page 4 of 4 --------------------------------- 1 RESOLUTION 84, 2012 2 3 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM 4 BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO 5 EXECUTE AN ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT INCENTIVES 6 AGREEMENT WITH TBC-TIRE & BATTERY CORPORATION AND 7 SUBSIDIARIES; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR 8 OTHER PURPOSES. 9 10 WHEREAS, TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries ("TBC") is the 11 nation's largest vertically integrated marketer of tires for the automotive replacement 12 market; and 13 14 WHEREAS, TBC is currently headquartered in Palm Beach Gardens, and 15 currently has an estimated 2,532 employees in the State of Florida; and 16 17 WHEREAS, TBC was considering one (1) other location for this new facility, 18 which would eliminate jobs in the City of Palm Beach Gardens and move them out of 19 state; and 20 21 WHEREAS, TBC has committed to create 175 new jobs with an average wage of 22 $81,110, which is 180% of the Florida statewide average wage for 201 0; and 23 24 WHEREAS, the City of Palm Beach Gardens City Council approved Resolution 25 63, 2012, authorizing the $105,000 for the Qualified Target Industry Tax Refund 26 Program as the required local match under the provisions of Section 288.106, Florida 27 StatutesiJ. and an additional $398,000 as local support for the Quick Action Closing 28 Fund pursuant to Section 288.1088, Florida Statutes; and 29 30 WHEREAS, the City wishes to enter into an Economic Development Incentives 31 Agreement with TBC, which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A"; and 32 33 WHEREAS, the City Council deems approval of this Resolution to be in the best 34 interests of the health, safety, and welfare of the residents of the City of Palm Beach 35 Gardens and the public at large. 36 37 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY 38 OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA that: 39 40 SECTION 1. The foregoing recitals are hereby affirmed and ratified. 41 42 SECTION 2. The City Council of the City of Palm Beach Gardens hereby 43 accepts and approves the Economic Development Incentives Agreement with TBC-Tire 44 & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries, and authorizes the Mayor to execute same. 45 46 SECTION 3. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon adoption. Page 1 of 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 Resolution 84, 2012 PASSED AND ADOPTED this __ day of ________ , 2012. CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA David Levy, Mayor ATTEST: BY: -------------------Patricia Snider, CMC, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY R. Max Lohman, City Attorney VOTE: MAYOR LEVY VICE MAYOR PREMUROSO COUNCILMEMBER TINSLEY COUNCILMEMBER RUSSO COUNCILMEMBER JABLIN AYE NAY ABSENT G:\attorney_share\RESOLUTIONS\2012\Resolution 84 2012-ED Incentives agreement-TBC.docx Page 2 of 2 Resolution 84, 2012 EXHIBIT "A" p M BEACH GARDENS ·;q unique place 10 lire, learn, work CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS 10500 North Military Trail Palm Beach Gardens, Fl33410 AGREEMENT FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT INCENTIVES BETWEEN THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS AND TBC-TIRE & BATTERY CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES THIS AGREEMENT is entered into by and between the City of Palm Beach Gardens, a municipality organized and existing under the laws of the State of Florida, with a principal address of 10500 North Military Trail, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida 33410 (hereinafter referred to as the "City"), and TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries (hereinafter referred to as 'TBC"), a foreign corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of Delaware, with a principal address of 4300 TBC Way, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida 33410, and whose Federal Employer LD. Number is 310600670. W I T N E S S E T H: WHEREAS, the Florida Legislature enacted Section 288.1088 (hereinafter referred to as the "Act"), which established the Quick Action Closing Fund (hereinafter referred to as "QACF"), which is a discretionary grant that the State provides to certain businesses that are participating in the Qualified Target Industry Tax Refund Program (hereinafter referred to as the "QTI Program") to effectively compete for those businesses and respond to extraordinary economic opportunities; and WHEREAS, the Florida Legislature enacted Chapter 2011-76, Laws of Florida, which states that when awarding funds from the QACF preference shall be given to those projects that include at least a 20% local match of cash or in-kind contributions, which contributions provide a cash savings to the private business entity receiving the incentive awards; and WHEREAS, the Florida legislature enacted Section 166.021, which grants economic development powers to municipalities and acknowledges that the expenditure of public funds for economic development activities is a valid purpose; and WHEREAS, pursuant to the above legislation, it is the policy of the City to stimulate economic growth in the City, by either attracting new business to the City or by encouraging the expansion of existing businesses within the City; and Page 11 of 9 , City of Palm Beach Gardens TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries WHEREAS, the creation of new employment opportunities for residents of the City and the increased tax revenues resulting from such business expansion or relocation within the City is beneficial to the local economy; and WHEREAS, the City Council has determined that providing a local match for the State's Qualified Target Industry Tax Refund Program and the Quick Action Closing Fund encourages existing businesses to expand and encourages new business to enter the City, thereby creating new employment opportunities for the residents of the City; and · WHEREAS, TBC is the nation's largest vertically integrated marketer of tires for the automotive replacement market; and WHEREAS, TBC acquired Midas, Inc., one of the world's largest providers of automotive services; and WHEREAS, TBC is a targeted industry proposing to create job opportunities by expanding its corporate headquarters by purchasing office space in the City; and WHEREAS, TBC considered one (1) other location for this facility, which would have eliminated jobs in the City of Palm Beach Gardens and move them out of the state; and WHEREAS, TBC anticipates creating 175 new jobs in the City with an average salary of Eighty-One Thousand One Hundred Ten Dollars ($81, 11 0.00), which is 180% of the Palm Beach County, Florida average annual wage; and WHEREAS, the State of Florida has agreed to provide TBC a Qualified Target Industry Tax Refund ("QTI") award in the amount of Five Hundred Twenty-Five Thousand Dollars ($525,000.00); and WHEREAS, the City proposes to provide TBC a local match of up to 20% of the total Qualified Target Industry Tax Refund grant amount or One Hundred Five Thousand Dollars ($1 05,000) to be paid in installments to the State over a six-(6) year period beginning in Fiscal Year 2014-2015, which will be based on TBC's overall job creation; and WHEREAS, in addition to the QTI local match, the City will also provide TBC an appropriation of Three Hundred Ninety-Eight Thousand Dollars ($398,000) as local support for the Governor's Quick Action Closing Fund (QACF); and WHEREAS, the City finds and declares it is in the public's best interest to award this economic development incentive grant to TBC pursuant to this Agreement. NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and mutual covenants hereinafter contained, the parties do agree as follows: 1. Recitals. The above recitals are true and correct and form a material part of this Agreement. Page 12 of 9 City of Palm Beach Gardens TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries 2. Incorporation of Premises. The· premise of this Agreement is incorporated herein as if fully set out below. All exhibits to this Agreement are hereby deemed a part hereof. 3: Effective Date. This Agreement shall be effective on the date it is last executed by a party hereto, and shall, unless sooner terminated as provided herein, automatically terminate September 30, 2022. 4. The City's Obligations: Page 13of9 a. The City's local match funding totaling One Hundred Five Thousand Dollar ($1 05,000) in accordance with Section 288.106, Florida Statutes, will be remitted in accordance with the guidelines set forth by the Department of Economic Opportunity. Accordingly, the City will fund the necessary 20% local match each fiscal year as requested by the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity. The City shall appropriate the One Hundred Five Thousand Dollars ($105,000) ("QTI Payments") as local participation for the Qualified Target Industry Tax Refund Program Fund for Fiscal Years 2014/15 through 2019/20 as requested by the State of Florida's Department of Economic Opportunity utilizing the following phasing schedule: Fiscal Year 2014/2015 2015/2016 2016/2017 2017/2018 2018/2019 2019/2020 TOTAL: Scheduled Amount from State $43,500 $87,000 $131,250 $131,250 $87,750 $44,250 $525,000 City's 20% Local Match $8,700 $17,400 $26,250 $26,250 $17,550 $8,850 $105,000 b. The initial installment of the Quick Action Closing Fund (QACF) of One Hundred Ninety-Nine Thousand Dollars ($199,000} will be disbursed to TBC upon TBC's demonstration to the City's reasonable satisfaction that the following milestones have been achieved: i. Provide a copy of the signed, executed agreement of the Quick Action Closing Fund Agreement between TBC and the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity; ii. Demonstrate through appropriate payroll documentation, in a manner and form to be specified by the City, that TBC has hired 50 new employees that will be permanently located at the Palm Beach Gardens facility; Page 14 of9 City of Palm Beach Gardens TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries iii. Provide newspaper clippings and/or documented press releases identifying the project's location within the City of Palm Beach Gardens via newspaper clippings and/or press releases; and iv. Demonstrate that TBC has made an investment of at least Four Million Dollars ($4,000,000) for facility purchase, renovations, and/or equipment purchases via real estate documentation, receipts, and/or documentation of accounts payable. c. The second and final installment of the Quick Action Closing Fund of One Hundred Ninety-Nine Thousand Dollars ($199,000) will be disbursed to TBC upon TBC's demonstration to the City's reasonable satisfaction of the following: i. TBC has at least 175 new jobs that have an average salary of Eighty- One Thousand One Hundred Ten Dollars ($81, 11 0) via appropriate payroll documentation with salaries provided; ii. TBC has at least 120 full-time employees in the Palm Beach Gardens facility via the appropriate payroll documentation and position roster; and iii. TBC has made a capital investment of at least Twelve Million Dollars ($12,000,000.00) in Palm Beach Gardens on or before December 31, 2014, via real estate documentation, receipts, and/or documentation of accounts payable. d. In order to request payment from the City of any of the QACF installments TBC shall: i. Submit a written request to the City for the QACF installment payment along with all supporting documents, statements, and other evidence demonstrating full satisfaction of the payment prerequisites set forth in this Agreement. ii. Upon the City's determination that TBC has satisfied the applicable prerequisites for the subject installment payment, the City shall make the appropriate QACF payment within ninety (90) days of receipt of TBC's written request for same. -·--· -··---------·---- City of Palm Beach Gardens TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries 5. Obligations of TBC: a. TBC shall create 175 new full-time jobs and retain 120 positions, paying an average annual wage of Eighty-One Thousand One Hundred Ten Dollars ($81, 110) from Fiscal Years 2014/2015 through 2019/2020. If the number of jobs created and retained within the City by TBC is less than 175 by Fiscal 2019/2020, TBC shall reimburse the City Three Thousand Dollars ($3,000) for each employment position obligation that has not been created and retained in accordance with the requirements set forth herein. b. TBC shall maintain jobs created for a period of three (3) years after the final QTI Payment is issued for the Project. If TBC fails to maintain such jobs for the entire three-(3) year period, then TBC shall reimburse the City Three Thousand Dollars ($3,000) for each position obligation not maintained for the entire period. c. TBC shall verify employment and jobs created with salary information via an annual report sent to the City by September 1st of each year following the final QTI Payment for three (3) years containing the appropriate payroll documentation and salary information to justify the terms contained in this Agreement. 6. Termination. Page 15 of 9 a. This Agreement shall automatically terminate on September 30, 2022. b. If TBC defaults on any material obligation or material term of this Agreement the City shall provide written notice to TBC of the alleged default, and TBC shall have thirty (30) days thereafter within which to cure same. In the event that the breach or default remains uncured after thirty (30) days the City may provide written notice of termination to TBC and this Agreement shall be terminated and the City may pyrsue any and all legal remedies available to seek reimbursement of funds already paid. c. If the State terminates the QTI Tax Refund Agreement or the Quick Action Closing Fund Agreement, the City will automatically be released from any and all obligations under this Agreement and TBC shall, within sixty (60) days of the State's termination of the above referenced agreements, remit to the City any and all portions of the City's QTI Local match payments that would otherwise be due and owing to the State from the City as a result of the termination of the QTI Tax Refund Agreement or the Quick Action Closing Fund Agreement. d. Failure by the City to enforce a breach of any of the provisions of this Agreement shall not be deemed a waiver of any other or subsequent breach and shall not be construed to be a modification of the terms of this Agreement City of Palm Beach Gardens TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries 7. Records. TBC shall maintain books, records, and other evidence relating to Project Gold in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, procedures, and practices, which documents Project Gold in a manner that fulfills the requirements of this Agreement. 8. Audit. TBC expressly acknowledges that the City shall have the right to audit the books and records from time to time for compliance by TBC with the terms, conditions, limitations, restrictions, and requirements of this Agreement and such right will extend for a period of three (3) years after the term of this Agreement. The City shall, upon reasonable notice, have full access during normal business hours for inspection, review, and audit of the books and records. Any cost incurred by TBC as a result of a City audit shall be the sole responsibility of and shall be borne by TBC. 9. Repayment. TBC shall be liable for repayment of any funds dispersed under the terms of this Agreement, which may be deemed by the City to have been dispersed in error. 10. Indemnification. TBC shall indemnify and hold harmless the City, its agents, employees, and elected and appointed officials from and against all claims, damages, losses, and expenses (including all attorney's costs and fees, and all attorney's costs and fees on appeal) arising out of or resulting from TBC's performance or activities as provided herein. 11. Force Majeure. The parties shall use reasonable diligence to ultimately fulfill the intent of this Agreement but shall not be liable to each other, or their successors or assigns, for damages, costs, attorney's fees (including costs or attorney's fees on appeal) for breach of contract, or otherwise for failure, suspension, diminution, or other variations of services occasioned by any cause beyond the control and without the fault of the parties. Such causes may include, but shall not be limited to, Acts of God or of the public enemy, acts of other government (including regulatory entities or court) in its sovereign or prior contractual capacity, fires, floods, epidemics, quarantines, restrictions, strikes, or failure or breakdown of transmission or other facilities . . 12. Controlling Laws. This Agreement and the provisions contained herein shall be construed, controlled, and interpreted according to the laws of the State of Florida, and all duly adopted ordinances, regulations and policies of the City now in effect and those hereinafter adopted. Venue for any and all claims, controversies, or disputes arising out of or relating to any part of this Agreement, or any breach hereof, shall be in Palm Beach County, Florida. Page 16 of9 City of Palm Beach Gardens TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries 13. Miscellaneous. a. TBC warrants that it has not employed or retained any company or person, other than a bona fide employee or consultant working for TBC, to solicit or secure this Agreement, and that it has not paid or agreed to pay any person, company, corporation, individual, or firm, other than a bona fide employee working solely for TBC, any fee, commission, percentage, gift, or any other consideration that is contingent upon or resulting from the award or making of this Agreement. b. TBC warrants and represents that all of its employees are treated equally during employment without regard to race, color, religion, disability, sex, age, national origin, or marital status. c. This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement between the parties with respect to the specific matters contained herein and supersedes all previous discussions, understandings, and agreements. Amendment to or waivers of the provisions herein shall be made by the parties in writing. d. If any sentence, phrase, paragraph, provision, or portion of this Agreement is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed an independent provision, and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portion hereto. e. If either party has to file suit to enforce the terms of this Agreement the prevailing party shall be entitled to its reasonable attorney's fees and costs, including fees and costs on appeal. 14. Notices. Any notices required or allowed herein shall be in writing and given by certified mail, return receipt requested, or in person with proof of delivery to the addresses below, or such other addresses either party shall have specified by written letters to the other party; delivered in accordance herewith:. Page 17 of 9 City: City of Palm Beach Gardens 10500 North Military Trail PaJm Beach Gardens, Florida 33410 Attn: City Manager TBC: TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries 4300 TBC Way Palm Beach Gardens, Florida 3341 0 Attn: Kyle Benko, Senior Vice President & Corporate Controller City of Palm Beach Gardens TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed these presents and have set their hands and seals each upon the date so indicated. . · STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH TBC-T!RE & BATTERY CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES By: fA~Benko Senior Vice President & Corporate Controller PERsgNALL Y · APP£3ARED before me, the undersigned authority, -~lft..:..'+¥!..!/v.:::::..._..q,.l:J:fJ=._t'f:.!.:1t:d~--· [vf well known to me or [ ] who has produced his/her as identification, and known to me to be the _____________ of TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries, and acknowledged before me that he/she executed the foregoing Agreement on behalf of TBC- Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries, as its true act and deed, and that he/she was duly authorized to do so. WITNESS my hand.and official seal thisL day oft'~&.,..-, 2012. Page 18 of 9 City of Palm Beach Gardens TBC-Tire & Battery Corporation and Subsidiaries IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Agreement on the date first written above. CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA By: ____ -=------:-:-:----:-::-------- David Levy, Mayor ATTEST: By: _____________ _ Patricia Snider, CMC, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY: By: _____________ _ R. Max Lohman, City Attorney STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PALM BEACH PERSONALLY APPEARED before me, the undersigned authority, David Levy, [ ] well known to me or [ ] who has produced his/her as identification, and known to me to be the Mayor of the City of Palm Beach Gardens, and acknowledged before me that he/she executed the foregoing Agreement on behalf of the City of Palm Beach Gardens as its true act and deed, and that he/she was duly authorized to do so. WITNESS my hand and official seal this _ day of ______ , 2012. NOTARY PUBLIC Print Name: --------------My Commission Expires: G:\attorney_share\AGREEMENTS\Econornic Incentive Agreement for TBC -revisions 9-17 -12.docx Page 19 of 9 Subject/Agenda Item: CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS CITY COUNCIL Agenda Cover Memorandum Meeting Date: October 11, 2012 Resolution 78, 2012 Resolution 78, 2012 PGA Commons Parcel 2 Planned Unit Development Amendment Consideration for Approval: A request from PGA Commons Land Trust to make modifications to the site plan of the Rocco's Tacos Restaurant. The PGA Commons Parcel 2 Planned Unit Development (PUD) is located at the southwest corner of PGA Boulevard and Hickory Drive. [X] Recommendation to APPROVE with Waiver and DENY Tiki Torch Color Request [ ] Recommendation to DENY Reviewed by: f Planning & CP Originating Dept.: Planning & Zoning: Project Manager \(1? Kathryn DeWitt, AICP Sr. Planner Finance: Accountant Sarah Varga 1-------------1 Fees Paid: N/A [X] Quasi -Judicial [ ] Legislative Funding Source: 1---[X_] _P_u_b_lic_H_e_a_r_in_g ----1 [ 1 Operating Advertised: [X] Other N/A [X] Required [ ] Not Required Paper: Palm Beach Post Budget Acct.#: N/A t----=-A-p -pr-0-v-ed--=-=B-y -: ___ ____, Date: 09/26/12 Contract/Agreement: ~Affected parties: [X] Notified [ ] Not Required Effective Date: N/A Expiration Date: N/A Council Action: ] Approval ] Approved w/ Conditions ] Denial ] Continued to: __ Attachments: • Development Application • Project Narrative • Location Map • Approved Light Basket Exhibit • Existing Site Photographs • Past Site Photographs • Trademark Green • Approved Site Plans • Resolution 78, 2012 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Meeting Date: October 11 , 2012 Resolution 78 , 2012 Page 2 of 5 PGA Commons Land Trust is requesting to modify the site plan for the Rocco's Tacos Restaurant located within Parcel 2 of the PGA Commons Planned Unit Development (PUD). The modifications include a waiver to allow amber-colored light bulbs within the existing light baskets and a request to change the color of the existing tiki torches from brown to lime green. Both elements are located within the outdoor seating area of the restaurant. Staff is recommending approval of the waiver for the amber light bulbs and denial of the request to change the color of the t iki torches. BACKGROUND On February 11 , 1999, the City Council adopted Ordinance 8, 1999 approving the PGA Commons Parcel 2 PUD to allow 17 townhomes, 6,606 square feet of general office, 7 ,150 square feet of medical office, 12,654 square feet of general retail, 3 ,300 square feet of restaurant, and eight (8) apartment units located above the commercial uses . Numerous amendments have been made since the original approval related to the mix of uses, signage, and site plan. Most recently, two (2) administrative amendments were approved to allow changes to the Rocco's Tacos tenant space. In October 2011 , an administrative amendment (ADMN-11 -07 -000412) was approved to allow modifications to the approved elevations, site plan, and landscape plan for Rocco 's Tacos restaurant in the tenant space previously occupied by Ouzo Blue. The elements of this approval were not implemented or installed in accordance with the approved plans. The tiki torch poles, which were approved to be black, were painted lime green (see Past Site Photographs). The window and door frames, which were not modified with the subject petition, were also painted lime green . The number of light baskets installed exceeded the total number approved for the site. There were also a number of art pieces, signs, and outdoor seating furniture installed , which were not approved with the petition. The City notified the Applicant of the various deviations. As part of the Applicant's effort to bring the site into compliance with the approved plans, a subsequent administrative amendment (ADMN-12-01-000448) was approved in January 2012 . As part of the petition , the window mullions, door frames , and tiki torch poles were approved to be painted brown, the approved light baskets were relocated within various trees on the site (the total number of baskets previously approved was not exceeded), outdoor wait stations were added, and outdoor artistic pieces were added. The site is currently in compliance with the approved plans (see Existing Site Photographs). LAND USE & ZONING The subject site is zoned PUD overlay with an underlying zoning of Mixed Use (MXD) and Residential High (RH) and has future land-use designations of Mixed Use (MXD), Residential High (RH), and Residential Medium (RM). The site is also located within the PGA Boulevard Corridor Overlay. Subject Property PGA Commons Parcel 2 North Gardens of Wood South Woodland Lakes West Woodland Lakes East PGA Commons Parcel 3 CONCURRENCY Planned Unit Development (PUD) I Mixed Use (MXD) I Residential High (RH) Residential Medium (RM) Planned Unit Development (PUD) I Residential Low-2 (RL-2) I Residential Medium RM I Residential H Planned Unit Development (PUD) I Residential Low-2 (RL-2) I Residential Medium RM I Residential H. Planned Unit Development (PUD) I Mixed Use (MXD) I Residential Medium (RM) Meeting Date: October 11 , 2012 Resolution 78, 2012 Page 3 of 5 Mixed Use (MXD) I Residential Medium (RM) I Residential High (RH) Residential Medium (RM) Residential Low (R L) I Res idential High (RH) Res idential Medium (RM) Mixed Use (MXD) I Residential Medium (RM) The subject petition does not propose any modifications to the existing concurrency approvals. PROJECT DETAILS Site Details Parcel 2 of the PGA Commons PUD is approximately nine (9) acres in size. The parcel has vehicular access from PGA Boulevard and from Hickory Drive (see Location Map ). No changes to the existing access on site are proposed. Subject Request The Applicant is requesting a waiver to allow amber-colored light bulbs to be utilized within the light baskets previously approved for the site, and is proposing to change the color of the 17 existing tiki torches from brown to lime green. The light baskets were approved by the City and are currently installed within various trees located in the outdoor seating area (see Approved Light Basket Exhibit). A total of 50 light baskets were approved to be located within 10 trees surrounding the seating area . The light baskets in the Approved Light Basket Exhibit show the baskets with the amber lights . The baskets hang from the trees and currently contain clear bulbs in accordance with the City's Code (see Existing Site Photographs). The Applicant would like to replace the existing clear bulbs with amber-colored bulbs to create the desired ambiance for the outdoor seating area. The 17 existing tiki torches are located within the outdoor seating area of the Rocco 's Tacos restaurant (see Approved Site Plan). Currently, the tiki torch poles are brown and match the brown colors of the door frames, window mullions, and awning poles as approved by the City (see Existing Site Photographs). The Applicant is requesting approval to paint the tiki poles a lime green color to be consistent with the restaurant's trademark (see Trademark Green). The Applicant had initially painted the tiki torch poles lime green, but was required to repaint the poles in accordance with the City's approval (see Past Site Photographs). Meeting Date : October 11 , 2012 Resolution 78, 2012 Page 4 of 5 Waiver Request The Applicant has requested one (1) waiver. T bl 2 W . a e . a1ver R e( JUes t 1 Code Section Requirement Proposal Waiver Staff Support 78-182( d)(1 )( d)(2), Clear bulbs without interior or Amber-colored To allow Building & Accent exterior frosting, colors, or reflectors bulbs colored bulbs Approval Lighting 1) The Applicant has requested a waiver from Section 78-182(d)(1)(d)(2), Building and Accent Lighting, to allow amber-colored light bulbs. Accent lighting includes any lighting that is used to enhance, highlight, or define specific elements of landscaping, art, or architecture. The subject light baskets are located within trees which surround the outdoor seating area. The lights help to define the trees as well as the confines of the outdoor seating area, which enhances the overall appearance of the restaurant area. The City's Code requires accent lighting to contain clear bulbs without exterior frosting, colors, or reflectors. The amber-colored lights give a yellow-orange hue and present a minimal deviation from clear bulbs. They also help to create an outdoor restaurant environment that is similar to the lighting inside the restaurant. Staff supports the requested waiver. Staff Analysis Staff is supportive of the Applicant's requested waiver to allow amber-colored lights in lieu of clear bulbs within the existing light baskets, but is not supportive of the request to change the color of the tiki torch poles from brown to lime green. The proposed amber-colored light bulbs deviate minimally from a clear bulb. The light produced from a clear bulb at night is very similar to the light produced by an amber bulb at night. The ambiance of the outdoor seating area is created by the lighting from the light baskets and the tiki torches. The fire from the tiki torches produces a yellow-orange hue, which is similar to the hue produced by the proposed amber-colored bulbs. Allowing the amber bulbs would allow lighting consistency on site. The Code already allows the Applicant to utilize colored lights for up to 90 days in a given calendar year for the purpose of seasonal lighting. The impact of the proposed change is minimal, and staff is supportive of the subject waiver request. Unlike the proposed light bulb color change, the Applicant's request to change the colors of the tiki torch poles presents a substantial character change to the site. The proposed lime green color is part of the Applicant's trademarked colors and branding. The existing brown color of the tiki torches matches the door frames and window mullions of the tenant space. Changing the color of the torches to lime green would create inconsistency throughout the exterior fac;ade of the tenant space. Meeting Date: October 11, 2012 Resolution 78, 2012 Page 5 of 5 The tiki torches are also visible from PGA Boulevard. Changing to such a bright and contrasting color will negatively affect the character and aesthetic quality of the corridor. Within the PGA Corridor, the City strives to do the following (Section 78-221(b)(2)): 1) Create a special identity for PGA Boulevard through the use of planning and design standards. 2) Ensure high quality, architecturally compatible, and consistently landscaped development along the corridor. 3) Regulate uses within the corridor which will create a specific character and aesthetic quality for the corridor. 4) Ensure that new development or redevelopment projects preserve and enhance the existing visual character of the corridor. 5) Promote and protect the health, safety, and general welfare of the City. The proposed lime green tiki torches are not in alignment with these standards. The Applicant has received approval for numerous improvements to the site, which include the addition of tiki torches, 50 light baskets, a fire pit, several art pieces, and outdoor wait stations. They have also altered the existing outdoor bar. These improvements have allowed the tenant to create an environment that complements its restaurant theme while remaining consistent with the aesthetic quality of the corridor. Allowing the tiki torches to be painted lime green would be detrimental to the character of the site and create an inconsistent color palette for the exterior tenant space. Due to the negative character change that would occur as a result of the proposed color change, staff is not supportive of this aspect of the Applicant's request. DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMITTEE (DRC) All outstanding comments from the DRC have been satisfied. PLANNING, ZONING, AND APPEALS BOARD (PZAB) On August 7, 2012, the PZAB recommended approval of the subject petition to the City Council by a vote of 5-2. More specifically, the Board recommended approval of the requested waiver to allow colored light bulbs and recommended denial of the Applicant's request to change the color of the tiki torches to lime green, as presented by staff. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends APPROVAL of Resolution 78, 2012 as presented. CITY OF ·PALM BEACH GARDENS DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION Planning and Zoning Department CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS 10500 North Military Trail Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410 (561) 799-4243 Fax (561) 799-4281 Request: ['"Planned Community Development (PCD) CjPlanned Unit Development (PUD) IXAmendrnent to PCD, PUD or Site Plan C Conditional Use C Amendrnent to the Comprehensive Plan Q Adrninistrative Approval C 'Adrninistrative Appeal Project Name: PGA Commons Parcel 2 C Annexatio~ CRezoning !:Site Plan Review r=,concurrency Certificate I!Time Extension O Miscellaneous C !Other C ________ .. ___________________ , Date Submitted: I July 06,2012 Owner: Jon Channing, Trustee of the PGA Commons Land Trust, dated February 12, 1999 Applicant {if not Owner): --------------------------------------------- Applicant's Address: 5520 PGA Blvd, Ste 200. PBG, FL TelephoneNo. (561) 630-8630 Agent: Urban Design Ki lday Studios Contact Person: !..!An:..:.:nc.:::e:....:B~o:.:::ot::.:h'-------------E-Mail: abooth@udkstudios.com Agent's Mailing Address: 477 S . Rosemary Avenue, WPB, FL 33401 Agent's TelephoneNumber: (561} 366-1100 ~~------------------~----------------- FOR OFFICE USE ONLY Petition Number: ______ _ Date& Time Received: -------------• Fees Received Application $ Engineering$ _______________ _ Receipt Number: ______________ _ A h't ctArchltectural Design Associates, (561) 626-7381 rc 1 e : --------------~------------------------------------------- Engineer: ----------------------------------------------------------- PI Urban Design Kilday Studios, (561) 366-1100 anner: ------------------------------------------------------------ L d A h't ct Urban Design Kilday Studios, (561) 366-1100 an scape rc 1 e : __________________________________________________ _ Site Information: Note: Petitioner shall submit electronic digital files of approved projects. See attachment for details. G I L . Southwest Comer of PGA Boulevard and Hickory Drive enera ocat1on: ----------------------------------------------------- Add 5520 PGA Boulevard, PBG, Fl 33408 ress: ------------------------------------------------------------ S . 11 T h" 42 R 42 ect1on: owns 1p: ange: ------------------------------------------- 52-42-42-11-34-001-0000 Property Control Number(s): ----------------------------------------- A 5.2 . PUD/MXD . No Change creage: CurrentZomng: RequestedZomng: ---------------------------- B Flood Zone Base Flood Elevation (BFE) -to be indicated on site plan. __ _ C C h . PI L d U D . . MXD and RH urrent ompre ens1ve an an se es1gnat1on_: ---------------------- Ex. . L d U Mixed Use center R d L d U · No Change 1stmg an se: equeste an se: · --------------------------------- Proposed Use{s) i.e. hotel, single family residence,etc.: No Change P d S F b U No Change to existing development approval. ropose quare ootage y se: -------------------------- ProposedNumberandType of Dwelling Unit(s) i.e. single family, multifamily, etc. (if applicable): No Change to existing development approval. 2 ----------------------~ ----- Justification . Information concerning all requests (attach additional sheets if needed.) {Section 78-46, Application Procedures, Land D_evelopment Regulations.} 1. Explain the nature of the request: The applicant is requesting approval to modify the color for the tiki torches to the establishment's trademarked color of •green"; to allow amber tinted light bulbs in the existing hanging light baskets located outside in the seating areas. 2. What will be the impact of the proposed change on the surrounding area? There will be no adverse visual impact to the surrounding area within the PGA Boulevard parkway system. The modifications will enhance the pedestrian experience by using amber tinted lighting, providing for a more relaxed and enhanced experience within the parkway and outdoor seating area. 3. Describe how the rezoning request complies with the City's Vision Plan and the following elements of the City's Comprehensive Plan -Future Land Use, Transportation, Housing, Infrastructure, Coastal Management, Conservations, Recreation and Open space, Intergovernmental Coordination and Capital Improvement. This is not a request to rezone the property. Compliance with the Vision Plan and the Comprehensive Plan were addressed when the PUD was approved. 3 4. How does the proposed project comply with City requirements for preservation of natural resources and native vegetation (Section 78-301, Land Development Regulations)? All requirements for preservation of natural resources and native vegetation were addressed with the approval of the PUD. 5. How will the proposed project comply with City requirements for Art in Public Places (Chapter 78-261, Land Development Regulations)? Not Applicable 6. Has project received concurrency certification? Yes, Concurrency has been previously approved and is on file with the city. Date Received~ . . .. .............. .. Legal Description of the Subject Property (Attach additional sheets if needed) Or see attached deed for legal description. Location The subject property is located approximately 0.0 mile(s) from theintersectionof PGA ------ Boulevard & Hickory Drive , on thel I north,Q east,0south~west side of _____ _ Corner of the intersection (street/road). -------------------------------- 4 Applicant's Certification I!We affirm and certify that JJwe understand and will comply with the land development regulations of the City of Palm Beach Gardens, Florida. I We further certify that the statements or diagrams made on any paper or plans submitted here with are true to the best of my/our knowledge and belief. Further, JJwe understand that this application, attachments, and application filing fees become a part of the official records of the City of Palm Bea dens, Florida and e not returnable. Applicant is: C: Owner 0 Optionee 0 Lessee ~Agent r Contract Purchaser Anne Booth Print Name of Applicant 4n S. Rosemary Avenue · Street Address West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 City, State, Zip C~e (561) 366-1100 TelephoneNumber (561) 366-1111 Fax Number abooth@udkstudios.com E-Mail Address 6 OWNERS/AGENTS AGREEMENT Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared JON CHANNING, TRUSTEE, of THE PGA COMMONS LAND TRUST, DATED FEBRUARY 12, 1999, who being first duly sworn on oath, deposes and say: 1. That, he is Trustee of the property, known as PGA Commons Parcel2, with a PCN#of 52-42-42-11-34-001-0000 located in the City of Palm Beach Gardens, Florida; and 2. That, on behalf of THE PGA COMMONS LAND TRUST, DATED FEBRUARY 12, 1999, he is requesting an PUD Amendment for the Rocco's Taco Restaurant within the PGA Commons Parcel2 Planned Unit Development on the above described property. 3. That, he has full authority to file and pursue this application and that he is authorized to act on behalf of THE PGA COMMONS LAND TRUST, DATED FEBRUARY 12, 1999, in connection with such filing. 4. That, THE PGA COMMONS LAND TRUST, DATED FEBRUARY 12, 1999, has appointed URBAN DESIGN KILDAY STUDIOS and ANNE BOOTH to act as Agent in its behalf to accomplish the above. 5. That, THE PGA COMMONS LAND TRUST, DATED FEBRUARY 12, 1999, commits to proceed with the proposed development in accordance with the Administrative Approval and such conditions and safeguards as may be set by the City in such approval; and 6. That, THE PGA COMMONS LAND TRUST, DATED FEBRUARY 12, 1999, or its successors or assigns, commits to complete the development according to the plans approved by such Administrative Approval, and to continue operating and maintenance to such areas, functions, and facilities as are not to be provided, operated or maintained by the City of Palm Beach Gardens pursuant to written agreement; and 7. That, THE PGA COMMONS LAND TRUST, DATED FEBRUARY 12, 1999, commits to bind any successors in title to any commitments made in the approval. J Sworn to and subscribed before me this Q]9"*"'-day of rYJCv!..M--• 2012 (Notary Seal) Notary Public, State of Florida Commission Number My Commission Expires:~ t ~~ ZC> l"L NOTARY PUBUC-STATE OF FLORIDA .,. .......... .,. Sandra J. Parks {~j Co~ission # DD801476 '•,,;,.,,... Expll'es: AUG.l3, 2012 BONDED TH1111 ATLAN"nQ JOI(I)Il(O CO., 11(0. Palm Beach Gardens Planning and Zoning Department 10500 North Military Trail. Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410 561-799-4230 Permit# ________________________________ ___ Financial Responsibility Form The owner understands that all City-incurred professional fees and expenses associated with the processing of this application request are ultimately the responsibility of the owner. A security deposit shall be d.eposited in an interest-bearing account with any accrued interest to be retained by the City of Palm Beach Gardens. The owner and/or designee shall be invoiced on a monthly basis for professional fees such as, but not limited to, consultant engineering services, legal services, advertising costs, and/or any other costs attributable to the processing of the permit for which the City incurred during the previous month . The owner and/or designee shall reimburse the City within thirty (30) days from date of invoice. If payment is not received, the City may utilize the security deposit for re-imbursement purposes. All activities related to the pending permit(s) will cease until any outstanding invoices are paid. The owner/designee furt er understands that transfer of this responsibility shall require a completed fonn, si d notarized by the responsible party, and delivered to the City Planning and Zonin P. fthe name and/or ddress ofthe responsible party changes at anytime dUring t I af 0 DESIGNEE/BILL T Gardens's Taco Ltd. 400 Clematis Street, Suite 209 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 Date Multiple PCN's Property Control Number NOTARY ACKNOWLEDGEMENT STATE OF Florida --------------------------- COUNTY OF Palm Beach --------------------------- 1 hereby certify that the foregoing instrument was ackno~ed before me this ~~Y of March , 20§ by ~~t:,~o5£ . ll~~h~ personally known to~~ Q~ ~•ideRQfioatioo, NOta/YjpULJ~- ~orz=, J"_ ?A-R\L-6 Printed name State of Y\4'4.DA at-large My Commission expires: QWktU~ ~l-\; 1.0\2-; NOTARY PUBLIC· STATE OF FLORIDA .......... ,,_ Sandra J. Parks {W. ~Commission #DDS01476 .. .,.,.l Expires: AUG.13, 2012 s~NDKD Tl!iU ATLIINTIC JioNPING co., me. Project Narrative Rocco's Tacos at The Commons July 27, 2012 Location urtx:ln ,des1gn kl ~ldOLJ STU Dl OS~ Ur ban Planning and Design landscape Architectu re Communication Graphics The Rocco's Taco's restaurant is located within The Commons "Central" (Parcel2) on the south side of PGA Boulevard west of the intersection of PGA Boulevard and Hickory Drive. The Commons is a Mixed Use Planned Unit Development which includes a mixture of retail, restaurants and residential uses. The PGA Commons' unique design and character meets the intent of the Mixed Use regulations creating a sense of space, pedestrian amenities, neighborhood and community serving commercial uses and employment opportunities. The brightly colored art, varied wall and awning colors, colorful signage and tenant accents unify the project and create visual interest. The requests proposed in this application will be consistent with and enhance the overall appeal of the PGA Commons. Colors The applicant has made a substantial investment in branding and trademarking the restaurant chain. The branding of Rocco's includes their logo, sculpture, lighting , furnishings, and the colors they have used to pull the restaurant theme together. The applicant has withdrawn their request for all proposed exterior color changes w ith the exception of the request to allow the poles of the Tiki torches to be painted green. The applicant respectfully requests approval to allow the small component of accent color to be allowed on the Tiki torch poles which they believe would be in character with the color accents and decorations provided by the property owner and other tenants at The Commons. The Commons has become known for having a colorfu l and eclectic blend of art and eye catching accents which are designed to bring attention to the various commercial establishments. The addition of the trademarked "Green" to the Tiki Torch poles was originated as a creative use of the color, but in practice the restaurant management, as well as others, have found that by painting the torch . poles a bright color, they pedestrians. The location of the torches have been placed to avoid contact with the flow of pedestrian traffic, however, due to are more visib le to the openness of the plaza and the success of the restaurant, there are frequently people waiting for a table and meandering around in the grass areas. By allowing the trademarked "green" on the poles of the torches, it will help to make them more visible to minimize any potential conflicts. 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 225 -The Lofts at CityPiace West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.11 oo 561.366.1111 fax www.udkstudios.com LCC000035 Project Narrative Rocco's Tacos at The Commons Amber Colored Light Bulbs July 27, 2012 Page2 The applicant is requesting approval to allow the light baskets which are installed in the trees, to have amber colored bulbs. The amber bulbs create a pleasant lighting effect for the outdoor restaurant patrons. The amber light is easier on the eye, is consistent with the lighting inside the restaurant and does not create lighting as harsh as white light does. The light baskets generate light similar to the light emitted by the Tiki torches or lights such as gas street lights. The code allows colored lights for three months in a year, this application is requesting approval for a waiver from Section 78-182 (c)(6)(d)(1)(d){ii) to allow the amber colored light bulbs to remain year round. The addition of Rocco's Tacos to The Commons has created a synergy that has been missing in the plaza for quite a while. The success of the restaurant has brought people from all areas of the county to the PGA Corridor and as a result other businesses have benefited. The ownership group of Rocco's Tacos has made a major financial commitment in the construction of the restaurant and is committed to remaining in this location for many years. Rocco's management is committed to being good neighbors and tenants in the plaza. They are also committed to the community as an employer and in support of numerous charitable organizations. The applicant respectfully requests City Council approval of the above. WAIVER CRITERIA Rocco's Tacos at The Commons July 23, 2012 Waiver requested: 'Urb:ln des1gn kllday STUDIOS Urban Planning and Design Landscape Architecture Communication Graphics 1. Section 78-182(c)(6)(d)(1)(d)(ii), to allow amber colored bulbs to remain year round. (1) The request is consistent with the city's comprehensive plan.· The proposed waiver is consistent with the Land Development Regulation that allows for waivers in a PUD. The proposed waiver is not in violation of any of the policies of the Comprehensive Plan. The Commons was developed in accordance with an approved master plan, which was approved in accordance with the City's Comprehensive Plan. (2) The request is consistent with the purpose and intent of this section. This request is consistent with the provisions of the code that allow waiver requests from the lighting code. (3) The request is in support of and furthers the city's goals, objectives, and policies to establish development possessing architectural significance, pedestrian amenities and linkages, employment opportunities, reductions in vehicle trips, and a sense of place. The proposed waiver will allow a softer ambient light source which is pleasing to the eye and consistent with an overall ambiance created by the restaurant. The restaurant is part of a mixed used development which provides meandering pedestrian sidewalks, open plazas with outdoor seating, community gathering spaces and mature landscaping. The proposed lighting will enhance the experience of the pedestrians and diners. (4) The request demonstrates that granting of the waiver will result in a development that exceeds one or more of the minimum requirements for PUDs. The Commons PUD exceeds the landscape and open space code requirements. The proposed waiver will enhance the common area and provide a soft ambient light for the plaza. 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 225 -The Lofts at City Place West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.udkstudios.com LCC000035 Waiver Criteria Rocco's Tacos at The Commons July 23, 2012 Page2 5) The request for one or more waivers results from innovative design in which other minimum standards are exceeded. The proposed waiver is the minimum waiver required to achieve the desired results. The amber bulbs will create a pleasant atmosphere and a cohesive theme provided by the restaurant. All other land development regulations have been met or exceeded. (6) The request demonstrates that granting of the waiver will result in preservation of valuable natural resources, including environmentally-sensitive lands, drainage and recharge areas, and coastal areas. The proposed waiver will not have any impact on any natural resources, drainage or land area. The proposed light fixtures are installed in the landscape areas which were approved as part of the PUD. The landscape areas are not impacted by the proposed waiver. (7) The request clearly demonstrates public benefits to be derived, including but not limited to such benefits as no-cost dedication of rights-of-way, extensions of pedestrian linkages outside of the project boundaries, preservation of important natural resources, and use of desirable architectural, building, and site design techniques. The approval of the PCD incorporated the dedication of public rights-of-way, construction of roadway improvements, and employment opportunities. The proposed waiver is a major component of a restaurant that has provided a needed synergy for the plaza and multiple jobs. (8) Sufficient screening and buffering, if required, are provided to screen adjacent uses from adverse impacts caused by a waiver. The site is adequately buffered by mature landscaping. Adjacent uses are non-residential and will not be impacted by the proposed waiver. (9) The request is not based solely or predominantly on economic reasons. The proposed lights are a major component of an overall theme for the ambiance of the restaurant. The lights are currently being used all of the other Rocco's Tacos sites throughout the county and create an overall lighting theme. The proposed amber bulb is more subdued and pleasing to the eye than the clear white lights allowed by code. Location Map PGA Commons PUD-Parcel 2 1··.:-. Proposed Basket Lighting (Individual custom made light ftxtures) Note: Ught bu.lbs to be clear unless approved as an alternative color by the City Council, or approved as seasonal lighting for 90 days per LOR Section 78-182 . .... c .CD .. E :tt: Q. c 0 O(i :e > 1D Q) o..Cl Graphic Prepared by Urban Design Kilday Studios 1 January 29, 2012 EXISITNG SITE PHOTOGRAPHS BROWN TIKI TORCH POLES EXISTING ON THE SITE Page 1of11 BROWN TIKI TORCHES AGAINST EXISTING LANDSCAPING Page2 ofll BROWN TIKI TORCHES Page 3of11 VISIBiliTY OF TIKI TORCHES TO PGA BOULEVARD Page4of11 VISIBILITY FROM PGA BOULEVARD Page Sofll LIGHT BASKETS WITH CLEAR LIGHT BULBS · Page6ofll . (. -.~~-~ ': ~\: ~ ' .. , OUTDOOR SEATING AREA SHOWING BROWN DOOR FRAMES AND AWNING POLES Page7of11 EXISTING BROWN WINDOW AND DOOR FRAMES Page8of11 EXISTING BROWN WINDOW AND DOOR FRAMES Page9of11 PAST SITE PHOTOGRAPHS PROPOSED LIME GREEN TIKI TORCH POLES Page lOofll PROPOSED LIGHT BASKETS WITH AMBER LIGHT BULBS Page 11 of11 ROCCO'S TACOS DOOR FRAME, WALL FRAME, . and TIKI TORCH POLE COLOR SELECTION • PGA COHHOHS April 16, 2012 All door frames, window frames, and Tiki torch poles are to be consistent with the above trademark green color. PGA COMMONS -PARCEL 2. PHONE# 630-8630 FAX# 630-8631 5520 PGA BOULEVARD, SUITE 200 PALM BEACH GARDENS, FL 33418 --, SITE DETAILS ~ ... - A'GI~W/(1.111: , ........... f1\i--=-TYP.:.:,..:.JC:::A,:;L=-:-:,.P:,: AR;..:;K;..:;I;..:;NG.._, _:O:_::L..c.AN-"D-'-S-'-C-'-AP-'--IN_G __ ~ SC~U * vr .; r-fr ~--------------------------------------~~·"' 39, P(i JOJ) 1DUNT I J.JO>SF .'Outdoor Seatlrig QPionter .. JDM PLAT PGA BOULEVARD CANAL PROJECT DATA -PARCEL 2 mA SUIIUARY (ro.tiiEROAL I AI'ARlliENlS -AI.~G PGA ll.W.) GENERAL OFFICE MEDICAL OFFICE SHOPS/RETAIL RESTAURANT· NXlOR RESTAURANT -OUTDOOR PARKING SUMMARY (NON RESIDENTIAL) AREA H,liii SF. 3,015SF. 11,618SF. 4,225SF. 1,377SF. 42,316SF. TOTAL PARKING 159 HANDICAPPED PARKING (INCLUDED-6 LOAIDING SPACES 2 BICYCLE SPACES 9 • PARKING REQUIRED BASED OH A PEAK PERIOD ANALYSIS PRPARED BY URBAN DaQt STUDIO. TOWNHOME SUMMARY TOWN HOMES TOWNHOMES AREA (ENLOSED M:) TOWNHOME PARKING SUMMARY (2)4 UNIT (3)3 UNIT GUEST(S%) AREA TOTALS PER BUilDING REQ'D f!lQY!Q§Q 10 12 8 10 TOTALOFFICEIRETAL/APARTMENTS TOWNHOME AREA TOTAL BLDG AREA 1700'S. 34,175SF. TOTAL REQ'D PROVIDED 20 24 24 35 ABOVE 47 59 43,114SF. 34,175SF. 77,289SF. LAND AREA (8.9117 ACRES) 391,909 SF. LOT COVERAGE BUILDING COVERAGE IMPERVIOUS AREA 57,818SF. 15% 170,480 SF. 43% (WALK, PlAZA, DRIVEWAY, ETC.) PERVIOUS AREA 163,611 SF. 42% 391,909SF. 100% NO USE PLAN OPEN SPACE 15% 40% 35% 59% 25% 50% ~PAR<El.NO. ;,v,, r . ·. y ~lOTNO. r' l/1~ 'l t--J' I t., Jjl$ ~ L~ _ _j TOI\tiHOIIE --------PROPERTY LINE (l:] NO. C1F PARKING SPACES -PER PARCEL • (gl c PERGOLA STRUCnJRE PEDESTRIAN PORTAL I GAZEBO Pl.AHTER I 'MiEEL STOP -Pl.AZA/PA~ ~ l1jJ 9 ID IKl -* .. ,..- HANDICAPPED PARKING SPACE -SEI OCTAL 2~-2 PEDESTRIAN WAlJ(WA.Y LICHT W/ BAkED ENAMEL FIHISH; 14' UOI.IfT1friG HEIQiT SltRNER LTG-3D20-150HPs-INV-9A'mD 1 150 HPS =,g_~.:..W"''"'l""d~~l~•J'!'""J"tul :~ ~~:m ~Yo~ rc~:·n £ C:!Gch Gc: ( ::.(:.~:~:n=~J'i~~ :~:_-:-:>c.=""'-........ .££t.:L-~- STOP BAR :--0::;,:·•.-;,1 i'f::../J.<)J..t.[../.:.Ll.:..f. '/•ICC 24" VAU.£Y 0\JilER l,:·;•,.;;_.:~f::'!T.,o':':j •: '-.' .. 'r!_/:jjfL s• RAISED CDICRETE a.J;RB . · I SITE PLAN II PARCEL·2 ,, ~~-------- 11 I ,, SCALE: 1"•40'-0" I I · hll ··· f!i ~!~- L ~ ~ i ~ : :I ~ ~-!-~j ~~ ~-· ~= ;~ f-< z % ·- fi;;l -• m! ~ ~ .. 8 .. ,Oil g:! ~ "' _;j! ~" ~~ f-. " ,:. ~ .. < it-~ .. ~i "' ~ " ~iii o: ! <( 0 0:: 1-0 z (f) .....J w ...... :::< z c.ri 0.. 0 0 z .....J 2 w w 0 > 2 0:: w <( 0 0 <..? w u :r: U1 u :::J <( 0 <( w w CD X (_') :::< ~ .....J 0... <( <( 0.. .. .; ~TORCH- (_:) ~HAND(UER ~ I i I; i i ll 'I ! j I I 'I I l ! ; 1 i j ;_~.-~_:-~ _jjl ,.--··-f . ···---. " i l i! ! ' i! I' • RECESSED OOWNUGHT . . --TRACK UGHTING ~2011 EXIT UGHT EXIT / EIIERGENCT LIGHT •. lHI' ~~1\JRIIIIL. ~IS 6IVEH IN GOtPI~ H0 U!e OR 015!ettAAfiON MA'(' eE ~ HllCUT PRIOR .-RITT!!t Gat5EHT OF Ttl! ARGHITEC.T. ALL GOI1'10N LAH R!eHT5 Of GOPT'RJ6Hl' NO Ol'H!RHIS! .-..Re ~'I' SPEGI~GALL.Y ~0. .D D 0 .D CL .CJ r=I .... D .. CJ . .CJ • .·. i / I f / i f i \@1 I I I . I. \\ #" : + -1. 1\. I( I ... I I t+v @] \l ./ ·····-.. ~---u· -·--,\...--.... /')1 I / ./~ I ' I I I l 1 I I I I I I I I I I I \ -.... &~~- &=....~ &~- &~ &~~~!~~All ~ll t-----1 - D--- DATil P.S. ~11'3111 _......, AS NOTED "'oe ..o. ._,. A·5 o .. ·- 1 RESOLUTION 78, 2012 2 3 4 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM 5 BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING AN AMENDMENT TO 6 THE PGA COMMONS PARCEL 2 PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT 7 (PUD) TO ALLOW MODIFICATIONS TO THE APPROVED SITE 8 PLAN, SPECIFICALLY RELATED TO ACCENT LIGHTING, AS 9 MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN; PROVIDING 10 WAIVERS; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER 11 PURPOSES. 12 13 14 WHEREAS, the City Council, as the governing body of the City of Palm Beach 15 Gardens, Florida, pursuant to the authority in Chapter 163 and Chapter 166, Florida 16 Statutes, and the City's Land Development Regulations, is authorized and empowered 17 to consider petitions related to zoning and land development orders; and 18 19 WHEREAS, the City Council adopted Ordinance 8, 1999, approving the rezoning 20 of the 8.997-acre parcel to a Planned Unit Development (PUD) Overlay and approved 21 the construction of 17 townhomes, 6,606 square feet of general office, 7,150 square 22 feet of medical office, 12,654 square feet of general retail, 3,300 square feet of 23 restaurant, and eight (8) apartment units; and 24 25 WHEREAS, on October 7, 2011, an administrative amendment (ADMN-11-07- 26 000412) was approved to allow modifications to the approved elevations, site plan, and 27 landscape plan for Rocco's Tacos restaurant; and 28 29 WHEREAS, on January 30, 2012, an administrative amendment (ADMN-12-01- 30 000448) was approved to allow further modifications to the Rocco's Tacos restaurant; 31 and 32 33 WHEREAS, PGA Commons Parcel 2 has a Planned Unit Development (PUD) 34 Overlay with underlying zoning designations of Mixed Use (MXD) and Residential High 35 (RH), has future land-use designations of Mixed Use (MXD), Residential High (RH), and 36 Residential Medium (RM), and is located within the PGA Boulevard Corridor Overlay; 37 and 38 39 WHEREAS, the Planning and Zoning Department has reviewed the application, 40 has determined that it is sufficient and consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan 41 and Land Development Regulations, and has recommended approval; and 42 43 WHEREAS, the Planning, Zoning , and Appeals Board reviewed the petition at its 44 August 7, 2012, meeting and recommended approval of the subject petition (PUDA-12- 45 04-000036) by a vote of 5-2; and 46 Page 1 of 3 Resolution 78, 2012 1 WHEREAS, the City Council has considered the evidence and testimony 2 presented by the Applicant and other interested parties and the recommendations of the 3 various City of Palm Beach Gardens reviewing agencies and staff; and 4 5 WHEREAS, the City Council deems approval of this Resolution to be in the best 6 interests of the health, safety , and welfare of the residents and citizens of the City of 7 Palm Beach Gardens and the public at large. 8 9 10 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY 11 OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA that: 12 13 SECTION 1. The foregoing recitals are hereby affirmed and ratified. 14 15 SECTION 2. The application is hereby APPROVED for an amendment to the 16 PGA Commons Parcel 2 PUD site plan approval to allow amber-colored light bulbs 17 within the existing light baskets located in the outdoor seating area, which is in addition 18 to the general requirements otherwise provided by resolution for the real property 19 described as follows: 20 21 (See Exhibit "A" for Legal Description) 22 23 SECTION 3. The City Council of the City of Palm Beach Gardens, Florida hereby 24 APPROVES the following waiver: 25 26 1. Section 78-182(d)(1 )(d)(2), Building and Accent Lighting, to allow amber- 27 colored light bulbs within the existing light baskets. 28 29 SECTION 4. This approval shall be consistent with all representations made by 30 the Applicant or the Applicant's agent at any public hearing . 31 32 SECTION 5. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon adoption. 33 34 35 (The remainder of this page, intentionally left blank) 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 Page 2 of 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 Resolution 78, 2012 PASSED AND ADOPTED this __ day of _______ , 2012 . CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA BY: ----------~-------------------David Levy, Mayor ATTEST: BY: -------------------------Patricia Snider, CMC, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY BY: -------------------------R. Max Lohman, City Attorney VOTE: AYE NAY ABSENT MAYOR LEVY VICE MAYOR PREMUROSO COUNCILMEMBER TINSLEY COUNCILMEMBER RUSSO COUNCILMEMBER JABLIN G :\attorney_share\RESOLUTIONS\2012\Resolution 78 2012-roccos tacos site plan mod ifications .doc Page 3 of 3 EXHIBIT "A" LEGAL DESCRIPTION LYING IN SECTION 11, TOWNSHIP 42 SOUTH, RANGE 42 EAST, CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 103, PAGES 193 THROUGH 195, PUBLIC RECORDS OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA. CONTAINING 8.997 ACRES, MORE OR LESS. CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS CITY COUNCIL Agenda Cover Memorandum Meeting Date: October 11, 2012 Resolution 89, 2012 Subject/Agenda Item: Appointment of Regular and Alternate Members to the Art in Public Places (AIPP) Advisory Board. [X] Recommendation to APPROVE [ ] Recommendation to DENY Reviewed by: of Planning & Development Compliance N/A Bahareh Wolfs, AICP Originating Dept.: Planning & Zoning: Project Manager Kathryn DeWitt, AICP Sr. Planner [ ] Quasi-Judicial [ ] Legislative [X] Public Hearing Finance: Accountant" N/A Sarah Varga Fees Paid: N/A Funding Source: [ ] Operating [X] Other_,_N..:..:.I.:....:A'--- t---------------1 Budget Acct.#: Approved By: Advertised: [ ] Required [X] Not Required Affected parties: [X] Notified [ ] Not Required N/A Contract/Agreement: Effective Date: N/A Expiration Date: N/A Council Action: ] Approval ] Approved w/ Conditions ] Denial ] Continued to: __ Attachments: • Resolution 89, 2012 -Exhibit "A" - Appointments -Exhibit "B" - Attendance Records and Applications ------------------------------------- BACKGROUND Meeting Date: October 11, 2012 Resolution 89, 2012 Page 2 of2 The purpose, powers, and duties of this Art in Public Places (AIPP) Advisory Board are to promote greater public participation in, and access to, arts and culture in the City and to make recommendations to the City Council to implement the AIPP regulations including site and artwork selection and review of artist(s) and artwork(s) commissioned or purchased by the City. Effective October 1, 2012, Meriel "Honey" Bryan, Paul Kaufman, and David Porter are eligible for reappointment. Therefore, the appointments for 2012-2013 include three (3) Regular Members eligible for re- appointment (Meriel "Honey" Bryan, Paul Kaufman, and David Porter), one (1) Regular Member vacancy, and two (2) Alternate Member vacancies. SUMMARY: Regular Member(s) eligible for reappointment Meriel "Honey" Bryan Paul Kaufman David Porter Alternate Member(s) eligible for reappointment as Regular Members None Vacancies to be Filled One (1) Regular Member First Alternate Second Alternate Additional Applications on File Reginald Maton David Paul Helane Hertz Joy Hecht Staff posts notices of vacancies at City Hall and on the City Website. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends APPROVAL of Resolution 89, 2012 as presented. Current Composition of the Board David Porter, Chair Cable Neuhaus, Vice Chair Meriel "Honey" Bryan, Regular Member Paul Kaufman, Regular Member Diane Cappella, Regular Member Alexander Hanlin, Regular Member 1 RESOLUTION 89, 2012 2 3 4 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM 5 BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING THE APPOINTMENT 6 OF REGULAR AND ALTERNATE MEMBERS TO THE ART IN 7 PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE 8 DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 9 10 11 WHEREAS, Section 2-108, Code of Ordinances provides for the Board to be 12 comprised of seven (7) regular members and two (2) alternate members; and 13 14 WHEREAS, as of September 30, 2012, there are three (3) regular members 15 eligible for reappointment, one ( 1) regular member and two (2) alternate vacancies; and 16 17 WHEREAS, notice of the vacancies has been posted at City Hall and on the City 18 website; and 19 20 WHEREAS, the City Clerk has collected applications of all interested persons 21 who wish to serve as members of the Board, along with attendance records of the 22 current members, which are attached hereto as Exhibit "B"; and 23 24 WHEREAS, the City Council deems approval of this Resolution to be in the best 25 interests of the health, safety, and welfare of the residents and citizens of the City of 26 Palm Beach Gardens and the public at large. 27 28 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY 29 OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA that: 30 31 SECTION 1. The foregoing recitals are hereby affirmed and ratified. 32 33 SECTION 2. The City Council hereby approves the appointment of regular and 34 alternate members to the Art in Public Places Advisory Board as set forth in Exhibit "A". 35 36 SECTION 3. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon adoption. 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 Page 1 of 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 Resolution 89, 2012 PASSED AND ADOPTED this __ day of _______ , 2012. CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA BY: -----------------David Levy, Mayor ATTEST: BY: ---------------Patricia Snider, CMC, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY BY: --------------R. Max Lohman, City Attorney VOTE: AYE NAY ABSENT MAYOR LEVY VICE MAYOR PREMUROSO COUNCILMEMBER TINSLEY COUNCILMEMBER RUSSO COUNCILMEMBER JABLIN G:\attorney_share\RESOLUTIONS\2012\Resolution 89 2012-AIPP appointments.doc Page 2 of 2 EXHIBIT "A" Regular Members(s) Alternate Members(s) Resolution 89, 2012 Expiring on 09/30/2014 Expiring on 09/30/2014 Expiring on 09/30/2014 Expiring on 09/30/2014 Resolution 89, 2012 EXHIBIT "B" Art in Public Places p p p p p p p p p p p p p A p A p p A R p A p p p p p A ~ .. .. ~ ~ ~ "' "' "' ::s "' ::s 0 ::s 0 ::s 0 0 "CC € il c 'E 0 :c ::s u:: ~ 0 1-II. 1/) City of Palm Beach Gardens Boa rei Please Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided in A I . t" this application is considered to be public record, PP ICa IOn except as provided by law. Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: Address: =~He=m============~=~He=la=ne===========~c=JI~ --~--------~ City: State: Zip: :13=2=V=ia==D=e=l C=o=r=s=o=======================~ .... ,P-a-lm-B-ea_c_h_G_a_r-de_n_s-------.~~ Florida I r-13_3_4-18---...., Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: r-,5-6-1--62-7--7-6_0_9 ____ ...... , ,...,--------...,,772-559-2688 ,-----------------, Years of Residency: EJ Secondary Email Address: Preferred Means of Contact: ... I H_o_m_e_P_h_on_e _____ --' Please place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. !if Art in Public Places Advisory Board D Community Aesthetics Board D Parks and Recreation Advisory Board D Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * D Budget Oversight Committee (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00 p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) D Fire Pension Board (meets semi-monthly as called) 0 Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: I AIPP -Art in Public Places Board Second Choice: Third Choice: Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes @ No If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0Yes @No If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? Are you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings ®Evening Meetings What would you hope to accomplish by participating? Provide many years of art related expertise to the City, continue to beautify the City and mentor younger volunteers concerning art related matters. Next Page I Present Employment: Profession: lnta I In/a la~-::~dr:Jdr::r-=e-=s-=s-=-: __________________ _. Pos1t1on: ~~n-la _____________________ ~l~ln_la _____________________ ~ Are you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes @ No Are you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ® No Do you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No How many years have you practiced in the above profession? D Could your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee? O Yes ® No If yes, explain: Professional Background (please check all that apply) D Accountant D Adult Sports Programming D Aquatics Programming D Architect D Architect Design/Urban Planner til Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. D Attorney D Banker D Building Construction D Div. 1 Bldg -General Contractor Educational Background D Div. 2 M EP Contractor D Engineer D Environmental Professional D Golf Course Participant D Horticulture & Landscaping D Land Surveyor D Landscape Architect D Member of Bus. Dev. Board D NPB Count Chamber of Commerce !if other: D Business Owner in PBG D PGA Corridor Association D Real Estate Professional lifRecreation Programming !if Senior-Targeted Activities D Special Population Advocate D Tennis Center Participant 'lifVisual I Literary Arts D Volunteer from PBGYAA Diploma/Degree Institution Course of Study 1. IB.s. IINew York University ~~Education P===========================~IPIN=e=w=Y=o=r=k=U=n=iv=e=rs=it=y==================~~~~E=d=u=ca=t=io=n==================~ 2. IM.A. 3. I ~------~11 ~ ------~ Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No Have you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes 0 No If yes, ex~ Sr. Docent at Norton Museum, Board Member of P.B Jewish Film Festival, Arts Facilitator at PBCC How did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? 0 City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend ® other: ~~N_e_w_s_p_ap_e_r ____ ___. Prior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: I I I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. !if Agree I understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG Mandai'-Y~ Cofte of Ethics Training. IJtl gre Name: Date: I'H-e-la_n_e_H_ert-z--------,~8 Aug 2012 .___P_ri_n_t _ _.l j Previous Page City of Palm Beach Gardens Board 8t Committee Application lease Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided ir this application is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: ~~M-a_t_o_n __________________ ~,~LR~e-g_in_a_ld ________________ ~j~~~R-e_g __ ~~--------------- \ddress: City: State: Zip: -12_9_0_0_L_a_R_o_c_h_el-le-C--irc-l-e--------------.,,Palm Beach Gardens II Florida II ,...3-34_1_0 ____ ...., lome Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: >46-21 0-3708 j Ljs_s_1-_9_04_-_s_73_7 ______ ___~lls46-21 0-3708 j'lre_g_m_a-to_n_@-co_m_c_a_s_t._ne_t _______ _ 'ears of Residency: D Secondary Email Address: •referred Means of Contact:'~ w_o_rk_P_h_o_n_e _________ ..JI •lease place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code/' some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. !if Art in Public Places Advisory Board !if Community Aesthetics Board !if Parks and Recreation Advisory Board !ifPianning, Zoning and Appeals Board * !ifBudget Oversight Committee (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) iK Fir!=_penslQILBoan;[ ______________ J'!leets ~el!l_!:_l!l~_~_thly ~~~-a.~l~d) -_ !ifPolice Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form :f you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: I BOG -Budget Oversight Committee Second Choice: I Fire -Fire Fighters Pension Board Third Choice: -I AIPP -Art in Public Places Board -lre-you~current-ly~erving-on-a-Palm-Beach-Gar-densBoar-d-er-Gommittee?-t:)-y~-Ng ____ _ If so, which one(s)? lave you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? \re you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s)? iave you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? \re you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings ® Evening Meetings · IVhat would you hope to accomplish by participating? Use my corporate knowledge, experience as CIO to give back to the community . ---··--···r"'·-., ···-···· "hink Strategic Technology Partners, LLC !Consulting ~~r~e-s~s~=------------------------------------~p H~o~s~itnl~o~n~=--------------------------------------- -_2_9_0_0_L_a_R_o_c_h_e _ .... lle __ ... C ..... ir ..... c~le ___ -__ -__ -__ -_,_~ __ -__ -__ -_ --__ -___ -___ -_-____ -____ -___ -_ ~---_-------_-___ -_ -'[IPri-nci~al tre you a Lobbyist? . 0 Yes ® No .re you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes .® No lo you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No low many years have you practiced in the above profession? D :ould y~ur occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided 1pon by the Board or Committee? O Yes ®No If yes, explain: •rofessional Background (please check all that apply) ] Accountant ] Adult Sports Programming ] Aquatics Programming ] Architect ] Architect Design/Urban Planner ] Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. ] Attorney ] Banker 0 Div. 2 MEP Contractor !if Engineer 0 Environmental Professional !if Golf Course Participant 0 Horticulture & Landscaping 0 Land Surveyor 0 Landscape Architect ---: · 0 Member of Bus. Dev. Board ] Building Construction 0 NPB Count Chamber of Commerce ] Div. 1 Bldg -General Contractor :ducational Background Diploma/Degree BA -·-BSIF IM~ !if Other: Institution Columbia University, Columbia College --- _ Golumbia£ngin.e_exing_&_Ap_plied Science Columbia Engineering-& Applied Science tre you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No lave you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes 0 No !if Business Owner in PBG 0 PGA Corridor Association !if Real Estate Professional 0 Recreation Programming 0 Senior-Targeted Activities 0 Special Population Advocate D Tennis ce-nter. Participant~------- 0 Visual I Literary Arts !if Volunteer from PBGYAA Course of Study Math/Economics -·.·,. Industrial Engine_ering Eng Management --------- If yes, Coach. Palm Beach Gardens explain: recreation baseball fow did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? ) City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend ® Other: !Palm Beach Post •rior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: j I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. !if Agree understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG landatory Code of Ethics Training. a me: Date: -~-~-:~-~-, .... -D-1\-,.....,-+-,...-.... --, .. --------.l '? l'u •n '?n !jl" Agree City of Palm Beach Gardens Board &. Committee Application Please Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided i this application is considered to be public record 1 except as provided by law. Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: .ddress: ~~Pa_u_I--------------~~~~D~av_id ______________ ~I~~~~------------ City: State: Zip: -.0-8_7_1-55_t_h_P_I_N ___________ ____,IIPalm Beach Gardens II Florida llr-3-34_1_8---.., lome Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: ·=,6=1-=3=1=0=-3=2=6=7==========~~.-5-6-1--7-4-5--7-7_1_5-------,~~561-31 0-3267 . II rd-a-vi..,.d_@_s_o--~-th-fl-o-rid_a_h_o_m_e_c_a-re-.c-o,_.m__,.., --- 0===2 =---------' ·ears of Residency: Secondary Email Address: ~referred Means of Contact: ._I c_e_l_l P_h_o_n_e ______ _. ldavid.paul@fluerdeliscapital.co~ Jease place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. if Art in Public Places Advisory Board D Community Aesthetics Board lifParks and Recreation Advisory Board lifPianning, Zoning and Appeals Board * D Budget Oversight Committee (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30 p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00 p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00 p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) D Fire Pension_Board (m.e~~s semi-monthly as c~lled) . D Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) ~ * Required to file a statement of financial interest form f you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: I PZAB -Planning, Zoning & Appeals Board Second Choice: RAB -Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Third Choice: IAIPP-Art in Public Pla~es Board .re you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No If so, which one(s)? ·'ave you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? .re you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s)? lave you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? .re you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings 0 Evening Meetings /hat would you hope to accomplish by participating? 1 would like to contributed time and resources for the betterment of Palm Beach County in the public sector. I am a proud citizen of Palm Beach County and currently reside in Unincoproated Palm Beach County. I am an active member in the Northern Palm Beach Chamber of Commerce and Juoiter Liaht Masonic Lodae. Mv aoal is to [ ~rE;~ n2~: --------------------------------------------------------------------- Iouth Florida Home Care IIHome Care for Elderly ~.ar.ar.r~e~s~s~=------------------------------------~ kp~o~sT.itrrio~n~=------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------~ ·500 Military Tr: #22=131~-Jupiter, Fl;'33458 --lcEO ~------------------------------------------~e you a Lobbyist? 0Yes ®No .re you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ®No 10 you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ®No low many years have you practiced in the above profession? D ould your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided pon by the Board or Committee? O Yes ®No If yes, explain: ~ofessional Background (please check all that apply) I Accountant I Adult Sports Programming f Aquatics Programming I Architect I Architect Design/Urban Planner I Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. I Attorney I Banker I Building Construction I Div. 1 Bldg -General Contractor ducationaiBackground D Div. 2 MEP Contractor D Business Owner in PSG D Engineer D PGA Corridor Association D Environmental Professional D Real Estate Professional D Golf Course Participant D Recreation Programming D Horticulture & Landscaping !if Senior-Targeted Activities D Land Surveyor D Special Population Advocate 0 Landscape Architect _ 0 T~n_n[s ~~11~er Par::tJc:ip_anL ____ _ D Member of Bus. Dev. Board D Visual I Literary Arts !ifNPB County Chamber of Commerce D Volunteer from PBGYAA D Other: L-1 __________ _,1 Diploma/Degree Institution Course of Study IM BA I 'IN_o_rt_h_e-as-t-er_n_U_n-iv_e_r-si-ty-----------------.~~Business Ad ministration ~==================~ Iss llspringfield College IIHuman Services _l==l ____ = ___ =::_==:::_=::_=:::===11------------------~rF= ____ =___ === re you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No ave you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes 0 No If yes, explain: low did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? ) City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend ® Other: IPalm Beach Post rior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: I I ArtGras, Riverwalk Projects in Jupiter, Loggerhead Triathalon, Sunfest etc mderstand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. !if Agree mderstand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG !if Agree :mdatory Code of Ethics Training. arne: Date: -'"-.:-..J_\_A 1--n---. -.I ---------------,~1 A • '-,..,1'\-1,.., Text I would like to contributed time and resources for the betterment of Palm Beach County in the public sector. I am a proud citizen of Palm Be~ci:LCo~Joty_and cum~ntly resjde ioLJninCQRroated Palr::oJleaGb Co_un):y_._LaJJLaJLacliv_e _____ . member in the Northern Palm Beach Chamber of Commerce and Jupiter Light Masortic Lodge. My goal is to improve the appeal of Palm Beach Gardens in order to draw revenue. -----·····---- ----· ------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------ City of Palm Beach Gardens BoarctPiease Note: Pu_rsuant_ to ~s ~19.07_the information ~rovided in A I . t" th1s application IS cons1dered to be public record, PP ICa IOn except as provided by law. Last Name: First Name: Ml: Nickname, if preferred: Address: =~he=ch=t===========~=~joy=============~c=J~I --~--------~ City: State: Zip: ~=3=59=0==1o=ir=e=la=n=e=========================~.--~p-al_m_b_e_a_c_h_g-ar_d_e-ns------.~~ Florida 11'3-34_1_0 ___ , Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: 1._5_6_1-_6_2_7-_3_1_3_2 ____ ___.11 = ===---------'~ ,,----------,~~yoyohecht@aol.com Years of Residency: EJ Secondary Email Address: Preferred Means of Contact: ._I N_o_pr_e_fe_re_n_c_e _____ _. Please place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. if Art in Public Places Advisory Board D Community Aesthetics Board D Parks and Recreation Advisory Board D Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * D Budget Oversight Committee (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00 p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) D Fire Pension Board (meets semi-monthly as called) D Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: Second Choice: Third Choice: Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes @ No If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? @Yes 0 No If so, which one(s), and when? !planning zoning and appeals Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0Yes @No If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? @Yes 0 No If so, which one(s), and when? !planning zoning and appeals Are you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings @ Evening Meetings What would you hope to accomplish by participating? l keep PBG beaumul I L.--------------------------------------~1 r-N-e_x_t_P_a_g_e~ ------------------------ Preserit Employment: Profession: r~-o-u-se_w_i-fe _ __:____;;__ ______________ ---,1 brchitect Xddress: ~os1t1on: Are you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ® No Are you registered with Palm Beach County? ® Yes 0 No Do you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No How many years have you practiced in the above profession? D Could your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee? O Yes ®No If yes, explain: Professional Background (please check all that apply) D Accountant D Adult Sports Programming D Aquatics Programming liK Architect D Architect Design/Urban Planner DArts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. D Attorney D Banker D Building Construction D Div. 1 Bldg -General Contractor Educational Background D Div. 2 MEP Contractor D Business Owner in PBG D Engineer D PGA Corridor Association D Environmental Professional D Real Estate Professional D Golf Course Participant D Recreation Programming D Horticulture & Landscaping D Senior-Targeted Activities D Land Surveyor D Special Population Advocate D Landscape Architect D Tennis Center Participant D Member of Bus. Dev. Board D Visual I Literary Arts D NPB County Chamber of Commerce D Volunteer from PBGYAA D Other: ._l __________ _.l Diploma/Degree Institution Course of Study 1. IB.A IIAdelphi U. IIEng./French 2. ls.A. architect I :=IN=.Y=.=I=n=st=T=e=c=h=no=l=og=y============lllarchecture 3. ~------------------------~~----------------------------~F~ ============~ Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No Have you participated in civic or community activities? ® Yes 0 No If yes, ex~ Chair Frenchman's Creek Charity Foundation Chair F.C. Women for Scripps Cancer Research How did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? ® City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend 0 Other: Prior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: l I I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. lil Agree I understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG Manda~ Co~e of Ethics Training. IJ!I Rgre Name: Date: r-ljo_y_h_e-ch_t _______ __,l26 Sep 2012 .___P_ri_n_t_ ..... l I Previous Page txtActivityExplanation -Page 2 Text Chair Frenchman's Creek Charity Foundation Chair F.C. Women for Scripps Cancer Research CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS CITY COUNCIL Agenda Cover Memorandum Meeting Date: October 11, 2012 Resolution 90, 2012 Subject/Agenda Item: Appointment of Members to the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board [X] Recommendation to APPROVE [ ] Recommendation to DENY Reviewed by: R. Advertised: NA Date: 1-----------1 Paper: Submitted by: [ x 1 Not Required Affected parties 1-----------l Approved by: [ 1 Notified City Manager [ x 1 Not required Costs: $0.00 (Total) $0.00 Current FY Funding Source: [ 1 Operating [x 1 Other Contract/Agreement: Effective Date: NA Expiration Date: NA Budget Acct.#: Council Action: 1 Approved 1 Approved w/ Conditions 1 Denied 1 Continued to: Attachments: • Resolution 90, 2012 • Exhibit "A": Attendance Records • Exhibit "B": Applications Meeting Date: October 11, 2012 Resolution 90, 2012 Page 2 of2 BACKGROUND: The purpose, powers and duties of this Parks and Recreation Advisory Board are to serve as advocates for the citizens by conducting constructive investigations, discussion and review; provide advice to the Community Services Department, City Manager, and Council with a broad outlook towards improving present recreational facilities and increasing utilization of the facilities by the public; and evaluating and recommending future community needs for recreational projects and facilities. Effective October 11, 2012, Tory Buckley, Jacob Noble, Bill Sonnenreich, and Arnie Schneider are eligible for reappointment. Therefore, the appointments for 2012-2013 include four (4) Regular Members eligible for reappointment (Tory Buckley, Jacob Noble, Bill Sonnenreich, and Amie Schneider), one (1) Regular Member, and two (2) Alternate Member vacancies. SUMMARY: Regular Member(s) Eligible for Reappointment Tory Buckley -2-year term Jacob Noble -2-year term Bill Sonnen reich -2-year term Arnie Schneider-1-year term. Arnie will be term limited as of 09/30/13. Vacancies to be filled One (1) regular member-filling unexpired 1-year term of Jim Amsler-expires 9/30/13 First Alternate Second Alternate Additional Applications on File Keith Ahronheim Dennis Beran Christopher Dinolfo Reginald Maton David Paul David Peters Rebecca Pine Kenneth Steele Current Composition of the Board: Tory Buckley-Regular Member-Chair Tim Frohling -Regular Member-Vice Chair Howard Nass-Regular Member Jacob Noble-Regular Member Arnie Schneider-Regular Member Bill Sonnenrieich -Regular Member To Be Appointed-Regular Member To Be Appointed-First Alternate To Be Appointed-Second Alternate Staff posts notices of vacancies at City Hall and on the City Website. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of Resolution 90, 2012 as presented. ------------------------------------ 1 2 3 RESOLUTION 90, 2012 4 5 6 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM 7 BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING THE APPOINTMENT 8 OF REGULAR AND ALTERNATE MEMBERS TO THE PARKS AND 9 RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE 10 DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 11 12 13 WHEREAS, Section 2-138 of the City's Code of Ordinances, provides for the 14 Board to be comprised of seven (7) members and two (2) alternate members; and 15 16 WHEREAS, as of October 11, 2012, there are one (1) regular and two (2) 17 alternate member vacancies; and 18 19 WHEREAS, notice of the vacancies has been posted at City Hall and on the City 20 website; and 21 22 WHEREAS, the City Clerk has collected applications of all interested persons 23 who wish to serve as members of the Board, along with attendance records of the 24 current members, which are attached hereto as Exhibit "B"; and 25 26 WHEREAS, the City Council deems approval of this Resolution to be in the best 27 interests of the health, safety, and welfare of the residents and citizens of the City of 28 Palm Beach Gardens and the public at large. 29 30 31 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY 32 OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA that: 33 34 SECTION 1. The foregoing recitals are hereby affirmed and ratified. 35 36 SECTION 2. The City Council hereby approves the appointment of regular and 37 alternate members to the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board as set forth in Exhibit 38 "A". 39 40 SECTION 3. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon adoption. 41 42 43 44 45 46 Page 1 of 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 Resolution 90, 2012 PASSED AND ADOPTED this __ day of ________ , 2012. CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA BY: ------------------------------David Levy, Mayor ATTEST: BY: -------------------------Patricia Snider, CMC, City Clerk APPROVEDASTOFORMAND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY BY: ·-------------------------R. Max Lohman, City Attorney VOTE: AYE NAY ABSENT MAYOR LEVY VICE MAYOR PREMUROSO COUNCILMEMBER TINSLEY COUNCILMEMBER RUSSO COUNCILMEMBER JABLIN G:\attorney_share\RESOLUTIONS\2012\Resolution 90 2012 RAB appointment 2012.doc Page 2 of 2 Regular Member(s) Tory Buckley Jacob Noble Bill Sonnenreich Arnie Schneider Alternate Member(s) EXHIBIT "A" Term(s) Expiring on 09/30/14 Expiring on 09/30/14 Expiring on 09/30/14 Resolution 90, 2012 Expiring and term limiting on 09/30/13 Resolution 90, 2012 EXHIBIT "8" PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD 2011-20~2 Council Liaison • Marcie Tinsley Staff Liaison • Mike Kelly Staff Liaison • Charlotte Presensky Staff liaison • Tim Kasher Aft. Staff Liaison • Christv Wolnewltz All Staff Liaison • Mike Kelly 2011·2012 Board Members - Jim Amsler (Regular Member) Eric Workman (1st Alternate) Timothy Frohllng (Vice Chair) Howard Nass (Regular Member) Amle Schneider (Regular Member) WJJJlam Sonnenrelch (Regular Member) Tory Buckley (Chair) Jason Noble (Regular Member) Vacant (2nd Alternate ) P= Present A•Absent R" Resigned NM =No Meeting C=Cancelled NQ=No Quorum NAM., Not a Member Excused Absence: Sub~ena, lllneea, Jurv Duty Parks Recreation Advisory Board Attendance 11/21/11 A p p A p p p p p p "' 2 N ~ 0 N I d lll 1123112 315112 NQ 7116112 p p p p p p p p p A A A A A NAM p A p p p A p p A p A p p A p p p p I f I ;::! ~ ~ ~ ~ ;; ~ 0 ~ ~ ... I I ~ !ll C1 C1 a ~ ~ ~ ; : ' Page 1 City of Palm Beach Gardens Board &. Committee Application Pursuant to rmation provi ir this application is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: I:A=h=ro=n=h=e=im=================J:IK:e=it=h====================~~L-----~----------------~ddress: City: State: Zip: _,s_o_o_l_d_M_e_a_d_ow __ w_a_Y _________ __.II ,..P_a..:lm-B-ea-. ch __ G_a_r_d-es_n _____ __,,, Florida II r3-34_1_8 ____ _, lome Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: )61 656 0284 I ~~5==61==7==7==5_7_8_15 ____ -JII ..-5-16-24_1_2_4_6_3-----.,, rk-ah-r-on_h_e-im-@-ao-1.-co_m ______ _ 'ears of Residency: D Secondary Email Address: •referred Means of Contact: L.l c_e_l_l P_h_o_n_e ______ _, •lease place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By CodeJ some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. 0 Art in Public Places Advisory Board 0 Community Aesthetics Board !if Parks and Recreation Advisory Board !if Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * !if Budget Oversight Committee (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at6:00 p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) liJFire Pension Board (meets semi-monthly as called) !if Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a .statement of fin~ncial interest form :f you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: I PZAB -Planning, Zoning & Appeals Board Second Choice: I BOC -Budget Oversight Committee Third Choice: j Fire-Fire Fighters Pension Board ~re you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No If so, which one{s)? iave you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one{s), and when? ~re you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No If so, which one(s)? fave you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? If so, which one(s), and when? ~re you able to attend: ® Daytime Meetings 0 Evening Meetings IVhat would you hope to accomplish by participating? Be able to apply my legal and business background to assist the Board and committees .. OYes ®No • ---·· • -···r·-• • ··-· • -· ~h;se Bank jiAttomey .~a~a~r~e~s~s~=-------------------------------------J "P~o~snit~io==n~=--------------------------------------- ;-3-99_P_G_A_B_Iv_d_#_1_2_0_, _P_B_G_, _F_L_3-34_1_0 __________ ...,nManager Homeownership Center .re you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ® No .re you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ® No to you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No low many years have you practiced in the above profession? .D :ould your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided 1pon by the_ Board or Committe.e? r.::\• Yes 0 No If yes, explain: ~ If the subject involves Chase Bank. 'rofessional Background (please check all that apply) ] Accountant ] Adult Sports Programming ] Aquatics Programming ] Architect ] Architect Design/Urban Planner ] Arts and Culturallnstit. Mgmt. I" Attorney rBanker ] Building Construction ] Div. 1 Bldg-General Contractor :ducational Background Diploma/Degree BA JD 0 Div. 2 MEP Contractor 0Engineer D Environmental Professional · 0 Golf Course Participant 0 Horticulture & Landscaping 0 Land Surveyor -~··fJtam:tsc~ Arthitro 0 Member of Bus. Dev. Board 0 NPB Coun Chamber of Commerce !if Other: NYS Administrative Law Judge Institution !Adelphi University Stetson University, College of Law lre you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0No lave you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes 0 No 0 Business Owner in PBG D PGA Corridor Association 0 Real Estate Professional D Recreation Programming D Senior-Targeted Activities 0 Special Population Advocate EJ-Tl:mnis-centerPartid pant 0 Visual/ Literary Arts 0 Volunteer from PBGYAA Course of Study ~ Economics Law If yes, explain: ·-·-..=...c.,~-~-·· -· ol Chairman of Honda Classic 3 years. liow did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? Board member Patio Homeownership Association. ) City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend ®Other: jPalm Beach Post 'rior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: I I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Comrraittees to which I have applied. lil Agree understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG tandatory Code of Ethics Training. lil Agree lame: Date: J\.11'\\,;UVIlYI:.~JJli::llli:UIUII-ri::lyt: 1!. Text Vol Chairman of Honda Classic- 3 years. Board member Patio· Homeownership Association. ---------·-··--~------------------~----·------------ -----·-----. -----·-··-·-·· .. City of Palm Beach Gardens Please Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided in this application is considered to be public record 1 Bf?.ard &. COf!!~i~ee Ap~_~cati'!~-_ ---~~C:~Pt Cl~_p!:_ovic!_ed b'lJay.~_. _ _ _______ ··--. Last Name: First Name: Ml: Nickname, if preferred: Address: ~~-nd-e~--n----------~~~~M-eli_ss_a __________ ~lr==J~I---=------~--~' City: State: Zip: ,..,2_2_0_2_C_o_u_rt_, ____________ ___,,jPalm Beach Gardens II Florida I r-,3-3-4-10----. Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: ~---------~~,..~-.-------------~,~5613109261 I r,m-.p-.-a-nd_e_r-so_n_0_7_11_@_._g_m_a_il.-ornn------~~ Years of Residency: D Secondary Email Address: I Preferred Means of Contact: Ll H_om_e_P_h_on_e _____ ___. Please place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in sent'ing: By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. 0 Art in Public 'Places Advisory Board D Community Aesthetics Board lil Parks and Recreation Advisory Board D Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * D Budget Oversight Committee (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) D Fire Pension Board (meets semi-monthly as called) D Police Pension Board ·cmeets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: Second Choice: Third Choice: Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes ®No If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? ·Qves ®No If so, which one(s), and when? Are you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings ® Evening Meetings What would you hope to accomplish by participating? I am an attorney who has been involved local government law in south Florida for over 20 years, primarily in Broward County. I moved to Palm Beach Gardens 2 years ago and really love living here and taking advantage of Next Page . . . ~ ' .. Present Employment: Profession: r,G_rn_d_u_a_re--St_u_d-en_t_a_n_d_s_m_y_a_t_h_o_m_e_m_o_m ______ ~--------~, ~ttomey I -Address: Position: ·_122_o 2_~c_~u_rt _________ ____.l ~--~-------------------.~!' Are you a Lobbyist? OYes ®No Are you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ® No Do you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No How many years have you practiced in the above profession? EJ Could your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee? 0 Yes ®No If yes1 explain: Professional Background (please check all that apply) 0 Accountant D Adult Sports Programming D Aquatics Programming OArchitect D Architect Design/Urban Planner 0 Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. !il Attorney 0 Banker D Building Construction D Div. 1 Bldg-General Contractor Educational Background Diploma/Degree l.IBA, 1986 2. !Juris Doctor, 1990 3.Jenrolled in Masters Program 0 Div. 2 MEP Contractor D Business Owner in PBG 0 Engineer 0 PGA Corridor Association !1l Environmental Professional !if Real Estate Professional 0 Golf Course Participant 0 Recreation Programming 0 Horticulture & landscaping 0 Senior-Targeted Activities 0 Land Surveyor 0 Special Population Advocate 0 Landscape Architect 0 Tennis Center Participant 0 Member of Bus. Dev. Board 0 Visual/ Uterary Arts 0 NPB County Chamber of Commerce 0 Volunteer from PBGYAA 0 Other: ~~-------~---'' Institution lluF lloF College of Law I IF AU Course of Study II English jjLaw, Land Use, Environmental !!Public Administration Are you registered to vote 'in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No Have you participated in civic or community activities? ® Yes 0 No If yes, explain: How did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are .applying? ® City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend 0 other: I._ _______ ___. Prior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: I j I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. Name: Dare: IMAiissR P. And Arson l2o Jun 2011 Print Previous Paae t I txtHopetoAccomplish -Page 1 Text l.am-an.attomey.wbo.has been involvedJocal-govemmentlawJn.south-Eioridalor-.over-20-years,-primarily-inl---• Broward County. I moved to Palm Beach Gardens 2 years ago and really love living here and taking advantage of ffie lovely park facilities. nook forward to being inv6hied iii planning -and d-eveloping parks and pai1< programs hi the city. City of Palm Beach Gardens Boar Application lease Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided this application is considered to be public recorc except as provided by law. --------------------------··-· ·---------~~~-'------------~--=== Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: .... ,B-e-ra-n-------------~ ~~D.,....e_n_ni_s ____ ----....;-JI D 1...------:::::-------- ldress: City: State: Zip: ~-. V_i_a_D_e_l C_o_r_s_o------,--------.... ,,Palm Beach Garrdens II Florida . I rl3-34_1_8 ___ _, )me Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: :t;1-625-4800 ~~~N=/A=...,..-~----.....J''561-625-4800 llr-b-er-a-nj_@_b_e_lls_o_u-th-.n-e-t ------ !ars of Residency: D Secondary Email Address: ·eferred Means of Contact:-~._ E_m_ai_l _______ ___. ease place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: 9y Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. 0 Art in Public Places Advisory Board 0 Community Aesthetics Board ~Parks and Recreation Advisory Board fJ Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * ~Budget Oversight Committee (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30 p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly qn the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursd~y_at 8:30a.m.) l] Fire Pension-Board . ____ -c(meet~~~!!IJ-:_~~nthly as ~lied) -------· -~-,....--------------- 0 Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: I BOC -Budget Oversight Committee Second Choice: RAB-Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Third Choice: ·e you currently serving on a __ ~1.111 Beach_ ~~-r~e_~!;-Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No If so, whiCh one(s)? sve you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? !f so, which one(s), and when? . .. ---·-·--. ~· _ 0Yes ®No ·e you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No !f so, which one(s)? sve you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee?-" [f so, which one(s), and when? ·e you able to attend: ® Daytime Meetings 0 Evening Meetings hat would you hope to accomplish by participating? 0Yes ®No I would like to be ~n active member of the community to ensure Palm Beach Gardens continues to be a beautiful, exciting and enjoyable place to live. ,-------.,_- \ 1\1 .... ,·~._ n-.... Q:tired jiEngineer and Construction t~ar.r~e~s~s~=----------------------------------~ kp~o~s~.t~io~n~:~---------------------------------- ------------------·-· ··-·----·----~--------··--·-l-1.___--.----··-_-·-_··-_-.---~------· .. _ ....... _---·--_··-_--____,·-------_ .... ' ·-· ·e you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ®No ·e you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ® No , you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No )W many years have you practiced in the above profession? EJ 1uld your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decide 1on by the Board or Committee? O Yes ®No If yes, explain: ·ofessional Background (please check all that apply) ·Accountant Adult Sports Programming Aquatics Programming Architect Architect Design/Urban Planner Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. 0 Div. 2 MEP Contractor liJEngineer 0 Environmental Professional til Golf Course Participant 0 Horticulture & Landscaping 0 Land Surveyor D Business Owner in PBG D PGA Corridor Association D Real Estate Professional 0 Recreation Programming D Senior-Targeted Activities D Special Population Advocate _ AttorneY-- Banker ··------IJ .. Lan.ds.cape_A[chitect __ .... ---·-··--D Te.o_ois_Ce.n.te.r.Ea.tttcipa.nt _______ _ 0 Member of Bus. Dev. Board D Visual/ Literary Arts Building Construction Div. 1 Bldg-General Contractor 0 NPB County Chamber of Commerce 0 Volunteer from PBGYAA []Other: ~.....1 -----~----'~ lucational Background Diploma/Degree Institution Course of Study !Masters IIGeorge Washington University, Wash. D. C !!operations Research I=IB=a=c=he=l=or=s=o=f =Sc=i=en=c=e==========="""""=~Jiuniveristy of Maryland II Mechanical Engineering ..___1----__ -·_----=-~-....... ==l=f ===== .. =-----=·--==_-~____.11....__---==--· .. ---=-----=----~_···- ·e you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No 1ve you participated in civic or community activities? 0 Yes ®No If yes, ex1 ow did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? r.... ---------------'-- City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend ® Other: JPalm Beach Post ·ior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: I 0412112010 j 1nderstand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. 1if Agree 1nderstand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG Manda~ Code • T · • 1m Agree 11cs rammg. me: Date: n--. -:_-_-•• -...,--::::t::"~=--n-=--n-..... -.--------,1 "A /A , .... ~ "' "--"' ·=-· ~-,......_ __ City of Palm Beach Gardens Please Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided in Board a Committee A lication this applicatio~ is considered to be public record, ------· --·· --·· .. ---.--·----~~!__ _______________ ··-·-------~xc;_em; __ ~nrm"dec;Lby_law_,__ .. __ ... _ --------· __ Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: Address: ~~r?~i-n_.o~ff~o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~C~h_n_·s_ro_p_h_er ________________ ~J~JL ____ ~~--------------~ City: State: Zip: .-,9-0-49 __ C_y_p-res __ s_H_o_ll_ow_D_t_·iv_e _______________ ....,IIPalm Beach Gardens II Florida I .-,3-3-4-18-------. Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: =~5=6_1-3=5=2=59=5=9==========~ :15=6=18=3=9=05=8=9==========~~5613528795 I rJc_P_D-in_o_lfo_@_a_a-ol-.c-o_m _______ __, Years of Residency: ~ Secondary Email Address: Preferred Means of Contact: ~..1 E_m __ a_u _____________ _. Please place a check next to each board/ committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code, some Boards/Committees have spedfic requirements for membership. 0 Art in Public Places Advisory Board D Community Aesthetics Board fifParks and Recreation Advisory Board 0 Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * if Budget Oversight Committee 0 Fire Pension Board (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarter1y on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00 p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00 p.m.) {meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00 p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) Cm~gt$. s~mi-:mgnthiY_E? call~c:l) __ . 0 Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: f BOG -Budget Oversight Committee Second Choice: I RAB -Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Third Choice: Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No . If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? If so, which one(s), and when? Are you able to attend: ® Daytime Meetings 0 Evening Meetings What would you hope to accomplish by participating? 0Yes ®No I would like to bring the opinions and leadership of a young working pro~essional into Palm Beach Gardens local government. I have v..that it takes to listen to all the facts on a particular subject and cast an educated vote on that Next Page Pr~sen.~ ,employment: Profession: ~~M~o~r~se_L_i~-e------~----------~--------~~----~'='B~u_s~in~e_ss ___ D_ev_e_lo_p_m_e_n_t ____________________________ ~ ·Address:·-·---·-·-------·-Position: ---· -------·--·· ·-····------··· lr4-84-7--Fr_e_d_G_Ia_d_s_ro_n_e_D_rl_ve __ WP __ B_,_F_L_3_34_1_7------------~ Are you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ® No Are you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ® No Do you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No How many years have you practiced in the above profession? D Could your occupation present a cOnflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee? 0 Yes ®No . If yes, explain: Professional Background (please check all that apply) D Accountant D Adult Sports Programming D Aquatics Programming 0 Architect 0 Div; 2 MEP Contractor 0 Engineer 0 Environmental Professional 0 Golf Course Participant lil Business Owner in PBG D PGA Corridor Association D Real Estate Professional D Recreation Programming D Architect Design/Urban Planner 0 Horticulture & Landscaping Iii( senior-Targeted Activities 0 Arts and--Gu!turai-Inst~t .... fvlgmt~ -GI--land--£uP!ey-Or::_____ ld-Special-RopuJat.ion-Advocate---- 0 Attorney 0 Landscape Architect 0 Tennis Center Participant 0 Banker !if Member of Bus. Dev. Board D Visual/ Literary Arts 0 Building Construction D NPB County Chamber of Commerce 0 Volunteer from PBGYAA 0 Div. 1 Bldg-General Contractor 0 Other: }._ ___________________ ..... ! Educational Background Diploma/Degree Institution Course of Study 1. ls.s tluniversity of Ftorida llsiology I -2.--jrv1:S. · ------------III::Jniversity·of-South-Fforida ·------IFging-and-Neuroscience------·~-•-I 3 ·1.._ ______ __..jilL--____ ____..~II I Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0No Have you participated in civic or community activities? 0 Yes ® No If yes, expfain: How did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? ®City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend -0 Other:( L _____________ ____J Prior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: J J I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. Name: Date: !christopher Dinolfo 17 Sep 2011 Print Previous Page txtflopetoAccomplish -Page 1 -I would like to bring·tlu)·opinions-and-feadershfp--ofa young working-professionafinto·Palm-Beach-Gardens·local---•--------- govemment I have what it takes to lis1en to all the facts on a particular subject and cast an educated vote on that particular matter. Working amongst the senior community. being employed by MorseUfe, I would like to also be a voice for the Medicare population wi1hin our community. City of Palm Beach Gardens . Board Be. Committee Application lease Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided ir this application is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. ·--------·"--·. "·~~------·--·-·---~~--.. -------·-------"" ·--·-~----~-------------------.. ·--.. ------------------ Last Name: First Name: MI-: ·Nickname, if preferred: JrM-a-t-on __________________ ~,LIR_e_g_in_a_rd _______________ ~l~fL_e_g __ -=~--------------- ~ddress: City: State: Zip: 1_2_9_0_0_L_a_R_o_ch_e_ll_e_C_ir_c_le _________ __,,,Palm Beach Gardens II Florida II r-3_34_1_0 ___ _, tome Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: 346-210-3708 1 .._ls_s_1-_s_o4_-_s7_3_7 ___ _..__.lls46-21 0-3708 1 rlre_g_m_a-to_n_@_co_m_ca_st-.n-e-t ------ rears of Residency: D Secondary Email Address: •referred Means of Contact: L..l w __ o_rk_P_h_o_n_e _____ _,-~ •lease place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: · By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. fil Art in Public Places Advisory Board fil Community Aesthetics Board 1iJ Parks and Recreation Advisory Board 1iJ Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * 1iJ Budget Oversight Committee (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00 p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00 p.m.) {meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) · .!if Fir~ Pension Board --.Jr:n~~ts -~-~!lli-monthly as c~_IJ~~) filPolice Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interes~_form :fyou have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: I BOC -Budget Oversight Committee Second Choice: j Fire -Fire Fighters Pension Board Third Choice: j·AJPP-Art in Public Places Board \re you:curr~n~ly_ ~ei:Ving_on ~:.--e~_i·.n_~~ait.~6arcierisJioarifor~cominTrl:ee? ---Gv~s _ ~® ·N~ ·-_---~:~~~ ~~~~;~-=- If so, which one(s)? lave you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? ~re you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No If so1 which one(s)? lave you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? \re you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings ® Evening Meetings · IVhat would you hope to accomplish by participating? Use my corporate knowledge, experience as CIO to give back to the community -·-------··-~---·-··.:..r_·--•:....·-·-·--·-·--·--------------, .. -· ---·-··· fhink Strategic Technology Partners, li .. c §onsulting L ress: 5~~o~s~.t~io=n:7:--------------------------- r290iflaRocheTieClrCTe---··--:· .. ----------H .. _ .. __ ....:._.::.::.: .. ; ___ :.tiP.incipal ~-----------------------------------------lre you a Lobbyist?. 0 Yes ® No ~re you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ® No to you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No low many years have you practiced in the above profession? D :ould y~ur occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided 1pon by the Board or Committee? O Yes ®No If yes, explain: •rofessional Background (please check all that apply) ] Acqmntant ] Adult Sports Programming ] Aquatics Programming ]Architect ] Architect Design/Urban Planner ] Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. 0 Div. 2 MEP Contractor lif E-ngineer 0 Environmental Professional lif Golf Course Participant 0 Horticulture & Landscaping 0 Land Surveyor liK Business Owner. in PBG D PGA Corridor Association fiK Real Estate Professional 0 Recreation Programming 0 Senior-Targeted Activities 0 Special Population Advocate ] .Attorney -_ ___ -. 0 Landscape Architect _____ 0 Tennis Center Participant ____ _ ]Banker ] Building Construction ] Div. 1 Bldg -General Contractor :ducational Background Diploma/Degree . BA ' B$11;:_ --.--···~~-•r>•••··----~----• ··-~--••• u. ---· - !VIS 0 Member of Bus. Dev. Board 0 NPB Coun Chamber of Commerce !if other: Institution Columbia University, Columbia College QQI~!IJJ?i~ ~!!gLn .. ~~i!lg....§r_~J?[!Ii~!! Selene_~ - Golumbia Engineering-& Applied Science ,re you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No - 0 Visual/ Literary Arts !iKVolunteer from PBGYAA Course of Study !Math/Economics .. ·-·-~n_~y§trial E!!gJ!l~~!!.ll.9_ ... ---·~ Eng Management .. ··- -----·· -- lave you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes 0 No If yes, Coach. Palm Beach Gardens explain: recreation baseball fow did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? ) City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend ®Other: !Palm Beach Post •rior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: .... ! ___ -,---,,...__, understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. 1if Agree understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, l am required to complete the PBG landatory Code of Ethics Training. arne: Date: lif Agree ' · Last Name: First Name: ~ , MI: Nickname, if preferred: 1ddress: ~~P-au_r __ ~--~----~~~~0-av_id~··------------~'~L-~~~--~---- City: State: Zip: ,-0-87-15_5_th_P_I N--------------.~~Palm Beach Gardens II Florida I ri3...,.J4_1_8 __ __, lome Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: i61-310-3267 11561-745-7715 JJss1-310-3267 . I .... ,d-a-vi....,..d@-. -s-ou ...... t-hf-lo-ri-da_h_o_m_e_c-ar-e-.c-o_m __ _ ~-=---------~---~L-------1~--------~ L"--------------------------- 'earS of Residency: D Secondary Email Address: jdavid.paul@fluerdeliscapital.com r,referred Means of Contact: '-' c_e_l_l P_h_o_n_e _________ ....,~ )ease place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. !if Art in Public Places Advisory Board 0 Community Aesthetics Board ·!if Parks and Recreation Advisory Board !ifPianning1 Zoning and Appeals Board * D Budget Oversight Committee D Fire Pension Board (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) {meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) (meets semi-monthly as called) \0 Police Pension Board {meets quarterly as called) ,) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form ~you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: I PZAB -Planning, Zoning & Appeals Board Second Choice: RAB -Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Third Choice: lAIPP -Art in Public Pla~es Board. ~re you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No , If so, which one(s)? ~ave you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? 1re you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No . If so, which one(s)? lave you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? If S01 which one(s), and when? tre you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings 0 Evening Meetings )hat would you hope to accomplish by participating? 0Yes ®No I would like to contributed time and resources for the betterment of Palm Beach County in the public sector. I am a proud citizen of Palm Beach County and currently reside in Unincoproated Palm Beach County. I am an active member in the Northern Palm Beach Chamber ofCommerce and Juoiter Lioht Masonic Lodae. Mv aoal is to .... ~-:.-.. ·-·.~:~· --~-~ . . ~··-:~~~~~~~(··:~~-if,~,·~~'tF #.\!if.~·:.:··· ~-~~r -~~:~~,~-~~.-~:r.:-J<~-.... -·~· ,-"::-~ <~~~-~-:: ·~, .---~ .. :,·· v· • , ~·:•· ........... _.·-··. ·-.• . ......... >outh Florida Home Care jiHome Care for Elderly ,ddress: R~~o~s~•tr.lo~n~:~----------------------------------- ~'s_oo __ M_iri_m_~_T_r_._#2_2_-_13_1_._Ju_p_it_er_._F_r._33_4_s_s ____________ ~j~c_E_o ______________________________________ _ ~.re you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ® No .. 1re you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ® No . -... lo you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ®No low many years have you practiced in the above profession? D :ould your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided 1pon by the Board or Committee? O Yes ® No If yes, explain: :tofessional Background (please check all that apply) ] Accountant ] Adult Sports Programming J Aquatics Programming ·] Architect ] Architect Design/Urban Planner ] Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. ] Attorney 1 Banker ~ J Building Construction J Div. 1 Bldg -General Contractor :ducational Background. Diploma/Degree Cl Div. 2 MEP Contractor 0 Engineer 0 Environmental Professional D Golf Course Participant 0 Horticulture & Landscaping 0 Land Surveyor 0 Landscape Architect 0 Member of Bus. Dev. Board fil NPB County Chamber of Commerce 0 Other: { . . · Institution I 0 Business Owner in PBG 0 PGA Corridor Association 0 Real Estate Professional 0 Recreation Programming fil Senior-Targeted Activities 0 Special Population Advocate 0 Tennis Center Participant 0 Visual/ Literary Arts 0 Volunteer from PBGY AA Course of Study : !MBA jjNortheastem University !!Business Administration · (as ~~~S=p=ri=ng=fi=le=ld=C=o=l=~=g=e==================~'~?H=u=m=a=n=S=e=N=ic=e=s============== .~ I I l j,re you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No ~· • • ' • > lave you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes 0 No If yes, explain: iow did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? ) City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend ® Other: jPalm Beach Post •rior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: j . I rtGras, Riverwalk Projects in upiter, Loggerhead Triathalon, Sunfestetc ~understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. lif Agree ::understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG fil Agree landatory Code of Ethics Training. ·a me: Date: ---•• -:~-~-A-1 -,...-_-.-•• ----------,~ ., 1\. ·-I"H'\of.., , Text I would like to contributed time and resources for the betterment of Palm Beach County in the public sector. I am a proud citizen of Palm Beach County and currently reside in Unincoproated Palm Beac;h County. I am an active member in the Northern Palm Beach Chamber of Commerce and Jupiter light Masonic lodge. My goal is to i,mprove the appeal of Palm Beach Gardens in order to draw revenue. -~-~------··----==--•----------·--·------=---··-······-· APiJliCatiOii fur City AdVisozyBoilrd/ComiliiUee Appointment -- Please Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the infOrmation provided in dlis applieatioo is Considered Co be public record, except as provided by law. · N:amc: L241!,'cl L. /if,_c. Home Address: t2ti 'f/u&t;rA. /2:1 Cify: 'Fl./,~/,. 4J.,;pp:I3Y'.f HomePhoneNumber:(~l)flS"-t-k/ WorkPhoneNmnbcr:($M) Jlfl-9~~>dl"~z.~ Years ofResidency? 4. mp s E-Dlllil adtkess: d/fid ~r~ €},6us,, -.J",c .CA,., .k• /,~~ .. J,.,,;J ~Jus. G) WHICHBOARDO~COMMITTEBAREYOUAPPLYlNGFOR: oe-1/'So~•tte.../... 0 Art In Public Plata Advisory Beard [J CommunitJ Aesdletlts Board t.Y'" Parks ud Reereatfoa Advisory ~oard tl .;Economic D~opmeat AdriiiOI"f BOard ~Budget Owenfght Committee tiY'I'Iannlng, Zo.tng & Appeals Board" (meeu 3r4 Tuesday of~ month at 5:30p.m.) (meets 1111 Wednesday ofeada month at 5:30p.m.) (meets tiler Monday of eaeh month at 7:00p.m.) (meets the 1.•d TlumHiay of eada rnoath at 8:30a.m.) (mee1s the 4"' Tlumday of eaeh montb at 8:30a.m.) (meets the r and ,n. 1'1tesdays of eadl month at 6:38 p.m.) ("RequiRd to tile a statement oftlnanclal interest form) If you have chec::bd mQI'C tbtm one box. whidt would be your: lstChoioe PcAA 21111 (]~<ru:e&2C.. 3nl0toice el(tH3 Are you registered in Che Stile ofFiorida? U~» . An: you licensed in the State ofFiorida: "jn Anoeh« State: ru I d"' ~ I ~ ~ 1!. < , Do you possess a City ofPalm Beach Gardens oocupatiooal HceMe?---L,<J..;__;;~ __ _ Howlonghaveyoupmcticedtheaboveprofilssion? ~,...y ~1 y.c....tc. Preferred mailing address: ()!)Home ( ) Oftil:e Could rour occupation present a conf:lic:t of interest on any su:hjq:t matte£ di~ revi.~ or decided 1J1101! by the BOII!d or t I Committee: ( )Yes( )No "7 :It-~~ .,b~c&.e.,~.-.,. o--~lS.S."""-· :r:..(' .. -1-di.J =""~.,.._.a. , u l,. /1 !.L£ J .. ,~ • ('~ c:,.,.c. .. -ace.. t" rro-~ 1:&~~ . Please explain: · · · - ~HANSON David L. Peters, P.E., C.P.E. Vice President ----Hanson Professional services Inc. ---- w~tw.hanson-inc.com • dlpeters@lianson-inc.com 1601 Belvedere Road, Suite 303 South • West Palm Beach, FL 33406-1558 (561) 471-9370 • Fax: (561) 471-9369 Proressl011al BaekgrGuad (Please check the appropriate boxes) _ _ _. -'-·--_ ·--_o __ Yisual, ~g~_.lite@cy_g. ________ _ --···. Q_ ~At~I~_®signer.landscape.designer _ IJ Urban pliiD!lingfdesigtr ·· ·· · ·· D Arts and cultural inslitutim miiDllgeDlent At Building construction D Horticulture and landscaping D Youth or adult educator ...... ----;---· ··----------. 1:1 Own/operate a business in the City. l4 Member of:Business Development Board, North Palm Beach County Chamber of Commerce or PGA Corridor Association: ~A~ey . • Engineer IJ Real estate prottssional Land surveyor Bankt:r Accountant Other .Educational Badcgrolllld: Diploma Degree or Certificate How did you learn abollt the Board or Coamtittee for wll1eh. fOU have applied: City's Web site: Commllllity Groap: Newspap.er (speeify) ./"' /J-'3.-/. A. c./-. City's dlrut mu1 Brec:bure: __ Other: (speeify) ____ _ Prior to submitting an applicoJion. yo11. are entUJUrtiged to attend one meeting_ Dale aUeoded: ____ _ Please rd1ml the application and resume to: City Clerk 10500 North Military Trat1 Palm Beach Oardens. Fl33410 (561) 799-4121 FOR.UsEBYCITYOFPALMBEACHGARDENSONLY: ~inUdt« ______________ _ Dak: of Appointment---------- Orientation Date:--------- City of Palm Beach Gardens Board & Committee Application ~-----·-----------~-----·-·-- lease Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided ir this application is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: Lddress: r,P-in_e __________ ,__,I._IR.,...e_b_ec_c_a ________ ____JI D lsecky City: State: L-------::Z:-:-ip_: __ -~----- 1_3_3_0_M_e_r-id-ia_n_W_a_y_S_A_p_t_D ________ ...,IIPalm Beach Gardens II_F~orida Jl .... 3_34_1_o ___ _. 16me Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: ~i~=~6=~=?=.~-8=_3=._3==---=-===-=====~~ .... 5-6-19_6_6-66_5_0 ____ __,,,5613080694 II rc-offi--~-e-ld_y_@_h_o-tm-a-il-.c-o_m __ ,.------ ~~;""'·"""·""·""· ..... , ~.,....,......,.......;""""""""'"d Secondary Email Address: Jcoffeeldy@gmail.com 'ears of Residency: 'referred Means of Contact: L,.IE_m __ a~i'~-------....1 11ease place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. 0 Art in Public Places Advisory Board 0 Community Aesthetics Board !iK Parks and Recreation Advisory Board D Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * !iK Budget Oversight Committee (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30 p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30 a.m.) .0 Fire Pension BoarcL __ . ____________ _lmeets semi-monthly as. called) 0 Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form :f you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: I BOC -Budget Over~ight Committee Second Choice: RAB -Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Third Choice: ~e you currently servingoncrPatnrBeach-Ganfen·s-Board.:.orCommitte·e?-Q'feS·-·®·No --· · --· · ·------------~ ·----·-·----·-··-·-·--.-- If so, which one(s)? fave you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? ~re you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which .one(s)? iave you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? 're you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings ®Evening Meetings Nhat would you hope to accomplish by participating? Working on a team to come up with new strategies for moving the city forward and saving money. I'm a proponent of using existing technology to create more efficient processes and thus create budgetary savings. _. -_-_-_._. ___ -_-·_;•j~F;:_•_-....:;.,;_"_··---··---· --------------. •• -·---·-··· 'aim Beach County Parks and Recreation Department §ovemment Employee ~--r~e~ss~:~------------------~--~~------~AP~o~s~•t~io~n~:--------------------------------- ----------------------------------~__, 100 6ih-AV9ffiiesoi.lill;-Lake·worth, FC334B1·-·-·-------·-Directoron=rnancial andstTpporfServicas···-·· re you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ® No re you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ® No ·o you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? Q Yes ® No ow many years have you practiced in the above professio-:t? D ould your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided pon by the Board or Committee? ®Yes 0 No If yes, explain: Any matters directly associated with contracts related to the Palm Beach County Parks and Recreation Department. rofessional Background (please check all that apply) ] Accountant ] AdultSports Programming ] Aquatics Programming 1 Architect ] Architect Design/Urban Planner ] Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. ] Attorney. . __ . _ ] Banker ] Building Construction ] Div. 1 Bldg -General Contractor :ducational Background Diploma/Degree D Div. 2 MEP Contractor 0Engineer D Environmental Professional 0 Golf Course Participant 0 Horticulture & Landscaping D Land Surveyor 0 Landscape AF:chitect 0 Member of Bus. Dev. Board 0 NPB Count Chamber of Commerce Iii' Other: Institution 0 Business Owner in PBG D PGA Corridor Association D Real Estate Professional 0. Recreation Programming D Senior-Targeted Activities D Special Population Advocate 0 Tennis <;:~nter Participant. D Visual I Literary Arts Ovolunteer from PBGYAA Course of Study · _IAss~:_i;t:_?f .. ~-~~---. . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . Jl~lm Beach Community College = JJGeneral Studies ==-----...... . IBachelor of Science I Florida Atlantic University Management Information Systems :-JMaS~erofBUsirl'e~~~~~~-~o-~--...... ~.-.~.JFro~~A~~trc~~~W.=~~=--~---~--· BusinessAamiruStratloh- ~re you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No lave you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes · 0 No If yes,· explain: iow did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? ) City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend ® Other: jPalm Beach Post ,rior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Worked as Precinct Clerk for several PBG municipal elections as well as County elections. · Date Attended: j · J · understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. !if' Agree understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG landatory Code of Ethics Trainin9. a me: Date: fif Agree -· _________ ,:._ _____ · APPliCATIONFO,R CITY-ADVISORY BOARD/COMMIITEE·APPOINTMENT-----------·-· Please Note: Pursuant to FS 1 9.07 the information provided in this appliCation is<:onsidered to be public record, except as provided by law. Name: s e.e -~ ({e"' e+ HomeAddress: 5{.9 RiVERS (DE () RlV£ City: P /3: G . . .. i.i"p3 5'1 / ~ Years of Residency: /4 . Computer _Available: ( 0) Yes (.)(; No Home Phone: (_) b] D 33 fO Work Phone: (_) b 3 0 g5~0 Cell Phone (5R) b i 6 9 0 2 8' Primary E-mail Address: £cJ ~ Secondary E-mail Address _________ _ Preferred Means of Contact: Primary E-mail /e(~ /~-/ ff 0 .M 1:::.:. Please place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: 0 Art in Public Places Advisory Board (meets 3rd Tuesday of each month at 5:30 p.m.) 0 Community Aesthetics Board (meets 1st Wednesday of each month at 5:30 p.m.) _,g Parks and Recreation Advisory Board (meets the 3rd Monday of each month at 6:00 p.m.) 0 Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board* (meets the 2nd Tuesday of each month at 6:00 p.m.) D Budget Oversight Committee (meets the 4th Thursday of each month ~t 8:30a.m.) *Required to file a statement of financial interest form · If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: 1st Choice. N/A 2nd Choice N/A 3rd Choice Primary E-mail Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? ( 0) Yes (){)No Which.orie(s)_· _N/A · · Previous service on City Board~orCo.!:!lmittees? (~)Yes ( 0 ) No /9 9 // ..I. 2 O 1 C) Whichone(s) N/A PoLtC-t::::: Fe:.rJSrOA-1 Date(s)ofService: "T ,l,o 612--nY'21 ./..=-t:Pt, ye.E:r f7£ AJ fit> /1/ . -=-___;;_..:::__:__ Are you currentfy serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? ( () ) Yes ( :Q') No Which one(s) -------------------------- Previous service on County Boards or Committees? (0) Yes (Q) No Which one(s) Date(s) of Service: ______ _ 0 N I 0 I 0 :z: Are you able to attend: (~aytime meetings(~ evening meetings 1/ ,a/?1/1/G fr1 c:...-//eO(-c ::5" :Sr-o/VAL !=YDt;;~~~ ~ul1lo~hope:: ~~rnplis~; P:r~~~~lf~/. /17_,1--T~~:~~/3 (.)~c{-~rf_~~ --t::XL __ d --· N _____ ___/_ _ . 2/::R_ _ 7-..... _ ..... __ 'Z) .... -------- PresentEmployer: Ae cbk fo A~e.. ~ {:nu/AA._ & [/y-..'1 CDhtk-1•#1//1.~~ Address: f:O 0 (..) Y" 9 Y"e_ ?:-:f C/ Ty · _ . - Profession: / T _ . Posmon: __________________________ ~------- Are you registered in the State of Florida? t)(} Yes ( 0) No· ( 0) Another State ( 0) N/A Are you licensed in the State of Florida? ( 0 .) Yes (~)No ( 0 ) Another State { 0 ) N/A Do you possess a City of Palm Beach Gardens occupationallicens~? ( 0 ) Yes ( }8l ).No ·How long have you practiced the above profession?~------------ Could your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or ~ommittee: ( 0 )Yes ~No ' _ Pleaseexplain: .I ~ R~ftve.dJ 50 J_ C ~ cb.vofe_ "Vk-':( e{fvt+s fo +£-_,;-go avcl· --.·-APPLICATION FOR CITY· ADVISORY BOARD/COMMITFEE·APPOINTMENT ·-- Professional Background (Please check the appropriate boxes.) D Visual, performing or literary arts D 0 [] D Architect, architecture designer, landscape designer Urban planning/design Arts and cultural institution management Building construction 0 Horticulture and landscaping D Attorney D Engineer 0 Real estate professional D land surveyor ~Banker D Accountant )21 Youth or adult educator D Other (Please list below) Own/operate a business in the City 1 ~f~ 5 I \\. C ~ ~~ e:.. t' / c { f D D Member of Business Development Board, North Palm Beach 1 _ County Chamber of Commerce or PGA Corridor Association 'S"f't>"'V ·'if Rc?c.he. 2ft W\.. ~CY"L j{.g '· By Code (Ordinance 17, 2004; Ordinance 5, 2009, Ordinance 35, 2009), some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. {).y ~ ~ c5t? -1(/e_ . rot/i ck. d e_ Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? (¢_)Yes ( 0) No Have you participated in civic or co.mmunity activities? ( ~ Yes: · ( 0 )No · If yes, please explain: I 5'errted c5 z;;v.?/ee f:c/1. +t...e. ?~.5~~ !3o~d.7 o fft.p Gf; of!.7;SG f"'rYL ~ouf 10 y-e 3¥5 '~"Aiic'e_"' ~c5 <·6~?fl£~/01Per" I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. (6 U.2c.>IO ···-···-·· -· ·····-·· -----Type-yourname-here----··· --------·---------Date--------·-·---· ···--··---- How did you learn about the Board or Committee for which you have applied: /)2 ve L~ V/ fo (cf. 1/kfl City's Web site: J:L Community Group: _l1_ Other: (specify)---==--- Prior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date attended:------ CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS CITY COUNCIL Agenda Cover Memorandum Meeting Date: October 11, 2012 Resolution 91, 2012 SUBJECT/AGENDA ITEM Appointment of Regular Members and Alternates to the Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board. [X] Recommendation to APPROVE [ ] Recommendation to DENY Reviewed by: R. Max atalie Crowley Director of Planning and Zoning [ ] Quasi -Judicial [ ] Legislative [X] Public Hearing Advertised: Date: N/A Paper: atalie Crowley, AICP Director of Planning and Zoning [ ] Required 1--------------1 [ X] Not Required Approved By: City Manager Affected Parties: [ ] Notified -x] Not Required FINANCE: Finance Administrator: N/A Allan Owens Budget Acct.#: N/A City Council Action: [ ] Approved [ ] App. w/ Conditions [ ] Denied [ ] Continued to: Attachments Resolution 91, 2012 -Exhibit "A"- Attendance Records -Exhibit "B" - Applications ·. ·' QUALIFICATIONS: Meeting Date: October 11, 2012 Resolution 91, 2012 Page 2 of 3 In addition to the specific requirements stated below for the individual boards and committees, Section 2-89 of the City's Code of Ordinances includes general provisions to avoid any perceived or actual conflicts of interest by adding that members cannot be employed by or have any contractual relationship with the City, unless otherwise provided by the Code. The general provisions also provide that members can only serve on one (1) board or committee at any one (1) time. Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board: Residency in the City of Palm Beach Gardens and at least one (1) member from each of the specific types of professional disciplines related to (1) Architecture, (2) Engineering, and (3) a Division 1 (general, building, or residential) contractor are requirements for Board membership. At least one (1) member must be from a specific type of professional discipline, including an attorney, real estate professional, environmental professional, landscape architect, planner, Division 2 (MEP) contractor, or land surveyor, and the Board must have one (1) resident at large as a Board member. •, It is a requirement of the City's Code of Ordinances, Section 2-148 (b), that some Boarq members are chosen from professionals in the architecture, landscape architecture, planning, legal, and real estate fields so that they can make knowledgeable recommendations to City Council on development petitions. While their professions provide them with insight and understanding of development, it also creates the potential for conflicts of interest to arise: ~urrently, Board members are advised that a recusal from the preceding is required in the event that there is a conflict of interest SUMMARY: Regular Member(s) eligible for reappointment as Regular Member • Charles Hathaway-Term expiring September 30, 2012-Eligible for renewal . • Roma Josephs-Term expiring September 30, 2012-Eligible for renewal • Douglas Pennell-Term expiring September 30, 2012-Eligible for renewal • Randy Hansen-Term expiring September 30, 2012-Eligible for renewal Vacancies to be filled: • First Alternate • Second Alternate Additional Applications on File Shawna Bedford Meriel "Honey" Bryan Ed Bowers Kenneth Cote ----------------------------------------- John Hughes Solomon Kaplan Stuart Klein Reginald Maton Lowell Levine Don Lahr Scott Mason Michael Molenda David Peters Marion Suro Margaret Shannon Current composition of the board: Randy Hansen -Vice Chair, Regular Member Charles Hathaway-Regular Member Roma Josephs -Regular Member Michael Panczak -Chair-Regular Member Douglas Pennell -Regular Member Howard Rosenkranz -Regular Member ~obert Savel -Regular Member Meeting Date: October 11, 2011 Resolution 91, 2012 Page 3 of 3 ~taff posts notices of vacancies at City Hall and on the City website. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of Resolution 91, 2012 as presented. 1 2 3 RESOLUTION 91, 2012 4 5 6 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM 7 BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING THE APPOINTMENT 8 OF REGULAR AND ALTERNATE MEMBERS TO THE PLANNING, 9 ZONING, AND APPEALS BOARD; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE 1 0 DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 11 12 13 WHEREAS, Section 2-148, Code of Ordinances provides for the Board to be 14 comprised of seven (7) regular members and two (2) alternate members; and 15 16 WHEREAS, as of October 1, 2012, there are four (4) regular members eligible 17 for reappointment and two (2) alternate vacancies; and 18 19 WHEREAS, notice of the vacancies has been posted at City Hall and on the City 20 Website; and 21 22 WHEREAS, the City Clerk has collected applications of all interested persons 23 who wish to serve as members of the Board, along with attendance and voting records 24 of the current members, which are attached hereto as Exhibit "B"; and 25 26 WHEREAS, the City Council deems approval of this Resolution to be in the best 27 interests of the health, safety, and welfare of the residents and citizens of the City of 28 Palm Beach Gardens and the public at large. 29 30 31 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY 32 OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA that: 33 34 SECTION 1. The foregoing recitals are hereby affirmed and ratified. 35 36 SECTION 2. The City Council hereby approves the appointment of regular and 37 alternate members to the Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board as set forth in Exhibit 38 "A", attached hereto. 39 40 SECTION 3. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon adoption. 41 42 43 44 45 46 Page 1 of 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 Resolution 91,2012 PASSED AND ADOPTED this __ day of ________ , 2012. CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA BY: ----------------- David Levy, Mayor ATTEST: BY: ---------------Patricia Snider, CMC, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY BY: --------------R. Max Lohman, City Attorney VOTE: AYE NAY ABSENT MAYOR LEVY VICE MAYOR PREMUROSO COUNCILMEMBER TINSLEY COUNCILMEMBER RUSSO COUNCILMEMBER JABLIN G:\attorney_share\RESOLUTIONS\2012\Resolution 91 2012 pzab appointments.docx Page 2 of 2 EXHIBIT "A" Regular Member(s) Alternate Member(s) Resolution 91, 2012 Expiring on 09/30/14 Expiring on 09/30/14 Expiring on 09/30/14 Expiring on 09/30/14 Resolution 91, 2012 EXHIBIT "8" CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS MEMORANDUM TO: Natalie Crowley, Director of Planning and Zoning, Staff Liaison FROM: Donna Kramer, Municipal Services Coordinator SUBJECT: Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board Renewals and Vacancies DATE: September 12, 2012 The following list provides a summary of the Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board current renewals and vacancies. Attendance sheets and application(s) are attached. Please prepare the required staff report and resolution and submit to the Office of the City Clerk no later than September 24,2012 for inclusion on the October 11,2012 City Council Agenda. Term Expiring Eligible For Renewal Reappointments: Hathaway, Charles Regular Member 9/30/12 Yes Josephs, Roma Regular Member 9/30/12 Yes Pennell, Douglas Regular Member 9/30/12 Yes Position to be filled by an Architect or Engineer or Division 1 (general, building or residential contractor): Hansen, Randolph Regular Member 9/30/12 Term Expires 9/30/12 Positions to be filled: First Alternate N/A NIA Second Alternate N/ A N/A Alternates eligible for appointment to regular member: None. Please advise if applicants are no longer interested in serving so our records can be updated. Required Positions: No less than two (2) of the following professions must be represented: • Architects; • Engineers; • Division 1 (general, building or residential contractors). ,/ September 12, 2012 Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board Renewals and Vacancies Page -2- At least one ( 1) of the following professions must be represented: • Attorneys; • Real estate professionals; • Environmental professionals; • Landscape architects; • Planners; • Division 2 (MEP) contractors; • Land surveyors. At least one (1) of the following: • One (1) resident at large Attachments: 1. Applications(s) 2. Attendance Record 3. Voting Record Ln .. ,.,nvN. FOR CITY-ADlfiSORY-BOARD/COMMITIEE-AP-J!OINTMENI------ Please Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided in this application is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. Name: Shawna L. Bedford Home Address: 11836 Valencia Gardens Avenue City: Palm Beach Gardens ._3_3_4_1_0 __ Years of Residency: _s ____ Computer Available: ( 0) Yes ( 0) No Home Phone: ~) 628-2988 Work Phone: ( 561 ) 628-2988 Cell Phone ( 561 ) 628-2988 Primary E-mail Address: sbedford@ipre.com Preferred Means of Contact:_ Primary E-mail Secondary E-mail Address shawna bedford@hotmail.a Please place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: D Art in Public Places Advisory Board (meets 3rd Tuesday of each month at 5:30p.m.) 0 Community Aesthetics Board (meets 1st Wednesday of each month at 5:30p.m.) 0 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board (meets the 3rd Monday of each month at 6:00p.m.) IZJ Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board* (meets the 2nd Tuesday of each month at 6:00 p.m.) 0 Budget Oversight Committee (meets the 4th Thursday of each month at 8:30a.m.) . *Required to file a statement of financial interest form If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: 1st Choice_ N/A 2"d Choice 3rd Choice Primary E-mail Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? ( 0) Yes ( 0) No Which one(s) _N/A Previous service on City Boards or Committees? ( 0 } Yes ( 0 ) No Which one(s}. N/A . Date(s) of Service:------ Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? { 0} Yes ( 0) No Which one(s) Harbour Oaks Director & MacArthur Center Director Previous service on County Boards or Committees? { 0) Yes (Q) No Which one(s) Date{s) of Service:------- Are you able to attend: {E)) daytime meetings ( ®) evening meetings What would you hope to accomplish by participating? To help bring in new commercial and residential developments that will benefit the community as a whole. Present Employer: Illustrated Properties Real Estate, Realtor Address: 2725 PGA Blvd., Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410 Profession: Real Estate Agent Position: Real Estate Agent-Sales Are you registered in the State of Florida? { (!) ) Yes ( 0 ) No ( 0 ) Another State { 0) N/A Are you licensed in the State of Florida? ( 0 ) Yes ( 0) No ( 0 ) Another State ( 0 ) N/A Do you possess a City of Palm Beach Gardens occupational license? { 0 ) Yes ( (!) ) No How long have you practiced the above profession? 8 Years, 3 with Illustrated Properties 0 \J'l I 0 -J I 0 J> 0 Could your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee: { Q)Yes {<!>)No Please explain:------------------------------------ ' ~ ~ ·~ -·-··· APPLICATION FOR-CITY ADVISORY-BOARD/COMMITTEE-APP-OINTMENT---- Professional Background (Please check the appropriate boxes.) D Visual, performing or literary arts D 0 Architect, architecture designer, landscape designer Urban planning/design D Arts and cultural institution management D Building construction D D 0 D Horticulture and landscaping Youth or adult educator Own/operate a business in the City Member of Business Development Board, North Palm Beach County Chamber of Commerce or PGA Corridor Association 0 Attorney D Engineer 0 Real estate professional D Land surveyor D Banker D Accountant D Other {Please list below) Formerty served as an active member and Ambassador of the WPS Chamber Of Commerce and have attended several PBG City Counsel and BOB meetings By Code (Ordinance 17, 2004; Ordinance 5, 2009, Ordinance 35, 2009), some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. Educational Background Diploma, Degree or Certificate Institution Course of Study Diploma Lexington High Scholl, Lexington, MA Standard Studies None Northeastern University, Boston, MA, Salem State College, Salem, MA Business Marketing & Law License Insurance Broker, Boston, MA (now expired) Insurance license Real Estate Salesperson/Broker, Florida (Active) Real Estate Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ( 0 )Yes ( 0 ) No Have you participated in civic or community activities? ( 0 ) Yes: ( 0 )No Jf yes, please explain: Citizen's Police Academy (current). Adopt A Street Program PBG (applied), Harbour Oaks HOA, Director (current), MacArthur Center POA. Director (current) I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. Shawna L. Bedford 04/27/2010 Type your name here How did you learn about the Board or Committee for which you have applied: City's Web site: 0 Community Group: _D_ Other: (specify) D Prior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date attended:------- L · suiJ.rnit I Date ~hJm: Fischer Gaeta Corp. 5618721958 09/18/2007 18:17 11157 P.002/003 09 ?9-07A09:46 f<CVD • Application for City Advisory Board/Committee Appointment Plet~se Nou: Ptirsoant to F.S 119.07 the information provided in this application is considered to be public record. except as 2 provided by law. . (LU..f _ c5 8' _ <;; 01 & r;, N~: ~~;~I • ~ ''.~~Home Ad""":~=;?"! Bdc lk ~J . 0 City: pCJfl~!\:. c;Q.52;=&~ HomePhoneNumber:()bOWS .. ~ WorkPlioneNumber.!}bO b~7-£I7XJ YearsofResidency? :1. "('l' E-mailaddress: ~br'(Cl.N El t~cre... Co""' WinCH BOARD OR COMMITl'EE ARE YOU APPLYING FOR: -~· Art in PubUc: Places Advisory Board 0. Community Aesthetics Board Q Parks and Recreation AdviM»ry Board -g Economic: Development Advisory Board Q Budget Oversight Conn:uittee . (meem 3nt Tuesday of each month at S:30 p.m.) (meem 111 Wednesday of each ntonth at 5:311 p.m.) (meets the 3ril Mo-nday uf each month at 7:00 p.m.) (meets the lnt Thursday of each month at 8:30a.m.) (meets the 4111 Thursday of each month at 8:3CJ a.m.) (meets the a•d and 41hTuesdsys-ohat:h-montlrat 6:30 p~m..J - (*Required to file a statement of financial interest form) -:}(-Plarudng,Zoldng& Appeals Board*· · If you havA. <(l!ecked more tban. one pox. ;which would be your: . 1 ~~ • t•a.oicert:l 2114 Choic:e A,=:t 3ntChoice[ cr')l\O!l, c.. ULJ, Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? ( ) Yes <,)QNo Which om::(s) . · - Previous service on City Boan:ls or Committees? ( ) Yes D<} No Which onc:(s) I>ate(s) of~c:nrice: ----- Are you wm::ntly serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? { ) Yes C)\rNo Which one(s) · . Pnwi0tl5 service on County Boards. or Committees? ( ) Yes ()()No Which onc(s} Datc(s) ofsdviee: -· ___ _ Are you able to a~: Q( ) daytime meetings C)<') ll'WeDing meetings ~wouldyou~m~ly~~... -\-+ lt 'b~}2\,~ !';~<'-;rO~J:;:J~'f\lt; ;;'h);'fe:!f~~c~J :: Pea€-~ ... c~ PresentEmployer: ~k~ .. =~i~~kf3r:A!~~-COMfWCieJ ~1o.-f'f<>f< (}N>b•- Are you registered in the S$ ofFlorida? Y (.$ Another State: __ _ Arc you licensed in tho Stateof.florl.da: Yt. .S Another State: __ _ Do you possess a City ofPalm Beacll Gardcmoccupationallicensc? '{ { ...S How long have you practiced the above pl'Qfcssion? J. £ ~ f Q r:s. _ -~-·~-Frefertechnailing address: ((<)Home ( ) Office Could your. · ~ml present a conflict of interest on any subject matter diseuised, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee: ~)Yes( )No · Pleaseexplain: Ma.1 apr~~~ p~l:~\ ~c~e\opc.rs or t"1J<,~Oc-.s" ~kc o '-4> tt o c , t4 v f_) ~ \-, "' co t-'\ t"l e.re , c. \ r-c Q..( t si-a.. -k: 1 fiJ +lc. c , +) . Fr:DIIl:Fischer aaeta. Corp. 6618721958 08/18/2007 1&:18 I Professiortal BaekgroWid (Please cheCk the • boxes) Q Visual, pafmmiDg or Jitf:mry at.1:1. Q Architect, Atdrltecto.re desiper, landscape designer Cl t.hban plannin&'design . 0 :::::=!mm:tu1ionmauagemmt . Holticult:u11: and Iandscepiug Youth or adult educator 1157 P. DOS/DOS l Ownfopaate a business in the City. · Member 0,fBusiness Development Boaid. North Palm Beach County Chamber ofCommen:e or PGA Corridor Association. Attorney IJ Etigineer 'it' Real estate professional 6.-Land surveyor o Banker 0 Accountant Cl Otba' I By Code (Ordiwmee 17, 1004), some Boards/Committees bavupedfje U~quirementt f<»r 'membership Educatioul BadgrOIIIId: Diploma,Ilegprc< orCertifiS#!. · I:ristitUtion CO:unreOt'Studv 'ii~? QQ-rk~-&~u: .. !~Jru~A~ Uo.+,cu.\-h.= Are. yQU registered to vote in. Palm Beach Cmmty? (XJY es ( } No q-tl-o] Bow did you/bout the Board or Com~ for w.hic:h you have applied: Oty's Web site: Community Group: Newspaper (specify) __ City'.sdirecl mail Brochure: ,_,-Other: (specify}---- Prior 10 submittbJg lm application. you are encourag.J 10 attend one meeting. Date attended:----- Ple;15e retum. the application and n:swne to: CityCk:rk lOSOO North MilitaJy Trail · Palm Beach Gardens, Fl33410 (S61) 799-4121 Applications will be kept fin file in the City Clerk'& ojficefor two (2) yean. FOR lJSE BY CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ONLY: · Appointed to=--~-----DateofAppointm.ent:_. _____ _ ~on~----~--------- I MERIEL "HONEY" BRYAN, CEO Global Real Estate Resources, LLC Licensed Real Estate Broker Honey Bryan is a native of Palm Beach County, Florida and is a seasoned and driven professional with a lifelong career in the commercial real estate and finance industries. As a Florida Licensed Real Estate Broker and Mortgage Broker, she has the proven ability to integrate and utilize her solid foundation in of all aspects of commercial real estate and up to date knowledge of the marketplace. Throughout her career, she has assisted clients in consummating transactions for the sale, acquisition, leasing, development and/or financing of retail, office, industrial and investment properties throughout the South Florida market. She has also collaborated extensively with her clients to facilitate land use changes and rezoning of vacant land for the development of both retail and multifamily projects. In the pursuit of excellence, Honey strives to provide the highest level of customer service. She accomplishes this by analyzing the specialized needs and goals of each client and then develops strategies and solutions to meet customer driven objectives. It is her intention to always conduct her business by meeting and exceeding the highest professional and ethical standards of the commercial real estate industry. ' · Honey is a member of the National Association of Realtors has been active in numerous professional organizations including the Realtors Association of the Palm Beach, National Network of Commercial Real Estate Woman (NNCREW), International Council of Shopping Centers, ( ICSC), Realtors Commercial Alliance (RCA) . She is currently working on obtaining a designation as a Certified Commercial Investment Manager (CCIM). In an effort to give back to her community, she has also served on the executive boards of Seagull Industries for the Disabled; Give a Life Foundation, Benzaiten Center for the Living Arts Foundation and PEO. Global J ' Real Estate , Resourcesf(!;C Putting it aJJ together ~~ GLOBAL REAL ESTATE RESOURCES, LLC "PUTTING IT ALL TOGETHER" Through a collaborative philosophy ofleveraging its resources, expertise and experience, Global Real Estate Resources, LLC ("GRER") will strive to provide incomparable guidance and extraordinary customer service to its clients and partners by being the full service "resource" for all types of real estate investors. GRER utilizes a multi-disciplined approach to the process of studying, assessing and forecasting the complete scope of an asset as a whole. The integrated due diligence and analysis processes will allow GRER to create solutions tailored to its client's specific short and long term financial goals. GRER also offers a comprehensive package of real estate services such as strategic advice and buyer representation in purchasing distressed debt assets, real estate assets, property management, landlord and tenant leasing repres~ntation, and investment sa~es and disposition brokerage. Clients will have access to one integrated advisory and service platform to access local and seasoned professional expertise in making investment decisions involving commercial real estate in Florida. GRER's menu of real estate services can be packaged and priced according to the needs of the client and scope of work. Whether the project is one due diligence assessment or a fee engagement utilizing the full array of services in order to add value to the asset through cost control and income enhancement, GRER will strive to meet the client's needs in an efficient and timely manner. Global Real Estate Resources LLC, Licensed. Real Estate Broker 9121 N. Military Trail, Suite 108, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida 33410 561-308-8266 (cell) honeybee 101 O@gmail.com Application for City Advisory Board/Committee Appointment Please Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided in this application is considered to be public record, except as d provided by law. L) Name: t;; ~~A J Home Address: 1/ Ct ~~~~""/a /M Clf City: £~G. Zip: ~;'Y/6.ome Phone Number: ( .1_7/...s72twork Phone Number: ( ~eY-c?/C' Years ofResidency?---"-R"-----'¥.__ ___ E-mailaddress: G uew;VetJ;-f'~IJ,_, P;:....#,~~~ Cv ~ WHICH BOARD OR COMMITTEE ARE YOU APPLYING FOR: D Art in Public Places Advisory Board D Community Aesthetics Board D Parks and Recreation Advisory Board [t-""Economic Development Advisory Board D Budget Oversight Committee ~ Planning, Zoning & Appeals Board * (meets 3'd Tuesday of each month at 5:30p.m.) (meets 151 Wednesday of each month at 5:30p.m.) (meets the 3'd Monday of each month at 7:00p.m.) (meets the 2"d Thursday of each month at 8:30a.m.) (meets the 41 h Thursday of each month at 8:30a.m.) (meets the 2"d and 41 h Tuesdays of each month at 6:30p.m.) (*Required to file a statement of financial interest form) If you have s.Ueckeg.more than one ~ox, )fhich would be your: 1st Choice e2 t!l_ 2"d Choice~~~ 3'd Choice ____ _ ) Yes (P") No Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? ( ) Yes ( t--}No Which one(s) -------,-------,- Preyious sem~_on Cp_unty_lloar<ls.J>r Committ~s? (_)Yes_( )_NQ__ _______________ _ Which one(s) Date(s) of Service: ______ _ Are you able to attend: Mdaytime meetings ( ~ening meetings PresentEmployer: ~~;;;.,;,0~ ,/),J/j:g(l( Address: ?/t/1~ J#';~~I(-.,A'i' §;4(1.<. Profession: ~ #A./11-' {1,-;J.-. N (1', A ill Position: Y7"- Are you registered in the State of Florida? Another State: ___ _ --1-----. --, --· -~------------------------------ Are you licensed in the State of Florida:_____ Another State: ___ _ Do you possess a City of Palm Beach Gardens occupational license? ~ <)I-t I( e/' ~./~A/~ i1!/ How long have you practiced the above profession? ___ <-'-~-~-------- Preferred mailing address: (~me ( ) Office Could your occupation Pie~ a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee: ( )Yes ( V) No Please explain:------------------------ I Professional Background (Please check the appropriate boxes) I ' a Visual, performing or literary arts. r8 Architect, Architecture designer, landscape designer · a Urban planning/design a Arts and cultural institution management a Building construction a Horticulture and landscaping a Youth or adult educator .Ill Own/operate a business in the City. a Member of Business Development Board, North Palm Beach County Chamber of Commerce or PGA Corridor Association. a Attorney ,f!f Engineer a Real estate professional a Land surveyor a Banker J~,( a Accountant .. n• 41"11' .c. v-;"" . / r Other Cr~.,.,~4f,~ J'<V(}Vt)'t. ._ ~:;?"41U?' By Code (Ordinance 17, 2004), some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership Educational Background: Diplomf!. Degree or Certificate Institution Course of Study ~Cd ~.f'/&- Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ( Vffes ( ) No Have you participated in civic or coiilmunity activities: Yes: (Y') No: ( ) . Ifyes,pleaseexplairu _C/-;ZY ~~til~ . ---~(.f,;JJ_~~~,f __ I un~~es, role and tUne oommi"""'t to the Boards "'Committoes J-whioh I have appliod . .......£~---~~_· -__ 7t1r/a~ Signature Date How did you learn about the Board or Committee for which you have applied: City's Web site: Community Group: Newspaper (specifY) • City's direct mail Brochure: Other: (specify) ~ _,/. ..,~ ~,..,~-< I --Er.ior:to..submitting anapplication,_you.are.encoumgedto_attend.ove meeti]Jg_. -··· -----···----------·- Date attended: · Please return the application and resume to: City Clerk 10500 North Military Trail Palm Beach Gardens, Fl 33410 (561) 799-4121 FOR USE BY CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ONLY: Appointed to:---------- Date of Appointment:~------­ Orientation Date:=~=======- t' --~·-· . ·'!'-APPLICATION FOR CITY ADVISORY BOARD/COMMITTEE APPOINTMENT Please Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided in this application is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. Name: Kenneth J. Cote Home Address: 2654 Bordeaux Ct. City: Palm Beach Gardens Zip: 33410 Years of Residency: Recent Computer Available: ( (!)) Yes ( 0 ) No Home Phone: ( 561 ) 803-7494 Work Phone: (_) ______ Cell Phone ( 413) 531-4416 Primary E-mail Address: kcote22@yahoo.com Preferred Means of Contact:_ Primary E-mail Secondary E-mail Address kcote22@gmail.com Please place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: D Art in Public Places Advisory Board (meets 3rd Tuesday of each month at 5:30 p.m.) 0 Community Aesthetics Board (meets 1st Wednesday of each month at 5:30p.m.) 0 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board (meets the 3rd Monday of each month at 6:00 p.m.) 0 Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board* (meets the 2nd Tuesday of each month at 6:00p.m.) D Budget Oversight Committee (meets the 4th Thursday of each month at 8:30a.m.) *Required to fife a statement of financial interest form If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: 1st Choice. N/A 2"d Choice N/A 3rd Choice Primary E-mail Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? ( 0) Yes ((!'))No Which one(s) _ N/A Previous service on City Boards or Committees? ( 0 ) Yes ( (!) ) No Which one(s). N/A . Date{s} of Service:------ Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? ( 0) Yes ( ®)No Which one(s) _________________________ _ Previous service on County Boards or Committees? ( 0) Yes (0) No Which one(s) Date(s) of Service:------- Are you able to attend: ((!))daytime meetings (®)evening meetings What would you hope to accomplish by participating? Be involved in my community. Present Employer: _R_e_tir_ed _______________________ _ Address: ____________________________ _ Profession: ___________________________ _ Posmon: ________________________________ __ Are you registered in the State of Florida? ( ® ) Yes ( 0) No ( 0) Another State ( 0) N/A Are you licensed in the State of Florida? ( 0 ) Yes ( 0 ) No ( 0 ) Another State ( 0 ) N/A Do you possess a City of Palm Beach Gardens occupational license? ( 0 ) Yes ( 0 ) No How long have you practiced the above profession? ""'n/'""a,__ _________ _ Could your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee: ( Q)Yes (®)No Please explain:------~------------------------------ ·-' APPLICATION FOR CITY ADVISORY BOARD/COMMITTEE APPOINTMENT Professional Background {Please check the appropriate boxes.) D Visual, performing or literary arts D 0 Architect, architecture designer, landscape designer Urban planning/design D Arts and cultural institution management D 0 Building construction Horticulture and landscaping D Youth or adult educator D D Own/operate a business in the City Member of Business Development Board, North Palm Beach County Chamber of Commerce or PGA Corridor Association 0 Attorney D Engineer D Real estate professional D land surveyor 0 Banker 0 Accountant lZJ Other {Please list below) District Court Judge (17 years, Massachusetts City Attorney (3 years, Holyoke, Massachusetts By Code (Ordinance 17, 2004; Ordinance 5, 2009, Ordinance 35, 2009), some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. Educational Background Diploma, Degree or Certificate Institution BA University of Texas at Arlington J.D. University of Puerto Rico Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ( 0 )Yes ( 0 ) No Have you participated in civic or community activities? ( 0 ) Yes: ( 0 )No Course of Study Psychology Law If yes, please explain:----------------------------------- I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. Kenneth J. Cote 11/02/1009 Type your name here How did you learn about the Board or Committee for which you have applied: City's Web site: lZJ Community Group: _[]_ Other: (specify) lZJ Prior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend ane meeting. Date attended: 11/2/200910:15 j. · Submit: · Date City of Palm Beach Gardens Boar Application · ---· - lease Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided ir this application is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. ------~-·--·----'==================.:....:::::::.::::: Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: ~ddress: ~~H-UG-H-Es----------~~~po_H_N ____________ ~I~~~JA_c_K-=----------- City: State: Zip: -} A_L_N_W-IC_K_R_D ___________ __,,,PALM BEACH GARDENS II Florida I ,..,3-34_1_8 __ __, tome Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: 561-622-6995 1 ~...ls_s_1-_84_s_-6_o_3_s ____ ....~lls61-373-2493 11 rjh_u_g-he_s_9_@_b_e_lls_o_u_th-.n-e_t _____ _ rears of Residency: EJ Secondary Email Address: •referred Means of Contact: ~.-1 c_e_l_l P_h_o_n_e ______ ...J •lease place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. DArt in Public Places Advisory Board D Community Aesthetics Board D Parks and Recreation Advisory Board !if Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * D Budget Oversight Committee D Fire Pension Board (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) (meets semi-monthly as called) 0 Police Pension Board {meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form f you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: I ~========================~ Second Choice: I ~========================~ Third Choice: I ~---------------------------------~ ~re you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes ®No If so, which one(s)? lave you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? ®Yes 0 No If so, which one(s), and when? 'BEAUTIFICATION ~re you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one{s)? lave you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? ~re you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings ® Evening Meetings Vhat would you hope to accomplish by participating? I WOULD HOPE TO BE ABLE TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE POSITIVE PLANNING FOR THE CONTINUED GROWTH OF PALM BEACH GARDENS IN AN ORDERLY AND WELL PLANNED MANNER Next Paoe " ---·· .. ----.---, ···-···· rHE K~YES coMPANY _ . u •• ~ --·-_ I §EAL TOR ,...,~d""'d""'r.,..,e'""'s'""'s.,..: ---------------'--------~ Pos1t1on: ~i1~29~0~L~E~G~A;C;Y~A~V:E~S~U:IT:E;1~4:0===~=·~~~.~~~=-=-==-=-=~~~~~-· r-==================================~~ ~re you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ® No ~re you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ® No )O you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? ® Yes 0 No low many years have you practiced in the above profession? EJ :ould your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided 1pon by the Board or Committee? O Yes ® No If yes, explain: •rofessional Background (please check all that apply) ] Accountant ] Adult Sports Programming ] Aquatics Programming ] Architect ] Architect Design/Urban Planner ] Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. ] Attorney ] Banker ] Building Construction ] Div. 1 Bldg-General Contractor !ducational Background 0 Div. 2 MEP Contractor 0 Engineer 0 Environmental Professional 0 Golf Course Participant 0 Horticulture & Landscaping 0 Land Surveyor 0 Landscape Architect 0 Member of Bus. Dev. Board 0 NPB Coun Chamber of Commerce [il Other: SPECIAL TV CONTRACTOR Diploma/Degree Institution · 'BACHELOR OF ARTS "YOUNGSTOWN UNIVERSITY I I 0 Business Owner in PBG 0 PGA Corridor Association lif Real Estate Professional 0 Recreation Programming 0 Senior-Targeted Activities 0 Special Population Advocate 0 Tennis Center Participant 0 Visual I Literary Arts 0 Volunteer from PBGYAA Course of Study IIPOLICIAL SCIENCE ~' ------~'~------~~------~re you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No tave you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes ONo If yes, ex rtow did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? PRES-BURWICK HOA,SEC/BD PGA POA,PRES-SEMINOLE LANDING ASSN, NUMEROUS BDS IN PB CTY AND FLA ) City Web Site 0 Community Group ® Friend 0 Other: !._ _______ _, ,rior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: I I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. fiK Agree understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG MandaE=vv Code o1 :thics Training. 11fl Agree lame: Date: ()_H_N_~_H_I_J_n_H_F_~-------,,1 0 ~P.n ?01? Print Previous Paoe ll.ll"\l,;liVIlYCJI.j..lli:llldliUII -ri:lyt: £ '-' -'"·Text PRES-BURWICK HOA,SEC/BD PGA-P0A~PRES-SEMIN01::E-•----------------------------- LANDING ASSN, NUMEROUS BDS IN PB CTY AND FLA C_i9' of Palm Beach Gardens Board & Committee Application lloJII .. ::ac::"' Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 information provided ir this application-is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: ~~K-A_P_LA __ N ________________ ~~~~s~o-'o_m_o_n ________________ ~j~~----~----------------- lddress: City: State: Zip: -11_3_8_1_p_ro_s_p_e-ri--tyo_a_k_s_a-pt-.6-3_6 ________ _,,,palm beach gardens II Florida I ~~3-3-4-10------...., lome Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: )561 775 0938 1 ~=~-----.....1 1917 647 9033 r-------------- 'ears of Residency: D Secondary Email Address: •referred Means of Contact: .,Lc_e_l_l P_h_o_n_e __________ _. •lease place a check next to each board/ committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code,. some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. D Art in Public Places Advisory Board D Community Aesthetics Board D Parks and Recreation Advisory Board .lit Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * lit Budget Oversight Committee 0 Fire Pension Board (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00 p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) (meets semi-monthly as called) 0 Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form f you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: j PZAB -Planning, Zoning & Appeals Board Second Choice: j BOC -Budget Oversight Committee Third Choice: 1re you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No If so, which one(s)? lave you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? .re you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s)? lave you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? .re you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings ® Evening Meetings llhat would you hope to accomplish by participating? lbe a concerned citizen. Next Paae -----------------------------------------------. ---··--···r·-, ···-··-· etired ... -~~~wyer ny state korea us courtsr ~lara~r~e~s~s~=---------------------' Pos1t1on: tre you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ® No tre you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ® No •o you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ®No low many years have you practiced in the above profession? ~ :ould your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided 1pon by the Board or Committee? O Yes ®No If yes, explain: •rofessio.nal Background (please check all that apply) ] Accountant 0 Div. 2 MEP Contractor 0-Business Owner in PBG ] Adult Sports Programming ] Aquatics Programming 0 Engineer 0 PGA Corridor Association 0 Environmental Professional 0 Real Estate Professional ] Architect 0 Golf Course Participant 0 Recreation Programming ] Architect Design/Urban Planner ] Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. !""Attorney 0 Horticulture & Landscaping 0 Senior-Targeted Activities 0 Land Surveyor 0 Special Population Advocate 0 Landscape Architect p Tennis Center Participant J Banker 0 Member of Bus. Dev. Board 0 Visual I Literary Arts ] Building Construction 0 NPB County Chamber of Commerce 0 Volunteer from PBGYAA 0 Other: .__I ______ ____.[ ] Div. 1 Bldg -General Contractor :ducational Background Diploma/Degree Institution : ILLB ~~NYU law school Course of Study jjraw admitted 1954 ·~I--------~~~----------~~-------tre you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? 0Yes ®No lave you participated in civic or community activities? 0 Yes ®No If yes, explain~ iow did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? ~ City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend 0 Other: jnewspaper article •rior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: j I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. 1if Agree understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG landatory Code of Ethics Training. arne: Date: -'"'ll_n_m_n_n_h_k-~-n-l-~-n------~~1. Attn ?01? Print Previous Paae lif Agree Feb 02 10 06:33p Stuart B. Klein,PA 561 478 SS31 p.2 I APPLICATION FOR CITY ADVISORY BOARD/COMMITT£E APPOINTMENT Please Note: Pwsuant to f.S 119.07 the information provide-d in this applitation is considered to be public ret.ord, eKcept as provided by law. Name: Stu<Jrl "'· l'ileln Home Address: 10113 Hunt Club Lane City: ~J~ Beach Gardens Zip: 33148 Years of Residency: _2._5~--Computer AvAil;;hiP.· ( 0) Ves ( 0 ) No Home Phone:(~!_) 6~2-5794 ~-Work Phone:(~) 478·1566 _Cell Phone(~) 676-83_8_3 __ Primary E-mail Address: sbk@klein$law.com Preferred Means of Contact:. Wod~ !>hone Se,ondary E-mail Address kleinslaw@aol.com .Please place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: 0 Art in Public Places Advisory Board (meets 3rd Tuesday of each month at 5:30 p.m.) 0 Community Aesthetics Board 0 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board [Zl Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board* 0 Budget Oversight Committee (meets 1st Wednesday of each month at 5:30p.m.) (meets the 3rd Monday of each month at 6:00p.m.) (meets the 2nd Tuesday of each month at 6;00 p.m.) (meets the 4th Thursday of each month at 8:30a.m.) *Required to file a statement of financidl interest form If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: 1!' Choice_l'lanning Zoning and App~als 2"d Choice_ N(A·-·---··· --·-----31 d Choice Primary E-mail Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? ( 0) Yes ( 0) No Which one(s) _ N/A Previous service on City Boards or t:ommittees? ( 0 ) Yes ( 0) No Which one(s). N/A Oate(s) of Service:------ Are you r.urmntly <>Prvine on a Palm Be:.u;h County Bo3rd or Commiltce? ( 0 ) Yes ( 0} No Which one(s) --.. -----·------------------ Previous service on County Boards or Committees? ( 0) Yes (0) No Which one(s) Many Nul for Profits. \?Ut not yuvemmentat Date(s) of Service:-·------- Are you able to att,end: ( 0) daytime meetings ( 0) evening meetings What would you hope to accomplish by participating? Add 3 tllfltmml voice 10 the direcUon ul PBG from prnmlrily a real ~ate a\lorney whn hli!S 1\~«l ~'the City tor n1at1y years and chlll:lNI\ were rai~d heru. Present Employer: Stuart B. Kte.i_n.;...P_.A_. ___ , ________________ _ Address: ~~A Bcvtevara. SuitG 110. P;:ilm Beach Gardens. Florida33410 Profession: Allumey . Posilion: _Pn_·,,_t:'..:..·pte __________________________ _ Ar~ you registered in the State of Florida? ( 0 ) Yes ( 0) No ( 0) AnothPr St<~te ( 0) N/A Are you licensed in the State of Florida? ( 0 ) Yes ( 0 ) No ( 0 ) Another State ( 0 ) N/A Oo vou possess a City of Palm Beach Gardens or:r.up..tion<1llicense? ( ® ) Yes ( 0 I No How long have you practiced lhe above profession? .,.2;l!.S..:..t..uv~~a.!..!!r~;'-------- Could your occupation prP<;Pnt a ('(Inflict of interest on any subject m;;t\'ter discus!>cd, t~viewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee: ( 0)Ves ( 0} No Please explain: hllhec,rry •. although it has nnl occurred and if il did Etrise, I would not P<~rticipat._e. _____ _ Feb 02 10 06:33p Stuart B. Klein,PA 561 478 SS31 ; ... ,._. .• APPliCATION FOR CITY ADVISORY BOARD/COMMITTEE APPOINTMENT Professional Background (Please check the appropriate boKes.) 0 0 VIsual, performing or literary arts Architect, architecture designer, landscape designer 0 Urban plannmg/design D Arts and cultural institution management D Buildil'tg I.VIll>ll ut:liull 0 Horticulture and landscaping 0 Vo\.Jth or ~dult cducntor D 0 own/operaLe " business in the City Member of Business Development Board, North Palm Beach County Chamber of Commerce or PGA Corridor Association 0 Attorney D Engineer D Real estate professional 0 Land surveyor 0 Banker D Accountant 0 Olla:!r (Piea$e list below) p.3 fBv Cod;{Ordinance i·7:l004; Ordin~~ce s:'ioo9, Ordina~·~·e 3s: l009), some B~ard~/Committees ha~e ·~Petific requir~m-~nts for l ~embership. _ . __ •. _ . Educational Background Diplvm(l, Ot.!KJ ttl! v1 O:!r Urit:ate Institution Bachelnrl; Ohio University .)[1 University of Toledo Colleg~;~ of law Ll.M New York University Sc;hool of Law Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ( 01Yes ( 0) No Have you participated in civic or c.ommunit'Y activities? ( 0) Yes: ( 0 )No Course of Stud'i Psychology Law l.aw I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. Stuart B. Kl~in 02/01/2010 Type your name here How did you leam about the Board or Committee for whkh you have applied: City's Web site: 0 Community Group: _[J_ Other: (specify} U Prior co submitting on avalicarion, you ore P.nr.nurnaPrl tn oW>nd one meeting Date attended: :!11/2010 1S:112 [ Submit Date City of Palm Beach Gardens Boar(jPiease Note: Pu.rsuan~ to .Fs ~19.07.the information ~rovided in A I. t' th1s apphcat1on IS considered to be pubhc record, PP ICa 10n except as provided by law. Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: Address: ~~La_hr----------~~~~Do-n----------~~~~~~--------~ City: State: Zip: ~=3=30==K=e=ls=e=y =P=a=rk=C=i=rc=le====================~~=P=B=G=====================~~ Florida llr-3-34_1_0 ___ ...., Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: ~~5_6_1-_62_4_-_28_9_1 ________ ~'='====~----------~~~r-----------------....,, ~~la_h_rd_o_@_a_o_l._co_m ________________ ~ Years of Residency: ~ Secondary Email Address: Preferred Means of Contact: 1~.-N_o_pr_e_fe_r_en_c_e _____ ....J Please place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. 0 Art in Public Places Advisory Board 0 Community Aesthetics Board 0 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board stfPianning, Zoning and Appeals Board* 0 Budget Oversight Committee 0 Fire Pension Board (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30 p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) (meets semi-monthly as called) 0 Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: Second Choice: Third Choice: Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0 Yes @ No If S0 1 which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? Are you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings ®Evening Meetings What would you hope to accomplish by participating? Utilize my 12 years of participation on Oaks East HOA Board, and Committee chairperson, and business experience garnered with 30 years at IBM and 7 years at Sensormatic Corp, in management positions. Give Back to the community. I Next Page j Present Employment: Profession: ~§-e-ti-re-d----~~------------------------------~1 I ~ddress: •p~o~s~1t~1o~n~:~----------------------------------~ Are you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ®No Are you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ®No Do you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No How many years have you practiced in the above profession? D Could your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee? O Yes ®No If yes, explain: Professional Background (please check all that apply) D Accountant D Adult Sports Programming D Aquatics Programming D Architect D Architect Design/Urban Planner DArts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. D Attorney D Banker D Div. 2 MEP Contractor D Engineer D Environmental Professional 1iJ Golf Course Participant D Horticulture & Landscaping D Land Surveyor D Landscape Architect D Member of Bus. Dev. Board D Business Owner in PBG D PGA Corridor Association D Real Estate Professional D Recreation Programming D Senior-Targeted Activities D Special Population Advocate D Tennis Center Participant D Visual/ Literary Arts D Building Construction D NPB Count Chamber of Commerce D Volunteer from PBGYAA D Div. 1 Bldg -General Contractor Educational Background liJ Other: Sales & management positions at 1 Diploma/Degree Institution Course of Study 1. IBA I Knox College !Economics & Bus. Admin 2. I 3. I Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No Have you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes 0 No If yes, ex~ Served on Board of Directors at Oaks East HOA for 6 years, serving 2 yrs as Treas. and 1 yr as Pres. How did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? 0 City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend ® Other: jchuck Hathaway Prior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: 1'-----:----:--:-::---' I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. liJ Agree I understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG Manda~ Cofte of Ethics Training. l!t1 Agre Name: Date: j,-o-o_n_L_a_h_r ----------,!20 Sep 2012 [jrint ] I Previous Page I ,, I I I . ..,. City of Palm Beach Gardens se Note: Pursuant to FS 119.0Tthe ihfo-rmation in Board & Committee Application this application is considered to be public record, Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: =~LE=v=IN=E=============~=~Lo=w=E=L=L============~~~~---=~--------~ Address: City: State: Zip: '-, .... 1=4_1-1=_8-_A-_R-_L-O=\i=N=C=O=U=R=T==================~~.-P-8-G---------~~~ Florida I .,3-34-.1-0-----, Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: =~3z=s=-6=9=o=o===========l:l3:74:-o:6:7=3===========~~=3=7~=o=6=7=3===========~~r-&-B-i,-,-e-~--t-~-~--.-~----~ Years of Residency: D Secondary Email Address: Preferred Means of Contact:j .... N_o_p_re_fe_r_e_n_ce _____ __. Please place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code., some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. D Art in Pu bile Places Advisory Board · 0 Community Aesthetics Board D Parks and Recreation Advisory Board !if Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * lif Budget Oversight Committee D Fire Pension Board (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00 p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00 p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) (meets semi-monthly as called) D Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: BOG -Budget Oversight Committee Second Choice: I PZAB -Planning, Zoning & Appeals Board Third Choice: Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes @ No If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0Yes @No If so, which one(s), and when? Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? OYes @ 1\Jo If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0Yes @No If so, which one(s), and when? Are you able to attend: @Daytime Meetings 0 Evening fV!eetings What would you hope to accomplish by participating? I' AM AN EXPERT WITH BUDGETS Next Page . P're~c;?~t ~m.r.foj!ment: Profession: l.-s-O...:.T_H...;.E,._B_.Y:e....'S...:.IN:..:.T"""E;:.R_N_A_T_IO-N-A-L-R-EA-l-TY---"'-'-""~-..............._..-.........,,-~REAL ESTATE BROKER Address: osition. I~K_E_w_G_A_R_o_E_N_s_D_R_I_v_E ________________________ ~II~B_R_o_KE __ R_·--------------------------------~r Are you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ® No Are you registered with Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0 No Do you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No How many years have you practiced in the above profession? ~ Could your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee? O Yes ® No If yes, explain: Professional Background {please check an that apply) if Accountant D Adult Sports Programming 0 Aquatics Programming 0 Architect D Architect Design/Urban Planner 0 Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. 0Attorney 0 Banker 0 Building Construction 0 Div. 1 Bldg -General Contractor Educational Background D Div. 2 MEP Contractor fil Business Owner in PBG D Engineer D PGA Corridor Association D Environmental Professional fil Real Estate Professional 0 Golf Course Participant D Recreation Programming D Horticulture & landscaping D Senior-Targeted Activities D land Surveyor 0 Special Population Advocate D landscape Architect D Tennis Center Participant filMember of Bus. Dev. Board 0 Visual/ Literary Arts filNPB County Chamber of Commerce D Volunteer from PBGYAA 0 Other:!.__-__________ _.( Diploma/Degree Institution Course of Study 1. JsBA llsERNARD BARUCH jjAcCTG-FINANCE-ECONOM!cs 2. t==l ======:'I~====-===+'===~ 3.1 I_ J Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes 0No Have you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes 0 No If yes, CODE ENFORCEMENT explain: BOARD IN PB How did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? ®City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend . 0 Other: ~~----------' Prior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: I l I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. Name: Date: LOWELL LEVINE ) 25 Aug 2011 Print Previous Page City of Palm Beach Gardens Board & Committee Application Please Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided ir this application is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: lrM_a_ro_n ____________________ ~,,~R~e-g_in_al_d ________________ ~I~~~R-e_g __ ~~--------------- ~ddress: City: State: Zip: -12_9_0_0_L_a_R_o_c_h_el-le-C--irc_l_e----------------.,~~Palm Beach Gardens II Florida I ... ,3-34_1_0 ______ ..., tome Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: )46-21 0-3708 I ~~5""6""'1-,9,0 .... 4-_6_7_37 ________ ----~.11646-21 0-3708 llrre_g_m_a-to_n_@--co_m_c_a_s_t.n_e_t __________ _ 'ears of Residency: D Secondary Email Address: »referred Means of Contact: I Work Phone _I •lease place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. if Art in Public Places Advisory Board if Community Aesthetics Board if Parks and Recreation Advisory Board if Plann~ng, Zoning and Appeals Board * if Budget Oversight Committee (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00 p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) .if Fir5! PensiQIJ_Board_ ______ _ _______ (meets ?-~~!:__f!!Or1_thly as ~CI_!I_~d) if Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form :t you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: I BOC -Budget Oversight Committee Second Choice: I Fire -Fire Fighters Pension Board Third Choice: I AIPP-Art in Public Places Board ~re you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? If so, which one(s)? tave you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? ~re you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s)? lave you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? ~re you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings ®Evening Meetings· l'tlhat would you hope to accomplish by participating? Use my corporate knowledge, experience as CIO to give back to the community Next Pace . ---··-----.... --., ···-··-· -hink Strategic Technology Partners, LLC !Consulting ~r.r~e~s~s~=--------------------------------------~ BP~o~s~it~i~o~n~=--------------------------------------- I-_2_9_0_0_L_a_R __ o-~c-h--8~-~~-e-C-ir_c_le _____ -_ -__ -____ -. __ -___ --____ -__ -__ -___ -__ -__ -_-__ --___ --___ -_-__ -____ -__ -____ -__ -__ -___ --.. __ UPrlncipa-1 ~re you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ® No lre you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes .® No to you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ®No low many years have you practiced in the above profession? D :ould your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided rpon by the Board or Committee? 0 Yes ®No If yes, explain: •rofessional Background (please check all that apply) ] Accountant ] Adult Sports Programming ] Aquatics Programming ] Architect ] Architect Design/Urban Planner ] Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. ] Attorney ] Banker ] Building Construction ] Div. 1 Bldg -General Contractor :ducational Background Diploma/Degree BA BSIE -. MS D Div. 2 MEP Contractor tif Engineer D Environmental Professional tif Golf Course Participant D Horticulture & Landscaping D Land Surveyor D Landscape Architect D Member of Bus. Dev. Board D NPB Count Chamber of Commerce tif Other: Institution Columbia University, Columbia College Columbia Engineering & Applied Science Columbia Engineering-& Applied Science ~re you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ®Yes ONo tifBusiness Owner in PBG D PGA Corridor Association !if Real Estate Professional 0 Recreation Programming D Senior-Targeted Activities D Special Population Advocate __ D Tennis Center Participant_ D Visual I Literary Arts !if Volunteer from PBGYAA Course of Study Math/Economics ~ -" Industrial Engineering Eng Management -- lave you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes 0 No If yes, explain: Coach. Palm Beach Gardens recreation baseball iow did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? ) City Web Site 0 Community Group 0 Friend ®Other: !Palm Beach Post •rior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: I I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. IJl Agree understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG landatory Code of Ethics Training. a me: Date: -,.-,....-;..,-.,-,-ri-R __ I\_JI_!:lt_n_n---lr---------.1 ? A11n ?n1 Ill Agree --~--~-------------------------~~~:h Ci~ of Palm Beach Gardens B.oard & Committee Application Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the ir this application is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. Last Name: ~----First Name:-MI: Nickname, if preferred: .ddress: =~M=a=s=on===================l._lw_._s_c_ott ________ ---lj D IL-w---=::---------City: State: Zip: ~~4~2~9~S~a~n~P~ie~t~ro~C~~irc~le~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~=~·~P-a-lm_B_e-ac_h_G_a-rd_e_n_s-----,,, Florida I ,....,3-3-41-0----, lome Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: i615430306 11':::5~6~18~0~4~44_3_2 _____ ..... 11,.... ---------,,,,w_m_a_s_o_n_@_f_ox_r_o-th_s_ch-i-ld-.c-o_m _____ _ 'ears of Residency: D Secondary Email Address: 'referred Means of Contact: ._I H_o_m_e_P_h_on_e _____ ___. 'lease place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. DArt in Public Places Advisory Board D Community Aesthetics Board D Parks and Recreation Advisory Board if Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board * D Budget Oversight Committee {meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30 p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) D Fire Pension Board (meets semi-monthly as called) D Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form f you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: Second Choice: Third Choice: ~re you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No If so, which one(s}? lave you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? '-re you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s)? iave you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? OYes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? '-re you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings ® Evening Meetings Nhat would you hope to accomplish by participating? Volunteer my legal knowledge of land use, zoning, and construction law to the community that I enjoy living in. Next Paae -----------------------------. ---·· ... -···r·-,-,··-··-· ox Rothschila, LLP/ !!Attorney ~a~a~r~e~s~s~:-----7~----------------------------~ RP~o~s~it~i~o~n~=--------------------------------------- -22 __ L_a-ke-v-ie-w~A~v~e~,VV~e=s=t=P=a=lm==B=e=ac=h==================~~~~A_s_~_oc_i_at_e ______________________________________ __ re you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ® No .re you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes @ No 10 you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No low many years have you practiced in the above profession? D ould your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided pon by the Board or Committee? ®Yes 0 No If yes, explain: It could to the extent a client appears in front of the Board, or if my firm represents a client in fron1 of the board. However, I do not know of any representation that has ever caused a conflict. 1rofessional Background (please check all that apply) ] Accountant ] Adult Sports Programming ] Aquatics Programming ] Architect ] Architect Design/Urban Planner ] Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. f Attorney ] Banker ] Building Construction ] Div. 1 Bldg-General Contractor !ducational Background 0 Div. 2 MEP Contractor 0 Business Owner in PBG 0 Engineer 0 PGA Corridor Association 0 Environmental Professional 0 Real Estate Professional 0 Golf Course Participant 0 Recreation Programming 0 Horticulture & Landscaping 0 Senior-Targeted Activities 0 Land Surveyor 0 Special Population Advocate 0 Landscape Architect 0 Tennis Center Participant 0 Member of Bus. Dev. Board 0 Visual I Literary Arts 0 NPB County Chamber of Commerce 0 Volunteer from PBGYAA 0 Other: l.____ _____ ____.l Diploma/Degree Institution Course of Study · !Juris Doctor !!Tulane Univeristy Law School · jBA "Florida Atlantic University ·~' --------------~'~----------------~~--------------~re you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? @Yes 0 No fave you participated in civic or community activities? @Yes 0 No If yes, explain: How did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? I actively particpate in bar organization community outreacl activities. J City Web Site 0 Community Group O Friend ® Other: General knowledge of city ?rior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: ~-'-~-~,..---' understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. !if Agree understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG 4andatory Code of Ethics Training. lame: Date: -V-~-,._-_n_tt_M __ ~_s_n_n--------------.1 ?f\ .h tl ?n1? Print Previous Paae !if Agree -·· ••• Application for City Advisory Board/Committee Appointment Please Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the information provided in this application is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. Name: 1'1/i c. h a.{>_ I A1 0' 1-t 11\dC( Home Address: s 0 t I ld t?..JI\ 0 /, 0.. /3t:y c(;...C & ' t City:fNt fJcA tf:a_,Js.N; Zip:3:Sif ~rHome Phone Number: ~'t/) 77(""' WorkPhoneNumber:Qr/) 7ft -2o Z 2 ~ '· . 1~7 Years of Residency? CK, E-mail address: 1'1ctfka €) a_a/, c u In WHICH BOARD OR COMMITIEE ARE YOU APPLYING FOR: D Art in Public Places Advisory Board D Community Aesthetics Board D Education Advisory Committee D Parks and Recreation Advisory Board D Etonomic Development Advisory Board D Budget Oversight Committee W' Planning, Zoning & Appeals Board " (generally meets 1" Monday of each month at 5:30p.m.) (meets l" Wednesday of each month at 5:30p.m.) (meets the 2ad Wednesday of each month at 7:00p.m.) (meets the 3rd Monday of each month at 7:00p.m.) (meets the 3rd Thursday of each month at 8:30a.m.) (generally meets twice a year during regular business hours.) (meets the 2nd and 4lh Tuesdays of each month at 6:30 p.m.) ("Required to file a statement of financial interest form) If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: l't Choice 2nd Choice 3rd Choice ----- Are you currently ~ on a Palm .f\each Gardens Board or Connnittee? ( )() Yes ( ) No Whichone(s) <(luc.Ovi/C?VI. Ad-viJoly (okP...-.f-1...-e__ Previous seiVice on City Boards or Committees? ( ) Yes (')'(1) No Which one(s) Date(s) of Service: _____ _ Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? ( ) Yes ( )6 No Which one(s) ----------- Previous service on County Boards or Committees? ( ) Yes (\.;)No Whichone(s) Date(s)ofSmfiee: _____ _ Are you able to attend: ( ) daytime meetings ( )<) evening meetings Are you registered in the State of Florida? r ..:e S Are you licensed in the State of Florida: 1/ -R :; ~c Another State: ___ _ Another State: ___ _ Do you possess a City of Palm Beach Gardens occupational license? AJ & How long have you practiced the above profession? ----.,.-,(-=-0_, ""1¥''-"'.e'-'a...='-r-'1=-----~ t. Preferred mailing address: ( '}(J Home ( ) Office Could your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discnssed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee: ( )Yes(X}No · Please explain:----------------------- • _t..._ -- l Pt·?fessional Background (Please check the appropriate boxes) IJ -Y-isuaJ...perfonni.ng_orliteracy_arts~------------------------------1 ___ _ IJ Architect, Architecture designer, landscape designer ....ar Urban planning/design IJ Arts and cultural institution management 8 Building construction IJ Horticulture and landscaping IJ Youth or adult educator IJ Own/operate a business in the City. IJ Member of Business Development Board, North Palm Beach County Chamber of Commerce or PGA Corridor Association. 1!1" Attorney !A Engineer IJ Real estate professional IJ Land smveyor IJ Banker IJ Accountant 1 1. !~ Other ..(. ft v ftc. A hi...Ctol-tq,, /o...w I By Code (Ordinance 17, 2004), some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership Educational Background: Diploma. Degree or Certificate :.J=--' __.DL..o.:.-'------L""''l""-'"-'-'.L.I<lv'-"'ec..:.,._._T' ...... I+=I''J'-"'-t._· "'--M_t_·<t.._l!:l;_.·-'-' _ __,.,I._.,.;J'-"';k:....d""'e""'ci..-""· ':..:;,""'"~--'-/ Pr<'-'f erlJ (Ch.,~,;tc 'Lc:f LCJ LV ::L o..-. "-" ~vt~-e~ profes-s r;.r ~ -1 rtood,'A.< Ai!c."'.fu.. Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ( 'XJYes ( )No Have you participated in civic or community activities: Yes: (X) No: ( ) Ifyes,pleaseexplain: <Cd~~.f.,oi1t AJ.v;r.::>z Cc~J-\.r{-h:...-G-- · tment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. /o-3 -t>-L' Date How did you learn about the Board or Committee for which you have applied: City's Web site: Community Group: Newspaper (s.Pecify) __ City's direct mail Brochure: ___ Other: (specify) X P.J..._ flee._ 4v t}:,oJ~( Prior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting Date attended: ------ Please retwn the application and resume to: City Clerk 10500 North Military Tmil Palm Beach Gardens, Fl33410 (561) 799-4121 Applications will be kept on file in the City Clerk's office for two (2) years. FOR USE BY CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ONLY: Appointed to:---------- Date of Appointment:-------- Orientation Date:--------- 'e ~ tc-r..e£ .r I Appliealion for City Advisory BcardiCommittee Appointment Plesse Note: Pursuant to FS 119.07 the informatim provided in this applieatioo is considered Co be public record. except as provided by law. N_ame: .t:Ju,,'t:l L. Al~cs HomeAddress: ,211 (j'/tM&t;,.,.,_ t2l City: tal« BeAe.lt.. t;wr/~p:l»,,; Home Phone Number: (Gt,i)ff';:-t9s:t Work Phone Number: f$11) ..Vfl # 9.61-!!>tS~ z-~ YearsofResidency? tG_""P s: E-mailadthss: d/.;zef,~.$ t!} ~SM -/~c.CA,.,; /,:rJ-. J,.y,;J /'~1-v.s. G) WHICH BOARD OI;l COMMITl'BE ARE YOU APPLYING FOR: oe-1/ <so...:U...~te..-1- a Art Ill Publ.it Plato Advisory Board a Community Aestbetles Board t::.r" Parks ud Retreatlon AdviSOI'J Board :! . ...-:Eeonomle Developmeat AdvisorY BOard ur Budget Oversight Committee ut"" .Pianalllg, Zoldng & Appeals Board • (meets 3nt Tuesday ol each month at 5:30p.m.) (meets 1"' Wednesday or each month at 5:30p.m.) (meets the 3nt Munday ur eadl month at 7:09p.m.) (meets the 1.•4 Thiii"Sday ol eaeh month at 8;30 a.m.) (meets the 4• Tbunday ol eaeh month at 8:30a.m.) (meets the 1.0 aDd 4~t> Tuesdays ol each month at 6:3t p.m.) (*Required to file a statement of' Onaadal interest form) If you have cheda::d more than one box. wbic:h would be your: lot Choice P ~ AA 21111 Choice Bok-3nt Choice P/t1H5 Are you tegistered in the State ofFiorida? U~~> Another Strte: P"" Are you licensed in the State ofFiorida: i':;, Another State: rtf, d '" ~ I ,J ~ E. f. "::. Do yoo possess a City of Palm Beach Gardens oooupatiooal.license?--J.P;..;;;......;":..__-- How long have you practiced the above profession? t:!:',...y .P-1 'RAJ<:. Ptefm'ed mailing address: ()!)Home ( ) Office David L. Peters, P.E., C.P.E. Vice President ----Hanson Professional services Inc. ---- www.hanson-inc.com • dlpeters@hanson-inc.com 1601 Belvedere Road, Suite 303 South • West Palm Beach, FL 33406-1558 (561) 471-9370 • Fax: (561) 471-9369 -----·------------ • Prolasl011al Baekgrou.a.d (Please check the appropriate boxes) a Visua1, perfbnning or litetary arts. a Architect, M:hifEcture designer, landscape designer a Urban plamrlngldesign a Arts and culbnl institutioo management A Building QOIIslructim a Horticul!D:e and landscaping a Youth or adult educator a Own/operate a business in the Cif¥. f1 Member ofBusiness Development Board, NOith Palm Beach County Chamber ofCommen:e or PGA Conidor Association: '?""" Attorney 1:!1 Engineer a Real estate proft:ssional a Land surveyor a Bankec Accountant Other .Educatioual Baekgro1111d: Diploma Dmree or Certificate eeifie reqairemeots for membersh • Institution Dow did you leara aboot tlte Board or Coamdttee for whleh you have applied: City's Web site; Commbllity Groa.p: Newspaper (speeify) ./' /',.1'-.i!J.w./. J(f?.,/, City's dlred mail Bredlure: __ Other: (speeify) ----- Prior to submitting an applicalion, you are encourOged to attend ons meeting. Date attended: ____ _ Please rerum the appli<:ation and reswne to: City Clerk IOSOO North Milifary Trail Palm Beach Gardens, Fl33410 (561) 799-4121 FOR USE BY CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ONLY; Appointed to: ________ _ Date of Appointment:------- Ori~on~: _________ __ 09/30/2005 FRI 12:02 FAX 561 626 0304 !PRE ABACOA Ap}>lication for City Advisory Board/Committee Appointment Pl<'M<' V;;!l': Pursuant to FS 119.07 lhe informalion provided in this application is considered to be public record, except as provided by law. ~!A-.~! • ' ,.....,. ,po U:l2 """' -......, ..... ,~~,, 'c::::'l' l' ~(). \ c Name: ;i\:u.( ON ~\.J ''>..! Home Address: : v Af-Ait::.tt\ .l. A?~( \ VL. IU:JOOl/002 r . City: 'V6G.-Zip3S'\:\B Home Phone Number: 00 ~jO .bt]..OWork Phone Number: (8gf .\.:,22-S7)0b Years of Residency? :'! MO\ E-mail address: AA~\OrJ(...;) hfv\..../(J~..?;vf-..0. co~ WHICH BOARD OR COMMITTEE ARE YOU APPLYING FOR: [l A1·t in l'tiltlk 'Plat:I'S :\(h·isory l::loarti CJ Conu11nnit:: ,/\.t..~!i~hNh:~ Bo<trd W l~dn;:atino . .-\<hh<.w,· Cummitt;;~ u r~u'i\!; t~nd U.:."".t~rn:~ifH~ AdY~Snr:-. BtJ!l'rd 0 ltcl:!non~!c Ut:-\ t~lfi{.HUi.'nt .~\.dvi"SiH·~ St'~(lnJ 0 Ht1£f;;e!. 0\·{;r~iJ~ht ('Htn»liHct-V f'l~-l.H;J~~t:~~ ?.uH.iH~! & •\pp(\i'i.l~ nu~trd ·:. · {gene~:·a!iy i1l<~ds 1·" }1'1i1Hlay t)f racb uumtf't ut 5:3!1 Jl.IU.) (uu:{!tS f" Wcd:nt"idny nit~acll mnotll Rt :5:3!). p.m.) {mcr:h the Z"" Vi!.:dn,•sda~· or eacll month <117:00 p.m.) (llltN:i Hw ya \·i<m<b:· nf (!<lch nHmth at 7:0!i ~l.m.) {nu-ets tl1c :r·< Tlmrsdll~· nf em:h m<mUl ilf 8:JU a.m.) (t!t.:"tHtraUy nH~t'~; (\Vi~:!" a yc.a.r during r~igalt}.r bu~}ncs::;.lHlurs.) lnw\'i"l' H1r: l"" und -l'" Tm'~days <Jf each month ;,;t 11:.3{) p.m.) (~·'f.h?([Uifi.~d tu Gte; ~1 ~.{nicn~e~lt of nnantia~ int~r~:\1 t~)rHi) If you have checked more !han one box, which would be your: r~ C1l1)i::.:t~ 2.::• C!hti~~ J''~ (~hoi~e. ____ _ Arc you cum:ntly serving on a Palm Beach Garcfei)S Board or Committee? ( · ) Yes ( vr;:;o Whichone(s) _________ ---: Previous service on City Boards or Conunittces? ( } Yes ( V}'ffo Whiehone(s) Datc(s) of Service:------ Are yuu. currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board orCommillee? ( } Yes { t/No Which one(s) . ~ Previous service on County Boards or Committees'? ( ) Y cs ( '0No Which one(s) _ Dall~(s) of Service: ____ _.__ Are you able to allend: ( -vJ'daytime meetings ( ~vening meetings What would you hope to accomplish by participating? ·-ro \-\t"'L? Q;·Row O\.IR,CI:.N KCTA-iN\t-r&: rts ~~-:-t ?! /4-W/2£ -'-1 . I Present Employer: -·~-s""'9CL"";_.=-'='f".._-_____________ _ Address: Profession: 1?E:SAL ES\'&-=te -~(£)"9-JD ,1\.. Position: SAu:;~ G:::;tt-.)&U~ Are you registered in the Stale of Florida? je:s -Are you licensed in the Stale ofHorida: 'i"E·S Another State: ___ _ Another State: ___ _ Do you. possess a City of J>alm Beach Gardens oc~upationa! license? "-)0 -"([...J,P C'i:"'C12. How loHg have you practiced the above profession? lf-'1-B"V2--~ Preferred mailing address: ( 0Home ( ) Ofiice Could your occupation prcs~t conflict of in !crest on any subjt:ct matter discussed, l'eviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee: ( )Yes ( VfNo · Please explain: _______________________ _ 09/30/2005 FRI 12:03 FAX 561 626 0304 IPRE ABACOA @002/002 I 0 Visual, J>crfonning or literary arls. 0 Architect, Architecture designer, landscape designer 0 Urb<m plauningldcsign 0 Arts ami cultuml inslitution management D Building construction D Horticulture and landscaping D Youth or adult educator 0 Own/operate a business in the City. 0 Member of Business Development Board, North Palm Beach County Chamber of Commerce or PGA Conidor Association. D Attorney 0 Engineer ~ Real estate professional D Land surveyor Q Banker D Accounlant 0 Other Educational Background: . Diploma, Degree ur Cerlifica!c 15S Institution CAu~f.uA C';(5A.b.'\ Ul-l\V Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ( )Yes(~o Course of Study "Bv&we::-~ . . A1Sil1Ni~1f<A\lOrJ Have you j>articiJlatcd in civic O!' community activities: Yes: ( v) No; ( If yes, please explain: Af;:c iN ~\)£>Lie {(~:..ACE$ 1 ~ (/<::Mk& ~-­ BJ~..\lJ!G<o..\ a P:f::QE. \rfi)MP:I\) bCT\\1\IlES. e e.Jer·.J\SJ !tiZDE&t\S Pri01· to submitting em application, you are encouraged Ia artencf one meeting i)uti.' nitl!tHtcd~ Please return the application and resume to: City Clerk 10500 North Military Trail Palm. Beach Gardens, PI 3341 () (561) 799-4121 . Applications will be kept on file in tire City Clerk's oj]ice.for two (2) years. FOR USE BY CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ONLY: Appointed to:------·---- Date of Appointment ___ _ Orientation Date:-----·----- I City of Palm Beach Gardens Board Please Note: P~rsuant. to .Fs ~19.07.the information ~rovided in A I. t" th1s application 1s considered to be public record, PP ICa 10n except as provided by law. Last Name: First Name: MI: Nickname, if preferred: Address: rls_h_a-nn_o_n----------------~~~~M~a_r9_a_r_et ________________ ~I~~~M-e_9 __ ~~--------------~ City: State: Zip: ,...11_1_1_1_0_ri-n-oc_o_W __ a_y-------------------------.~~Palm Beach Gardens II Florida llr3-34_1_0 ______ , Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: Email Address: 1~5_6_1-_7_75_-_1_4_19 ________ ___.1 r~----------,11313-207-7028 11 rm_v_d_gs-@--ao-1-.c-o-m---------------------. Years of Residency: ~ Secondary Email Address: Preferred Means of Contact: ~~ H_o_m __ e_P_h_o_ne __________ __, Please place a check next to each board/committee on which you would be interested in serving: By Code, some Boards/Committees have specific requirements for membership. 0 Art in Public Places Advisory Board 0 Community Aesthetics Board 0 Parks and Recreation Advisory Board liKPianning, Zoning and Appeals Board * 0 Budget Oversight Committee 0 Fire Pension Board (meets quarterly on the 3rd Tuesday at 5:30p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 1st Wednesday at 4:00p.m.) (meets quarterly on the 3rd Monday at 6:00p.m.) (meets monthly on the 2nd Tuesday at 6:00 p.m.) (meets monthly on the 4th Thursday at 8:30a.m.) (meets semi-monthly as called) 0 Police Pension Board (meets quarterly as called) * Required to file a statement of financial interest form If you have checked more than one box, which would be your: First Choice: Second Choice: Third Choice: Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0 Yes ® No If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach Gardens Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? Are you currently serving on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0 Yes ®No If so, which one(s)? Have you ever served on a Palm Beach County Board or Committee? 0Yes ®No If so, which one(s), and when? Are you able to attend: 0 Daytime Meetings ® Evening Meetings What would you hope to accomplish by participating? I hope to help keep Palm Beach Gardens an attractive place to live and to provide input that would help streamline the process for development proposals. I would like to make sure that any future development proposals that are approved are beneficial to the city and its residents. ~xt Page j Present Employment: Profession: 'IR-e-ti-re_d __ __;__..;;. _______________ _,l0ttorney \ ~~a~ar-re=s=s~:~-----------------~ k~=o=snit~io~n~:~----------------~·-~ Are you a Lobbyist? 0 Yes ®No Are you registered with Palm Beach County? 0 Yes ® No Do you possess a City of PBG Occupational License? 0 Yes ® No How many years have you practiced in the above profession? ~ Could your occupation present a conflict of interest on any subject matter discussed, reviewed or decided upon by the Board or Committee? O Yes ® No If yes, explain: Professional Background (please check all that apply) 0 Accountant 0 Adult Sports Programming 0 Aquatics Programming 0 Architect 0 Architect Design/Urban Planner 0 Arts and Cultural Instit. Mgmt. !il Attorney 0 Banker < ! .. l ' 0 Building Construction D Div. 1 Bldg General Contractor Educational Background Diploma/Degree 0 Div. 2 MEP Contractor 0 Business Owner in PBG 0 Engineer 0 PGA Corridor Association 0 Environmental Professional 0 Real Estate Professional D Golf Course Participant D Recreation Programming D Horticulture & Landscaping 0 Senior-Targeted Activities D Land Surveyor ·D Special Population Advocate D Landscape Architect D Tennis Center Participant D Member of Bus. Dev. Board D Visual I Literary Arts D NPB County Chamber of Commerce D Volunteer from PBGYAA 0 Other: .._l __________ __,l Institution Course of Study 1."1Juris Doctor (JD) llwayne State University, Detroit, Ml 2.· lsachelor of Arts llwayne State University, Detroit, Ml 3'1' · !Brown University, Providence, Rl Are you registered to vote in Palm Beach County? ® Yes 0 No Have you participated in civic or community activities? ®Yes 0 No IIHistory "History. (trans after 2 yrs.) If yes, ex~ President, The Isles HOA Member ofT axpayer Action Board How did you learn about the volunteer program for which you are applying? 0 City Web Site 0 Community Group ® Friend 0 Other: Prior to submitting an application, you are encouraged to attend one meeting. Date Attended: I I I understand the duties, role and time commitment to the Boards or Committees to which I have applied. 1if Agree I understand if I am selected to serve on a board or committee, I am required to complete the PBG Manda~ Code of Ethics Training. IJ!I Agree Name: Date: , ..... M-a-rg_a_r_e_t S-ha_n_n_o_n---------.,17 Sep 2012 , __ P_r_int I I Previous Page Planning, Zoning & Appeals Board FY 2011-2012 I 10/11/11 10/18/11 11/1/11 11/15/11 12/13/11 1/10/12 2/21/12 3/6/12 4/10/12 5/8/12 6/12/12 7/10/12 8/7/12 9/11/12 Staff Liaison • Natalie Wong Crowley p p p p p p p p EA c EA p p Alternate Staff Liaison • p p Attorney R. Max Lohman p p p p p p p p p p p p Attorney Keith Davis Attorney Abigail Jorandby 2011-2012 Board Members Michael Panczak (Regular Member -Chair) p p p p p p p A p p p p Randolph Hanaen (Regular Member -Vice Chair) p p A p p p p p p p p p Charles Hathaway (Regular Member) p EA p p p p p p p p p p Joy Hecht (Regular Member). p p p A p A p p p p R R Roma Josephs (Regular Member) p p p p p p p p p p p p Douglas Pennell (Regular Member}. p p p p p p p p p p A p Howard Rosenkranz jRegular Member) p p p p p p A p p p p p Robert Savel (Regular Member-July 2012) p EA p p p p A A p p p p P =Present A•Absent R• Resigned NM • No Meeting C=Cancelled NQ=No Quorum NAM • Not a Member Excused Absence: Subpoena Illness Jurv Dutv Meeting Date/Subject 1 0/1212010 Recommendation to City Council- Quasi-judicial hearing -CUMJ-1 0-08- 000018: Downtown at the Gardens - Major Conditional Use. Recommendation to City Council- Quasi-judicial hearing-MSNP-10-09- 000 008: Dirty Martini at Downtown at the Gardens -Minor Site Plan. Recommendation to City Council - Public Hearing-LDRA-10-08-00 0034: A City-Initiated petition regarding Recreational Open Space, Mixed- UseZoning Districts, and Definitions in order to revise and clarify the subject regulations and to ensure consistency with tghe Comprehensive Plan . 11/9/2010 Recommendation to City Council- Quasi-judicial hearing-REZN-1 0-1 0- 000010: Rezoning of Parcei18.A07 from County RS & RE Zoning Districts to Palm Beach Gardens RL-2 Zoning Recommendation to City Counc il- Quasi-judicial hearing-SPLA-10-10- 000020: Major Site Amendment for an Outdoor Bar at Midtown 12/1412010 • Recommendation to City Council- Quasi-judicial hearing-PUDA-1 0-11- 000026: Borland Center Electronic Marquee Sign -PUD Amendment 8129/2012 PZAB VOT ING RECORD FY2010-2011 ~00» /,~ ~/; 0~. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~'b ~ ~ ~'b ~ ~~ ~'b ~ ~ ~ ~~ e(:' ~ ~ ~"'~ ~~ ~ec; ,o.,~ ·~.f q_e(:' ~o" c,"'~ '\o<l City Council appointed new members at the 10/07/2009 meeting Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A N/A 7-0 Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A N/A 7-0 Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A N/A 7-0 Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Absent Yes Yes N/A 7-0 Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Absent Yes Yes N/A 7-0 Approve Yes Yes Recused Yes Absent Yes Yes Yes Yes 7-0 1 of 11 Meeti ng Date/Su bject Recommendation to City Council- Quasi-judicial hearing -SPLA-08-01- 000010: Steeplechase Research and Office Center 1/11/2011 Recommendation to City Counci l - CPTA-10-11-000019-Text Amendment to the Capital Improvements Element (CIE) - Ordinance 2, 2011 Recommendation to City Council - LDRA-1 0-12-000036 -Amendment to the City's Land Development Regu lations providing for an Architectural Review Exemption - Ordinance 3, 2011 2/8/2011 3/1/2011 Recommendation to City Council - Quasi-Judicia l Hearing - PUDA-11-01-000027 -Frenchman's Crossi ng requesting a PUD Amendment for additional signage at 4019 Hood Road (Veterinary Hospital) 8129/2012 PZAB V OTING RECORD FY2010-2011 ~~0 /; 4 /; 4 /.; //X:. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~'ti ~ ~ ~'ti ~ ~e ~'ti ~ ~ ;;. ~6 e<:' ;;.~ ~ ~'b<:' ~~ ~efJ \o.,e -4:-'b<:' ~·<:' ~o" cl '\ 4J Approve Yes Yes Yes No Absent Recused Yes Yes Yes 6-1 Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Absent Yes Yes N/A 7-0 Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Absent Yes Yes N/A 7-0 CANCELED Approve Yes Absent Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A 7-0 2 of 11 Meeting Date/Subject 1 ttecommenaatlon to {.;lty {.;Ouncu - Quasi-Judicial Hearing - LDRA-11-01-000037 -A City-initiated amendment to the City's Land Development Regulations In order to revise and clarify project build out determination criteria; to amend the list of permitted uses, minor and major conditional uses, and prohibited uses to incorporate "places of assembly;" and to amend related definitions. 4112/2011 Recommendation to City Council - Quasi-Judicial Hearing - LDRA-11-02-000038 -Amendment to Code Section 78-228(b)(1) and Section 78-229(a)(2) to extend the effective date of both regulations to May 31, 2014. Recommendation to City Council - Quasi-Judicial Hearing - MISC-11-03-000079 -Amendment to the traffic control agreement for PGA National 5/10/2011 8/29/2012 PZAB VOTING RECORD FY201 0-2011 ~0~» ~~ ~~ 0». ~ ~~ ~ ~.., ~ ~ ~ ,:i>~ ~ ~ ... ~ ~ e~ ~ ~ i' ~ ~ ~ ~\:! ~ ~"'~" ~~~ ~e;s' ....,o"'l; +"'~e qe~~ ~o.,e r.,~e A,.Ot(p Approve Yes Absent Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A 7-0 Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A N/A 7-0 Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A N/A 7-0 CANCELED 3 of 11 8/29/2012 PZAB VOTING RECORD FY201 0-2011 ~00» 4~ ~~ /'l~. ~ ~# ~ ~..., ~ ~ ~'li ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ !\. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ Meeting Date/Subject ~~~" ~,f' ~e~ -.o"~~; +~~e q,e~~ ~cl' "~~~~; ,._o-..'6 06/21/11 (Meeting rescheduled from 06/14111) 1 Recommendation to City council (Public Hearing) Quasi-Judicial Hearing SPLA-1 0-07-000019 -Downtown at the Gardens -Major Site Plan Approve Amendment Absent Yes Yes Yes Yes Absent Yes Yes N/A 6-0 Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing) Quasi-Judicial Hearing SPLA-11-05-000025 -Frenchman's Creek Planned Community Recused Motion Development (PCD) Major Site Plan Filed Left meeting failed Amendment (Motion to deny) Absent Yes Yes Form 88 No Absent No at 7:00p.m. N/A 2-2 7/1212011 Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing) Quasi-Judicial Hearing PUDA-11-04-000028 -Village Recused Square II Planned Unit Development II Filed Approve (PUD) Amendment Yes Form 88 Absent Yes Yes Vacant Absent Yes Yes 5-0 Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing) -QUASI-JUDICIAL HEARING SPLA-11-04-000022 -Old Palm Planned Community Development (PCD) Amendment for Parcel F1 Approve (Clubhouse Parcel) Yes Yes Absent Yes Yes Vacant Absent Yes Yes 6-0 Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing) -QUASI-JUDICIAL HEARING SPLA-11-04-000023 • Old Palm Planned Community Development (PCD) Amendment for Parcel A (Sabat Approve Palm) Yes Yes Absent Yes Yes Vacant Absent Yes Yes 6-0 4 of 11 Meeting Date/Subject Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing) ·QUASI-JUDICIAL HEARING SPLA-11-04-000024 -Old Palm Planned Community Development (PCD) Amendment for Parcel C (Majesty Palm) 8/23/2011 • Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing) LDRA-11-07 -000041 - City initiated request to amend the Impact Fees Amending the City's Land Development Regulations in order to update the City of Palm Beach Gardens' Impact Fees for Parks and Recreation, Fire Rescue, Police, and Roads. Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing) LDRA-11-07-000042-City initiated request to amend the Targeted Expedited Permitting Process Amending the City's Land Development Regulations regarding Section 78-57 "Targeted Expedited Permitting Program" 9/20/2011 Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing) -REZN-11-07 -000011 Howell Watkins Middle School Rezoning 8/29/2012 PZAB VOTING RECORD FY2010-2011 ~ ~If fl>4, ~ ~ ... 'b~., :.f:.~ ~~0 /; /; /; ~/; //~. ~ fl>~ "' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.:r ~ ~'b' ~p ~e($' ...,o"q; -+t~ q,e~~ ~o"q; '?'b~q; At.~~~ Approve Yes Yes Absent Yes Yes Vacant Absent Yes Yes 6-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Absent Yes 7-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Absent Yes 7-0 Approve No longer 7-0to Postpone Postpone Postpone Postpone Postpone on board Postpone Postpone N/A postpone 5 of 11 Meeting Date/Subject Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing) -CUMJ-11-08-000020 Cabo Flats Restaurant at Downtown at the Gardens -Major Conditional Use Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing) -PUDA-11-07 -000032 Corporate Center at the Gardens 10/11/2011 Recommendation to City Council - Quasi-Judicial Hearing REZN-11-07- 000011 Howell Watkins Middle School Rezoning 11/1/2011 Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing) CPSS-11-05-000003 Small Scale Future Land Use Map Amendment regarding the Gordon & Doner property located south of 4114 Northlake Boulevard Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PPUD-11-05- 000024 Rezoning from Residential Medulm (RM) and General Commercial (GC1) to General Commercial (CG1) with overlay zoning of Planned Unit Development (PUD) and PUD approval for the 0.87 acre Gordon & Doner property located at4114 Northlake Boulevard Recommendation to City Council Quasi judicial Hearing PUDA-11-05- 000029 Banyan Tree Planned Unit Development (PUD) Phase Ill 8/29/2012 PZAB VOTING RECORD FY2010-2011 ~~~» 4 h ~/.;//X:. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ \;:: ~'li ~ ~ ~ ~ e~ ~ ~ ~ :~.. ~ ~ :~..\;! ~ ~,i" ~p ~,;; ...,o.,e ~~&~e q,e~~ ~o<P '?~&~e A...cf1 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 6 of 11 Meeting Date/Subject Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judical Hearing PCDA-11-05- 000011 Downtown at the Gardens Planned Community Development (PCD) Amendment to revise the approved Master Sign Plan 11/15/2011 Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PUDA-11-09- 000033 and CUMJ-11-09-000021 Turtle Beach Planned Unit Development (PUD) Amendment Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PUDA-11-07- 000031 Nova SE University Planned Unit Development (PUD) Amendment 12113/2011 Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing MISC-1 0-07- 000074 The Sancuary PUD Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PUDA-11-07 • 000030 Waterford Hotel Planned Unit Development (PUD) Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PCDA-10-07- 000010 Parcel 31-04 PCD Amendment Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PUDA-1 0-04- 000025 Southampton PUD Amendment 1/10/2012 8/29/2012 PZAB VOTING RECORD FY201 0-2011 ~/~0/; ~~ ~/; //~. ~ ~~ ~ ~"" ~ ~ ~ ,:1>'/j !> ~ ... 'li ~ e~ ~ !I. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~'b~., ~~ ~e(S:' ...,o"~ ~'b~~ qe~~ ~o.,~ "'>'b~~ "" No (Robert No longer Approve Yes Savel) Yes Yes Yes on board Yes No N/A 5-2 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Not at Dias N/A 6-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Not at Dias N/A 6-0 No No longer (Robert Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes No on board Yes Savel) N/A 5-2 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes NJA 7-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes NJA 7-0 7 of 11 Meeting Date/Subject Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing SPLA-11-09- 000027 LA Fitness Plaza Major Site Plan Amendment Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PCDA-11-05 - 000011 Downtown at the Gardens Planned Community Development (PCD) Amendment to revise the approved Master Sign Plan 2/21/2012 Recommendation to City Council Public Hearing CPMA-11-09-000014 Large-scale future land use map amendment regarding a 10.4 acre parcel of land located at the southwest corner of Hood Road and Interstate 95 Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PPUD-11-09- 000026 Rezoning a 10.4 acre parcel of land from planned development area (PUD) to residential medium (RM) with a planned un it development (PUD) overlay; the subject parcel is located at the southwest corner of Hood Road and Interstate 95 Recommendation to City Councel Quasi-judicial hearing SPLA-12-01- 000028 Frenchman's Creek PCD townhome setback modification 8/2912012 PZAB VOTING RECORD FY2010-2011 ~~0» 4 ~ ~/; //~. <I' ($1 :\. ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~<:' ~ ~ ~~ ~~ "' ~.. ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~~ ~~'(' ~e-'(' ,o"'li +~~'li qe~fl:' ~o"'li '-J~~'li .t,.O<P No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 No (Robert No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Savel) No on board Yes No N/A 4-3 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Absent N/A 6-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Absent N/A 6-0 Declared a conflict and did No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes not vote Yes on board Yes Absent N/A 5-0 8 of 11 Meeting Date/Subject Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PPCD-11-03- 000004 Rezoning from p lanned devel opment area (PDA) to planned community developmemt (PCD) and master plan approval Parcel 31.06/07 Recommendation to City Council Quasi -judicial Hearing SPLN-11-06- 000009 Requesting site plan approval for Parcel A to allow for 224 multi- family residential dwelling units Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PUDA-11-11- 000034 Banyan Tree Pl anned Unit Development 3/6/2012 Recommendation to City Council Public Hearing continued from 2/21112 Quasi=judicial Hearing SPLN-11-06- 000009 Recommendation to City Co uncil Quas i -judicia l Hearing SPLA-12-01- 000029 Requesting a site plan amendment Recommen d ation t o City council Quasi-judicial Hearing REZN-12-02- 000012 Rezoning from planned development area (PDA) to conservation (CONS) for 198.9 acres of canal right-of-way located within the Loxahatchee Slough 8/29/2012 PZAB VOTING RECORD FY2010-2011 ~0~»hh~~ 0~. ~ ~~ ~ ~... ~ * '1: ,1/>'li ~ ~ c..'li ~ e~ ~ !\. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~., ;$' ;so ~eq ~e ~~ ~e ~e p,.llj ~'li ~'li ~e ,o +'li q_e ~o ">'li A,.O No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Absent N/A 6-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Absent N/A 6-0 No l onger Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Absent N/A 6-0 No longer Approve Absent Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 6-0 No longer Approve Absent Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 6-0 No longer Approve Absent Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 6-0 9 of 11 Meeting Date/Subject Reommcndation to City Council Public Hearing CPTA-12-02-000021 Text amendment to the comprehensive plan which provides for a comprehensive update to the future land use Public Safety and other elements as may be necessary for interal consistency 4/10/2012 Recommendation to City Council Public Hearing CPTA-12-02-000022 Text amendment to the Capital Improvements Element Recommendation t o City Co uncil QuasiOj udicial Hearing PPUD-11-08- 000025 and CUMJ-12-0 1-000022 The Mandel Jewish Communituy Center (JCC) Aurthur I. Meyer Jewish Academy Planned Unit Development (PUD) Recommendation to City Council Quasi-jud i c ial Hearing SPLA-12-02- 000030 Downtown at the Gardens Site Plan Amendment Recommendation to City Council Public Hearing LDRA-12-03-000044 A City-Initiated Amendment to the Land Deve lopment Reglations 6/12/2012 Recommedati on to City Counci l Quasi judicial Hearing Misc-12-04-000084 Gosman Parcel Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PUDA-12-05- 000038 Midtown Planned Unit Development Amendment 8/29/2012 PZAB VOTING RECORD FY2010-2011 ~~0» /J /; ~/.; /'l;<:_ ~ ~' ~ ~"' ~ ~'b " ~ .._'li ~ e~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~'b~" ~~~ ~tP ..,o.,e ~'b~e q,e~~ ~o.,e c,'b~e '\0<1 No longer Approve Absent Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 6-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 No longer Approve Yes No Yes No Yes on board No Yes N/A 4-3 No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 No longer Approve Yes No No Yes Yes on board No Yes N/A 4-3 No longer Approve No Yes Yes Yes Yes on board No No N/A 4-3 10 of 11 Meeting Date/Subject Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PCDA-12-04- 000014 Evergrene Planned Community Development 7/10/2012 Reommndation to City Council Quasi- judicial Hearing SPLA-11-08-000026 Downtown at the Gardens Shared Parking 8/7/2012 Recommendation to City Council Quasi-judicial Hearing PUDA-12-04- 000036 PGA Commons Parcel 2 Planed Unit Development Amendment 9/12/2012 PZAB VOTING RECORD FY201 0-2011 ~00/1/Jh~~ 0~. (!'~ ~ :\. ~ ~~ ~ ~~ " ~ ._'be:> ~ e~ ~.:j. !'. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~., ;$' ;s "eq ~e ~~ "e ~e ir"'li ~~ ~'b ~e ,o +~ q_e ~o '?~ ~ No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes on board Yes Yes N/A 7-0 Yes No Longer No longer (Robert Approve Yes Yes Yes on board Yes on board Savel) Yes N/A 6-0 No Longer No longer Approve Yes Yes Yes on board Yes on board No No No 4-3 11 of 11 TO: FROM : SUBJECT: DATE: CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS MEMORANDUM Mayor and Council members Ronald M. Ferris, City Manager. ~ November 2012 State Constitutional Amendments 10/03/2012 As you are well aware, there are eleven (11) constitutional amendments on the November 6, 2012, ballot. If approved, five (5) of the amendments would have the potential to negatively impact the City of Palm Beach Gardens' tax base. Most notable of these is Amendment 4, which is estimated to reduce the City's ad valorem revenues by $3.1 million over four (4) years. I have attached a memorandum from Allan Owens, Finance Administrator that further discusses the financial implications of the amendments. The Florida League of Cities (FLC) is officially opposing Amendment 4, as are countless other organizations. The Women's League of Voters has publically come out against all eleven (11} amendments (article and information attached). While staff does not philosophically oppose or support the various amendments, it is instead believed these items should be brought forth via the appropriate State Legislative process. As such, I have included Resolution 93, 2012, which opposes Amendment 4, for your review. If it is the pleasure of the Council body, I would like this item to be discussed at the October 11, 2012, Council meeting. Upon approval, Resolution 93, 2012 would be sent to the FLC for inclusion with other municipalities that have passed similar resolutions. If you have any further questions, please do not hesitate to contact my office at 799.4112. CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS MEMORANDUM DATE: October 1, 2012 TO: Ron Ferris, City Manager /) /) FROM: Allan Owens, Finance Administrator ~----- SUBJECT: Amendment 4 Next month there will be five referendum questions on the ballot that, if approved , would have a negative impact on the City's tax base. Two of these amendments would expand tax exemptions directly. Amendment 2 would expand a current homestead exemption for veterans disabled in combat to include those who were not Florida residents when they entered the military. Amendment 10 would expand the tangible personal property tax exemption from $25 ,000 to $50,000. Two other amendments would enable either the legislature or local governments to create exemptions. Amendment 9 would let the legislature create a homestead property tax exemption for surviving spouses of veterans or first responders killed in the line of duty. Amendment 11 would give the legislature the power to allow local governments to create a homestead exemption equal to the market value of a home worth less than $250,000 if it has been the residence of a low-income senior for at least 25 years. Lastly , the most detrimental item on the ballot, by far , is Amendment 4, which would amend the constitution in four ways: 1. Allow the legislature to pass a law prohibiting the assessment of a homestead and specified non-homestead properties from increasing if the market value on January 1st of a year is less than its market value the previous January 1st. 2 . Reduce from 10% to 5% the limit on annual increases in assessments of non-homestead real property. 3. Allow the legislature to pass a law providing an additional homestead exemption for non-school assessments to anyone who buys a full-time residence in Florida after not owning a Florida homestead for the previous three years . This additional homestead exemption would last five years . In the first year, it would equal half the home's market value on January 1st of the year the homestead was established , but the exemption could not exceed the median market value of all homestead properties in the county. The exemption would be reduced by 20% each year , so that by the sixth year it no longer would exist. If approved , it would apply to property purchased on or after January 1, 2012 . 4. Delay unti l 2023 the repeal, currently scheduled to take effect in 20 19 , of constitutional amendments adopted in 2008 that limit annual assessment increases fo r specified non-homestead real property . One analysis prepared by the Florida Association of Counties (copy attached) estimates the t otal reduction in State-wide ad valorem revenues at approximately $(1. 7) billion for years 2013-2016. Of this total , the study estimates cities in Palm Beach County will lose $(46.4) million . Using population figures , the City of Palm Beach Gardens' total estimated impact over four years was calculated at $(3.1) million , and is illustrated in the table below: (In thousands) 2013 2014 2015 2016 Total Impact on PBC Cities $(5 ,300) $(9 ,500) $(13 ,000) $(18 ,600) $(46 ,400) PBG sha re, based on (349 (627) (858) (1,228) (3,062) population (6 .6%) Obviously, if approved , Amendment 4 could have a sign ificant impact on the City's financ ial forecast. In the absence of additional new revenues , future tax rat es may have to be raised , and/or services may have to be cut. If you have any questions, please let me know . Amendment 4 Provisions Estimated Impacts on Non-School Ad Valorem Taxable Values & Taxes ($Millions) Amendment 4 Contains Three Main Provisions: 1) 11First-time" Homesteader exemption-50% of value phased-out over five years. 2) Non-homestead Assessment Cap -reduced from 10% to 5%. 3) Anti-Recapture for property with an assessment cap -if just value drops, assessed value does not go up; includes both Save Our Homes and Non-Homestead assessment limitations. Note: Only the Save Our Homes Anti-Recapture change affects school taxes. Estimated Taxable Value Impacts ($M) Total 1st time Anti-Recapture* Anti-Recapture* Taxable Value FY Homesteaders 5%NHSCap Homestead Non-Homestead Impacts 2013-14 (3,304.0) (7,545.0) (4,880 .7) (1 ,301.1) {17,030 .8) 2014-15 (5,077.4) (14,881.5) (7,994.5) (3,075.8) (31,029 .3) 2015-16 (7,124.0) (22,299 .5) {10,028.4) (3,783.9) (43,235.8) 2016-17 (9,359.8) (36,803 .7) {12,363.1) (4,660.6) (63,187 .2) * Anti-Recapture Provisions Require legislative implementation Estimated Tax Impacts ($M) Total 1st time Anti-Recapture* Anti-Recapture* Non-School Tax FY Homesteaders 5%NHSCap Homestead Non-Homestead Impacts 2013-14 (35.5) (82.8) (54.6) (14.3) (187.1) 2014-15 (54.6) (163.3) (89.4) (33.8) (341.0) 2015-16 {76.6) (244 .8) (111.9) (41.5) (474.8) 2016-17 (100.7) (404 .0) (137 .3) (51.2) (693.1) 4 Yr. Tot (267.3) (894.9) (393.1) (140.7) (1,696.1) * Anti-Recapture Provisions Require legislative implementation Tax Impacts By Type of Jurisdiction ** Total Non-School Tax FY Counties Cities lndep. Dist. Impacts 2013-14 (112.9) (49.3) (25.0) (187.1) 2014-15 (205.3) (90.2) (45.5) (341.0) 2015-16 (286.0) (125.3) (63.4) (474.8) 2016-17 (417.6) (182.9) (92.7) (693.1} 4 Yr. Tot (1,021.8) (447.7) (226.6) (1,696.1) ** County Level Detail Attached June 13, 2012 Page 1 Prepared by Capital Analytics, LLC Year of Tax Roll Statewide Alachua Baker Bay Bradford Brevard Broward Calhoun Charlotte Citrus Clay Collier Columbia Dade DeSoto Dixie Duval Escambla Flagler Franklin Gadsden Gilchrist Glades Gulf Hamilton Hardee Hendry Hernando Highlands Hillsborough Holmes Indian River Jackson Jefferson Lafayette Lake Lee Leon Levy Liberty Madison Manatee Marion Martin Monroe Nassau Okaloosa Okeechobee Orange Osceola Palm Beach Pasco Pinellas Polk Putnam St. Johns St. Lucie Santa Rosa Sarasota Seminole Sumter Suwannee Taylor Union Vol usia Wakulla Walton Washington ESTIMATED PROPERTY TAX IMPACTS OF CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT 4 ($Millions) Tax Impacts Based on 2011 Average Countywide Millage Rates and Changes in Taxable Value By County TAX IMPACTS ON COUNTIES TAX IMPACTS ON CITIES 2013 2014 2015 2016 Year of Tax Roll 2013 2014 (112.9) (205.3) (286 .0) (417.6) Statewide (49.3) (90.2) (0 .9) (1.4) (1 .9) (2.6) Alachua (0.2) (0.4) (0.0) (0.1) (0.1) (0.1) Baker (0.0) (0.0) (1.0) (1 .7) {2.4) (3.4) Bay (0.2) (0.4) (0.1) (0.1) (0.1) (0.2) Bradford (0.0) (0.0) (1 .1 ) (1 .7) 2 .3 {3.2) Brevard 0 .5) (0 .8} (13.3) (24.1) (33.1) (47.5) Broward {12 .9) (23.4) (0.0) (0.1) (0.1) (0.1) Calhoun (0.0) (0.0) (1 .5) (2.8) (4.1) (6 .2) Charlotte (0.1) (0.2) (0.4) (0.7) (1 .0) (1.5) ~ 1!:.11_ ~1.5~ (2.2) Citrus (0.0) (0.0) clay (0.0) .JQ:.!l.. (3.7) (6.8) (9.6) (14.2) Collier (0.5) (0.9) (0.1) (0.2) (0.3) (0.4) Columbia (0.0) (0.0) (30.1) (56.4) (78.7) (116.3) Dade (16.6) (31.1) (0 .0) (0.1) (0.1) (0.2) DeSoto (0.0) (0.0) (9 .1 0 .2 (0.3} 0 .4) Dixie (0 .0) (0 .()) (7 .3) (13.3) (18.4) (26.0) Duval (0 .3) (0.5) (1 .0) (1 .8) (2.4) (3.4) Escambia (0.1 ) (0.2) (0.3) (0.5) (0.7) (1 .0) Flagler (0.1) (0.2) (0.1) (0.3) (0.4) (0.5) Franklin (0.0) (0.1) ~0.2~ ~ {0.5) (0.7) Gadsden (0.0) ~ (0.1) (0.2) (0 .2) (0.3) Gilchrist (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.1) Glades (0.0) (0.0) (0.1) (0.2) (0.3) (0.4) Gulf (0.0) (0.0) (0.1) (0 .1) (0.1) (0.2) Hamilton (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0 .0) (0.1) (0.1) Hardee (0.0) 0 .0 (0.0) (0.0) (0.1) (0 .1) Hendry (0.0) (0.0) (0.4) (0.8) (1 .2) (2.0) Hernando (0.0) (0.0) (0 .2) (0 .4) (0.5) (0.7) Highlands (0.0) (0.1) (4.9) (9.0) (12.8) (19.2) Hillsborough (1 .2) (2.2) (0 .0) (0.0) (0.0) (0 .1) Holmes (0.0) (0.0) (0 .5) (0.8) (1 .1) (1 .5) Indian River (0.1) (0.1} (0.1) (0.2) (0.2) (0.3) Jackson (0.0) {0 .0) (0.1) (0.1) (0.2) (0.3) Jefferson (0 .0} (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Lafayette (0.0) (0.0) (0.6 1 .0 (1 .3) (2.0) Lake .{9.2) 0.41 (5.4) (10.2) (14.5) (22.0) Lee (2.4) (4.6) (1 .7) (2.9) (4 .0) (5.5) Leon (0.5) (0.9) (0.1) (0.1) (0.1) (0.2) Levy (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.1) (0.1) Liberty (0.0) (0.0) (0.1) ~ (0 .1) (0 .2) (1 .0) (1 .8) (2 .5) (3.7) Madison (0.0) (0 .0) Manatee (0.2) (0.3) (0.5) (0.9) (1 .2) (1 .9) Marlon (0.1) (0.2) (1.5) (2.6) (3.6) (4.9) Martin (0.2) (0.4) (3.0) (5.9) (8.3) (12.7) Monroe (1 .0) (1 .9) 0 .5 (0.8) (1 .1) (1.4) Nassau (0 .1) (0.2) (0.4) {0 .7) (1 .0) (1 .3) Okaloosa (0.2) (0.3) (0.1) (0 .2) (0.3) (0 .5) Okeechobee (0.0) (0.0) (3.7) (6.9) (9.8) (15.0) Orange (1 .2) (2 .2) (0.5) (0.9) (1 .3) {1 .9) Osceola (0.1) (0.1) (10.7) ~ (26.3) ~! (1 .2) (2 .2) (3.2) (4.9) 1~alm Beach (5 .3) (9.5) Pasco (0.1) (0.2) (3.7) (6 .4) (8.9) (12.7) Pinellas (1.9) (3.3) (1 .1) (2.1) (2 .9) (4.4} Polk (0.3) (0.6) (0.7) (1 .3) (1 .8) (2.5) Putnam (0.1) (0.2) (1.2) .(?.0) (2 .7) (3.5) St. Johns 0.1) (0.2) (1 .0) (1 .9) (2.7) (4 .0) St. Lucie (0.4) (0.8) (0.4) (0.6) (0.8) (1 .3) Santa Rosa (0.0) (0.0) (1 .3) (2 .2) (3.1) (4 .5) Sarasota (0.4) (0.7) (1 .1) (1 .8) (2.5) (3.5) Seminole (0.4) (0.6) (0 .3) (0.6) (0.8) ~U? (0.1) (0.1) (0.2) (0.2) Sumter (0.0) (0.0) Suwannee (0.0) (0 .0) (0.1) (0.2) (0.3) (0.4) Taylor (0 .0) (0.0) (0.0) (0 .0) (0.0) (0.0) Union (0.0) (0.0) (1.8) (3.1) (4.4) (6 .5) Vol usia (0 .9) (1 .7) (0.2 (0 .3) (0.5 (0.7) (0.3) (0.5) (0 .6) (0 .9) 1gakuUa (0 .0 0 .0 Walton (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0 .1) (0.1) (0.1) Washington (0 .0 ) (0.0) Page 2 2015 2016 (125.3) (182.9) (0.5) (0 .6) (0.0) (0 .0) (0.6) 0 (0.8) (0.0) (0 .0) (1.1) ~~) (32.2 ) (46.2) (0 .0) (0 .0) (0.2) (0.4) (0.1) (0.1) J.Q:1L (0 .1) (1 .3) (1.9) (0.0) (0.1) (43.4) (64.1) (0.0) (0 .0) (0.0 (~ (0 .6 ) (0 .9) (0.3) (0.4) (0.3) (0.4) (0.1) (0.1) JQ1L ~1) (0.0) (0 .0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.1) (0.0) (0.0) (0 .0) (0 .~) (0 .0) (0.0) (0.1) (0.1) (0.1) (0.1) (3.1) (4.7) (0.0) (0.0) (0.2) (02) (0.0) (0.0) (0 .0) (0.0) (0.0) (0 .0) (0 .5) (0 .8) (6 .6) (10.0) (1 .2) (1 .7) (0.0) (0 .0) (0.0) (0.0) (0 .0) (0 .0) (0 .5) (0.7) (0 .3) (0.5) (0.5) (0.7) (2.7) (4.1) (0.2) (0 .3) (0 .4} (0.6) (0.0) (0.1) (3 .1) (4 .7) (0.2) (0 .2) (13.0) (18.6) (0 .2) (0.4) (4.6) (6.5) (0 .8) (1 .2) (0.3) (0.4) (0.2) (0.3) (1.1) (1 .6) (0.0) (0.1) (0.9) (1.4} (0.8) (1 .2) (0.0) (0.1) (0.0) {0 .0) (0 .0) (0 .0) (0.0) (0.0) (2.4) (3.5) (0.0) {0.0) (0.0) (0 .0) (0 .0) (0 .0) ESTIMATED PROPERTY TAX IMPACTS OF CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT 4 ($Millions) Tax Impacts Based on 2011 Average Countywide Millage Rates and Changes in Taxable Value By County TAX IMPACTS ON SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX IMPACTS ON ALL NON-SCHOOL LOCAL GOVT. Year of Tax Roll 2013 2014 2015 2016 Year of Tax Roll 2013 2014 2015 Statewide (25.0) (45.5) (63.4) (92.7) Statewide (187.1) (341 .0) (474.8) Alachua (0.2) (0.3 ) (0.3) (0.5) Alachua (1.3) (2 .1) (2.8) Baker (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Baker (0.1) (0 .1) (0.1) Bay (0.0) (0.0) {0.1) (0.1) Bay (12) (2.2) (3.0) Bradford (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Bradford (0.1) (0.1) (0.2) Brevard 0 .1 (0.1) (0 .1) (0.2) Brevard 1_1.6) 1 2 .6) {3 .6) Broward (6 .0) (10 .9) {15.0) (21 .6) Broward (32 .2) (58.5) (80.4) Calhoun {0 .0) (0.0) (0 .0) (0 .0) Calhoun (0.0) (0.1) (0 .1 ) Charlotte {0 .1) (0.2) (0.2) (0.4) Charlotte (1.7) (3.2) (4.5) Citrus (0.1) (0.1) (0.1) (0 .2) Citrus (0.5) (0.9) (1.2) l~y (0.7) (1 .2) (1 .7) Collier (5 .2) (9.6) (13.5) Clay i!QL (0.0) (0.1) (0.1) Collier (1.0) (1 .8) (2.6) (3.8) Columbia (0.0) (0.0) (0.1) (0.1} Columbia (0.2) (0.3 ) (0.4) Dade (4.2) (7 .8) (1 0.9) (16.1) Dade (50.9) (95.4) (133.0 ) DeSoto (0 .0} (0 .0) (0.0) (0.0) DeSoto (0.0) (0.1) (0.1) Dixie (O .Ql (0 .0) (0 .0) (0.0) Dixie (9.1) (0.2) (0 .3) Duval (0 .3) (0 .5) (0.7} (1.0) Duval (7.9) (14.2) (19 .7) Escambia (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Escambia (1.2) (2.0) (2.7) Flagler (0 .0) (0.1) (0.1) (0.1) Flagler (0.5) (0.8) (1 .1) Franklin (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0} Franklin (0.2) (0.4) (0.5) Gadsden (0.2) (0.4) ~ Gilchrist (0.1) (0.2) (0 .2) Gadsden i!QL (0 .0) (0.0} (0.0} Gilchrist (0.0) (0.0) lO,'}) (0.0} Glades (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Glades (0.0) (0.0) (0 .0) Gulf (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Gulf (0.1) (0.2) (0.3) Hamilton (0.0) (0.0} (0.0) (0.0) Hamilton (0.1) (0.1) (0.2) 1!iardee (0.0) (0 .1) 0 .1 Hendry (0.0) (0 .1) (0 .1) Hardee 0 .0 (0 .0} (0 .0 ) (0.0) Hendry (0 .0) (0 .0} (0 .0} (0.1) Hernando (0.0) (0.0) (0.1) (0.1) Hernando (0.5) (0 .9) (1 .3 ) High lands (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Highlands (0 .3) (0.5) (0.6) Hillsborough (0.9) (1 .6) (2.2) (3.3) Hillsborough (6.9) (12 .7) (18.2 ) 1~es (O.Q) (0.0) (0 .0) Indian River (0.7) (1.2) (1.6) Holmes (0 .0) (O.D) (0.0) (~~ Indian River (0 .1) (0 .2) (0 .3) (0.4) Jackson (0 .0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Jackson (0.1) (0.2) (0.3) Jefferson (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0 .0) JeffeiSon (0.1) (0.2) (0.2) Lafayette (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Lafayette (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) 1~1te J 1 .0) (1 .6) l2 2) Lee (10.7) (20.3) (28.9 ) ~e (0 .2) (0 .3) (0.4} (fM } Lee (2 .9) (5 .5} (7 .9} (12.0) Leon (0 .0) (0 .0) (0.0} (0.0) Leon (2.2) (3.8) (5.2 ) Levy (0.0) (0.0) (0.0} (0.0} Levy (0.1) (0 .1) (0.2) Liberty (0.0) (0.0) (0.0} (0 .0} Liberty (0.0) (0 .1) (0 .1) Madison (0 .1) (0 .1) (0 .2) Manatee (1.4) (2.4) (3 .3) Madison (0.0) (0 .0) (0.0) (0 .0) Manatee (0.1) (0.3) (0 .4) (0 .5) Marion (0.0) (0 .1) (0.1) (0.1) Marlon (0.7) (1.1) (1 .6) Martin (0.2) (0 .3} (0.4) (0.5) Martin (1 .9) (3.3) (4.4) Monroe (0.7) (1 .4) (2 .0) (3.1) Monroe (4.8) (9.2) (13.1) Nassau (O .OJ (0 .1) (0 .1) (0.1) Nassau (0.6) (1 .0) (1 .'!) Okaloosa (0 .1) (0 .2 ) (0 .3) (0.4) Okaloosa (0 .7) (1 .3) (1 .7 ) Okeechobee (0 .0) (0 .0 ) (0.0) (0.0) Okeechobee (0 .1 ) (0 .2) (0.4) Orange (0.4) (0 .8) (1.1) (1 .6) Orange (5 .3) (9.8) (1 4 .0) Osceola (0.0) (0.0) (0.1) (0 .1) Osceola (0.6 ) (1 .0) (1 .5) Palm Beach (4 .0) (7.1) (9.8) (13.9) Palm Beach (19.9) (35.8 {49.1 ) Pas. co--(0.1) (0 .2) (0.2} (0.4) Pasco (1.4) (2 .5 ) (3 .7) Pinellas (1 .2) (2.1) {2.9) (4.1} Pinellas (6.7) (11 .8) (16.5) Polk (0.1) (0.2) (0.2) (0.4) Polk (1 .6) (2.8) (3.9) Putnam (0 .0) (0 .0) (0.1) (0.1) Putnam (0 .8) (1 .5) (2.1) St. Johns (0 .1) (0.2) (0.2) (0.3) St. Johns (1.4) (2 .4) (3.1 St. Lucie (0.5) (0 .8) (1 .2) (1 .8) St. Lucie (1 .9) (3.5) (5 .0) Santa Rosa (0.0) (0 .0) {0 .0) (0.1) Santa Rosa (0.4) (0.7) (0.9) Sarasota (0.5) (0.8) (1 .2) (1.7) Sarasota (2.1) (3.7) (5.3 ) Seminole (0.1) (0.1) (0.1) {0 .2) Seminole (1 .5 ) (2.5) (3.4) Sumter (0 .4) (0.6) (0 .9) Suwannee (0.1) .?.) (0 .2) Sumter (0.0) (0 .0 ) (0 .1) (0.1) Suwannee (0 .0) (0.0) (0 .0) (0.0) Taylor (0 .0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Taylor (0.1) (0.2) (0.3) Union (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Union (0.0) (0.0) (0.0) Volusla (0.6) (1 .0) (1.4) (2.1) Volusia (3.3) (5.8) (8.2) Wakulla 0 .2 (Q.4) (0.5) Walton (0.3) (0 .6) (0.8) ,~a (O .Ol (0.0) (0 .0 ) (0.0} Walton (0.1) (0 .1) (0.2) (0.2} Washington (0 .0) (0.0) (0 .0) (0.0) Washington (0.0) (0.1) (0 .1 ) Page3 2016 (693.1) (3.7) (0.2) (4.3) (0.2) (4.8) (115.3) (0.1) (6.9 ) (1 .8) (2.4} (20.0) (0.6) (196 .5 ) (0.2 ) (0.4) (27.9) (3 .8) (1 .6) (0 .7) (0.8 ) (0.3) (0.1 ) (0.5 ) (0.3) ~) (0.1) (2.1) (0.9) (27.2) (0 .1) (2.2) (0.4) (0.3 ) (0.0 ) (3.3 ) (44.0) (7.2) (0.2) (0.1) (0.2) (4.9 ) (2 .4 } (6.1) (20 .0) (1.8) (2 .3) (0.6 ) (21 .3) (2 .3) (70.1) (5.6 ) (23.4) (6.0) (3.0 ) (4.1) (7.5) (1.4) (7.5) (4.9} (1.3) (0.2) (0.5 ) (0.0) (12.1 ) (0.7) (1 .1) (0.1) Amendment 4 on 2012 General Election Ballot (HJR 381-2011) Methodology for Estimating County-by-County Impacts on Non-School Taxes 1. Impact of Changing Non-Homestead Assessment Cap to 5% from 10% a. Start with State Revenue Estimating Conference's Official Impact Estimates on non-school property taxes ($millions). I ·2013[ --20141 --· -2(l15j 2016 . (82.3)1 (162.2)1 (243.0)_ (401.2)1 b. Calculate each county's share of current law non-homestead differential at 10%. c. Use current law shares of 10% cap to allocate taxable value impacts to each county, with the total taxable value reduction equivalent to the estimated reduction in non-school property taxes, based on 2011 aggregate millage rates. d. For each county, apply weighted-average (aggregate) millage rates to each county's share of the taxable value impact. This was done separately for county, municipal and independent special district levies using the 2011 aggregate millage rates. e. Total county-wide non-school impacts are the sum of the non-school jurisdictions' impacts within that county. Similarly, statewide totals were calculated by type of jurisdiction and for all non- schoollevies. 2. Impact of Anti-Recapture -Non-Homestead Properties Only a. Start with official state estimate. 2013 : 2014 . b. Same steps as above. (14.2)1 (33.5)1 3. Impact of Anti-Recapture-Homestead Properties Only a. Start with official state estimate. I 2013 (53 .2)[ b. Each county's share of the current Save Our Homes 2015 2016 (41.2)1 (50.8)1 2014 1 2015 (87.1)1 (109.3)1 differential was used to allocate a statewide taxable value reduction equivalent to the state's estimated tax impact based on 2011 aggregate tax rates. 2016 1 (134.8)1 c. Estimates by county and by type of jurisdiction were based on countywide taxable value impacts and the appropriate aggregate millage rates from 2011. Note: Only non -sc hool impacts are shown. This is the only Amendment 4 provision which will affect school taxes. SCHOOL PROPERTY TAX IMPACTS NOT INCLUDED in NON-SCHOOL IMPACTS. 4. Impact of First-Time Homebuyers 2015 2016 a. Start with official state estimate. (36.0) (55.3) (n.7) (102.0) b. Original estimates of taxable value impacts for the First-Time Homebuyers were based on county- specific new homestead counts and median home values by county. Those shares of the total taxable value estimate were used to allocate the taxable value equivalent to the newest statewide tax impact to individual counties. c. Estimates by county and by type of jurisdiction were based on countywide taxable value impacts and the appropriate aggregate millage rates for each county from 2011. August 29, 2012 Amendment 4 Impact Methodology League ofWomen Voters against all Fla. amendments-09/26/20121 MiamiHerald.com Page 1 of 1 ~ht BiamiHttalb m· Posted on Wed , Sep. 26, 2012 League of Women Voters against all Fla. amendments The Associated Press The League of Women Voters of Florida opposes all 11 proposed state constitutional amendments on the Nov. 6 ballot. League officials announced their opposition Wednesday to the amendments, all offered by the Republican-led Florida Legislature . ... The organization notes that five amendments -numbers 2, 4, 9, 10 and 11 -would cut local property taxes by more than $1 billion in the first three years , likely forcing cuts in education , transportation, public safety and other services. Amendment 3 would limit state revenues . The league has a longstanding policy of opposing limitations on tax sources or revenues in the constitution. It also contends Amendment 8 could cut public school funding by lifting a ban on state aid to religious organizations including parochial schools . © 2012 Miami Herald Media Company. All Rights Reserved . http ://www.miamiherald.com http:/ /www.miamiherald.com/20 12/09/26/v-print/3 022272/league-of-women-voters-agains... 10/3/2012 League of Women Voters of Florida • 2012 Constitutional Amendments Page 1 of3 GET INVOLVED Join our online community .. lsiQn uj)J Find a Local League 1 Contact your elected officials IJ Face book D Twitter 0 You Tube ~Vamos A Votar WHERE lHE lEAGUE STANDS ON lHE 2012 CONSliMIONAI.AMENDMENTS The titles of the amendments below are those that voters will actually see on the ballot this November; the League opposes all 11 amendments. These amendments were all placed on the ballot by the Florida Leg islature and, if approved, would become part of the Florida Constitution . There are five amendments on the ballot that address reductions in local property taxes. If all five (2, 4, 9, 10, 11) were to pass, local governments would lose over $1 billion over the first three years of implementation . In addition to concerns that this lost revenue could result in cuts to essential services, such as education, transportation and public safety, the League's position has always been that no tax sources or revenues should be specified, limited, exempted or prohibited in the Constitution. It is important to note that this information only applies to state amendments; accordingly, voters should be aware of amendments to their respective local, county or city governing structures. t Heanh care Services This amendment would allow Florida to opt out of federal health care reform (i.e. the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act). THE LEAGUE OPPOSES THIS AMENDMENT . Florida has the second highest rate of uninsured citizens in the United States. The League of Women Voters of Florida supports the implementation of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act in Florida, emphasizing access for all and control of costs. In addition, Amendment 1, if passed, could conflict with federal law and thus be deemed unconstitutional. 2. Veterans Disabled Due to combat lniurv; Homestead Prooenv Tax Discount This amendment expands the homestead exemption to disabled veterans who were not Florida residents when they entered military service. THE LEAGUE OPPOSES THIS AMENDMENT. The League of Women Voters of Florida position is that there should be no increase or extension of homestead exemption. Also, as mentioned above on the introduction, our position states that no tax sources or revenues should be specified, limited, exempted, or prohibited in the Constitution . This amendment, if passed, would cost local governments $15 million over the first three years of implementation. 3. State Government Revenue limitation This amendment replaces the existing state revenue limitation based on Florida personal income growth with a new state revenue limitation based on inflation and population changes. THE LEAGUE OPPOSES THIS AMENDMENT. The League of Women Voters of Florida believes that the state of Florida has an infrastructure deficit, and that state service levels and the quality of life are declining. Because the long-term goals of the state comprehensive plan were designed to reverse decline in levels of service and improve the quality of life, League members find these goals are generally desirable and worth working toward. LWVF has been speaking out against this amendment for several sessions of the legislature and during the 2008 Tax and Budget Reform Commission (where the amendment was defeated). This legislation was passed in Colorado in 1992, and has negatively affected the state's ability to fund essential public services such as health care, transportation and education. For more information about Amendment 3's impact on state government services, please read the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities' report on the topic~. 4. Prooenv Tax limitation; Prooenv Value Decline; Reduction for Non .. Homestead Assessment Increases; Delav of Scheduled Repeal http://www.thefloridavoter.org/resources/issues/2012-constitutional-amendments 10/3/2012 League of Women Voters of Florida • 2012 Constitutional Amendments Page 2 of3 This amendment would reduce the annual growth in assessment limitation on certain non-homestead property from 10% to 5%. It would prohibit increases in the assessed value of homestead property and certain non-homestead property when the market value of the property decreases. It also gives first time homesteaders an additional exemption equal to 50% of the median just value of the property ; this exemption diminishes to zero over a five year period . This amendment would also give out-of-state residents the benefit of the homestead tax exemption . THE LEAGUE OPPOSES THIS AMENDMENT FOR THE SAME REASONS STATED FOR OPPOSING AMENDMENT 2. Amendment 4, if passed , would cost local governments $1 billion over the first three years of implementation. For more information about Amendment 4's impact on local government services, please read the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities' report on the topic~. 5. State Coons This amendment adds a requirement that Supreme Court justices appointed by the Governor must also be confirmed by the Senate in order to take office. It also authorizes the repeal of a court rule by a simple majority of the legislature instead of the 2/3 majority now required. The amendment also would allow the House of Representatives to review all files of the Judicial Qualifications Commission without regard to whether the request is specifically related to impeachment considerations. THE LEAGUE OPPOSES THIS AMENDMENT. The League believes that the Governor should be able to appoint judges from a group of nominees selected by a panel or commission composed of members of the Florida Bar and lay members, and that judges should be retained in office by means of periodic review through an election in which a judge would run unopposed and solely on his/her record. The League also believes an independent judiciary is essential to the balance of power, and feels that this amendment weakens the judiciary in favor of the legislative branch. &. Prohibition on Public Funding of Abortions: Construction of Abortion Rights Federal law prohibits the expenditure of federal funds for most abortions; this amendment would enshrine those proh ibitions in the state Constitution . There is another provision in the amendment that would stop the use of the state Constitution's privacy clause in abortion cases; courts would no longer be able to use the clause in defending abortion rights. THE LEAGUE OPPOSES THIS AMENDMENT. The League believes that public policy in a pluralistic society must affirm the constitutional right of privacy of the individual to make reproductive choices. 8. Religious Freedom This amendment would repeal a 126-year-old provision in the state Constitution that prohibits taxpayer funding of religious institutions. If passed, the amendment would allow the state to use taxpayer monies to fund religious institutions and schools. THE LEAGUE OPPOSES THIS AMENDMENT. The League supports adequate funding of public education w ith no use of public funding for the expansion or funding of private education through a voucher program . LWVF supports a free public school system with high standards for student achievement and with equality of educational opportunity for all that is financed adequately by the state through an equitable funding formula. 9. Homestead Propenv Tax Exemption lor surviving Spouse of Militarv Veteran or First Responder This amendment grants full homestead property tax relief to the surviving spouses of military veterans and first responders killed in the line of duty. The deceased must have been a permanent resident of Florida as of January 1 of the year they died. THE LEAGUE OPPOSES THIS AMENDMENT FOR THE SAME REASONS STATED FOR OPPOSING AMENDMENT 2. Amendment 9, if passed, would cost local governments $1 .8 millio n over the first three years of implementation. 10. Tangible Personal Propenv Tax Exemption This amendment affects businesses only and pertains to equipment or furniture used in a business. Under current law, the first $25,000 of tangible personal property is exempt from taxation ; this amendment will raise that exemption to $50,000. Cities and counties will be able to grant additional exemptions. THE LEAGUE OPPOSES THIS AMENDMENT FOR THE SAME REASONS STATED FOR OPPOSING AMENDMENT 2. If passed, this amendment would cost local governments $61 million over the first three years of implementation. http://www.thefloridavoter.org/resources/issues/2012-constitutional-amendments 10/3/2012 Leagu e of Women Voters of F lorida • 2012 Constitutional Amendments Page 3 of3 n Additional Homestead Exemption lor low-Income seniors who Maintain long-Term Residencv on Propertv; Equal to Assessed Value This amendment grants full homestead property tax relief to low-income seniors who have lived in their home for at least 25 years . THE LEAGUE OPPOSES THIS AMENDMENT FOR THE SAME REASONS STATED FOR OPPOSING AMENDMENT 2. Amendment 11 , if passed and enacted un iversally throughout the state, would cost local governments $27.8 million over the first three years of im ple mentat ion . 12. Appointment ol Student Bodv President to Board ol Governors ol the State Universitv Svstem The State University System is governed by a 17-member Board of Governors. Currently, the president of the Florida Student Association is a member of the board . Th is amendment would create a new council composed of student body presid ents, and the chair of that council would replace the current FSA representative on the Board of Governors. THE LEAGUE OPPOSES THIS AME NDM ENT . The League believes that the Constitution should be a simple, understandable and integrated statement of basic law, free from obsolete and statutory detail . http://www. thefloridavoter .org/resources/issues/20 12-constitutional-amendments 10/3/20 12 1 RESOLUTION 93, 2012 2 3 4 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM 5 BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA CONCERNING AMENDMENT 4 TO 6 THE FLORIDA CONSTITUTION WHICH, IF ADOPTED, WOULD 7 CREATE ADDITIONAL INEQUITIES IN FLORIDA'S TAX SYSTEM 8 BY GRANTING CERTAIN TAX BREAKS TO SOME TAXPAYERS AT 9 THE EXPENSE OF OTHER TAXPAYERS; PROVIDING AN 10 EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. 11 12 13 WHEREAS, a proposed constitutional amendment sponsored by the Florida 14 Legislature will be placed on the 2012 general election ballot as "Amendment 4"; and 15 16 WHEREAS, this proposed constitutional change reduces the current assessment 17 limitation on non-homestead real property from 10 percent to 5 percent; and 18 19 WHEREAS, the proposed amendment grants first-time homesteaders an 20 additional homestead exemption equal to 50 percent of the just value of the property up 21 to the county median home value; and 22 23 WHEREAS, the proposed amendment creates a prov1s1on that allows the 24 Legislature by general law to prohibit increases in the assessed value of homestead 25 property if the just value of the property decreases; and 26 27 WHEREAS, Amendment 4 creates inequities for non-homestead properties by 28 allowing identical properties to be taxed differently, and Amendment 4 extends the 29 sunset provision already in the Florida Constitution from 2019 to 2023, which allows 30 these inequities to be in place longer; and 31 32 WHEREAS, Amendment 4 shifts the tax burden to new or growing businesses, 33 creating an unfair disadvantage for new businesses that would have to pay higher 34 property taxes than their more established counterparts; and 35 36 WHEREAS, the non-homestead assessment cap reduction and the first-time 37 homesteader provision apply to city and county taxes and not to property taxes 38 assessed for public schools; and 39 40 WHEREAS, over the last few years, several property tax initiatives, including 41 additional homestead exemptions, Save Our Homes portability , and statutory millage 42 caps, have also contributed to the unequal treatment of Florida's taxpayers; and 43 44 WHEREAS, there are estimates of the total tax impact of Amendment 4 of $1.6 45 billion cumulatively over a four-year period beginning in 2013-2014, with approximately 46 $447 million borne by the municipalities; and Page 1 of 3 Resolution 93, 2012 1 WHEREAS, the City Council deems approval of this Resolution to be in the best 2 interests of the health, safety, and welfare of the residents and citizens of the City of 3 Palm Beach Gardens and the public at large. 4 5 6 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY 7 OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA that: 8 9 SECTION 1. The foregoing recitals are hereby affirmed and ratified. 10 11 SECTION 2. The City Council of the City of Palm Beach Gardens will evaluate 12 the impact Amendment 4 may have on its property taxes. 13 14 SECTION 3. The City Council of the City of Palm Beach Gardens urges its 15 residents to carefully consider the potential adverse consequences of Amendment 4 16 before voting in the November 2012 general election. 17 18 SECTION 4. A copy of this Resolution shall be provided to the Florida League of 19 Cities, Inc . and other interested parties . 20 21 SECTION 5. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon adoption. 22 23 24 (The remainder of this page intentionally left blank) 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 Page 2 of 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 Resolution 93, 2012 PASSED AND ADOPTED this __ day of--------' 2012. CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA BY: ---------=---------------------David Levy, Mayor ATTEST: BY: --~-----------------------Patricia Snider, CMC, City Clerk APPROVEDASTOFORMAND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY BY: ---------------------------R. Max Lohman, City Attorney VOTE: AYE NAY ABSENT MAYOR LEVY VICE MAYOR PREMUROSO COUNCILMEMBER TINSLEY COUNCILMEMBER RUSSO COUNCILMEMBER JABLIN G:\attorney_share\RESOLUTIONS\2012\Resolution 93 2012-amendment4resolutionforcities-final2.docx Page 3 of 3 ----------------------------------------------------------------, Page 1 of3 http:/ /www2. tbo.com/news/politics/20 12/oct/0 1 /namaino 1-opponents-of-amendment-4-say -tax -breaks- w-ar-518238/ Tampa Bay On line Published: October 01 , 2012 Home I news I local I govt politics I Amendment 4 foes: Tax breaks mean unintended consequences By JEROME R. STOCKFISCH Voters will revisit one of the Florida Legislature's pet pocketbook issues in November, with nearly half of the proposed constitutional amendments on the ballot addressing property tax breaks. Five of the 11 amendments going before voters on Nov. 6 call for property tax exemptions that would give new breaks to first-time buyers, second-home owners, those whose homes' market values have dropped, certain individuals and small businesses. In Florida, lowering their own taxes has been a no-brainer for voters. But cities and counties that have to provide services with dwindling revenues are urging voters to consider the consequences. The most ambitious of the proposals, Amendment 4, would cut about $1.7 billion from local revenues statewide over the next four years. Counties alone already have cut spending by $3 billion since 2007, according to the Florida Association of Counties. "The biggest issue is that it (Amendment 4) takes a very complex property tax system and makes it even more complicated," said Amber Hughes, a legislative advocate for the Florida League of Cities. "It picks winners and losers. We need a fair system, and this is not that." Amendment 4 has the muscle of the Florida Association of Realtors behind it. The group has poured $3 million into a humorous "Tax Your Assets Off' ad campaign. Current law caps annual assessment increases on non-homestead property -typically Floridians' second homes or those used by winter visitors from out of state -at 1 0 percent. The amendment would reduce that to 5 percent. Amendment 4 also provides first -time homebuyers who now receive a $50,000 homestead exemption an additional exemption ofhalfthe appraised value of the new home, up to $150,000. That benefit is phased out over five years. http:/ /www2. tbo.cornlmember-center/share-this/print/?content=ar51823 8 10/112012 Page 2 of3 And it eliminates the "recapture rule" that has allowed taxes to rise on homes whose market value decreased. Sen. Mike Fasano, a Republican from New Port Richey who was one of the sponsors of Amendment 4, said the proposal goes beyond a one-off property tax break. "I'm a big believer in that the success of turning our economy around here in Florida will have a lot to do with our housing and real estate markets," Fasano said. "The building industry just contributes so much to our economy." Florida Tax Watch, a Tallahassee watchdog group, estimated that Amendment 4 would create more than 19,000 jobs, increase gross domestic product by $1.1 billion, and boost personal income by $5.3 billion in 10 years. But Florida Association of Counties spokeswoman Cragin Mosteller said her group is particularly troubled by the break for second-home owners, which makes up the biggest chunk of the amendment's budgetary impact. She called the amendment a cost-shift to year-round residents. "We're being sold a tax cut, but it's just a tax shift," she said. "Year-round residents have a lower tax burden, so if you lower the tax burden of our snowbirds, think about that seesaw. Year-round residents' taxes have nowhere to go but up." The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities in Washington, D.C., concluded that the "deeply flawed set of property tax changes" included in Amendment 4 would lead to tax increases for large numbers of Floridians, a competitive disadvantage for new and emerging businesses, and significant cuts in local services "while producing little if any economic benefit." Amendment 4 would likely cut $6.8 million to $8.8 million from Hillsborough County coffers next year, according to a county estimate. That might not necessarily mean a tax increase -an unpalatable move for elected officials -but it would most likely bring another round of cutbacks. The county faced a $15 million shortfall this year, and $65 million last year. It has laid off 1,600 employees since 2007. "We would look at other potential reductions," said Tom Fesler, the county's budget director, noting that the county's parks and social service agencies have been particularly hard-hit. Also appearing on the Nov. 6 ballot are Amendment 2, which would provide property tax relief to disabled veterans; Amendment 9, offering a break for surviving spouses of veterans or first responders killed in the line of duty; Amendment 10, which boosts the exemption on tangible personal property from $25,000 to $50,000; and Amendment 11, providing property tax relief for low-income senior citizens. There were two amendments calling for homestead or other property tax exemptions in 2006, one in 2008, three more by a state budget commission that same year, and one more in 2010 -and voters passed every one. "For the last few election cycles, voters have voted in favor of their pockets," said Tony Carvajal, chief operations officer at the Collins Center for Public Policy, a neutral group that is educating voters about the amendments. "I think voters look at homestead exemptions as something that is about reducing their http:/ /www2. tbo.com/member-center/share-this/print/?content=ar51823 8 10/112012 Page 3 of3 taxes. I don't think they fully consider the consequences to local government." www2.tbo.com ©Copyright 2012 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General company. http://www2.tbo.com/member-center/share-this/print/?content=ar518238 10/112012 Greenacres opposes ballot question that would create ... I www.palmbeachpost.com Follow us on Wednesday, Oct . 3, 2012 18:19 a.m. Subscribe now I Digital edition Hi, (not you?) I Member Center 1 Sign Out Sign In or Register Breaking news starts here ·~ Site e Web Web Search by YAHOO! Posted : 8 :22p.m . Monday , Oct. 1, 2012 Search Page 1 of3 Greenacres opposes ballot question that would create additional property tax breaks By Willie Howard Palm Beach Post Staff Writer GREENACRES-Fearing more reductions in property tax revenue following the housing bust, the city council passed a resolution Monday opposing Amendment 4, the statewide constitutional amendment that would create additional property tax breaks. One of 11 state constitutional amendments on the Nov. 6 ballot, Amendment 4 would reduce revenue to Florida cities by an estimated $44 7 million over four years beginning in the 2013-14 budget year, according to the Florida League of Cities. The amendment would create property tax exemptions for first-time home buyers, further limit assessment increases on nonhomesteaded property such as second homes and give state legislators the power to prohibit increases in assessed value if the market value of a property falls. The Realtors Association of the Palm Beaches supports the amendment, saying it will boost sales of vacant properties and create jobs. For Greenacres, Amendment 4 would further aggravate budget woes created by low property values that accompanied the real estate bust, City Manager Wadie Atallah said. "Any additional property tax reduction will necessitate a discussion of what services we provide," Atallah said. The total taxable value of property in the city has fallen 47 percent since 2008, to $1.14 billion this year. The amount the city collects from Greenacres property owners has fallen 37 percent , to $6.2 million, since 2008 . Atallah said it's impossible to estimate the impact of Amendment 4 on the city's budget because it's impossible to tell, for instance , how many people would take advantage of first-time home buyer tax breaks. Deputy Mayor Peter Noble said property tax breaks created by Amendment 4 could force the city to raise its tax rate, increasing the tax burden on property owners who don't benefit from the exemptions. http://www. palmbeachpost.com/news/news/local/ greenacres-opposes-ballot -question-that-... 10/3/2012 Greenacres opposes ballot question that would create ... I www.palmbeachpost.com Page 2 of3 "It could affect us all ," Noble said . Other Palm Beach County cities plan to adopt similar resolutions opposing Amendment 4, said Richard Radcliffe , executive director of the Palm Beach County League of Cities. Passage of Amendment 4 could force cities to cut back on essential services such as law enforcement, Radcliffe said. "It could really set cities back," he said . More News We Recommend From Around the Web • Police ID West Palm Beach man , 24, who died in Greenacres crash (PalmBeachPost.com) • North police blotter: Woman's 'missing' vehicle found in neighbor's parking spot (PalmBeachPost.com) • Police believe they found missing teen's remains (PalmBeachPost.com) • One dead in multi-vehicle crash in suburban West Palm; Military Trail shut down near Melaleuca Lane (PalmBeachPost.com) • Nude photos prompt blackmail probe in Boynton Beach (PalmBeachPost.com) • Supreme Court weighs whether activist Lozman's houseboat in Riviera Beach was a vessel (Palm BeachPost.com) Comments If you would like to post a comment please Sign in or Register 3 Comment(s) Comment(s) 1-3 of 3 .. ,.-----.,..-------, ... [ Cancel Jl Edit cornment J • Posted by Ralphyboy at 9:21 p.m. Oct. 1, 2012 • Report Abuse • How Liberal are you? This quiz will tell you . (PATCH) • Best seat on the plane is 6A (Fox News) • 8 Surefire Ways to Demotivate Your Employees (NFI B) • Man Accused of Killing Girlfriend After She Told Him She Had HIV-Do You Blame Him? (MamasLatinas) • 102-Year-Oid Woman Still Drives Her 82-Year- Oid Car (AOL Autos) • The Most-Spoiled Chi ldren in the U .S. Live in ... (Women& Co.) [?] When your family or mine has a reduction in income, due to job loss, reduction in hours, illness, or some other reason, we are forced to reduce our expenditures. WHY DOESN'T THIS APPLY TO GOVERNMENT????? • Posted by jaccam at 10:33 p.m. Oct. 1, 2012 • Report Abuse We don't get rid of services. You get rid of the salaries and entitlements . Plain and simple. It called elementary math, If the taxpayers lose their homes so do you. • Posted by willinthevow at 7:37a.m. Oct. 2, 2012 • Report Abuse http://www. palmbeachpost.com/news/news/locall greenacres-opposes-ballot -question-that-... 10/3/2012 SrQA:r .. eL.' 7: ~ b'l\o/.d.' 9.' Y7 CI1Y OF PALM BEACH GARDENS COUNCIL AGENDA October 11, 2012 7:00P.M. Mayor Levy -~eive.J.. "7.' ~.s­ Vice Mayor Premuroso Council Member Tinsley Council Member Russo Council Member Jablin I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL ill. ADDITIONS, DELETIONS, MODIFICATIONS: IV ANNOUNCEMENTS I PRESENTATIONS: a. PRESENTATION OF THE GFOA -GOVERNMENT FINANCE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION BUDGET AWARD. V. ITEMS OF RESIDENT INTEREST AND BOARD/COMMITTEE REPORTS: VI. CI1Y MANAGER REPORT: VII. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC: (For Items Not on the Agenda, please submit request form to the City Clerk prior to this Item) VIII. CONSENT AGENDA: a. (Page 3) APPROVE MINUTES FROM SEPTEMBER 13, 2012 CITY COUNCIL MEETING. b. (Page 10) APPROVE MINUTES FROM SEPTEMBER 20,2012 CITY COUNCIL MEETING c. (Staff Report on Page 13, Resolution on Page 19) RESOLUTION 84, 2012 - APPROVING AN AGREEMENT FOR ECONOMIC EVELOPMENT INCENTIVES WITH TBC CORPORATION. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE AN ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT INCENTIVES AGREEMENT WITH TBC-TIRE & BATTERY CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. IX. PUBLIC HEARINGS: <* Designates Quasi-.Judkial Hearing) a. *(Staff Report on Page 31, Resolution on Page 63) RESOLUTION 78, 2012- PGA COMMONS PARCEL 2 PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT AMENDMENT. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING AN AMENDMENT TO THE PGA COMMONS PARCEL 2 PlANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT (PUD) TO ALLOW MODIFICATIONS TO THE APPROVED SITE PLAN , SPECIFICALLY RELATED TO ACCENT LIGHTING, AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN; PROVIDING WAIVERS; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. X. RESOLUTIONS: a. b. c. d. (Staff Report on Page 67, Resolution on Page 69) RESOLUTION 89, 2012- APPOINT MEMBERS TO THE ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD. A RESOLUTION OF THE CllY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING THE APPOINTMENT OF REGULAR AND ALTERNATE MEMBERS TO THE ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. (Staff Report on Page 84, Resolution on Page 86) RESOLUTION 90, 2012- APPOINT MEMBERS TO THE RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD. A RESOLUTION OF THE CllY COUNCIL OF THE CllY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING THE APPOINTMENT OF REGULAR AND ALTERNATE MEMBERS TO THE PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. (Staff Report on Page 113, Resolution on Page 116) RESOLUTION 91, 2012 -APPOINT MEMBERS TO THE PLANNING ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD. A RESOLUTION OF THE CllY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA APPROVING THE APPOINTMENT OF REGULAR AND ALTERNATE MEMBERS TO THE PLANNING, ZONING, AND APPEALS BOARD; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. (Memo on Page 167, Resolution on Page 178) RESOLUTION 93, 2012 - AMENDMENT 4 TO THE FLORIDA CONSTITUTION. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA CONCERNING AMENDMENT 4 TO THE FLORIDA CONSTITUTION WHICH, IF ADOPTED, WOULD CREATE ADDITIONAL INEQUITIES IN FLORIDA'S TAX SYSTEM BY GRANTING CERTAIN TAX BREAKS TO SOME TAXPAYERS AT THE EXPENSE OF OTHER TAXPAYERS; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. XI. ITEMS FOR COUNCIL ACTION/DISCUSSION: XII. CITY A TIORNEY REPORT: XID. ADJOURNMENT PLEASE TAKE NOTICE AND BE ADVISED that if any interested party wishes to appeal any decision made by the Qty Cmttreil with respect to any matter considered at this public hearing, such interested persons will need a record of the proceedings and may need to ensure that a verbatim record is made, including the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Ad and Section 286.26, Florida Statutes, persons with disabilities IU!eding specioJ accoiiUIWflations in order to parlicipate in this proceeding are entitled to the provision of certain assistance at no cost Please call the City Qerk's Office at 561-799-4122 no later than 5 doys prior to the hearing if this assistance is required For hearing impaired assisttuu:e, please call the Florida Relay Service Numbers: 800-955-8771 (TDD) or 800-955-8770 (VOICE). NOTE: All presentation materials must be received by the City Clerk prior to the presentation to the Council. Please Print Comments From The Public Request to Address City Council Name: ~}~~/i __ ~-~~~~O~L ____________________________ _ Address: .....~.)_'0~~---'~____;;_S:...L....;; ~=----~--~>.--=C...:...:tr/t-'---C.V..::....__ ___________ _ City: f5C Subject: Members of the public may address the City Council during the "Comments by the Public" Portion of the agenda and during "Public Hearings". This Request to Address the City Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting. The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes. Please Print Name: Address: City: Subject: ------------- Comments From The Public Request to Address City Council Members of the public may address the City Council during the "Comments by the Public" Portion of the agenda and during "Public Hearings". This Request to Address the City Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting. The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes. Please Print Name: Address: City: Subject: Comments From The Public Request to Address City Council Members of the public may address the City Council during the "Comments by the Public" Portion of the agenda and during "Public Hearings". This Request to Address the City Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting. The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes. Please Print Name: Address: City: Subject: Comments From The Public Request to Address City Council k:-?_r.J I A! tAm~ I 2~11 . Yo t-l \fp\_ 1.1 .f, 6 G. f?uJ,I,t. LfJ tHk4~NtJ Members of the public may address the City Council during the "Comments by the Public" Portion of the agenda and during "Public Hearings". This Request to Address the City Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting. The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes. Please Print Name: Address: City: Subject: ?r)/( Comments From The Public Request to Address City Council Members of the public may address the City Council during the "Comments by the Public" Portion of the agenda and during "Public Hearings". This Request to Address the City Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting. The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes. Jo}t•J•~ e."ttf ~~· ~ ~'tL. tk.l•·1 '8Cf ~ lu't·@ Tonight we are holding quasi-judicial hearings on the following cases • *RESOLUTION 78, 2012 -PGA COMMONS PARCEL 2 PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT AMENDMENT This means that the City Council is required by law to base its decision on the evidence contained in the record of this proceeding, which consists of the testimony at the hearing, the materials w~ich are in the official City file on this application and any documents presented during this hearing. The Council is also required by law to allow cross-examination of any witnesses who testify tonight. Cross- examination may occur after the staff, the applicant and other participants have made their presentations and will be permitted in the order of the witnesses' appearance. It is necessary that anyone who testifies at the hearing remain until the conclusion of the hearing in order to be able to respond to any questions. If you plan to testify this evening, or wish to offer written comments, please fill out a card and give it to the City Clerk. The City Clerk will now swear in all persons who intend to offer testimony this evening on any of these cases.