Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda AIPP 111505• AGENDA CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 15, 2005, AT 5:30 P.M. COUNCIL CHAMBERS I. CALL TO ORDER II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE III. ROLL CALL: • ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD Regular Members Lee Bickford Diane Cappella Myra Davis Ellen Dukes (Vice Chair) William Leizman Linda Oliver (Chair) Marilyn Spungin Alternates Theodore Thoburn (1St Alt.) Georgia Heard O'Brien (2 "d Alt.) Also in attendance: Kara Irwin, Planning Manager Nina Nikolova, Planner /Staff Liaison Amy Stepper, Alternate Staff Liaison IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. September 20, 2005 2. October 18, 2005 V. OLD BUSINESS 1. Borland Center - Recommendation to City Council 2. Donald Ross Village - Recommendation to City Council 3. Art Ordinance - Status update VI. NEW BUSINESS VII. ADJOURNMENT • • • CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD Agenda Cover Memorandum Date Prepared: November 7, 2005 Meeting Date: November 15, 2005 Petition AIPP- 05 -09- 000005 SUBJECT /AGENDA ITEM Petition AIPP- 05 -09- 000005: Art in Public Places — Midtown PUD Recommendation to City Council: A request by Lucy Keshavarz on behalf of the Borland Center Owners Association Inc., for the consideration for approval of the proposed Art in Public Places for the non - residential portion of the Midtown Planned Unit Development (PUD) (f.k.a. Borland Center PUD). The Midtown PUD, approved by Resolution 92, 2004, is located along the north side of PGA Boulevard between Gardens Square Boulevard and Shady Lakes Drive. Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: FINANCE: N/A AIPP Advisory Board Growth Management: Action: City Attorney N/A Project Costs: $ N/A [ ] Approved Christine Tatum Manager- g er Total A [ ] pP• w/ conditions Kara L. Irwin [ ] Denied Finance N/A Planning Manager $ N/A [ ] Rec. approval [X] Quasi — Judicial Development Current FY [ ] Rec. app. w/ conds. Compliance N/A [ ] Legislative [ ] Rec. Denial Bahareh Keshavarz - Wolfs, [ ] Public Hearing Funding Source: [ ] Continued to: AICP Advertised: Attachments: Growth Mana ent Required [ ] q [ ]Operating [X] Other NA • Applicant's Narrative Administrato [X] Not Required • Location map • Artwork Details Charles K. Wu, AICP • Artist Resume Budget Acct. #: • Project Budget Breakdown Approved By: N/A Affected Parties: City Manager [ ] Notified [X] Not Required Ronald M. Ferris BACKGROUND Date Prepared: November 7, 2005 Meeting Date: November 15, 2005 Petition AIPP- 05- 09- 000005 • Midtown is located along the north side of PGA Boulevard between Gardens Square Boulevard and Shady Lakes Drive. On August 5, 2004, Midtown was approved by City Council for the master plan approval and conditional use approvals to allow for the development of 64,533 square feet (500 -seat small theater, and 300 -seat banquet hall, Sunday School and accessory facilities) for a cultural center and church facilities, 64,025 square feet for retail space, 19,950 square feet for restaurant space, 10,900 square feet for office space, and 225 rental units on an approximately 47 -acre site, through the adoption of Resolution 92, 2004. The subject site is currently being developed in accordance with the plan approved by said resolution. In accordance with Section 78 -262 of the Land Development Regulations entitled Art in Public Places, Fee Imposed on Development, all budgets for new construction of private and public developments shall include one percent (1 %) of the total budget for vertical construction as a fee for art in public places. The subject fee shall be used by the developer for the provision of artwork on the project site, or the developer may choose to contribute one percent (1 %) of the total vertical construction costs directly to the City for the provision of art on public property. Under the provisions of Section 78- 261(a)(1) of the City's Land Development Regulations entitled Deposit of Funds, prior to the issuance of a building permit on site, the petitioner is required to place $160,000 into an escrow account, which represents an estimate of one (1 %) percent of the estimated total cost of vertical construction on site (please see the attached project budget breakdown). • PROPOSED ART IN PUBLIC PLACES The proposed Art in Public Places designed by Terry Thommes is described below (please see attached images and location maps): Reliance The applicant is proposing a large -scale art piece situated directly on PGA Boulevard. The art, titled Reliance, is a concrete and stainless steel arch situated over a pedestrian pathway located within the PGA Overlay, directly visible from the adjacent right -of -way. The sculpture will be approximately 13 feet in height and 60 feet in length (see attached rendering). The sculpture will have glass insert of various shapes and colors, which will be internally illuminated. ARTIST The artist, Terry Thommes, is a local sculptor. Thommes' works of art are currently being shown in various museums, as well as in public and private spaces (please see attached artist resume). STAFF ANALYSIS The petitioner has satisfied the requirements established in the City's LDRs relating to the • provision of Art in Public Places. Should the Art in Public Places Advisory Board recommend approval of the proposed art to the City Council, staff recommends the following conditions of approval: OA • 0 Date Prepared: November 7, 2005 Meeting Date: November 15, 2005 Petition AIPP- 05 -09- 000005 1. The applicant, successors or assigns shall be responsible for maintenance of the works of art. (Planning & Zoning) 2. The applicant shall submit photographs of the installed artwork within 60 days of completion. (Planning and Zoning) I Prior to the issuance of the final Certificate of Occupancy for the non - residential portion of the project, the applicant shall install all proposed artwork approved for the site. (Planning & Zoning) 3 Art & Culture Group,, I n c. • October 28, 2005 '� AIPP ADVISORY BOARD City of Palm Beach Gardens 10500 North Military Trail Palm Beach Gardens, Florida 33410 Re: Borland Center for Community Enrichment - Midtown Art in Public Places Final Recommendation Request Dear AIPP Advisory Board Members: On behalf of the Borland Center Owners Association Inc., it is my pleasure to submit the enclosed information for your review and request a positive final recommendation to the City Council of Palm Beach Gardens for the proposed art & cultural public art. Our excitement over this proposed sculpture continues to grow. programming Please find the following information enclosed for review prior to the AIPP Advisory Board Meeting: design and • Project Site & AIPP Location consulting • Colored Front Elevation "Reliance" Sculpture • • Colored Plan View "Reliance" Sculpture • Artist's Sketch Plaza Site & Location of Sculpture • Site Plan Plaza Area CAD Format • Colored Landscape Plan Plaza Site • Artist's Resume • Public art budget information 66 St. James Drive Palm Beach Gardens Florida 33418 Phone /fax: (561) 622 -9892 • As you will see by the enclosed drawings, the color and approximate size of glass has been indicated in the front elevation and plan view drawings. Glass inserts will be cut in various sizes. The size of the glass prior to being cut into shapes is 8" x 12" x 1" and the artist plans to use the maximum amount of height and width when having the glass cut into shapes. On a human scale this size will be intriguingly large. Glass of this thickness will contain air bubbles, which at human scale will add an interesting texture. The glass shapes may seem small in the drawings, however please keep the glass measurements in mind as well as the overall monumental size of the sculpture. Also, you will notice in the plan view of the sculpture that the "arrow" at one end of the sculpture has been eliminated and a soften feature added. This was a suggestion of some AIPP Advisory Board members at the September 20, 2004 meeting. �Y G PA • We hope that everyone has made it through the recent hurricane in good health and with a dry roof over head! We are in the process of fully accessing the affect the hurricane has had on the overall project timeline and will have an updated timeline to share with members at the meeting on November 15, 2005. We are very excited by the proposed sculpture and the plaza area designed to enhance this inspiring work of art. I look forward to meeting with the members of AIPP Advisory Board to fully review this request. Sincerely, /T44#— Lucy M. F. Keshavarz Arts Consultant to Borland Center Owners Association Inc. Enclosures n U • TERRY THOMMES EDUCATION MFA in Sculpture, University of Georgia, 1980. Studied under John Kehoe, James Knecht, Larry Millard, & William Thompson BFA in Sculpture and Metalsmithing, Western Michigan University, 1978. Studied under Gerald Dumlao, Paul Mergan, and Dwayne Lowder EDUCATIONAL GRANTS, FELLOWSHIPS, AWARDS University of Georgia, Art Fellowship for Independent Study in Italy, 1979 MFA Studies Abroad Scholarship, University of Georgia, Cortona, Italy, 1978 MFA Ford Foundation Grant, University of Georgia, 1977 Ford Foundation Grant, Western Michigan University, 1975 International Kinetic Art Competition Winner(Netherlands) -Third Place Award 2003 Art in the Park, Key West, Florida, Best sculpture viewed from air, 2004 U [:I�L•]��u����T:L�: fi�Cl7 Instructor, Lighthouse Center for the Arts, Tequesta, Florida, 2005 Director, Art Workshops of Tuscany - Arezzo, 2003- present Sculpture Area Chair, Armory Art Center, West Palm Beach, 2000 -2003 Instructor, Armory Art Center, West Palm Beach, 1999 -2000 Adjunct Instructor, Florida Keys Community College, 1997 Assistant Professor of Sculpture, University of Georgia, 1993 AFFILIATIONS College Art Association, New York, New York International Sculpture Center, Washington, D.C. Florida Artist Registry, Tallahassee, Florida Martin County Arts Council. Stuart, Florida Palm Beach Cultural Consortium, West Palm Beach, Florida • SELECTED EXHIBITIONS • Harrison Gallery, Current Flotsam, Key West Florida 2005 Cultural Courthouse Gallery, Boat Show, Martin County, Florida 2005 Sculpture Key West, Fort Zachary Taylor, Key West, Florida 2005 Karen Lynne Gallery, Thommes and Borgerding, Boca Raton, Florida 2004 Art Basel- Miami, Miami, Florida 2004 Art in the Park, Ft Zachary Taylor, Key West, Florida 2004 Florence Biennale, Florence, Italy 2003 Art Basel, Basel, Switzerland 2003 Art in Motion, Netherlands, 2003 Art Workshops of Arezzo 2003, Arezzo, Italy Art in the Park, Fort Zachary Taylor, Key West, Florida 2003 Soho Arts South, Recent Works, Palm Beach, Florida, 2003 Nature Conservancy, Blowing Rocks Preserve, Jupiter, FL 2003 Lucky Street Gallery, Group Exhibition, Key West, Florida 2002 Contemporary Artists of Florida, Group Show ,City of Adventura, Florida 2002 MCAA Cultural Galleries, Two Person Exhibition Stuart, Florida 2002 Northport Gallery, Solo Exhibition,Northport, Michigan, 2002 DeBilzan Gallery, Group Exhibition, Santa Fe, New Mexico 2002 • Soho South, 4 person Exhibition, Palm Beach, Florida 2002 Lucky Street Gallery, Thommes and Buckheim, Sculpture and Paintings, Key West, Nov, 2001 Northport Gallery, Implications, 2 person show, Northport, Michigan 2001 Armory Art Center, West Palm Beach, 2001 Inside - Outside, Guadalupe Fine Art, Santa Fe, New Mexico 2000 Ann Norton Sculpture Gardens, West Palm Beach, Florida 2000 Martin County Cultural Center Galleries, Stuart, Florida 20000 Armory Art Center, West Palm Beach, Florida 2000 Solo Exhibition, PELAGIC DRIFT, Lucky Street Gallery, Key West, Florida 1999 Art in the Park Outdoor Sculpture Exhibition, Fort Zachary Taylor, Key West, Florida 1999 Solo Exhibition, PELAGIC WEIRS, Guadalupe Fine Art, Santa Fe, New Mexico 1999 5th Annual Spiritual Art Exhibition, Guadalupe Fine Art, Santa Fe, New Mexico 1998 Art in the Park, Fort Zachary Taylor, Key West, Florida 1998 ARS EROTICUS, Woodenhead Gallery, Key West Florida 1998 Neovo, Guadalupe Fine Art, Sante Fe, New Mexico 1998 Hortt 39 Exhibition, Ft. Lauderdale Museum of Art, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida 1997 Solo Exhibition, Castello di Gargonza, Monte San Savino, Arezzo, Italy. July 1997 Solo Exhibition, Gallery on Greene, Key West, Florida. April 1997 is Gasparilla Exhibition, Tampa, Florida 1997 • Art in the Park Outdoor Sculpture Exhibition, Key West, Florida 1996 Gallery on Greene Group Exhibition, Key West, Florida 1996 Hortt 38 Exhibition, Ft. Lauderdale Museum of Art, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida 1996 Group Show, Soho Gallery, Pensacola, Florida 1996 Six Artists, Eye of the Lizard Gallery, Vero Beach, Florida 1996 Images 96, New Smyrna Beach, Florida 1996 Group Exhibition, Lucky Street Gallery, Key West, Florida 1996 Solo Exhibition, Florida State Capitol Complex Gallery, Tallahassee, Florida 1995 It's All Relative, Gallery Mesa, Mesa, Arizona 1995 Two Person Exhibition, Goodwin & Thommes, Lucky Street Gallery, Key West Florida 1995 Group Show, Eye of the Lizard Gallery, Vero Beach, Florida 1995 National Sculpture Show, Rockafeller Gardens, Ormond Beach, Florida 1995 SELECTED COLLECTIONS Terrence McNally, New York, New York • Tim Allen, Sherman Oaks, CA Whitney Houston, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey Jacqueline and Roland Grim, Key West, Florida Knox Collection, Stamford, Conneticut Ben and Ellen Levy, Albuquerque, New Mexico Phil and Mary Shannon, Cumming, Georgia & Summerland Key, Florida Castello Di Gargonza, Monte San Savino, Arezzo, Italy Count Roberto Guiaciardini, Florence, Italy Dr. Jorge Oti, Santa Fe, New Mexico Hellmich Collection ,Knokke, Belgium Kevin Avants, Santa Fe, New Mexico Jan Van Duppen, Beerce, Belgium Leonessi Collection, Arezzo, Italy Paolo Berti, Arezzo, Italy Heinz Collection, Marathon, Florida Cornerstone Sculpture Collection, Greenwich, Connecticut Redstone Collection, Needham, Massachusetts Sal Micca, Winchester, Connecticut McKenzie Collection, Greenbrae, California Goldman Collection, Swampscott, Massachusetts Birer Collection, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida • • SELECTED COMMISSIONS 1995 - present 3i Implant Innovations, Palm Beach Gardens, Public Sculpture, 2005 Katherine Dunne, Bronze Gates and Garden Entries, 2004 Tina and Robert Kraft, Bronze Gates and Entrys, Bronze Vanes, 2003 -2004 Port Salerno Fire Station, Bronze Public Sculpture, Stuart, Florida, 2002 Linda Dove Design, Metalsmithed Bronze Firescreen, Tequesta, Florida 2001 Burrage Residence, Custom Art Gate, Florida Keys, 2001 Carolyn Smith, Bronze and Brass Railings, Jensen Beach, Florida 2000 Phil Shannon, Bronze Gates and Lamps, Summerland Key, Florida 2000 Bauer Residence, Bronze, Brass, Copper and Keystone Entry Gates and Entrance, 1998 Mary Shannon, Bronze and Concrete Sculpture, Bronze Gates, Cumming, Georgia 1998 Lutheran Outdoor Ministries Florida, 17 Ton Stone Installation, Gainesville, Florida 1998 Denise Brown, Sugarloaf Key, Florida. Bronze Gates, Bronze Lamps, Interior Sculpture 1997 Byron Hochausser, Boca Raton, Florida. Bronze & Granite Sculptural Furniture 1996 Blue Heaven Restaurant, Key West, Florida. Corten Steel Entry & Pedestrian Gates (painted) 1996 Dr. Daniel Gill & Dr. Francesca Brettschneider, Big Pine Key, Florida. Bronze Gates, Doors 1996 Dr. Fred & Meridith Troxel, Big Pine Key, Florida. Outdoor Sculpture 1995 Dr. Daniel Gill, Big Pine Key, Florida. 8' Carved Marble Outdoor Sculpture 1995 Shark Key Development Corp., Shark Key, Florida. Bronze Entry Gates, Bronze Pedestrian Gates John & Maribel Maschall, Sugarloaf Key, Florida. Bronze Entry Lamps Dee Hardin, New York, New York. Carved Marble Heads • Jean Hellmich, Knokke, Belgium, Carved Marble Heads Dr. Fred Troxel, Big Pine Key, Florida Carved Marble Heads Richard McKenzie, Greenbrae, California. Carved Marble Couple PUBLIC WORK 3i Implant Innovations, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida Plaza Resulana, Santa Fe, New Mexico Port Salerno Fire Station, Port Salerno, Florida, Bronze Western Michigan University, Sculpture Tour, Kalamazoo, Michigan, Metal and Concrete Castello di Gargonza, Monte San Savino, Italy Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary, Large Underwater Environmental Concrete Sculptures Bahama Village, City of Key West, Florida. Welded Corten Steel Gates Marathon Regional Airport, Marathon, Florida. Welded Wall Relief BIRTHPLACE: Plainfield, New Jersey, USA 1953 - RESIDENCE: 6185 SW Gaines Avenue • Stuart, Florida 34997 USA Tele: 772 - 286 -2386 Fax: 772 - 220 -4797 •Final Recommendation Request - AIPP Borland Center Owners Assoc. Inc Budget Information 15- Nov -05 AIPP Budget - $160,000.00 Costs of aroaosed AIPP Reliance by Terry Thommes (Includes design, fabrication, installation of sculpture $145,000 by artist. Artist to subcontract engineering and lighting.) Art Specific Site Work: plaza design $5,000 plaza hardscape $10,000 plaza landscape $5,000 electrical to sculpture $2,000 Memorial Plaque $3,000 Arts Consulting Fee $24,000 Total $194,000 r � U • • • CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD Agenda Cover Memorandum Date Prepared: November 7, 2005 Meeting Date: November 15, 2005 Petition AIPP- 05 -10- 000009 SUBJECT /AGENDA ITEM Petition AIPP- 05 -10- 000009: Art in Public Places — Donald Ross Village PUD Recommendation to City Council: A request by Urban Design Studio on behalf of Donald Ross/Military, L.C., for the consideration for approval of the proposed Art in Public Places for the commercial portion of the Donald Ross Village Planned Unit Development (PUD). The Donald Ross Village PUD, approved by Ordinance 53, 2002, is a 45.37 -acre site located on the south side of Donald Ross Road, between Military Trail and Central Boulevard. Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: FINANCE: N/A AIPP Advisory Board Growth Management: Action: Project Costs: $ N/A [ ] Approved City Attorney N/A Christine Tatum Mana er g —Total A w/ conditions [ ] App. Kara L. Irwin [ ] Denied Finance N/A Planning Manager $ N/A [ ] Rec. approval [X] Quasi — Judicial Current FY [ ] Rec. app. w/ conds. Development Compliance N/A [ ] Legislative [ ] Rec. Denial Bahareh Keshavarz - Wolfs, [ ] Public Hearing Funding Source: [ ] Continued to: AICP Advertised: Attachments: Growth Mana ment Required [ ] q [ Operating • Applicant's Narrative [X] Other NA . Location map Administrato [X] Not Required . Project Budget Charles K. Wu, AICP Breakdown Budget Acct. #: N/A • Artwork Details • Artist Resume Approved By: Affected Parties: City Manager [ ] Notified [X] Not Required Ronald M. Ferris Date Prepared: November 7, 2005 Meeting Date: November 15, 2005 Petition AIPP- 05 -1 0- 000009 BACKGROUND • On April 10, 2003, the City Council adopted Ordinance 53, 2002, which approved the development order for Donald Ross Village Mixed -Use Planned Unit Development (PUD). The master plan was divided into two phases of development. Phase I of the Donald Ross Village MXD PUD was approved for 9,000 square feet of professional office, a 3,236 square foot convenience store with gas sales, a 4,000 square foot bank, a 14,873 square foot drug store, 13,000 square feet of restaurant space, 2,400 square feet of outdoor restaurant seating, 57,487 square feet of retail use and 156 multi - family dwelling units. On July 1, 2004, the City Council adopted Ordinance 23, 2004 and Resolution 125, 2004, which amended the Planned Unit Development (PUD- 04 -12) to allow for off -site mitigation. City Staff determined that it is more appropriate for the site plan approval and the conditions related thereto be transferred to a separate ordinance and resolution, as opposed to having the zoning, master plan approval, waivers, and conditions of approval adopted through ordinance. The zoning set forth in Ordinance 53, 2002 has been re- affirmed by Ordinance 23, 2004 and the master site plan, waivers, and conditions of approval have been transferred to Resolution 125, 2004. Per Resolution 125, 2004, two conditions of approval (conditions 37 & 38) were modified to allow for additional off -site mitigation, as well as an expansion of a previously approved waiver for the reduction in the upland preserve buffer width, so that the applicant can go forward with the companion petition MISC- 04 -19. On July 1, 2004, the City Council adopted Resolution 115, 2004, which approved a parcel for off -site mitigation of 29% of the upland preserve set aside required for the site. • On August 5, 2004, the City Council adopted Resolution 149, 2004, which approved a waiver to eliminate the lake maintenance easement along the south side of the 5.09 -acre lake on site. In order to justify the requested waiver, the applicant provided a 25 -foot easement along the north end of the adjacent property, Dwyer High School parcel, so as to function as the lake maintenance easement. On November 18, 2005, City Council adopted Resolution 210, 2004, which approved an amendment to the Donald Ross Village Mixed -Use Planned Unit Development (PUD) for phase II of the subject site with a 93 -room hotel, a 13,500 square foot retail building, an 18,387 square - foot medical office building, and a 20,000 square -foot fitness center. The subject site is currently being developed in accordance with the plan approved by said resolution. In accordance with Section 78 -262 of the Land Development Regulations entitled Art in Public Places, Fee Imposed on Development, all budgets for new construction of private and public developments shall include one percent (1 %) of the total budget for vertical construction as a fee for art in public places. The subject fee shall be used by the developer for the provision of artwork on the project site, or the developer may choose to contribute one percent (1 %) of the total vertical construction costs directly to the City for the provision of art on public property. Under the provisions of Section 78- 261(a)(1) of the City's Land Development Regulations entitled Deposit of Funds, prior to the issuance of a building permit on site, the petitioner is • required to place $118,497 into an escrow account, which represents an estimate of one (1%) percent of the estimated total cost of vertical construction on site (please see the attached project budget breakdown). 2 Date Prepared: November 7, 2005 Meeting Date: November 15, 2005 Petition AIPP- 05 -10- 000009 PROPOSED ART IN PUBLIC PLACES • The applicant is proposing two separate design concepts to meet the requirements for Art in Public Places. The first was procured through Jovanini Design, and is comprised of thirty -one pieces. The second is a mosaic design for the project's plaza areas, which has been designed by Gina Hubler of Design Impacts. Both concepts are described below (please see attached images and location maps): Images of a Village The creative intent of the multiple artworks within the site reflects the project's name and function as a village. The applicant is proposing a series of thirty -one (31) bronze sculptures, depicting children in various forms of play, located throughout the site as part of the pedestrian and vehicular experience of the site. The bronze sculptures, by Jovanini Design, Inc, are handcrafted by skilled craftsman using the lost wax method of casting, which was revived in the Renaissance and widely practiced until modern times. In addition, the applicant is proposing multiple mosaics and an iconic fountain within the project's main plaza area. The mosaics have been designed by Gina Hubler, of Design Impacts around the columns within the "Ice Cream Plaza" located within the project's main gathering area. The large fountain feature will have a plaque honoring the creative efforts of Henry "Hank" Skokowski, the founder of Urban Design Studio and original planner of Donald Ross Village. The Donald Ross Village PUD, as a mixed -use project, was designed to focus on the pedestrian is experience within the site. The proposed artwork is providing an experience through art that will encourage pedestrian traffic to discover all of the "village images," thereby enhancing the intended use of the site. Although the applicant is not proposing one or a few original designs, the proposed concept is integrated into the intended design of the site and will provide further development of the mixed -use community design themes throughout the non - residential portion of the site. ARTIST Bronze Sculptures The bronze sculptures have been provided by Jovanini Design, Inc, whose products are handcrafted by skilled craftsman using the lost wax method of casting, which was revived in the Renaissance and widely practiced until modern times. (please see attached mission statement) The mosaics have been designed by Gina Hubler, of Design Impacts, who is an artist and teacher at the studio in Miami, Florida. (please see attached artist statement) STAFF ANALYSIS The petitioner has satisfied the requirements established in the City's LDRs relating to the provision of Art in Public Places. Should the Art in Public Places Advisory Board recommend • approval of the proposed art to the City Council, staff recommends the following conditions of approval: 3 Date Prepared: November 7, 2005 Meeting Date: November 15, 2005 Petition AIPP- 05 -10- 000009 1. The applicant, successor's or assigns shall be responsible for maintenance of the works of • art. (Planning & Zoning) 2. The applicant shall submit photographs of the installed artwork within 60 days of completion. (Planning and Zoning) • :7 3. Prior to the issuance of the final Certificate of Occupancy for the non - residential portion of the project, the applicant shall install all proposed artwork approved for the site. (Planning & Zoning) 4. No works of art shall be located within a preserve area. (Planning & Zoning) 4 • November 3, 2005 Ms. Kara Irwin, Senior Planner Growth Management Department City of Palm Beach Gardens 10500 N. Military Trail Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410 RE: DONALD ROSS VILLAGE - MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION FOR ART IN PUBLIC PLACES - OUR REF.: #99- 044.26 (MA) Dear Kara: Urban Design Urban Planning Land Planning Landscape Architecture The purpose of this resubmittal is our request to be scheduled for the November 15, 2005 Art in Public Places Advisory Board meeting for a recommendation to the City Council on the proposed artwork for the Donald Ross Village MXD PUD. At the last AIPP Board meeting on October 19, 2005, there was discussion with regard to the directive from the City Council that the Art Committee should not consider /approve any "animals or wildlife" art. The City Council felt that there was enough "animals and wildlife" art that had been approved throughout the city. In addition, it was also discussion on whether domesticated animals would fall under this directive. • Consequently, we have exchanged one (1) of our art 'statues that featured a girl with a horse to a girl playing the flute. In addition, we are requesting that the AIPP Board support our request to include the statues that featured dogs playing with children and the one (1) statue with two (2) boys on a turtles back. We believe these statues represent the joys of childhood and interaction between a pet and its owner rather than the strict representation of a species of wildlife. The statue with the boys on the turtle is not only a whimsical depiction of tropical life, but also connects with the provision of the adjacent "critter crossing," which connects two upland preserve areas on the site. In addition, we have replaced one other statue with a new statue of a girl holding a watering can. This addition has brought the total of statues feature females up to 20 on the site, as this was another concern expressed by the Board. At the last Board meeting, there were several questions with regard to the statues: What are the statues made of? The statues are made of bronze, which is a mixture of two metals - copper and tin. 2. How thick is the bronze? On average the thickness of each bronze statue is 1/4 of an inch, although this varies between the statues. CITY OF PALM BCH GDNS 3. How long will the statue last and will the color fade? The bronze NOV >> statues are very hard - wearing and therefore last forever. The color does not fade as long as the bronze is maintained • appropriately. In order to maintain the bronze, you need to 477 S. Rosemary Avenue wax it on a regular basis, usually every two to six months. Suite 225 - The Lofts at City Place West Palm Beach, FL 33401 G: \Jobs \Parcel 4. 0204Dona ldRossVillage\AIPP\Application Info \cover letterl 10305.wpd 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax LCC35 www.UDSonline.com LCC35 i Donald Ross Village • Art in Public Places November 3, 2005 Page 2 Included with the submittal are 13 copies of the following of the information previously submitted along with the two (2) new statues: • Information on the artist for the mosaics; • Color Photo of the selected work of art ; • Specifications of the artwork; • Photo realistic image of sculpture in the median; • Master PCD site plan; • Hardscape Plans; Please let me know if you have any questions or require any additional information with regard to this submission. Sincerely, URBAN DESIGN STUDIO • arty 4A. or, AICP 0 Attachments cc: Tom Hamilton Andrew Brock G: \Jobs \Parcel 4.0204 Donal dRossV ill age\AIPP\Appl icati on Info \cover letter] 10305.wpd LCC35 r� U • Donald Ross Village Art In Public Places # SKU # Title Price 1 P1009 Girl Reading on Rocking Chair $3,460.00 2 8701 Boy with Dog $740.00 3 V78001 3 Boys on Stairs $1,239.00 4 8533 Girl with Boy Under Tree Play Swing $3,080.00 5 8688 2 Girls & 1 Boy in a Circle $3,500.00 6 8652 2 Boys $1,881.00 7 A611 Sitting Boy & Girl with Dog $2,450.00 8 D1575 Boy Fishing on Tree $1,960.00 9 B215 Girl & Boy Under Umbrella $2,100.00 10 B568 4 Boys & 1 Girl on Large Pipe $7,000.00 11 B700 Girl & Boy With Dog $2,760.00 12 13239 Boy With Girl on Swing $2,920.00 13 8613 2 Boys on Turtle $2,720.00 14 B548 1 Girl, 4 Boys Walking on Rocks $7,040.00 15 P1030 Boy Carrying Golf Bag $1,329.00 16 8556 Walking Boy on Log $2,640.00 17 131040 Boy Golfing $1,169.00 18 3253 Girl on Swing, Boy Pushing $2,080.00 19 TH -373 Girl Playing Ball with Dog $1,820.00 20 B739 Girl with Kite $2,400.00 21 B493 Standing Boy Fishing $2,760.00 22 B554 Boy & Girl on Seesaw $2,717.00 23 V74050 Girl Playing Flute $1,540.00 24 P1039 Boy Playing Golf CITY C F PALM • G:Vobs \Parcel 4. 0204DonaldRossVillage \.41PPWpplication Info \statue table nov 2- 05.wpd�� Y J) L LCC35 P14NNING & ZONIN " P ;�� L� LJ Donald Ross Village Art In Public Places 25 D1574 Boy Playing Flute on Tree $1,960.00 26 T60063 Girl with Water Can $900.00 B749 Boy & Girl Reading $2,660.00 127 28 T20001 A Boy with Lantern $1,200.00 30 P1004 Boy & Girl with Book $1,920.00 31 V50190 Boy & Girl Reading on a Bench $4,620.00 32 Pot Fountain and Mosaic $14,763.44 Art Consulting Fees $18,000.00 Additional Mosaics $9,949.56 Total $118,497.00 • G:Uobs\Parcel 4. 0204Dona ldRossVillageWlPPWpplication Info statue table nov 2- 05.wpd 11CC35 Jovanini Design, Inc - Mission Statement 1� j • Moncy back Guarantcc A. 5% off I Free Shipping! - Click Acre (Including on thready diSCOLInted items) Jovanini Design_ Inc ,, Vlissio l 4 New Items 4 Specials Bronze Statues Bronze Fountains Bronze Lighting Bronze Mailboxes Bronze Tabel -Tops Bronze Remington Bronze Urn Information -> 100% Guarantee -� Your Privac-%Securit -� Sales Tax info (FL) -j- Shipping Info -� Wholesale Info -► Return Policy 4 International Orders 4 Deal of the Month i How_ to Order -� Gift Certificate_ � Tell a Friend -i' About Us -t Contact Us Customers Say -� Mission Statement Help i Webmasters /Links nc • [LICK i0 � 1 SEPT 30 2005 5 1 fi `1 Mission Statement: Page I of 2 it • Over SOO+ View Cart ; View Account ; Jovanini Design, inc mission statement is to offer our clients the highest quality bronze at the most competitive prices available, while providing high -level customer service and personal attention, in addition to offering an enjoyable shopping experience. In addition, it is our #1 priority to reach 100% customer satisfaction and help our clients get the item they desire at the best price on the internet. If you found a similar product to one ours at a lower price, email us the URL page of that product and we will do everything we can to beat or match that price. Jovanini Design, Inc is committed to expend its base of high - quality products on a regular basis so that our clients will have a greater variety of products to chose from. We guarantee a secure shopping experience to our clients using a technology called Secure Socket Layer (SSL) to encrypt any personal information you transmit to us online. Our site is digitally secured using GoDaddy.com which is a leader in digital certificates and internet security. The information is encrypted on your computer and decoded after it reaches Jovanini Design, Inc secure server. This information cannot be decrypted during transit. Click on our "confirmed web site seal" on the left to view our SSL certificate information. Your order is always safe when purchasing from our site. I rlror_ Adv. Shc Your View ( Cun 2 EAG S220t 8 CAJAI HIED J� W BI -9 http : / /jovaninidesign.com /sunshop/ index .php /action/Mission_Statement/ 9/30/2005 Z J ,d W o' .I i z om�v-z a o z � Q le 4 Q 0 ci N N O Z � W� V /MNL2lf-1 a1xia o-70 1 r s I ni �i .I 7 I to CL I a °1 � I I I t o � z ��fldN�n.L vGl?j0�� 1 K V) > 6Z W oWW o \r cil m tad Cc Q u �� d a 0 Z to Z ai �--1 W Y Q J S F 0 z z 1�57 0 Z V 0 _ 0 N 0 U) J as L a. Qi Q �od 3 O a� C/) W U �0 ca 0 m t� Z o� 21 Z cl (,3 v� r-I .j �.I I � I 0 74 �v w su �N ® w ® Z5 w su � v� �y J �I DI 2w mffi t�• W WN w� J ® Z Q� ® �W D C (. N N 0 Y7 � N >a V i cc d i O ca _4) W C O LA- z• 9 �a vU 1 �-w V i cc d i O ca _4) W C O LA- vw 1 AU IL I o I 7bt �I •1�'0 0 �rci V i cc d i O ca _4) W C O LA- 41 0 0 4 �I 0'I l w I � � �0. ' to ha I Nu IL s a I :4. z� zw 'I I �:z 4) v cc 4) 3 ca as I I I I N I ®• I o s I I_•a�: � Q v 71 I I I a I F l w I � � �0. ' to ha I Nu IL s a I :4. z� zw 'I I �:z 4) v cc 4) 3 ca as L _CL ♦v w a� O O V O J 06 C c� a. N N tQ O V N N N Q • • Fn Q C7 a. .a cC U c c a� a� 3 a� a� L N I O cv V O L _CL v U) V N a. :ice cn s x4 -;uacutyouu #unu/u/oo aoj 1� U= A g -14uao PUP /Jog ay1 b Z O a Q O W� O C o W � U 4 a Q a � W v V q V V C j a 1 Z owe Q .f 0 0 0 0 s Qq W 4( 4 � � a � W pv C � 4O 2� ;~ y O f 1 • 1 . y � 1 o 3 � � Z i P-1 Its m --- -.err all tot - It 1110111,111111 It ��� ► � , �- ��,�! j�lj lam± �•�j�l �� 1- , � � . 1 1 all ow If 1 K �.r =�7h' l4,1f�� s� I - - -- mail Z: flow 7 PR* Koo IBM0 Will MA its Am log- IF 7. ILI ' iii 1 (� �1 � K� ,� ,�., 1= I IN —F N IWO �MMML6 1 'y `sII� � i 4SI-00 W/� 1%,610- I'M el sts p '41 r FA • • • 6 C1_ fF/ f • C • • • 09 • • • n vt 1 KenTaylorDesign.com :: Bronze Sculpture Wholesale - B568 Ken Taylor De sign Catalog > B568 http: / /www. kentaylordesign.com/shop /cart. php ?target= product &prod... Phone: (786) 271 9357 Address: 2013 SW 31 AVE PEMBROKE PARK FL 33009 ro-7 Catalogf C:�A Your Account Y $ Contact 11.11151 • • of 2 ' Categories Description Children Animals 5 KIDS ON People and Etc LARGE PIPE Fountains 39 "H x 80"W x Desktop p 10 10/6/2005 1:30 PM Min ice/ I k C] L71 Ie) -, �� �`.- �, �:� -- t +��_ _. '�. . \�` �r., � `, �'�- ` �' �,:,. � ,a j �"'° '; �\ �_ -- �� _� `� .. _ -_ t ��'� E�. 4 � r�', �� ,� , ,�� m 11 �� 1 ���� +�IMw _ .� �.�. ,� 4 '�:,� :� �+�► ',, b ,� J .... 4' j �..+ i � r' /, , �. i / � / ( \ ..fir - J ` � , � .� �j � 7, ;. � ii` lA ,. �� r`k � i �� ^4. -.'%' r:r � �Y 1 e �* _�� ^r .' L� �� '\\ /' 1•t �, • ,�1. , t �� 1 , � yt` � �� � :� - �. 1► r ,, �. �' . 1 ^ �` J ���: t. iti ,f .� .� .�. ,. -- �� �- �,� k i r� ,� ., �' C� • M KenTaylorDesign.com :: Bronze Sculpture Wholesale - TH -373 J • 1 of 2 Ken Taylor, iksign Catalog > TH -373 http: / /www. kentaylordesign.com/shop /cart. php? target = product &prod... Phone :(786) 271 9357 Address: 2013 SW 31 AVE PEMBROKE PARK FL 33009 1�2-,, Catalog -f 4 Your Account -, 1 ,S Contact Us e+ Description GIRL HOLDS BALL WITH DOG 47 "H x 46 "W x 19" ' Categories Children Animals People and Etc Fountains Desktop 19 10/6/2005 2:53 PM • 0 • 20 • • 91 I/ 4 • • • 9A • • • 25 • CJ -mow s low, 0 � A MAPP, Jz;K4 Y:, h Ir I i ' L p Ago Pat I,entini - Fwd: FW: Donald Ross Mosaics Page 1 From: Marty Minor • To: Lentini, Pat Date: 8/31/2005 11:51:52 AM Subject: Fwd: FW: Donald Ross Mosaics Artist info below >>> "Grace" <grace @kwdesign.net> 07/25/05 2:34 PM >>> - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Gina [mailto:gina @designimp.com] Sent: Monday, July 18, 2005 9:31 AM To: Marty @UDS.cnchost.com Cc: grace @kwdesign.net Subject: Donald Ross Mosaics Marty, I was recieved your info. from Grace at Krent Wieland, hopefully this will help with the application. Design Impact has been creating wall installation and fine art mosaics since 1;995, with designer and mosaicist Gina Hubler at the helm. Our primary Atelier is loca e a Miami, Florida, however we have designed and installed projects throughout the United States and Europe. I thought that I would begin with an intro to the project, which might be used for the Art in Public Places application. `The work of art which has been chosen for the Donald Ross Village Project is inspired by the concept of community, and the uplifting spirit which this center aims to provide to those which share its facilities. The proposed placement of this work is focused in the fountain areas, however it will be carried through the village center, in elements embellishing columns, as well as planters. The intention is to provide those which pass with an upward strength, and the feeling of rising to any occasion." I am also including • references for your approval. Sincerely, Gina Hubler- Principal Professional References: Michael Howard- Facilities Director Luigi Vitalini ArchitectThe Mills Co. (Formerly Taubman) Hersh, Vitalini, & CorraziniThe Falls Entertainment Complex Hersh, Vitalini, & Corrazzini AIA (305)- 255 -4571 (305)567 -0602 Carol ZeinerProfessor St. Thomas University Law School(305) 361- 8114Cc:Krent Wieland Design, Inc. tist Statement http : / /www.mosaictools.com/gallery/statement) ARTIST'S STATEMENT f ' My philosophy of art and beauty comes from the principles of colour, with light as its essence. Colours meld to form new colours and the feelings which they inspire. In the same breath, they split apart with an unequal divide to produce seemingly alike, but different colours and emotions. I equate colour with all that is life, the tears, the joy, as well as the rapture. Everything that is in the human experience can be described and felt through colour and design. FINE ART I truly enjoy taking an artists painting or 2D media and translating the work into mosaic. I see the collaboration between myself and another artist as a challenge. The result of creating "artwork for the eternity" with the sensibilities of the original work is very satisfying! is FURNISHINGS I have been designing custom furnishings for the past 20 years, for the past decade I have focused on creating furnishings with mosaic elements. I enjoy working with my clients to provide focal point furnishings which have meaning to those which will be living with them. I often include hidden elements which are significant to the owners! Fun - Creative -Focal Point Furnishings! C COMMISSIONS Mosaic design can translate into any medium. I have enjoyed designing and fabricating mosaics for a variety of installations both residential and commercial. My installations are site specific, both the location, as well as the clients needs are taken into consideration during my creative process. SECRET ANGELS My secret angels are among the most spiritual of my creations. I feel that my career as an artist has been defined by a succession of "leaps of faith ". My series of angels is one that is truly from my heart. I feel honored when they use me as a conduit to life on earth! Now, I know I may be getting a bit esoteric, however they really do seem to have a magical quality. Each one has a spirit and personality of its own. I also enjoy creating other mixed media works, the angels may hide in these panels also! Enjoy! S to D,., ;n • 200S (3, ,K F'o, & r rri, I : , , 70O, C'. .. F;.. r, , ..ratFr,e 4 ` of 1 8/31/2005 11:54 AM )out the Artist http : / /www.mosaictools.com/gina/ U] IL , I have been an artist and designer all my life though creating as a mosaicista is truly my passion! I feel very fortunate to work in a profession where my talents are not only used but stretched with each new project. It is my nature to focus on each project with fresh eyes, stretching the envelope, and reaching for my ultimate potential as an artist. It is an field interesting time to be creating in this eld which has become so popular in such recent years. My work may be found throughout the U.S., Canada, Europe, and Asia. I feel blessed to share my talents both with those which I create for, as well as my students. Teaching in itself is a very different mind set, I generally teach one week per month in either Miami, Allentown, or Italy. I appreciate your interest in my work, and look forward to creating for or with you! of 1 8/31/2005 11:55 AM Gallery • • • loft http://www.mosaictools-conVgallery/detail.phtrrd?c=g&id=2 8/31/2005 3:49 PM Gallery http: / /www.mosaictools.com /gallery /detaii.phtml ?c= g &id =22 U L • Y� r Y +Wadolum with t 771k7 pf. ivate colletlfui, marhk., and mvilti R� 1 r i i Ir 1 of 1 8/31/2005 3:49 PM Gaue. -y, , • • w http://www.mosaictools.conVgailery/detail.phtml?c=g&id=60 f It l)om'.I ,,7i:,-q Ni�ai,i� Alc�lri 8/31/2005 3:46 PM ,An-Iu -4uuu 10:,51 rmum-,)im. mu uCl1IcRVuar IIYU 0010,504110 1 -000 r.uutluut r -1 d0 r� DAVID J. WIENER BOARD CERTIFIED REAL ESTATE LAWYER ADMITTED TO PRACTICE IN FLORIDA AND N9W YORK .7 • DAVID J. WIENER, P.A. COUNSELOR AT LAW SUfTE 305 ONE NORM CLEMATIS STREET WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA 3340 1 7 !L, (56 1) 366 -9 144 FAx. (56 1) 356 -9 1 45 E -MAIL: dwiener@Eiterijngcentrecor-p.com January 13, 2005 City of Palm Beach Gardens 10500 North Military Trail Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410 Re: Donald Ross Village — Art in Public Places Ladies and Gcntlelnen: Please be advised that Donald Ross/Military, L.C. (`Developer ") has deposited the sum of the 3118,497.00 with the Undersigned law Firm, in escrow, to be applied to fillfill Developer's obligations in connection with Art in Public Places for the Donald Ross Village project at the southwest corner of Military Trail and Donald Ross Road in Patin Beach Gardens, Florida. A n DJW /jmc 4 LA I Donald Roav & Ccnrral \City of *F3G - Ar( in Public Placas 111 30�;,doc �'�'.. cy. n-;. 7.. �` w; : -.,. +.: .�, - . �� .�'�1 0�" i� r mar^ ., f . "�'" t a+ a +° _ .. — ., ": ,1 .. ,. - : "1`74 t�. w; : -.,. +.: .�, - . �� .�'�1 0�" i� r mar^ ., f . "�'" t 1.{ O C -3 R 101 • • n O • Ila F CD 0 14 CD 0 3 N w bt Ila F CD 0 14 CD 0 3 N w rF CD Final Submittal Review City of Palm Beach Gardens AIPP Advisory Board November 15, 2005 Borland Center Owners Association, Inc. Arts Consultant: Lucy M. F. Keshavarz Art & Culture Group, Inc. Borland Center Owners Association, Inc. project location West View Military Trail Borland Center Owners Association, Inc. AIPP location in front of building C along PGA Blvd. PGA SOU[EVARD u _ Borland Center Owners Association, Inc. C building elevation U1 1 iVsiIk1\ IIX)Ki1cNORTIIMMI1K ;A11OUJAW»aa —M L—A ill.■ l— — ■ ■` BUILDING C Borland Center Owners Association, Inc. preliminary submittal 9/20/05 — rendering looking north from PGA Blvd Two m depicti to crew_ _... _ �..� __.........._. _ _. . �.._. Borland Center Owners Association, Inc. color elevation view SFAliU4655 9TEE4 Ti1df.1L•7 f81WFO9iC.EB 4y5T eC FIFE CRp"S ACMbEE5 CDW[f2Cra SASE O w�j-ITU�.+.� caw. a V 3 "rfi "8.A A "'R4ftK WLORRO 4"55 14 SFP TS (VARIOUS SNAPpS) [LAY ®RjeIC PAVIRRS 4H5,H •' a PLAZA a W^PE i y GpµE��TE Fb4T!%14°.+TZ, SmC5jj eFFz 5F'rmc . A FAH'RIGATRO 9TAUVLErb aYEGI� 3TItUGfURG -co sWIALNEER 5r'FL5 L'lCEaSEP fl.WMyfVAT�or.] W LA^Jf Q�r.le.!{C"IL' 645 Borland Center Owners Association, Inc. color plan view {4 �eew�a�c�v cr,�r soHC�e*e w/'s -rJxcc Frr�rSN Ld Nt FobfINC;S bEid yV 4�[7 �' TO ENIi. SPEC STAINL.E.°5 ?Vr5r- +j P7f a _ . .. . 0 'x i2}K I "'fH lGK COL40'10 --O yr,a�s nrss�crr� � FA97S��G,aT�i7 3�YArN LEsS STF�1_ STFt nsG7U Pa F- IV 6Yi�l.�, APE Cg rt Borland Center Owners Association, Inc. landscape & plaza area design in response to "Reliance" _+JU KEO CKINII41 LILY CREPE MYRTLE BOMMP4LM KOYAL PALM BUILDING C ART IN ME PUBLIC PLACE MEWOM VATS PALM WROPEAN AAN PALM $RICK PAVER TYP. 9 Blkf RACK rYP PEDESTRIAN uc-Hr rm WSEAYWALL Wlth' 3 "44P EXISTING SIDEWALK 16 "SEAT WALL WITH 3 "CAP SOO ANNUAL PG4 $LVD. • s. SOP 16 "S€Ar WALL Wf 9 3 "CAP BXISrING POWER Pole W SE REMOV90 PROPERTY CINE Borland Center Owners Association, Inc. Bruce Borland Memorial text The Bruce E. Borland Center for Community Enrichment Named for Bruce E. Borland, a loving and caring man of genuine character who dedicated his life to his family, to his God and to the community he so dearly loved. He worked tirelessly to fulfill the dream of building a bridge for this community by establishing a gathering place where all could learn of faith and enjoy the arts in the warm atmosphere of true fellowship. Tragically, on October 25, 1999 the lives of Bruce Borland, Van Arden, Stephanie Bellegarrigue, Robert Fraley, Michael Kling and Payne Stewart ended in a plane accident. Symbolically "Reliance" is both a gateway and a bridge— connecting people within the community, and demonstrating that one side cannot stand without the other. As a tribute to Bruce Borland's life, work, love and vision, may the ideals that brought this place and sculpture into existence remain and inspire long after his name is forgotten. Borland Center Owners Association, Inc. Estimated AIPP budget & costs Final Recommendation Request - AIPP Borland Center Owners Assoc. Inc Budget Information 15- Nov -05 AIPP Budget - S160,000.00 Costs of proposed AIPP Reliance by Terry Thommes (Includes design, fabrication, installation of sculpture $145,000 by artist. Artist to subcontract engineering and lighting.) Art Specific Site Work: plaza design $5,000 plaza hardscape $10,000 plaza landscape $5,000 electrical to sculpture $2,000 Memorial Plaque $3,000 Arts Consulting Fee $24,000 Total $194,000 Borland Center Owners Association, Inc. projected timeline November Submittal to AIPP Advisory Board for final recommendation December /January To City Council for approval February — August Fabrication of public art Building permit for public art Installation of public art