HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda CESM 120307AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE AND BE ADVISED that if any interested person desires to appeal any
decision made by the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at
his hearing, such interested person may need a verbatim record ofthe proceedings made, including
the testimony and evidence presented at this hearing.
CALL TO ORDER:
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE:
ROLLCALL
Kevin Wagner, Special Magistrate
David Reyes, Operation Director
R. Max Lohman, Code Compliance Attorney
Mohammed Jamal, Code Compliance Supervisor
Alex Lopez, Sr. Code Compliance Officer
Michael J. Williams, Code Compliance Officer
Ruth Nelson-Peeples, Code Compliance Officer
Robert Creston, Code Compliance Officer
Rossalind Breland, Recording Secretary
QUASI -JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS: The Code Enforcement Special Magistrate shall have
the jurisdiction and authority to hear and decide alleged violations of the codes and ordinances
enacted by the City of Palm Beach Gardens, including, but not limited to, the following codes:
building, electrical, fire, gas, landscape, plumbing, sign, zoning and other similar type codes which
may be adopted by the City of Palm Beach Gardens in the future which regulate aesthetics,
construction, safety, use of property, or location of any structure on real property in the City of Palm
Beach Gardens. This authority is granted via Ordinance No. 8-1995, Section 1, and "Jurisdiction
Special Magistrate I 2. 03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
ORDER OF BUSINESS: The normal order of business for hearings of agenda items is as
follows:
Swearing in of City Staff
Presentation and Testimony of Case by City Staff
Swearing in of Defendant I Witnesses
Testimony of Defendant I Witnesses
Discussion of Case
Motion on Floor
Decision by Special Magistrate
I. REPORT FROM OPERATION DIRECTOR:
Next Special Magistrate Hearing on January 7, 2008 at 5:30P.M.
I. POSTPONEMENTS:
II. COMPLIED CASES:
III. VIOLATION CASES:
A. CaseNo.
07-09-1474
Property Owner
Evelyn & Paul H. Guay
4133 Lake Spur Circle South
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Violation Location:
10048 Plant Drive
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
PCN: 52-42-42-12-00-000-5080
LEGAL: 12-42-42-,73.63 Ft ofS 297.26 ft ofw 140ft ofE 290Ft.
2
Special Magistrate 12. 03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
Code Section Violated:
78-112 Building Permit
Violation Description:
Apply for permits to repair the driveway and for the installation of the doors
Code Compliance Officer:
Robert Creston
B. CaseNo.
07-10-1625
Property Owner
Janet B. Price Trust
C/0 Susan A. Gammino
201 Debra Lane
Palm Beach, FL 33480
Violation Location:
30 Via Del Corso
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33418
PCN: 52-42-42-10-14-000-0790
LEGAL: PGA RESORT COMMUNITY PL OF VILLA D ESTE LT 79
Code Section Violated:
86-194 Clarity ofWater
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
Violation Description:
Repair/ replace damaged roof, permits may apply
Clean and maintain pool to be clear at all times
Code Compliance Officer:
Robert Creston
C. Case No.
07-09-1529
Property Owner
Robert G. & VictoriaS. Hook
297 Mulberry Circle
Jupiter, FL 33458
3
Special Magistrate 12.03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
Violation Location:
8922 Dania Drive
PCN: 52-42-42-24-00-000-1420
LEGAL: 24-42-42, S 95FT OF N 470FT OF E 110FT OF N% OF NW Y4 OF NE
1,1.;
Code Section Violated:
78-395 Recreational vehicles and watercraft
Violation Description:
Boat and R V shall be properly screened or removed from property
Code Compliance Officer
Robert Creston
D. CaseNo.
07-04-794
Property Owner
Nancy W. Clark
4401 Bellewood Street
Jupiter, FL 33458-2849
Violation Location:
4401 Bellewood Street
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33418
PCN: 52-42-42-13-05-042-0030
LEGAL: UNIT NO 5 PALM BEACH SQUARE LT 3 BLK 42
Code Section Violated:
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
78-329 Maintenance Required
Violation Description:
Mow, cut, trim and prune all overgrown landscape to include but not limited to the
front, rear, and sides of property and keep maintained. Remove trash plywoods,
bicycles in front patio area, ladder extension cord, buckets and building materials on
Eastside of property, bicycles and boards along fence on Westside and keep
maintained. Paint exterior ofhome. Remove all boards from windows. Obtain permit
to install or replace windows
Code Compliance Officer:
4
Special Magistrate 12.03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
Alex Lopez
E. CaseNo.
07-07-1354
Property Owner
Julie M. O'Rourke
527 Riverside Drive
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Violation Location:
527 Riverside Drive
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33418
PCN: 52-42-43-42-18-03-005-0060
LEGAL: PL 1 PALM BEACH GARDEN ESTATES LT 6 BLK 5
Code Section Violated:
54-58 Placement for collection
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
78-329 Maintenance
Violation Description:
Mow, cut, trim and prune all overgrown landscape to include but not limited to the
front, rear, and sides of property and keep maintained. Remove all open/ exposed
storage, trash and debris. Remove plywood boards in rear. All trash and recycle
containers to be placed away from public view when not in use. Paint exterior of
home including all peeling paint, facia and soffit area.
Code Compliance Officer:
Alex Lopez
F. CaseNo.
07-09-1498
Property Owner
PBG Loehmanns Realty LLC
4851 Tamiami Trail North Ste 300
Naples, FL 34103-3098
Violation Location:
4100 PGA Blvd
5
Special Magistrate 12. 03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33418
PCN: 52-42-42-01-00-000-5010
LEGAL: 1-42-42, TH PT OF SE Yt LYG SELY OF PGA BLVD, ELY OF SR 9,
WLY OF RCA DR (LESS S 310FT, SELY SWLY 145.04 FT OF NELY
Code Section Violated:
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
78-284 Prohibited signs and prohibited sign locations
78-290 Temporary Signs Allowed
78-308 Compliance
78-313 Minimum Landscape requirements for nonresidential development
Violation Description:
Replace all missing/damaged roof tiles. Pressure clean entire roof to be free of
stains/mildew. Repair all holes and/or breaks on building exterior. Pressure clean and
paint entire building exterior and monument signs to be free of stains/mildew and
peeling paint. Remove from property all abandoned equipment, appliances, trash,
debris and open storage to include but not limited to donation box in parking lot and
abandoned electrical conduit/ wires and electrical panel enclosures in rear. Repair
and/or replace all damaged signage. Remove all prohibited banners and signs to
include but not limited to (3) Interiors Showroom and Tuesday Morning banner. All
dumpsters must be placed in their designated areas and enclosed. Repair
damaged/missing dumpster enclosures. Permits and inspections may apply; refer to
Building Department
Per City Forester: Mow, cut, trim and prune all overgrown vegetation on property
to include retention area at rear, area between bank and cinema. Replace all dead,
missing and/or damaged trees, hedges, shrubs, exotic vegetations, mulch and sod.
Code Compliance Officer
Alex Lopez
G. Case No.
07-10-1590
Property Owner
James H. Rainey
4146 Hickory Drive
6
Special Magistrate 12.03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33418-3902
Violation Location:
4146 Hickory Drive
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33418
PCN: 52-42-42-12-02-006-0120
LEGAL: PGA NATIONAL GOLF CLUB EST 1 LT 12 BLK 6
Code Section Violated:
34-181 Nuisance Declared
54-58 Placement for collection
78-329 Maintenance
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
Violation Description:
Mow, cut, trim and prune all overgrown landscape to include but not limited to the
front, rear, and sides of property and keep maintained. Remove all open/exposed
storage, trash and debris, plywood, concrete block, battery in the front of property.
Garbage containers must be removed away from public view when not in use.
Vehicles on property must be operable, registered and display tags at all times.
Code Compliance Officer:
Alex Lopez
H. CaseNo.
07-10-1624
Property Owner
Ronsal RCA
17674 Scarsdale Way
Boca Raton, FL 33496
Violation Location:
4050 PGA Blvd
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33418
PCN: 52-42-43-42-18-03-005-0060
LEGAL: 1 -42-42, PAR IN SE V4 OF SE V4 L YG W OF & ADJ TO RCA DR AS IN
OR3710P434
Code Section Violated:
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
7
Special Magistrate 12. 03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
78-290 Temporary signs allowed
78-308 Compliance
Violation Description:
Repair or replace all missing, broken, damaged building exterior. Pressure dean and
paint entire building exterior. Remove from property all trash and debris. Replace
missing/ damaged electrical panel enclosure in rear. Repair or replace all damaged/
missing exterior light fixtures on property. Obtain permit for Real Estate sign or
remove sign from property. Repair damaged dumpster enclosure. Permits and
inspections may apply.
Code Compliance Officer:
Alex Lopez
I. Case No.
07-10-1628
Property Owner
Harbour Properties of Florida INC
4060 PGA Blvd Ste 204
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Violation Location:
4060 PGA Blvd
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33418
PCN: 52-42-42-01-00-000-5014
LEGAL: PL 1 PALM BEACH GARDEN ESTATES LT 6 BLK 5
Code Section Violated:
78-329 Maintenance
Violation Description:
Mow, cut, trim and prune all overgrown landscape on west and south sides of
property.
Code Compliance Officer:
Alex Lopez
J. Case No.
07-11-1658
8
Special Magistrate 12. 03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
Violation Description:
Fence repair color needs to be continual with the rest of the fence. Replace soil and
resod the area between homes at 1071 and 1072. Sod areas in front of the hedge and
in patchy spots on front lawn.
Code Compliance Officer:
Ruth Nelson-Peeples
L. Case No.
07-10-1603
Property Owner
Grande at Palm Beach Gardens Inc.
1601 Forum Place Suite 80S
West Palm Beach, FL 33401-8108
Violation Location:
Preserve behind Harbour Oaks
PCN: 52-43-42-07-28-000-0720
LEGAL: Siena Oaks LT 72
Code Section Violated:
78-303 Approval Required
78-316 Preserve areas
78-742 Remedies
Resolution 81, 2003-proposed retammg walls and drainage system between
residential buildings and the preserve area
Violation Description:
Cutting branches off 19 or more trees and removal of at least one tree -irreparable
and irreversible damage done to a protected reserve.
Code Compliance Officer:
Ruth Nelson-Peeples
M. CaseNo.
07-11-1668
Property Owner
Regina Gagne
585 Riverside Drive
10
Special Magistrate 12.03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410-4844
Violation Location:
585 Riverside Drive
PCN: 52-43-42-18-03-005-0180
LEGAL: PLAT 1 PALM BEACH GARDEN ESTS LT 18 BLK 5
Code Section Violated:
78-393 Parking and storage restrictions for commercial vehicles
Violation Description:
Boat must be properly parked and screened or removed from premises
Code Compliance Officer:
Ruth Nelson-Peeples
N. Case No.
07-10-1557
Property Owner
Carey T. Prince
4321 Crestdale Street
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Violation Location:
4321 Crestdale Street
PCN: 52-42-42-13-06-039-0090
LEGAL: PALM BEACH SQUARE UNIT 6 LOT 9 BLK 39
Code Section Violated:
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
78-393 Parking and storage restrictions for commercial vehicles
Violation Description:
Remove debris, outdoor storage i.e., tools, containers, tires, wood, metal construction
equipment and supplies from front yard areas
Remove prohibited trailer from front yard area
Code Compliance Officer:
Michael Williams
0. Case No.
07-10-1600
11
Special Magistrate 12. 03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
Property Owner
Gregory F. & Juanita I. Dziekan
11856 Bayberry Street
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Violation Location:
11856 Bayberry Street
PCN: 52-42-42-01-02-035-0100
LEGAL: PL NO 4 CITY OF P B GARDENS LT 1 BLK 35
Code Section Violated:
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
Violation Description:
Repair and/or replace blue tarp roof. A permit is required for this work.
Code Compliance Officer:
Ruth Nelson-Peeples
P. Case No.
07-09-1532
Property Owner
James Bellew
3710 Cosmos Street
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Violation Location:
3710 Cosmos Street
PCN: 52-43-42-18-04-019-0130
LEGAL: PL NO 3 CITY OF P B GARDENS LT 13 BLK 19
Code Section Violated:
86-194 Clarity ofWater
86-222 Enclosure required
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
Violation Description:
Pool requires cleaning
Pool requires 4' enclosure (b) for acceptable forms ofbarriers
Repair and/or all rotted wood, missing wood around facia, soffit. Repair roof
appropriately and remove all boarding from windows and/or doors
12
Special Magistrate 12.03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
House requires painting, faded dirty and/or peeling areas are evident
Remove debris, outdoor storage i.e., tools, containers, tires, wood, metal, containers,
construction equipment and supplies from front and side yard areas in public view
Code Compliance Officer:
Michael Williams
Q. CaseNo.
07-10-1614
Property Owner
Vincent Bellafiore
9361 Applecrest Drive
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Violation Location:
9361 Applecrest Drive
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
PCN: 52-42-42-13-05-041-0250
LEGAL: UNIT NO 5 PALM BEACH SQUARE LT 25 BLK 41
Code Section Violated:
66-46 Engaging in business without license or upon false statements
Violation Description:
Cease from operating outside scope of home based business license, i.e., storing
distributing and/or receiving product at 9361 Applecrest Drive
Code Compliance Officer:
Michael Williams
R. Case No.
07-09-1527
Property Owner
Magda Castillo
9626 North Military Trail
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Violation Location:
9626 N. Military Trail
13
Special Magistrate 12.03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
PCN: 52-42-42-12-01-069-0251
LEGAL: CITY OF P B GARDENS NO 6 LT 25/LESS S 10 FT I BLK 69
Code Section Violated:
34-122 Owner to keep property clear of rubbish, vegetation
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
Violation Description:
Grass and/or weeds must be cut and maintained at all times. Drain fountains of all
dirty stagnant water. Remove all recyclable bins and trash cans from front yard areas.
Remove trash, debris, and storage from front yard areas.
Code Compliance Officer:
Michael Williams
S. Case No.
07-11-1671
Property Owner
Debra & Gary Stavis
18 Cromwell Drive
Mendham, NJ 07949
Violation Location:
4 Glencaim Road
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
PCN: 52-42-42-09-01-000-0330
LEGAL: PGA RESORT COMMUNITY PL 3 LT 33
Code Section Violated:
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
78-329 Maintenance Required
86-194 Clarity of Water
Violation Description:
Mow, trim, cut and prune all overgrown landscape to include the rear, front, and
sides of property.
Clean and maintain pool and spa to be clear at all times.
Code Compliance Officer:
Alex Lopez
14
Special Magistrate 12.03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
T. Case No.
07-11-1711
Property Owner
Harris Kervelle
69 Dunbar Road
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Violation Location:
69 Dunbar Road
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
PCN: 52-42-42-08-01-000-1280
LEGAL: PGA RESORT COMMUNITY PL 6 IN PB47P153 LT 128
Code Section Violated:
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
78-329 Maintenance Required
86-194 Clarity ofWater
Violation Description:
Mow, cut, trim and prune all overgrown landscape to include but not limited to the
front, rear and sides of property and keep maintained. Remove all trash and debris
from property and keep maintained. Clean and maintain pool clear at all times.
Code Compliance Officer:
Alex Lopez
U. Case No.
07-11-1710
Property Owner
Thomas Marianna
4 Dunbar Road
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33418
Violation Location:
4 Dunbar Road
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33418
PCN: 52-42-42-08-01-000-0040
15
Special Magistrate 12. 03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
LEGAL: PGA RESORT COMMUNITY PL 6 IN PB47P153 LT 4
Code Section Violated:
79-5 Maintenance and appearance standards for all structures and landscaping
78-329 Maintenance Required
86-194 Clarity ofWater
Violation Description:
Mow, cut, trim and prune all overgrown landscape to include but not limited to the
front, rear and sides of property and keep maintained. Remove all trash and debris
from property and keep maintained. Clean and maintain pool clear at all times.
Code Compliance Officer:
Alex Lopez
V. REQUEST FOR AN EXTENSION OF TIME:
VI. REHEARING
VII. LIEN CERTIFICATION
VIII. RELEASE OF LIEN
IX. NOTICE OF FAILURE TO COMPLY
X. REQUEST FOR REDUCTION OF FINE
A. Case No.
07-06-1095
Property Owner(s):
Jon M. Rosenthal, Development Manager
Ram Reality Services
4801 PGA Blvd
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
16
(NONE)
(NONE)
(NONE)
(NONE)
(NONE)
Special Magistrate 12. 03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
Violation Location:
Midtown-Borland Center
4751 PGA Blvd
Code Section Violated:
Resolution 6, 2006
78-261 Installation of Artwork
Violation Description:
Failure to install art work in public places at Midtown-Borland Center
Code Compliance Supervisor
Mohammad Jamal
B. CaseNo.
07-06-1103
Property Owner(s):
U S Land Holdings LLC
P 0 Box 30633
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33420
Violation Location:
5490 Hood Road
PCN: 52-42-41-35-00-000-1060
Legal: 35-41-42, NLY 340.81 FT OF WLY531.38 FT OF W% OF N Yz OF SW
~OF NE 114 (LESS TH PT IN OR5581P451)
Code Section Violated:
34-121 Enumerated conditions prohibited, declared nuisance
34-122 Owner to keep property clear of rubbish, vegetation
Violation Description:
Remove all trash, debris, garbage, and junk from property
Cut, trim, mow all overgrown grass, weeds, vegetation on entire lot and properly
maintained
Code Compliance Officer:
Alex Lopez
17
Special Magistrate 12. 03.07
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DECEMEBER 3, 2007
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5:30P.M.
XI. OLD BUSINESS-CASE UPDATE
XII. DISCUSSION
XIII. ADJOURN
18
Special Magistrate 12. 03.07
(NONE)
(NONE)