HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda P&Z 081010� ` J
�.}�y
* * . _
���+�'{ *
�■ �� '�i:'-
� ,�;:.:.� �
•�', ��':
�G�
AGENDA
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
PLANNING, ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD
TUESDAY, AUGUST 10, 2010 AT 6:00 P.M.
COUNCIL CHAMBERS
• CALL TO ORDER
• PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
• ROLL CALL
• ADDITIONS, DELETIONS, MODIFICATIONS
• REPORT BY THE DIRECTOR OF PLANNING AND ZONING:
NATALIE WONG
• APPROVAL OF MINUTES: 07/20/2010
PLANNING, ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD
Regular Members: Alternates:
Craig Kunkle Vacant (lst Alt.)
Barry Present Roma Josephs (2"d Alt.)
Randolph Hansen
Michael Panczak
Joy Hecht
Amir Kanel
Joanne Koerner
1. Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing)
CUMJ-10-07-000017 Calvary Chapel Jupiter — Major Conditional Use
A request from Nathan Murrell, agent for Calvary Chapel of Jupiter, Inc., to approve
Major Conditional Use for the church, located at Palm Beach Gardens High School on
the northeast corner of Military Trail and Holly Drive. The proposed church use includes
the use of the school's auditorium, cafeteria, and approximately seven (7) classrooms.
Project Manager, Kathryn Wilson, Planner, kwilson@pbgfl.com
Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board
August 10, 2010
2. Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing)
MISC-10-07-000073: PGA Marina Planned Unit Development (PUD)
A request from Anne Booth, the agent for PGA Marina Center, Ltd., to approve an
amendment to the PGA Marina PUD to increase the number of boat storage areas,
and modify the site and landscape plan. The subject site is located at the northwest
corner of PGA Boulevard and the Intracoastal Waterway.
Project Manager, Kathryn Wilson, Planner, kwilson@pbgfl.com
3. Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing)
LDRA-10-03-000029: City initiated request to amend the LDR's to revise the sign
Code
A City-initiated request to amend the City's Land Development Regulations
("LDRs") in order to comprehensively amend the sign regulations regarding the
purpose and intent, permitted signs, prohibited signs, other related issues, and certain
definitions.
Planning Manager, Martin Schneider, Planner, mschneider@pbgfl.com
4. Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearing)
LDRA-10-04-000031: Land Development Regulations changes to Section 78-187 for
Special Events, Section 78-191 for Outdoor Seating, Section 78-290 for Temporary
Signage, and Section 78-751 for Definitions
A City-initiated request to amend the City's Land Development Regulations ("LDRs") in
order to clarify and revise the special events, outdoor seating, temporary signage, and
definitions sections.
Project Manager, Allyson Black, Resource Manager, ablack@pbgflcom
5. OLD BUSINESS
6. NEW BUSINESS
7. ADJOURNMENT
!n accordance with the Americans with Disabilifies Act and Floricla Statute 286.26, persons with disabilities needing special accommodations to
participate in thas proceeding should contact the Caty Clerk's Office, no later than five days prior to the proceeding. at telephone number (561)
799-4120 for assistance; if hearing zmpaired, telephone the Floricta Re[ay Service Numbers (800) 955-8771 (TDD) or (800) 955-8770 (VOICE),
for assistance. If a perso:2 deczdes to appea[ any decision made by the P[anning, Zoning and Appeals Board, Loca[ Planning Agency, or Lund
Developmer�t Regulatioves Commission, with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, they will need a record of the
proceedings; and for such, they may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and
evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Exact [ega[ description and/or survey for the cases may be obtained from the files irr the Growth
Management Department.
Common/pz agenda 08.10.2010
2
�
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
PLANNING, ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD
REGULAR MEETING
J�JL�' Zoy 2010
The regular meeting was called to order at 6:00 p.m. by Chair Craig Kunkle.
I. CALL TO ORDER
II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
III. ROLL CALL
1 o Members Present: Chair Craig Kunkle, Vice Chair Michael
i l Hecht, Amir Kanel, Barry Present.
12 Members Absent: Joanne Koerner.
13 Also Present: City Attorney R. Max Lohman; Planning and Zoni
14 IV. ADDITIONS, DELETIONS AND MODIFICATION
�
16
None.
V. REPORT BY GROWTH
17 Planning and Zonin� Director Won� reported the City
18 Planned Community Development (PCD) Amendment (Resol
19 VI. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
20 Michael Panczak made a motion to appro,ve the June 29, 201
21 Barry Present seconded.
22 Motion passed 6-0.
23 VII. PUBLIC HEARINGS
24 Those preparing to give testimony were sworn in,
approved the
; 2010).
Hansen, Joy
Wong.
National
25 1. Recommendation to Citv Council (Public Hearing)'(Quasi-Judicial Hearing)
2� MISC-10-01-000065: A request by Donald Ross Military LLC, for approval to locate one (1)
27 flat wall sign above �he second floor-line on the north:elevation of Building H, and re-orient two
28 (2) monument signs located al�ng DQr�ald Ross� Road. The Donald Ross Village PUD is
29 approximately 45-acres and' is, ]ocated a�on� the south side of Donald Ross Road between
KL
31
32
33
34
35
Military
Chair
opened the pi
�t: None.
closed the pu
�sen <made a n
3� Joy Hechtseconde
37 Motion passed 6-0.
Kilday Studios.
hearing.
►n for approval.
38 2. Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearin�)
39 LDRA-10-03-000029t Citv initiated request to amend the LDR's to revise the si�n Code: A
4o City-initiated request to amend the City's Land Development Regulations ("LDRs") in order to
41 comprehensively amend the sign regulations regarding the purpose and intent, permitted signs,
42 prohibited signs, other related issues, and certain definitions.
43 Presentation bv: Planner Martin Schneider.
44 Chair Kunkle opened the public hearin�.
45 Public Comment: Joev Eichner, PGA Corridor Association; Anne Booth, Urban Design Kilday
46 Studios.
PLANNING� ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD REGULAR MEETING Page 1
07•20• 10
i
2
3
4
5
6
7
s
�
lo
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
Chair Kunkle closed the public hearing.
Discussion ensued.
Barry Present made a motion for postponement to date certain August 10, 2010.
Michael Panczak seconded.
Motion passed 6-0.
3. Recommendation to City Council (Public Hearin�)
LDRA-10-04-000031: Land Development Re�ulations chan�es to Section 78-187 for Special
Events, Section 78-191 for Outdoor_Seating, Section 78-290 for Temporary Si�nage, and
Section 78-751 for Deiinitions: A City-initiated request to amend
Regulations ("LDRs") in order to clarify and revise the spe
temporary signage, and definitions sections.
Presentation bv: Resource Manager Allvson Black.
Chair Kunkle opened the public hearing.
Public Comment: Eileen Tucker, 1045 Shady Lakes Circle,
DeFrancesco, 1049 Shady Lakes Circle, Palm Beach`Gardens;
Association. � `
Chair Kunkle closed the public hearing.
Discussion ensued.
Barry Present made a motion for postponement to date certain Au
seconded. _
21 Motion passed 6-0.
22 VIII. OLD BUSINESS
23 None.
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
IX. NEW BUSINESS
None.
PLANNING, ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD REGULAR MEETING
07•20• 10
s Land Development
ts, outdoor seating,
Palm
Joev ]
10, 2010.
Gardens; Vito
PGA Corridor
Page 2
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
X. ADJOURNMENT
Chair Kunkle adjourned the �neeting at 7:23 p.m.
The next regular meeting will be held August 10, 2010.
APPROVED:
Alr
Craig Kunkle, Chair
Donna M. Cannoza
IWlunicipal Sexvzces Caordinatar
Note: These minutes are prepared in compfiance with 286.011 F.S. and are not verbatim transcripts of the
meeting.
All referenced attachments are on file in the Office of the City Clerk.
Note: All those preparing to give testimony were sworn in.
PLANNING, ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD REGULAR MEETING
07•20• 10
Page 3
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
PLANNING & ZOIVING COMMISSION
Agenda Cover Memorandum
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition No. CUMJ-10-07-000017
SUBJECT/AGENDA ITEM
CUMJ-10-07-000017 Calvary Chapel Jupiter — Major Conditional Use
Public Hearing and Recommendation to City Council: A request from Nathan Murrell,
agent for Calvary Chapel of Jupiter, Inc., to approve Major Conditional Use forthe church,
located at Palm Beach Gardens High School on the northeast corner of Military Trail and
Holly Drive. The proposed church use includes the use of the school's auditorium,
cafeteria, and approximately seven (7) classrooms.
[X] Recommendation to APPROVE
[ ] Recommendation to DENY
Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: FINANCE: PZAB Action:
Planning and Zoning:
City Attorney: Rec. a roval
Finance L l Pp
Proj�ct�Manager: Administrator: [] Rec. app. w/ cond.
R. Max Lohman, Esq. `�:��' [] Rec. Denial
Kate Wilson N/A [] Continued to:
Development AI►an Owens
Compliance: Re�ource Manager:
�� f�
Bahareh K. Wolfs, AICP Allyson Black Accountant:
[X] Quasi — Judicial Attachments:
Director of lanning and L] Legislative ❖ Resolution 28, 2007
Zo 'n : [X] Public Hearing Sarah Varga '�' Location Map
❖ Project Narrative
❖ Traffic Statement
Advertised: Fees Paid: [X] �:• Sign Location Plan
atalie M. Wong, AICP Date: July 28, 2010 Yes •:� Sign Exhibit
Paper: Palm Beach •:� Traffic Circulation
Approved By: Post Budget Acct.#: Plan
City Manager [X] Required N/A
[ ] Not Required
Ronald M. Ferris A►ffected Parties:
[X] Notified
( ] Not Required
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition: CUMJ-10-07-000017
Page 2 of 9
BACKGROUND
Resolution 28, 2007, approved the Palm Beach Gardens High School site plan and major
conditional use for the school (see attached Resolution 28, 2007). The site is
approximately 40 acres and is located on Military Trail between Lilac Street and Holly Drive
(see attached Location Map).
Palm Beach Gardens High School would like to allow the Calvary Chapel Church to utilize
their facilities on Sunday mornings. The church will be holding one (1) service on Sunday
mornings only, and will occupy the existing auditorium, which contains 850 seats. The
church anticipates using a total of 400 seats on a weekly basis; however the proposed
conditional use assumes the use of the total number of seats in the auditorium. In addition
to the auditorium, the church would occupy the school cafeteria and various classrooms for
their children's ministry. The church will only operate on the site on Sunday mornings, and
will not utilize the school facilities at any other time (see attached Project Narrative).
LAND USE & ZONING
The subject site has a Future Land Use designation of Public (P) and an underlying zoning
designation of Public or Institutional (P/I) with a Conditional Use (CU) overlay.
Table 1. Existing Land Use and Zoning Designations
• � �
Subiect Property
Palm Beach Gardens High School PUD / P/I / CU P
North
Golfers Village RM RM
Lilac Park P/I ROS
South
Plat 6 RL3 RL
East
Plant Drive Park P/I ROS
Nativity Lutheran Church RM RM
W est
Palm Gardens Condominiums, RM RM
Garden Trail, Golf Estates Villas
CONCURRENCY
The proposed use was evaluated by the City's Traffic Consultant and determined to be in
compliance with the Countywide Traffic Performance Standards (see attached Traffic
Statement).
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition: CUMJ-10-07-000017
Page 3 of 9
PROJECT DETAILS
Project Site
The proposed use will be located within the existing Palm Beach Gardens High School
building. No site or building modifications are proposed to accommodate the use.
Parkinq
The approved site plan for Palm Beach Gardens High School contains 731 parking spaces.
Based on the City's parking requirements, the church requires 283 parking spaces
(calculation is based on 850 seats). Since the church will only occupy the school facilities
on Sunday mornings when school is not taking place, the church will utilize the existing
parking spaces on site, which well exceeds the church's parking requirement. The
attached Traffic Circulation Plan shows the traffic flow and designated church parking area.
Site Access
No changes to the existing access are proposed with this petition. The site currently has
two (2) vehicular access points on Lilac Street and two (2) on Holly Drive. The Applicant
proposes to have two (2) police officers on site to assist in directing and monitoring the
traffic flow. As shown on the attached Traffic Circulation Plan, the church patrons will
enter and exit the site from Lilac Street (western most entrance). Upon exiting, southbound
vehicles will be directed to turn right on Lilac Street and use Holly Drive to make a left turn
onto Military Trail. Northbound vehicles will be directed to turn left on Lilac Street towards
Military Trail. A condition of approval requiring the presence of at least one (1) police
officer has been included to ensure the traffic is well monitored.
Si.qnaqe
The Applicant is proposing three (3) directional signs (see attached Sign Location Plan).
All three (3) signs are temporary in nature in the sense that they will only be displayed on
Sunday mornings during church operations. The signs are intended to direct the church
patrons to the designated parking area upon entering on site, and into the appropriate
lanes upon exiting.
Sign 1 will be located at the northwest corner of the subject site along Military Trail, Signs 2
and 3 will be located internal to the designated parking area. All three (3) signs meet the
standards in the City's sign code (see attached Sign Exhibits).
In addition, the City will be installing a traffic directional sign on Lilac Street directing traffic
exiting the site northbound and southbound on Military Trail, as shown on the Sign
Location Plan. This will alleviate traffic until the intersection light is installed.
Landscapin.q
No changes to the existing landscaping are proposed with this petition.
Phasinq
The conditional
use will not be completed in phases.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition: CUMJ-10-07-000017
Page 4 of 9
Drainaqe
No changes to the existing drainage are proposed with this petition.
MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE ANALYSIS
Section 78-159, Permitted, Conditional and Prohibited Use Chart, allows a Place of
Worship within a P/I zoning district as a Major Conditional Use. A Conditional Use Analysis
has been conducted in accordance with Section 78-52, Conditional Uses, (d) Criteria, of
the Land Development Regulations.
The following is Staff's analysis based on the criteria set forth in Section 78-52(d),
Conditional Uses:
1) Comprehensive Plan. The proposed use is consistent with the comprehensive
plan.
The comprehensive plan designation for this site is Public (P). The zoning designation
is Public or Institutional (P/I), which is consistent with the comprehensive plan
designation. The proposed use of a church is a conditional use within the P/I district.
The proposed use is consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan.
2) Chapter requirements. The proposed use is consistent with all applicable
requirements of this chapter.
The proposed major conditional use is consistent with all requirements of Chapter 78.
3) Standards. The proposed use is consistent with the standards for such use as
provided in Section 78-159.
The proposed use is consistent with the standards listed in Section 78-159, Table 21
Permitted, Conditional and Prohibited Use Chart: Place of Worship (note 49).
(Note 49) Churches and places of worship shall comply with the standards
provided below:
(a) Less than 1,000 permanent seats or approved capacity may be located as a
major conditional use in any residential zoning district, and in CG-1, CG-2,
and P&I zoning districts.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition: CUMJ-10-07-000017
Page 5 of 9
(b) More than 1,000 permanent seats or approved capacity may be located as a
major conditional use in the following districts: CG-1, CG-2, PI, M-1, M-1A,
and M-2.
(c) Typical uses associated with churches and places of worship include the
following:
1. Sanctuaries, assembly halls, or similar large meeting rooms where
religious services are held;
2. Community centers or fellowship halls, which may be the site of
religious services, but also used for community, athletic, fraternal,
social, civic, charitable, and recreational programs;
3. Offices utilized for administrative purposes related to the operation of
the church or place of worship;
4. Religious merchandise or merchandise related to the operation of the
house of worship may be sold in an accessory retail facility;
5. Playgrounds and athletic fields; and
6. Rectory or similar residence for religious officials, limited to one per
place of worship.
(d) The following uses may be included within any major conditional use
approval granted by the city council to establish a church or place of
worship, or as an additional major conditional use operating as part of the
facility:
1. School, elementary or secondary;
2. Day care, child;
3. Day care, adult;
4. Assisted living facility; and
5. Monastery or convent.
(e) Additional standards applicable to churches and places of worship are
provided below.
�
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition: CUMJ-10-07-000017
Page 6 of 9
1. Up to 50 percent of required parking may be grassed consistent with
section 78-372 of this chapter.
2. Minimum lot size is two (2) acres.
3. Churches and places of worship with more than 1,000 seats or approved
capacity shall be Iocated on and provide primary vehicular access from
the following roadways: city collector, county minor arterial, state minor
arterial, state, or state principal arterial.
4. Lighting for athletic fields, parking lots, and security shall be shielded
from adjacent residential zoning districts.
5. All day care centers, elementary or secondary schools, monasteries or
convents, or assisted living facilities shall provide primary vehicular
access from the following roadways: city collector, county minor
arterial, state minor arterial, state, or state principal arterial.
(f) Temporary uses such as special events, outside services, seasonal sales,
seasonal displays, other events of a limited nature may require a special
events permit or approval as required in section 78-187.
The Applicant acknowledges these requirements.
Public welfare
welfare by:
The proposed use provides for the public health, safety, and
(a) Providing for a safe and effective means of pedestrian access;
No changes to the existing pedestrian access points are proposed with this petition.
The parking lot and internal access provide safe and efficient pedestrian access to
the existing buildings.
(b) Providing for a safe and effective means of vehicular ingress and egress;
No changes to the existing vehicular access points are proposed with this petition.
The Applicant plans to hire police officers to assist in the monitoring and directing of
traffic generated by the proposed use. In addition, the traffic directional signs
proposed as part of the petition will assist in providing safe vehicular circulation.
(c)
Providing for an adequate roadway system adjacent to and in front of the
site;
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition: CUMJ-10-07-000017
Page 7 of 9
No changes to the existing points of ingress and egress are proposed with this
petition. The Applicant plans to hire police officers to assist in the monitoring and
directing of traffic generated by the proposed use. In addition, the traffic directional
signs proposed as part of the petition will assist in providing safe vehicular circulation.
(d) Providing for a safe and efficient onsite traffic circulation, parking, and
overall control; and
The Applicant has submitted a Traffic Circulation Plan that shows the manner in
which the patrons will enter and exit the site and provides a designated parking area.
In addition, a Traffic Statement has been included that demonstrates that the church
meets the Countywide Traffic Performance Standards.
(e) Providing adequate access for public safety purposes, ineluding fire and
police protection.
No changes to the existing site configuration are proposed with this petition.
5) Screening and bufFering. The proposed use utilizes such techniques as
landscaping, screening, buffering, site or building design, or business operation
procedures to mitigate impacts on surrounding properties, including such
impacts as:
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
��
�J)
(h)
(i)
�J)
Noise,
Glare,
Odor,
Ground, wall, or roof-mounted mechanical equipment,
Perimeter, interior, and security lighting,
Signs,
Waste disposal and recycling,
Outdoor storage of inerchandise and vehicles,
Visual impact,
Hours of operation.
The proposed use will occupy an existing school facility and will not have any negative
impact on the surrounding properties. The church will utilize the school's indoor
auditorium; therefore, there will be no outdoor noise generated. The use will not
produce a glare or odor, does not require additional mechanical equipment or lighting,
will utilize existing waste disposal and recycling, will not store merchandise or vehicles
outdoors, and does not have a negative visual impact. The church has proposed
signage, which was discussed above, and will only operate on Sunday mornings.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition: CUMJ-10-07-000017
Page 8 of 9
6) Utilities. The proposed use minimizes or eliminates the impact of utility
installation, including underground and overhead utilities, on adjacent
properties.
The proposed use will have no impact on utilities on or off the site.
7) Dimensional standards. The proposed use meets or exceeds all dimensional
requirement required by the chapter.
All applicable dimensional requirements have been met.
8) Neighborhood Plans. The proposed use is consistentwith the goals, objectives,
policies, and standards of neighborhood plans.
�'
There is no neighborhood plan for this area.
Compatibility. The overall compatibility of the proposed development with
adjacent and area uses, and character or area development.
The proposed use will occupy an existing school facility, which received a similar major
conditional use approval. The use is permitted within the zoning district, is
complimentary in nature to the existing use, and will not negatively affect the
surrounding development.
10) Patterns of development. The proposed use will result in logical, timely, and
orderly development patterns.
The proposed use does not require additional development.
11) Purpose and intent. The proposed use will be in harmony with the general
purpose and intent of this chapter and the goals, objectives, and policies of the
City.
This use is complimentary in nature to the existing use, and meets the intent of this
chapter.
12) Adverse impact. The design of the proposed use and structures will minimize
any adverse visual impacts or impacts caused by the intensity of the use.
The proposed use does not require additional development.
13) Environmental impact. The design of the proposed use minimizes any advers�
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition: CUMJ-10-07-000017
Page 9 of 9
impacts that may be created, including impact on environmental
resources including air, water, storm water management, wildlife,
and wetlands.
and natural
vegetation,
The proposed use does not require additional development; therefore, all
environmental impacts were assessed with the previous approval.
COMMENTS FROM THE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMITTEE (DRC)
On July 22, 2010, the subject petition was reviewed by the DRC committee. To date, no
objections have been received. Since then, staff has been working with the Applicant to
address comments related to the project through the review process.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends APPROVAL of petition CUMJ-10-07-000017 with the following
conditions:
1. The maximum number of seats permitted to be used by the church shall not exceed
850. Broadcasts to any other location outside the school auditorium intended to serve
more than the 850 permitted seats in the church is prohibited. This condition shall not
be construed to prohibit the broadcast or webcast of such services to other remote
locations or to individual personal computers or electronic devices. (Planning &
Zoning)
2. The church shall provide, at their expense, at least one (1) officer on site during the
designated church hours to assist in the control of the traffic circulation. (Planning &
Zoning)
3. The signage approved with the subject petition is reserved for the church use only.
The church signage is permitted to be displayed only on Sunday mornings during
designated church hours. (Planning & Zoning)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
30
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
Date Prepared: February 28, 2007
�ttt� #�tT1�C1dt7ik'I��S �'1"c�j36���i:t�}t �t;Ot�{: F�t��3`#�
RESOLUTION 28, 2007
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM
BEACH GARDENS, FLORlDA APPROVING THE SITE PLAN AND A
MAJOR CONDITIONAL USE FOR THE 39.74-ACRE PARCEL OF
LAND, GENERALLY LOCATED AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF
LlLAC STREET AND MILITARY TRAI�, AS MORE PARTICULARLY
DESCRIBED HEREIN, TO BE REFERRED TO AS THE "PALM
BEACH GARDENS HIGH SCHOOL"; ALLOWING THE
REDEVELOPMENT OF THE EXISTING HIGH SCHOOL;
PROVIDING FOR A WAIVER; PROVIDING FOR CONDITIONS OF
APPROVAL; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City has received Petitions PPUD 06-12-000012 and CUMJ 06-
03-000003, which includes a request #or a major conditional use and site plan approval
to allow the demolition of the existing high school and the construction of a new high
school facility on the 39.74-acre site, generally located at the southeast corner of Lilac
Street and Military Trail, as more particularly described herein, ta be referred to as
"Palm Beach Gardens High School"; and
WHEREAS, the subject site has a land-use designation of Public (P) and a
Public or Institutional (PI) zoning classification with a Conditional Use overlay; and
WHEREAS, the Growth Management Department has reviewed said application,
has determined that it is sufficient, and has recommended its approval; and
WHEREAS, the Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board reviewed said application
at a public hearing at its January 9, 2�07, meeting and voted 7-0 to recommend its
approval to the City Council; and
WHEREAS, the City Council has considered the evidence and testimony
presented by the Applicant and other interested parties and the recommendations of the
various City of Palm Beach Gardens review agencies and staff; and
WHEREAS, the City Council has determined that adoption of this Resolution is in
the best interest of the citizens and residents of the City of Palm Beach Gardens.
NOW, THEREFOR�, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA that:
SECTION 1. The foregoing recitals are hereby affirmed and ratified.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
Date Prepared: February 28, 2007
Resolution 28, 2007
iNit::A 'en�men#:::::�ra''�s�d<Ei'€;�e:::`:E:::�s�rzf
_. .: h.:.,t?� :..:::... : ::::: :s::: :,::.p::: :.:::::::::Y:::::::�Q:: �::::::::::
SECTION 2. Petitions PPUD 06-12-000012 and CUMJ 06-03-000003 are hereby
APPROVED on the following described real property to allow the redevelopment of an
existing high schooi, generally lacated at the southeast corner of Lilac Street and
Military Trail, subject to the conditions of approval contained herein, which are in addition
to the general requirements otherwise provided by ordinance:
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
PALM BEACH GARDENS HIGH SCHOOL
LEGAL DESCRIPTION (PER TITLE COMMITMENT):
TME NORTH 1,000.00 FEET OF THE SOUTH 1,050.00 FEET OF THE WEST 875.00
FEET OF THE EAST 1,742.22 FEET OF THE SOUTHEAST QUARTER OF SECTION
12, TOWNSHIP 42 SOUTH, RANGE 42 EAST.
T�GETHER WITH
BEING A 1,000.00 FOOT BY 333.00 FOOT PARCEL OF LAND IN THE SOUTHEAST
QUARTER OF SECTION 12, TOWNSHIP 42 SOUTH, RANGE 42 EAST, CITY OF
PALM BEACH GARDENS, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORfDA; BE1NG MORE
PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
BEGINNING AT A POINT IN THE NORTHERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY OF HOLLY DRIVE
100.00 FEET WIDE AS SHOWN IN RECORD PLAT NO. 6, CITY OF PALM BEACH
GARDENS AS RECORDED OCTOBER 9, 1962 IN PLAT BOOK 27, PAGES 130, 131,
AND 132 OF PALM BEACH COUNTY RECORDS, SAID POINT BEING 568.00 FEET
EASTERLY (ALONG SAID NORTH RIGHT- OF-WAY OF HOLLY DRIVE) FROM THE
NORTH-SOUTH QUARTER SECTION LINE OF SAID SECTION 12; THENCE
NORTHERLY, AT RIGHT ANGLES TO SAID NORTH RIGHT-OF-WAY OF HOLLY
DRIVE, A DISTANCE OF 125.00 FEET TO A POINT; THENCE CONTINUING
NORTHERLY, AND PARALLEL TO THE EAST LINE OF SAID SECTION 12, A
DISTANCE OF 875.00 FEET TO A POINT: THENCE EASTERLY, AND PARALLEL TO
THE SOUTH LINE OF SECTION 12, A DISTANCE OF 333.10 FEET TO A POlNT;
THENCE SOUTHERLY, AND PARALLEL TO AND 1,742.22 FEET FROM THE EAST
LINE OF SECTION 12, A DISTANCE OF 1,000.00 FEET TO A POINT IN SAID NORTH
RIGHT-OF-WAY OF HOLLY DRfVE; THENCE WESTERLY AL.ONG SAID NORTH
RIGHT-OF-WAY OF HOLLY DRIVE, A DISTANCE OF 333.26 FEET TO THE POINT
OF BEGINNING.
TOGETHER WITN
A PARCEL OF LAND LYING IN THE SOUTHEAST QUARTER (1/4) CORNER OF
SAID SECTION 12, TOWNSHIP 42 SOUTH, RANGE 42 EAST, PALM BEACH
COUNTY, FLORIDA, AND MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
2
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
Date Prepared: February 28, 2007
Resolution 28, 2007
;`it ::,;1�::;:eridmen#s:: :":�><as�d'.::°.,,< `:tia `E:<�4�f'd
1A1: h :,::t?� ::::.::,::::::::. ,:. F�t;::.P::::.: :: ::b�:.�c,:.. o :.:. ..........
COMMENCE AT THE SOUTH QUARTER (1/4) CORNER OF SAID SECTION 12;
THENCE ALONG THE WEST LINE OF THE SAID SOUTHEAST QUARTER (1/4)
N00°40'21"E FOR 175.00 FEET; THENCE S89°14'29"E FOR 63.56 FEET TO THE
EASTER�Y R1GHT-OF-WAY LINE OF MILITARY TRAIL PER FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION RIGHT-OF-WAY MAP, SECTION 93600-
2608, STATE ROAD NO. S-809 AND THE POINT OF BEGINNING OF THE
FOLLOWING DESCRIBED PARCE�; THENCE CONTINUE S89°14'29"E FOR 504.44
FEET; THENCE PARALLEL WITH THE SAID WEST LINE OF THE SOUTHEAST
QUARTER {1/4) N00°40'21"E FOR 1025.00 FEET TO THE SOUTHERLY RIGHT-OF-
WAY LINE OF LILAC STREET; THENCE ALONG SAID SOUTHERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY
FOR THE FOLLOWING THREE (3) COURSES: (1) THENCE N89°14'29"W FOR
489.96 FEET TO THE POINT OF CURVATURE OF A CURVE CONCAVE TO THE
SOUTH, HAVING A RADIUS OF 25.00 FEET; (2) THENCE WESTERLY ALONG SAID
CURVE TO THE LEFT, THROUGH A CENTRAL ANGLE OF 12°58'40" FOR 5.66
FEET; (3) THENCE S38°01'37"W FOR 12.80 FEET TO A P�INT ON A NON-
TANGENT CURVE, CONCAVE TO THE WEST, NAVING A RADIUS OF 2,924.79
FEET, WHERE THE RADIAL LINE BEARS S88°22'43"W, SAID POINT LYING ON THE
SAID EASTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LlNE OF MILITARY TRAIL: THENCE ALONG SAfD
EASYERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY FOR THE FOLLOWING THREE (3) COURSES; (1)
THENCE SOUTHERLY ALONG SAID CURVE TO THE RIGHT THROUGH A
CEN7RAL ANGLE OF 21 °7'38" FOR 117.10 FEET TO A POINT OF TANGENCY; (2)
THENCE S00°40'21"W FOR 755.68 FEET TO THE POINT OF CURVATURE OF A
CURVE CONCAVE TO THE WEST, HAVING A RADIUS OF 2924.79 FEET; (3)
THENCE SOUTHERLY ALONG SAID CURVE TO THE RIGHT THROUGH A
CENTRAL ANGLE OF 2°46'18" FOR 141.49 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING.
TOGETHER WITH;
A PARCEL OF LAND LYING IN SECTION 12, TOWNSHIP 42 SOUTH, RANGE 42
EAST, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS
FOLLOWS:
THE SOUTH 969.88 FEET OF THE WEST 50 FEET OF THE EAST 867.22 FEET OF
THE SOUTHEAST '/4 OF SECTION 12, TOWNSHIP 42 SOUTH, RANGE 42 EAST,
LESS TNE SOUTH 50 FEET THEREOF FOR HOLLY DRIVE RIGHT-OF-WAY.
CONTAiNING 39.74 ACRES, MORE OR LESS.
�
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
Qate Prepared: February 28, 2007
Resolution 28, 2007
V�?itf�;:A�i'eitdrri�ri#s::i�r�s :::�s�d;i:p:':;i�c�i`aqE:::�p�r<#
_ :...:...:.:.:..:: ::...:...:...:.....p ........ Y........................._
SECTION 3. The City Council of the City of Palm Beach Gardens, Florida hereby
approves the foliowing waivers:
1. Section 78-144, Civic and institufiona/ zoning district regulations, Table 19,
waiver to increase the maximum building height by 6 inches.
SECTION 4. This approval is subject to the following conditions of approval,
which sha11 be the responsibility of the Applicant, its successors, or assigns:
Planninq and Zoninq
1.
2
one year after completion of the school modernization improvements,
perform an annual intersection analysis until the sooner of (1) five vears, ar
_ ... . .. . .... .. .. .....
_ . . . . . . . _....__. ._ _ _ _ .
(2) until such time as the ;: '
�pprc���l>i� t�btatr��d;. {Planning & Zoning, Police)
Upon completion and opening of the new parking lot off of Lilac Street, the
Citv shall be authorized to conduct periodic Traffic Operations Analvsis.
the Ci
(Planning & Zoning, Police)
�
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2Q
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
Date Prepared: February 28, 2007
Resolution 28, 2007
3. Approval of the subject appiication shall grant the Applicant the authority to
construct improvements for ingress and egress purposes within the property
identified as "Parcel 2" within the Easement Grant between the School
Board and the City of Palm Beach Gardens dated January 7, 1969. (ORB
1698; PAGE 1198) (Public Works, Planning & Zoning)
4. Alf on-site lighting shall be cast downward and shall be shielded from adjacent
residential properties. (Planning & Zoning)
Engineerinq
5. The Applicant shall copy to the City all permit applications, permits,
certifications, and approvals. (City Engineer)
6. The Applicant shall provide all necessary construction zone signage and
fencing as required by the City Engineer. (City Engineer)
7. The construction, operation, and/or maintenance of any elements of the
subject project shall not have any negative impacts on the existing drainage
of surrounding areas. If at any time durmg the project development it is
determined by the City Enq►rs�er'�nd �l�`� �ou#h� ���ar#�� �a#�r t�1lar�aq�rr�er�#
C1'i���' `fi that any of the surrounding areas are experiencing negative
drainage impacts caused by the project, it shall be the Applicant's
responsibility to cure said impacts in a period of time and a manner
acceptable to the City prior to additional construction activities. (City
Engineer)
8. The Applicant shall provide a letter of authorization from the utility easement
owners authorizing encroachment of the landscape buffers within their
respective utility easements. (City Engineer)
9. On or before May 1, 2008, the Applicant shall provide the City with a
drainage easement over the 50-foot-wide Parcel 5480, which runs along the
eastern property line. (City Engineer)
Police
10. Prior to the initiation of vertical construction, the
(Police, Planning & Zoning)
5
icant shall
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
11.
Street.
Miscellaneous
Date Prepared: February 28, 2007
Resolution 28, 2007
ti�it�i:;�;t?`iert�►ii:�t�#s:j�i'a `QS�d':;Ei ;;:;Sc�i'esol::�o�rzf
F? ....... ......�............................
in�ress/e�ress points.off of Lilac
-: <.:: < :,. ,.; :::;.:.:±:.: ::.:, ::..::: .:. :.. : ...:;;...: (Pol i ce)
12. The Applicant shall notify the City's Public Works Division at least 10
working days prior to the commencement of any work/construction activity
within any public right-of-way. In the case of a City right-of-way, the
Applicant has five working days to obtain a right-of-way permit from the
City's Construction Services Division. Failure to comply with this condition
shall result in a Stop-Work Order of all work/construction activity within the
,:
public right-of-way ��-�N;�j ,,.;.,. ,;;:.. ;.:.. ';,.;. (Construction
Services)
13. The build-out date for this project shall two years from the date of approval
of this Resolution, unless extended per City Code Section 78-61. (City
Engineer)
SECTION 5. This property shall be constructed in compliance with the following
plans on file with the City's Growth Management Department:
1. Sheet G1-1: Site Plan, prepared by Sylla Incorporated, dated October 10,
2005, and last revised on February 12, 2007; dated and stamped by the
Pianning and Zoning Division on February 22, 2007.
2. Sheets L1-1 through L1-5: Landscape Pian, prepared by Sylla Incorporated,
dated August 31, 2006, and last revised on October 27, 2006; dated and
stamped by the Planning and Zoning Division on February 22, 2007.
3. Sheet A4-1 through A4-11: Architectural Floor Plans and Elevations,
prepared by Tercilta Courtemanche Architects, Inc., dated October 10,
2005, and last revised on February 12, 2007; dated and stamped by the
Planning and Zoning Division on February 22, 2007.
SECTION 6. This approval shall be consistent with all representations made by
the Applicant or Applicant's agents at any workshap or public hearing.
SECTION 7. This Resalution shall become effective immediately upon adoption.
0
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
Date Prepared: February 28, 2007
Resolution 28, 2007
1Nitii::Atrieit�m�i�`ts:l�i`�?:<os�d!:�i: :>Se�''t<:C� `� :'i�
l? :........:....Y.....:.....4:::. G::1'::
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 3'`"'� day of _� , 2007.
ATTEST:
BY:��
CM.�
Pat icia Snider, C, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND
LEGAL SUFF[CIENCY
BY: �H �./ r!.(/�1/ o � 1"-
VOTE:
CITY OF PALM
BY:
//____,�
e P. Tatum, Cit�Attorney
MAYOR RUSSO
VICE MAYOR LEVY
COUNCILMEMBER JABLIN
COUNCILMEMBER VALECHE
COUNCILMEMBER BARNETT
AYE NAY
�
✓
_�
�_
�_
ABSENT
G�DEN,9, FLORIDA
Mayor
G:lattorney_share\RESOLUTIONS\site plan approval for pbghs - reso 28 2007-revised after first readingl.doc
%
�
r^
�
�
,
;
LOCATION MAP
Calvary Chapel Jupiter
s 4 � � �'*a .-- � � Jy� �� { s''"���-�,��'"L k x _ "ea � i � �
'r �''1.,rd. . �.*�'�i :.t"aI. ��.c ¢ j ;�`� WS'r'^�,r; ^�v�,• �. � ey „,o, '� °
�'f. 4 A' � � Tt' � ,,11� . '� y ��,_ �.. T � � y -. y t h � .:�
� � ... ��A ' �F y � ...'A (� � � S r r.x�K fi. � 4 ~r�r� "�,a'! � �k .�f; .
c r 'r �, � � F F}-�-�,,� � < �4d
.�- 1 �e.'� . �1� � .� r ,�a. ���' � ' � � � �t rt,l.�'�+F}�°���• ..�. � '•�' �+p1"''-'v' 'r� �'..' .
``�� ,: f�Ati _ r`� "*.�-�`,et�� •�1,��: �� �'� ���� �
4 � # ' � , '+�
- � � '�.!: , •.rj�;�� � rw . �'`4 .-:a. :- �P a � k� .
�.. 9 �. �il� � � � -� .. j- �d�.:� } � { � �� h� 1 � � � � ��
yyy � � y �. i
�.*J � ..1. ✓�,��, . � � � e �� ,°� � J�� � ..n f �`i ��^ - � A �a��.d...�..
� ►«. „ -�'� 'r'�, -."" ,�� k y K • a 1 -.nk � 4e n ? �! +��' s �„�.`� -jR� ��+�.e \ � j i"' '1 '1 + '
� + �� d Y K��r 1 (. . 'i * t !�° �-;,� _ � i �a, :� •' ,;
��2 M:;� . �„ -,� �r"�" 4 � �— I �f � � • ' � _ r r 1 �
� l.���i� ��.� � `':'�'� .��lv�.f�.-�+� _ �
� r � . , ..r ; �s �� ,Y ,�
��jiw4� � . ;x}. � �� ,, �« ���, ,�,,�.�..�.��urns �o� �.,� ' ��,�
` � �. . a � ,�, , ... � � �. �►� � � �=y�
. �. � � M�� +a- �; � . � ,r�� ,
�� , ��ts �' ,�� , �`.
� ' � +r r� ,: . , �
� �.an � � d 2w 7 _,... , � r.� �� 1 u�_. '.�.."�'o., . o
,, �.��;�,�tf k.� ��j�"�`�` � � '� ��� _ �' �
.'F^'�'f'��F� ff� s f � ,+ � �a ���,, ` � �
� �'.t�� .� t �, � ,.w.. •:,� # �w i � �M - �F t�'� � � . � � � �' �-� f
` 4 .,f 1 '�t -y,.� 4 � ✓ . . � °,
>c . f . :i i � � � : ,y. ��. f yc:4�i`�,•
'� �' x�?:' c •. a (A!°'1_ � � : .: _ ��:� � +.. a� �
i ��
, � ,, � . � � �'�,v „ � ,�'_�- � �`; � s�. 5 L il � c 9:�tt�zc�t. + � � � � +''��.
� ,�
.�
��'.
��� ,,
81
���1�,.�::.:-,�
. .,� ,
5'♦ v
�. tY +a
w � �� �
� � >- ��,,�-� , � i ..4 , �; '_ a,�.� ' � � .. � ; i • � ,�� r � s ;��
r 9f� �.� � '.M�'ri'� �t� ! � . � ,� , _ � a �� ca}�:� { � ?�'� t�3j
��:: Fj� a .�+`�_"• ..,�,, �J� ., .. ��. � .�' � •' i�' '��;a�
�."��' �::L-`t�3 ..��iY'i_.. �.;�'`�' t. ty.� .y'� J�! Subject Site ., ; �_,� �1 .a-^. �' _ !
� }'� � �.� `�; � f , �t = ! � �`�', �-. ,� � � =�
a ^; y, , � �. � °
.� i ' �
� }'.. . �.. ..y� R .. �a� � -�� I . �r
, �a.'➢ ��°t�., '4` Holix:Drive , ; � �--��
..> . . �f 8d9�� T « _ , �a,a t Fa:,� �
'�' �' - w � . . i Q,'S C'�-C'�iJ� � ����(({��� �-��Q.� !h' } I 1"'- •
�s3�''l � • � �`'� �� � n �' .-.a- 1 ��",f � r . . i �� ��'' i ;: � `"� \ . i �, �
Y -��/ �, � i ' t i
���. � i j`� �a . t / ��„� c5:t e
i ��� �.{ ' � d`? `f-'; �;'k3`J j �_� � 1 }w�+r I M..
r �y� 7"y�'J." ..!y '"Tp�*^�` ` �( `�. t���,yyyrf+�ir �
�� N � . i' 1. i � ..F H � � !iuf. tar V �f +f + � ` �
r' :� :: ��..,� u _�.:�,�_����t�tL� �
�'`�.."� �
A��� �Y '�
4 �;� J.:.��
� .+ P
�.'r`'�' ���-^ !
�. i
T�� ^�
.�"�`� � ) °h _ ,
� � �
.�t. r�( ��� "?
1 � , � ,
rL �
� r.'1`�,_:I
�"'� �.. : '
�e....rh ,.
Project Narrative
Calvary Chapel Jupiter
Major Conditional Use Application
Description of Use
Calvary Chapel Jupiter is renting the Palm Beach Gardens High school auditorium, cafeteria, and 7
classrooms by the hour on Sunday mornings. The auditorium will be used for an hour and fifteen
ininute church service. The cafeteria and classrooms will be used for our children's ministry space from
infant to 6t�' grade for their Sunday school classes. Our service time is Sunday froin 10:00 am to 11:15
am. The school facilities will be used by the church onlv during this time.
There will be limited if any interaction with other school uses as we are meeting onlv on Sunday
mornings and there is no school activity typically scheduled during this time.
Once again, we are ineeting in the auditorium for the worship service, the cafeteria for KS-4t�' grade
class, and in classrooms in the 300 building for our preschool space. The preschoolers are divided by 0-
6 month infant nursery, 6-12 months, 12-24 months, 2 year olds, 3 year olds, 4 year olds, and St�' and 6t�'
grade in one room.
We are using the full auditorium which seats 850; however, we are currently using about 400 of those
seats.
We are not using office space at the school, as again we are only renting by the hour for Sunday
morning as an independent church with no other ties or relationship with the school.
The Auditorium is approxiinately 14,000 sf (including the Lobby area).
The Cafeteria is approximately 6,705 sf
Each Classroom is approximately 810 sf
Si�na�e
We would like to have permission to place a bamler sign in a pvc frame on the corner of Lilac Street and
Military Trail direction patrons to the school parking lot. In addition, we would like permission to place
a sign on the gate at the actual parking lot entrance off of Lilac Street to point into the entrance (please
see the attached Sign Location Plan). Both of the signs are temporary, and would only be displayed
prior to the service time each Sunday morning and removed at the end of the service.
Traf�c Circulation
The traffic circulation and parking will no different than that typical to the use by the school. The
congregants typically arrive fifteen minutes to a half hour prior to the service. They will enter from
Lilac Street into the large parking lot west of the auditorium (see attached Traffic Circulation Plan). At
the end of service they will exit the same direction for about the same time frame as the entry.
We have already hired two (2) PBG police officers to be present each week to monitor and direct the
flow of traffic in and out of the Lilac Street/Military Trail entrance.
�TC
__ _ ___ __ ___ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _____ _ ___ _
ITransportation Consultants 511�4 Okcc�chohec l3oulevard, tiuitr 3I11
July 21, 2010
Ms. Kathryn Wilson
City of Palm Beach Gardens, Planning & Zoning
10500 North Military Trail
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Re: Calvary Chapel - #PTC10-006E
Dear Ms. Wilson:
Wcst Palm f3each, FL 33-11?--15U-}
(>611 296-9G98 F�x 29(i-969�)
www.pindertroutman.cc�m
Certi(i�ate of Authc>rization Numh��r:'989
The purpose of this letter is to provide a traffic statement for the above referenced project. It is
proposed to utilize portions of the Palm Beach Gardens High School for Sunday services for the
Calvary Chapel. It is proposed to use the following school facilities:
❖ Auditorium
•:• Cafeteria
•'• Classrooms
14,000 SF
6,705 SF
5,670 SF
26,375 SF
Attachment 1 provides the Sunday daily and peak hour of generator trip generation for the proposed
project. It is proposed to have two (2) Palm Beach Gardens police officers directing traffic at the �ilac
Street and Military Trail intersection before and after services to address traffic circulation.
No weekday impacts will be generated by this development. Therefore, the proposed project is in
compliance with the Countywide Traffic Performance Standards.
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact this office.
Sincerel�v;� � , �'
' � . �'_.
l
;,-� � :% 1
� 'L , p
� "�� � / � /
// , �� `��i� i .'i( //rG. �.�
/ l t.C/ �� -��.�
���nc��ea M. Troutman, .E. /z � /�
FI°/ ��ida Registration #�45409 �
G' ✓
AMT/Idr
Attachment
PinderTroutman Consulting, Inc.
Lrlhv 11�iltinn 1l�-lJ(JGf "- '1- 1ll
�
0 0
� o
� �
n ry
� ^
0
0
0
c
�°
H
r
r.+
C
�
i
u
�
Q
GJ
Q.
fd
.0
�
y
�
U
G
O
�
ea
L
�
C
G1
U
Q
H
�
�
�
c
�
�
��
N N
� n
� �
H
a
�i
H
�
C
L
�
X
W
0
� O
� N �
� a
a �'- v �
�
M M
� �
y
d
�L
�
�
.Fd
�
� �
r �
� �
� �
CL X
c c
O �
� �
L �
v O
VII
a�
F'- J
�� �
cn cn
•N � �
= I� n
.*+ M M
_ �D l0
N N
W 'D �
� O �
- U
d
N
�
'�
_
�
� s a
�
s O
U t-
� �
� � c-
� M M
� �
'i
H � � �
� �
C� �--� c-
L
�
W � �
� U1
C � �
0
� O
� N u�
� a
a � � °
,� N N
� M M
� �
� � � �
� O r r
�
~ �" �'
C � �
� r r
� �
p" �
� �
� �
�i �
C �
O `�'�
n
e -I-
G� X
c �
v N
a °'
� II
F-
� �
� N �
•N V� tf�
C � �
.P+ M M
= l0 l0
N N
W '� O
�' O �
U
a
h
�
�
C
J
L QU
� O
U 1-
c
0
�
w
s
w
�
0
.y
�
�
c
a�
U
�
w
H
�
N
N
c
.�
c
w
c
0
.�
0
a
�
c
fd
H
�...
0
�
�
�
�
C
N
�
�
�
�
c
�
G
U
S
U
m
v
m
E
�
U
O
�
N
Title: Sign Location Plan
Date: August 4, 2010
Sheet 1 of 1
Prepared by: Calvary Chapel of Jupiter, Inc.
; ��
� �
1 . � � , . . . . . . . ,. �
t�t . . . . . . . . . .
t� . . . . . , ..
� .4 n'. ', � � .
�
R
7 t
X. . � . . . . . . . .
i
�
�
i
�
�
�.1
� ' ��
�
f
I
Qi
.«.
s
�
x
�:;;
, .
+
) - '�
((f
t
�':i ':ui.i' �.� �,•
�'
t
,a
�
�
�
..;
•
�f '.
I�
�
��
��
��
� w
.
�Y�
I''�.
p �� ..
I ' `£[S��
1�-
�
�:
�;�
`�!�,
-
�
�
.�
�
�
�`
1<�::..' __�' �_'
��
—
�.r
�
�
�
W
�
'.
�
0
�
0
N
�
�
� N
� O
Q� N
N N N
� � �
F"� Q Vl
ti
�
�
�
.�
�
ti
�
0
�
fti
U
�
�
�
�
U
�
"C
N
�
�
�
�
i •
4
If
�
�
�jCL�c'
. . �y � � �
- � ,a - � � � �' � � � � _ _ s-.�
s.�j, [; , . � � . �. §,, �,� � ,,�,� � -. T . ._ s_= .,- . �"f �' -
i = � � � _� ��a, �' ' .
. j � � _ � . .. � � - - �.� �' � ~
:. ,.__ _ . _..._ u�cs�r
� i� rr. �
!S3"" �,
.. � •'j,
T
�..
�
' �� �
�
�
� r �.— a--- -
��
�. � .�-�. _
� . � rr- �
1 ' , ��-� :..
!
�i^".♦
•+� ��_ . T
I
�o
t♦
♦, �'.
♦ .
.
e�.� . .. .
16�� � � `�
ri4`� !�
�• � �
f?" •' , �
� . , .�
��n��+.���iiU►1./� ;
� p '
( .a�
— a-------_3g:_ _' (—...--���-------)
� ; � ' i i
� 1 �" � � � r
�'�'\ I � I
� � 1 �'�
� � `t , , . .�s
� � � �
V:..:il.tiLi�� . � . _ , s ,
�� A __ �
� �1
�
._.
— ,}''.
�"" l;. _ � � _ usi[t"-'
^t"""",: ( �
a11;��w� �/ � . : ,: .. _
- : ,- �, :..���.�._.�..::..
, ,,�,_., 6' Fenc� ca/wini�sEreeii� °:
�.-
Install lands�ap_ing
...:.......�-.
per �he �pprc�v�.iii vand�cape Plan
!�/2�(ii 2
�:
�
1+gu.v orrn�
«�.
�
, aT'' � � � �� / r � � 1
� t e ��,
" -.+ %: d '�`z:� �1.:
r
.�
,3
���1 1 �'+
� il
a. a�
1���.v.J�- w
����%/ � ���St� ...�s
.i^: T<!_
� .�f a
. -
,, - - ou "p
:i ir � ►i��' ►
'`����� ::��
� ��' � .
;' :��
i::
iiii�iii , A��: ..
!�e� , � .r� Ec, ' !� �
:...
.:� �
....,.:: . .......:�.��. • -
,. ..
�. ; • . _ ... . . � �
..: �. �j9;3.� �� r.. .; =i�6
i�:is • 4l�!� 1 P��! t iu : ,,�I
iii� -�'� �� �i,�a
��, ��' � ..:
: �,,.;. • _. . :
� f'• ,�
.; S�y �� -•r m� �
-.a �^"4��L� �'
�� ��. .� [a"��' "y�"'."a`�
,..,, Poac•o��; �,._...� -;,-�-�-��
��� ':�'': �. ���
:F:Q :.�1�•'•••••••0:: [l"�"�'r��;�
;�:::.'.:.'•,.��:_ ...:::�:6C:CCC:'.� ... .....0�. _ EatS W.'•'['�.�.._
,�r� '• c:�'� '�': ' ���
� ,,� j� �a��aea
�_ _; .^1 �� t�v�r��
�:' �:s�c»::_ � �
�;;:::::�' �� ��
� : . ,-r, a-t-�,--
4 � ���
S a � � O ��NB.3
C7C��': ��!.,�'@e��•:�s�uua� 6.�Yl�R�Oi�
� � NRii
t:: � .e � Q� ��iS 6�3t
_ '"i:: � ��Y il�fl
s���
e°s6e: - �s.���
1I ����•�
; ' ���
��m�
! � �� ���
:�.� .
:�:.�
� �
�,�.�..� �
� � � t:m �l6�'
�,, ' "�` �.`
���
��
��
��
� QB ��
���
Title: Traffic Circulation Plan
Date: July 22, 2010
Prepared by: Calvary Chapel of Jupiter, Inc.
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
PLANNING, ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD
Agenda Cover Memorandum
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition No. MISC-10-07-000073
SUBJECT/AGENDA ITEM
MISC-10-07-000073: PGA Marina Planned Unit Development (PUD)
Public Hearing and Recommendation to City Council: A request from Anne Booth,
the agent for PGA Marina Center, Ltd., to approve an amendment to the PGA Marina
PUD to increase the number of boat storage areas, and modify the site and landscape
plan. The subject site is located at the northwest corner of PGA Boulevard and the
Intracoastal Waterway.
[X] Recommendation to APPROVE
[ ] Recommendation to DENY
Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: FINANCE: PZAB:
City Attorney: Planning and Zoning: Finance [] Rec. Approval
N/A Administrator: [] Rec. Approval with
R. Max Lohman, Esq. Resource Manager: Conditions
p „ N/A [ ] Rec. Denial
��h'� Allan Owens [ ] Continued to:
Development Compliance: ����
Allyson Black
� �
Bahareh K. Wolfs, AICP Project Manager: Accountant:
Director of Planning and ��r���-%/ -�_
Zon'n . Kate Wilson, Planner
Sarah Varga
Attachments:
[X] Quasi — Judicial Fees Paid: [X] ❖ Location Map
a alie M. Wong, AICP [] Legislative Yes ❖ Project Narrative
[X] Public Hearing ❖ Reduced Plans
Budget Acct.#:
Advertised: N/A
Approved By: [ ] Required
[X] Not Required
City Manager
N/A Affected Parties:
Ronald M. Ferris [ ] Notified
[X] Not Required
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
M I S C-10-07-000073
Page 2 of 5
BACKGROUND
Ordinance 31, 1997, approved the PGA Marina PUD to allow 264 dry storage slips, 20
wet storage slips, a 36,355-square foot boat warehouse building with an accessory 600-
square foot marina store, a 2,244-square foot boat sales building, a 1,250-square foot
two-story commercial building, 52,100 square feet of outdoor sales area, and 46,050
square feet of outdoor storage area.
Subsequently, an Administrative Amendment was approved in 2006 to allow an
increase in the number of dry storage slips on the site to allow a total of 394 dry slips, to
relocate and add parking spaces, and to increase the amount of landscape open space.
The subject petition includes a request to add three (3) new boat storage areas, reduce
the parking stall widths, and approval of a waiver from the number of required parking
spaces. In addition, the Applicant is proposing to add additional open space, enhance
the existing landscaped areas, and improve the overall operations of the marina. The
new boat storage areas will be used for the existing boats on site.
The subject petition was initiated from a code enforcement citation, because boats were
being parking in vehicular parking spaces. The petition does not propose any additional
boat slips, rather provides additional boat storage areas to assist in the marina's more
efficient operations. The Applicant has proposed changes to the storage areas and
parking areas with consideration to the vehicular and boat traffic circulation on site.
With the proposed addition of parking spaces, and pavement markings, staff believes
that the marina will function more efficiently than it currently does.
LAND USE & ZONING
The subject site has a Future Land Use designation of Commercial (C) with a zoning
designation of General Commercial (CG1) and Planned Unit Development (PUD)
overlay.
(The remainder of this page left intentionally blank.)
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
M I SC-10-07-000073
Page 3 of 5
Table 1. Surrounding Zoning & Land Use Designations
� - � �
Subject Property pUD/CG1 C
PGA Marina
North
Marina Gardens RH/RM RH/RM
Soverel Harbour Marina CG1 C
Riverhouse Restaurant CG1 C
South
Waterway Cafe CG1 C
East
Seasons 52 Restaurant PUD/CG1 C
West
Harbour Financial Center CG1 C
CONCURRENCY
No additional concurrency approval is requested with the subject petition.
PROJECT DETAILS
Site Details and Access
PGA Marina is located
at the northwest corner of PGA Boulevard and the Intracoastal
Waterway, and is approximately 7.2 acres. The subject site has two (2) existing
vehicular access points from PGA Boulevard (see attached Location Map). The site
shares vehicular access with the Riverhouse Restaurant, which is situated adjacent to
the marina at the northeast corner. No change to the existing access is proposed with
the subject petition.
Parkin
The City's parking regulations (Section78-345) requires commercial marinas to provide
one (1) space per two (2) wet slips, one (1) space per five (5) dry slips, plus additional
uses. This equates to 103 spaces; 87 spaces are proposed. The Applicant has
requested a waiver from this requirement (see Waiver section).
The Applicant has also reduced the widths of the parking stalls to nine (9) feet. Section
78-344(2a) allows for a reduction in parking space dimensions if additional open space
is provided at a ratio of 1.5 square feet for each square foot of reduced paved parking
area. The Applicant has met this criterion.
Signape
The Applicant is proposing to add pavement markings directing patrons to the
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
MISG10-07-000073
Page 4 of 5
designated parking areas; therefore, redirecting cars through the site more efficiently.
In addition, one (1) directional sign will be added at the western portion of the site
directing marina patrons towards the marina parking areas.
Landscaping/Bufferinq
The PGA Marina site currently contains 18 percent open space; 15 percent is required.
The reduction of the parking stall widths requires that an additional 1,832 square feet of
open space be provided. The additional open space proposed will increase the overall
open space on the site to 18.4 percent.
Drainaqe
No changes to the existing drainage are proposed with this petition.
Waiver Repuests
The Applicant is requesting one (1) waiver with this petition.
1) The Applicant is requesting a waiver from City Code Section 78-345, Table 33,
Required Oft=Street Parking, to allow for a reduction of 16 spaces. The Applicant is
proposing to provide 87 parking spaces, which equates to a ratio of one (1) space
per three (3) wet slips and one (1) space per six (6) dry slips. Based on the
historical experiences of the PGA Marina, which consistently has a large number of
boats in long term storage, the number of boat launches they have is below the
standards that would require parking at the ratio required by the code.
In addition, the marina is not setup favorable to live-aboard boaters. While many
marinas contain amenities such as showers, washers/dryers, restaurants, and other
recreational services, PGA Marina does not include such amenities; therefore, it is
not conducive to the typical live-aboard boater. The yacht sales operation has
consistently been able to utilize the wet slips for the purpose of housing the boats
that they have for sale. Parking demand for brokerage boats is very limited. The
reduction in the parking requirements for the wet slips reflects this continued use.
Although the parking demand for these slips is substantially lower, the Applicant is
only requesting a reduction of one space per boat.
Based on the above conditions, the proposed increase in required landscaping, and
the overall improvement of the marina's operations, staff supports this waiver
request.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
MISC-10-07-000073
Page 5 of 5
COMMENTS FROM THE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMITTEE (DRC)
On April 22, 2010, the subject petition was reviewed by the DRC committee. Since this
time, staff has been working with the Applicant to address all comments.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends APPROVAL of petition MISC-10-07-000073 with the following
conditions:
1. All landscaping and parking lot improvements shall be completed within six (6)
months from the approval date of the subject petition. (Planning & Zoning)
2. Prior to the issuance of the infrastructure permit, the Applicant shall submit
signed/sealed/dated construction plans for review and approval. (Director of
Engineering)
3. The Applicant shall provide a signed and sealed pavement marking and signage
plan, or provide the same on the engineering plans; said plans must be reviewed
and approved by the Director of Engineering prior to the issuance of the
infrastructure permit. (Director of Engineering)
4. Prior to the commencement of construction, the Applicant shall schedule a pre-
construction meeting with City staff. Inspections related to the infrastructure permit
will not be performed until the pre-construction meeting has occurred. In addition,
failure to comply with this condition could result in a Stop Work Order of all
work/construction activity for the subject development site. (Director of Engineering)
5. The Applicant shall comply with all Federal Environmental Protection Agency and
State of Florida Department of Environmental Protection permit requirements for
construction activities. (Director of Engineering)
6. The construction, operation and/or maintenance of any elements of the subject
project shall not have any negative impacts on the existing drainage of surrounding
areas. If, at any time during the project development, it is determined by the City that
any of the surrounding areas are experiencing negative drainage impacts caused by
the project, it shall be the Applicant's responsibility to resolve said impacts in a
period of time and a manner acceptable to the City prior to additional construction
activities. The City may cease issuing building permits and/or Certificates of
Occupancy until all drainage concerns are resolved. (Director of Engineering)
' �., F ' . +
A!� � ` I
..,, ���
! �.S � � +•• . � a
' e i .eu �' I �-. �
" i ' .� .t .t i'- I � .
��",,.� � r�� �� '� . �
I
��,. �' I t+-+,.-..� v
� , . � ., r��
��} . �� �` � '' � �
��, ����� ; ` vt`� -' -.
�3 f «��� ��
+ t { '4� � i �
� e � � � � �� ���m `� � �4.� .
� �
J� !
��`' '�� � ;,�
',�~= � �r� a
_ �'� . _ �M .} � ,
��.
�4 , � �t� ��°� ti{.r i+�� . � �:. � .
_� Y,:�
�. ��
��yM '��
LOCATION MAP
PGA Marina
2401 PGA Boulevard
��"� �}�pM� 1�Ua�,71t; i:; !�
+�ry-, "�' � ' i�� � �
�!.:"F f_1 .� •��` 2 ��' � I
t �
`��B�L�' ` S 1� `i, . � '
� 7 �
� d.. � , „
� ��
� !'- �, �� ;,.�(`"� ,
! 4
� �t'�� ?f�..
�„.�� ....� ,.. 4 a , � -.w
'..�r��- i��Fl r� �
`r�� . � - a'n�d+�,�
7�'; �� �-r-+-� ' iY�"'tit•!�dJ���*� t
P � -., ."�iq� t't. d r"qr
r � ,� ��.�ll'-��,� �t , i
�r- �'
�,:;'� s �+�'�� � � exi
�� "� �. �
#. i�`.,a�'��s+-�iy"� � r' - �t^. ..p�
s +�..:
� 4;) '� �
t �,
�
�
��.
=� 4 x:..�' Subject"�_� � -
�rt
��, R' 3 S l t@ "' �,f �A""� �
- �'' �786 � ��'e
� �� �,
�� � � � ��, I � "� � _,�`�` ; ^+r-+ �,. `.,�
7-.. .� 4 �1� �3� ,...
�t �
. ��
��i j� ' ' . �
�.,�r,�,
��� � ��
,
_' `ys' �'"e'r a�j )?:°��
�� � # •�'� l i . +
�'L�.� � ,�� +��
,�"�- �� ,��-wi
,
�? �. y n'
.�� '� ' '
� �
��.� ��,� ,
:�
. ,� � R..e :
�"_- ..,-.� �,—
� .+. �`' ; P�, t i
� i #�
�t ..z �;F.>��
�s.v.a,�� � ill... i.
PROJECT NARRATI�E
PGA MARINA PUD ANiENDMENT
A�ril 1, 2010
Amended June 23, 2010
Amended July 13, 201�J
Amended Ju/y 19, 2010
Location/Request
urban
��sign
ki I da
STUDIOS
Urban Planning and Design
Landscape Architecture
Communication Graphics
The subject site is an approximate 7.2 acre tract of land located at the northwest corner
of PGA Boulevard and the Intracoastal Waterway. The site has a zoning designation of
Planned Unit Development (PUD), with an underlying zoning of CG-1, and a Future
Land Use Plan designation of Commercial (C). To the north of the site are the Soverel
Harbour Marina and the River House restaurant which have CG-1 (General
Commercial) zoning designations and Comm�rcial Future Land Use Plan designations.
To the east, are the Intracoastal Waterway and the Seasons 52 Restaurant which have
a PUD zoning designation and a Future Land Use Plan designation of Commercial. To
the south is the Waterway Cafe which has a CG-1 zoning designation and a
Commercial Future Land Use Plan designation. West of the site is Harbour Financial
Center, which also has a CG-1 zoning designation and a Commercial Future Land Use
Plan designation.
This request is for an amendment to the approved site plan to allow for a reduction in
the number of parking spaces required per boat slip, a reduction in the width of regular
parking spaces, modification to the location of parking spaces, the addition of additional
open space, the improvement of site landscaping, and the designation of additional
areas where boats may be stored.
The proposed modifications w;ll require the approval of one waiver to allow for the
reduction in the rsquired number of parking spaces, The proposed changes will not
increase the number of boats that may be sfored, but will allow for the storage of I�rger,
wider and taller boats at gro;�nd level thereby maintaining the height limits required by
the code.
History
The PGA Marina PUD was approved by th� �ity Council with the adoption of Or ' ce
�...
31,1997. The original approval allowed 264 dry storage slips, 20 wet storag i��� °
36,355 s.f. boat warehouse building with an accessory 600 s.f. marina stor �q�le4�� cQ,
s.f. �oat sales building; a 1,250 s.f. 2-story commercial ,; ZQ�o
building., 52,100 s.f. of outdoor sales area, and 46,050 s.f. of PLANNING&
outdoor storage area. ,�,A,,,,�
On A ril 21, 2006, an Administrative Amendment was a roved 477 S. Rosemary Avenue
p pP Suite 225 - The Lofts at CityPlace
to allow an increasz in the number of dry storage slips on the West Palm Beach, FL 33401
site to allow a total of 394 dry slips, to re!ocate and add parking 561.3b6.1100 561.366.1111 fax
s aces and to increase the amount of landsca e o en s ace. `""""�uakstua�os.com
p P p p �cc00003s
PGA Marina P�D
Misc. Amendment
Currently the site development program includes the following:
394 dry boat storage slips
20 wet boat storage slips
600 s.f. marina store
2,244 s.f. boat sales building
1,250 s.f. 2-story commercial building (yacht sales)
36,355 s.f. boat warehouse building/maintenance area
52,100 s.f. outdoor sales area
46,050 s.f. of outdoor storage area
Phasinq
All proposed improvements will be completed in one phase.
Access
April 1, 2010
(Amended July 19, 2010)
Page 2
The two existing aceess points along PGA Boulevard will remain unchanged with this
proposed amendment.
PGA MARINA SITE DATA
Ap roved Pl�ns Proposed
Acrea e 7.2 7.2
Boat Warehouse 36,355 SF 36,355 SF
Marina Ship Store 600 SF 600 SF
(As accesso use to Marina)
Boat Sales Commercial 2,244 �F 2,244 SF
Yacht Sales Commercial 1,250 SF 1,250 SF
Buildin Lot Co��era e 12.5% 12.5%
Boat Slips
(Dry) 394 394
(Wet) 20 20
Outdoor Sales Display 52,100 SF 52,100 SF
Outdoor Stora e 46,050 SF 46,050 SF
Parkin 106 87*
Open Space 18% 18.4%
* Waiver request
Land Use
The existing development is consistent with the Commercial Future Land Use Plan
designation for the site.
PGA Marina PUD
Misc. Amendment
Surroundinq Zoninq and Land Use analysis
Apri! 1, 2010
(Amended July 19, 2010)
Page 3
EXISTING USE ZONING DESIGNATION FUTURE LAND USE
PLAN DESIGNATION
SUBJECT PROPERTY:
PGA Marina PUD(CG-1) Commercial
TO THE NORTH:
Marina Gardens, RH/RM
Soverel Harbour Marina, CG-1 (General Commercial
and River House Rest. Commercial)
TO THE EAST:
Seasons 52 Restaurant PUD (CG-1) Commercial
TO THE SOUTH:
Waterwa Cafe CG-1 Commercial
TO THE WEST:
Harbour Financial Center CG-1 Commercial
Siqnaqe
The proposed modifications to the site will not impact the existing signage. No ct�anges
are anticipated to the existing signage of either the Marina or the River House
Restaurant. The applicant is proposing to provide additional signage and pavement
markings to direct marina customers to parking areas on Marina property.
Landscape Plan
The applicant is proposing to increase the open space and landscape planting on the
site in four areas. The first area is adjacent to the northwest corner of the �roperty
a�jacent to a large shade tree, the second is an area adjacent #o the Yacht Sales office,
the third is an area adjacent to the northeast property !ine between the boardwalk and
the parking lot, and finally an area adjacent to the eastern entrance from PGA Blvd.
The applicant is also proposing to replace and enhance the landscaping along the entire
length of the north/south entrance drive which leads to the marina parking area and also
serves as the access drive for the restaura�t, and to extend the existing hedge to the
east along the base of the bridge embankment.
The first additional open space area is approximately 136.5 sf and is located east of and
adjacent to an existing tree generally located in the northwest corner of the site. The
plan proposes to remove the asphalt of ths adjacent parking space and convert the
pavement area into open space, incorporating the additional open space area into the
existing planting area. The planting area has been designed to accommodate a bench,
walkway and low shrubs to create a pleasant sitting area under the existing tree. The
second additional open space area is approximately 194 sf and is located west of and
PGA Marina PUD
Misc. Amendment
April 1, 2010
(Amended July 19, 2010)
Page 4
adjacent to the yacht sales office. The pavement area will be removed and additional
landscaping will be installed around the existing tree and adjacent to the entrance to th�
building. The third area is approximately 396.2 sf and is adjacent to the north property
line in the northeast corner of the site. The plan proposes to plant a hedge the length of
the boardwalk between the boardwalk and the parking lot. The hedge will be broken
with strategically placed crosswalks to ailow boaters acces� to the marina. The fourth
area of additional open space is approximately 238 sf and is located adjacent to the
parking spaces at the easternmost entrance from PGA Blvd. This area will be planted
with a hedge to assist in screening the parking spaces.
The existing shrub planting along the entrance arive is propcsed to be removed and
replaced with a lush combination of shrubs and ground covers. Double Sabal Palms
will be planted on either side of the intersection of the driveway leading to the
restaurant.
The site is required to provide 15%, or 47,044 sf of open space. The site currently
provides 18% open space. With the additional open space being provided, the site wili
have 18.4% or 57,708 sf of open space. The proposed parking stall width reduction
requires that an additional 1831.5 sf of open space be provided to compensate for the
reduction in pavement area for the 9' wide spaces. The site provides 10,633.5 sf of
additional open space which exceeds that requirement.
PGA Marina PUD
Misc. Amendment
April 1, 2010
(Amended July 19, 2010)
Page 5
SITE ANALYSI�:
PGA IVlarina Miscellaneous Ap�plication
Comparison Proposed/Existing Consistent
to CG-1 zoning Conditions
district
Parking ;
Waiver requested for
Required 106 87 reduction in required
parking
Parking Space Size 10' x 18.5' spaces 9' x 18.5' spaces Additional Open
Space provided
Landscaping
20" Buffer along PGA 15' along PGA Boulevard
Boulevard� 8' around (0' at the boat turnareund Existing Non
Buffers east, west and northern area), 8' around the Conformity
property lines applicable north, and west
property lines
WAIVER REQUESTS
Boat Storage Slip Parkinq Stall ealculation (Section 78-345)
The applicant is requesting a waiver from Section 78-345(a), Table 33: Required Off-
Street Parking Spaces, of the City's Land Development Regulations which requires a
commercial marina to provide parking at a ratio of 1 space for every two (2) wet slips,
plus 1 space for every five (5) dry sl�ps. The applicant is requesting a waiver io allow a
reduction in the ratio of required parking spaces to provide 1 space for every three (3)
wet slips, and 1 space for every six (6) d.ry slips.
The PGA Marina site has been in existence since the 1970's ard under the current
ownership since January 1 A98. Over the years, the applicant has seen the trend for
longer, wider and taller boats k�ecome the standard for storage. Ir� order to stay below
the maximum height limit of 36' established by the LDR's, the applicant has been limited
in his ability to stack the larger boats on the multi-level racks. As a result, the IargEr
boats have been stored in the unused parking space areas.
In an effort to bring the approved site plan into conformity with the actual needs and
demands of the marina, this application is requesting a reduction in the required parking
spaces to allo�v boat storage areas in the existing car parking areas. The applicant has
through the years seen that the parking demand at the Marina is consistent year tc year
and is much lower than the standards required by the Land Development Regulations.
The applicant understands that adequate parking is important to his customers and that
PGA Marina PUD
Misc. Amendment
April 1, 2010
(Amended July 19, 2010)
Page 6
a shortage of parking is counterproductive to business. The applicant has a license
agreement with the owner of the adjacent restaurant which allows their customers and
patro�s to park on each other's property during off hours. To address concerns
regarding the applicability of this waiver request to future parking requirements, the
applicant has proposed a condition of approval as follows:
"If, in the future, the applicant, successors or assigns, requests approval to increase the
number of boat storage slips currently allowed, the parking ratio waiver will no longer be
applicable and will need to be re-evaluated. The re-evaluation of the parking ratio shall
not however be more restrictive than that permitted by the current City of Palm Be�ch
Gardens Land Development Regulations.
The current national trend for live-aboard boaters is to moor at marinas that provide
amenities such as showers, washers/dryers, and recreational amenities. There are
none of those amenities for the wet slips provided at PGA Marina therefore the marina
is not attractive to the typical live-aboard boating public. The yacht sales operation,
however, has consistently been able to utilize the wet slips for the purpose of housing
the boats that they have for sale. Parking demand for brokerage boats is very limited.
The reduction in the parking requirements for the wet slips reflects this continued use.
Although the parking demand for these slips is substantially lower, the applicant is cnly
requesting a reduction of one space per boat.
Based on the historical experiences of the PGA Marina, which consistently has a large
number of boats in lona term storage, the number of boat launches they have is below
the standards th�t would require parking at the ratio required by the code. The
utilization of the marina parking has consistently been far below the national and
international standards. Documentation of the number of times the PGA Marina staff
launch a boat over the last few years are ir the attached Move/Launch re�orts. The
attached "move/launch" reports reflect the number of times a boat is launched which
correlates to the number of cars that need parking spaces. On average, the experience
of the Marina shows a demand for 1.5 spaces p�r boat being launched. These reports
reflect the maximum number of launches on the busiest days did not exceed 33
laurches in any one day. With the parking spaces provided on the marina property,
there will be approximately 2.6 spaces available per boat being launched on the
weekends which is the busiest time of the week. The proposed parking plan would
allow 4� boats to be launched, with two cars per boat. Please note that this calculation
does not include the use of the parking spaces at the restaurant. I't should also be
noted that on the weekends, when the sales offices are closed, the parking ratio will
meet and exceed the code requirements of 1 space per 5 boats for the dr,� slips.
Establishing a standard for parking at a marina has b�en documented to be difficult at
best because of the variety of variables that affect boat usage and parking demands.
Accordi^g to the Brevard County report "An Overview of Marina Use and Pa�kinq
�tandards" attached to this application, "there is no universal rule for parking at marine
facilities and any plan needs to consider the location, types of boats berthed, and
activities at the marina", and according to the "Guidelines for Car Parking at Marinas
PGA N1arina PUD
Misc. Amendment
April 1, 2010
(Amended July 19, 2010)
Page 7
and Launchinq Ramps bv Ron Stone" "the ICOMIA Marina Committee querying its
members from more than 30 countries could find no nati�nal statistics anywhere for
quantifying the nu.mber of parking spaces required for a marina".
The difficulty in establishing a standard ratio for parking at a marina is reinforced by the
attached comparison chart which documents several municipal codes, ITE, and ULI
standards. The standards are not consistent or applicable to the actual uses and needs
at the PGA Marina.
Also attached you will find launch records from several other marinas in tre state. The
widely differeni results of these records reinforce the conclusions that no two marinas
seem to be consistent in their use or parking needs.
The report "An Overview of Marina Use and Parkinq Standards" states that for "sites
with slip counts between 125 and 452 slips that 12% of the total storage capacity was
the maximum launching ability on a daily basis". This ratio applied to the dry slips at
PGA Marina would indicate that a maximum of 47 launches could be made in one day.
Parking demand at the marina is the highest on weekends when the yacht and boat
sales offices are closed making all spaces available to boaters. Parking provided under
this scenario would provide 1.85 spaces per launch.
The Marina Store which is located conveniently for access to the launching area is an
accessory use to the marina and does not generate traffic by itself. The patrons of the
Marine Stor� are either already on site for another purpose, or they have arrived by boat
and do not need parking. The launching docks or the seawalls provide temporary
park�ng for that purpose and therefore on-grade parking has not been included in the
calculation for the marina. Please note that the attached site plan has also been
amended to include a parking space adjacent to the �,�arina Stare.
In addit;on to the spaces provided on the Marina property, a license agreement with ihe
property owner of the adjacent restaurant property further increases parking options.
Altf�ough parking spaces on the adjacent restaurant property may not b� counted
toward the required parking spaees, recognizing the ongoing cross parking agreement
between the property owner of the River Hause Restaurant and the applicant is a reality
in the evaluation of this waiver request. The agreements in place allow the owner of the
restaurant to use the marina property at night, and allow marina �atrons the use of the
restaurant parking lot during the day. This orr�oing agreement between the two
property owners has been in existence since prior to the purchase of the marina by the
current applicant and is mutually beneficial to both parties. Although the Marina patrons
generally use the restaurant parking lot rather than the marina parking lot, the proposed
parking plan provides enough parking on thz Marina property to satisfy the demand
historically required by the marina patrons.
PGA Marina PUD
Misc. Amendment
April 1, 2010
(Amended July 19, 2010)
Page 8
To address concerns of the adjacent property owner, the applicant has aiso agreed to
the following:
1. Provide signage, directing marina customers to parking spaces on the marina
property, and,
2. Send notices to the marina patr�ns with a map showing where parking is located
on the marina property, and,
3. Remind marina patrons that parking their cars in the restaurant parking lot after
5:30 is not allowed, and that they may be subject to having their cars towed if
they do not respect that limitation, and,
4. Provide carts near the more remote parking spaces to make it mors convenient
to haul their gear to their boat, and,
5. Require marina employees to park in the more remote parking spaces.
LOCATION MAP Zoning = RH/PUD
LUP = RH
N85°01'28'E
22.31'
•NOTE: All racks are moveable to
accomodate different sizes of boats.
{ F�+} - PROPOSED STORAGE RACKS
`..J (NEV� STORAGE RACKS) w`'>,
E ,����
EXISTING STORAGE RACKS /' �; �fi
(TO REMAIN) �
�'
i�
(IVP.IHC.6IGN
g2''9� � / . }�, b
65��i$/ BOAT SLIPS # �1�
j / / TYF. 5 N.0
� � S.F.&DEWAII( `,).
/ � FLOSNW.�AO41PWHILT
�/
� � ryApitE ES
/ � � �
i�/ �� �
a
�i � PARKINC,
� � ULTI-LEVEL . 7
2
�`a>, /� CKS)
��` / ,� 1
�+'N \ / H°
� � � � � / / IPING � ULTI-LEVE
/ /
� - .�,aF.
�/// // � �oeu�
/ / / I I
RORO'NAY FAS:VEM' I
' / / (O.R6 5942. PG 397)
� l. 4�
ROFDN'A✓ ElSEMLNT �"
(O.ft.B. 2668,Pi:1484)
Zoning = CG1 6� �as,
LUP = C �+=fl�F'+* rYCr
COMMERCIAI
BUILDING
STOP
STOP
�: ,'-° _
Site Data
T.dRT7RS'i FI il�l�/lHUfY:
Vi,
�
,
ili�
BacKFl.ae e RAC 5 (MUITI-LEVEL
PROrEC7oR / ��� RACKS)
' .,% •J__ Y! � i
&F � I$ y�fIYORAM ���� E%ISTINO
}� � EOOE Of PAVFHEM
� /�-- = =12' SEA OAST UTILITY EASEAIENT
J � o.e.e. �o�oo ac �n<)�
�— � GENERAI
rEE P^'^�++� 2°�0' BOAT OUT�OOFt SALE55TORAGE
'SIGN �� (GRAVEL)
' — — _
RIVER HOUSE SIGNS TO REMNN)
:XIO',S�G�+.FAS��?ENih0q2 (MULTI-LEVELPACKSN
AURINA PMKING
BOATREPAI L (0. . Io70o VG i/
STORAGE
w� — _ _
� NOTE:as*x+ w.a«oc�rroxecauroun.�nav
TO BE COORDIIUTEO WttH 9.VA TO
PROTECT Ep91iN0 UIILITES.
BOAT/JIE/STOAVOU
ewuxes. aooG
_�–� _ IICYi
� /
, .�...... �.. E �t��. ---- --
BOAT OUT�OOR SALESfSTORAGE
(GRAVEy
N REMOVABLE
� e g __ ___ „{MULTI-LEVEL RACKS) _ WHEEL ST�
, : ro� REMOVABLE CFIAIN—�
� . EMxorsEPUixwc °�'�''� FOFiCROSSACCESS
�--a�'
I � � _,_._— — — — — — — — —�
' � \/1/��/'��'�Y1i'1_i'� �ti a - �
� is.ar ts.as� 1 � v� .�.a.cuoarv�
LOAdNGMEA w.vruvwaHSw
,� (MULTI-LEVEL RACK
ai
'o� ""�_ _ — _ — _
' �,A�� tOk30' FPL
ELSFIAEAT �
��>• i mE�PLOYEEPNMBq r'sraca+srur,ums, GEW��:';� �
��
SAfE SIGH7 TRIANGLE
L�_ _
�
: �"', �' � � ,�.x.�..�, b.
bMwt�C� W �M.✓petl1�0�M
eayw.
Atl. COU4n U!4
IN6
- 1 ft" S4N PVC (AM 26 .— --.
-- ------�.
s --�—�- — -°_-�
�
ucxr
pp$r
� � . S r5�z6'48�
, E� I
LB NT
(MULTI-LEVI
�q��� /
e� 'oao�'
9
� a ^�
V
Y y
/
N e7°assa' E 700.00'
UPngC CG1 P.0.8. N82°10'34"E180.55 �_ _
.� �r 5 87°45'64' H' �.7�
NO6°3398"E .��. W 161.� !
5.16' "^�'_ S 8�� � �R Pi��N)MEffR
(181.59� �'1-��
WATERWAY
SOVEREL HARBOUR
w�sr
�
N
RIVERHOUSE
RESTAURANT
(NOT INCLUDED)
E �so.asr,_
i:a��a�:����a
�
V /
J//
� ° 30' U(IiRY FASENEM
�� _ _ _ _ _O.F.B. J556. PC I6[I _ _ _ _ _ _
1lbflYAGE
C�ec1�M
' — — — F�oo� — — — — — — — n�� COVEREO SEATING AREA
–� OGFR ���/' OGH7 � ��-9� S;NiiARY FASFMEM--_�� � I_ _ _ _ UG�'� _ _ _ _
_ _ �— / _ N "— EX15TI��G 16'�`.AI�_� =3'88'2Tf8' E46� - — — — — — UEL7ANK&
- - - � .��� s� ^� �-�-
I �-±� �
I li �f DUMPSTER
� M � cr�ucnres
'� (CWVIi�LINKFENC[WRHSLATS�
' I
i i I t�o oitxa,wFw �wEx.u.wsw
� I t i
�n rraE � cuRe
�I I ( —�
. .�� C+b �!
� � I SALES OFFICE � en
II� BOAT SALES 8
I�Id9IE7
7.80'
i STOP SIGN
STOP 8AR
DCURB
iJ:vcy��cr�
13�Z�71� �Z�P1 � 3 C k1: Ce3
MARINA
F(J \
�
�
20' FlRc ACCE55 iANE
U71U1Y EASEYEA7
�PARKING FORTHE BOIIMDS ��Wp�iFR FASEIIEN
RIVERHOUSE RESTAURANT �6• Gqt�, 5�E¢)
(NOTSl18JECTTOCfTY R����.��y�q
APPROVAL)
� OATOUT�OORSAIESlSTORAGE �
� (SINGLE LEVEL RACKS],_ _ — _ L' _
��p' WnTF.'R ��� �� _ ��— —
" I +►��""� N8�9°57'S6'_W 249.69' ,_
-..-------e`�-�°°
�� .__. _ _
� —
;�'� 9
,
SAFE SIGHT TRIANGLE �
��� SEM'� FASENFM SEICMST UIRI�ES
(O.R.B. 1856, PG 3IJ) P.G.A. BOULEVARD ���,��o �„ RE�S
- - w- - - - 'i; i - - - - -
TYPE D CURB DETAIL Note:
"°�m Riverhouse Restaurant valet parking Is accommodated in area designaled
as Parcel B on survey as per recorded parking agreement dated 17.16.88
� ��j�� °'"` �� and license agreement dated 4.15.94. (NOt subJect to City Approval)
.�„�,.o... �"�'�,.,:,.. �.�.._,. ;,1—i
..,� "'""L'" � DEVELOPMENT TEAM
;.�_. r� a�:�:�w.,�.�,.,,�,.
,....,,,.�., w.m., �o..�,��.
" =` � v�.��,�,�.,�
... , r , , �- . . +,. �::... : _ . . '. � . . . _...•:.'.:EN�:MC9Erqmieiq,:hr .: _ .
Type F Curb Detail Handicap Ramp ��E��«r�.,�.�,�
��
t`i0i0: MYIr^mnP�u�WUnmT�n�ImMMwM��*'+�
'All sto bars shall be thertno lastic stri m. '°�''°°"""' "°"'n° `°'°'"'�""'
P P P 9 a+e+U...m�w.�.mn....v�vmmrv�r a
.�a���.���.
�
Zoning = CG1
LUP=C
PARKING SPACE DETAILS
� . . ��
S02°14'O6"E
5.0�'
NO2°40'48'W
5.00'
Zoning = PO
LUP = C
L �
�
W
� Q
�FUELINODOCK �
l ¢
J '� —N,C R9LE Q
�
I �
---i� � Z
_ — _ — _ — �
I
— — — = � = �
ADUITIONAL OPEN SPACE REQUIRED
FOR 9' WIDE PARKING WAIVER
66 SPACES 9' WIDE REQUIRES:
1831.5 S.F. OF ADDITIONAL OPEN SPACE —
1' X 18.5' = 78.5'
18.5' X66=1221.0
1221.0�C1.5=1831.5
q .,�„ t . . ____— __ . . .
F �co�� i
—M ..� �urOfM� ~ :�: 4
ti � �. �
:-.A.� �_ ° �
.x.e,�� � ....�. � i-La .
I� j . .. . . . ,�, �, � . � ..., .....
�x �uw�� � .rowve.`v�.•
10' PAftKING SPACE .. HANDICAPED PARKING SPACE HANDICAPED SIGN (TYP.� 9' PARKING SPACE
N.T.S MiS N.T.S. N.i3.
ki � CI�
STUDIOS�
Urban Planning & Design
Landscape Architecture
Communicadon Graphics
The Lofts al City Place
477 S. Rosemary Ave., Suile 225
Wesl Palm Beach, FL 33401
P 561-386-1100
F 561-366-111i
wvnv.udkstudios.com
CopyrlpM
AII IMGI� El�IYM� �R('WemMNrlIW WAII!
npnwMatl by iM� Enwliry �rv owmtl by
�M Ih� proprly d ifi� Malpn�i, aiM rvn
cnetW (p iM �xdwHe uu o/Na �pctME
nroAcL m.0 kNn. aukM. amnwm«�a
or pe�u �NII �wt M w�d by, w tll�doaW
a.�r w�o�, n�� w o«a«nia+.nnow
L`.c wrHNn WrtM�alon dIM dulpMr.
wa: a.atto
PmJeclNO.: Gi-19T.013
DWCnW 6Y: J9
DmmBy: J9
ChackeE By: A6lSP
Dale Oravm By UaW Drex� 0y
Q�
0
Z�
� �
� �
� V
� � �
_ � U �
�
■ � C �
� � l.J�
■ � � �
�.�.. � � �
NORTF! /� ���OF
�f(� �C�
. ��--� ��<_ i � ���Ns
Scale: 1" = 30'- ' ���N��QJy�
W
c ........_. . . ,.�r�y .
V � � , � � a�N,�U'
of 1
MULCHAREA
MULCH
N65°Ot'28'E
22.31'
...,. �
/ / / / /
/ /
/ / FOMWAY EASGMJIi
i / ' (O.R.B. 58a2, PG J9�)
. ' �`
RcU�WAY
(C.R.B. [
6' SFi1GQ0.S?
EASEkENi (N(1T
exu�eauamsaamai
COMMERCIAL gx
BUIL�ING �
N4C
sror sicn
STOP BAR
�- -
• . • .�a •
:... _ . -
... •. -.• � -.•. . .-•.
...
�'. • ;�u� �..
f� �� � �
Ff '' ` /
lf/fr4
_.:,} � �
�;}�.. v , . /���Q
3 �� I��
f�. ���. ��/ r� �
4 -
I � �C�� ,���I �
Q • � � : � ' Illlllllt;,�!�
v `' - ,�
'
� II l, � �S� I
' `. s! �• � �t��
. s. .�a
, ` ll.. .. ,..,'t�,2D?�,�� �
. !�`� � . �
<. .,�l�k� ��%�/���/I . d. '�� �:
� ' � �
�
,1::rl;�..:•- • ��.,- L
.:�:�..,.���� � . . .. . �
.. �:v�.-.'
��y`��� ��
•'• � �� �
t �5c i1': 1 �1'
IfiM13�}'~iiY
�� .
�p�((� :�� • ���• • ••.
�lbi- •'
�_
�___ ._ — _ -'�--
i _ _ _ _ _
n, iEX13TIN64FICU5HED0E :e��uinP��
;��. .
11 REMOVABLE—�
WHEEI S�_....
REMOVABLE CHAIN-
FOR CROSS ACCESS
— —�
i
� E%ISTINGQUEEN
���-0.
O.F.B. ;�X.4� P.6. COUN�' U�lll'�
1755 ,�_�39.EmFGS'Y3•Y-'i93 �
`_`L".�"=��==�,,;,.__-_-----„---
\ SAFE SIGHT TRIANGIF \ FnSEUt7Ji o.R.B.
\�.F.pq�pny. 3639.PG5 190-193
E%ISTWO MAM06ANV TftEE
� (NOIE: NL H.V pQViY iPFE3 ME EXAS1P431
_�_ _ �1 _ _ 1 -_
�
61GWFIES 9B' PIASTIG 0.00T BMfl1EH
AS PF20NOE0 BV DEEP q00T.
SEACOAST NOTES:
Note: All landscaping shall conform to SUA
Construction Standards and Specifications - -
Section II, Item "D" Landscape Guidelines.
E%ISTWGCOCONUTPALM . ""'""•
(NOIE PLL �t PNH& ME EXISTMlGI
LICM
�
� ,-.. ��
� �`�:
� �'`
7 `��
��
� �
� O
'
� �
:�,'.
( �
I �
N 87°45'S4" E 100.00'
N g2°10'3�1' E 1fi0.55' .
P.O.B. S02°14'�"E
... .�'C"�- S 87°AS'5-4' W 99.78� � 5.00'
! �
N 5.ifi �•� '=�„� � S 02° 01�'34" � PEry1METER
(161: � ��(ZIP1��)
WATERWAY
SOVERELHARBOUR
iz_,___ _
WOODENCIi055� � �'-.' �y
�y�sn.p bn. � �EO RIVER HOUSE
''p_ � CARTSTORAGE
9 RAILROAD nES N � /
RIVERHOUSE � ,� �/
RESTAURANT
(NOTINCLUDED) \ �
— _ _ __' — — — _ — — — � izsEwnc�
�`�' ��M COVEREDSEATINGARG
`PJSi � — � _ �' SWGTpkY fASflAENT��,_ � � I _ _ _ _ �K' � _ � ' — -F � —
E%ISTMG 16" F.M_ °0�^q1A'°°111°'��0�
- — — —i— .¢-oewr�wc-nccna�— — — -.--i-FHELTANKS-�
1, i 1 DUMPSTER
N �
8'TPL.GATES
�CFWN-LNkC FENCE WITH SUTS)
EXISTING 6' FICUS HEDGE
I I I iSAS 16Y15
I LWnIHGAAEA µw[v.Fiwcuvw
I
I I I
!Si 7ypE 0 CURB
I ' I
� �i I � �
o?
� I MARINE
SALES OFFICE 8
I I BOAT SALES
. e t ,-x.c. caossixa
p`,�;" , �.,
� e;����.��.
;U;,:�.n',F; . " `
y'''.•''. F �.
�.�'���y?� ' !
�� V�'6 ��� �y
�"x"� ����i�l�t����3
��
■-.—_ �
.�
;::..
-I�
... . . : ..
�
ROOFED OVERHANG
vM�
12' F.b. COUNIY U71Litt STORE
fA£kEPf! 0 R.B.
26J9, f'GS �90 � �
••
u�
20' FlRE ACCESS !AM1'E
r--untln' F/.SEYEMi
NO2°40'40'W
5.0��
¢
�
1 Q
FUELING �OCK �
J� �
� �f1AC POl: �
�
I �
—! P-� Z
BJIWNS WA7FR EtSEMEfR ` — _- — .- — — �
(6� GV.V. S7EEL)
� FlRE HYDFPNI
_ :� .. � . � . .
. .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
. . . .
-�'�a � . . .. . �,oi•r__ ____'_— — — � �
��=,yR. _ - _--- __�
` ..
SAFESIGHTTRIANGLE I gEEF00TPUJ1lNi(i%NIF00.0ETqlfOYW(IU9T
-mfraxmrxe. ! sucoasrununEs
ro. a �5� �i P.G.A. BOULEVARD �'�,� �oF�„ �,��"�
ADDITInNAL OPEN SPACE REQUIRED
� — - - ff3R-9`WIDE-�ARKtN��1AIAlt/€R- -
66 SPACES 9' WIDE REQUIRES:
1831.5 S.F. OF ADDITIONAL OPEN SPACE
1' X 18.5' = 78.5'
18.5' X 66 = 1221.0
1221.0 X 1.5 = 1831.5
�.. . I
��
k� I da�
STUDIOS
Urban Pianning 8 Design
�andscape Architecture
Communication Grephics
The Lofts at City Place
477 S. Rosemary Ave., Surie 225
West Palm Beach, FL 330.07
P 561-366-1100
F 561-36E1111
www.udksludios.com
CapyrlpM
AII M�tl� N�IgMr tn�nBame111�� �M WGN
r.pr...M.a nr mb amH�a.� ow�.a ny
md Ilu V�W�M of th� Mkrwr� �M wv�
antl�d fw tlr �roWtNS ur NIM �PwM W
Praf�C. Thu� IMU� b��Yn�. u*�Mwn�i�h
a pl�n� �h�ll mt M uME Oy, or dl�cbsM
b mY Wnon� Ilrm� w caryw�GUii wIUaR
«
m. wrin.� wmm..w� aaw eo.p�.r.
o.a: a.m.io
Prof�dNa: B1-iB1.013
UnIpME9y: JB
Onwn9y: JB
Ch�ek�d6y: AB/BP
Q�
�
� O
� �
� v,
Q�
�
� � C
� �
a���
� � � �,
�m U
� � � �
O��J�
NORTH
0 15' 30' 60'
�i��
Scale: 1" = 30'-0"
LA-1
of 2
Plant Legend (On-site
e=.�,= �� � ��� oo � s■
■ �. � �...��� �::'�.�:"�m0 ... .: . . , � ■
i�
O
i�
1
V,
�
'y
�d `t
����
sMauas
un svw
1B 0.'�OCi700 TW FlC
�i�
.�
�
� FJ�J�J? ���
� j �m�
� ,•<•••• ���
.,.. •
.,r,.•D,.,'.
[{�iLf
� i�� �
� '/H///< ��
� �� '�'
MT. Sa��. nEw�aks
siz �w
I EH°trp
2�' JO` 3W.wM.M1abOeae.2a•o.c.
14' 11' 1pel.rqd.fuMbbw,ID'o.c
ta• � te'I 3um.oxA,ftmEase.ZCOa
1�' � 16 � �YN.mM.Nlbbcea.2l'o.a
1�' � 1S � 3qd.mM..MbOwN'O.c.
� .
� ■
� �
� �
� �
soo
QiY PIPMNANE M. SPR I�EAWi1B
0.025 15.800 SLHqutinoFbHam Uuwkw.YqEOM1M L_J❑
•wn uN4Ym Ya'fB.Y
57 708 3 f
, . - . �. �.. :�
Points Required: 10,726.21 100 S� x 18 = 10,387.49 Required Points
Points Provided: �3j���.�
NO7E:LANDSCAPE MATERIAI BEING�:4:.%1J1E0 ON`FQOT EMBANKMENT ARE NOT INCLUOED IN PROVI�ED POINT CALCULATIONS.
iRIM plY i1p5C iT010i MU[N W]Y
ri nv lEVF1 R 1R[E KMIi.
qMIMN 6' XCE (A � iKM lPORS.
rmc. cnvxwc rx�c m x wsr+ �"
x�mrcuc ar uticss m�av�sc
vccvan
rvuM nuxcrzx s�w� rt <msisrcxr -
an.wr .w�v. ow¢s. �oosc
�caTM[s. �ncx, ro uvrtrcs
YP10.f MiTEM V/ 2-]/�' NIW LMIOI
SlE(L W1p5 ip 140 Mi�ipi d
RKE xl x�rt[ iwa Mrvw
�a.P�
�,�„ � �,..E.�
s.n� rt wcaco w m�*mn m�
Fuart Q ixc ex.a rw �xaurz
n.co¢
S li v� a 16•1 VCO4 NIiCNS-
s uxtxs vr r.aiw ro ww mwK.
w
sw. wms �v.�� ••••
xMlxx J t2��1 VYA RiGCS
INI.O �-6' <UIipAYlJS $N1(£N N�M
TE 1RCC PR i0 fR0 V/.iFR
aK..zrr s.w.c aev �rm.�
fLLl M1%l. W➢ FWR/A1 vIM )MCf0.t.
amv. � cawrc* rw., xr�mvsr a
cw.cr rw. i wv rrzx umruwi�ox
w wvu m ixswc amwimv m
�orcKers.
LrC5M1 �5 PEP VL.w1A'u iO�[S
TYPICAL PA�M TREE PLANTING
x.s
w�c m a amr w.� sw.�
¢ �r �v.sr vz� uuv[ nc
�ws v w�x
wu[ uux nr w�cxs
e�xcnw uxc mic ru
va�ns ro Knsve •
wsux xnss.
�FMK .WY [pll�VfT Qf1ER
lMUI kVIF° i1MI IMY �E
.ms�v vm�s.
..�
uno re• can.nn�swcee
•PoWO }�E iREE Vrt t01Q0
�az�wnw v�.u.
IdllVati �PSniFN Tvx�
2' q C�xS1fR M4l Sli
W MPHJ 0� WE�SfiAYL
sm m vavcxr sc*nnc.
xmrwa�s �css � r
r sir ox �we.crzo
S@. IXPIlIER Q� KlE
f91 BIILi 2' L 4iGiER
Mu� x r i.acca rw�x
YINEiER Of' B�lt.
onrcrrn a �rt.e me
�n a rwi�c vi� >��uc�rm
mi r.*[vux m crosm a
i�vE 56L (NI M.E WG
i➢i RAYt.
LARGE SHRUB PLANTING
,,.�
nxr eaurt�w rw.� ce caa.nco
iK P'RCCTIfN 6 TxF Ov�ER.
,:3'..;;^`' 'li�, .
..ti•'':�:; I+ ..
`y I
i '
'tI� ' I
�i,
.0 .
�
•
�
.�
�..
��
3.-
�.
�.
���`� ., �� �� I. �h. .
iy��'�
�I I 1�
��, � �. �+
r'_
� .�,
./�rl_�
� I}# � � I 1 I �
r"mae�°�y,wer,.:r„�,a,`;ia;9:co'�a'.. I � �I II�� I'f.
.II. �+ �ii - ,°il��'=� I ��
=11''.�°���../?% II_ q;.,
_j� ;�b�`�ri ;ayii�
... II!!1L . �
=ii=u=n.=��
♦�
PfMK CNN02 fFM TC l0V 1/3 6-
rxc cm*wu. um rcm wu�.n
wre a *�u+c
MnIKx Y SxPEt�y C� YSS L.er �
MM1W6' IIONI�fGM H� C�6 iNiX�f.S�•
lIP OF ARI.M iILL SIW.L X I.i LE1S
1' I.WVC 11lE fM[SICO WR]E.—
TREE PLANTING (2-4" CALIPER)
x..�.
w x.ns aw.� x wrvw wm ia¢
101nK SMU C t91E 6 xm W.Ai
scws.
'SIMOC iPFES SW41 IMVC � 3Y(YE.
StYlrfrt iAUKK VIlM SPRpRf
nwa.r xmvcu av �a.wc�
unvvw.r msrx�wrco, ra¢ s
nu v-awco cw�acx
�i �z rai �b wiu.�sw�n a.
uu vz• awcrtx au�ccrn we�c
VIPC� 3 QIVS xIN IIXALRt4KVaVRE4
FvE�lv
mr.cco� at *uvr�wc��t rEn wr
VIK� UR VMi[ M1NL'W alapIX
wRV �-c� cmnwws s.vcca �waxo
1MC l.ffE P�i f0 Mk4 l:[ vl.lfR.
x , . . zr snxc
lPYb1f0 tlUK
fIl1 INIFA�N. SiMLL LMSIii 6IMLIVE
ma rxw� wac wc m� nun.
�1E �L�lCPS��IIE' 1(OVC iK
IES! T/tt' 6 P�WL 10 K
IP'KL TC fRGHi EIX£ IK
r�c wwrow �o.
Y• MIX 5146LE➢ CYHiSS MALN
ir vm�x ,vnw �cn rn¢ es
wa ms w.:x..vr�a
concn�+c m c .� x�w
rtwsx cv�ec rc mn.
CYISi1N' 91L
PLANTING BED EDGE
urw� s s�wurs nt �x[
M1urtpG L'�"E �S Nx[
rnsr ro [nwusK�
�,.,,.� �� _..,�
} + 6 AF10 !O fI[C iF91t
+ 6 MVlIlF K0.
}+ i� t' RFMIrM1rli 9NIS ME fSt[➢
+ } 1' u �t�WE iK INxt SMNB
y + + sm vsc xauR m snomx
} � f� �KE
� { + NIL,CX RIXL
I+ i.� `.1 �: 1O� i ro¢vp�x*�m answ
+ • PLYIIIML Lm EWE. LVL LLUN
+ .,�^�^ ',.� � uro sruion �s wxcrm
' er Q,.rca.
..�v'`Ty":✓.��`'•''':. wnnswa•eeeomcni
`°`yt.•r•i:r':`a��`:�r. aoc��aruru.x}u+s
SHRUB AND
GROUND C�VER LAYOUT
x.=.
� \�y\��\�\\�
1�'��:�a fi����
��\�.����;�, SV1�
\�)q,V�V�\�\ �
����t�y\�'s`��
�\Q\\�\\�\"�\
' � � �
� � •�� �
Typical Canopy Tree, Lnrge or Exotic Paim Tree with Root Barrier
]rs ld. N09
�
Root Barrier Symbol (see spec de�ow)
N.T.S.
ROOT BARRIER QTY.
' usau,uu....err�w � �
Ia�tw.�re.nnwa-s
Y'IW�YNrtY.MIId
rtWNOivN�[i4n`Y�MWYM1��tld �Yful��N�
pwYw�%�WhYeR� �
W �
I�+wM'
uaeanieu.fw..
�
.itY�WWr rruawmV�
'NW14+e^ wnW�Mw��..
•trp[mxa�
.htlab
r.�nor.r.. P��.
ronxx+:vrwni.e �.�si w
tesf.wn�l�wl�nm.��..1 nnitr
v�.uww..+y.«a�ee..
�m+M•���bao�anam Raxiw)nwurt.
.NM�
w��r..wPU.,.un-nv.i �sawwaro�
UM�T11fa�4fN1�xIT�fl�N �+ov
MacqY_119]9UFn�w
4�Yw+MMW✓Y+
._.... .-�c�
Iwwn�MY IYwI��Yr� '�M�IIVhYWY111lWxltk4
„y„µ� wWm�ewaowua
��� ��«u`
s�w�rer
o-.o '�
�w�w� aw w� — �hw
......
. W �.,...,�-.� _,� � �. �.
�.�.�..,��„�.
.��,;.�..��
.�����
•wo+a.-mar.an�eux..arannu.rw ^==+%ti.:
mwvm.veva •.•"••
•w.�r r�u�
.�.��_._..�.._�.�
COMMERCIAL FERTILIZER MEASUREMENTS PLANT MATERIALS
SHAOE TREES: HEIGHT SHALL BE MEA9URE0 fROM GftOUNO (T0.EE5, SHRUBS, GROUNDCOVERS. AND VINES)
FERTiLIZERS SHALL BE UNIFORM M COMPOSITION DRY AND TO THE AVERACaE BRANCH HEIGHTOF CNiOPY. SPREAD
FREEFLOWINO.THEFERTILI2ERSHALLBEDEINEREDT THE SHALLBEMEASUREOTOTHEEN�OFBRANCHINGE UALLY
PLANT SPECIES AND SIZE SHALL CONFORM TO TH0.SE
O Q
SITEINTHEORIOMIALUNOPENEO&10S,EACHBEARINOTHE AItOUNDTHECROWNFROM7HECEMTEROFTHETRUNK �NDICATEDONTHEDRAWINGS.NOMENCLATURESHPLL
MANUFACTURERSSTATEMENTOFANALYSIS ANOSHALLME MEASUREMENTSARENOTTOINCLUDEANYTERMINAL
CONFORMTOSTANDARDIZEOPIANTNAMES 1942
E7
THEFOLLOWINGRE�UIREMENTS; SIX(8)PERCENT GROKTH. SINGLETRUNKTREESSHALLBEFREEOFY EDIiION. PILNURSERY3TOCK3HALLBEINACCORDANCE
NITROGEN,SIX(8)PERCENTPHOSPHOROUS,ANDSIX(8) CROTCHESTHATCAULABEPOINTSOFWEAKLIMB WITMGHNDESANOSTANDARDSFORNURSERYPLANTSPARTS
PERCENTPOTASSIUM. FERTILiZERSHALLBEAPPLIEATO STRUCTUREORDISEASEINFESTATION.
I d II LqTEST EDITION PUBLISHED BYTHE FLORI�A
ALL 3Y,ftUBS (1l3 LB. PER 3 OAL. POT, 1/4 LB. PER t DEPARTMENT OF AGftIW LTURE AND CONSUMER SERVICES.
GA POnANDGROUNOCOVER. THESODSTARTERFERTI- SHRUBS: HEIGHTSHALLBEMEASUREDFROMTHEGROUND UNLES33PECIFIEDOTHERWISE,ALLPINVT3SHAI.LBE
IJZERMIXTURESHALLBEASIO-10ATARATE TOTHEAVERAOEPOINTWNEREMATUREPLANTOROWTH FLORIOAGRA[)ENUMBERiORBETfERASDETERMINE�eY
OFiSLBS.PER10003.F.. THEUPKEEPFERTILIZERSHALI STOPS. SPREA�SHALlBEMEASURE0T07HEENOOF
THE FLORIOA OIVISION OF PLANT INDUS7RY. &PECIMEN
BEA7&48COMPLETEFERTIIJZERA141414 9RANCHINGEOUPLLYARWNDTHESHRUBWSS.
MEANS AN EXCEPTIONAILY HEAW SYMAiETRICAL. iICaHTLV
FERTILIZERISRE�UIREDONALLTREESAND MEASIIREMENTMEANOTTOINCLUOEANYTERMINAL KNITPLANT,SOTRAINEDORFAVOREOINRS
SFIRUBSOVERS'NNEIGHT(12LB.PER50FSPREPD). GRONTH. DEVELOPMENTTHATFIRSTAPPEARANCEISUNQUESTIONABLE
AGRIFOftM TABLETS WITH TYEIdIY (2�) PERCENT ANO OUTSTANDINGLY SUPERIOR IN FORM, NUMBER OF
NITROCaEN, TEN (10) PERCENTPHOSPHOROUS, FIVE (5) PALMS: CLEAR WO00 (C.W.)-SHN.L BE MEASUREO FROM BRANCHES, COMPACTNESS AND SYMMETRV. AlL PLANTS
PERCENT POTASSIUM IN 21 GRAM SIZES 9MALL BEMPLIFA THE GROUND AT TIME INSTALLATION TO THE BOTTOM OF SHALL 8E FftESHLY OUG, SOUND, HEALTHY, VIGOROUS,
AT THE FOLLOWING RATE: i PER i GAL. PIANTS, 2 PER THE PROND 8HEATH, WELI BRANCHED AND FREE OF OISEASE AND INSECT EGGS
3 OAL. PLANT3 AN� 2 TABIETS PER 1' OF TREE 7RUNK AND LARVAE AND SHALI MAVE ADEWATE ROOT SYSTEMS.
CALIPER. MPLYPALMSPECIALASPERI.WJUFACTUREftS OVERALIHEIGHT(OA.)•SHALLBEMEASURFDfROMTHE TREESPORPLhNTINGRONSSHALLBEUNIPORMINSIZE
RECOMMENDATION. GROUND ATTHETIMEOFINSTALIATIONTOTHEAVERAGE ANOSHAPE:ALLMATERW.SSHALL6ESUBJECTTO
FRONDHEIGHT. APPROVALSYTNEOWNER. WHEftEftE�UIREMENTSARE
MUICH OMITfED FRC�M THE PLAfJT LIST, THE PLANTS FURNISHED
PALMS WITH MARRED OR BIJRNED TRUNKS WILL NOT BE SHALL BE NORMAL FOR THE VARIETYAND PLORIDAp1.
MULCHMATERIALSHALLBESHREDDEDCVPRESSMULCHAND �CCEPTED. PLANTSSHALLBEPRUNEDPRIORTODEIIVERVONLYUPON
THE APPROVAL OF THE OWNER.
MOISTENEO AT THE TIME OF APPLICATION TO PREVENT .
WINODISPLACEMENT.MULCHSHALLBEAPPLIEDTOA PIANTINGSOILANDBACKFILL CONTAINERGROWNSTOCK
MINIMUM 3' �EPrM IN PLANTING BE0.S.
PLANTING SOIL POR USE IN PREPARING BACIffILL FOR
SOD PLANTPITSSHALLBEAFERTIIE,FRIABIE,NATIVESOIL 1.ALLCONTAINERGROWNMATERIALSHALIBEHEALTHY,
WITHOUTMIMUREOF9U&SOILMATERIALS.ITSMALL VIGOROUS,WEIL-ROOTEOPLANTSANDESTABLISHEOINTHE
THE SOD SHALL MEEf FLORIDA STATE PLANT BOAftO BE FREE FROM HEAW CLAY, STONES, UME, LUMPS, CONTAINER-IN WHICH THEV ARE SOLO. THE PLANTS SHFLI
SPECIFICATIONS, ABSOLUTEIY TRUE TO VARIETALTYPE, AN� �NTS, ROOTS OR OTHER FOREIGN MATERIALS, WEEDS, OR �VE TOPS OF GOOD �UALIT'ANO BE IN A HEALTHY
FREE FROM WEEDS, FUNGU3, INSECTSAND OISEPSES OF NOXIOUS GRASSES (SUCH AS BERMUDAORNUT GRASS). R GROWIN� CGNDITION.
ANV KIND. SHALL NOT CONTNN TOXIC SUBSTANCES WHICH MAY BE
NARMFUL TO PLPNT GROWTH. 2. AN ESTABLISHED CONTAINER OftOWN PLAM SHALL BE
SUBSTITUTIONS TRANSPIANTED INTO A CONTAINER ANO GROWN IN THAT
BACKFILLFORSODAREASSHALLBESU&�ECTTOLESSER CONTAINERSUFFICIENttVIONOENOUGMFORTHENEW
NO SUBSTITUTION OF PL.',NT MATERIAL NPES OR SIZES STANDAROS AT THE DISCREfION AND DECISION OF THE OWNER FIBROUS ROpTS TO HAVE OEVELOPED SO THAT THE ROOT
WILL BE ALLOWED WITHOUT WftfTTEN AUTHORIZATION FROM MASS WILL RL-TAIN ITS S4APE PND HOLD TOGETHER WHEN
THEOWNER.CONTAINERGROWNMATERIALWILLN0T9E PLANTINGSOILFORL'SEWBE�SPORANNUALSAND/OR REMOVEOFROMTHECONTAMER. -
ACCEPTED AS SUBSTITUTE FOR 88 B MATERIAL UNLESS PEftENNIALS SHALL CONTAIN NATIVE SOIL OUG FftOM HOLE.
PREVIOUSLVAPPROVED.INTENOEDSUBSTITl7TIONSSNALIBE TILLINTOTHETOP16121NCHESOFSOILWITHA
SPELLED OUT IN BIO. TIME-RELEASE FERTILIZER. �
ur�ar�
���g�i
��iaa�
STUDIOS
Urban Planning 8 Design
Landscape Architecture
Communication Graphics
The Lofts at City Place
477 S. Rosemary Ave., Sufls 225
West Palm Beach, FL 33407
P 561-366-1100
F 561-366-1111
w�wr.udkstudlos.com
Copy�ipM
MI Weey Malpm. PmnyemaM�� �M plana
iepnea�rted by ihu dm�inp �n owmd by
�nd N� P�W rtY of Mc tla�9mr� mE vnn
'MNI.� iIX MN �ACIW M VN OIIMl�CIMA
PraHct TMw Wu�. Jnkn�, �mna�nrnn
w pim� �h�ll m! be u�etl Ey, adbelosM
to tnY WnoM ��, a�Pa+�ui Mltlrout
�I1IYTMIM �lIMl�b114�1MCp�QMf.
o.i.: a.oi.+o
v�,1.�NO.: et.ic�.ma
WtlpnW By: J9
Deawn By; JB
ChwkMBy: A819P
a�
Z�
� �
� }^`i
� W
�^, ^`
W W
�
Q �
\V �,�'I`
� •`V
� �, �
■ .0 � �
� �
F
r � � �
�� U
� �
�
� �
�
�. � � �
LA-2
of 2
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
PLANNING, ZONING, AND APPEALS BOARD
Agenda Cover Memorandum
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Subiect/Aqenda Item
Ordinance 21, 2010/Petition LDRA-10-03-000029: Code Amendment to Section 78,
Division 7. Signs
Public Hearing and Recommendation to City Council: A City-initiated request to amend
the City's Land Development Regulations ("LDRs") regarding the purpose and intent,
permitted signs, prohibited signs, other related issues, and certain definitions.
[ X ] Recommendation to APPROVE
[ ] Recommendation to DENY
Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: Finance: N/A PZAB Action:
R. Max Lohman
Planning and Zoning: Costs: [] Rec. approval
Martin Schneider, � N�A [] Rec. app. w/ conds.
City Attorney AICP Total [] Rec. Denial
�' �� [ ] Continued to:
1'L�:,_�
Bahareh Wolfs, AICP Planner � N/A
N/A
Development Compliance Current FY
[ ] Quasi-Judicial Funding Source:
Allyson Black [ X ] Legislative
[ X ] Public Hearing [ ] Operating
(X ]
Resource Manager Other N/A
Natali ong, AICP Budget Acct.#:
Advertised: N�q Attachments:
Date: July 9, 2010 • Ordinance 21, 2010
Paper: Palm Beach
Directo of Planning and Post
Zoning
[ X ] Required
Approved by:
Ronald M. Ferris Affected parties
Notified:
[ ] Notified
City Manager [ X] Not Required
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-00002910rdinance 21, 2010
Page 2 of 29
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The subject petition is comprised of various amendments to the City's sign code (Division
7. Signs). The City's sign regulations were last updated in 2000 as part of the rewrite to
the entire Land Development Regulations. At several City Council meetings, City Council
has mentioned the need to revisit the sign regulations and requested staff research sign
issues. Staff has also received general comments from the business community and
residents regarding signage regulations. In addition, staff has had a number of internal
discussions on Sign Code issues, including review meetings with various personnel of
other departments to see how the Code could be updated and improved.
Staff is proposing a number of amendments to the Code for technical or regulatory
reasons. In addition, a number of proposed revisions are recommended to the permitted
signs regulations. These amendments are intended to provide clarity and simplification to
the Code, and reduce the number of PCD/PUD waiver requests for signage. Staff received
direction from City Council on these proposals at the June 17, 2010, City Council meeting.
The amendments are detailed below in the Proposed City Code Amendments section.
At the July 20, 2010, meeting of the Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board (PZAB), this
item was postponed to date certain time of August 10, 2010, at 6:00 p.m., to give the board
and business community more time to meet with staff and further review the proposed
amendments. Since that time, staff has met one-on-one with PZAB members, and with a
group of business representatives to review the amendments.
PROPOSED CITY CODE AMENDMENTS
Staff is proposing the following text amendments to the following Code Sections (deletions
are �I�, new language is underlined):
DIVISION 7. SIGNS*
*Editor's note: Formerly, div. 6. See the editor's note ch. 78, art. V, div. 3.
Sec. 78-271. Intent and purpose.
� The purpose of this division is to create the legal framework for a comprehensive
and balanced system of signage to facilitate
no�„�o �niJ +hoir o,,,,�r„n.,-,on+ the effective use of sians as a means of communication in
the citv and to avoid the visual clutter that is potentially harmful to traffic and pedestrian
safety, property values, business opportunities and community appearance. With these
purposes in mind, it is the intent of this division to "�'+hnri-�o +�o „ o„f ;ryn nr,,,,;,�o�, +ho„
,
, �
,
Tonihlo ;� +������� :n �r,.,_, .,�r�.���oG ��,T enable the fair and consistent
enforcement of these siqn reaulations and to promote the implementation of the citv's
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 3 of 29
comarehensive future land use plan. Additionallv, this division provides for reaulations to
achieve the followina:
(1) Proaertv value arotection. Siqns should not create a nuisance to the occupancv or
use of other properties as a result of their size, heiaht, brightness or movement. Thev
should be in harmonv with buildinas, the neiahborhood and other conformina sians in
the area.
(2) Communication. Sians should not denv other persons or aroups the use of siaht
lines on aublic riahts-of-wav, should not obscure important aublic messaaes and should
not overwhelm readers with too manv messaaes. Sians can and should help
individuals to identifv and understand the iurisdiction and the character of its subareas.
(3) Preservation of communitv's beautv. Cities such as this which include larae
landscaaina buffers and numerous planned develoaments, consistina of small and
larae office, retail, residential and industrial uses. relv heavilv on their natural
surroundinas and beautification efforts to retain their economic viabilitv. This concern is
reflected bv the active and obiective reaulations of the appearance and desian of sians.
(b) Reaulations strictiv enforced. It shall be unlawful for anv persons to post, displav,
chanae or erect a sian or sian structure that reauires a permit without first havina obtained
a aermit therefore in accordance with section 78-276. Sians or sian structures erected
without a valid permit shall be deemed in violation of this chaater and it shall be mandatorv
to obtain the applicable permit, or remove the sian or sian structure immediatelv. All sians
not exaresslv aermitted bv this chapter are strictiv prohibited.
�Note: The modification will clarify the
enforce the sign regulations and iss�
permitting requirements.]
Sec.78-272. Application.
purpose and intent language, in order to
ie violations on failure to comply with
The regulations of this division shall apply to all signs within the city.
Sec. 78-273. Nonconforming signs.
(a) Retention of existing signs. Every legal sign existing as of da„� �°Y�� � �,�°Q� new
adoation datel, and which is a type of sign not permitted in this division or is not consistent
with the requirements of this division may be continued or retained until da^� �°„ r�?��o
six vears from adoation date, except as may be provided otherwise by the city council.
(b) Expiration, removal, and exempt signs. Upon expiration of the time period stated in
subsection (a) above, all affected signs shall be removed immediately by the property
owner. Signs exempt from this requirement are listed below.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-0000291Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 4 of 29
(1) PUD signs. Signs which have been specifically approved as part of a PUD, PCD, or
site plan within a PCD.
(2) Flat wall signs. Existing flat wall signs below the third floor of a multiple story
building or the roof line of two-story office buildings shall be allowed to remain
indefinitely. However, these signs are subject to the nonconformina structure
provisions of section �-� 78-715.
(3) Residential development signs. Signs located within residential zoning districts
which indicate the name of a residential subdivision or development.
(4) Certain nonconforming signs. Signs made nonconforming by sign regulation
revisions adopted by � r�.,�;n�nce-��-9-9- finsert Ordinance #1 are subject to the
nonconformina structure provisions of section �� 78-715.
(5) Annexation.
a. Any permanent sign existing on property annexed into the city, not permitted
under this division but lawful at the time of annexation, shall be removed no later
than six years from date the city comprehensive land use plan change affecting
the property is adopted by the city council.
b. Temporary signs which are not permitted by this division shall be removed within
60 days from the date of adoption of the comprehensive land use plan
amendment which pertains to such property.
(c) Amortization. The time period provided in this subsection is for the purpose of
amortizing the costs of a sign created or existing on or prior to adoption of the ordinance
from which this section originally derived by virtue of lease of location or sign space, or
throuah annexation into the citv.
�Note: This provides new dates and timeframes for retaining signs made
nonconforming by the sign code amendments, and refers to the correct
nonconforming structure provisions.]
• . .... ..
. ., _, � _: _ -. � ., _ � . . . .. _. � . . -�:
-.... . .. . . _ ., ._ .. _, . . . .. . -- -... _, . . ..
�.� .::_,:.��..�n..�.�e...:� ._.:.�_�:�_.:
[Note: This section is obsolete. Its purpose was to ensure all temporary signs that
existed when the sign regulations were adopted in 2000 wou/d need to be removed
within 30 days of the newly adopted regulations.]
Sec.78-274. Reserved.
Sec.78-275. Addresses.
All residential and nonresidential structures shall post the building address in a location
viewable, readable and unobstructed from the adjacent public or private right-of-way. The
size of residential address numbers shall not be less than four inches or exceed six inches
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 5 of 29
in height or as otherwise aaaroved bv the addressinq committee based on setback from or
width of riaht-of-wav. The size of nonresidential address numbers shall not be less than
eiaht inches or exceed 12 inches in height, or as otherwise approved by the addressing
committee or the master signage program based upon the specific height of the building to
which the numbers and letters are attached or setback from or width of riaht-of-wav. In
cases where there is no adiacent riaht-of-wav, orfor other reasons of public health. safetv.
or welfare the addressina committee mav use its discretion to determine the appropriate
location and size of addresses.
All nonresidential structures with flat roofs. which have a buildinq footarint of at least
10.000 sauare feet and are constructed after fnew adoation datel. shall have the address
number posted on the rooftop. The address numbers shall be block letters of at least four
feet in heiaht with a minimum of 18 inch letter width. and be made of a reflective material
with a color that contrasts with the roof color. and shall be permanentiv affixed to or aainted
on the roof.
�Note: This sets a minimum number size for residential and non-residential
addresses, and gives the Addressing Committee more flexibility to determine
address numbersize depending on setback, right-of-way width, and otherhealth or
safety reasons. It a/so adds a requirement for rooftop address numbers for new,
non-residential buildings for public safety concerns,]
Sec. 78-276. Permits required, fees, and revocation.
(a) Building permit required. It shall be unlawful for any person to erect, repair, alter,
relocate, or maintain any permanent sign defined in this division without obtaining a
building permit� and paying the required fee.
(b) Revocation. The building official is authorized to revoke any building permit if a sign
is erected or installed that does not comply with the requirements of this division.
(c) Maintenance and inspection.
(1) Maintenance. All signs for which a permit is required, together with all supports,
braces, guys, anchors, sign faces, and other structural and nonstructural members,
shall be maintained in good condition and appearance, and in compliance with
applicable building codes. The ��+i-I�inn� C� may order the removal of any
sign that is not maintained in accordance with this section. The removal shall be at
the expense of the owner or lessee. Examples of unacceptable maintenance and
repair include the following:
a. Cracked, ripped, or peeling paint present on more than ten percent of the
surface area of a sign;
b. Bent, broken, loose, or otherwise insufficiently attached supports, struts, or
other appendages;
c. Partial illumination for more than 14 days;
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 6 of 29
d. Obstruction of sign face by weeds, vines, tree branches, or other vegetative
matter; and
e. Maintaining a position that is more than 15 degrees from vertical for more than
ten successive days.
(2) The building official and/or code enforcement shall reinspect all signs erected within
the city as often as deemed necessary. ",-�-€°° °"^�� "� rorri �irorJ fnr roincr�on+inr�
�Note: This clarifies who may order removal of signs, since it may be a City official
or the magistrate deciding on a Code Enforcement hearing. It also clarifies who may
re-inspect signs, and allows the City to charge for re-inspection costs if needed.]
Sec. 78-277. Design requirements.
All permanent signs shall be designed and constructed in compliance with applicable
building codes. All electric wiring shall be installed underground, within building walls, or
otherwise located so as not to be visible.
Sec.78-278. Variances.
(a) Variance allowed. The ��P�PZAB, consistent with the requirements of section 78-
53, may grant a variance from the strict application of this division.
. •_. .. . ._ .. - - - - -- .._..._ . ._ ! � • -- -- --
- - � • - - - --
{s} � Exceptions.
(1) PUDs and PCDs. The city council may, at time of development order approval or
development order amendment, grant one or more waivers to the requirements of
this division applicable to a PUD, PCD, or site plan within a PCD.
(2) Compliance with intent and purpose. The city council may vary the size, setback
requirements, and number of permitted signs in a PUD, provided the city council
determines a PUD application complies with the general intent and purpose of this
division.
�Note: This corrects the name of the Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board (PZAB),
and eliminates the vote count. The variance process is outlined in Section 78-53.
Variance Requests., and voting requirements are already described in Section 2-95.
Quorum and Required Vote.]
Sec. 78-279. Removal of abandoned signs.
Any sign which no longer is used to advertise a licensed business or a product sold on-
premise shall be removed by the owner of the property, building.-� or structure upon which
the sign is located within ten days after written notification from the building official. Upon
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 7 of 29
failure to comply with the notice within the time specified in the order, the building official is
authorized to cause removal of the sign. Any expense associated with the sign removal
shall be paid by the owner of the property, building, structure, or premises to which the sign
is attached or on which the sign is located.
�Note: Scriveners error corrected.]
Sec. 78-280. Removal of unsafe signs.
If the building official determines any sign regulated in this division is unsafe, insecure, a
menace to the public health, or constructed, erected, or maintained in violation of this
division, a written notice of such determination shall be provided to the property owner. The
owner of the property has ten days following receipt of the written notice to remove, repair
or otherwise alter the sign so as to comply with this division. If the sign is not removed,
repaired or otherwise altered to comply, the necessary removal or improvements shall be
carried out by the building division at the expense of the owner of the property. The
building division shall cause any sign which is an immediate peril to persons or property to
be removed summarily and without notice.
Sec. 78-281. Owner to be charged for cost of removal by city.
When the city has caused or paid for the removal of a sign, the actual cost of the removal
shall be paid by the owner of property on which the sign is located_ The cost of removal
shall include accrued interest at the rate of ten percent per annum from the date of the
completion of the work.
�Note: Scriveners error corrected.]
Sec. 78-282. Lien for costs of removal.
If the full amount due the city for sign removal is not paid by the owner within 60 days after
the removal of such sign, the city shall cause to be recorded in the official record books a
lien against the property. The lien shall remain in full force and effect for the amount due in
principal and interest, plus costs of court, if any, for collection, until final payment has been
made.
Sec. 78-283. Obstructions.
Signs shall not be erected, installed, constructed, attached, or maintained so as to serve as
an obstruction as noted below.
(a) Ingress and egress. A sign shall not block any fire escape, or any window, door, or
opening used as a means of ingress or egress.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 8 of 29
(b) Fire escapes and ventilation. A sign shall not be attached to a fire escape or be placed
in such manner as to interfere with any opening required by the building code for
ventilation.
(c) Visibilitv trianqles. A sian shall not be placed in such a manner as to obscure siahtlines
within the visibilitv trianqle at the intersection of two roads or a road and a private
drivewav in accordance with the citv's intersections reaulations in Sec. 78-508 (d). No
sian located within a visibilitv trianale shall exceed 30 inches in heiaht as measured
from the surface of the nearest vehicular traffic area.
{s3 d� City property. Signs shall not be allowed on city property or rights-of-way within the
city unless specifically authorized by the city council. Any signs not authorized on city
property or rights-of-way shall be immediately removed by the city, and the costs of
such removal shall be borne by the parties responsible for the installation.
{-�} �e Othergovernmental agencies. Other governmental entities which have jurisdiction
or control of public right-of-way may install signs within such rights-of-way. Any signs
that are not authorized on such rights-of-way shall be immediately removed by the city
or governmental agency, and the costs of such removal shall be borne by the parties
responsible for the installation.
[Note: Visibility triangles at intersections are added as areas within which signage
shall not be located in such a manner as to obscure sightlines. While "obstruction
of vision" is listed as a Prohibited Sign (Sec. 78-284(d)), it does not define visibility
triangles or give specific language for what is allowed. More precise language
provided within Sec. 78-283 will help ensure that this public safety issue is not
overlooked by applicants submitting sign petitions or by staff reviewing signage
applications.j
Sec. 78-284. Prohibited signs and prohibited sign locations.
(a) General. The signs described below, unless otherwise provided in this section, are
prohibited and shall not be installed or constructed within the city.
(b) Off-premise signs. Off-site} e� off-premises, or billboard signs are prohibited. �41-s�1�
, ,
� ' r�rnr� n �nihi� �� c��r; �-r.�i-�rvc",Z+'i�.°-c�r.
�.y.
(c) Traffic �el reaulation signs. Any sign which resembles, is similar to, or may be
confused with any sign or device to control vehicular, bicycle, or pedestrian traffic is
prohibited.
(d) Obstruction of vision. Any sign installe
intersection, or in any street right-of-way
prohibited.
d or erected in a location,
so as to obstruct free and
or at a street
clear vision is
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-0000291Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 9 of 29
(e) Prohibited sign characteristics. Only passive-type signage shall be permitted. Unless
otherwise permitted in Section 78-285��signs which incorporate animation, bright or
flashing lights, movement or motions caused by the wind, electrical, or mechanical
means, flashing or electronic messages, or other real or apparent forms of motion are
prohibited.
(f) Prohibited illumination. Illumination of signs utilizing flashing, intermittent, rotating,
revolving, oscillating techniques is prohibited.
- - - -- - •- -- - - •--• -- •- - - -- -- - - - •- •- - - . .
- - - .. . .. . --
{#} c� Other prohibited signs. In addition to the prohibited signs indicated above, the
following signs are prohibited in the city:
(1) Awning signs, unless otherwise provided herein;
(2) Bunting, pennants, streamers, and other similar signs or devices normally but not
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
always installed in a series, designed to move with the wind, and usually attached
to buildings, trees, ropes, poles, and similar structures; provided, however, the use
of pole-mounted banners may be permitted in accordance with Section 78-292.-}
Murals unless approved bv Citv Councili
Painted wall signs;
��,-,�y�, ar'r}�s_,,�t#c�v+s�e—a�le� °�^+�^„ ��-R���'� Sians created bv colored
illumination or shadow castina;
Changeable copy signs, e� ^'� ���c�� ^�:� �� reE +a��o "° ���l� #
gase�e with the exception of the followina which mav be displaved as set forth in
this division:
a. Gasoline price sians located on pump islands or on monument sians:
b. Menu aricina sians;
c. Buildina directorv sians; and
d Ground sians for municipalities public schools and/or state colleaes located
in Public/Institutional zoninq districts;
(7) Signs with extruded figures or elements;
(8) Portable signs;
/Q\ C?nnf cir�nc
�
{a-9}�9 Balloons� e� balloon signs or inflatable shapes or fiaures with or without coav:
{�1-} 10 Copies or imitations of official signs;
, , , , ,
('I `Z1 �vr�ncorJ nonri +i �hirin•
�
(�-4} 11 Beacons or searchlights;
(�} 1�2 Signs attached to an accessory structure;
{-�6} 1�3 Signs which emit sounds;
(�} 1�4 Exposed neon tubina. AJneon signs, and LED sians, unless otherwise
provided herein;
.
�
�
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 10 of 29
15 Signs which emit visible smoke, vapor particles, or odor;
16 Sandwich board or "A" frame signs and pole sians, unless otherwise provided
herein:
1�7 Signs which exhibit obscene or illeaal written messaaes or material;
1�8 Snipe signs ^r cimil�r �omr�nr�r�i �,rync attached, posted or located on or to
a�trees, light poles, utility poles; street liaht, sidewalk, curb, fire hvdrant, bridae
or anv other public propertv. exceqt for public utilitv, convenience and warnina
Sians nr oimilor c+r� in+� �roc•
�
{�} 1�_9 Signs placed upon benches, bus or transit shelters, or waste receptacles,
unless specifically approved by the city council; and
, �
{�4} 20 Any other sign, device, or equipment ',
°° c�n„° °��� not specificallv aermitted by this division.
(h) Severabilitv. Should anv provision of Section 78-284 or anv aortion thereof, anv
paraaraph, sentence, or word be declared bv a Court of competent iurisdiction to be
invalid, such decision shall not affect the validitv of the remainder of Section 78-284.
�Note: Revisions to clarifysignage types, eliminate duplication, and describe certain
exceptions, A Severability clause is included to ensure if this Section is challenged,
the rest of the Division will not be invalidated.]
(The remainder of this page intentionally left blank)
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 11 of 29
Sec. 78-285. Permitted signs.
Permanent signs shall be permitted as provided in Table 24.
Table 24: Permanent Signs
TABLE INSET:
Maximum
Permitted Max. Size of Max. Maximum Sian
Sign Type Zoning Copv Area Sign Number of Structure Other Limits
Districts {Sq—��} Faces Sians Dimensions
(1)
•Requires solid
base not less than
three feet high
w/out sign copy,
except for address
numbers or leasinp
information as
reaulated bv Sec.
78-290. Temaorarv
•1 for first Sians
300 lineal •Sign copy not to
feet of exceed building
Non- R�W Height: 10 identification and
Ground Sign residential* 60 sc� 2 . feet Width:
(2) feet 1 for each #�ee five tenants
additional 15 feet (not includina
700 lineal leasinp informationl
feet of er si�
ROW •Tenant names
shall be at least 6-
inch letter heiaht.
•Min. 15 feet
setback from ROW.
•Min. 50 feet
setback from non-
ROW property
lines.
1 for parcel •Sign letters shall
with af least not exceed 36
100 lineal inches in height.
FlabWall feet of •Sign for building
Sign for ROW; A and tenant
Principal Non- (.�} gp buildina with identification
Structure or residential sauare feet � frontaae on None purposes.
Principal I-95 or the •NMT one name or
Tenant �3 Florida message may be
Turnpike included.
may have a •Each principal
sian facina I- structure is allowed
95 or the a flat or wall sign.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 12 of 29
Florida •Wall sign cannot
Turnaike in exceed more than
addition to 70 percent of the
its sian immediate vertical
facin its and horizontal
rip marv surface area to
street. The which attached. {-�}
sian facina I-
95 or the
Florida
Turnpike
mav be
located
above the
second
floor.
•Sign must face
ROW or primary
entrance.
NMT 5% of •Uniform type,
area of color, material,
Flat/Wall elevation of shape & style.
Sign for Non- tenant space 1 per tenant •Letters NMT 24
Ground Floor residential or bay. In no 1 space or bay None inches.
Users �3 case shall �ler�e •Max. 2 lines of
coav exceed copy.
70 square •Signs shall not be
feet. located above
second floor line or
above building
parapet.
•Sian must face
ROW or primarv
entrance.
•Uniform tvpe.
color, material�
shape. & stvle.
NMT 5% of •�etters NMT 24
area of inches.
elevation of •Max. 2 lines of
Flat/Wall tenant cOpV•
Sian for Professional s ace or � 1 per tenant None •Allowed above the
second storv Office bav. In no = saace or bav ground floor.
office tenants case shall •Onlv allowed for
coav exceed
70 square second storv
feet. tenants of two-storv
buildinas whose
tenants have a
primarv buildina
entrance facina a
maior arterial or
collector road, and
access not throuah
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 13 of 29
a central lobbv.
•A roof sian is
permitted onlv as a
substitute for a wall
siqn. not in addition
to a wall sipn.
•Onlv for principal
NMT 5% of tenants or tenants
area of with over 5,000
elevation of �ross leasable
tenant sauare feet.
s ace or •Sipn letters shall
Roof sians bav. In no 1 ber tenant not exceed 36
for one-storv Non- case shall with over inches in heiaht for
buildinas with cobv exceed 1 5 000 aross None principal tenant: 24
mansard or residential g0 sauare leasable
inches for other
hfp roofs feet for sauare feet tenants.
rinci al
tenants, or •Sian must face
70 sauare ROW or arimarv
feet for other entrance.
tenants. •Roof sipns must
be individual letters.
•Roof sian supports
shall be painted to
match the roof.
•Cabinet sians are
not permitted.
•NMT �20% of total
glass area ailowed
� �mo hn� irc
m�.�-�rva-rv �
E3{3E?1�/@�@52.. � .,' .,,.' `
rorrlc 1?. 4olor�hnrio
i
n�am�"�;�to be
covered bv window
sians.
0
Lesser of ^''°° nr°' ""^,",°'�
100 square � nor +on�r+ #gr=ggg�s-a+�d
Non- feet or 20% �`c"�`� °°",`"°° "ff°r°,�
Window Sign 1 "� ���npa�, ����—oi None •Not more than
residential of gross
glass area_ � None 50% of anv sinale
window or alass
door mav be
covered bv sians.
•All sign materials
must be
permanent.
•Paper, cardboard,
etc., are prohibited.
•Sians allowed in
qround floor
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 14 of 29
windows onlv.
•Must be attached
to wall.
•Must be framed or
matted.
•Not included in
area for window
Menu Sign signs.
(Wall- Non- 4 square � 1 per None •Enclosed in frame
mounted) residential feet restaurant or casing
compatible with
building design and
color.
•Casing shall not
project more than 2
inches from wall.
1 per
restaurant. •Constructed of
durable materials.
Additional •May be pole-
signs mounted, "A"=
permitted if frame, or sandwich
outdoor
Menu Sign Height: 5 feet board.
Non- 15 square seatin
(free- residential feet 2 areas are Width:3 feet •May include name,
standing) hours, credit card,
either: menu, and price
separated information.
by 6 feet •Must be stored
high wall or inside restaurant
not visible to when closed.
each other.
1 per
building_or 1
directional
si�n �er •Max. 4 feet above
Building 10,000
Non- 4 square Height: 4 crown of paving or
Directional residential feet 2 sauare feet feet. road.
Sign of total
buil�cd�in
sauare
footaae in
rp oiect.
•Max. 3 feet above
crown of paving or
road. Sians located
1 per within a visibilitv
Exit and Non- 4 square approved Ple+�e Heiaht: trianale shall not
Entrance residential feet 2 entry or 3 feet exceed 30 inches in
exit. heiaht measured
Signs from the surface of
the nearest
vehicular traffic
area.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 15 of 29
•Min. 2 feet from
property line.
•Copy limited to
EXIT, ENTRANCE,
EXIT ONLY, etc.
•Internal
illumination only.
•Shall be �located
in landscaped
area.
•Drive-through
restaurants only.
•Internal
illumination only.
•Mav include
chanaeable copv.
•Must be
landscaped
consistent with
Menu Board Non- 20 square 1 per Height: 5 feet division �8 of article
residential feet 2 restaurant Width: None V,
•Located NMT 100
feet from principal
building.
•May have remote
or electronic
service.
•Shall not be
located adjacent to
residential zoning
districts.
•May include
changeable copy.
•May be integrated
Gasoline 15 square 2 1 None into another sign.
Price Sign feet •Sign with price
integrated shall not
exceed permitted
sign size.
•May be suspended
from soffit or eave.
•Must be parallel to
soffit or eave.
Occupant •Min. clearance of 8
Non- 6 square feet from bottom of
Identification residential feet 2 1 None sign to top of
Sign
walkway.
•Located at main
entrance.
May be externally
illuminated.
Building 18 square 1 1 per Height:6 feet •2 or more buildings
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 16 of 29
Directory feet building with Width: None on same parcel or
Sign tenant or development.
business •Internal
spaces not illumination only.
directly •Located within a
accessible 25 feet radius of
from main entry to
building building.
exterior •May be a
changeable copy
sign.
•Shall be placed in
landscaped area.
•Vehicle pull-off
may be required.
•Only time and
Time and NMT 25°/o of Permitted temperature may
Non- only as part be displayed.
Temperature residential total sign 1 of a wall or None. .Size to be included
Sign area flat sign. within overall size
of principal sign_
Commercial
and/or Mixed 1 per light •Meet all
Pole- 3 feet width
mounted Use 21 square 2 pole and/or by 7 feet requirements in
Banner and/or feet pedestrian �ength Section 78-292=
Public pole
Institutional
� .,oY ��,�n .,r
-,--p��—P.a=� or�
� ^°-��ri^,� 2 •Letters may not
�er exceed 24 inches in
Perimeter communitv height.
Wall or Entry entrancewav •Illumination limited
Feature 1; or 2 1 si n on to backlighting with
Ground Residentiali 60 square for sian either side opaque letters or
Signs for Mixed Use feet in of entrance: None. ground lighting for
Residential median or 1 sian in letters.
Development center •Residential entry
� median of feature signs �e
communitv shall be approved
entrance by city council.
drivewa .
• Onlv allowed for
municipal buildinps.
Chanaeable public schools,
and/or state
copv/diaital Heiaht: 10 colleaes in Public/
d�� Public/ 60 square 2 1 feet Width: Institutional zonina
around sian Institutional feet = _
� 15 feet districts.
•Reauires solid
base not less than
three feet hiah
w/out sian coav.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-0000291Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 17 of 29
•Min. 15 feet
setback from ROW.
•Min. 50 feet
setback from non-
ROW propertv
lines.
Notes to Table 24.
*Non-residential �includes commercial portion of residential PUDs or PCDs.
ROW = Public road right-of-way.
NMT = Not more than.
(1) Height measured from average grade unless otherwise noted. ��tes-t� T�-,-�,p,��T
/nnri+ini �orJ frnm r�ro�iini �o r�orrol
2� Ground sign must be landscaped as provided below.
a. Front: minimum width shall be not less than the height of the sign.
b. Side: minimum width shall be not less than the height of the sign.
c. Rear: minimum width shall be three feet.
/'�\ I ocoor nf �ha fnlln�niinrr•
� Q(1 crn �oro foo�� nr
. �
e ��
�T���GCt"Ft�t��� .riEt l:L� `]}oI'%�c + °GC-upVV�� t1"'Fii
�on�orlino nf +ho ��i�nori} r�� �hlin rirrht nf �nir+�i
3) For commercial retail, or commercial aortions of proiects within Mixed Use land use
desiqnations that front directiv on a maior roadwav (arterial or collector) with no front
parkina, one additional sian is allowed on the rear elevation of buildinas, as lona as the
customer parkina and access is located in the rear.
�Notes for Section 78-285. Permitted Signs section]:
1. Ground signs:
a. Permits address numbers or leasing information on the bottom three feet of a
ground sign.
b. Allows an increase from a maximum of three to a maximum number of five with the
caveat that the maximum total size of the copy area remains unchanged at 60
square feet.
c. Adds a minimum of 6-inch high lettering for tenant names to maintain readability.
2. Flat/Wall Sign for Principal Structure or Principal Tenant:
a. Simplifies the maximum size to 90 square feet.
b. Allows one additional sign facing Interstate 95 (1-95) or the Florida Turnpike for
buildings directly adjacent to these limited access roadways. In addition, these
additional signs may be allowed above the second floor.
3. FlaflWall Sign for Ground Floor Users
a. Clarifies sign area size by restricting total size to 70 square feet.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 18 of 29
4. Flat/Wall Sign for Second Floor Professional Office Tenants:
a. Allows additional tenant signage for office tenants on the second floor whose
primary entrance is through the front fa�ade and face any right-of-way. In other
words, direct access to the second floor space must be from an exterior door on the
second floor, not through the main lobby entrance. The restrictions forsize, number,
and uniformity are similar to ground floor tenants.
5. Roof Signs for One-Story Buildings with Mansard or Hip Roofs:
a. Allows roof signs as a substitute for a wall sign in one-story structures with mansard
or hip roofs. Roof signs would not be listed as a prohibited use, but would be
permitted as described in the permanent sign table. The signage size and other
regulations are similar to the flat/wall signs currently allowed.
b. Allowed only for principal tenants or tenants with over 5, 000 gross /easable square
footage.
c. Cabinet signs prohibited.
6. Window Signs (Window signs currently have specific size requirements based on
content. Currently, sign regulations allow not more than 5 percent of total glass area
for name, hours, open/closed, credit cards, and telephone numbers, and not more than
15 percent of total g/ass area for goods and services offered.)
a. The proposal allows not more than 20 percent of total glass area to be covered by
window signs. (This will remove regulating content while maintaining the same total
percentage of window coverage.)
b. The modification also removes the restriction of one window sign per tenant or bay,
but adds a requirement that not more than 50 percent of any single window orglass
door may be covered by signs.
c. Only allowed for ground floor windows.
d. One illuminated sign of 3 square feet or less is also permitted in a window, as long
as it is not visible from a public right-of-way.
7. Building Directional Signs (Currently building directional signs are limited to one per
building. However, shopping centers or institutional uses, such as hospitals and
churches, with one or two large buildings with several points of access often need more
directional signage.)
a. The proposed modification would add the following language: "Maximum numberof
directional signs can be one per building, or one per 10, 000 spuare feet of total
building square footaqe in project."
8. Exit and Entrance Signs
a. Adds height restriction of three feet.
b. Adds further restriction that signs located in visibility triangle shall not exceed 30
inches in height from the surface of the nearest vehicular traffic area, in order to be
consistent with engineering requirements.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 19 of 29
9. Menu Board
a. Allows changeable copy.
b. Updated to correct division number of landscaping regulations.
10. Perimeter Wall or Entry Feature Signs for Residential Development
a. Requires landscaping around base of sign.
b. Adds Mixed Use to the Permitted Zoning District.
c. Clarifies number of faces based on whether sign is placed in entry median or not.
d. Increases number of signs from one to two signs per entranceway; one sign on
either side of the entrance, or one sign with two faces in the median.
e. It is important to note that all residential entry feature signs will still require City
Council approval.
11. Changeable Copy/Digital Display Ground Sign (Currently changeable copy signs
are not allowed, except for gasoline sales, menu signs, building directory, and traffic
control/traffic information. This would allow permanent, changeable copy signs for
public information purposes to be located on public/institutional zoned land.)
a. Same size, setback, and landscaping requirements as Ground Signs.
b. Only one per property.
12. Notes to Table 24 (the notes to the permitted sign table have been modified as
follows):
a. Scriveners Error -#2 was missing from the Ground sign landscaping provisions.
This has been corrected.
b. Previous note regarding maximum size requirements was eliminated. The
maximum size requirement has been simplified to 90 square feet only and moved
into the table. The remaining restrictions were eliminated as unnecessary.
c. A new note (#3) is added. This note allows commercial retail, or commercial
portions of projects within Mixed Use land use designations, that front directly on a
majorroadway (arterial orcollector) with no front parking, one additional sign on the
rear elevation of buildings. This is allowed as long as the building's primary access
is from the rear and customer parking is located in the rear. This wil/ eliminate a
waiver to allow a second sign, which is needed to help patrons identify store names
from the rear parking lot.
�End of Notes for Section 78-285. Permitted Sign Section.]
(The remainder of this page intentionally left blank)
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 20 of 29
Sec. 78-286. Illumination.
(a) Permitted illumination.
(1) Nonresidential zoning districts. Ground, flat, or wall signs shall be illuminated utilizing
the following: backlighting, internal lighting, or permanently fixed and encased lighting
from below, and external to, the sign surface. External lighting greater than 15 watts is
prohibited unless properly shielded to prevent glare upon adjacent public rights-of-way
or adjacent property. The department may require ' photometric or other
studies to ensure sign lighting will not adversely affect the public health, safety, and
welfare.
(2) Residential zoning districts. Only backlighting with opaque lettering and permanently
fixed and encased face lighting from below the sign surface shall be permitted in
residential zoning districts.
(b) Neon signs and LED sians. Neon or LED signs are permitted within a building,
provided such signage is not visible from a public right-of-way, except as � otherwise
be provided herein.
(c) Permitted neon signs. An exposed neon sign may be displayed and shall not be visible
from a public right-of-way subject to the following restrictions:
(1) The sign area shall not exceed three square feet;_
�?1 Tho oi�tiri ch�ll�������e�r �nihi�o• �rirJ
,
n n
f^�
(d) Permitted LED sipns. LED sians mav be displaved and mav be visible from a public
riaht-of-wav subiect to the followina restrictions:
(1) The subiect sian must satisfv the definition of a"Traffic control/traffic information"
siqn as set forth in Sec. 78-289;
(2) The purpose of the siqn shall be limited to public convenience, public utilitv. public
safetv, and/or public warninas; and
(3) The siqn has been placed, located, or installed bv or at the direction of the Citv.
Palm Beach Countv, state, federal, or other public aaencies.
�Note: LED signs are added to neon signs as illuminated signs permitted within
buildings. These signs shall not be visible from any public right-of-way. Exposed
neon signs are still permitted, but shall not be visible from public rights-of-way.
Permitting neon "open" signs is eliminated because it is content based. The color
restriction of white only is also eliminated. New LED sign regulations are proposed
to allow their use as "traffic control/traffic information"signs in the public rights-of-
way for public safety and public information uses.]
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 21 of 29
Sec. 78-287. General standards.
The following standards are applicable to all permitted signs.
(a) Sign materials. All lettering, logos and other such identification markings on signage
shall be permanent and not interchangeable, unless otherwise proved herein.
- -- --- . .._. • -- •• -- -- • .. ._ e _. . . .. __ .
- -:-• -- - •- - --- .. •. :' '• '•
(c) �b Landscaping. Ground signs shall be landscaped. The minimum landscape area
dimensions are indicated below.
(1) Front: minimum width of the landscape area shall be the height of the sign.
(2) Side: minimum width of the landscape area shall be the height of the sign.
(3) Rear: minimum width shall be three feet. Landscape areas associated with
ground shall be irrigated, unless waived by the growth management department,
and shall be maintained as required by section 78-329.
(d) �c Flags. Not more than three flags and three flag poles shall be located on any single
r� e� D ����r! r+rr, flnryc r nrocor�tir�n nn�iornmor���l rolirrin��o rin+_fnr_r�rnfi+ nr
pp y. T��rc —� �rc,ac,n'c�vrrc,rrrn-r� � � �
. , .
�ormi��o�J f�,n, Flag poles shall not exceed 25 feet in height. One flag per pole is
permitted. The area of a flag shall conform to the requirements listed below.
Additionallv, no flaa pole shall be located anv closer to anv propertv line than the heiaht
of the flaa aole as installed The number, size, and heiaht of flaas and flaa poles mav
be increased with Citv Council aparoval.
TABLE INSET:
Height of Maximum Maximum
Flag Pole Flag Area Dimensions
20 to 25 Feet 4-� 40 square feet 5 feet by � 8 feet
Less than 20 Feet � 24 square feet 4 feet by 6 feet
{e} d� Logos. Logos or any federally registered trademark may be permitted as part of
a sign as follows:
a-�1 If designed as an integral part of the advertising copy;
�-�2 If consistent with an approved color scheme of the master sign plan; and
��3 If displayed as registered.
GRAPHIC LINK: Fiqure 13a
��� oow S �
, ��' 'G� �
i�'._,�___7a
� L
� LNDTH _�
�
r - -�
� EMBI.EM
oa
� �� 1
i
�____._i
� WIDTM "
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 22 of 29
�� �G����L�
;..;�GS!`1����3� �
L L
vnon+
Figure 13a
i'.� '.�
� I I
�7 GRCLE
= i �
L_ _J
�QTH ^
(f) Calculation of sign area.
(1) Sign area. Sign area shall be calculated as illustrated in Figure 13a and 13b. The
area of a sign face shall be calculated by means of the smallest rectangle that will
encompass the entire area of a sign, including all letters, numbers, characters,
logos, emblems, information, or other display. The sign area shall include any
materials or colors utilized to differentiate the sign from the backdrop or structure on
which it is placed, including all materials to form the cabinet or other structural
members of the sign. Sign area shall not include any supporting framework, bracing,
or decorative fence or wall when such wall is consistent with the requirements of
section 78-285.
GRAPHIC LINK: Fiaure 13b
r--- ----�
� � i
� ODD SHAPE �
1 �
l-. � _ _ _. ... �1
"� N+IDTN�
� � S��
� Yv�D7�
MULTIPLE T M ^ � _ _ i
e
� ;ELEMENTS � i
L—.__._. -------- _ �OGO_J
�._._..._.._...__.._._�.�__ WIOTH~ �---_......_. . _,._�
Figure 13b
(2) Sign area of multi-faced signs. Sign area for multi-faced signs shall be calculated as
indicated below and in Figure 14.
a. The area of a double faced sign with sign faces that are parallel or the interior
angle of the two faces is 15 degrees or less shall be calculated using the area of
only one sign face.
GRAPHIC LINK: Fiaure 14
1S D�9f��Y or L�r�
�;I�4fi�'I
�
�
�
�
�r�:;,,..
k`` ����t�
.�
�
9 BtDED ANGLEQ 81GN
'15 ° OR UNDER
Y�ItYT� x NCIGHI'= $�G1v ARC1l
��
_I
��
,
,
_�
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/0rdinance 21, 2010
Page 23 of 29
�5 D�Or�iw «Mnr
�____-- °-
�
�
�
�
►._.
►�
�
L7
i
:r
,�
�'�``- ,���� �.
`� ;,....,�,,�.�
? SIDED SIC�N d1lER 15 `
1MIDTH� x NEIG� IT� - SIt3N AF�d
WIUtH`x HFIG�ITx- 51CNAI+�A
Figure 14
• -. -.. ... •- . -. . . . - . .. . . .-. .-
. •-. -- - . -. . •. . . - . .- .•.-. .•- .
•-- ...-... .
� � � � r � � � 1 � i � � � � � � � � � � � � � r
� � � i � � � � � � � � � � i i � ' 1 � � � � �
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
� � � � • � � • � � � � • � � � • � � • �
� � � � � � u � • � � � � � � • � � � � � � � � � � � � • • � � � �
• � � � � • � � � � u � � � � � • � � • � � • � � � � � � ••
� � � � � � � � � � � � � • � u � � � � � � � � � • •
� ► � � � � � � u � � u � � � � � � � • � � u � u � � �
� � � �
�Note: A restriction of signage near residential areas is being removed. Flag
setbacks are added, and flag dimensions are revised. The number, size, and height
of flags and flag poles may be increased with City Council approval. Fence or wall
sign area calculations are deleted because the same issue is covered in Sec. 78-287
(f)(1) and fence signs are temporary in nature and are not encouraged as permanent
signs.]
Sec. 78-288. Sign program.
The growth management department may require any development order application for a
PUD, PCD, MXD, or conditional use to submit an overall master sign program. The master
sign program shall indicate location, number, size, font, type of siqn, landscaping, and
illumination of proposed signs.
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/0rdinance 21, 2010
Page 24 of 29
jNote: Master sign program requirements are clarified.]
Sec. 78-289. Exempt signs.
�a The signs listed below are permitted signs, and are exempt from the requirements
of this division.
(1) Mailboxes. Roadside mailboxes.
(2) Residential identification signs. Residential building identification, displaying the
name or property occupant or street address, provided such sign is less than
four square feet.
�g� ��n�„ �„�;,.;+;nry�� Warnina signs. Signs prohibiting peddlers or solicitors, indicating
security such as burglar alarms, or "beware of bad animal" signs. Signs of this
nature shall be located at the entrance of the building or residence, or adjacent
to fenced areas.
(4) Traffic control/traffic information. Traffic control, directional, and ublic
information/warnin signs placed in public rights-of-way by federal, state, county,
city, and other public agencies or at the direction of or as reauired bv same.
(5) Interior signs. Signs located within a building; and not visible from a public right-
of-way.
(6) Courtyard signs. Signs located on the exterior elevation of an interior courtyard,
provided such signs are not visible from a public right-of-way, parking lot, or
abutting residential zoning district.
(7) Vehicle advertising. Motor vehicles with business names, business addresses,
telephone numbers, contractor certification numbers, logos, and similar
information painted or embossed on vehicle surfaces, when otherwise permitted
or required by law. Parking of such vehicles shall be limited as provided below.
a. Motor vehicles including but not limited to trucks, vans, and automobiles, and
anv trailer towed bv such vehicles, with business signage shall not be parked
in off-street parking areas for the purpose of advertising a business or
service.
b. Such vehicles shall be parked in off-street parking areas that are located in
the rear or side yards so ���� that the sianaae is not �I� visible
from any public street right-of-way.
c. Leaal tenants of commercial properties whose vehicles are reaistered.
licensed, and fullv operational for companv use are exempt from Sec. 78-
289(a)(7)b. for the purpose of parkinq such vehicles on site.
[IVote: "No soliciting" signs are broadened to "Warning" signs to provide a clearer
description. "Traffic information"is added to "Traffic control"signs, because these
signs can also be used to provide public information. The amendment to vehicle
advertising would allow vehicles with advertising to park at a commercial location, if
the company to which the vehicle belongs is a tenant at that location. This will
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-0000291Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 25 of 29
prevent companies from having to find off-site or screened parking locations for
company vehicles.]
Sec. 78-290. Temporary signs allowed.
[THE TEMPORARY SIGNS SECTION IS BEING REVIEWED AND REVISED
SEPARATELY AS PART OF ORDINANCE 19, 2010.]
Sec. 78-291. Non-commercial messages.
� Notwithstanding anything in this article to the contrary, any sign erected pursuant to the
provisions of this article may, at the option of the applicant, contain either a non-
commercial message unrelated to the business located on the premises where the sign
is erected or a commercial message related to the business and located on the
business premises pursuant to the following regulations:
(1) The non-commercial message may occupy the entire sign face or portion thereof.
(2) The sign face may be changed from commercial to non-commercial messages as
frequently as desired by the owner of the sign, provided that the following is true:
a. The size and design criteria conform to the applicable portions of this article;
b. The sign is allowed by this article;
c. The sign conforms to the requirements of the applicable zoning designation; and
d. The appropriate permits are obtained.
(3) For the purpose of this sign code, non-commercial messages shall never be
deemed off-premises signs.
Sec. 78-292. Pole-mounted banner criteria.
Pole-mounted banners shall only be permitted in public institutional, commercial, or mixed-
use zoned areas for the limited purposes of brand identification or as a holiday decoration;
provided the following conditions are met:
(a) A miscellaneous plan approval by city council is required for all pole-mounted
banner programs, except those installed on city property by the city. Any additional pole-
mounted banners, graphics, locations, or increase of sign square footage other than what
was previously approved by city council requires a new miscellaneous plan review
approval. As part of the application process, the applicant must complete a detailed sign
program to include:
1. A copy of a current site plan showing all the proposed locations where the
pole-mounted banners are to be placed;
2. The light pole detail upon which the pole-mounted banner is to be located;
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 26 of 29
3. The pole-mounted banner's copy shall be limited to the name of the
development, the development's logo, and development's branding, which does not
include any individual business name, tenant, or individual business' logo.
4. All graphic designs, variations, and/or seasonal sets of the banners must be
provided for city council review and approval in accordance with the criteria set forth
herein. City council may prescribe specific time periods during which a particular
seasonal set of banners may be displayed if approval of more than one set of
banners is sought by the applicant.
(b) The program must satisfy the following requirements:
1. Pole-mounted banners must be located on an existing light pole;
2. One (1) pole-mounted banner per light pole may be permitted;
3. Pole-mounted banners on light poles shall be two-sided with the identical
design on each side;
4. Trees, palms, or shrubs shall not be pruned beyond the limits of the city codes
or accepted maintenance standards in order to facilitate the placement of any
banners;
5. Banners shall not interfere or block any existing or future traffic or pedestrian
controls or signage;
6. Within 24 hours of announcement of a tropical storm or hurricane watch by the
National Hurricane Center, which places the city within the "3-day cone of
probability," all pole-mounted banners shall be removed;
7. The city may require the removal of any pole-mounted banner should the city
find that the pole-mounted banner is in a state of disrepair or is not being
maintained appropriately with respect to accepted maintenance standards (e.g., not
faded, free from rips and tears, properly attached, untattered, and generally in a
state of good repair). The applicant shall either remove or replace the banner within
ten (10) calendar days of being noticed;
8. All poles holding or supporting pole-mounted banners shall require a building
permit in order to verify the safety and wind loads of the banners;
9. Pole-mounted banners shall only be interior to a particular site or development
and shall not be placed in an area immediately adjacent to a public right-of-way;
10. Light poles with pole-mounted banners shall be a minimum of fifteen (15) feet
from the property line, and no portion of the pole-mounted banner shall extend into
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 27 of 29
or be visible from a public right-of-way immediately adjacent to the property or
development upon which such pole-mounted banners are located;
11. The minimum clearance of banners above the finished grade shall be eight (8)
feet;
12. Non-rectangular pole-mounted banners shall conform only to the maximum
banner area criteria providing that a minimum clearance of eight (8) feet above the
finished grade is maintained;
13. Banner Size:
a. Pole-mounted banners on light poles shall meet the following dimensions:
Height of Maximum Maximum
Light Pole Banner Area Dimensions
20 to 25 Feet 21 square feet 3 feet width by 7 feet
length
Less than 20 4.5 square feet 1.5 feet width by 3
Feet feet length
b. A banner's highest point shall not exceed the highest point of the pole upon
which it is mounted.
Secs.78-293--78-300. Reserved.
OTHER IMPACTED SECTIONS:
Section 78-751. Definitions.
Surface area means the area of the facade upon which a sian is located and includes the
rectanale created bv vertical walls or buildina edaes and architectural features such as
doors, windows, bandina, or other architectural elements located above or below the
proposed sian area.
Visibilitv trianales (aka: safe site distance trianales) the area at the corner of two
-_-
intersectinq roadwavs or a roadwav and drivewav where alacement of visual obstructions.
such as landscapina or sians shall be limited
[Note: Two new definitions related to the sign code are proposed for the Definitions
section.]
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-0000291Ordinance 21, 2010
Page 28 of 29
STAFF ANALYSIS
The purpose of proposed amendments described above is to bring the City's sign code up
to date, and to make the regulations and their enforcement more effective. The
modifications will also reduce the number of waiver requests by allowing additional signage
for types of signs commonly granted waivers. This will simplify some of the more common
signage requests from residents and business community, and make regulating, enforcing,
and processing requests for signs more efficient for staff.
PZAB ACTION
At the July 20, 2010, meeting of the Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board (PZAB), this
item was postponed to a date certain time of August 10, 2010, at 6:00 p.m., to give the
board and business community more time to meet with staff and further review the
proposed amendments. Since that time, staff has met one-on-one with PZAB members,
and has co-ordinated a group of business representatives to review the amendments. The
following revisions have been made since the July 20, 2010, meeting:
• For rooftop addressing, the language has been clarified to be the address number,
not street address.
• The term "traffic control" sign has been changed to "traffic regulation" sign in the
prohibited signs list to avoid confusion with a different type of sign referenced in a
later section.
• The prohibited sign characteristics description in the prohibited signs section was
revised to clarify that electronic messages or movement are prohibited, unless
otherwise permitted in Section 78-285.
• The prohibition of internal displays of inerchandise has been eliminated.
• For ground signs:
o Address numbers or leasing information are allowed on the base of ground
signs;
o The minimum letter height for tenant names on ground signs has been
changed from 8 inches to 6 inches; and
o The requirement for uniform color lettering on ground signs has been
eliminated to avoid creation of non-conforming uses.
• The second story tenant signs have been revised to allow them only for second
story tenants of two story buildings whose tenants have a primary building entrance
facing a major arterial or collector road, and access not through a central lobby.
• For roof signs:
o Roof signs must be individual letters;
o Roof sign supports shall be painted to match the roof; and
o Roof signs are prohibited from being cabinet signs.
• A restriction of signage within 100 feet of residential property has been removed.
• Removed the allowance of one illuminated sign of three feet from the window signs
section of the permitted sign table. This type of sign is specified in Section 78- 286
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-03-000029/0rdinance 21, 2010
Page 29 of 29
(the Illumination section). Exposed neon signs of three square feet or less may be
displayed, as long as they are not visible from a public right-of-way.
• Vehicles with advertising, which may be parked at commercial properties to which
the vehicle owner is a legal tenant, must be registered, licensed, and fully
operational for company use.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends approval of Petition No. LDRA-10-03-000029/Ordinance 21, 2010 to
amend Section 78, Article V, Division 7. Signs, and Section 78, Article VIII. Definitions, of
the City's Land Development Regulations.
CITY OF PALM BEACFi GARDENS
PLANNING, ZONING, AND APPEALS BOARD
Agenda� Cover Memorandum
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinarnce '!9, 2010
SubiectlAqenda Item
Ordinance 19, 2010/Petition LDRA-10-04-OU0031: Land Deyeloprne�t Regulation
changes to Sections 78-187. Special Events, Section 78-191. Outdoor Seating,
Section 78-290. Temporary Signs Alloweda and Section 7$-751. Definitions.
Public Hearing and Recommendation to City Council: A City-initiated request to
amend the City's Land Development Regulations ("LDRs") in order to clarify and revise
the special events, outdoor seating, temporary signs allowed, and definitions sections.
[ X ] Recommendation to APPROVE
[ ] Recommendation to DENY
Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: Finance: N/A PZAB Action:
R. Max Lohman Planning and Zoning: Gosts: �] Rec. approval
N/A Allyson Black � N�A [] Rec. app. w/ conds.
City Attorney 7otal [] Rec. Denial
[ ] Continued to:
Bahareh Wolfs, AICP Resource Manager
$ N/A
�r �� CurrPnt FY
Develop ent Compliance � �
Quasi-Judiciai Funding Source:
[ X j Legisla#ive
[ X ] Public Hearing � � Operating
Natalie . ong, AICP
[X ] Other N/A
Director of Planning and Budget Acct.#:
Zoning N/A
Advertised: Attachments:
Date: Juiy 9, 2010 • Ordinance 19, 2010
Paper: Palm Beach
Post ,
�
[ X ] Required
Approved by:
Ronald M. Ferris Affected parties
Notified:
N/A [ ] Notified
City Manager [ X] Not Required
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
PLANNING, ZONING, AND APPEALS BOARD
Agenda Cover Memorandum
Meeting Date: August 10, 2010
Petition LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
Subiect/Aqenda Item
Ordinance 19, 2010/Petition LDRA-10-04-000031: Land Development Regulation
changes to Sections 78-187. Special Events, Section 78-191. Outdoor Seating,
Section 78-290. Temporary Signs Allowed, and Section 78-751. Definitions.
Public Hearing and Recommendation to City Council: A City-initiated request to
amend the City's Land Development Regulations ("LDRs") in order to clarify and revise
the special events, outdoor seating, temporary signs allowed, and definitions sections.
[ X ] Recommendation to APPROVE
[ ] Recommendation to DENY
Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: Finance: N/A PZAB Action:
R. Max Lohman Planning and Zoning: Costs: [] Rec. approval
N/A Allyson Black � N�A [] Rec. app. w/ conds.
City Attorney Total [] Rec. Denial
[ ] Continued to:
Bahareh Wolfs, AICP Resource Manager
$ N/A
Current FY
Development Compliance
[ ] Quasi-Judicial Funding Source:
[ X ] Legislative
[ X ] Public Hearing
Natalie M. Wong, AICP [] Operating
[X ] Other N/A
Director of Planning and Budget Acct.#:
Zoning N/A
Advertised: Attachments:
Date: July 9, 2010 • Ordinance 19, 2010
Paper: Palm Beach
Post
[ X ] Required
Approved by:
Ronald M. Ferris Affected parties
Notified:
N/A [ ] Notified
City Manager [ X] Not Required
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
As requested by City Council, the following is
Regulations code amendment for the sections
seating; temporary signs allowed; and definitions
include:
Page 2 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
a City-initiated Land Development
related to: special events; outdoor
The major changes to the sections
78-187. Special events.
• Requiring the applicant to include locations of any outdoor music or
entertainment and to submit a sound management plan.
• Amending the signage for special events to only one on-site sign per 50 linear
feet, for a maximum of three signs, adding regulations regarding the variable
message boards, removing off-site signage, and creating criteria for right-of-way
banners for national and regional events and traffic control signage.
• Increasing the number of events from three to four events every calendar year
and increasing the number of events for commercial/office plazas with 10 tenants
or less from five to eiqht events per year, and those with 11 or more tenants from
ten to twelve events per calendar year.
• Adding additional language about the use of vendors for special events, allowing
them to display the merchandise provided it is not for sale and the displays are
on site and not blocking public access.
78-191. Outdoor Seating.
• Adding criteria for exemption for outdoor seating without service and allowing for
outdoor seating with service for a maximum of two tables (8 seats) or no more
than 100 square feet, whichever is less, provided all accessibility standards are
met.
• Removing the notice requirements.
• Requiring the applicant to provide the alcohol license, if applicable, and providing
the type of storage being proposed for the outdoor furnishings.
• Amending the fencing and screening so that it is reviewed on a per-case basis
versus as a requirement.
• Requiring outdoor storage tarps to be solid colors for cleaner appearance, and
also clarifying that outdoor heaters and seasonal equipment shall not be visible
from the right-of-way when not in use.
• Changing the hours of operation to Sunday through Wednesdav 7:00 a.m. to
10:30 p.m. and Thursdav through Saturday 7:00 a.m. to 11:30 p.m.
• Prohibiting all live entertainment located outside beginning at 10:00 p.m. every
night of the week if the outdoor seating area is located within 300 feet of a
residential property, unless specified by a special event permit. Ambient music
may be permitted for the outdoor patrons provided the noise level is consistent
with Section 78-661. Noise. and Article III. Noise.
78-290. Temporary Signs Allowed.
• Decreasing the setbacks to 8 feet versus 15 feet from the right-of way.
• Creating a�rearly permit for rental, lease, and sale of non-residential buildings
and standards for the temporary sign.
Page 3 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
• Creating design standards for temporary signage for consistency.
• Allowing the possibility of leasing information to be placed on the existing base of
the project's monument sign.
78-751. Definitions.
• Amending the special events definition to provide for more clarification on the
definition of special event.
• Creating the following definitions:
o Right-of-Way Banner
o National Event
o Regional Event
o Event Signage
o Outdoor Bar
o Development and clarifying development as it pertains to Art
o Certificate of Completion
o Certificate of Occupancy (land development)
o Certificate of Completion (infrastructure permit)
o Live Entertainment
BACKGROUND
As requested by City Council, staff made efforts to gather input from the Northern Palm
Beach County Chamber of Commerce (Chamber) and the PGA Corridor Association
(Association) concerning issues from both the business community and City residents
regarding Special Events, Outdoor Seating, and Temporary Signage Code Regulations.
Below is a synopsis of the meetings that were held:
• Business Community (NPBC Chamber and PGA Corridor Association)
o November 19, 2008 — Chamber meeting with President and Association
and staff
o January 13, 2009 — Staff met with Association on code sections and
information
o February 9, 2009 — Staff had follow-up meeting with Association
o March 13, 2009 — Staff met with Chamber Government Affairs Committee
o April 3, 2009 — Chambers met to discuss information
o May 20, 2009 — Staff met with Association to discuss proposed changes
o August 3, 2010 — Staff met with the Association and Chamber to discuss
further proposed changes.
• Residents
o Public Notice - Announcements, posters, ads, flyers, website
o November 19, 2009 — Public workshop for citizen input
o December 3, 2009 — Public workshop for citizen input
0 9 residents - total both meetings
• City Council
o June 6, 2009 - Staff presented business community recommendations to
Page 4 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
Council
o April 15, 2010 - Staff presented recommendations based on input from
business community and residents
The proposed amendments include the changes that City Council directed staff to move
forward on, as well as some minor changes for consistency and clarification.
PROPOSED CITY CODE AMENDMENTS
Staff is proposing the following text amendments to the following Code Sections
(deletions are �sl�, new language is underlined):
SECTION 78-187. SPECIAL EVENTS.
(a) Permit required for special event. No person, firm, group, corporation or institution
shall participate in, advertise for� or in any way promote, organize, control, manage,
solicit, or induce; participation in a special event, as defined in section 78-751, unless a
special event permit has first been obtained from the city as provided herein. No person,
firm, group, or corporation shall violate any terms of a special event permit issued under
this article, nor in any manner interFere with the progress or orderly conduct of a special
event.
Any person, firm, group, corporation or institution seeking to conduct a special
event in the city shall file a complete application for a special event permit with the
c�°^��� °"°^+� planner as designated by the growth management director or desianee.
on forms provided by the city. Unless waived by the growth management director, or
desianee. for good cause and for the public interest of the city, a complete application
for a special event permit shall be filed on or before the following deadlines prior to the
event to allow sufficient time for the review process:
TABLE INSET:
Expected attendance Minimum aduance time required to file
Less than, or equal to, 1,000 persons one month
1,001 to 5,000 persons two months
5,001 to 50,000 persons four months
More than 50,000 persons six months
The applicant shall provide all information solicited on the special event permit
application form, unless waived by the c^°^�°' °"°n+� planner, upon finding that such
information is not necessary.
�NOTE: These are administrative changes.]
(b) Permit requirements
Page 5 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/0rdinance 19, 2010
(1) Authority. Notarized evidence the property owner/managing agent
authorizes the use on the site for the special event reflected on the special event permit
application.
(2) Site plan. A detailed site plan for the event, including} but not limited to,
property boundaries; road access; location of trash receptacles, sanitary facilities, tents�
or other structures; location of rides if applicable; location of parking; location of
temporary dwellings, offices, and equipment; location of anv live entertainment. outdoor
music, or staaes: and proposed setbacks of activities, fences, tents, booths, etc.} from
adjacent properties.
�NOTE: Clarifies and reminds the applicant to present any live entertainment
proposed for the special event,J
(3) Stafement of use. A detailed statement of use, including but not limited to�
sponsor(s), vendors(s), band(s) and/or other musical operations, planned activities,
duration of event, hours of operation, anticipated attendance, temporary lighting to be
provided on-site, security, utilities, and use of generators.
(4) Signage. Signs are permitted only if related to a special event.
a. On-site signs:
oi�o c�iirr� r�or cv�oniol o�ion+ ic r+ormi+�or: ��nl000
�- I_ �--6�}2-91"l�ti��-p
,,m �+ nf +ho �;+". One (1) on-site sian is permitted for each side of the
propertv that fronts a aublic riaht-of-wav for no less than 50 linear feet, up
to a maximum of three (3) sians. However, in all cases at least one f1) on-
site sian aer event shall be permitted.
�ii. Any on-site sign related to a special event shall be illustrated
in a detailed on-site sign plan, including, but not limited to� the proposed
location, size, type, copy area, graphics, and color, including the dates of
installation and removal of the sign for � the event in accordance with
section 78-290: Temporary signs allowed.
� iii.
p� "—upprvv�P.�-�6��invr�-r=v -�1.�-: poniol o�ion�c r��n-r°Y N� S�gn$
r.v�crra� v r. r,-ca � r.
shall be permitted in the safe=site visibility triangles as described in section
78-315(i): Visibility triangles.
4 iv. Traffic control sian, as set forth in section 78-289, mav onlv be
used for purposes to direct traffic and/or as deemed necessarv for the
safetv of the public. and/or for public events held bv the citv. and approved
bv the arowth manaaement director, or desianee.
('NOTE: Creates set criteria for the signage; provides clarification regarding the
traffic control signage.]
Page 6 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
b. �# s+f°�;�,& Right-of-wav banners:
ff_ci n/o1 ir�nl��rJiriir c�roo� h�nn r�nlc h�rin
i. ny e„�T�e—s+g,,� �-���e�s, e�
,' riaht-of-wav banners related to a reaional, national.
cit , and/or citv co-saonsored special event shall be illustrated in a
detailed e#-�i#e sign plan that shall indicate on a site plan the location,
copy area, graphics, size, type, and colors of the sign(s) for the event.
Such plan shall be submitted with the special event permit. All sians
located on qublic aropertv or riaht-of-wav other than citv aropertv shall be
submitted with the authorization of the applicable aaencv and aparoved bv
the arowth manaaement director. or desianee.
.. _ .. . .. .. .. .. ... .. . _ . .._. .. _
.. . -- :- : - - :--. . .. . : ._ . . : .._.
. ._ ... _. . ._ .. .. . ._ ,. . _ ._.
�. _ .. .. ._ . : _. ._ ... _ . . . _.:
_ ._ . ._ ._: _. _ _. .. .. ._ _.._ _. . . .
-.. : _ ._ .. .. . .- - -• •- - - ... .. . ._.._.
. _ . .. _ . .._ .. :. . _ ._ .. . - - - ..
- -- - - e � -•e - - -- •-e -- - -• e ---- -
_-- •- - - • - - - -- ' � • . •. - . •- • • . -•
� � - . 1 . - •. �. •- • - - -• -• - - . • �-
- • -• � . - •. •. - - • � • - - -
4 iii. No e#'�;�° ��� riaht-of-wav banners shall be permitted in
the safe=site visibility triangles as described in section 78-315Q); Visibility
triangles.
iv. Installation and removal. The aaplicant shall be resqonsible for
the maintenance and restoration of the citv facilities and/or citv-maintained
light aoles durina the installation and removal of the riaht-of-wav banners.
..
. -• -- : -: -• - -• : -- ._ .. . .
-- •_ - - •- • :- -- •• -- •- - -- - •- - - ��-
.. . ._.._. - - : - - - •- - - -- -: - : • -. _ ..
. . .. ._ . ..-- -- - - -- •: - .. . ..
- - G O - - � • • - - O 0 • - - 0 - - - • - - • - - - - • •
� � � � � � . - � u • � . • • - • . � . � • ' . . � '
�
c. Traffic control sianaae related to a special event shall be permitted at
the discretion of the arowth manaaement director. or desianee subiect to
the review and aqproval of a traffic control sian plan illustratina the
number. copv area. location. and araphics of all sians aroaosed. All sians
located on qublic proqertv or riaht-of-wav other than citv qroaertv shall be
Page 7 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
submitted with the authorization of the aaplicable aaencv.
(NOTE: Prohibits off-site signage in conjunction with Section 78-284(b); however,
it provides for righf-of way banners with criteria for regional, national, City and/or
City co-sponsored special events, and permits traffic control signage for public
safety and traffic control during special events.]
(5) Food service. If food service will be available at the event, the applicant
shall provide a complete list of food service vendors, their respective Palm Beach
County mobile occupational license permit if applicable, Florida State health certificates,
and a list of the type of food service proposed.
(6) Alcohol. Applicants may provide alcoholic beverages in accordance with
chapter 6 of the city code: Alcoholic beverages, provided that a copy of the permit
issued from the Florida Department of Beverages and Tobacco is attached to the
special event permit application.
7) Live Entertainment. Anv saecial event that is proposina to include live
entertainment shall adhere to the followina:
1. Submit a sound manaaement plan as a part of the special event application for
review.
2. The sqecial event must meet the reauirements of section 78-661(b). Noise.
3.The arowth manaaement director, or desianee, mav reauire the applicant to
hire an acoustical enaineer. or the applicant mav be reauired bv the citv to hire code
enforcement qersonnel consistent with the fees and charaes schedule to monitor the
noise levels for compliance.
�NOTE: Provides criteria for review of live entertainment and noise impacts
during the special event.]
{�} �8 Insurance. The operator of an event shall provide evidence of insurance
acceptable to the city in an amount of at least $1,000,000.00, and shall provide the city
with a certificate of insurance showing the city as an additional insured. Events with an
expected attendance over 10,000 people shall submit a certificate of insurance
evidencing coverage of at least $2,000,000.00, with the city named as an additional
insured. Proof of additional insurance may be required by the city. Insurance shall not
be cancelled or re-issued without a 20-day written notice to the city.
{-�-} 9� Bond. A refundable security bond, or similar financial pledge acceptable
to the city, will be required, at the discretion of the �es�,���;� ^—�n�growth
manaaement director. or desianee, to ensure that any damage is repaired and the
premises returned to its previous condition prior to the event, including the removal of
any signs or banners, includina riaht-of-wav banners. within two calendar days of the
event.
�Note: These are administrative changes and permits the Ciiy to request a bond
Page 8 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
or similar pledge as a part of the permit for right-of-way banners.]
{-�} 1�0 Indemnification. The applicant shall submit an indemnification
agreement, as approved by the risk manager and the city attorney, including any and all
such claims, suits, actions, damages, or causes of action arising as a result of the
special event, or of the condition of the premises on which the special event is held}
including any personal injury or loss of life, or damage to or loss of property, and from
and against any order, judgments, or decrees which may be entered, and from and
against any costs, attorneys' fees, expenses� and liabilities incurred in and about the
defense or settlement of any claims, and the investigation thereof.
{�-9-} 1�1 Other materials. Other materials and documentation as may be
required by the growth management director, or desianee.
(c) Review:
��� �,+ ,�;��T��.��� �no,.,,� o"on+� r�lonnor All special events permits,
includina citv co-sponsored events, � shall be reviewed by the Development
Review Committee (DRC) in accordance with section 78-46 (d1): Application
procedures.
. ... . -- - - .- - - -- .... -. • - .
- - .• . • - -- - •- - - -• - - - -• - - e •
� � � � � � � � ' � ' ' � ' � � � � � � � - � � � u � • • • •
� ' � � . � ' • � � u
(3) All citv co-saonsored events shall be administered and implemented bv
Standard Operatina Procedure (SOP). A copv of the most current citv co-saonsorship
SOP shall be kept on file with the Citv Clerk and shall be available for aublic inspection
durina normal workina hours.
("NOTE: These are administrative changes and clarifications for the process of
City and City co-sponsored events.]
(d) General standards:
(1) Location. Special events may occur only on properties possessing the
following non-residential zoning district designations: CN, CG-1, CG-2, CR, P/I, M-1, M-
1A, M-2, �GB; PDA, and PO�B. In residential zoning districts, or residential
portions of PUDs, PCDs, or MXDs overlavs, special events may occur on public or
private schools, churches and houses of worship, public parks, and public or private
property.
(2) Duration. A special event shall not exceed seven consecutive days. The
growth management director or desianee, may authorize one administrative time
Page 9 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
extension of up to three days for good cause and for the public interest of the city. Any
event more than ten days in length must be submitted to the city council for approval.
Pumpkin sales and Christmas tree sales shall not exceed 30 days.
�NOTE: These are administrative changes.]
(3) Number per year.
a. No more than #�ee four special events every calendar year shall be
held by any applicant at one location, unless otherwise approved by the city
council following a recommendation by the growth management director, or
desianee.
b. No events shall occur consecutively, except for those with city council
approval, and if approved shall require a separate permit and fee for each event.
c. Tenants located in commercial/office plazas; are permitted ##�ee four
special events per tenant each calendar year; however, this number of permitted
special events shall exclusively apply to each tenant; and cannot be transferred
to another tenant or party.
d. Sub-tenants within commercial/office plazas are not permitted any
special events.
e. Commercial/office plazas with ten tenants or less shall be limited to a
maximum of #+ve eiaht events per calendar year. Commercial/office plazas with
a-1- eleven tenants or more are permitted #� twelve special events per calendar
year.
f. Anchor tenants are each permitted three events per calendar year
exclusive of the limitation in subsection e. above.
g. No more than two special events at any given time may occur
simultaneously at any commercial/office plaza. Special event applications will be
reviewed and approved by the city on a first-come, first-served basis.
h. City-sponsored and city co-sponsored events are hereby exempt from
the limitation on the number of events per year.
�NOTE: /ncreases the number of events per calendar year for individuals as well
as commercial/office tenants and plazas.]
(4) Access. With the exception of block parties, all efforts shall be made to
provide vehicular access from a collector or arterial roadway.
(5) Traffic control. Use of city police or acceptable alternative to direct and
control traffic may be required.
Page 10 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
(6) Sanitation. Plans for sanitation including temporary bathroom facilities,
inspection of food facilities, drainage, garbage and litter control, and recycling shall be
approved by the growth management director.
(7) Compliance. If a violation occurs at an event permitted by the city, the
growth management director or desianee, may deny permits to the operator for future
temporary events for a period of no more than 18 months.
8) Vendors. Outdoor sales are arohibited, notwithstandina seasonal sales such
as Christmas trees. pumqkin sales, sparklers. and flower sales. for specific holidav
celebrations or similar events. The displav of inerchandise bv a sponsor for a special
event mav be allowed, provided the merchandise is not for sale, the displavs are shown
on the site alan, and it does not block public access.
�NOTE: Clarifies and allows outdoor sa/es for specific special events as well as
the display of sponsor merchandise during a special event.]
(e) Denial of special event permit. A special event permit shall be denied under the
following conditions:
(1) The application is not complete in all material respects accurate within the
knowledge of the c�°^�°' °��°��c planner. The °^°^;°' °.,°^+° planner may allow for any
additional materials to be submitted within seven days of the denial notification by the
�„o,,,,� o„o�+� planner.
�NOTE: These are administrative changes.]
(2) All of the conditions set forth in section 78-187 and all contractual
requirements imposed by the city, if any, have not been met.
(3) The special event will interfere with or unduly burden municipal services
including�but not limited to�police, fire, and emergency medical protection, water and
sanitary sewer service} and solid waste removal.
(4) The public benefit has not been demonstrated.
(5) The permit fee has not been paid.
(f� Conditions for granting a special event permit. All special event permit applications
approved pursuant to this article shall be subject to the following conditions:
(1) The public areas utilized shall be cleaned within two calendar days �
following any special event; and in all respects restored to its former condition.
(2) All city ordinances, rules} or regulations applicable to the special event shall
Page 11 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
be observed unless indicated in such section or waived by the growth management
director�or desianee, for good cause and the public interest of the city.
(3) The special event permit may be revoked by the city if any conditions listed
in (fl arise anytime after the issuance of the permit and prior to or during the special
event.
(g) Exemption of public right-of-way closures. Any special event or block party that is
temporarily blocking off, fencing, or in any way appropriating any publicly_dedicated
street, sidewalk, or alley within the city for a special event or block party is hereby
exempt from section 62-2 of the city code of ordinances; however, such permit
application shall be subject to review in accordance with section 78-187(d). Closure of
any public right-of-way not within the city's jurisdiction shall require approval from the
appropriate authority. A"block party" is defined in section 78-751; a majority of
residents must consent to closure, and the event must be sponsored solely by such
residents and not be for any commercial or for-profit purpose.
(h) Special event contract and city service fees. The city may require, as a condition of
a special event permit, that the applicant enter into a contract with the city relative to the
duties and responsibilities of the permit holder as a condition of the special event. By
such contract, the city shall require that the applicant pay to the city the municipal costs
in providing services in support of the special event. The city may require that the
applicant pay to the city a user fee for the use of public property.
(i) Police se►vices. The police department shall review the permit application and
assess the need for police services. If police services are required, the applicant will be
informed of such and will take the responsibility for contacting the police department
directly. The applicant is responsible for the cost of these services. The police chief,=or
�1+S�2f designee} is the final authority on the need for police service, including the
number of officers required and the hours assigned.
(j) Fire rescue services/emergency medical services. The fire rescue department shall
review the permit application and assess the need for fire rescue services and/or
emergency medical services. If such services are required, the applicant will be
informed of such and will take responsibility for contacting the fire rescue department
directly. The applicant is responsible for the cost of such services. The fire chief or
his/her designee is the final authority on the need for fire rescue and/or emergency
medical services.
(k) Community services. The community services department shall review the permit
and assess the need for community services. If services of the department are required,
the applicant will be informed of sucha and will take the responsibility for contacting the
community services department directly. The applicant is responsible for the cost of
such services. The p��6 �—;;mT�s—t�a;��°�; community services administrator, or
designee} is the final authority on the need for communitv services.
Page 12 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
(I) Appeal of permit application. The applicant may appeal, by written request, the
denial of a special event permit to the city manager's office.�or designee� within ten days
of the growth management director's decision. The written request shall specifically
state what portion of the denial is being appealed. The city manager's office shall have
30 days to make a decision and to notify the applicant. The city shall reserve the right to
charge a non-refundable filing fee to offset all, or a portion of, the costs involved in
handling the appeal.
(m) Enforcement. Any violations of any provision of this article shall be enforced by
the code enforcement special �e� maaistrate consistent with section 78-741(b) of
the . Code of Ordinances.
�NOTE: These are administrative changes,]
SECTION 78-191. OUTDOOR SEATING.
(a) Applicability. Outdoor seating shall
restaurant, business, or institution serving
subject to the standards listed below.
be permitted as an accessory use
food or beverages in an enclosed
to a
area,
(1) Access. The outdoor seating area is adjacent to, and has direct access
through, a doorway to that portion of the business or institution which is enclosed.
(2) Location. The outdoor seating is located directly adjacent to the restaurant
or food service establishment and is owned or leased for this purpose.
(3) General circulation. The outdoor seating can be accommodated without
impeding the access of the general public to one or more of the following:
a. the enclosed portion of the restaurant or food service establishment;
b. any other use located within the same building or structure; or
c. any common elements shared by the restaurant or food service
establishment and any other users of the same building or structure.
(4) Safety. Outdoor seating shall comply with all building, fire, and safety code
requirements.
(5) Parking. Parking for areas utilized for outdoor seating shall be calculated
and provided as required in division 8 of article V. Outdoor seating shall not be
established if required parking cannot be provided on_site or if a nonconformity is
created.
/ G:�oR �}Grhr .�. �� ��ii�.5.� �i. � rti .�tF��Bi�. �—vi u-u �. �r�-G�-� c r� io f n nr! � r
e �
(6) Outdoor furniture. Furniture that is desianed as outdoor furniture, which can
withstand the elements of the rain and intense sun shall be used.
lNOTE; Benches for seating are proposed to be exempt from review in a further
section and clarifies the type of furniture to be used as outdoor seating furniture.]
(b) Review. Outdoar seating may be included as an element of an overall application
for development order approval, or as an amendment to an existing development order.
Page 13 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
Anv outdoor bars that are visible from anv public riaht-of-wav must receive aparoval
from citv council. In addition to any other requirements contained herein, each
application for approval of outdoor seating shall include the information listed below.
1 • ' � � � � ' • � � � • � • u � � � � � � � � � � � �
� ' � � � � � • • • � � � � � ' • � � � � � � � • � � � � � • � � �
� � � � � � � � • • � � � � � • � � � � � � � • • • � � � � � � � � � �
� � � 1 • • � • • � � � • � � •• � � � � • • � � �
� � � � � � � � � � • • � � � � � � • � � � • � � � � � � • � •
� � � • •• � � � � ' • � • � � � � � • � � � � � •• � � � � � � �
�
�NOTE: Eliminates the not�ce requ�rement and requ�res outdoor bars to be
approved by City Council.]
�
following:
1. Site plan. A site plan, at a scale acceptable to the city, which indicates the
a. The building for which the outdoor seating is proposed;
b. The location of the restaurant or food service establishment;
c. The proposed location of the outdoor seating, including number of
tables and chairs. any fencing, screening� or materials to separate the seating
area; a�
d. The location of any sidewalks or other pedestrian walkways or
passageways adjacent to or affected by the proposed outdoor seating; and the
location of all existing or additional parking to be provided for the seating�; and
e. If applicable, a coav of a valid and current state alcoholic beveraae
license to serve alcohol where the proaosed outdoor seatina will be, or anv other
license or permit reauired bv the citv for oaeration.
{4} 2. Consent. A copy of the written consent of the individual, corporation, or
other entity that owns the property upon which the outdoor seating will be located.
{5} 3. Indemnification. The applicant shall provide, in a form acceptable to the
city attorney, indemnification of the city for any liability for personal injurar and property
damage due to the approval or existence of the outdoor seating.
{-6} 4. Renderings. Photographs, renderings, elevations, samples, and other
materials as may be required by the cit�r which illustrate the following: the style and
color s�of all furnishings and menu boards, and the color, style, and materials used for
storaae, fencing, screening, or otherwise separating the outdoor seating.
5. Alcohol. Alcoholic beveraaes mav be consumed in the outdoor seatina area
___ _
provided the primarv oaeration is licensed to serve alcoholic beveraaes in accordance
with Chapter 6. Alcoholic Beveraaes.
Page 14 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
6. Revocation. The aparoval of outdoor seatina is conditional at all times. An
outdoor seatina aqproval mav be revoked or suspended bv the citv upon findina that
two or more code violations have occurred reaardina the outdoor seatina within a
calendar vear, or that the outdoor seatina is beina operated in a manner which
constitutes a nuisance that undulv impedes or restricts the movement of pedestrians, or
that in anv wav constitutes a liabilitv. The revocation will be in writina, settina forth
s ecific reasons and arovidina an effective date.
('NOTE: This provides clarification to the requirements of the application.]
(c) Minimum standards. Outdoor seating shall, at a minimum, comply with the
standards listed below.
(1) Walkways. Outdoor seating shall be arranged, when in use, in a manner that
provides a pedestrian walkway of not less than six feet in width adjacent to each table.
(2) Multiple tenants. Outdoor seating located on a pedestrian walkway which
provides access to more than one occupant of a building shall provide an unobstructed
passageway of at least six feet in width. The unobstructed passageway shall be located
adjacent to, but not through, the outdoor seating area.
(3) Location. Outdoor seating shall be located only along the frontage of the
affected restaurant or food service establishment, and shall not be located in front of or
adjacent to any other user or tenant, unless otherwise previouslv aaqroved bv citv
council.
(4) Prohibited location. Outdoor seating shall not be located within any area
designated for parking.
' � � ' ' � • � � � � • • � � � - � � � ' ' ' � �
• � � � - � . � � � � � . • � u - . � � • • . � � - .
� � u . � � • � . � � � . � . • � • � � � • • � • � -
� � �� � . .� � • •� •• . � • � � � • � � � � • .�
� � � � • • � • • � � � � � � � � • � � ' ' � � � � • � . . � � • �
' • � � � • . • � � • � • . . � . • � . � � . . � �
. . � . � • • • . . � � . � � • • . . � . • • • � •
• . • • . � � • . � � • . • � � � � • • � . . �
• � • � � • . • • • . � � � • � • � . • . � � � • • � � •
. • � � � � .
�NOTE; This proviales flexibility for the screening requirement on a case-by-case
basis, as not al/ locations require screening.]
(6) Compatibility. Outdoor seating, including fencing and screening materials,
shall be compatible in color and style with the exterior of the building. Signs, lettering, or
advertising, excluding permitted menu board, shall not be attached to outdoor seating.
Page 15 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
Small labels may be permanently attached to the furnishing to identify ownership for
security purposes.
(7) Storage. Outdoor seating and furnishings shall be stored in a secure manner
when not in use. If seatina and furnishinas are stored outside. solid colored tarps shall
�NOTE: Provides clarification for acceptable types of storage requirements and
allows for consistent enforcement]
(8) Hours of operation. Excluding outdoor seating located in inner courtyards,
outdoor seating service shall comply with the hours of operation noted below.
a. Sunday through Th� �i-rrai�a-'a-��� Wednesdav. All sales and service of food
and beverages are prohibited between the hours of 10:30 p.m. and 7:00 a.m.
b. �"� Thursdav through Saturday. All sales and service of food and
beverages are prohibited between the hours of ��:��T 11:30 q.m. and 7:00
a.m.
c. All live entertainment is arohibited beainnina at 10:00 p.m. on anv
niaht of the week if outdoor seatina is located within 300 feet of a residential
propertv. unless permitted specificallv bv a sqecial event. Ambient music
throuah saeakers mav be permitted for outdoor qatrons provided the noise level
is consistent with all aaplicable performance codes such as Section 78-661.
Noise and Article III. Noise.
�NOTE: Changes the days and time for permitted outdoor seating. A/so, restricts
any live entertainment, music or speakers to be located outside past 10:00 p.m, in
areas located within 300 feet of a residential property unless permitted by a
special event. Ambient music for the patrons of the outdoor seating may be
permitted provided the noise meets the regu/ations set forth in Performance
Codes (Section 78-661 and Section 34-56).]
(d) Exemations. The followina shall complv with section 78-191 (a); however, thev are
exemat from formal review of outdoor seatina:
(1) Casual Seatina without service. Businesses, institutions, or uses that serve
food or beveraaes solelv inside mav have outdoor casual seatina, such as a bench or
tables. and shall meet all accessibilitv standards.
�NOTE: Al/ows for outside casua/ seating for tenants such as an ice cream shop
or a takeout restaurant to place tables or benches outside the store; provided
they meet the accessibility standards. The number of tables is contingent upon
the amount of space permitted.]
2) De minimus Standard. Businesses. institutions, or uses that serve food or
beveraaes mav be aaqroved to serve food for outdoor seatina bv a maximum of two
tables (eiaht seats) or no more than 100 sauare feet. whichever is less. provided thev
meet all accessibilitv standards.
�NOTE: Some tenants have a sma/l a
which only a/lows for one or two tables.
maximum area for serving outdoors
outdoor seating.]
Page 16 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
ea that they can serve patrons outside
This allows a business that serves food a
without having a formal review of the
Sec. 78-290. TEMPORARY SIGNS ALLOWED.
(a) Permitted temporary signs. Temporary signs allowed within the city are listed in
Table 25.
(b) Approval. Temporary signs shall be approved by the ci�. Signs
not approved by the c� are subject to immediate removal by the city,
at the expense of the owner. Temporary signs shall comply with the standards listed
below.
(1) Illumination. Temporary signs shall not be illuminated.
(2) Setbacks. Temporary signs shall be setback at least �5 eiaht feet from the
riaht-of-wav line. not blockina the visibilitv trianales. t
p� T,T�;ea�e�t�epe�t���,�
��� e�er�e�
(3) Maximum height. A temporary sign shall not be higher than five feet above
the averaae arade at the propertv line within the
nearest proximitv of the sian.
(4) Permitted sign types. Only pole or sandwich-board-type signage shall be
used for temporary signs.
(5) Prohibited sign types. R°���,�n#+p^,�rte�s�+r°����^�T° °�,T
, , •
"�'mr'vrr�ti-t'an—ttlY���--e� �� trri��C�Y-�arr�r°cro 'r-rn�r � �ca—vr-vin��$-�f
. Shall be as set forth in Section 78-284.
�NOTE: The changes are administrative in nature and provide consistency in
measuring the setback requirements for enforcement.]
(The remainder of this page intentionally left blank.)
Page 17 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
Table 25: Temporary Signs
TABLE INSET:
Type of Sign Maximum Earliest Final Notes and
Size Installation Removal Remarks
(Sq. Feet) Date Date
nr icci io r�or rocirlon+iol
�YY��
.4 cinn nor
T. r9�r'�c.T
nnnrccir7cn4i�l n�rnol
V1��tVt
•Signs may not be
placed on public
property.
•Signs may not be
•Residential - placed in public rights-
•Residential - none •Residential - of-way.
6 square feet •Nonresidential - none •Signs may not
Political* •Nonresidential 30 days before •Nonresidential - obstruct vision at
- 32 square feet primary, general, 5 days after corners, intersections,
or runoff election election etc.
or referendum. •Applicable to federal,
state, county, and
local elections.
• ne (11 sian mav be
permitted for each side
f the proaertv that
fronts a public ripht-of-
way for no less than
0 linear feet. uq to a
maximum of three (31
sians per proaertv.
•1 sign per residential
dwelling or lot_
•1 sign per
nonresidential parcel
or lot_
•Sign may be installed
•Residential - in lieu of any permitted
6 square feet nonresidential sign_
Free Speech •Nonresidential None None •Signs may not be
Sign * -as permitted by placed on public
sign regulations property.
•Signs may not be
placed in public rights-
of-way.
•Signs may not
obstruct vision at
corners, intersections,
etc.
Page 18 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
c.,�ooa,� ^f�r�n�
r
�G�L \A/hon r�rnr�or4�i ���
J� ..�
�e�ie�-e# � effere� fer sale slas+r��
g�il�ing.
Sale: Residential 6 Day open house Day open house
Open House* begins closes
Sale: Day open house Day open house
Nonresidential 16 begins closes
Open House
aAl�e�--�iJ�i p�
nffororJ fnr c�lc nr
��� � ��� �i rl��ic �ftor c�lo
��— � �–
�eci�
\A/hon h��ilrlir�n
Ron} nr I ooco• �B� �i-E�ttCY
' �'_ rlo�iol�pm��� rcn+o'J nr Ic^+ orJ
�� IGIICGQ�TGCI�GQ -
Ol Civ�- -
1CC1�
���'�'�"}�
Ron4 nr I c�co• nfforor! nr
°�°r norncn� (4 (1(10%\ hn� i cinnc
�9�-e# �- ��"�I�� 'F�99i}��Fig„vuse��
�� ,.,Y�,.,Y rcn#ciJ nr loocc�7 ���.
�h�t-
icc��
When complete On receipt of
Development 32 development first certificate of
Sign order application
filed with city occupancy
Project Issuance of On receipt of •No more than two
Suppliers/trades 32 building permit final certificate of sians shall be
occupancy permitted at one time.
Grand Opening/
Project Opening/ 7 days before 10 days after
New Businesses 32 event opening or
event
Outparcel/Phase 32 7 days before 10 days after
Opening event opening
' - " " 7 rl�vc hcfnro '
G�iori�/C�lo Aln} �� '�°i� ��'�
��lo/o�� cnl%� ��IBFi--�
fnr�_
G�ion4/colo fnr � `` �--�GtGf-C �F�1�� �cr^°^-°PPT�°vca
t� c�le/o�icri�
�r'� �e� °F"r"°'�� a�mini��ra�ive�elisa :
Page 19 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/0rdinance 19, 2010
•In accordance with
subsection 78-187
bl(41(a) one (11 on-
i e sian mav be
7 davs prior to 2 davs after permitted for each side
32 of the aroqertv that
�ecial Event = even event
Sianaae fronts a aublic riqht-of-
way for no less than
50' linear feet, up to a
maximum of three (31
sipns. Minimum one
(11 per aroaertv
allowed.
Event •Maximum 4 �er
7 davs prior to
Sianaae/sale for 16 event 1 dav after event alendar vear per
rfi r�c
•Per section 78-187
41(b). must be
repional, national. Citv
Riaht-of-wav 30 davs arior to 2 davs after or Citv co-sponsored
banner 24 event even special event
•Must have
authorization from
apnlicable aaencv
•Onlv canvas
overinps of around
60 days from sipns allowed.
Name Chanae- issuance of •Office and retail uses
60 square feet Issuance of
pround sian permanent sian g�
co�v rin of COqV e� e� • Mav be submitted
apalication (**1 when sian permit for
new permanent sian is
submitted
School/Day 32 30 days before �914 days after •Max. 3 per calendar
Care/Nursery registration registration r�
Garage Sale* 12 1�day before Day of sale 1 sign for the sale
sale
�� .�` 'I r!�" �f+or c�lo ��g�#
C�lo�.�i -It!`— Q�71Lkj r� .�It�
� �� �
1/�/i�hni i+ R� iilrJirinc
Special Event Day before 1 day after �s���
Direction 4 event event ����
Signage
Issuance of land On receipt of
Construction clearing, land
Entrance 16 alteration, or finaf cer�ificate of
building permit occupancy
NOTES TABLE 25:
*) Exempt from fees and aermit reaistration provided the sian meets the
Page 20 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
reauirements set forth in Table 25.
(**) A written reauest for a 30-dav extension mav be aranted administrativelv
provided the permanent sian is not completed but is in the process of completion.
�Note: the Notes for Table 25 are clarifying the types of temporary signs that
are exempt from fees and permits, provided they meet the criteria in Table 25
and providing an extension to the name change covering, provided the
applicant is working with the City in the process.]
�NOTE: The changes in Tab/e 25 inc/ude:
■ Specifying a number for political signs based on the amount of public
right-of-way with a maximum number of signs allowed;
■ Clarifying the temporary signs which are exempt from applying for a
permit; however, they must meet the criteria in the table;
■ Providing a maximum number of signs for project suppliers/trades;
■ Removing the temporary sign criteria for non-residential sale, lease, and
rentals because, due to the nature of the economy, a business may always
have one tenant space available, therefore allowing the temporary sign to
remain and deteriorate. These signs are proposed to require a year/y
permit with renewa/s based on the new criteria listed in a section below;
■ Consolidating the special event signage criteria and making it consistent
with the special event section (78-187);
■ Adding an event signage/sale-for-profit category for those applicants that
would like a temporary sign for a special occasion (such as Easter church
services) but are not considered a"special event";
■ Adding right-of-way banner criteria consistent with the special event
section (78-187);
■ Providing a maximum number of signs for school/day care/nursery
registrations and allowing the sign to remain for 14 days after registration;
■ Adding criteria for a name-changelground sign covering allowing a
business (such as a bank) to temporarily have the new name over the
permanent ground sign while it is in the process of making the new sign;
and
■ Removing the criteria for "outside sa/es/sites without buildings" signage
because currently the City requires a special event permit for any sales
that occur on vacant parcels (such as Christmas frees).]
(6) Maximum sign faces. A maximum of two faces will be allowed for each
temporary sign.
7) Maintenance. All sians shall be kept in aood condition. present a neat
a pearance, and be maintained free of debris. stains. mold. discoloration. or
deterioration.
81 Hazard. A sian shall not directiv or indirectiv create a traffic or fire hazard or
interFere with the free and unobstructed use of streets or sidewalks.
Page 21 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
�NOTE: Allows for enforcement of the maintenance and placement of temporary
signs.]
9 Permit.
a. A citv temporarv sian permit is reauired for all temporarv sians except
those exempt as shown in Table 25.
b. Non-residential sale of qortion of buildina. rental. or lease aermit
1. An application for temporarv sianaae will be made with the Citv.
All applications will be issued and renewed administrativelv bv the Citv.
2. If approved, a aermit for temporarv sianaae will be issued for a
period of no lonaer than one vear. A renewal permit mav be submitted
annuallv if the applicant is in comqliance with the citv's standards.
3. An administrative fee will be charaed for the issuance of the
temaorarv sianaae aermit as reaulated bv the fees and charaes schedule
on file.
�NOTE: Creates a process by which an annual permit will be submitted and
approved.]
4. Standards. Sianaae must be in compliance with all temaorarv
sianaae standards and meet the criteria below:
i. Size. Maximum sauare footaae of the sian is 16 sauare
feet.
ii. Sian post. Post shall be a 4x4 treated wood post or other
acceatable material. The minimum number of posts shall be two.
The posts shall be directiv buried into the around at a minimum of
two feet. Use of concrete is arohibited.
iii. Backina. Sian shall be installed on a%2 inch alvwood.
Plvwood shall be attached with weather-resistant screws.
iv. Color. The entire sian must be painted and have no more
than two colors, includina the letters. The colors of the sian must be
consistent with the approved principal color of the development
and/or buildina.
c. An additional leasina sian not exceedina 12 sauare feet mav be
incorporated into the aroiect's monument sian within the 3-foot reauired base, if
provided. Letter size shall be no less than 5 inches for around sians. Must have no more
than two colors and be consistent with the aeneral desian of the monument sian. A sian
permit must be submitted and approved bv the citv.
�NOTE: Creates standards for the temporary signs that are enforceable and
aesthetically pleasing. A/so allows the /easing information to be placed on the
monument sign of developments as a temporary sign which minimizes signage
and still is aesthetically pleasing to the public.]
Page 22 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
(c) Removal.
(1) Hurricane watch. Any temporary sign installed within the city shall be
removed by the owner or city if a hurricane watch is posted. The city shall not be
responsible for the replacement of such signage after a hurricane watch is discontinued.
(2) Violations. The city shall have the right to remove any temporary signage in
violation of this section.
(d) Number. Each side of a property facing a public right-of_way is allowed one
temporary signs as permitted in Table 25. Each side of a proaertv facina a arivate riaht-
of-wav mav be allowed one temporarv sian as aermitted in Table 25 at the discretion of
the arowth manaaement director.
(e) Prohibited materials. Paper, cardboard, or other such material subject to rapid
deterioration shall not be used for any sign that is to be displayed for more than 30
consecutive days.
(NOTE: Allows for additional temporary signage for the private right-of-way.]
SECTION 78-751. DEFINITIONS.
(NOTE: The definitions clarify what defines a special event and adds a definition
for right-of-way banner, outdoor bar, regional event, national event, live
entertainment and event signage. In an effort to expedite and clarify the intent of
some of the current definitions, there are some administrative changes included
with this petition for certificate of comp/etion, certificate of occupancy, and
development,]
Certificate of Completion means aermission aranted bv the buildina official upon
satisfactorv comaletion of a buildina. structure. and electrical. aas or plumbina svstems.
This certificate is proof that a structure or svstem is comalete and for certain tvaes of
permits is released for use and mav be connected to a utilitv svstem. This certificate
does not arant authoritv to occupv or connect a buildina, such as a shell buildina. prior
to the issuance of a certificate of occuqancv.
Certificate of Occuaancv (Land Develoament) means permission aranted bv the arowth
manaaement administrator. upon receivina a certificate of comaletion. which shall be
ranted upon the satisfactorv completion of a buildina. structure. or anv reauired site
and land development improvements from a proiect's development order. This
certificate does not arant authoritv to occupv or connect a buildina arior to the issuance
of a certificate of occupancv issued from the buildina official.
Certificate of Completion (Infrastructure Permit) means permission aranted bv the citv
enaineer upon the satisfactorv comaletion of anv water, sewer. pavina. drainaae.
aradina, or anv other items permitted throuah an infrastructure permit to a buildina.
structure, or other land develoament imarovements. This certificate is aroof that the
improvements are complete, and for certain tvaes of permits. are released for use and
Page 23 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
mav be connected to a utilitv svstem.
Development, as it aertains to art, means any project to construct or remodel any
private or public development, except residential and/or residential components of
mixed-use development, or any portion thereof within the limits of the city, where total
construction costs equal or exceed� $1,000,000.00.
Development means the carrvina out of anv buildina activitv. the makina of anv material
chanae in the use or appearance of anv structure or land, or the dividina of land into two
or more aarcels.
Live entertainment means an act and/or production that entertains, creates a diversion
and/or amusement, and is actuallv beina performed at the time of hearina or viewina.
National event means a special event of, relatina to. or belonaina to a nation as an
oraanized whole.
Outdoor bar means an accessorv structure to a primarv restaurant within a close
proximitv to the primarv restaurant, which serves food and/or beveraaes.
Recrional event means an event at which attendees are from a qre-determined
qeoaraphical area such as southeast, and over half of the particiaants live within 400
miles of the location.
Special event means a temporary meeting, activity, gathering, or group of persons,
animals, or vehicles, or a combination thereof, having a common purpose, design} or
goal that will affect or impact the ordinarv and normal use bv the aeneral public upon
any public or private facility, street, sidewalk, alley, �a-�I� public or private area, or
building where the °"� event substantially inhibits the usual flow of pedestrian or
vehicular traffic, and is not the type approved for, or customarily associated with, the
site upon which the event is located. A special event a� is not a normal business sale
event or similar activity for commercial and/or office establishments. e �„o�;�� o"o„+
, , , ,
, , , , ,
, , ,
Siqn, event sianaae means temporarv sianaae used to notifv the public that a special
occasion and/or a special sale is takina place, but does not meet the definition as a
�ecial event.
Sian. riaht-of-wav banner means sianaae that has letters, illustrations. or drawinas that
are aaplied to fabric or vinvl and are attached to a street pole or liaht pole in the public
riaht-of-wav. the placement of which has been proaerlv permitted bv the aovernment
a encv that owns the riaht-of-wav.
Page 24 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
STAFF ANALYSIS
The purpose of the proposed amendments as described above is to clarify the various
City code sections as well as make the regulations and their enforcement more
effective. The business community proposed the initiative to change the codes for
clarification and to assist in a downward economy. The residents also proposed some
changes during the two public workshops. Many of the changes address the comments
and questions that arose and will simplify the common requests from residents and the
business community. The amendments will also allow regulating, enforcing, and
processing the requests more efficient for staff.
PLANNING, ZONING, AND APPEALS BOARD
At the July 20, 2010, meeting of the Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board (PZAB), this
item was postponed to date certain time of August 10, 2010, at 6:00 p.m., to give the
board and business community more time to meet with staff and further review the
proposed amendments. Since that time, staff has met with the business community as
well as most of the Commissioners individually. The following reflects a few minor
changes to the petition:
Section 78-290 TEMPORARY SIGNS ALLOWED
• Event signage maximum number was changed from 5 to 4
• School/Day Care/Nursery — maximum number of 3 per calendar year and 14
days after registration
• Monument leasing signage
o Removed "in lieu of yearly permit"
o Added additional criteria for colors and consistency
o Minimum 5 inches letter size for leasing information
• Number-added criteria for private right-of-way signage
Section78-187 SPECIAL EVENTS
Added "or similar events" under the vendors' section for events that are not
foreseen
Added a definition of "live entertainment" to the Definitions section
Included a possible bond for right-of-way banners
Added information about co-sponsorship with the City
Section 78-191 OUTDOOR SEATING
• Live entertainment is prohibited after 10 p.m. if within 300 feet of a residen#ial
property
Page 25 of 25
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
• Ambient music may be permitted through speakers for outdoor patrons provided
the noise level is consistent with Section 78-661. Noise. and Section 34-56 in
Article III Noise.
• Allowed temporary signage facing a private right-of-way
• Added number of chairs permitted for the exempt de minimus standard
Section 78-751 DEFINITIONS added :
• Live entertainment
• Certificate of completion
• Certificate of completion (infrastructure permit)
• Certificate of occupancy (land development)
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends approval of LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
ORDINANCE 19, 2010
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM
BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA AMENDING CHAPTER 78. LAND
DEVELOPMENT. BY REPEALING SECTION 78-187. SPECIAL
EVENTS AND READOPTING SAME AS REVISED; FURTHER
AMENDING CHAPTER 78. BY REPEALING SECTION 78-191.
OUTDOOR SEATING AND READOPTING SAME AS REVISED;
FURTHER AMENDING CHAPTER 78. BY REPEALING SECTION
78-290. TEMPORARY SIGNS ALLOWED AND READOPTING SAME
AS REVISED; FURTHER AMENDING CHAPTER 78. AT SECTION
78-751. DEFINITIONS. TO PROVIDE DEFINITIONS FOR
"CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION", "CERTIFICATE OF
OCCUPANCY (LAND DEVELOPMENT)", "CERTIFICATE OF
COMPLETION (INFRASTRUCTURE PERMIT)", "DEVELOPMENT,
AS IT PERTAINS TO ART", "DEVELOPMENT", "LIVE
ENTERTAINMENT", "NATIONAL EVENT", "OUTDOOR BAR",
"REGIONAL EVENT", "SPECIAL EVENT", "SIGN, EVEN7
SIGNAGE" AND "SIGN, RIGHT-OF-WAY BANNER"; PROVIDING
THAT EACH AND EVERY OTHER SECTION AND SUBSECTION OF
CHAPTER 78. LAND DEVELOPMENT. SHALL REMAIN IN FULL
FORCE AND EFFECT AS PREVIOUSLY ADOPTED; PROVIDING A
CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE, AND
AUTHORITY TO CODIFY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND
FOR OTHER PURPOSES.
29 WHEREAS, the City Council has determined that a need exists to update and
30 modify criteria for special events, outdoor seating, and temporary signage in the City of
31 Palm Beach Gardens; and
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
WHEREAS, on April 15, 2010, the City Council discussed and provided direction
based on the business community's suggestions and input from the public; and
WHEREAS, City staff has initiated an amendment (Petition LDRA-10-04-000031)
to the City's Land Development Regulations amending Chapter 78. Land Development.
in order to address the City Council's concerns; and
WHEREASa the proposed code changes are consistent with previously-
discussed criteria; and
WHEREAS, on August 10, 2010, the Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board,
sitting as the
approval and
x; and
Local Planning Agency, conducted a public hearing and recommended
adoption of the proposed amendments �o the City Council with a vote of x-
Page 1 of 5
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Ordinance 19, 2010
WHEREAS, the City Council deems approval of this Ordinance to be in the best
interests of the health, safety, and welfare of the residents and citizens of the City of
Palm Beach Gardens and the public at large.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF PALM BEACH GARDENS, FLORIDA that:
SECTION 1. The foregoing recitals are hereby affirmed and ratified.
12 SECTION 2. Section 78-187. Special Events, Section 78-191. Outdoor Seating,
13 and Section 78-290. Temporary Signs Allowed of the Land Development Regulations of
14 the City of Palm Beach Gardens Florida are hereby amended and attached as Exhibit
15
16
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
,
"A" and made a part hereof of the current Land Development Regulations are hereby
adopted. The text adopted in Exhibit "A" shall be substituted for and replace in total the
previously-adopted text in the amended sections.
SECTION 3. Chapter 78, Land Development of the Code of Ordinances of the
City of Palm Beach Gardens, Florida is hereby amended at Section 78-751.
"Definitions." by adding new definitions for the terms "Certificate of Completion",
"Certificate of Occupancy (Land Development)", "Development, as it Pertains to Art,"
"Development", "Live Entertainment", "National Event", "Outdoor Bar", "Regional Event",
"Special event", "Sign, Event Signage", and "Sign, Right-of-Way Banner", each of which
shall be placed in alphabetical order in the list of definitions and shall hereafter be
defined and read as follows:
Certificate of Comaletion means permission aranted bv the buildina official uaon
satisfactorv completion of a buildina, structure, electrical, aas, or plumbina svstem. This
certificate is proof that a structure or svstem is complete. and for certain tvaes of
permits is released for use and mav be connected to a utilitv svstem. This certificate
does not arant authoritv to occupv or connect a buildina, such as a shell buildina. prior
to the issuance of a certificate of occupancv.
Certificate of Occupancv (Land Develoament) means aermission aranted bv the
rowth manaaement director, upon receivina a certificate of completion, which shall be
ranted uqon the satisfactorv completion of a buildina. structure. or anv reauired site
and land development imqrovements from a qroiect's development order. This
certificate does not arant authoritv to occupv or connect a buildina prior to the issuance
of a certificate of occuaancv issued from the buildina official.
Certificate of Comaletion (Infrastructure Permit) means permission aranted bv
the citv enaineer uqon the satisfactorv completion of anv water. sewer. pavina,
drainaae, aradina, or anv other items permitted throuah an infrastructure permit to a
buildina, structure, or other land development improvements. This certificate is proof
that the improvements are complete, and for certain tvpes of aermits are released for
use and mav be connected to a utilitv svstem.
Page 2 of 5
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
Ordinance 19, 2010
Development, as it aertains to Art, means any project to construct or remodel any
private or public development, except residential and/or residential components of
mixed-use development, or any portion thereof within the limits of the city, where total
construction costs equal or exceeds $1,000,000.00.
Develoament means the carrvina out of anv buildina activitv. the makina of anv
material chanae in the use or aqaearance of anv structure or land. or the dividina of
land into two or more parcels.
Live Entertainment means an act and/or production that entertains, creates a
diversion and/or amusement. and is actuallv beina aerformed at the time of hearina or
viewin .
National Event means a saecial event of, relatina to. or belonaina to a nation as
an oraanized whole.
Outdoor Bar means an accessorv structure to a primarv restaurant within a close
proximitv to the primarv restaurant, which serves food and/or beveraaes.
Recrional Event means an event at which attendees are from a pre-determined
aeoaraahical area such as southeast and over half of the aarticiaant lives within 400
miles of the location.
25 Special eEvent means a temporary meeting, activity, gathering, or group of
26 persons, animals, or vehicles, or a combination thereof, having a common purpose,
27 design} or goal that will affect or impact the ordinarv and normal use bv the aeneral
28 � upon any public or private facility, street, sidewalk, alley, p�r� public or private
29 area, or building where the �e�+a�l event substantially inhibits the usual flow of
30 pedestrian or vehicular traffic, and is not the type approved for, or customarily
31 associated with, the site upon which the event is located. A special event a� is not a
32 normal business sale event or similar activity for commercial and/or office
33 establishments. °�es��e�er�s� , + ho �,m.+ ' nr�cnrorl �„�,
�,,,,� �aT�--�,,a
34 , , , , , , ,
35 , ,
36 ' , .
37
38
39
40
41
Sian. Event Siqnaae means temporarv sianaae used to notifv the public that a
saecial occasion and/or a special sale is takina place but does not meet the definition as
a sqecial event.
42 Siqn. Riaht-of-Wav Banner means sianaae that has letters, illustrations. or
--__ _
43 drawinas that are applied to fabric or vinvl and are attached to a street pole or liaht pole
44 in the aublic riaht-of-wav. the placement of which has been proaerlv aermitted bv the
45 aovernment aaencv that owns the riaht-of-wav.
.�
Page 3 of 5
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
Ordinance 19, 2010
SECTION 4. All ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict be and the same
are hereby repealed.
SECTION 5. Should any section or provision of this Ordinance or any portion
thereof, any paragraph, sentence, or word be declared by a Court of competent
jurisdiction to be invalid, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remainder of
this Ordinance.
SECTION 6. Specific authority is hereby given to codify this Ordinance
SECTION 7. This Ordinance shall become effective immediately upon adoption.
(The remainder of this page intentionally left blank)
Page4of5
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
PASSED this day of
PASSED AND ADOPTED this
and final reading.
CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS
BY:
David Levy, Mayor
Robert G. Premuroso, Vice Mayor
Joseph R. Russo, Councilmember
Eric Jablin, Councilmember
ATTEST:
BY:
Patricia Snider, CMC, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND
LEGAL SUFFICIENCY
I:�'il
R. Max Lohman, City Attorney
Ordinance 19, 2010
2010, upon first reading.
day of
FOR
Page 5 of 5
, 2010, upon second
AGAINST ABSENT
�
�
•Established 1997
•Met at Jupiter HS until 200 -
•Established Jupiter Campus Aug 2� � 8
•Currently in expansion process at Jupiter Campus,
requiring to seek a large venue until completion.
•Centralized location based on congregations
geography.
a1�l�lr
z _. . _r
� � , �} � i �r�° ��,�!*-� �
�
�, � � I 4,a � � x" • R � �."S;",� . ry k !� � I � �� �� � ' �
��� ,'�*� ' � �' �.,. s _ e � . •�'�y� ��+" .' � ��sa y,4 �''"1 "�a.
, k �� .� �4.r �_ �a �. ' � �a - ��. _
� �
;1�' � � , �� B49 i;. � . � a���� � � �€�I
� � ,� .,,� � �
.. „ �. � �.
„
: T �, �-
��,,�� , � !�r �.� e. .:�' . � 'r . . ' .' �F.
� �� i. � �' ' ' � + . . � x
r�f�* � �� � h � .. I,,. ' 1 y IF .. +'_ �y ,i _ _ �_ P- cy
�
.:� �.. �� � ' ' , '' f� .k��'!'r ��" ��p �
.. I ' 1�1 � ip rP � i! 1 1 II-�: .
, �a+ � '" �,� i �+ F�A I°i6 � MI �Pl91ii � 1.� �. �FytAP. R1�� ����f ' =:,!1�• �'P �
-� _ Ila �h ..
's ' � �!v � . � �� ' . 1 � � ' � � n ��
� � r ■ . � i � �4 d���iineybJ^ , hvY'�,r����apt, r e �1'+b i ..�� , �. .
��, °� _ � .�: �"�w�� � .v... ��
, - •
�. � : ' ""�"� t= �. � �'� �i��a� E'��• �GH„",r � �� ' _
_ ,
� .. .� 'r. � �•oF11 hqr.�?�P F � �R� .+�� � �.
a
��`'�r���- � -�' � V 4;2 !y ' � � wfA �q r �.. 'i�' •j � f � .
, s C , � ,�—�', ,,����
� � �
' �� � �4 - � � � �MF F Yf"Yl�i.• � .�. L , -�
��# � "� • ��� ' � i��. �• � , ��� � ' �1� , ,
�. '� � i � � T._ �� , �?� �� ��� , � _ _ . �
� �: -,� � �r v � `l � � �'., ' . ?! . , r- �
�1 E+'�s+ — �k .� . � � � '.5.-
� � ��� tl �'� � i��-���� � � . . .t �� {
, 'y ;� L
._ � ��� .. , � �� '_� �•��'° " r L„ !� . �r a �
��� .� -k y " � ��-# '�, li�+T. � � -� fy _
�..� R �, ` , � � `� - #p f s , �' �
,;�.�`„� - � "�- ¢:� � , �, , • ,
� ��, ��,. � � �,� ���� ��', �-� � � � _
r '� � _ `'��. � ��.�}+� �'� ';�' •' �r .- - �
�,;' �s �: . 64� - " •��"'�"� •�"' �°�-4'� �� w . - _:�,;� �,', �,- 'i,�,�. .
.� T.., � _. .• i�.� x � . .. � �r � ...
+ , :
� " ��
'
' .
'r J �� s [ : i � � w . " ,. �
i � , ..._�;a.�r. �ir .■ . - � .. �� i . I . ' '�"��' .,,�b'�, �� -r
.� � � . 'JfPI^f���;'�. _
} ,� I i i�,o : i ��°:t. ° � y � ' . ,r `. ` ��_�.......`�.�: ._� � _ � � ' � ' 7e�..�YP/
- �` i �s�.
' �7 ��' ' + ..'� , � r � . . . -_. � , � �� _ .
x � y, � � �� 7� � '�, -
--� '"�`�. �""ID'�0:� � -- �i ,,� � ��• . , �`'�, �'
� z 't , ��' Y ' � 0. ��'`�!� y � � if r �-_'±ru� a ��yl ` � f� o �y,,d° ., a�� � a
�
A � � k � g �i, ,h '., �. '� � ° " ,�,
., ,
.� , . � a.� .
.
�
I
.. - - � � � �, #'ru�.
�.
R"�
-�� �.�., � � ;� s
, - � -- �_ �.�
�T - �. �
-�_ v�,. .. . i ��:��� �mdo-. h°' r'°"a�n."`�ea,.ara�
�� � ir � _ .. .ia _ � -r � �
4 � (_.- I . ���� � ..:�, ^'�n r��- ,.,� - —
�_ �.�. �- ,�' ��+'�� f �1 � „o
�� `.� i'' I L ' HIIN'-r111�.-4iNfl!y�,� k;k.,� s 1 r�� --
N �� � �i !� ] rX� H�°�u,kr+ � — _ —
� ,.!� i j � �. ,' �_ ������{� � .� '� � -� ��
,� ' ' ° ' - ; � � "�.m ��;, -
�. ��= _ _., --- _ ��,� �;�; _ i
� �� � r .� . _ � ° �� -_ • -
G i � i � �
�� � I ----- - .
i i � i �, :.4
i_ � �
e }_ _,' �� '� '
�1'�.y}„�
I �� 4 _� �L �__'_` iI• �• � .
-� � _ _
�- ;' - e.�._ �: ' � � �
� f �,��. Yr s���oa r`:�` ,,-Y_�
-- ! 51.1 t :5 ,.�'Ir.n f�ww' Y . :�' ` w„� :..:P_� �� .�
�
�r�. 'h. upp . �r� ....�u
.,�, - r � � �.r � i �
'�'�. - �� � � °�' = _ .-
� �m �
"�='T�
= ua� Gy�i
..,.r:•a-As;�.i'��:�i i ��-x.__F . °uo� r.:'!a.:i� F'k� . _ _
+F'�'4�1Y.�°�1�_ �..��i�_ijl.'�,�i'k..
1 `I<�.t.
• Calvary �'h����'I'' J' �� �iter will be using PBGHS
auditorium on Sunday mornin s between 9am
—11am for the church servic
• The church will also be using the cafeteria and
several classrooms for the children's Sunday
school.
'�I���i�i�[!
�� ,°,r., ,;e,.t...�., • ..
�'l � ��
R
r
i
Y � �� .I� ,e�,e�a . a ... ...v
1 - {i P ��.�'.� `..`Y.`w'im""�I�1
� �'°' �
� ' �� r . �� � ;�;,� � � �,o:. „a„
� �� _ � —��
�.. '� �: '
` ���� - ��- .������ - ��
,
iS � r!` + I "' � 4+^°�-�yy9
— 3 _ ,�,p�
_ � Y y -ri
• •L_ — . ""_ .se'
� ��'
�
�� �
��. �
�.
:.. �--�:s=
r
�
,�"'
�
� �ir...
W�—�..—
r- ���
I'� L—� ; ' "k' I � '{ _ _' �
I i � � I' — I � �.�
F' 3 I I }� ' "* i
�.� - :;�� „ - _ �� t �
_ ., r. �
_, � �.
_ c sbncu rnrvL�:�lac:rrtr�, s ��� .. t �
_ 5_�s.n�'I 7 .vPin7 {+�a.'.�-_ -: } ° �....� �- � . ' �
nr-�- =hn aP'"a . 1 I� I•:.x
— �- — � t. . �...
.� �. � -r- - �~ � ' � -
� � � �.� ...�-� s�-i
s;:,a sia� n' i��, �, ._r:�:� , r's�Pi�i
�,e�_.„�,_��._.�
::�,r��,�,:�,_.
, �.-._.�•. i,..= � -�:•�o. :,,,r._,�.., �.�r•.�. , i:r.
i n Exhi i
S t
�
This sign would be 4' H
'� � � � � '� � �'� . '� �' �
���txniq
J i_
�
I�11�TA�'�
�RAIL
I�QRTH
� BOUN�
J i-
� � tivr+�a
�11LIT� Rl�
TR �41�
��!l�iH
��UI�D
� _ �
� I.� � � 4 �i .
�� ��� ��
N ������
�������
i.� -� �_ - --- .
'I"iiF.o: qE�rn T`.ah€hit
V.an�o: A�ii'uxt •1� ��!ki�p
whcu r,f?
r n-, ��n�,-� R.�� ��..i;�:�..: r-n;�s�d�i ,.,c J���� ��r. r_i�•
�
Planned Unit Development Amendment
� y .. ���� _: .�� : � u� _ _ �z� . ���� ��_. �y��ne�s�ca�, _ _ ��
�
�
.� �
,� ���
�'� �RI�A� u
�
r��. � _ �, �' �f�
� � �
� � _ _
�� � � .� ,��� ��.
, � �* � - � � �._ z
_ � k_� _ � : � ��' �i'y �� ; ;
r � � G �r� � � � _
r � � .
� �,� ��r.� jT'- - �
- � �. �.-. i � - .
� � �j , L,
R
� ��'T�
�
_ �1� � �.� . 9__ _ -.. .y� -_ _ __ —..
� � f` �!� �
. ,�–_ �. I . y� � � 7a • i_ • ? ��� � �' �I
A • �. a ����_�, � _ ���
� -z , _ � - � _-- �� _ �
-�� . ��� • •
�� � .
,r �'.: ��`:� �'_ �;
'1r� � ` r -
e._.,,,�. - ?
. - , - �`'� � � _
�.=� ~ r �
--- -� a • � _ � : �
•
� �
�_ .w. � 6 ,��y� �T ,�'��i�� ;. •'' +��° � �P
�'� N ' � �' LL �!�'��rv�.�l{�.� � � } �i ,
�i J
�`i� ��'�� � .,r � � � ���3
� ��•� ' � , �
NN � ��'_ �.. � �. �•.
��`` � �, � � � �, �y,�.�
� � ' � � r ': �e . � � _� � A
��� �}n � ��� ��� �' _ �
` �' � T R$ � �� � � � �' .9 ''� �� � .
'� - 4 � ��� t-�a ��: .
. � , �
`���Y � � .. � �� �- Il�l a r� �
�[ r' ,y Y. � �1'1� � �, - 'i
�,��: �' j�. ! �-�
i .- � � °T 4 *� �'{� �� 9'A� �.�
�. � �.
�_ �
. � ,� .I��irt�►���:.�r ��i������; ��
� ._� �
' /� `�, � - -- � �o i ak .+� , �. � ��
r
;��.: � � �.t� �: � � �,�,�� �,�3 a ,.�,.- ,•� �,�,.,
,� '�� �.+�'� ,�fi �`,��'`��:�
�"�i�y s ,;� �
� _ � _ . #.. - _ _ . r -
�,�_ W�e'� LL S�r.eric� �
�
.,, , ,,: ,
� ��� � � � � a � ��O tl� ' T� � -�" — �'" �
M!
� " � .�.� �'"'�.� � �P.C���]#�?Clt�l, �
4���� y�� � +s�: � p �.� ' >� .e � ,
., .�s � --'� w � ����c� ' �
+, 'e�' � � � -� a , � i� �
� �� �� � �a � � � 1�?�
�:, _ � � � —� _ .
:� Y ' r ' '
� � �, .
s�' �, � � � ,.,� .'�� �� �`'�k;, � . .
, ,�
s,, } ..� , ' �� ,; "`�'� �. � ' ' _ � a_
_ �. � ��'� i�
�� R � ��
���r���� � �..
��
�rd�r��` a:
� 4
•�9e� '� ��� -
� '. � � $ �
� � �err�ir�c�N� = �
�,. i
�► , ��f�l �1 � �;,
, _ �,
..k #�� 'i e�.� �
- "� -
...��-�'� .�'J���.. ,_ „ — �n � ..
r��� r��,� ,�,,e ` - ._ . ��� �
.}, 3,�1•,�� . _.
`: { "� � � � �r� � I�i�i� i=�i+� u��f� �':
�;..�
+�
"� k.» �
, � � �i��P' �" � ' �
. fy,�j•+?rr . _
� + y �.
. ���� �� � �
� � � b _ �.. �
� � " L �
-°� �-- � —�. �.
{ � ; 4a. � t�`� .' �
� _ — e#_ _
� 'E i ■ BP � �V� �V�
. -� _._..�_ -
;� �
,��'��ff i�e �"��
� __ � �-
— f�+�' � I C��
a` ��
�
{ ��
, ��If�1
�.� �`�
� , �,.w��...�
- `�. ..
� _•.,�
�,��;� . � ,�
* f /„
I ��YY��{,��1J1I �
„��._s 69��-.:��,.: �
I� .
6 �r�!�`�r��^� �€��
����V� ..o , ,���� �1
�� .� •`y�,yp--:�.�li , �,�•. -
�i ... . � � � �.'�` �+,r: -' 1
. i � .���W '�r'/ v4.;
� � �,��� �� � �
��
_ �-�.."�C.'�..,�'��� 4, .i' i
'S'y�,'. � N"�-� � y
-i
� � i t _ _
�.* �, �;. o +� �. �
�-;4 `� -+ � �Y
�
� � F *�� ,t � .
1f Y � t � C�rG� �"� �
-;� �� � �
� �_, .
�'ISt� " � '"� ;�
� , y. � ���,� ,
�� ,�;� i - ei� '. +� �
a
. � � .�„ � .,
�� �.,� _ �,,
�' ���.�'�
�,. ��� Gi ��' �7 ��"�� a; �'
���� �.;, 1., ��� � � ��F
��'�" .. �'
.� � � � .
�'��� �d-� � t�
� �'r ' � o�, �' ti
� � 9� y � i�d4 .
�P��r���m�a ,
� �° � � �. � r � � `_� � k
tK,� �
�—`��, ""�" r" �
� � � � �. � _ �������.
y�� _ s.� �f''
. � �"^ ,i
. .. .. r �. �. �.,;�.. .�
�' . *�,:.
��� � �'�
�'J'. � F�I. s'���
,.
� �
� ¢4 � �
� .1,,.. �e��, �:,�+�
1 = '1� - � � ti �
� ' �- �•l ''� k�� �C a' ��� �°,a
� � � �. ,, �,. ��..
�.• - + ,a�-J' '{�+• a
,. ,,� t �
' °��. .� '�,�� _ �� ,� ��
�;�. `�_ �r�.. t ; , � .
. � ,' O
g .j �� �
� .1.�, r ' -��. � I ,
�i �
et�'`r�. � � ! � � ,'A�� ,
� i � r F..
-�. #y
�� ,� � �� � 1 r.
����'t�� � '� � `� : � �
�' M - {''�' ="�e � : �,'� - �� '' * � ` � � .
� c�. _ , - �- - - :
� � r�
— `�' ' ,�. °� "
$t , s. ��
[v � �r :s I�� r�i.,*� - � Y-b.. a� i�'-��� . ..
a�F
� ��
�� .
�L��
�i
,�. ,� "� ±� � ,. ,r °° �
� � . � ��
,� ;-_ _ = � - -
�' 1�r?� TFF�LVJ�v
` ' _- . 7
1
�°' �",�" � _ . �'_ .� �
�- � -- � . '��^ -�
S�tle�� � - . _ .. � ,
�_�.� t �- }��
�,,,� . _ - 4�,,:� �'- ,r� �
�` E+`-, �,� . ° 3 ` ,�' ih � � �, �� ��
�� . � ^� � �
r �+ r , ; �,
�-� Restauran�� p��rk�r������ �
� � uKi- �_- � � .
_ _ 'i ti �^�,
f � � �9 _ _ — *�° _ � : �� �
�i � I ,
_ , Starage B.arn �J _ � :�
� '
r, , �. . _.�: �
�S �; ,� � � '� �
�- � � �.� *'� a I��� � �. . , � a
�- � _ _ *
� °. _ . ��
"� +�. R�_A ��dJLEw'AY�D
_ --
r�
° --° -
. . - _� .��_ '� � �,�
.. - - - ... '�r � � �rc�. �.;�; .
I _- _ _' .. ..
�� � j .. r i . ��_-..
I
:��'� 11�A��
.. �-
� " .� '' � � �
�''': . . _ ��• � � � "S� ' 1 {
_ ; ' •' ,� ,�_. - �•L + '����.�
. ~�� ;' ��"�!r..�,
.,�;, . .� - `. . ` • - � • :''
� � �� : �� t : �i � .,^. +
�� ,�' r� �^'� � , � �1 ' ,� "# � a
��. . ` k � , � � � � _ # �,� ��� � '
, • . .y��
�. � ���" u4 r + •'.' �M1 ' ,� �TPj'
� �q1�: , _ .. � � .1 e�b � , � :S . i �C _ _ +�'Rn' _
.'
.._ *'. ' � �' _ . 1 J 'f — � m �� _
�� ,s�,.�:?"� � .r ` '� a` � � ,��: � �y' k � •i i !. I �
�p �� V - �.v _ �
, �#'� � �� � , � � �,y � � �•; i �
� �
�
��
�
�
I F _ %� �,, �z R � �i � � � ,�„�,.
�, .. � : r" - - ��" . . _ � � - �" � r � } `
, .
;
s
' �p � ��h '� . . ' "` - � . � '� f ��
;.+�
� - . �". � � . . .,-, ' .. � � �' +� � 7 �,�
. , t .'
o:
:, r
� . • � -�"� ' 1�1� �9�� - � � V �= � `�` ,� - . � -�. .. .
� r, r � '� � I
� �� � ,f
4
��' _ ^�`�..
N
�' �
J 4 ..,+� .� '�L�i� .
_ . ii 4_ �� �, � � _ � —T — � �"� ' i ,� � �e � � �
No additional boat slips pr�p��
� .�+.�► �_ . ... ,� � — - � - �� , � —
�� L
� • • • ' •�:�
•lr':[•
,�. . - �w+ a , .
� � �
�
t t�� _ �'�
�
�+ '. , -ti _
_k
r_ �'
'li
�� �
�� � � ��., .
��' . � � . # �r .� � +�
— � — .� �,:�,�-
� -� -___ .�___ _e.��>-� _-�F
, . 3 �-
r � � . , --- — _
4 r`I z � . r
, �' �, .z.. i i
. v.,
�>. �c .-
s
s �' a r � ..
� . t. j
. - y . � � . �- - 1
�5 . s �
� �
� . . . � i , �� •
. - A
` ,u
� � _ .
� ,� J. � �� ,�F �, . :�I.� ,�:
, ° �'i`' �,r�� `�r-,� � � , ' a
, .
��� � �� 4 - � �� �
, f � � .� �
-. � ' - . ; ,
~ � � � : ,:
� . . ,. �
� '� ?�. ��� � •� ;� �` . �� �
�
. - ,
�- � � � , . , ��:�
: . ,
�
.. _ � � � � �
,� . ` `'' � � � a�!K! : �,
.:x, �, '' �.� " , , _ ' . " � ` ' _�:� �"� �- � '� � � , ' _
. - � ,
' � '.. � _" �� �j �' . „r ' . . �.. �IMr,M1igl � �b ��� �
,, �-, �.
.: � .:_ : .� _ �
«,�,� ,� i -, � . � ;�
, � � � �p
� , �+"_ � � �.�=
*� r _ � � � �. , � �. F '���#' � • .,� '`� t
�
_ t � � ; , � � I � � � . .
,_ . ,
J „ , = r
. �,� . . . �- � ., 'iW If ` 4
, , .r' � �� .ti $ �..
- �� . . � � ` f • �r R�'. _
- ,
. .
; - � �
a� ' 3 - 7�' - t _�.
_ �� A' �,,,i, - - - - +�y'.-�,{ i'i . � �+. Tf'
� '` ' ' �'�"', * � , `� � �X' — - - = - .,+�..��
�', Y4 . . . . .
u � ��
� � - =' b � - , "� �: _ "���
�
�;,�—. � . �� � � — , �
,r _ �� — � ...
� _ ' � �' �� ''� � � ° ,� �, � rt � �.,
.
. .
� t � � s � .� � � � � v � �
} ; � ° -- --- -- ,. � �. .. ,. ' w - -
d' r
� �� Additional Parking �
, i � . � • , ,. ,.. ,p,,,��,,,,.� _
'�'� 11I j �� . f� I•d � . i"', .. _ ,I
. .`, I 1' � „ " # � ��W� �'+ �� �� }
� �
,� n �.. _, � .. • . , ��. - I y ��. �
1 Y I � � � t " - , ' - �, � ��� f- , � �;� " I�„/"� � �F
. � r . . � – - • `
I ,.. � 1L Y ,#II,�,�
��� �>
�
1� I � _ �!
�-� � .. . ....
� , _
_ ry
� �,''"- _ �-��_� � � ' � . . _ y!
� ' . -' ..� �— �7' ��� . ,� – _ _ _
:i �v�� 1 ..� �'ar.idi5��.a..�.� a '• s- . . �
.
� �_ � �h�'
.
Y ' -' - - ��'-��•- ,�� 1�`' - - n �. �_�����.�,�-#
. . ,. �. �
�
�
.
..
.
. I�. � �!,� !
.. . _ , _ _ _ � . � ;._.� � - -�"_ °
.�
._ "-.� . - _ � - - rr.-� . - - --. � - - . �
� � .i ..... „_ -��.
. 6'I� , ri. �:_ - � � „
Pro�osed ParKinq Moditicatio
. . ,: -
■ ■
ar � n a���r
•Parking Ratio Required : 1 space/5 dry
slips plus 1 space/2 wet slips
•Parking Ratio Proposed : 1 space/6 dry
slips and 1 space/3 wet slips
•394 Dry slips Requires 79 spaces —
Proposed 66 spaces
•20 Wet slips Requires 10 spaces —
Proposed 7 spaces
■ ■
ar � n a���r
•Demand for parking historically lower
than required by code
•Longer, taller boats better suited for
ground storage
•Maintain 36' height limits
•Meets code on weekends
•Private cross parking agreements
•To minimize waiver we have added
spaces and are re-striping spaces
#.-
:��-��� �`�- ��
� � ,,���`
�
I
` _}� � �f
k::��� i
�4 t � ,
�;�-� - .
� �-�.� _��
��:� 7 �e�
�
_ �
� y � .
r�
� � ,:,'f �
S ' �
� � r
� � i
_ , � , �
'r�'�� ,
�� �° �
�;
. ��
r - _ _�.:-� ��--
, ����
_ �-.
k �- � � �
�.`�,�_ -
,�+. � �
�,
� � .- �r.� _ , i .
.4 � ��' 'ry ��� 'il�� �
. "��. �� �p F+ ye .. �' � � � �q
��� - �._ � � �
� � .�� -� � �s �
� � x �� - ..
�� � : �
, N. I . �. .,, � a 1 ,
� � � ' I
; �� a ' g � -�� -9i�. _ .�; �, �
• � , �,r�'' r - ,
i ;;r - ?t � �� r �
- � • � � � +:.—e � _ — - -
; �--�-� , dditional Open Space - ��
�y
� , I proved Landscaping ' - �'
��_ + � � ��
z
, - �
� � � �� ..� • �� � � _ �9
� , �� �
� I��
i;
� �, ,. � ��_ � � �
�t: �_ � � :� . ..,. �y �.� '�",r� �
�!
�} # � .
�° � � -°1F ' � � ' . .: ,�.
� �er ` ' -
- �
— � � $ . _ �I
� - s_ _ -�_ - � -�- _�-
�r' �r.. � �.� �. B�u�+��Rn
. . ,� -
,� ,���`�, � '
`:�`��. '��
r � �, �`
� ,� t,. ,;�x ���
- �;"` r ;�,u
. ��"� . -s. �„ � ti
. �,: � ���' ���'
� �r � � � �� � �`� I � �
�° `z �� r "`�: ��� R� �
� �
��'y`'y. ���.� �_.�
� #If�h...-....._ . . . ..,a... r, _.. �. � .
. -,� �- ,��
�. �' ��
�.
� �
i�.e�_
� R �� �—'t ' a�'s.�,* _
' n �`,�'�t� � :. � _ T _ � _— _ - _ � � "�-.
_ p � _ � a � �, _ _. '� ti _-�,�"''�
; � ��_ ��;, - � '—
�� �� _ ' �
� �� y °� �_
'�� �� � — ��
,e
I " _ � �. �,
�
. ,� . ,�,�,,�.��� .:�`,,,� � � . . . '
r,�: : i �,r-�j� ,, . , � I �' �
�- � � . � �- ��
_, '� .� ,� _ — � �r � � � �
�� �1'�'� _ �
_ _ _ , _ - -.� �
_ -. . �� -.`
s ".�_L�. � ��' �i. _ _ _
` ���•�� �� s �
_ - ,r4�:`. � ,-y�.:�� � -- - �s' ']pt- <, -. .
! " _. _�..� ! ! _ _" _I�.1._ ' . z . . -
�
�
-A�
5:�.
_ �
, „ � �,� `.'"R, �'
; w � � ,
� . ; �.
�� ���
� ����
#�r i �
��
�,� . -
�
� _!
�
� �! —�
� ����
.�� . �
�
�
�=
��� �° '��` e
�� � � � � �'��
+� `'�,� �;, *� ��;,
�I� ���„��t� • '�� .
� �
�. � .
�
� x� .: ..
MULCH AREA -� .- �"'�OOD POSTS WITH ROPE
. . �i 6.. ',� �� ��,.
� � / ��� �{�� :
s4 . '{�' '
.:�� � s � � �. � � �LT i � 3'�'' . ,,Y �.
�{�'` M-'4�� : � _a� � ���#l`f/ER ROCK
;._�',�t " -
�^
.;� �r� r �, ' �,l'��6r.. '�
}-� � �� ��"�� t�' �
''�� _ :� � . . .
as F:: �wf :
''� r
r ;
"' � �a .� � r,:. �_ .
„�: �}•''
_ t"�Ir���` ���; �Y �
��i � �, _ � t:. r�
Q �. 1 ; W i� '` ' �.
.�r14 R t .
J r
�' � , � � ��" "'r`
g�� {..r �l ;s°� 3 -
� �� �
� ly .l ' s
MULCH AREI�"�
.����.��rr.,
�
5' BENCH WITH
CONCRETE WALK
f ? r" ' / d � t' "
�
�� ,
y �
Yd p'•
fr �
I
1 - �
4�
'�1
a_� �i
i 4
�� , I
F . �
F �,
�
��
�_
;:�.$—
�
_ �
�r, ._s,..—"-:w-�-
I . � f 1 .' . . L
�� �
�-#`� _� � _ _ __ -
. � �� �� �� �'�` � �
I �.
` ' � . = � : . . �.�.. .. "�_�.": �. .� .. -
R ' . . .- . Y . . . - . '. , '_ . .... -
�
i __ _
.�
r � �'� � R �
T ,���` t` - ,� ' .���,, ,�,`�
_ . � ``� ... � � t �� � � �� ��
� � ♦, �
�. " � 1:..�lr _4� . 7i� y'J °F
�a .
.
� i�
� •W � �
..
�' ' '
.
�,_� .., . � . �.. . _
�_..— . _ . i .' . c .�
� n ' . � ' • : , - ,yi: . ' 4 + ', � v
S- �6..
�y .i e.' � �. .��,d '.
wy
� •� ' � �*` ��, - �' �<<. . i ,
~ ��� �
'_ a 1� ��i y ,. _ .r e .p ���� . .
�� PC�� .
F '�++L' _`,�'.; s , � t T �{ '
� �
.. ��F ,..� �
4 k
� . �
._ �
, � . . "*-....
��
�7� � i�]1 . '_�_ _ — '
��������� .AS � 4 � --- � _
� `� `` �. , '� ; �
.rt � I��
;w�� � �+�"� � { t"
`x. ����� t"rC.-'� �r
,' .��
�: `
►
s
�
.�
�; _- �!'�,,
. ,
�. � ���.
, �,�, �
�� � �
� �? �
, � � �'' . �' ��'ti
' � � ,�
�t,�
�` �. ,�•
i L
';'` fi . +�.
�i ■
� � � � - �,
— � � ,iw.
4 � �- a � � ' ,
-,# �� ��� �
�� �,
- � ,_-� - � � � �,
�
�� � . � � � ��- M„�.�:•�:�
�- � ,� ,� t _ r . �t �_
�a �
�
#
��������
� =-� � � �--..�
�
� - ��
��
�
s s- �
� �. , .
�
.����.��rr.,
��� �
� „��- - . � ,.�
�° � ..
.af��
.r'._ . ! � � +�
��
�
�
;�
��
�
= o .�.,��_�- �...
�; - ,�. � � �
� �- - -
� �'�� � �
` �- - . � _ � '� �
.. � _ _
�, � - - �� - � � � y.,..� � � _ ,
�'' �
� T ��� � ��
_ ,. . >. . . � _ . . .��`' ,�� T - # �. � � � � _ �,
�����'��?n ��.�.�.�_ �� ��..�a�, — ` iil+yr
-- � -� �,���� .
a � �� �
�. . - -
�, .
� ���' r .P ���
�
�
�
� �
�; �
_ �.
� � �� ..
�
� �
�� � -�
�� , �
��
a _�
�� � �
.. -
1
� Y �.
"�
: . ,- - ��-s _, �°� �
4` �
x'�►--`.s�1:'l.4'�` � a
� . � r .. . ! � { . . . . � . . . . ..
/�
■ ■ ■ �
ar�na o � �ca �ons
•Efficient use of parking and storage
areas for existing large boats
•Improved access and signage for boaters
•Bringing site into compliance
•Increased Open Space, improved
landscaping and esthetic appearance
•Agree to the Conditions of Approval
• Staff Recommends Approval
i �
��� ���I� �
+ �r
II �
/ �/
( �� r
Planned Unit Development Amendment
, �+�. _ , . , , 1� � . ' �... . � _
_.r'�•�� � '' "MF��'
� ",�+ '� ��
�.-.
� � �
� � -
� �_ �. �
� � �
� � � ,��-A �
�
� , p
���
r
�` ?'-. F
� • �f_` � � �
'-�'�` `ti �
� '� � `� `} '--
�i�► �. �
_ �° �� � ���_� ��L "���C�SCap�� - .� . �
�
�
�
� �'��
����� !I
I�
�� i� �.���_
� �� _ � ���- �.� z
. y ,� �
� ` �� !;�- - � � .
�
��� Lro
� � ��,,�- - - :
1 � � - � i r-�� � .� �".�.i
��� � � �' • _ �'��
_ � � .�:� _ �
--_ .� _ __ .
--� _ �� � •
�. . .
,r �'.:" ��`:�
.���- �
'� ` °. T_�-° �
�._.,,�. - �
. - , - �`� � Y _�I
�:�� Fr�. � �
� . �
: •
-- � i
.�_
•
L4GATION IV1AP zo^,^� = R��P�o
LUP = RH
� ��
� ' � � �� fa'�'., -�ore. a � emw�eam
i �� I . �_, o:�� unerc�,is ,ao�ad.
s � r� �1� �• � OROP65E6 SiONnGF RACrcS
' Sf�FAt'R�GK51 J�s'.�
�su ' �I� �` � �j�l E ,mAFMa� o��,E � ` 1\ �;�
li - . , -a� � � i 1'i � � �
a�' � a
� ,�� „ � � � .�
� ` ''
�
Zoning-c�t � E
LUP-C i._.. xariu'u'°'w,*, �r� m
y��.r�sar' . w�-� �
6 £ � n�µ�.
' ' WATER4'dAY
soveR��Ha�aouR
/' � ✓ � ;, � � '-� f+ r� . uU. . r:��
��
(/ '/`'���,� � � � �� ti.:j�� � ' � •
\ �q�i . l... � .� � _.l.�,•
z,3, �� � ����. ��P . P f E +� R',`�°
W ,„ � � r C .�.,, 0. �I ' --° `� � -. �
- - ,se
� ,.�,� � � �s:
T� �r�4��vi ai.v 3� l� I
��
_,���,s�' ''
-N
�`�
�` za��na = ao
�.�.n,.�� �.. rvo�sE �_ LIJP=G
/ },
R9VERHpUSE / '
RE�TAURANT / -
, �✓ {r� i
� I. - � ��_� ��— '� - - �, �a�Ea ��, �
i � - oa,�. -;.,. �° ..� .. � a
`��� ° � � � s s�� .,E,w , _ .K� �1 � �� ��� � . �..ti.. ..�, �' �� ���.�x �
s,
— i
_ ,�� K " � — � -- _� �' �,
� � � � ��.., � , .�,- , �
_
,` ; , � �
��I � ' — — __ — ;, I �
za��ne - cci � � � . �. .. . . ....' E _ . � � : i��% - .. �Ne _ �� _ - _ � � �
a
�
LUP=C r �• .. � I '� �w
I �E % � � �
_���`�� � I$
� �II Ir� u -.._� ...��.�r..... _ .GeCAa -,. ' : L , RL�2oWE1+rIM1G ..-u_ .<��x� — ��� .
J� _
I,� ��---' - Llu .E��. .. �TII i - �t� � .� ., ,. - _ _.- . _
� g . �, .��� i �
' I .;_. .... ,.u�a, nr.:..,,< .. I . � . vu �i� �� - 1
� � , �.�. E _ —_ _`� �`�' �E `��_ ��_��
�,.�,� � � � --. --_ -- _ . - - � - . ,e, �
_ � _ L _. _ .-- �- _ _ . .. � � �g.. �,. �� ��" ~ e
�a�0� ��`.� ._` -- - -- -- �� - _�� � -.. - � .. _ _. �. .. . .
-��-„m�n�u�rr��__._ � _,- �_ . ._ - . . . � ..
..-. �� �' . .
�� " P.Lj.A. B'OULEVAR❑ �" A�OITInNAL OPEN SPACE REql11REO �
. '.A iE ,..... . - � .•.• . - •* ww""' FOR 9` WIDE PARKING W1rIVF0.
- —I _ - _ ° - — -- — = 3�,SF o ,P
_ _ _ ,
- ss ncesa �� s.
� ,. .-n-. .�� �-. —. _ _.. _._ __ — `., aaeH' nce
� � �
� - —'— � TYPE�CURB�ETAIL \. ..—_.. .'— �8.5 as — -..�.
SItE D2[2 - � � �: .. a. e . y. .�. � ee � re+a '�'. -� ?�Pny� CGt . ��i.r, ieais
�- .--. �I�.�� ���� �«��a.aa s.s���.,.��.,�crn.a . woron�uaaEnsPncEaaovroEO=�o.�ssr.
. ..' _ ,,._ . . x« � �,�.,
. ,.m.-�,,.�� I " _
,-`�`� �. ... - "._.: I
L-�' "'� . PARKINGSPACEUETA.ILS
- r � i
.m~ 're '�' . � ? OEVELOPMEN YTEpM = ' n1I`I - ..�� I `-"
�� � .� _
... ' .. ..�.._ ' �..._ �
„<�, . A< . . .. .. ... . TY➢eFC�rOQetei� H tice4�RamP ..+-4r... � el � ,��. -Yy --- I
� a,�a e,� a �,� a....�..�_,�. �.�o.P�.,���F_. :=�.� 4�.�.�,
� � • • ,' ���I_.�� � �.
, . � �-
urb�an
�SIC,�. fl
ki I aay
STllOkOS
V b PI 1 98D 19n
C ' L,t?tu1P„ �
—
—
Q�
�
� O
�.L
Lf �
a=
�
�
� �
L �
U
fT5
4/ m � �
� a �
� W �.
� Li in i
�
� /
NORTH
[ ���
Scale 1'=80'�0"
SP- '[
of 1
� �E9 TA ., � t"^,Y �� ' � .,�. .,.� '� , '� � y�,��• J�e : Y i..s, �,.y� �� -.� 'f.�Y
� v � � °- � -,r' � P �;Si+� : � . :�T e� � M � .a... .� _
. , �
� t , i
.^ , . m . . �P ' B , . m . �o �y - �°• ti � �, si.n F� _'!y� p ��. ' :� �q'° � ��4�'+ � ,' ^i'F
La . �y �, . . ■ � .. �� �, e , � _. � -. �' � � � ' � i4 ..,a. �� �M y� � r _
. .a `� y�
,m tl T
��.�� ..�1'E��° �. , . . � - v,_�r �� ..::J � j N�_ � "�7�YI�A�.. _ � . � � �!��
. .� y . - �,�d� � `. - �. . - . . , �o't. � f ; �.
°�" , ,. � . „�'. w , �.7�� � '�y�,� � � ' � �r.i..r � °..r� ° �aS,� � � � ' � -
�.�, �, � c �� r w� -� � y`y i i !' �., �
. — i � � °*� �� �- I�FA� �i�`f��, �� .v�'Y� � � �
_ _. �
IM. .1 .. ' 9 � . � ,� . ' � � �
'�.. _ '�.a e . `^.,.�i � f�,t .� ���•� `�� -� � � � 1
I rv . r a.
'�' > ,. . . . . .
^ �' e � L!''1� � � �r� �� � � �� �� � .�.�
< .. . , `}� . , � . . . �` . ' . � . _ � �: `
,. � N .. . �i!' . .,,,�" �� �v ` . v ir� , . �� �� ������� •.k
E r - �� , { � .c �q ,
. � � �. � � � �.
� . �.;, . , ��.� K . .. Fti,r `�i , � .�'_�,. .. ,.,�s-- e . . .. .' .� �,•
s... , �. . , . � I� e,
� . � I4� �_ � . „ �,..
� � 9 .� . � � .�. ��� . ^,r,� �r�1'� i,� ,� b:' , s . •a , � ��•��
. - - ... �.y r -,* �1 ,¢ � • -� n `' � ` �� - � �i � • � ��x
� _ ,.:. .�LA ;o '. ... ,� � � � �_�. � �'r'�� . - '���:� .�6 ��' • ; .� ,'�� r.
� , •
. - •
�}
� -� . `� _ • • .-_ "h ` '' - � " ° � - � • - ' � . . � s { � i -
a ��• ��'�6'� s`� � fPf . � " ..9 � �y �• ' � � � $� y�
� 9 ' � � ". .Y'• �� �� �v _',��■ ��I �..fy�$� � .iu._..' ,..,—�s,� ��4 '� .. a � r ��.. ��� �.
s a
� F , � or r4 ,a� � e . � X � "a, k —�'�� yy, � ` _ . • � a , r At � ��5y� . � L� � � � I , a ��
:. 3 �F e �� �a.a..�'� . � y ��. � � � p e • � 4 rr ��� •: � ,' � � � �I e � i� J � '� . �"a � � y : u �
Y T ! ■ ".
�� , � �. � . � . � .. . � ` � _ � .. - � � w y . , - � � .���M � o . . 4�
� � � .� ..' .^_ . � -� __ � �. .. _o • ��� , n ' i. � , 's .�� �.����� � a � 'E '.. �' ,. �
� i i
� � s :
, ^ _.� � �.� �-
�
� ,p�. � . . -, �'� . �.�. .4 • j � .��.,: , �I�'�� r T � 0`�� 9 ..,..' .
d _
� �'
.. °
a, , . -� � =`�r �; °` -' �T �' � � .. , ' ° � • "r�. ..y�. f" Ih j `�q•.� '�r-
a ,
- .� a� __� _�.:� ,,,7�����#'�'� 'i�� Ly �,.��nn, •F`.- 4 s ..�• -=re���,+�n •a� _
,ti � - � � {� , - . ' � � � �a � ,�.
, � I.�:. � i � : e ��: � ��+- .� � -�" =rr � �r ' 1°� �I.�-�
�, _ . . . F . ,
m .
. m . ,� ■
.. a�- . �� 1,;' - .. � �.. _ � ,p• s � ��- r� , f �.
� � F � - � .e ti A � .
� A � . ti
���' ti d': °'• , .'
� .� � .:, � ' - .i�a .-• � .� _.�
�' Q �
�
" � �
r �. �
� � u y
. t � � � — . �E. �° '' °-'-., � s ~4, � � .—R� `. ., �
, , ,. . _
" �-. � 'r`�'I�, �- � � c' —, 4 a _ ' p1 ' �� �_-��!� � �
� i � . �, .
`�.� a � y, ..r � ��E F•�� a.� . e� .r •�'. �,a. r •f'+ �R'F.tiy° e "�- � �
.
- _
. ��. � � ��- ����
�' .�i . m � � o f� r" ..u�r.^. � r � ,
, � , � ti!." `� a
� �' J _ �� �!�E .� _ �`� � .'�� . _ ."�` e � -� �
� . - y � � . v •. `,.,y'i .
. � �� - r � � � .
. � � , -"
, u � Y � y � � � e �� ' �'� �
�
F' � � ,� � �i , � � -^ �� �4 � �$� .,�j��.� � �e � : a �`� .',�Cr .. s- '�� �
� �
�r � �• °vb �,� 1+ _ , r�� A�d+ °
�. � �:. • ' � • .'. �' •-��i
.-� . �: ,� � � �,� �- {, � — • �
sc� p ^t�� �� �� - '7��`��"�� .. � • ��I �, , � � � � E:�. �
. , �
t` A} : '�.T� ,� �. �M � . �� '�� i317° �'
�
1 i�� • - � ;. ' � _
a` . � ,� � � • , �
� ; e e • m
i • ��
o- ... .
l � � ' - �� � 4 �. �
� ,� J��
. - .�.�a- s�
■ �' � . '° . r��. . � ._ . � ' � - � • � ' ,� 4.' �" �
, � �. �.
� �. ,J� .L���, .. s a .�.. � r� � � �.,�. .. . ' '
� `- ! . .�_ - — ^���"..� .—
� � ��� ��� � � � y , �.
, . � �-
�
■
roose �n oe
men men s
LDRA-10-03-000029 Ord. 21 2010
,
Planning and Zoning Department
August 10, 2010
�
�
ac roun a es
• Direction from Council to revisit sign regulations
• At the July 20t" PZAB meeting, a postponement was
requested to allow:
— PZAB members to meet individually with staff
— Staff to meet with the business community
• Staff inet individually with most PZAB members
• Staff inet with business community on August 3rd
!/�L, r
;y; .
�
�
■ ■
�nor c an es s�nce as
• Rooftop addressing clarified.
•"Traffic control" changed to "traffic regulation" sign in prohibited list.
• Electronic messages/movement prohibited "unless otherwise permitted
in Sec. 78-285."
� Prohibition of internal merchandise display eliminated.
• Restriction of signs within 100 feet of residential property removed.
� Removed illuminated window sign from permitted sign table; it is
specified in Sec. 78-286.
• Vehicles with advertising allowed at commercial properties where
vehicle owner is legal tenant. Vehicle must be registered, licensed, and
operational.
�
Chan es to Ground Si ns Revisions
g g
1�:. � ,,.,��,.,,.
.� _,
: ��_.
� _ �
�
� ��
���
�,
' f ��r r
� ;,�...� ���,
� ��� _
. .4Y.� _ � . f"
:�
`�
.�. .
� -.
:�
•Total copy area
re�nains 60 square feet
•Up to 5 tenant names
allowed
. . .. . -
-�... L-J... t�l-1i-
•Minimum � 6" letter
height
•Leasing information
and addresses allowed
on base
an es o
00 � ns
�� _
�:., .
�_ .�� .
�
,.._�, �
• Only allowed for existin , one-story buildings with
hip or mansard roofs
• No cabinet siqns
• Must be individual letters
• Supports shall be painted to match roof color
• Only for Principal tenants or tenants with over
5,000 gross leasable square footage
�
Chan es to 2nd Floor Office Tenant Si na e
g g g
•Only in Professional
Office zoning
•Only allowed for second
story tenants of two-story
buildings whose tenants
have a primary building
entrance facing a major
arterial or collector road
and access not through a
central lobby.
Proposed tenant
signs
� ��,��� a� �.� f� £ � . .� .. .. ,
� � " , f �-��
' 'i'.
ry
', �
, �� �
�°; - ;�' :�
.} ;
� -� ���� _� , yi �
�.�{', � . : �� � � •. F � .:!�
R�
����J���
�
;� p,.,�.'i`��,��,,',�:�
��
• ' ��y.�� � • • �
- �, ��?
��. ,���
1�.U� i 2� �� �.'!�b 1jr'y�A a' .
�� ����+ f � ..
+ ti
{ d W
s4y°�,� �4>4:t�yr �r '
' �`,
�'�' " a
�
�: _ � _ ,, �__ -
. , �
_ ,�
- � _�:
-
�_ � �
_ � �
^ _ �� - "_. ' ,
� ,-r- ° e
� � I
, l i � �_� ��
I i II +l �I � � i
,-��' � 1.'h���� �� �� _I I I I I I � � ..�- ITT 8� 5MAIL�Y �-�`'°
� � ����I�� �.1 Nf,�
�+ FII1t4 ?•'k �y �,fi'�'! �6�QU�Qf • . �
. . , �j.f.'�"! I�.R�'��� (4.�8a,P���`��
�' , '
�.
�
_, I y ,
• '-
'. � _ _
— Y
� I I %� �.1� �� .
i �
i y 'q � �
�`- �y
�'' _ -
R ° — J'-�-
•
�� '��k,� �
- - . �,. _ -�,�
. . , ? i A f t�,�
:�^�► _
�
.•-
� �� � l ♦ .. . .
�r ,:1��.._ �{ �,,.d.:"�;��.rl..�' a.��''''?5��
fPi
,- �
�
� � � �--
�� �
k ts, .
vy�.'� �� � � a
�
� , y.: ,
` �
�
'�rl"� �
� �•----•.
��.e�-, - •. .. �i2'�_���
. - '-,�,-"`-- -.t_ . .. ..
!/�L, r
;y; .
�
Pro osed chan es to 2nd Floor O ic
p g
Tenant Si na e
g g
• Second floor office tenant
signage
— Allow for second floor
tenants with main entrances
facing parking areas
— Allow for professional &
medical office uses in any
zoning district where
allowed.
�
�
■ ■ -��
ues �ons u r er �scuss�o
Thank you!
�
■
x ra � es
�
■ ■
erm i e i ns men men s
• Increase number of residential entry feature signs
• Increase number of tenants on ground signs
• Simplify maximum size of wall signs*
• Allow additional signage adjacent to I-95/Turnpike
• Simplify window signs
(continued)
�
■ ■
erm i e i ns men men s��on�t.�
• AI low roof sig ns for one story bu i Id i ngs w/ mansard
o r h i p roofs
• Simplify internal neon and LED signs*
• Allow increase in number of directional signs
• Allow rear wall signs for retail or mixed uses
• Allow 2nd floor tenant signs for office uses
• Allow changeable copy/digital display ground signs
for Public/Institutional uses*
���,���a��.�f� £ � . .. . .._y��
� �} t � �
' 'i'. f
r I F,
M
5 j' �� �
�.:} - �I �, � J
Q[ g�j.`�.�G _ _� `��� �.� � � •: .F � � . �
IRYM "'�. . .
\ � �
����J���
. �:
•i i� �
.4aa. , i�� l
! 6 !
��k� �� .� �� ��� i ��'P� 4.i�1 i ..
�
� .,;;,
�4 - y
�. : �.
� = �: � ` �`
,�.. _ �',. ,,,�"
��CA� _ �� .. ��� 4..
�/'��° � �'
'. � � Y �" � ' �i ::",�� `.. pi. �'�� ,�,,.
_ � � � 't + r
� , -� ���`rt�a
�� .'�t<��>i��� � g ;�,;*�.��� i
�:±i�_ _ - - �
�;
�s YYp �r
�� ...1 .r7i
,M� *'µ` 4 �J� o.x.
,� r a. � � '� � . i
� � �� � � � � �i�a .
x j� � .i��ti. �ry i (�T;�r'
� �Rri Y ��iFb y /� _
,+'�y�� �'�+ �. :�:f *w'F. '��A-
f lc . y
' ;a��d�4a4. ¢� ��
i � 1 �
��_ � ������
'����
��
k`
�
�� ���;� ; .
- — ' - �
�y�
Residential Entranceway Signs
Double-sided sign in
entrance median
# of Tenants on Ground Signs
•Total copy area
remains 60 square feet
•Up to 5 tenant names
allowed
•Uniform color
•Minimum 8” letter
height
•Leasing information
allowed on base
Ground Signs
3’
15’ max.
SIGN COPY AREA
60 square feet
maximum
10’ max.
Leasing info.
Visibility of signs from I-95 or Turnpike
•Currently: Only 1 wall sign allowed by Code
•Proposed: Allow an additional wall sign for buildings
adjacent to I-95 or Turnpike
–Valuable visibility
–Less waiver requests
Window signs
•Currently:
–15% of window can be covered by goods & services
–5% of window can be covered by name, hours, etc.
•Proposed: Simplify to 20% coverage for total copy
•Not more than 50% of a single window may be
covered.
Roof Signs
•Currently prohibited
•New signs would need to be through waivers
•Certain facades have limited sign location options
•Only for hip or mansard roofs
•Limit to one-story buildings
•Only for Principal tenants or tenants with over
5,000 gross leasable square footage
Roof Signs
Building Directional Signs
•Currently:Limited to 1 per building
•Proposed: Allowing 1 per building or 1 per 10,000
building square footage
Signs on rear elevation
Sign fronting major
roadway
Sign on rear elevation
(customer entrance)
Signs on rear elevation
Sign fronting major
roadway
Sign on rear elevation
(customer entrance)
Wall Signs for 2nd Floor Office Tenants
Existing ground floor
tenant sign
Proposed 2nd floor
tenant sign
Wall Signs for 2nd Floor Office Tenants
Existing ground floor
tenant sign
Proposed 2nd floor
tenant sign Existing principal
tenant sign
LDRA-10-04-000031
SPECIAL EVENTS, OUTDOOR
SEATING & TEMPORARY SIGNAGE
CODE AMENDMENTS
Planning Zoning and Appeals Board August 10, 2010
Background and Updates
At the July 20, 2010 PZAB postponed LDRA-10-04-
000031 to August 10, 2010.
Staff has made minor changes based on discussions
from the PZAB members
Staff has met with most of the PZAB Commissioners
individually
Staff has met with the Chamber and PGA Corridor
Association
Minor Changes since July 20, 2010
Section 78-290 TEMPORARY SIGNS ALLOWED
School/Day Care/Nursery –maximum number of 3 per calendar year and 14 days after
registration
Monument leasing signage
Added additional criteria for colors and consistency
Minimum 5 inches letter size for leasing information
Number-added criteria for private right-of-way signage
Section 78-187 SPECIAL EVENTS
Added a definition of “live entertainment” to the Definitions section
Included a possible bond for right-of-way banners
Added information about co-sponsorship with the City
Section 78-191 OUTDOOR SEATING
Live entertainment is prohibited after 10 p.m. if within 300 feet of a residential property
Ambient music may be permitted through speakers for outdoor patrons provided the noise
level is consistent with Section 78-661. Noise. and Section 34-56 in Article III Noise.
Added number of chairs permitted for the de minimus standard
Outdoor Seating (Section 78-191)
Removing the six foot requirement for walkways
As long as the walkways meet pedestrian accessibility
and building codes
Staff is creating a separate code section for a live
entertainment permit.
Background on Noise
The City Council has received resident complaints at
City Council meetings
Staff has researched with Code Enforcement the
complaints on noise related to commercial
properties in the evenings.
Majority of the calls show there was not a noise
violation,
In some instances the business complied with the noise
standards, and
In a few cases the repeated violations were brought
before the special magistrate.
Noise Study
May 26 –31, 2010, staff conducted a noise study
directed at PGA Boulevard corridor.
The study was taken at various times throughout the
days, including every evening from 8:00pm to
11:30pm.
There were no outdoor bands, no live radio
broadcasts, and no special events taking place.
Summary of the report showed that all businesses
met the closing hour requirements and the noise
decibel criteria.
Noise Research
Staff looked further into the complaints for the
noise.
The police reports from special magistrate hearings
indicate it was the presence of the live
entertainment that created the loud noise –not the
presence of outdoor seating.
The higher the volume from the speakers, the louder
the patrons have to talk –creating more noise.
Live entertainment permit
Staff is developing criteria for a live entertainment permit.
The commercial tenant would apply for the permit if they want
indoor/outdoor live entertainment or outdoor speakers.
A cash bond and application fee would be required.
The violations would go against the commercial tenant.
After a certain number of violations the permit would be
revoked.
Live entertainment would be prohibited at a certain time if the
commercial tenant is within 300 feet of a residential property
or the commercial tenant could submit a sound management
plan.
Recommendation
Staff recommends approval of
LDRA-10-04-000031/Ordinance 19, 2010
Background
Business Community (NPBC Chamber and PGA Corridor
Association)
November 19, 2008 –Chamber meeting with President and Association and staff
January13, 2009 –Staff met with Association on code sections and information
February 9, 2009 –Staff had follow up meeting with Association
March 13, 2009 –Staff met with Chamber Government Affairs Committee meeting
April 3, 2009 –Chambers met to discuss information
May 20, 2009 –Staff met with Association to discuss proposed changes
August 3, 2010 –Staff met with Association and Chamber to discuss further changes
Residents
Public Notice -Announcements, posters, ads, flyers, website
November 19, 2009 –Public workshop for citizen input
December 3, 2009 –Public workshop for citizen input
9 residents -total both meetings
City Council
June 6, 2009-Staff presented business community recommendations to Council
April 15, 2010-Staff presented recommendations based on input from business
community and residents
Special Events (Section 78-187)
Administrative changes
Requirements for outdoor music or live entertainment –
sound management plan
Specifying the use of vendors
Increasing the number of events
Three to four events every calendar year
For commercial/office plazas with 10 tenants or less from
five to eight events per year
For commercial/office plazas with 11 or more tenants from
ten to twelve events per calendar year
Special Events (Section 78-187)
Signage:
One on-site sign per 50’ linear feet, for a maximum of
three signs;
Adding regulations regarding the traffic control
signage as on-site signage;
Removing off-site signage;
Creating criteria for right-of-way banners; and
Creating criteria for traffic-control signage.
Temporary Signs (Section 78-290)
Decreasing the setback requirements to 8 feet versus
15 feet from the public right-of-way
Creating a yearly permit for rental, lease and sale of
non-residential buildings
Creating standards for consistency
Allowing the possibility of leasing information to be
placed on the projects monument sign
Creating an event signage criteria for special
occasions that are not defined as a special event
Definitions (Section 78-751)
Special Events
Regional event
National event
Outdoor bar
Sign, Event Signage
Sign, Right-of-way banner
Live Entertainment
Development
Development, as it pertains to art
Certificate of Completion
Certificate of Occupancy (Land Development)
Certificate of Completion (Infrastructure permit)
Outdoor Seating (Section 78-191)
Requirements to the application
Criteria for exemptions from outdoor seating review
Casual seating without service
De Minimus Standard –maximum 2 tables (8 seats) or no
more than100 sq. feet (whichever is less)
Amending the fencing and screening to be more flexible
Requiring City Council approval for outdoor bars that are
visible from the public right-of-way
Creating a criteria for the type of furniture to be used as
outdoor seating
Changing the hours of operation to Sunday through
Wednesday 7:00am to 10:30pm and Thursday through
Saturday 7:00am to 11:30pm.
Outdoor Seating (Section 78-191)
All live entertainment is prohibited beginning at 10:00 p.m. on
any night of the week if outdoor seating is located within 300
feet of a residential property, unless permitted specifically by
a special event.
Ambient music through speakers may be permitted for outdoor
patrons provided the noise level is consistent with all
applicable performance codes such as Section 78-661. Noise
and Article III. Noise.
300 Foot Radius-PGA Boulevard
300 Foot Radius –Legacy Place
300 Foot Radius-Intracoastal Area
300 Foot Radius-Midtown
300 Foot Radius –
Northlake Commons/Gander Mountain
300 Foot Radius –Downtown at the
Gardens
300 Foot Radius-Donald Ross
Village
300 Foot Radius-Gardens Square
Shoppes
300 Foot Radius –PGA Commons
East
300 Foot Radius –PGA Commons
Central
300 Foot Radius-PGA Commons
West
City of Palm Beach Gardens
Calvary Chapel Church
CUMJ-10-07-000017
Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board
August 10, 2010
Subject Request
Approve a major conditional use for Calvary Chapel Church to
locate in the Palm Beach Gardens High School on Sunday
mornings. No physical site or building changes are proposed to
accommodate the church use.
•Resolution 28,2007 –Approved the major conditional use
and site plan for the Palm Beach Gardens High School
•Future Land Use –Public (P)
•Zoning –PUD/Public or Institutional (P/I)
Background
Location
I-95
Burns Road
Lilac Street
Holly Drive
Mi
l
i
t
a
r
y
T
r
a
i
l
Major Conditional Use
•Proposed use meets all of the Major Conditional use criteria listed in
Section 78-52
•The church will only be operating on during non-school hours
•1 service per week on Sunday mornings
•850 seats in auditorium
•Church use requires 283 parking spaces 731 spaces on site
•Church will be hiring police officers to assist in traffic monitoring
Traffic Circulation Plan
Mi
l
i
t
a
r
y
T
r
a
i
l
Lilac Street
Holly Drive
Sign Location Map
Recommendation
Staff recommends approval of petition
CUMJ-10-07-000017
City of Palm Beach Gardens
PGA Marina PUD
MISC-10-07-000073
Planning, Zoning, and Appeals Board
August 10, 2010
Subject Request
Approve modifications to the existing site plan, landscape plan,
and a waiver for required parking. No additional boats are
proposed.
•Ordinance 31,1997 –Approved the PGA Marina PUD to
allow 264 dry storage slips,20 wet storage slips,outdoor
sales,and various associated buildings
•2006 Administrative Amendment increased number of dry
storage slips to 394
•Future Land Use –Commercial (C)
•Zoning –PUD/General Commercial (CG1)
Background
Location
Proposed Site Modifications
•Add 3 new boat storage areas
•Reduce parking stall widths of existing spaces
•Increase open space areas on site 18.4%open space
(15%required)
•Improve overall operations of the marina
o Pavement markings and one directional sign directing
patrons to parking areas
•Waiver to provide 16 spaces less than required
Waiver Request
•Number of boat launches is below the parking ratio required by City
Code
•Marina lacks amenities favorable to live-aboard boaters
o Showers
o Washer/dryers
o Restaurant,and other recreational amenities
•Large amount of boats in long term storage
Code Ratio Proposed Ratio
1sp /2 wet slips 1 sp /3 wet slips
1sp /5 dry slips 1 sp /6 dry slips
Recommendation
Staff recommends approval of petition
MISC-10-07-000073
Gerald F. Richman ' -,
Alan G. Greer I ',
John M. Brumbaum .
Bruce A. Christensen ?
ChaneSH. Johnson
Diane Wagner Katle0
Manuel A. Garcia-tinares ~
Ma* A. Romance
John G. White. Ill
Lyle E. Shapim
MlChael J. Napoleone
maid P mnm J,.
John R. Whntles
Enc M. Sodhi
teem 8. Fretre
Mam M. Myron
Eman J. Wall
Joshua L. Spwnt
Yolyvee Y Rivera
Grashrd W. Smith
Steven Nacleno. Of Counsel
Manuel Farach. MCounsei :
Gary s. getenshy ~:
RobenL.Floyd Il"lh il'C
Kenneth J. Well , Ig.::, :iOll,
R~Y H. %awn 1922 ars~:
REPLY TO:
West Palm Beach Ofke
August IO, 2010
Planning and Zoning Board
City of Palm Beach Gardens
10500 N. Military Trail
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Subject: PGA Commons
Dear Board Members:
On behalf of our client the PGA Commons, we wish to elaborate on the
memorandum that has been submitted to your attention and for your
consideration which highlights a number of critical issues regarding the recently
proposed amendments to the city's land development regulations (LDR's) and
in particular, the issues regarding section 78-1 91, "outdoor seating"
As expressed in the memorandum, the PGA Commons as well as numerous
other similarly situated businesses in Palm Beach Gardens will be severely and
negatively impacted if the proposed amendments were to be adopted without
significant revision that fairly addresses the important issues involved such as
whether there is any justification for any significant change much less, the
traumatic and potentially damaging impact of the proposals relating to outdoor
seating. Other issues involved relate to the inequitable impact upon the business
climate of the city, the social impact, as well as questions of vested rights and
due process where the proposed amendments can be interpreted to permit
drastic action far out of proportion to any concerns involved.
The PGA Commons and other business interests wish to work with the city in
addressing any legitimate issues involving outdated performance standards and
similar issues while seeking to have the city employ a careful, reasoned, and
justifiable approach with regard to the businesses operating within the city that
employ outdoor seating.
MIAMI OFFICE Miami Center. Suile 1000
201 South B8rca)ne Boulevard . Mlaml. nonda 33131
305.373.4C.X . Emward 954 523.4297 . Far 305.373 4099
E-Ma,,: ,"fc@r,chmangreer.com W*NI r#thmangreer.Com
WEST FUN BEACH OFFICE One Clearlake Centre Suile 1504
250 Aurtralian Avenue, Sauth . West Palm Beach. Flonda 33401
561.803.3500 . Fax 561.820 1608
, Planning and Zoning Board
August 10,2010
Page 2
We look forward to working with the city to achieve an equitable and legitimate set of standards.
Sincerely yours, L.9dfL Gerald F. Richman --’---
GFWdvc
cc: Mayor David J. Levy
City Council Members
Ron Ferris, City Manager
R. Max Lohman, City Attorney
RICHMAN GREER. P.A
YWn. Wnt Pam BUSh
From: Ed Chase and loey
To: Palm Beach Gardens Ci Council; Palm Beach Gardens City Manager, Palm
Beach Gardens Ci Attorney, Palm Beach Gardens Growth Management
Department, Palm Beach Gardens Planning and Zoning Board, North Palm
Beach County Chamber of Commerce, PGA Corrldor Association.
Date: 8/10/10
Re: Proposed Changes to LDR's regarding Signs, Temporary Signs, Special
Events and Outdoor Dining.
The members of the North Palm Beach County Chamber of Commerce 1 PGA
Corridor Association Joint Task Force appreciate the staffs willingness to meet with
us on August 3d in order to have a dialogue on some issues in the proposed OR's
that are of importance to the business community. We came away from the
meeting feeling that we had gone a long way toward finding common ground on
some Important items and, although we believe that some fine tuning is stili in
order, based on the frank and positive discussion we had, we are confident most of
It can be worked out as the process proceeds.
Probably the most important item on which we felt we had a meeting of the minds
is that outdoor seating, in and of itself, is an popular asset for the Cii; whereas
sound, and its affect on residential neighbors, is the real issue. We stand ready and
willing to work with the City to help develop an logical, scientifically based,
enforceable process containing the proper "teethc so as to make the control of
sound reasonable and enforceable.
The Ci's Performance Code was written about 25 years ago when you could
'barely hear a pin drop" in the Ci. As polnted out in the City's June 7th Code
Compliance Noise Study, of the 22 evening sound readings taken by staff between
May 26m and 31' along PGA Boulevard, 12 were listed as traffic, 2 were listed as
traffic and low music, 2 were a/c units, 3 were listed as "nla" and 3 were "quiet."
The Performance Code does not reflect many current conditions and it must be
thoroughly and scientifically restudied before businesses are threatened with heavy
fir& and severe sanctions. We do not endorse a "rush to judgment" on this issue.
The current ordinance should suffice until a proper update is done. There are many
qualified acoustical engineers in South Florida who have done similar studies for
other cities, and we believe you should pick the most qualified firm for the task.
Outdoordining6lOlOa
1
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Request to Address City Council
Please Print
OWE- SUKE \u wrt- fq, 8
City: RcW.t;ro vv 42% Mwq‘
Subject: VwuI we 7-0 <?rnlC
Members of the public may address the City Council during the “Comments by the Public”
portion of the agenda and during “Public Hearings”. This Request to Address the City
Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting.
The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Request to Address City Council
Address: f?n.a f;?) IAA oJ \-&
L City: Q % &
Subject :
Members of the public may address the City Council during the “Comments by the Public”
portion of the agenda and during “Public Hearings”. This Request to Address the City
Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting.
The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Request to Address City Council
Please Print
Name: Ex Chase.
City: e- 13. ba V Ls; p-
Address: 3902 6k-b~ E. 0 n‘ yQ
Subject:
Members of the public may address the City Council during the “Comments by the Public”
portion of the agenda and during “Public Hearings”. This Request to Address the City
Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting.
The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Request to Address City Council
Please Print
Name:
\ Address:
City:
Subject: 1
Members of the public may address the City Council during the “Comments by the Public”
portion of the agenda and during “Public Hearings”. This Request to Address the City
Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting.
The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Request to Address City Council
Please Prinxd /--.
Name:
Address:
City:
Subject: % ___
Members of the public may address the City Council during the “Comments by the Public”
portion of the agenda and during “Public Hearings”. This Request to Address the City
Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting.
The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Request to Address City Council
Please Print,
City:
Members of the public may address the City Council during the “Comments by the Public”
portion of the agenda and during “Public Hearings”. This Request to Address the City
Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting.
The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Request to Address City Council
Please Print
/
Name: CrE fi ?i c 13 RrctlhRd A 770nnlcy
-
Address: JCI 5t < &dW FLOC c-
City: ehc, C*LZOkqkQL
Subject: I-rGp7 4 w RC L DR P’dfo sG-0
A--4Gn/dA&V75
Members of the public may address the City Council during the “Comments by the Public”
portion of the agenda and during “Public Hearings”. This Request to Address the City
Council must be delivered to the City Clerk prior to the commencement of the meeting.
The time limit for each speaker is limited to three (3) minutes.