Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda AIPP 021908AGENDA CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2008, AT 5:30 P.M. COUNCIL CHAMBERS i. CALL TO ORDER II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE III. ROLL CALL: ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD Regular Members Alternates Lee Bickford (Chair) Cable Neuhaus (1s` Alt.) William Leizman (Vice Chair) Jennifer O'Brien (2nd Alt.) Diane Cappella Myra Davis Ellen Dukes Lynn Silber Karen Hainsworth Also in attendance: Kara Irwin, AICP, Growth Management Administrator /Staff Liaison IV. ADDITIONS, DELETIONS, MODIFICATIONS V. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. AUGUST 21, 2007 2. DECEMBER 18, 2007 3. JANUARY 15, 2008 VI. ITEMS BY COUNCIL LIAISON VII. ITEMS BY STAFF LIAISON VIII. OLD BUSINESS 1. NORTH COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER - WORKSHOP 2. DOUBLE TREE HOTEL — RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL 3. LATITUDES IN THE GARDENS — RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL 4. CITY ART PARK - WORKSHOP IX. NEW BUSINESS X. COMMENTS BY THE PUBLIC XI, COMMENTS BY THE BOARD XII. ADJOURNMENT 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD AUGUST 21, 2007 MINUTES The Art in Public Places Advisory Board convened on August 21, 2007 in the Council Chambers of the Municipal Complex, located at 10500 North Military Trail, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida. The meeting was called to order by Lee Bickford, Chair, at 5:35 P.M. Karen Hainsworth, 1 st Alternate, will sit on the board as a regular member for the meeting. A quorum was declared. 1. Roll Call Members Present: 2. 3. 4. Members Absent: Also in Attendance: resolution Artist Terry October. 5. New Business • None. Art In Public Places 08.21.07 Lee Bickford, Chair William Leizman, Vice Diane Capella Ellen Dukes Myra Davis Georgia Heard- en Karen Hainsw , Cable Neuhouse, 2n the minutes from the July 17, 2007 owtTi Management Administrator, on information 1 members on public art programs. art can also be scheduled. 115tal discoloration issues are being reviewed at this time and A before moving forward with regard to other pieces of art. ' sculpture at the Borland Center is expected to be dedicated in Page 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 6. ADJOURNMENT • With no further business to discuss the meeting adjourned at 5:53 P.M. APPROVED: Lee Bickford, Chair Donna M. Cannon Municipal Services Coordinator NOTE: These action minutes are prepared in compliance with 286.011 F.S. and are not verbatim transcripts of the meeting. A verbatim audio recording is available from the Office of the City Clerk. All referenced attachments on file in the City Clerk's office. Art In Public Places 08.21.07 Page 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD DECEMBER 18, 2007 MINUTES The Art in Public Places Advisory Board convened on December 18, 2007 in the Council Chambers of the Municipal Complex, located at 10500 North Military Trail, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida. The meeting was called to order by Lee Bickford, Chair, at 5:32 p.m. A quorum was declared. I. CALL TO ORDER II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE III. ROLL CALL Members Present: Lee Bickford, Chair William Leizman, Vice Chair (left at 6:55 p.m.) Diane Capella Ellen Dukes Karen Hainsworth (arrived 5:39 p.m.) Lynn Silber (left at 7:05 p.m.) Cable Neuhaus, 1 st Alternate Jennifer O'Brien, 2nd Alternate Members Absent: Myra Davis Eric Jablin, Council Member, Council Liaison Also in Attendance: Kara Irwin, Growth Management Administrator Angela Wong, Community Services, Operations Manager Marty Minor, Urban Design Studio Joel Channing, Channing Corporation Mark Fuller, MTFuller Functional Arts IV. ADDITIONS, DELETIONS AND MODIFICATIONS • None. V. APPROVAL OF MINUTES MOTION 1 A motion was made, seconded and passed unanimously to minutes of October 16, 2007. VOTE Lee Bickford Yes William Leizman Yes Diane Capella Yes Ellen Dukes Yes Lynn Silber Yes Cable Newhaus Yes Jennifer O'Brien Yes Art In Public Places 12.1807 accept the meeting Page 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 VI. ITEMS BY COUNCIL LIAISON Kara Irwin, Growth Management Administrator, Staff Liaison, expressed Eric Jablin's, Council Member, Council Liaison, regrets at missing the meeting because of a family medical emergency. At this time (5:39 p.m.) Karen Hainsworth, Board Member, arrived and was seated for the meeting. VII. UPDATE BY STAFF LIAISON Kara Irwin, Growth Management Administrator, Staff Liaison, provided the staff liaison report: • In answer to a request at the last meeting, an aerial photograph of the Municipal Complex was provided, which included the vacant land on Military Trail between Burns Road to the South and Johnson Dairy Road to the North. • Ms. Irwin explained the options available and procedures to follow for the board to go forward with their ideas for a sculpture garden on the noted property. • Lee Bickford, Chair, stated the sculpture garden would be discussed under Old Business. VIII. OLD BUSINESS Lee Bickford, Chair, opened discussion of the proposed sculpture garden. • Lee Bickford inquired about the size of the vacant land. Angela Wong Community Services, Operations Manager, provided the dimension as 1.68 acres. • Diane Capella, Board Member, stated at one time the purchase of a (Dale) Chihuly piece was considered for the lake area. She suggested if it is not suitable for the lake that it should surely be considered for the sculpture garden. • Lee Bickford stated the requirements for purchasing the Chihuly. • Discussion ensued regarding the parameters for the sculpture garden and the possible expenses in its creation. • Lynn Silber, Board Member, stated the first piece for the sculpture garden should be important and provide a focal point, to which other board members agreed. • Kara Irwin, Growth Management Administrator, Staff Liaison, summarized the board's intent as: a master plan for multiple locations in the future, for a passive park that provides locations for the experiences of art throughout, and having a key piece that may be a water feature. • Kara Irwin stated the information will be forwarded to Eric Jablin, Council Member, Council Liaison, to be brought before the City Council for consideration at the January 3, 2008 meeting under Section V, Items of Resident Interest and Board /Committee Reports. • Lee Bickford encouraged all board members to attend the January 3, 2008 City Council meeting as a show of support for the sculpture garden project. • Lee Bickford inquired about the status of the PGA Flyover art. Kara Irwin replied that it is still under review in the Legal Department. William Leizman inquired about the status of the warranty on the PGA Flyover art. • Lee Bickford closed the floor to discussion of Old Business. Art In Public Places 12.18.07 Page 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 IX. NEW BUSINESS DOUBLETREE HOTEL PUD AIPP WORKSHOP (Condition 1, Resolution 128, 2006) Lee Bickford, Chair, opened discussion for the DoubleTree Hotel PUD workshop for the artwork, Triads, by artist Mark Fuller. • Marty Minor, Urban Design Studios, stated he represents the DoubleTree Hotel owner, E &J Properties; Joel Channing represents Charming Corporation; and Mark Fuller, the artist, represents MTFULLER Functional Arts. • Marty Minor provided the information about the location of the project and the history of the site. • Marty Minor presented other work by artist Mark Fuller. • Marty Minor then described the present work under consideration and invited Mark Fuller to give further details. • Mark Fuller, artist, demonstrated light reflecting through the triads of his model. He explained the variances in shape and color at different times of the day. Mr. Fuller stated the opportunity to do a project like this is very limited because it requires Southern and Western wall exposure, which this project has. • Lee Bickford complimented Mark Fuller on the art he has installed in Legacy Place and inquired about the number of art pieces he has in Palm Beach Gardens. Mark Fuller replied that he is unsure of the number, but he does have pieces located in PGA Commons, Legacy Place and what used to be the Sun Trust Bank. • Lee Bickford expressed her concerns that Mr. Fuller may have too many pieces of art in Palm Beach Gardens. • William Leizman, Vice Chair, expressed his concern about only one artist giving a presentation. His understanding is that there would be three artists for each project. He also stated that PGA and Northlake Boulevards are beginning to look like penny arcades because some of the work presented does not come before the board. Mr. Leizman inquired about possibilities of different shapes being used besides the triad in Mr. Fuller's work for the long -term storage building. • Mark Fuller explained the triads are the best light- reflecting shape for the materials being used in the project. • William Leizman inquired if the artist has done this type of piece anywhere else. Mark Fuller replied that he has not. • William Leizman inquired if the artist had considered using neon. Mark Fuller replied that he has not. • Kara Irwin clarified that an applicant can bring three separate artists before the board for consideration or hire a consultant who chooses the artist or the art form they want to pursue. The purview is whether or not the board considers the artist a real artist. The board can look at location, the art piece itself and whether or not the artist can be considered an artist. When choosing art for the City the board can hire a consultant who would bring back pieces for consideration. The project under consideration is art on private property and through the process the City does want to encourage art. The owner can workshop a project if they wish. William Leizman stated that three artists should have been brought before the board for consideration. Kara Irwin explained that is not what the Code says. • Joel Channing, Channing Corporation, stated that he likes and respects Mark Fuller and his work. Mr. Channing likes the new and innovative material being Art In Public Places 12.18.07 Page 3 I used for the project. The cost is $100,000. Mr. Charming is an architect by 2 profession. He sees this project as a great opportunity to do something with 3 light. Mr. Channing expressed his surprise that the board members did not 4 embrace the project. Mr. Channing stated that he will not provide more diversity 5 because Mark Fuller is his choice he likes and trusts him. 6 0 Cable Neuhaus, Board 1 st Alternate, inquired about maintenance. 7 • Mark Fuller described the material to be used for the project, which is a 3MTM 8 product. All indications are the material is fine. 9 • Diane Capella, Board Member, expressed her support for this project citing its 10 innovation and beauty. 11 • Lee Bickford quoted Joel Channing stating, "We did it in the butterfly and we 12 did it in the fish." Lee Bickford expressed her opinion that it has "been done." 13 0 Joel Channing stated there is no refraction of light going into the butterfly and 14 the fish and this project is a different use. Mr. Channing expressed regret that 15 Lee Bickford did not like the art. 16 0 Mark Fuller described the process he used before making a decision. 17 0 Diane Capella stated she believes this is as diverse a project as she has ever 18 seen; that she has never seen anything like it before. 19 • Jennifer O'Brien, Board 2nd Alternate, inquired about light creating different 20 shapes. 21 • Joel Channing stated different light patterns were tried, but the outcome was too 22 busy. 23 • Lynn Silber, Board Member, asked Kara Irwin to expand on her explanation of 24 the board's responsibilities. 25 • Kara Irwin explained the Art in Public Places Advisory Board code requirement 26 and purview. 27 • Discussion ensued regarding the board's responsibilities and limitations. 28 • Lee Bickford asked the board members for justification of so many pieces of art 29 by the same artist within miles of each other. Ms. Bickford stated her opinion is 30 not personal regarding Mr. Fuller. 31 • Mark Fuller stated Ms. Bickford's comments had everything to do with him and 32 that he is sorry Ms. Bickford feels as she does. 33 • Joel Channing stated he believes the board's responsibility is to critique a piece 34 of art on its merits. Mr. Channing stated that he is taking Mark Fuller with him 35 to the next meeting and before Council. 36 • Lynn Silber inquired if the board has the right to stop a developer from using a 37 particular artist. 38 • Lee Bickford explained the board does not have the right to tell a developer he 39 cannot use a particular artist, but the board can go before Council and list all of 40 the art Mark Fuller has in the City and ask how many pieces one artist should be 41 allowed to do. The City Council will then take the issue under consideration. 42 • William Leizman requested two more artists come before the board for 43 consideration. He expressed his distaste for the PGA Commons butterfly and 44 school of fish. Mr. Leizman stated there should be a neon sign up because the 45 entire area looks terrible and is not sculpture. Mr. Leizman expressed his 46 preference for (Auguste) Rodin, form and no color. He does like the art on the 47 building. He believes that the "fish" and the "butterfly" are wonderful for the 48 people, but they are not art. Art In Public Places Page 4 12.18.07 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 Diane Capella expressed her disagreement. Ms. Capella stated that it is art and times and materials change and we are in the 21st century and have access to newer materials and newer technologies; color is not a bad thing. • Cable Neuhaus stated that we live in a pretty City, but it is characterized by few pieces of exceptional architecture and art. He is in favor of being "wild" at some times. DOUBLETREE HOTEL PUD AIPP WORKSHOP STATEMENT The workshop statement put forth is either in support of (yes) or opposed to (no) this artist and developer with this project (DoubleTree Hotel PUD). Each board member expressed direction for Mr. Fuller and reason for their vote. VOTE Lee Bickford, Chair No — No comment. William Leizman, Vice Chair No — Would like to see two more choices. Diane Capella Yes — Possible variation in size or shape. Ellen Dukes Yes — Approval of the project as it stands. Lynn Silber Yes — See something different from what is on street. Karen Hainsworth Yes — Would like to see three choices. Cable Neuhaus Yes — See something else that had been considered by the team. Jennifer O'Brien Yes — Would like to know the thought process of how the team arrived at the piece presented. Lee Bickford invited the members of the DoubleTree Hotel PUD project to return to the next meeting and bring other materials or ideas they would like to present for consideration. At that time there will be a formal review for an official vote for City Council consideration. Discussion ensued between Lee Bickford and Mark Fuller. The floor was closed to further discussion. LATITUDES IN THE GARDENS MXD /PCD AIPP WORKSHOP Lee Bickford, Chair, opened discussion for the Latitudes in the Gardens workshop for the artwork, The Sphere, by artist Mark Fuller. • Mark Fuller, artist, representing his client, Shapiro Portnoy, stated the sculpture will be located off of Central and Victoria Falls Boulevards. The project consists of two three -story office buildings. The sculpture will be located in the central courtyard between the two buildings. His proposal is a wind sphere (model presented). Mr. Fuller described the engineering including its movement and lockdown ability. It will have simplicity bearings that do not require lubricant and can carry heavy loads. • Lynn Silber inquired about the weight. Mr. Fuller described the material composition as very strong: aluminum skin laminated to polycarbonate honeycomb. His weight estimate is under 1,000 pounds. • William Leizman inquired about the thickness of the stainless steel. Mr. Fuller stated the stainless steel is .020 gauge thickness and the core is 16 mm (five - eighths of an inch) composite polycarbonate honeycomb. • Mr. Fuller described the pedestal bases that are under consideration. • Mr. Fuller answered further questions regarding structural engineering and design. Art In Public Places 12.18.07 Page 5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 X. XI. • Cable Neuhaus inquired if the board is involved in choosing a pedestal. He expressed his preference for height to raise the piece up. • Lynn Silber inquired if the pedestal would have a water feature. • Mr. Fuller described possible options for the pedestal, including a water feature. • Mr. Fuller discussed finishes. • Lee Bickford asked Mr. Fuller to bring possible suggestions for the pedestal when he returns. • Lee Bickford inquired about the site. • Kara Irwin, Growth Management Administrator, Staff Liaison, described the site location and surrounding roadways. • Kara Irwin described the protected environmental location. • Lee Bickford requested base options be shown when Mr. Fuller returns. LATITUDES IN THE GARDENS MXD/PCD A/PP WORKSHOP STATEMENT The workshop statement put forth supports artist Mark Fuller and his piece, The Sphere. Each board member expressed direction for Mr. Fuller. VOTE Lee Bickford, Chair Yes — Maintain height, public access Diane Capella Yes — Finish Ellen Dukes Yes — Disappointed in location Karen Hainsworth Yes — Environmentally friendly Lynn Silber Yes — Cleaning/maintenance by owner Cable Neuhaus Yes — Night lighting Jennifer O'Brien Yes — Make it appear to defy gravity William Leizman, Vice Chair, left meeting at 6:55 p.m. Lynn Silber, Board Member, left meeting at 7:05 p.m. COMMENTS BY THE PUBLIC None. COMMENTS BY THE BOARD None. Art In Public Places 12.18.07 (The remainder of this page intentionally left blank.) Page 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 XILADJOURNMENT There being no further business to come before the board, a motion was made, seconded and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 7:10 p.m. APPROVED: Lee Bickford, Chair William Leizman, Vice Chair Diane Cappella Myra Davis Ellen Dukes Karen Hainsworth Lynn Silber Cable Neuhaus, 1 st Alternate Jennifer O'Brien, 2nd Alternate Attest: Donna M. Cannon Municipal Services Coordinator NOTE: These action minutes are prepared in compliance with 286.011 F.S. and are not verbatim transcripts of the meeting. A verbatim audio recording is available from the Office of the City Clerk. All referenced attachments on file in the City Clerk's office. Art In Public Places 12.18.07 Page 7 i 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD JANUARY 1S, 2008 MINUTES The Art in Public Places Advisory Board convened on January 15, 2008 in the Council Chambers of the Municipal Complex, located at 10500 North Military Trail, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida. The meeting was called to order by Lee Bickford, Chair, at 5:30 p.m. A quorum was declared. In the absence of Lynn Silber, Regular Member, Lee Bickford, Chair, invited Cable Neuhaus, 1st Alternate, to join the Board on the dais. I. CALL TO ORDER 11. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE III. ROLL CALL _ Members Present: Lee Bickford, 6halr--=-- William Leizman, Vial r Diane Capella Myra D:— Ellen Dukes =°_ Karen Hainswor Cable Neuh &qs, Iff Alt t ennifer O'Bi�i 2nd Altd°tiate Members A ffft Lin Silber Also in- Attendance _ Nina Wilk -gip :,�`Planning Specialist, Planning and Zoning IV. AbbITIONS, DEMNS AN&MODIFICATIONS • Done. V. ELECTIO-M OFFICER s Motion fq -r--- air Lee Bickford; mwr, accepted nominations for the position of Chair for 2008. Nomination o6Lee Bickford for Chair by Diane Cappella, seconded by William Leizman was placed before the Board. No other nominations were received. Vote for approval was unanimous. Motion for Vice Chair Lee Bickford, Chair, accepted nominations for the position of Vice Chair for 2008. Nomination of William Leizman for Vice Chair by Myra Davis, seconded by Diane Cappella was placed before the Board. No other nominations were received. Vote for approval was unanimous. Art In Public Places 01.15.08 Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 VOTE Lee Bickford William Leizman Diane Capella Myra Davis Ellen Dukes Karen Hainsworth Cable Neuhaus, 1 st Alternate MOTION FOR CHAIR MOTION FOR VICE CHAIR Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes VI. APPROVAL OF MINUTES MOTION A motion was made, seconded and minutes of November 20, 2007. passed unanimou#y to accept the meeting VOTE MOTION Lee Bickford Yes William Leizman Yes Diane Capella Yes Myra Davis Yes Ellen Dukes Yes Karen Hainsworth Yes == Cable Newhaus, 1 st Alternate Yes VII. ITEMS BY COUNCIL LIAISON None. VIII. IX. UPDATE BY ST. • None. OLD BURNESS ,bW the floc -r7o discussion of old business. • LL =Myra Davis =aired 't the Dale Chihully sculpture. Lee Bickford, Chair, sked Nina Neva if j_ in Public Places will be on the next City Council da. Ms. Nikwa replied that she had forwarded the request to Kara Irwin, St Uaison, Gr(. th Management Administrator, but was unsure if it had been includin the ,;upcoming agenda. The next City Council meeting will be January ] Ofi If it is not possible to be on the January 17, 2008 agenda Lee Bickford, (fir, asked to be on the first February City Council agenda (February f,'2008). Nina Nikolova stated she would follow up on this item. • Myra Davis inquired about the status of the Call to Artists for the sculpture in the pond. Lee Bickford, Chair, stated that the subject was put on hold until discussion can take place with the City Council. No Call to Artists has been placed at this time. Nina Nikolova reminded the Board members about the additional maintenance and cost for art that is part of a water feature. • Myra Davis inquired about the status of the PGA Boulevard flyover art. Lee Bickford, Chair, stated she had no further information at this time. • Lee Bickford, Chair, stated board members should be looking for a central piece of art for the sculpture garden, should it be approved. Further discussion ensued. Art In Public Places Page 2 01.15.08 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 X. NEW BUSINESS None. XI. COMMENTS BY THE PUBLIC None. XII. COMMENTS BY THE BOARD • Myra Davis requested a plat of areas available for a sculpture garden. Lee Bickford, Chair, stated other considerations including lighting. • William Leizman, Vice Chair, inquired about the state of the library project. Nina Nikolova stated that plans have not been recebO yet: Discussion ensued about the outside architecture and art to be placedtside of the building. Nina Nikolova stated the direction given to the County was for art inside of the building and she expects their plans to reflect that direction. -- (The remainder ibis page intentioh� left blank.) Art In Public Places 01.15.08 Page 3 } 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 }0 ll 12 l] 14 15 16 17 18 lg 20 21 22 23 24 25 20 27 20 29 30 31 32 3] 34 35 36 37 30 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 40 47 48 X0UU. ADJOURNMENT There being no further business to ounue before the board, anootiou was made, aeuuodod and carried unanimously to adjourn the meeting at 5:53 p.m. _____V__' . Leo Bickford, Chair William Leizman, Vice Chair Diane Cappella Myra Davis Ellen Dukes Jennifer O'Brien, 2nd Alternate Attest: Donna M. Cannon Municipal Services Coordinator NOTE: These action minutes are prepared in compliance with 286011 F.S. and are not verbatim transcripts of the meeting. A verbatim audio recording is available from the Office of the City Clerk. All referenced attachments on file in the City Clerk's office. Art m Public Places uz'zs'ou Page 4 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS MEMORANDUM TO: Art in Public Places Advisory Board Members FROM: Allyson Maiwurm, Projects Coordinator DATE: January 30, 2008 SUBJECT: North County Government Center — Public Art Workshop @ 2/19/08 AIPP Please be advised that there will be a public workshop discussing three artists selected for the indoor public art for the North County Government Center Planned Community Development (PCD) in the North County Regional Library during the February 19, 2008 AIPP Advisory Board Meeting. The North County Government Center PCD is located along PGA Boulevard about 1.6 miles east of Interstate I -95, at the Southwest side of the intersection of PGA Boulevard and Campus Drive, and north of Fairchild Avenue. The development plans for the North County Government Center PCD are to expand the library by 14,612 square feet as well as amend the PCD to remove land parcels and overall acreage. The zoning is Public /Institutional which indicates this project is a public facility. Please see the attachments for information relating to the artists that have been selected that may provide art for the North County Regional Library. Should you have any questions or comments or require additional information, please do not hesitate to contact me at 799-4199• 1 •. Garth Edward s December 31, 2007 To the Committee; Libraries are one of the great institutions of our society, the result of our collective creativity. Integrating art into the building to reflect this creativity can make a visit that much more enjoyable. Visually there is a lot going on in a library. When identifying art sites I look at transitional areas such as entries, lobby floors, doorways or exterior areas. I take cues from the building itself. Is there an opportunity in the signage or in utilitarian objects, cold air returns. Each situation is unique and requires study. I have worked in situations requiring close coordination with architects, interior planners and contractors. The most intense of these was as a project artist for New Jersey Transits Hudson Bergan Light Rail Project. The work involved designing art projects, preparation of construction documents and creating budgets. I would like to work on the North County Regional Library art project. I am available to begin work immediately. I have spent time in the area over the years and don't see the distance as a problem. Sincerely Garth Edwards 13400 Madison Ave NE Bainbridge Island WA 98110 Ph 206 842 5213 Fx 206 842 1960 garth_edwards @msn.com K . ; , Garth Edwards PO Box 11294 Bainbridge Is. WA 98110 206 842 5213 phone 206 842 1960 fax garth_edwards @msn.com Design Teams Consultant for New Jersey Transit, Hudson Bergan light rail. 1995 Seattle Children's Theater. Project Artrist. 1991 -93 Awards NEA Fellowship for glass. 1981 Metal /Sculpture County / City Building. 16 Compositions. Aluminum. West Sound Acadamy donor wall. Etched aluminum. Mt. Vernon High School. Greetings. Aluminum. West Sound Acadamy. Building ID. Aluminum. S. Sound Community College, Six aluminum lanterns. King Co Housing. Fence, Bike Rack, Lino floor design. Memorial for Alaska Air crash. John Hay School. Green Hill School. Benches, wind vanes, mural. New Jersey Transit. Benches & wind vanes. Redmond Community Center. Work throughout. Anoka Treatment Center. Four aluminum gateways. Charnelton Parking. Rail & exterior panels. Aluminum E. Portland Community Center. Benches, bike racks. Tacoma 2007 Poulsbo 2007 Mt. Vernon 2006 Poulsbo 2006 Olympia 2005 Kent 2004 Seattle 2000 Chalis 2000 Hoboken 2000 Redmond 2000 Anoka MN 1999 Eugene 1999 Portland 1998 Franklin Elementary. 19 Balcony rail panels. Tacoma 1997 Children's Services. Corners, Benches. Pensacola 1997 Humbolt Library. Aluminum Graphic. Chicago 1997 Student Housing. Fence. University of Oregon. Eugene 1997 Haz Mat Station. Aluminum Tower. Kansas City 1996 Animal Science Building. W S U. Bench & wall graphics. Pullman 1997 Evergreen Medical Center. Aluminum figures & paint. Main St. Renovation. Grates, Tree Guards, Bollards. Children's Theater. Rail panels, Canopy brackets, Steel. Airway Prison Visiting Center. Benches & Graphics. King County Health Clinic. Portal, Bench & Bird Pole. Maple Valley Community Center. Fence /Bench. Kirkland 1995 Auburn 1995 Seattle 1994 Spokane 1994 Federal Way 1993 Maple Valley 1993 Dunlap St. Renovation. 100 Tree Guards. Phoenix 1990 Nordstrom Lloyd Center. Grills and Gate. Portland 1990 Nordstrom Downtown. Aluminum wall Graphic. Portland 1990 Transit Station Gate. Seattle Metro. Steel. 11' x 30'. Seattle 1990 Tree Grate. Seattle Metro. Cast iron. 60" x 60 ". Seattle 1989 Manhole Cover. Seattle Water Dept. Cast iron. 38 ". Seattle 1986 Window Grill. All Saints School. Steel. Portland 1983 A Garth Edwards Page 2 Enameled Steel Twelve historical portraits. King County Library, Bellevue 1993 Seven portraits. Tabor Middle School, Portland 1991 Oregon DOT. One panel. Salem 1989 Anchorage Dog Pound. 15 panels of animals. Anchorage 1988 Juvenile Court. Three Panels. Portland 1987 Turnagain Elementary. Ten Panels. Anchorage 1985 Leaded Glass King County Housing,. Etched glass at entry. Kent 2004 Barker Residence, Bainbridge Is 2002 Green Hill School. 12 prism & glass panels. Chalis 2000 Pierce County Library. Entry sidelights. Eatonville 1990 East Austin Senior Center. Entry. Austin Texas 1988 U. of Alaska. 11 panels student housing. Fairbanks 1985 Pope Elementary School. Entry. Puyallup 1984 U. of O Student Union. Entry. Eugene 1982 Tillamook County Hospital. Chapel Windows, Tillamook 1982 Bess Kaiser Hospital. Emergency Waiting. Portland 1981 Kaiser Clinic. Waiting Area. Portland 1980 Food Stamp Office. Eugene 1979 Stone /Ceramic /Concrete Green Hill School. Six Concrete Heads. Chalis 2000 Quadrant Corp. 37 ceramic tile portraits. Seattle 1998 Seattle Center. Five Concrete Heads. Seattle 1997 Nordstrom Lloyd Center. Sandblasted slate. Portland 1990 Seattle Children's Theater. Mural at entry. Seattle 1993 Exhibitions Grou Bainbridge Arts & Crafts. Works in Stone. Bainbridge Is 2005 The Art of Golf. Safeco. Seattle 1996 German tour. U.S. Printmakers. Germany 1993 Art in Architecture. Focus on Fire. Seattle. 1889 Govett- Brewster Gallery, New Zealand 1983 Portland Art Museum. Oregon Biennial. Portland 1983 Tucson Museum. Leaded Glass. Tucson 1978 University of Texas, Prints. San Antonio 1985 Renwick Gallery, New Glass. Washington DC 1979 Exhibitions Solo Lino Prints. Artworks Gallery. Seattle 1995 Leaded Glass. American Institute of Architects. Portland 1979 Prints and Drawings. Matrix Gallery. Austin 1987 Collections Corning Museum of Glass. Leaded Glass purchase. State of Oregon Public Buildings: Pendelton, Eugene, Salem, La Grande. State of Washington: Friday Harbor, Yakima, Battleground, Eatonville, Brownsville, Edmonds, Auburn, Kent, North Shore, Skagit, Edison, Tacoma. i MAUREEN MELVILLE 1909 Massachusetts Avenue McLean, Virginia 22101 January 6, 2008 (703) 533 -2448 melville lag uber@msn.com To whom it may concern: I am an architectural glass artist who trained as an architect. I have been making stained glass windows and fused glass murals for public art projects for nineteen years. My most recent project was a series of stained glass windows for a community recreation center in Washington D.C. I am currently working on a group of windows for the primary school building of the New Mexico School for the Deaf. I would like to be considered for this project because I have always been an avid reader and am passionate about the importance of libraries. I would like to make art that helps demonstrate to children that the library is a place where wonderful things can be discovered. I am interested in public art because more than many other arts, stained glass is an art that needs to be integrated into its setting. The public art process allows that opportunity. Because I am also an architect I think I am quite sensitive to the idea that the stained glass should build upon and enhance the architecture of the structure. I like the discipline that designing for a specific site imposes. My background as an architect makes me well suited to the collaborative approach outlined for this project and easily able to understand construction methods and documents. Along with designing in a way that is sympathetic to the architecture I like to design with a theme that is suggested by the purpose of the structure or by the local geography, history or culture. My work is always very tied to the site. I try to respond to the intended users. My work is colorful and uses a mixture of abstract and recognizable imagery. It would be very appropriate for the children and family oriented spaces of the library. Glass art can take the form of stained glass windows or be artificially backlit in lightless interior spaces. It can also be used in interior locations as an interior window. I nearly always work with hand blown antique glass that has beautiful rich color. I add detail by painting on the glass (fired on permanently in the kiln) and by sandblasting or acid etching the glass. I have always fabricated and installed my own work. I understand that this project has a very tight deadline so that I would be the consulting artist. A commercial stained glass studio would then fabricate the work. I am accustomed to working with many different public art committees and presenting my work to them. I am also familiar with the other requirements of public art projects and have experience with both their design and fabrication. My father lives in Port St. Lucie so I fly into Palm Beach frequently and am familiar with the Palm Beach Gardens area. I would welcome the opportunity to make a proposal to you for this project. Sincerely, Maureen Melville IuGlll 5101 DiesalD)WA19114 y 1909 Massachusetts Avenue McLean, Virginia 22101 (703) 533 -2448 melville lauberAmsn.com EDUCATION 1982 Harvard University, Graduate School of Design, Master of Architecture 1975 University of Chicago, AB Art History/Fine Arts Additional course work at the Art Institute of Chicago, Massachusetts College of Art, and the Corcoran School of Art. Participated in glass workshops with Brent Kee Young, Therman Statom, Susan Plum, Walt Lieberman and Dick Weiss, Charles Devillier, Dan Fenton, Ken Van Roenn, and Albinus Elskus. PUBLIC ART COMMISSIONS Current Project (Stained Glass), New Mexico School for the Deaf, Santa Fe, NM 2007 Stained glass windows, Brentwood Recreation Center, Washington D.C., 2007 Finalist, public art competition, Florida State University, Tallahassee Florida, 2006 Finalist, public art competition, Peru State College, Peru Nebraska, 2005 Finalist, public art competition, Freeman Justice Center, Key West Florida, 2005 Stained glass windows, Daytona Children's Medical Services, Daytona Beach Florida, 2005 Stained glass windows, Phase 2, Gulf county Health Department, Port St. Joe, Florida, 2003 Stained glass windows, Renne Library, Montana State University, Bozeman, Montana, 2003 Finalist, stained glass competition, School of Business and Industry, Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University, Tallahassee, Florida, 2003 Finalist, stained glass competition, Walton County Health Department, South Walton, Florida, 2002 Stained glass window, Hendry County Public Health Unit, Clewiston, Florida, 2002 Stained glass windows, Phase 1, Gulf County Health Department, Port St. Joe, Florida, 2001 Finalist, stained glass competition, Reitz Student Union, University of Florida, Gainesville, . ,w .. Florida, 2001. Stained glass window, Franklin County Health Department, Apalachicola, Florida, 2001. Stained glass window, Baker County Health Department, Macclenny, Florida, 2000. Finalist, stained glass competition, New Mexico Military Institute, Roswell, New Mexico, 1998 Stained glass window, Hendry County Public Health Unit, LaBelle, Florida, 1997 Fused glass tiles, Rockville City Hall, Rockville, Maryland, 1992 Stained glass window, Burnt Mills Elementary School, Silver Spring, Maryland Montgomery County Public Schools, 1992 Finalist, stained glass competition, Sherwood High School, Olney, Maryland Montgomery County Public Schools, 1991 Stained glass window, Highland Elementary School, Silver Spring, Maryland Montgomery County Public Schools, 1991 Stained glass window, Laytonsville Elementary School, Laytonsville, Maryland Montgomery County Public Schools, 1990 Stained glass window, Strawberry Knoll Elementary School, Gaithersburg, Maryland Montgomery County Public Schools, 1990 Stained glass window, Washington Grove Elementary School, Gaithersburg, Maryland Montgomery County Public Schools, 1988 ARCHITECTURE 1986 Registered Architect, District of Columbia GRANTS Finalist, Artist -in- Residence, Howard County Arts Commission, Howard County, MD 1995 Arts Education Grant, Commission on the Arts and Humanities, District of Columbia, 1994 Individual Artist Grant, Commission on the Arts and Humanities, District of Columbia, 1992 Arts Education Grant, Commission on the Arts and Humanities, District of Columbia, 1992 oU \'oo� G. ��GLM January 5, 2008 Gary L. Moore Box 10772 Miami, F133101 305.323.6923 garylmoore.com Experience, Background I have fifthteen years working experience through commissioned, fully integrated, large -scale public art works. My reputation of delivering fully realized complex interior and exterior artworks on time and on budget is well valued by commissioning agencies' nationally. I have successfully collaborated with city planners, architects, engineers, government agencies and other design professionals to produce site specific, award winning and innovative public art commissions. From research, community advisory group presentations, preliminary concept design, procurement, fabrication and installation, I maintain the integrity of an innovative forward thinking artistic vision. My most recently completed public art commission Pharoahs Dance (2007) has received international recognition for it is design excellence and innovative use of rustic terrazzo and fused glass. Pharoahs Dance has been a feature on the New York Times Back Page Section, Art Forum Magazines Special Art Basel Issue -2007, is a featured project for the America's for the Art's in Public Art 2007 Year in Review and a 2007 National Terrazzo Awards Honoree. I have had exceptional collaborative design team experience with a wide range of professional firms such as; Wallace, Roberts and Todd (WRT), Duany Plater -Zybert (DPZ), Ed Dorrell Stone (EDSA), Zyscovich Architects, PBS &J and Cesar Pelli & Associates. My most relevant experience for the North County Regional Library (Expansion Project) has been the creation of the Harrambe Room for the Broward County Library System. The Harrambe Room is a specialty space located in the lobby of the Library. The room is used as a storytelling area and has become a major tourist attraction in Broward County and a featured project for the Broward County Public Art and Design Agency. Incorporated into the building program, the Harrambe Room is a fully integrated site - specific public art commission. My inclusion on the design team during the preliminary design program enabled me able to create the Harrambe Room as an additional building feature. Design Approach Public library facilities have become major venues for neighborhood cultural and social life. My design approach would begin to initiate an environment that addresses the connection between home and community. I envision a public art installation poetically bridging the context of the expanded home environment: a familiar atmosphere of personal space but more communal and which promotes sharing and exchange. The art commission will create, through materials, textures and primary colors, an open and content rich public art commission where children and families share learning together and indeed, share life through research, reading and new knowledge. The new construction is viewed as an architecture design from which seamless public artworks emerge. Some art components may take the form of interactive elements like oversized game boards, clocks of odd configurations fabricated in durable permanent materials; built -in mosaic mural niches for storytelling and a variety of child sized "hanging out" nooks. Educational elements may include historic timelines with themes for science, geography and the arts playfully scattered throughout the new construction spaces. Thank you. Gary L. Moore 928 Mountain Street Philadelphia, Pa. 19148 305.323.6923 garylmoore.com Education Whitney Museum of American Art, Independent Study Program, 1991 - 92 Norwich University, MFA, 1996 University of Miami, Sculpture, 1992 Selected Public Art Projects 2007 Yesterday's Tomorrow: a series of fiRhteen historical markers located at five locations 24 X 12" each Digital print film transfer on rolled aluminum Village of the Arts and Humanities, Philadelphia, Pa. $65,000 A permanent sustainable outdoor sculptural installation, which re- envisions the traditional, cast bronze historical markers as energetic, vibrantly colored African influenced sculptural assemblages, attached directly to existing street utility poles. Created in collaboration with the Historic Fair Hill Quaker burial ground, Historic Uptown Theater and other community based institutions. 2006 Pharaohs Dance Plaza A fully integrated exterior piazza 6,000 sq ft ground mural rustic terrazzo in ten colors, 12ft circular stage with 2ft Height, fused and tempered glass, LED lighting, polished terrazzo, landscaping design Seven 2' diameter cast chrome themed medallions 482 sq. ft. of black bamboo, Carnival Center for the Performing Arts, Miami Florida Architect: Cesar Pelli & Associates Miami Dade Art in Public Places $745,000 Pharoahs Dance Plaza is a major entryway for the Carnival Center's Opera Ballet House. The Opera Ballet House is one of the two buildings of which composes the Carnival Performing Arts Center. The Plaza's ground mural, created in rustic terrazzo with deep tones of terra cotta and reds, is layered with an elaborate network of metal strip designs. These designs generate a visual movement suggestive of imaginary wind patterns seen during a desert sand storm. This detail enhances the narrative concept of the Pharoahs Dance Plaza's theme of American jazz and caravan travel across the 12th Century Sahara desert. Pharoahs Dance Plaza's terrazzo mural has eight cast chrome medallions embedded throughout tit's 6,000 sq. ft. area. The large shiny oval forms of the medallions create a counterpoint to the tactile rustic terrazzo. Each of the medallions display a unique motif that relates to the intricate designs found on ancient coins. The medallions are arranged as musical notations on an abstract field of color. Pharoahs Dance Plaza features a polished terrazzo raised circular platform, knick -named "the turntable ". In actuality, the raised platform serves as a stage for impromptu mini - concerts by performers engaged in productions at the Center. This creates a lively exuberant atmosphere before and after performances. The "turntable" has become a local attraction for it is free performances and a "must see" tourist attraction. As articulated in the evening, Pharoahs Dance Plaza theatrical lighting design imparts a dramatic red blue and yellow LED lighting system underneath the seat wall. Along the riser of the Turntable /stage are custom designed and fitted fused glass panels in translucent tones of mellow yellows layered with opaque discs of primary colors. The lighting feature here is similar to the seat wall not far away. Together the Turntable and Seat wall's lighting scheme creates a colorfully lit pedestrian passageway inside the main area of Pharoahs Dance Plaza. One additional element of Pharoahs Dance Plaza is the towering wall of Black Bamboo located behind the seat wall and buffers the Plaza from the busy street level valet parking area. As an interactive natural sound - scape, the bamboo whistles, rustles and shimmers from breezes rolling off Biscayne Bay, located just two blocks away. . Seeds of Change Rustic Terrazzo in eight colors, 12 "sq. Cast bronze medallions: 13 ea. of four designs, street banners: 36 ea. of four designs which designate the historic district. City of Delray Beach Florida Engineering Department and Community Redevelopment Agency Community workshops $245,000 Conceptualized as a public art overlay to Delray Beaches' downtown district street and infrastructure improvement project. Seeds of Change has become a major area attraction spurring development along a redeployed commercial strip. Located in the historical district of downtown Delray Beach, Florida, this work span six blocks of rustic terrazzo paving, colored cement with patterning, cast bronze medallions, Street banners, and light pole cladding in materials specified by the artist. All design and content elements have a strong reflection of the history and culture of the area site residents. College Hill Diamond Polished terrazzo floor in ten colors College Hill Community Center, Tampa Florida City of Tampa Art in Public Place, Community workshops $33,000 The College Hill Community Center is a recently completed park's facility servicing an inner city rural community with amenities such as a swimming pool, running track and active baseball field. The terrazzo floor design, located in the lobby is a fully integrated public artwork. Historic Negro League Baseball teams inspire the design of the flooring; sports activities abstract pop cultural images and intensive community workshops. Delray Beach Gateway Feature Preliminary Design Phase Architect: Post, Buckley, Schuh, Jimigan, (PBS &J) Fort Lauderdale, Florida City of Delray Beach Fl. CRA Conceptualized public art component consisting of two pedestrian plazas with vertical elements. The Gateway serves as a major entryway for vehicular traffic exiting from an interstate highway. Collaborated with City planners, Department of Transportation officials' architects and engineers in producing a conceptual plan. Conceived of and conducted community workshops as a consensus - making tool. 2005 Lauderhill Promenade Design Arts Community Workshop Architect: Ed Dorrell Stone & Associates, Ft. Lauderdale, FL Conceptualized and produced an artistic children's "street signage" workshop. The workshop was a vital component in developing a community consensus for new project development in the Lauder hill commercial district. 2004 Master Plan for Mixed -Use Development, Truman Naval Facility Key West Florida Florida Atlantic University Center for Urban Redevelopment and Education, Bahama Conch Land Trust, As lead artist, I developed public art components for a community development agency seeking to redeploy a once active U.S. Navy Facility. The scope of my involvement was to conceptualize within the Master plan an artistic overlay, which creates context and content specific to the area, and reflect the culture of residents in Key West. The Master Plan functioned as a primary document in the community development effective effort to raise support and funding for the project. Recently the development agency secured land and development rights to the Navel Facility primarily based on the Master Plan for Mixed -Use Development for the Truman Navel Facility prepared by the team. Afromatic Baked enamel on water jet cut steel 1,400 sqft Miami Dade Park and Recreation, Miami Dade Art in Public Places $160,000 Decorative security fencing surrounding a County Parks arts facility. There are 175 site specific designed steel panels with baked enable attached to upper 1' section of the security fencing. The designs incorporate landscape forms and abstract patterns which allude to the performing and visual arts. 2003 "Cut and Greet" Temporary Public Art Installation /Performance hair salon chairs, paint, landscaping, various other materials Delray Beach Cultural Loop, Delray Beach Florida A social sculpture where community residents received free haircuts and other grooming services, provided free of charge from qualified professionals. I recreated, in an unused church house, a neighborhood hair salon with bairber's chair, magazines, mirrors and other furnishings. Community residents were invited by way of flyers and word of mouth to come and have grooming services provided. From hair braiding, manicures, soda, chips and domino games the afternoon was spent relaxing and sharing stories. This public art commission utilized community residents as the medium in providing an opportunity for social interaction in an unexpected context. Harrambe Room Polished terrazzo in 6 colors, 640 square feet in diameter with 18 digital color prints on textured canvas, sealed in plastic (6' Height X 4' Width) Broward County Library System, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida $120,000 The Harrambe Room is a fully integrated site - specific public artwork located in the newly constructed primary research library. The Harrambe Room serves as the primary tourist attraction in a major specialty public library facility. The Room features a storytelling area, wall murals representing the history and culture of the community, and a natural acoustical sound -- scape. Puzzle Walk Rustic Terrazzo Health Science Building, University of South Florida at Tampa, Florida $38,000 Ninth Street Pedestrian Mall (1994 - 2003) Cast bronze medallions, custom colored concrete brick pavers, rustic terrazzo Miami Dade Art in Public Places, City of Miami Architects: Wallace, Roberts & Todd $650,000 The Ninth Street Pedestrian Mall was the first street improvement project in the city of Miami where a multiplicity of government agencies collaborated to produce a major infrastructure improvement project in down town Miami. As the lead artist for the project, I designed and installed 18,000 square feet of custom colored concrete pavers and a 20,000 square foot pedestrian plaza fabricated in rustic terrazzo. Embedded in the terrazzo, along the pedestrian plaza are seven cast bronze medallions. The medallions convey design and text content symbolic of the historic significance of the neighborhood. Recognized internationally, the Ninth Street Pedestrian Mall is a vital public artwork in Miami Dade County. The success of the public art work at the Mall has initiated and supported the development of an urban core with "Town Center" potential, and continues to serve as a standard in pedestrian plaza paving design. The Ninth Street Pedestrian Mall has been recognized with design awards from the American Society of Landscape Architects, National Endowment for the Arts: Design for Transportation Award, International Downtown Association and the International Concrete Paving Institute, and is a featured project in Landscape Architecture Magazine, January 1994. 2001 Miami Design District, Public Art Master plan, Miami, FL, In collaboration with Duany Plater - Zybert, Coral Cables, FL and DACRA Companies, Miami Beach, FL Miami Design District is an urban enclave of upscale designer showrooms, artist studios and restaurants. The Public Art Master plan was created as a working manual that dictates the placement, content, scale and programmatics of commissioning public art initiatives for the district. As a member of an artists team, my recommendation facilitated the establishment of the Underpass Mural Program which currently commissions artists to create site specific painted murals on areas where transit stops occur under highway over passes. Currently, the Public Art Master Plan functions as a development guide in the Design District. 1998 Image Control: Temporary Billboard Supported by the Public Art Fund, New York, this public art commission provided artists collaborations from New York City and Miami Florida. As an invited artist I designed fabricated and installed two billboard designs, repeated at seven locations in and around downtown Miami for three months. CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD Agenda Cover Memorandum Date Prepared: February 4, 2008 Meeting Date: February 19, 2008 Petition No. AIPP- 07 -12- 000017 Subject / Agenda Item: Petition AIPP- 07 -12- 000017: Art in Public Places — Latitudes in the Gardens Recommendation to City Council: A request by Mark Fuller, on behalf Hawkeye Central, LLC, for approval of the public art for the Latitudes in the Gardens Mixed -Use Planned Community Development (MXD/PCD), generally bounded by Interstate 95 and Central Boulevard to the west, the future extension of Victoria Falls Boulevard to the north, the future extension of Elm Avenue to the east, and the Paloma PUD to the south. [ X ] Recommendation to APPROVE ] Recommendation to deny Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: FINANCE: NA AIPP Board Action: Plannin M Growth Mana ement: [ ] Rec. approval Project Costs: $ NA [ ] Rec. app. w/ conds. Manager Total [ ] Rec. Denial Je o n Nina Nikolova [ ] Continued to: City Attorney: Planning Specialist $ NA Current FY Christine Tatum Funding Source: Development Compliance Manager: [ ]Operating [X ] Other NA Bahareh Wolfs, AICP GrowtA Management Budget Acct. #: Advertised: N/A Attachments: strato A : Date: . Artist's Resume Paper: • Artist's Statement . Site Plan Kara Irwin, AICP • Proposed Art and [X] Not Required Pedestal Design Options Approved by: City Manager: • Budget Breakdown Affected parties: • Copy of Escrow [ ] Notified Letter Ronald M. Ferris [X] Not Required [ ]None v Date Prepared: February 4, 2008 Meeting Date: February 19, 2008 Petition AIPP- 07 -12- 000017 BACKGROUND On July 20, 2006 the City Council adopted Resolution 53, 2006, for the master site plan approval of Parcel 31.04 MXD/PCD which consists of 50.58 acres. Concurrently with the PCD master site plan, the City Council adopted Resolution 55, 2006, granting site plan approval to the residential portion of the PCD within "Parcel C ", which is exempt from the art requirement. Furthermore, through the adoption of Resolution 4, 2007, the City Council granted site plan approval for the approximately 9.0 acre commercial area consisting of "Parcel A" and "Parcel B" of the Parcel 31.04 MXD/PCD, a.k.a "Latitudes in the Gardens." The approval allowed for 9,000 s.f. of restaurant use, 15,000 s.f. of retail use, 38,000 s.f. of medical office use, and 14,866 s.f. of professional office use. DISCUSSION The artist, Mark Fuller, representing himself and the owner of the property, appeared before the Art in Public Places Advisory Board for a workshop on December 18, 2007. In accordance with Section 78- 261(d) of the Land Development Regulations entitled Requirements for art or fee in lieu of art, all budgets for new construction of private and public developments shall include one percent (1 %) of the total budget for vertical construction as a fee for art in public places. The subject fee shall be utilized by the developer for the provision of artwork on the project site, or the developer may choose to contribute one percent (1 %) of the total vertical construction costs directly to the City for the provision of art on public property. Under the provisions of Section 78- 261(d)(1)a.l. of the City's Land Development Regulations entitled Deposit of funds, prior to the issuance of a building permit the petitioner is required to place $63,898.71 into an escrow account, which represents an estimate of one (1 %) percent of the estimated total cost of vertical construction on site. The budget for the proposed AIPP program is $75,000 (please see the attached project budget breakdown). PROPOSED ART IN PUBLIC PLACES The artist (please see attached artist resume), is proposing a kinetic wind - driven installation, entitled "The Sphere." It will be 14 feet in diameter, and will be placed on a pedestal that will be 19.5 feet in diameter and 6 feet in height. The artist has designed three options for the pedestal. The artist and owner are more partial to the pedestal designs that incorporate a planter bed for annuals, and a 360 degree seating around the base (please see attached images and site plan). PROPOSED LOCATION FOR ART The applicant is proposing one (1) location for the public art: 1. The sculpture is placed in the open courtyard area between Buildings 1 and 2. 2 s Date Prepared: February 4, 2008 Meeting Date: February 19, 2008 Petition AIPP- 07 -12- 000017 The proposed location is consistent with Land Development Regulations Section 78 -262 as follows: • Visibility: The proposed public art location takes the design of the site into account, so that the public can receive the most enjoyment and benefit from the art. The art is integrated into the site and is located in a pedestrian oriented area. The art would also be visible to vehicular traffic which enters the site. • Lighting: The proposed public art will be lit in an unobtrusive manner through the use of up- lights that will be placed within the pedestal base. The artist will provide further information at the AIPP meeting on February 19, 2008. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff is recommending approval of the subject petition with the following condition of approval: 1. The Applicant shall submit digital photographs of the installed artwork within sixty (60) days of completion. (Planning and Zoning) 3 L' Art In Public Places Lattitudes in the Gardens MTFULLER FUNCTIONAL ARTS 524 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd. Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.707.4688 CITY OF PAID! 8 C H Girt,',I PI.1"1fii LING & ONING Di ", 013108 �• About MTFuller MTFuller is an environmental graphic designer and creator of art works for a wide variety of applications. Established in West M T F U L L E R Palm Beach since 1986, Mark Fuller provides professional design, fabrication, and production services. FUNCTIONAL ARTS Primarily oriented towards designing identity elements to create a sense of place, Fuller's experience includes urban street furniture such as seating elements, bollards, lighting fixtures, tree grates, telephone kiosks, and graphic images on sound barriers along Interstate 95. His Art In Public Places installations have included kinetic constructions, compression- tension cable structures, and static free - standing elements. His works have been referenced by a spokesperson for the National Endowment For The Arts as "a good example of what public art should be ". Experience with and accessability to high -tech fabrication methods and finishing technology allow him to effectively determine appropriate production methods to accommodate budget, schedule, and function requirements. His projects often incorporate diverse fabrication methods utilizing polymer -based mouldings, cast stone fabrications, specialized epoxy - polyester hybrid coatings, and aero -space quality precision metal fabrications. Immediate access to state -of -the -art industrial lasers, CNC computerized machining, and large format image reproduction has enhanced MTFuller's ability to streamlining the process from concept to reality. Fluent in digital technology, MTFuller utilizes an array of powerful Macintosh and PowerComputing platforms for pre - production 3D modeling and imaging. Expertise in programs such as Photoshop, Raydream, Lightwave, and POV -Ray / Persistance of Vision enables photo - realistic monitoring of designs from conceptual design throughout the final design phases. Professional Experience Urban Design Studio, West Palm Beach, FL: Director of Graphics 1978 -80 Lance Wyman Ltd. New York, NY Senior Designer 1980 -86 MTFuller Functional Arts; West Palm Beach, FL: Owner 1986- present Animates, Inc.; New York, NY Principal 1988 - present Art In Public Places Helter Shelter - Pinellas County Arts Council, Seminole, Florida (2007) Last Pasture - Boynton Town Center, Boynton Beach, FL, (2007) The Obelisk - The Sembler Company, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida (2006) Stack145 - The Sembler Company, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida (2006) Butterfly Grove - PGA Commons, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida (2005) Track 2, 1 -9 - The Pinellas Trail; Pinellas County Arts Council, St. Petersburg, Florida (2004) Tears - The V FC -9/11 Memorial, The City of Hoboken, New Jersey (2002) Flock - The City of Mercer Island, Washington (2001) Square Peg Round Hole - Interim Services Corporate Headquarters, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida (2000) Tensegrity - The Children's Discovery Museum of the Desert, Palm Desert, California (1999) Marlin Palms - The City of West Palm Beach, West Palm Beach, Florida (1995) Fish Out Of Water - The City of West Palm Beach, West Palm Beach, Florida (1993) Other Sample Project Clients The State of New Jersey Department of Transportation. The City of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada The City of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada The City of Detroit, Detroit, Michigan The City of Trenton, Trenton, New Jersey The City of Boynton Beach, Boynton Beach, Florida The City of West Palm Beach, West Palm Beach, Florida Museo Amparo, Mexico City, Mexico U. S. Sugar Corporation, West Palm Beach, Florida Downtown Development Authority of West Palm Beach CoTran, Palm Beach County, Florida Farr -Jewett & Associates, Washington, DC Skidmore, Owings & Merril, New York, New York American Musuem of Natural History, New York, New York Historic Mercer Cemetary, Trenton, New Jersey South Street Seaport Museum, New York, New York Artist's Statement MTFULLER This proposal "THE SPHERE" provides an outline for a kinetic wind - driven installation. FUNCTIONAL ARTS Conceptually placed atop a water - sheeting cylindrical series of steps, "THE SPHERE" consists of multiple crescent - shaped fins which are aligned perpendicular to each other at the centerline. A primary support yoke is deep anchored to the foundation and has a 360 degree movement on the X / Z axis (horizontal plane) via a simplicity bearing shaft and collar. Secured to the upper -end of the support yoke, an additional simplicity bearing and shaft collar is mounted to the outer crescent of the spherical fabrication assembly, which will allow the fabrication body to rotate 360 degrees on the Y (vertical rotation) axis. This combination of axial rotations combined with the opposing planes of the crescent fins will allow the spherical assembly to direct itself into the breeze as it finds its path of least rersistance to the prevailing breeze. Constant corrections to the direction of even the slightest breeze provide viewers with a stimulating visual experience. Conceived as having a silver metallic finish with a colored inside leading edge of the fins, the theme of "THE SPHERE" is relative to the projects namesake of "Lattitudes ". This installation will be engineered to meet hurricane codes as follows: Wind Criteria: 140mph Exposure "C" FBC 2004 As an additional measure for safety under tropical storm conditions, "THE SPHERE" will have adjustable tension restraint cables which will prevent rotation of the spherical assembly on the Y axis (vertical rotation). The nature of forces upon the assembly will allow for horizontal movement to head into the wind. All aspects of the pedestal base will be provided by the project owner. RESPONSE TO AIPP WORKSHOP REVIEW.• The `sphere' design for the installation was previously met with approval, however the AIPP committee requested that a design option for the base element be presented. I have re- designed the base, and hereby present one design; with a variation to the top of the quadrant wall as a subtle option. This design is an excellent improvement over the previous scheme as it now offers a planter bed for annuals, as well as 360 degree seating around the base of the installation. 01C i F# 7 J ' `L - � � F-� .p ' / •_,tip`- � A� '� , 17 'r �.~,! i��1 -T� � '413 •.� .. r o 4r Al� ►f � � ' � •: � As ot T -_1. ORIGINAL SUBMITTAL DESIGN REVISED PEDESTAL DESIGN OPTION 'A' (Straight Quadrant Wall Tops) REVISED PEDESTAL DESIGN OPTION 'B' (Curved Quadrant Wall Tops) �vr Shapiro /Portnoy Companies January 31, 2008 City of Palm Beach Gardens Planning and Zoning Division Grown Management Department 10500 North Military Trail Palm Beach Gardens, FL 3 34 10 Re: Latitudes in the Gardens 12400 & 12500 Central Blvd. Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33414 To Whom It May Concern: Please be advised that we have deternuned the vertical construction costs of Latitudes in the Gardens using the standard Building Valuation Data Tables 1 and 2. The building is classified as Group B Business, Type U3, with a construction cost of $83.13 per square foot. We estimate the total vertical construction cost to be $6,389,871.00 (i.e., 76,866 square fcct times $83.13 per square foot.). We are submitting the minimum 1% of vertical construction cost into an escrow account as per the City of Palm Beach Gardens ordinance. The escrow amount is $63,898.71. If you should have any questions, or require further information, do not hesitate to contact us. Cindy Smith -- _ Hawkeye Central, UY O'cr PALM BCH CONS FEB 12006 PLANNING & 70NING DIV UTF111 1 FR rvmu nwnnL nK v a 524 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd. West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.707.4688 f mtfuller @earthlink.net Budget Schedule AIPP - Sphere AIPP Budget Design 1 February 2008 laUAmdes at the Gardens Logistics (professional fees, overhead, insurance) Materials (metal, pc extruded sheet, hardware) Materials Freight Production Services (laser, CNC, hybrid laminations) Assembly & Handling Installation Services 10% Margin 75,000.00 15,000.00 5,575.00 15,500.00 1,000.00 17,300.00 10,375.00 2,750.00 7,500.00 CITY OF PALM BEACH GARDENS ART IN PUBLIC PLACES ADVISORY BOARD Agenda Cover Memorandum Date Prepared: February 4, 2008 Meeting Date: February 19, 2008 Petition No. AIPP- 07 -12- 000018 Subject / Agenda Item: Petition AIPP- 07 -05- 000015: Art in Public Places — Double Tree Hotel Recommendation to City Council: A request by Marty Minor, on behalf of E &J Properties, LLC, and THI IV PBG LLC, for approval of the public art for the Double Tree Planned Unit Development (PUD), generally located in the northeast quadrant of the intersection of PGA Boulevard and Military Trail, and west of Interstate I -95. [ X ] Recommendation to APPROVE [ ] Recommendation to deny Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: FINANCE: NA AIPP Board Action: Plannin Growth Management: [ ] Rec. approval Project Manager __�& Costs: $ NA Total [ ] Rec. app. w/ conds. ( ] Rec. Denial Je on Nina Nikolova [ ] Continued to: City Attorney: Planning Specialist $ NA Current FY Christine Tatum Funding Source: Development Compliance Manager: [ ]Operating [X ] Other _NA_ Bahareh Wolfs, AICP Gro Management Attachments: Ad strator: Advertised: N/A Budget Acct. #: Date: [ ] None • Applicant Narrative Paper: Budget Breakdown . Artist's Resume Kara Irwin, AICP • Site Plan [X] Not Required • Artist's Statement • Triad Details Approved by: City Manager: • Elevations with Affected parties: "Triads" [ ] Notified • Examples of Artist's Ronald M. Ferris [X] Not Required work • Initial Concepts Date Prepared: February 4, 2008 Meeting Date: February 19, 2008 Petition AIPP- 07 -12- 000018 The proposed location is consistent with Land Development Regulations Section 78 -262 as follows: • Visibility: The proposed public art location is visible to both internal and external pedestrian and vehicular traffic. • Lighting: The proposed public art will be tastefully lit through the use of up- lights in order to prevent excessive glare and light trespass. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff is recommending approval of the subject petition with the following conditions of approval: 1. The Applicant shall submit digital photographs of the installed artwork within sixty (60) days of completion. (Planning and Zoning) 2. The Applicant shall install the art prior to the issuance of the certificate of occupancy for the self - storage building. (Planning and Zoning) 3 K C7 February 1, 2008 Ms. Nina Nikolova Planning Specialist Planning and Zoning Division Growth Management Department City of Palm Beach Gardens 10500 N. Military Trail Palm Beach Gardens, Florida 33410 urban Urban Design Urban Planning Land Planning Landscape Architecture RE: REQUEST FOR A RECOMMENDATION TO CITY COUNCIL FOR ART IN PUBLIC PLACES FOR DOUBLETREE NORTH PUD Dear Ms. Nikolova: At the December 18, 2007 Art Advisory Committee meeting, we presented the proposed artwork for Doubletree North Planned Unit Development, located east of Military Trail, west of Interstate 95 and north of PGA Boulevard. The proposed artwork, "Triads," will be placed on the southern, southwestern and southeastern elevations of the self - storage building currently under construction. The innovative artwork consists of a series of individually- mounted equilateral reflective and also transparent triangles which are mounted to the building. This installation will create a constantly- changing display of color and color shadows against the building elevation. This changing color display is caused by the use of materials on the artwork. The artist, Mark Fuller of MTFULLER Functional Arts, is a well -know artist who has installations within the City and throughout North America. Mr. Fuller, who is a resident of the City, has recently completed installations in Pinellas County, Florida, and the South County Civic Center in Delray Beach. Full plans and descriptions of the proposed "Triad" artwork are attached for your review. Also, attached is the artist's resume. As part of the building permit process for the City, the applicant, E & J Properties, provided the City with a check for $88,500 for the Art in� l��j The applicant, who also owns the subject site, hired Mr. Fuller for $89,250.bkd>�l4ie!'- costs for the artwork is attached for your information. At the Art Advisory Committee meeting, the Committee requested to see A examples of the other concepts considered during the design process for P1 MI ING- -9, 7P!4,1wa l !! the artwork. These design concepts are attached for your review. 477 S. Rosemary Avenue Suite 225 - The Lofts at City Place West Palm Beach, FL 33401 561.366.1100 561.366.1111 fax www.UDSonline.com LCC35 • We look forward to working with you in the provision of this artistic amenity. Should you have any questions, please feel free to contact me, We are looking forward to being placed on the February I 91 Art Advisory Committee meeting for this request. Thank you for your assistance. Sincerely, Urban Design Studio Marty R.A. Minor, AICP MTFULLER • FUNCTIONAL ARTS 2625 Ravella Lane Marty Minor Palm Beach Gardens, FL Urban Design Studio 33410 477 South Rosemary Avenue #225 West PalmBeach, FL 33401 e 561,70 .4688 �! mtfuller earthlink.net 561.366.1100 Budget Breakdown AIPP 1 February 2008 Doubletree North AIPP Budget Design Fees Logistics (professional fees, insurance, overhead) Materials (aluminum, polycarbonates, dichroic coatings) Materials Freight / Shipping Production Services (laser, waterjet, solvent welding) Assembly & Handling Electrical & Lighting Installation Services 10% Margin 89,250.00 15,425.00 6,760.00 20,200.00 2,150.00 18,200.00 9,400.00 3,600.00 4,600.00 8.925.00 Proposed Design For Art In Public Places Doubletree 2 0 CREATED BY: WFULLER FUNCTIONAL ARTS • About !!MTFuller 40 MTFuller Is an environmental graphic designer and creator of art works for a wide variety of applications. Established in West 7 P U L L f: F Palm Beach since 1986, Mark Fuller provides professional design, fabrication, and production services. Fui +s:'fiONP'_ Primarily oriented towards designing Identity elements to create a sense of place, Fuller's experience includes urban street furniture such as seating elements, bollards, lighting fixtures, tree grates, telephone kiosks, and graphic images on sound barriers along Interstate 95. His Art In Pubiic Places installations have included kinetic constructions, compression- tension cable structures, and static free - standing elements. His works have been referenced by a spokesperson for the National Endowment For The Arts as "a good example of what public art should be ". Experience with and accessability to high -tech fabrication methods and finishing technology allow him to effectively determine appropriate production methods to accommodate budget, schedule, and function requirements. His projects often incorporate diverse fabrication methods utilizing polymer -based mouldings, cast stone fabrications, specialized epoxy - polyester hybrid coatings, and aero-space quality precision metal fabrications. Immediate access to state- of- the-art industrial lasers, CNC computerized machining, and large format Image reproduction has enhanced MTFuller's ability to streamlining the process from concept to reality. Fluent in digital technology, MTFuller utilizes an array of powerful Macintosh and PowerComputing platforms for pre - production 3D modeling and imaging. Expertise In programs such as Photoshop, Raydream, Lightwave, and POV -Ray / Persistance of Vision enables photo-realistic monitoring of designs from conceptual design throughout the final design phases. arofessionai Experience Urban Design Studio, West Palm Beach, FL: Director of Graphics 1978-80 Lance Wyman Ltd. New York, NY Senior Designer 1980 -86 MTFuller Functional Arts; West Palm Beach, FL: Owner 1986- present • Animates, Inc.; New York, NY Principal 1988 - present Art In Public Places He/ter Shelter - Pinellas County Arts Council, Seminole, Florida (2007) Last Pasture - Boynton Town Center, Boynton Beach, FL, (2007) The Obelisk - The Sembler Company, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida (2006) Stack145 - The Sembler Company, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida (2006) Butterfly Grove - PGA Commons, Palm Beach Gardens, Florida (2005) Track 2, 1 -9 - The Pinellas Trail; Pinellas County Arts Council, St. Petersburg, Florida (2004) Tears - The WTC -9/11 Memorial, The City of Hoboken, New Jersey (2002) Flock - The City of Mercer Island, Washington (2001) Square Peg Round Hole - Interim Services Corporate Headquarters, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida (2000) Tensegrity - The Children's Discovery Museum of the Desert, Palm Desert, California (1999) Marlin Palms - The City of West Palm Beach, West Palm Beach, Florida (1995) Fish Out Of Water - The City of West Palm Beach, West Palm Beach, Florida (1993) Other Sample Project Clients The State of New Jersey Department of Transportation. The City of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada The City of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada The City of Detroit, Detroit, Michigan The City of Trenton, Trenton, New Jersey • The City of Boynton Beach, Boynton Beach, Florida The City of West Palm Beach, West Palm Beach, Florida Museo Amparo, Mexico City, Mexico U. S. Sugar Corporation, West Palm Beach, Florida Downtown Development Authority of West Palm Beach CoTren, Palm Beach County, Florida Far -Jewett & Associates, Washington, DC Skidmore, Owings & Merril, New York, New York American Musuem of Natural History, New York, New York Historic Mercer Cemetary, Trenton, New Jersey South Street Seaport Museum, New York, New York Pr Artist's Statement •MITFULLER FUNCTIONAL ARTS My proposal consists of creating a series of individually mounted equilateral reflective - yet transparent "Triad" elements that are mounted to selected upper -level building walls. This installation at Doubletree 2 will create an ever - changing display of color and colored shadows against the buidling facade. This change is possible through the use of a dichroic coated film which is integrally laminated to the surfaces of the "Triads "; and the observers specific viewpoint combined with the direction of the dominant light source. Consisting of 3 composite acrylic vanes mounted to a metal baseplate, each vane on the "Triad" will cast a colored shadow; the color of which will be determined by the angle of the dominant light source as it passes through the dichroic coating. The design of the "Triad" has been engineered to meet hurricane codes as follows: Wind Criteria: 140mph Exposure "C" FBC 2004 Materials consist of bright finished .25" aluminum baseplate and mounting channels, stainless steel mounting hardware, Acrylite Resist SGT" outer vane panels sandwiching a .125" clear acrylic sheet laminated with a 3M dichroic radiant film. • LIGHT SOURCE • STUDY MODEL OF "TRIADS" PHOTOGRAPHED IN SUNLIGHT • • C I � �J WALL SURFACE i 25' ACR RESIST SG 1 25" ACR DICHROIC COMPOSITE DETAIL i I I II.5" TYPICAL pRONT VIEW .25" ALUMINUM BASEPLATE .625" ACRYLIC SANDWICH —.25 "ALUMINUM KEYED FLANGE WALL SURFACE MTFULLER FUNCTIONAL ARTS 5" TYPICAL BOTTOM VIEW 524 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd or 561.707 -4688 studio West Palm Beach, FL 33401 or mtfuiler @earthlink.net 'FRIAn nF-T'A.II q 0 m .•i aX 1 • .l e'c RY tl q� F S 1 � -3 7' 1 d' 0 l t l OZ o Q J OJ Wp H N r s qk p oz 0 !3 W U J -j Wp F- g w i- y a. Za O< w I >w w _, LIJ w-i ao I � Q E t m N L OJ Q Qi LL H O O N Q C n O V O c D Y C o O ti m f E V M D OOa [D M YLL J t f Ci m E E m m a a .. e fA m N 'S F W J � J a �z u' U F- z C LL ral • F� A a 0 z H 0 a lt� .r PC U C • • .l _a pow 3 eel o 04 w o sw 0 9 0 0 1.21 . ENO 0 � I � A o � � I CIO I � C Co �� N 'M MIW I ;74 WOO- '- - - r. . • fll O z W w H w 0 Q 0 r C D a CEO �� N woo rrw�• CEO �� N • • • • C �O CA ct � � U U � � U O ct Ct ct CIO � � ct U • • C �O • 1r1� u 1 10 \l • F-11 .o z V � U N v C • 6/9 • x` i i :co V 44-0 aL/ s/9 A !�I A w� r� V A C. &Q— w • VMW $mi 0 3 • , • 1�1 0 V O V Cd s a� C 0 0 r- r-I L-A k ., k .._._.. rrr 4 L 16 C: 0 L :3V VP- �wr a 71 a� as i a L* e N � � a �t1{ �7 f 1 1 •,cif , l > till � � A F' [/ 4 K• 14 M V �Z'3 cr: t - U,4 F 1.4 r ri,pf! r #14 t ` -.4 ;.x 69\ it . -POOR"= low 19 -W IV Af, IL 0 obs 'Are- • 0 C -8 r O In o� o� U � a LI • • a> W' o� w C p' 136 -) jo cn �J • • >Wv "Mo 79 ozz c C� CEO �� N • C7 • 0 u C O C �O 'MI ll� A, Now so • • 1 a u i f _ OF y� i C � Q -iT3 U r �r �r x ^y 4 ow • y y 0 C 50 110 110 lip ) I r. 4A MI mn V. V. 7�, AL, JK eJS 71 • • • b F� k 1 V� �-+ a V R 3 �' O�s�o C� �b�1D 3 r.A n C'ri ! M 1 A v, 4 LL L� c Q C r Y� S� I� W� 7 4•,+ � "� � •=� � 0 ate' o Cos it � • � ~ 0 4-o CJ PO ' 2 O .� ®' 4-o V 0 o H -AL COQ -nT3 U Si t Ap ti 47- .- zi. 4kA&. 64 • 0 r r "h r FV W 1` . C�Q -iT3 U K � . r1i w• - t J r � r 1 I 'il �y ZC) -I-- LL- u-I u A&P se C, COQ yr Ale Apt f4A • 0 0 (U LU A LI 14 C 8 8 0 U C �4 ;40 20 0 40 Feet 'N* 1 1-4 4t Ire over r1p 4r. 46, -T low. of 46 t. . . . . . . . . ..... I , 4AM 4h FA do\ J� M�m to �m M ll � im Ir I 'titI Ar? 14 Stir. IL D-i Wt. 40 41i al Ak It- JL- lit -A6 k2z k m i��l